Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ranbaxy Laboratories Ltd. v. M.S Shoes East (I) Ltd

Delhi High Court
Mar 13, 1997
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion — S.K. Mahajan, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent company is M/s. M.S. Shoes East (I) Limited, incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956, carrying on business in leather and allied products and having object clauses including construction and related activities. In 1995 the company attempted a public issue to raise funds which did not achieve minimum subscription. In or about January 1995 the petitioner, M/s. Ranbaxy Laboratories Limited, advanced inter-corporate deposits totalling Rs. 2,00,00,000/- to the company by two short-term loans (Rs. 1,00,00,000/- each) at 22% p.a. The company executed demand promissory notes and handed over post-dated cheques for repayment and interest. The cheques were presented and dishonoured. After repeated demands, the petitioner served a notice dated 3rd June, 1995 calling upon the company to pay Rs. 2,08,40,038/- within three weeks and threatened to file a winding up petition. The petitioner then filed a petition for winding up on the ground that the company was unable to pay its debts.

Eleven other petitions by various creditors were filed against the company (details given in the opinion) and compliance with the statutory notice requirement under Section 433 (and Section 434(1)(a) notices are discussed) is alleged. On receiving show-cause material, the company filed a reply admitting liability but asserting commercial solvency and contending that existing realizable assets (alleged market value about Rs. 200 crores) and potential claims against underwriters/lead managers could satisfy creditors. The company sought time to frame a repayment scheme; certain adjournments and a proposed instalment schedule were discussed in Court. A whole-time director gave an affidavit undertaking to pay in instalments as per a proposed schedule, but according to the petitioner no payments were made and a contempt petition was filed against that director.

At hearings (noted dates include 2nd February 1996, 30th April 1996 and 20th May 1996), the Court directed appearances and considered competing submissions. The Court ultimately admitted the petition and directed publication of a citation, returnable on 8th July, 1997.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on the facts, the company is "unable to pay its debts" for the purposes of Section 433(1)(e) of the Companies Act, 1956, such that a winding up petition should be admitted at the prima facie stage.
  2. Whether the Court's discretion under Section 433 permits refusal to admit a petition where (a) the company admits liability but claims commercial solvency based on disputed/contingent assets and potential claims, or (b) the company proposes to repay creditors given additional time.
  3. What is the appropriate standard at the prima facie stage when a creditor relies on non-compliance with a statutory notice under Section 434(1)(a) (i.e., whether the Court must admit the petition once the statutory requisites and an undisputed debt are established).

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent Company's (Applicant for relief from winding up) Arguments

  • The remedy under Section 433 of the Companies Act is discretionary; a creditor has no absolute right to a winding up order merely by showing inability to pay — the Court should exercise discretion.
  • Relying on authorities (including Pradeshiya Industrial & Investment Corporation of U.P v. North India Petrochemicals Limited), the company argued that winding up should not be used as a device to enforce payment and that where the company is commercially solvent or likely to revive, the Court should stay proceedings and give time to pay.
  • The company asserted commercial solvency: alleged realizable assets with market value approximately Rs. 200 crores; entitlement to sums (approx. Rs. 350 crores) from underwriters/arbitration and compensation claims (allegedly more than Rs. 550 crores) against lead managers; institutional support from banks/financial institutions; ownership/claim over HUDCO land (deposit of Rs. 69 crores) and potential significant value in that property.
  • The company stated some creditors had been settled and that it had negotiated or was in process of settling various claims; it proposed to roll over certain loans and had orally agreed to extensions with creditors.
  • The company urged the Court to exercise discretion in its favour and stay proceedings so that it may repay amounts under a scheme or timeline.

Petitioners' Arguments (including Ranbaxy and other creditors)

  • The petitioners contended that where a company fails to comply with a statutory notice given under Section 434(1)(a) demanding payment and the debt is not bona fide disputed, the Court has no discretion and must make a winding up order (relying on authorities such as Focus Advertising Private Limited, in Re).
  • They argued the present stage is one of prima facie inquiry: once it is shown the amount is due and the company has failed to pay despite notice, the petition should be admitted and citation published; the detailed merits and defenses can be litigated after citation.
  • The petitioners asserted the company had not filed up-to-date financial statements (no balance sheet or profit & loss after 30th September, 1994 was filed), had not filed a statement of affairs, and therefore could not substantiate claims of solvency; further, many assets were disputed, limiting the company’s ability to realize funds to meet demands.
  • They relied on multiple authorities (listed in the opinion) to support their contention that the Court should admit the petition where notice under Section 434(1)(a) is not complied with and where debts are undisputed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court (as stated in the opinion)
Pradeshiya Industrial & Investment Corporation of U.P v. North India Petrochemicals Limited and Another, (1994) 3 SCC 348 That an order under clause (c) of Section 433 is discretionary; winding up is not a legitimate means to enforce disputed debts; petitions used as pressure may be dismissed. Relied upon by counsel for the company. The Court held this authority was of limited assistance here because that case helps only where there is a bona fide dispute on liability; in the present matter liability was not disputed and the company had not presented a scheme or bona fide defence.
Aluminium Corporation of India Limited v. Lakshmi Rattan Cotton Mills Company Limited, AIR 1970 Allahabad 452 This citation was relied upon by the respondent to support the discretionary nature of Section 433 (as asserted by counsel). The opinion records it was relied upon by the respondent. The Court stated it did not find it necessary to refer to the judgments cited by both sides for the view taken.
Tinsukia Vastra Bhandar v. Assam Tea Corporation Limited, (1992) 1 Company Law Journal 32 (Gauhati) Relied upon by respondent counsel in support of discretion under Section 433. Recorded as relied upon by respondent; the Court did not analyze this authority in detail in the opinion.
Rishi Enterprises In Re, (1992) 1 Company Law Journal 275 (Gujarat) Relied upon by respondent in support of the discretionary approach to winding up. Recorded as cited by respondent; the Court did not elaborate on its application in the body of the opinion.
State Trading Corporation of India Limited v. Punjab Tanneries Limited, (1994) 2 Company Law Journal 270 Relied upon by respondent to support the contention that discretion exists under Section 433. Recorded as cited by respondent; the opinion does not set out an explicit rule from the case beyond noting it was relied upon.
Dundappa Shivalingappa Adi v. S.G Motor Transport Company (P) Limited, (1966) 36 Company Cases 606 Relied upon by respondent counsel (citation recorded in the opinion). Recorded as cited by respondent; no separate analysis of the authority is set out in the opinion.
New Kerala Chits and Trades (P) Limited v. Official Liquidator, (1981) 51 Company Cases 601 (Kerala) Relied upon by respondent in submissions (as recorded). The Court recorded the citation but did not extract a specific principle from it in the opinion.
Focus Advertising Private Limited, in Re, (1974) 44 Company Cases 567 (Bombay) Held that once there is non-compliance with a statutory notice under Section 434(1) and no bona fide dispute, the creditor is entitled to a winding up order ex debito justitiae; the Court may, however, regard wishes of majority of creditors. Reliance placed on this judgment by the petitioners. The Court recorded the principle and considered the petitioners' submission that non-compliance with the statutory notice requires admission of the petition at this stage.
Deccan Farms & Distilleries Limited v. Velabai Laxmidas Bhanji, (1979) 49 Company Cases 321 One of several authorities cited by petitioners in support of their contentions regarding admission where debts are undisputed and notices not complied with. Recorded as relied upon by petitioners; the Court did not undertake a detailed discussion of this authority in the opinion.
Navjivan Trading Finance Private Limited v. In Re (Gujarat), (1978) 48 Company Cases 402 Cited by petitioners to support their position on admission and the limits of enquiry at the prima facie stage. Recorded as cited by petitioners; no detailed application of the authority is set out in the opinion.
Madhuban Private Limited v. Narain Dass Gokal Chand, (1971) 41 Company Cases 685 Cited by petitioners among other authorities on admission of winding up petitions. Recorded as cited by petitioners; the Court did not expansively analyze it in the opinion.
Kalra Iron Stores v. Faridabad Fabricators P. Limited, (1992) 73 Company Cases 337 Cited by petitioners in support of their submissions on the appropriate test for admission. Recorded as cited by petitioners; the opinion does not extract a detailed rule from this citation.
C. Hariprasad v. Amalgamated Commercial Traders Private Limited, AIR 1964 Madras 519 Cited by petitioners in their compilation of authorities on admission and insolvency tests. Recorded as cited by petitioners; no specific analysis of the authority appears in the opinion.
Seksaria Cotton Mills Limited, (1969) 39 Company Cases 475 Cited by petitioners as part of supporting authorities. Recorded as cited by petitioners; the Court did not explicate its application in the opinion.
Airwings Private Limited v. Viktoria Air Cargo GmbH Langer Kornweg, AIR 1995 Karnataka 69 Cited by petitioners among other authorities concerning admission standards. Recorded as cited by petitioners; the Court did not elaborate on the authority's principle in the opinion.
Karnataka Leasing and Commercial Corporation Limited v. Smt. Lalitha Holla, (1995) 1 Company Law Journal 260 (Karnataka) Cited by petitioners as relevant authority. Recorded as cited by petitioners; the opinion does not set out a separate analysis of this authority.
Amalgamated Commercial Traders (P) Limited v. A.C.K Krishnaswami and Another, (1965) 35 Company Cases 456 Cited by petitioners in support of their legal position on winding up orders. Recorded as cited by petitioners; the Court did not specifically analyze the case in the opinion.
Dena Bank v. Khatau Dyes and Fibres Limited, (1995) 83 Company Cases 632 Cited by petitioners among other authorities concerning admission and insolvency. Recorded as cited by petitioners; no specific application is described in the opinion.
Madhusudan Gordhandas and Company v. Madhu Woollen Industries Private Limited, (1972) 42 Company Cases 125; also cited as AIR 1971 SC 2600 Principles: where debt is undisputed, the Court will not accept a defence that the company can pay but chooses not to; where exact amount disputed the Court may still make an order; the defence must be bona fide, substantial and likely to succeed; the wishes of majority creditors may be considered. The Court relied upon and applied the principles from this authority in explaining that where liability is undisputed and the company has not adduced a bona fide defence or scheme, the petition ought to be admitted at the prima facie stage. The opinion cites these principles and applies them to find prima facie inability to pay.
In the matter of Dhootpapeshwar Sales Corporation Private Limited, (1972) 42 Company Cases 139 Cited by petitioners as supporting authority. Recorded as cited by petitioners; the Court did not set out a separate analysis of this authority in the opinion.
Tube Investment of India Limited and Another v. Everest Cycles Limited, (1984) 56 Company Cases 165 Cited by petitioners among authorities on admission. Recorded as cited by petitioners; the opinion does not elaborate on its application.
Sree Shanmugar Mills Limited v. S.K Dharmaraja Nadar and Another, AIR 1970 Madras 203 Cited by petitioners in support of their legal propositions. Recorded as cited by petitioners; the Court did not use it as a basis for the decision set out in the opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's reasoning proceeds in the following steps, based strictly on the text of the opinion:

  1. The Court first observed that it is not in dispute the amount claimed by the petitioner (Ranbaxy) is due and payable by the company — the company admitted liability for the sums for which the petition was filed.
  2. The Court acknowledged the legal position that the power to wind up a company under Section 433 is discretionary. Counsel for the company relied on authorities (notably Pradeshiya) to argue that the Court should exercise discretion to stay proceedings where the company is commercially solvent or may revive.
  3. The Court distinguished the situation in Pradeshiya: that authority assists only where the company raises a bona fide dispute about liability. The Court held that where liability is admitted and there is no scheme before the Court showing how the company intends to pay admitted debts, Pradeshiya does not aid the respondent.
  4. The Court examined the respondent's claim of solvency. The respondent relied on alleged assets (market value about Rs. 200 crores), potential recoveries from underwriters (approx. Rs. 350 crores), and claims against lead managers (allegedly more than Rs. 550 crores), and asserted institutional support. The Court noted that many of these assets and claims were disputed and/or contingent and that realisation of such values was uncertain as to timing and outcome.
  5. The Court applied the statutory test for "inability to pay debts" under Section 433(1)(e): the question is whether the company can meet its current demands in a commercial sense while continuing as a going concern, not whether the company could discharge all debts by converting all assets into cash. The Court emphasized that assets essential to carrying on business should not be counted toward the company's ability to meet current demands.
  6. The Court noted that the respondent had ample opportunity (approximately one and a half years) to present a concrete scheme of repayment, and that an undertaking by a whole-time director to pay in instalments beginning in April 1996 had not been honoured — no payments had in fact been made to the petitioner as of the date of the opinion. The Court observed a contempt petition had been filed arising from that non-compliance.
  7. The Court also observed the majority (in value) of creditors were pressing for admission of the petition; only a small minority sought adjournment. The Court regarded the wishes of the creditors as relevant at this stage.
  8. On the basis of admitted liability, the absence of a bona fide, substantial defence or workable repayment scheme, disputed nature and uncertain timing of the claimed assets/receivables, and the company's inability to meet current demands, the Court concluded that prima facie the company was unable to pay its debts and that discretion under Section 433 should not be exercised in the company's favour.
  9. The Court therefore admitted the petition and directed publication of citation. The Court noted explicitly that for the view taken it was not necessary to refer in detail to the many judgments cited by both parties.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court ADMITTED the winding up petition and directed that the citation be published in The Hindustan Times (English), Navbharat Times (Hindi) and the Delhi Gazette, returnable on 8th July, 1997.

Implications (direct effects on the parties, as stated in the opinion):

  • The petitioners obtained admission of the petition at the prima facie stage — the Court found that the company was prima facie unable to pay its debts.
  • Publication of citation was ordered in the specified newspapers and the Delhi Gazette with a return date of 8th July, 1997, thereby commencing the next procedural stage of the winding up process.
  • The Court exercised its discretion under Section 433 against the respondent company for the reasons stated (admitted liability, lack of payment or workable scheme, disputed nature of alleged assets, inability to meet current demands, and support for admission by the majority of creditors).
  • The opinion does not state that it sets a new precedent; it applies existing principles (including those from Madhusudan Gordhandas and Pradeshiya) to the facts and finds admission appropriate on the prima facie record. The Court also observed it did not need to consider in detail the many authorities cited to reach its decision.

This summary is strictly limited to the material and statements appearing in the provided opinion and does not add information beyond that text.

Show all summary ...

S.K Mahajan, J.— The respondent - M/s. M.S Shoes East (I) Limited (hereinafter referred to as “the company”) was incorporated under the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956 and has its registered office at 5, N.W.A, Punjabi Bagh Extension, New Delhi. The company had been carrying on the business as manufacturers, purchasers, buyers, sellers, importers, exporters, stockists, distributors and dealers in leather, leather cloth, rubber, thermoplastic, rexine, etc. and all allied products made of the same. The company had also as its objects the work of construction, alteration, maintenance, etc. of moveable and immoveable properties, buildings, offices, etc. The other objects for which the company was established have been set out in its Memorandum of Association.

2. The company is stated to have won export awards for many years till 1992-1993 from the Leather Exports Promotion Council, established by the Government of India. In or about 1994/95 it decided to diversity its operation and enter into new projects including that of integrated hotel project. In order to raise funds for the diversified programme, the company decided to enter the capital market in February, 1995 and published a prospectus for the issue of 1,75,84,800 ‘Zero’ interest unsecured fully convertible debentures of Rs. 199/- each for cash at par aggregating to Rs. 349,93,75,200/-. It appears that for various reasons, which are not relevant for deciding this petition, the company was not able to get the minimum subscription stipulated in the prospectus. Around the same time, in or about January 1995, at request of the company, the petitioner - M/s. Ranbaxy Laboratories Limited, granted a loan of Rs. 2,00,00,000/- to the company by way of inter-corporate deposit. The amount was paid by way of two short-term loans of Rs. 1,00,00,000/- each on interest at the rate of 22 per cent per annum for 90 days and 91 days respectively. Payment of this amount of Rs. 2,00,00,000/- was made by two cheques dated 30th and 31st January, 1995 for Rs. 1,00,00,000/- each. In consideration of the grant of the said inter-corporate deposit of Rs. 1,00,00,000/- each, aggregating Rs. 2,00,00,000/-, on interest at the rate of 22% p.a, the company through its Chairman and Managing Director, Mr. Pavan Sachdeva, executed demand promissory notes dated 30th January and 1st February, 1995 promising to repay on demand after 91 days and 90 days respectively a sum of Rs. 1,00,00,000/- each for value received along with interest. Apart from executing the promissory notes, the company also handed over to the petitioner post-dated cheques for repayment of the loans and interest due thereon. Cheque No. 704184 and 704185 both dated 1st May, 1995 were issued for Rs. 1,00,00,000/- and Rs. 4,22,340/- representing the principal amount of loan and interest thereon for the first loan while two cheques being No. 675233 and 675234 dated 2nd May, 1995 for Rs. 1,00,00,000/- and Rs. 4,17,698/- were given by the company to the petitioner towards repayment of the second loan along with interest. The said cheques, however, on presentation to the bank were returned unpaid by the bankers of the company. In spite of repeated demands when the aforesaid amount was not paid, a notice dated 3rd June, 1995 was served by the petitioner calling upon the company to pay to the petitioner the aforesaid sum of Rs. 2,08,40,038/- within three weeks of the receipt of the notice failing which it was threatened that the petitioner would file a company petition for winding up of the respondent company. In spite of the receipt of notice by the company, the aforesaid amount was not paid and this is how the present petition was filed by the petitioner for winding up of the company on the ground that the company was unable to pay its debts.

3. Besides this petition filed by M/s. Ranbaxy Laboratories Limited, there are eleven other petitions filed against the company by various other creditors who have also complied with the requirement of notice under Section 433 of the Companies Act and the amount had not been paid in spite of the receipt of notice by the company. Details of other petitions are:—

C.P No. Name of Petitioner Principal amount Rate of interest 222/96 DCM Daewoo Ltd. 1,50,00,000/- 22% 2,00,00,000/- 27% 160/96 Goetze (India) Ltd. 1,00,00,000/- 22% 116/96 Escorts Finance & Investment Ltd. 1,40,00,000/- 23.5% 1,00,00,000/- 21% 50,00,000/- 22% 117/96 Escorts Limited 60,00,000/- 23% 3/96 Milestone Finance & Leasing (P) Ltd. 50,00,000/- 20.5% 93/96 Bajaj Auto Ltd. 50,00,000/- 20% 237/95 Parle Exports 1,00,00,000/- 20% 214/96 Concept Communication Ltd. 2,78,18,272/- 16% 237/96 Sundaram Finance 2,00,00,000/- 277/96 Necru Arts 47,63,815.80 146/95 SRF Finance 50,00,000/-

4. On receipt of notice from this Court to show cause as to why the petition be not admitted, the company has filed its reply. While the company has not denied its liability to pay the amount for non-payment of which the present petitions have been filed, the stand taken by the respondent company is that it is commercially solvent and is able to pay its debts. According to the company, the existing realisable assets of the company are sufficient to meet all liabilities. The respondent is alleged to have assets, market value of which is alleged to be about Rs. 200 crores. It is stated in the reply that the loan was taken by the company for its working capital requirements in the usual course of business and the respondent was expecting at that time to raise funds from the capital market to meet its working capital requirements for its hotel projects and the money received through the public and the right issues was also to be used for repaying of short term loans and bridge loans. It is stated that the petitioner was always aware that the loan being paid to the company would have been repaid only from the money received from the public and the right issue which could not be effected due to certain reasons as the minimum subscription stipulated in the prospectus in the public issue could not be legally achieved. It is alleged that the parties had orally agreed that the loan would be rolled over for one year on the same terms and conditions and the company was willing to execute all necessary documents to that effect. It is also stated that the company has about 50,000 shareholders and their interest would be jeopardised and prejudiced if the company is wound up.

5. On 2nd February, 1996 when the matter came up for hearing before the Court, it was stated by learned counsel for the company that the company was willing to pay the petitioners, however, it would lake some lime to make payment. The counsel, therefore, prayed for three weeks time to be granted lo the company to prepare a scheme of payment indicating the specific amount, period and instalments which they would like to pay to the petitioner. On this statement of counsel for the company, the case was adjourned to 30th April, 1996. On 30th April, 1996 learned counsel for the company had brought a sum of Rs. 2,00,000/- to pay to the petitioner and requested for some more time to file the scheme of repayment. The amount of Rs. 2,00,000/- was not accepted by the petitioner on the ground that the amount was too meager keeping in view the liability of the company to pay the principal amount and interest to the petitioner and other creditors. The Court, therefore, directed the Managing Director of the company to be present in Court on 20th May, 1996. On 20th May, 1996 the Managing Director of the company was not present, however, in his place Ms. Sadhna Sachdeva, the whole-time Director of the company was present. It was stated by her that given some indulgence, the endeavour of the company was to make payment of the entire amount to the petitioner. Learned counsel for the company stated that as per the proposal made by the petitioner itself, the company would start making payment from July 31, 1996 onwards and would continue to make the payment till 30th June, 1997. According to the proposal submitted by the petitioner and agreed to by the company, the total payment of the principal and interest was to be made within a period of 14 months and the first instalment of 1/14th of the amount of the principal plus total interest upto that date was to be paid by 30th April, 1996. Subsequent instalments of 1/14th of the principal amount plus interest on reducing balance was to be paid on the last day of every subsequent month. Ms. Sadhna Sachdeva, the whole-time Director of the company and wife of Mr. Pavan Sachdeva, Managing Director of the company, also filed an affidavit undertaking to pay to the petitioner the payment in terms of the schedule filed in Court by the petitioner. This undertaking was, however, not honoured by the company and not a single penny is stated to have been paid till date to the petitioner. The petitioner has, therefore, filed a contempt petition against Ms. Sadhna Sachdeva for her having deliberately and willfully violated the undertaking given to the Court.

6. It is, therefore, not in dispute that the amount claimed by the petitioner is due and payable by the company. It was for this reason that I had asked Mr. Mukul Rohtagi, learned Senior Advocate appearing on behalf of the company, to address the Court as to why the petition be not admitted and citation be not issued.

7. The contention of Mr. Rohtagi is that the remedy under Section 433 of the Companies Act (in short referred to as “the Act”) is discretionary and a person has no right to seek an order of winding up against a company. It is contended that the Act confers power on the Court to pass an order of winding up only in appropriate cases. It is submitted that the machinery for winding up should not be allowed to be utilised by the Court merely as a means for realising debts due from the company. Relying upon the judgment reported as Pradeshiya Industrial & Investment Corporation of U.P v. North India Petrochemicals Limited and Another, (1994) 3 SCC 348, it is argued by Mr. Rohtagi that an order under clause (e) of section 433 being discretionary is, as a general rule made only when it is shown that the company is commercially insolvent and where there is a chance of the company reviving and is earnestly making an endeavour to pay, the Court should stay the proceedings for a reasonable time and give the company a chance to make payment. The word “may” used in the opening part of the Section, according to him, indicates that even if the company is unable to pay its debts, it is a matter of discretion for the Court as to whether in the circumstances of the case, it would be in the interest of justice to wind up the company. In this regard, he has also relied upon the judgments reported as Aluminium Corporation of India Limited v. Lakshmi Rattan Cotton Mills Company Limited, AIR 1970 Allahabad 452; Tinsukia Vastra Bhandar v. Assam Tea Corporation Limited, (1992) 1 Company Law Journal 32 (Gauhati); Rishi Enterprises In Re-(1992) 1 Company Law Journal 275 (Gujarat); State Trading Corporation of India Limited v. Punjab Tanneries Limited, (1994) 2 Company Law Journal 270; Dundappa Shivalingappa Adi v. S.G Motor Transport Company (P) Limited, (1966) 36 Company Cases 606 and New Kerala Chits and Trades (P) Limited v. Official Liquidator, (1981) 51 Company Cases 601 (Kerala).

8. According to Mr. Rohtagi, out of the twelve petitions which have been filed against the company, the company has already settled with three petitioners, namely, Concept Communication Limited; Sundram Finance and Neeru Arts and these three petitioners are, therefore, not pressing their petition. Besides the three petitioners before the Court, the company is also stated to have settled its disputes with Onlooker Press and Reliance Agency. While the total principal amount due to all the petitioners from the company was more than Rs. 17 crores, the company is stated to have settled its disputes with the creditors to whom the company owed a sum of about Rs. 5.88 crores. The contention of the company is that the public issue of the company was entirely underwritten by the under writers through the Delhi Stock Exchange and Security Exchange Board of India (SEBI) and on the failure of the public issue the company is entitled to receive approximately a sum of Rs. 350 crores from the under writers for which arbitration proceedings have already been filed before the Delhi Slock Exchange. It is also the contention of the company that on account of the failure of SBI CAPS, the lead manager to the public issue, to fulfill its obligations under the Merchant Bankers Rules and Regulations and SEBI guidelines, the company is entitled to receive a compensation of more than Rs. 550 crores from the lead managers and its claim for that amount is being investigated by the MRTP Commission. The company is stated to have a number of prestigious diversified projects in hand and allegedly owns existing assets of Rs. 200 crores which are alleged to be sufficient to meet the claims against the company. One of the properties allegedly owned by the company is the land purchased from HUDCO for its hotel project. A sum of Rs. 69 crores was deposited by the company with HUDCO towards part payment of the price of the land. The said property, however, is in dispute inasmuch as HUDCO has cancelled the allotment due to the respondent company having not paid the balance instalments payable in accordance with the agreement between the parties. An affidavit was filed by the company on 11th February, 1997 stating inter alia that the financial institutions/banks have indicated that they were willing to support the company and an institutional meeting is alleged to have taken place between the financial institutions and HUDCO where it was allegedly decided to pay the balance consideration for the HUDCO property. Reliance for this is being placed upon a newspaper report published in The Hindustan Times dated 24th January, 1997. The said property was allotted to the company by HUDCO for approximately a sum of Rs. 178.88 crores and the present value of the property is stated to be approximately Rs. 300 crores. Relying upon these Mr. Rohtagi submits that the company is not financially insolvent and this Court should, therefore, exercise discretion in favour of the company and stay the proceedings for the time being so as tp give the company some time to repay the amount being claimed by the petitioners.

9. It is the contention of the petitioners that if a company fails to comply with the notice given to it under Section 434(1)(a) of the Companies Act for payment of a debt, the Court has no discretion to refuse to make a winding up order. Reliance is placed upon a judgment of the Bombay High Court in Focus Advertising Private Limited, in Re, (1974) 44 Company Cases 567, wherein it was held that once there was non- compliance with a statutory notice given by a creditor under Section 434(1) of the Companies Act, 1956 demanding payment of a debt owing by the company and the Court is satisfied that there is no bonafide dispute in regard to the petitioners debt, the creditor is entitled to a winding up order ex debito justiciae, and the Court will not listen to a defence on the part of the company that it was not commercially insolvent or that its financial position is not such as to be unable to pay its debts. The right to winding up order, however, is qualified by another rule, namely, that the Court will regard the wishes of the majority in value of the creditors, and, if, for some good reason, they object to a winding up order, the Court in its discretion may refuse the Order. It is, therefore, the submission that once there is a compliance of section 434(1)(a) and the Company in spite of notice having been received by it, has failed to pay the amount due from it to the creditor, the Court must pass the winding up order. In any case, it is the contention of the petitioners that at this stage the Court is only forming a prima facie view whether the company is unable to pay its debts and the question of winding up of the company will come only after the citation is published. This, according to the petitioner, is not the stage for the Court to go into all these questions and once it is proved to the satisfaction of the Court that the amount is due to the petitioners and the respondent has not paid the same in spite of receipt of notice, the petition should be admitted and citation be published.

10. It is also the contention of the petitioners that question of a company being commercially insolvent will not be considered by the Court when the petition is under Section 433(1)(a) of the Companies Act. Moreover to determine the commercial insolvency of the company what is to be seen is whether the company is in a posilion to pay its anticipated debts on demand having been made by the creditor, in the normal course of business. According to the petitioners, no balance sheet or profit and loss account has been filed by the company for the period subsequent to 30th September, 1994; the present statement of affairs have also not been filed; the company has itself expressed difficulties in managing its affairs after the public issue and it was all the more reason that the company should have filed its financial statement for the period subsequent to the public issue. It is also contended that the assets which are stated to be owned by the company are all in dispute and the company is not in a position to raise money for settlement of the claims of the petitioners. Reliance by the petitioners has been placed upon the judgments reported as Deccan Farms & Distilleries Limited v. Velabai Laxmidas Bhanji, (1979) 49 Company Cases 321; Navjivan Trading Finance Private Limited v. In Re. (Gujarat), (1978) 48 Company Cases 402; Madhuban Private Limited v. Narain Dass Gokal Chand, (1971) 41 Company Cases 685; Kalra Iron Stores v. Faridabad Fabricators P. Limited, (1992) 73 Company Cases 337; C. Hariprasad v. Amalgamated Commercial Traders Private Limited, AIR 1964 Madras 519; Seksaria Cotton Mills Limited, (1969) 39 Company Cases 475; Airwings Private Limited v. Viktoria Air Cargo Gmbh Langer Kornweg, AIR 1995 Karnataka 69; Karnataka Leasing and Commercial Corporation Limited v. Smt. Lalitha Holla, (1995) 1 Company Law Journal 260 (Karnataka); Amalgamated Commercial Traders (P) Limited v. A.C.K Krishnaswami and Another, (1965) 35 Company Cases 456; Dena Bank v. Khatau Dyes and Fibres Limited, (1995) 83 Company Cases 632; Madhusudan Gordhandas and Company v. Madhu Woollen Industries Private Limited, (1972) 42 Company Cases 125; In the matter of Dhootpapeshwar Sales Corporation Private Limited, (1972) 42 Company Cases 139; Tube Investment of India Limited and Another v. Everest Cycles Limited, (1984) 56 Company Cases 165; and Sree Shanmugar Mills Limited v. S.K Dharmaraja Nadar and Another, AIR 1970 Madras 203.

11. In Pradeshiya Industrial & Investment Corporation of U.P v. North India Petrochemicals Limited and Another (Supra), it was held by the Supreme Court that an order under clause (c) of Section 433 of the Act is discretionary. It was also held that a winding up petition is not a legitimate means of seeking to enforce payment of the debt which is bonafide disputed by the company. A petition presented ostensibly for a winding up order but really to exercise pressure will be dismissed, and under circumstances may be stigmatised as a scandalous abuse of the process of Court. The judgment is relied upon by Mr. Rohtagi in support of his contention that the present petition has really been filed to exercise pressure and same should, therefore, be held to be an abuse of the process of Court inasmuch as the company is stated to be commercially solvent and if given some time will be able to pay its debts. In my view, however, the judgment will not be of any assistance to the respondent. It is only in cases where the company has raised a bonafide dispute about its liability to pay that Court may not entertain the petition for winding up the company; holding the same to be an abuse of the process of the Court. However, in cases where the company has not disputed its liability to pay nor has filed any scheme for consideration of the Court to show as to how the company intends to pay its admitted debts, in my view, the respondent cannot be permitted to contend that the petition should not be admitted as the company has assets, even which are in dispute, in the present case, which if sold will realise more money than what is to be paid to the petitioner. The Supreme Court has held that inability to pay its debts in commercial sense means that the company was unable to meet the current demands. It is admitted case of the parties that the company in this case is not able to meet its current demands and it is only on the assumption that in case the assets of the company are sold that it will be able to recover such amount which will be sufficient to pay its liabilities. However, the assets which are allegedly owned by the company are in dispute and it is not certain as to what time will be taken by the company to acquire the money by the sale of its assets so as to pay its creditors. Even assuming for the sake of arguments that the company will be able to realise the amount more than its liabilities by the sale of the properties, in my view, this itself is not sufficient to hold that the company is commercially solvent or is not unable to pay its debts. In a case under Section 433(1)(e) the question is not whether the company can pay off its debts whether presently due or payable in future, but whether it is able to meet its current demands and whether the existing probable assets would suffice to meet the future demands. In my view, the company on its own showing is not in a position to meet its' current demands and I, therefore, have no hesitation in holding that prima facie it is unable to pay its debts. At this stage, this Court is only to take a prima facie view of the matter. The question whether the company will ultimately be able to pay its debts would be considered at the time when the final order of winding up to be passed.

12. In M/s. Madhusudan Gordhandas & Company v. Madhu Woolen Industries Private Limited, AIR 1971 SC 2600, it was held that where the debt was undisputed the Court will not act upon a defence that the company has the ability to pay the debt but the company chooses not to pay. Where, however, there is no doubt that the company owes the creditor a debt entitling him to a winding up order but the exact amount of the debt is disputed, the Court will make a winding up order without requiring the creditor to quantify the debt precisely. The principles on which the Court acts are first that the defence of the company is in good faith and one of substance, secondly, the defence is likely to succeed in point of law, and, thirdly, the company adduces prima facie proof of the facts on which the defence depends. Another rule which the Court follows is that if there is opposition to the making of the winding up order by the creditors, the Court will consider their wishes and decline to make the winding up order. Though, this is not the stage for me to consider this aspect of the mailer, however, even the creditors are not opposing the petition to be admitted. It is only the petitioner in CP.No 214/96 and CP.No 277/96 who has supported the petitioner in its demand to adjourn the case by two months, however, all other petitioners to whom the company owes a sum of more than Rs. 12 crores are pressing for admission of this petition.

13. In my view, the test of inability to pay the debts under section 433(i)(e) is not whether the company, if it converts all its assets into cash, will be able to discharge its debt, but whether in commercial sense the existing liabilities can be paid by it while it continued to carry on as a company. Value of such assets without which it cannot carry on business cannot be taken into account. Admittedly, the respondent company is not able to discharge its present liabilities and I am not, at this stage, to consider the question whether the company will be able lo pay its debts if all its assets are converted into cash.

14. Though, I am in agreement with Mr. Rohlagi that the power under Section 433 lo wind up the company is discretionary, however, the discretion has lo be exercised keeping in view the facts of each case. The company has been given sufficient time during the last about one and a half years to come out with a scheme as to in what manner it would be able to pay its creditors, however, in spite of the undertaking given by its Director to the Court that it will pay the creditors in instalments in the manner proposed by the petitioner w.e.f April, 1996, no amount whatsoever has been paid to the petitioner. In these circumstances, I am unable to exercise my discretion in favour of the respondent company. Moreover, there is no reason as to why the discretion should be exercised in favour of the respondent company when there is sufficient material on record to show that the respondent company is not in a position to meet its current liabilities. For the view taken by me, I have not considered it necessary to refer to the judgments cited by both the sides.

15. In this view of the matter, I admit this petition and direct the citation to be published in The Hindustan Times (English), Navbharat Times (Hindi) and the Delhi Gazette, returnable On 8th July, 1997.