- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
M. Jaganathan v. Pallavan Transport Corporation Ltd. .
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Abdul Hadi, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant (claimant) was injured in a motor-accident on 21.6.1990 while alighting from the front entrance of the respondent's bus, at a place which was not a scheduled bus stop for that bus. The bus was proceeding from Flower Bazaar Police Station towards Parrys Corner in George Town, Madras. As a result of the accident the appellant's left leg was amputated above the knee.
The claimant sued for compensation of Rs. 6,00,000. The Tribunal below found that the claimant alone was negligent and granted only the no-fault liability compensation of Rs. 12,000. The claimant appealed this civil miscellaneous matter. Abdul Hadi, J. delivered the judgment on the appeal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Tribunal was correct in holding that the claimant alone was negligent (i.e., whether the bus crew — conductor/driver — were negligent instead).
- What is the appropriate quantum of compensation to be awarded to the injured claimant given the nature of injuries (amputation of left leg above the knee), medical treatment, employment status and claimed heads of damage?
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The bus had stopped due to a traffic jam (procession) at a place that was not a bus stop and the conductor asked passengers bound for the next bus stop (Parrys Corner) to get down there; this is supported by the first information report (Exh. P-5) recorded within ten minutes of the accident.
- The claimant, like certain other passengers (including PW 2), began to alight after the conductor's suggestion; the driver moved the bus before the claimant had alighted completely, causing the claimant to fall and be run over by the left front wheel.
- There was no contributory negligence on the part of the injured; reliance was placed on several precedents (including Gujarat State Road Trans. Corpn. v. Keshavlal Somnath Panchal and Sydney Victor v. Janab S. Kadar Sheriff) to support the proposition that the crew owes a duty to passengers and that contributory negligence did not arise.
- On quantum, an itemised claim of Rs. 6,00,000 was placed before the court, with particulars including pain and suffering, continuing disability, loss of earning power and other heads; claimant had prolonged hospitalization and a long period of medical leave and was aged 45 with a basic salary of Rs. 1,400 as a railway technician.
Respondent's Arguments
- The bus did not stop at that place but was only moving slowly; the conductor did not ask passengers to alight at that place. Therefore, the injured got down from a moving bus at a non-bus-stop and the claimant alone was negligent.
- The respondent reiterated the Tribunal's finding of claimant's negligence and suggested at worst there could be contributory negligence on the claimant's part.
- As to quantum, several heads of the claimant's claim were challenged as excessive — in particular Rs. 75,000 for mental agony and Rs. 53,000 for labour/pain and suffering by family members. The respondent also contended that loss of earning power could not be claimed fully because the injured continued to be employed and received salary after the accident.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Managing Director, Thanthai Periyar Trans. Corpn. Ltd. v. N. Hussain Mohideen, 1993 ACJ 1259 (Madras) | The opinion records that when a bus cannot enter a bus stand due to traffic obstruction and is stopped outside (to enable passengers to get down), the version that the bus was merely moving slowly is difficult to accept; on those facts the Tribunal found rash and negligent driving by the bus driver. | The court relied on this decision as one of the authorities showing that when a bus stops due to obstruction and passengers alight, the bus crew can be held negligent; it was used in drawing the conclusion that the Tribunal erred in holding the claimant alone negligent. |
| Southern Motors v. C. Sivajothiammal, 1982 ACJ (Supp) 85 (Madras) |
This information was not available in the provided opinion. |
This information was not available in the provided opinion. |
| N.K.V Bros. (P) Ltd. v. M. Karumai Ammal, 1980 ACJ 435 (SC) | The decision contains the observation that Accidents Claims Tribunals must take special care to ensure innocent victims do not suffer and drivers/owners do not escape liability merely because of some doubt; culpability should be inferred from circumstances where it is fairly reasonable. | The court cited this authority to stress that tribunals should be cautious about denying liability to innocent victims and that culpability may be inferred from reasonably available circumstances — a principle relied upon in reversing the Tribunal's finding of sole negligence on the claimant. |
| Venkataswami Motor Service v. C.K. Chinnaswamy, 1989 ACJ 371 (Madras) | The case emphasises the fundamental duty of both driver and conductor to verify specifically whether any passenger is getting into or getting down from the bus before the bus is moved from the place where it has stopped, irrespective of whether that place is a bus stop. | The court cited this authority to support the proposition that the bus crew had a duty of care to passengers alighting when the vehicle stopped (even if not at a bus stop), and that the crew's failure in that duty supports a finding of negligence against them. |
| Gujarat State Road Transport Corpn. v. Keshavlal Somnath Panchal, 1982 ACJ (Supp) 377 (Gujarat) | The decision holds that where a passenger's body part projects from a bus window, the driver must take precautions more than mere warnings; the driver owes a duty to avoid injury to such passengers. It also held there was no contributory negligence on the facts. | The court relied on this authority to support the view that drivers have an expanded duty of care to passengers in foreseeable risky positions and to reinforce the proposition that contributory negligence did not necessarily arise on such facts. |
| Sydney Victor v. Janab S. Kadar Sheriff, 1974 ACJ 318 (Madras) | The decision observes that mere gripping of a window cross-bar (with part of the hand outside) is not necessarily negligent depending on the context (e.g., not negligent on a broad highway). It recognises context-specific assessment of contributory negligence. | The court cited this decision to support the proposition that mere acts by passengers (such as gripping a cross-bar) do not automatically amount to contributory negligence and to buttress its conclusion against attributing sole negligence to the claimant. |
| Sushma Mitra v. M.P. State Road Trans. Corpn., 1974 ACJ 87 (MP) | The decision states that the driver of a bus carrying passengers owes a duty of care with passengers in contemplation; the driver must avoid acts or omissions reasonably foreseeable to injure passengers and must bear in mind normal passenger habits. | The court relied on this principle to emphasise that drivers must conduct themselves with passengers' normal habits in mind and to support the conclusion that the bus crew owed and breached a duty of care to the claimant. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded stepwise, examining the factual matrix, the Tribunal's findings, the evidence on record and applicable authorities:
- It noted the Tribunal had found the claimant alone negligent and had not considered the full question of quantum, awarding only Rs. 12,000 under no-fault liability.
- The appellate court reviewed the claimant's evidence (PW 1) that the bus stopped due to traffic obstruction and that the conductor invited passengers to alight for the next bus stop; it also considered the first information report (Exh. P-5) recorded within ten minutes of the accident corroborating that the bus stopped.
- The respondent's case and evidence (including the conductor as RW 1) denied that the bus had stopped and denied instructing passengers to alight; RW 1, however, gave inconsistent answers in cross-examination regarding whether he had asked passengers not to alight and about how far the bus moved after the fall.
- The court gave specific weight to certain aspects of RW 1's evidence — for example, that the bus moved about 15 feet after the injured fell — observing that PW 1 (the injured) could not accurately watch how far the bus moved while he was falling and being injured.
- The court then placed the facts in the context of authority: it observed that it is common that buses stop in traffic and passengers tend to alight; in such circumstances drivers and conductors have a duty of care and must be careful to prevent injury. The court surveyed a line of decisions (quoted and summarised in the opinion) that establish the duty of the crew and that contributory negligence is not always attributable to passengers in such circumstances.
- Balancing the evidence and precedent, the court concluded that the Tribunal erred in finding the injured claimant solely negligent. Instead, the court held that the bus crew (driver/conductor) alone was negligent.
- On quantum, the court considered the extent of injury (almost the entire left leg amputated), the medical treatment timeline (General Hospital 21.6.1990 to 25.6.1990; Railway Hospital 25.6.1990 to 10.11.1990), and other claimed heads. While rejecting the respondent's contention that specified heads (Rs. 75,000 and Rs. 53,000) must be reduced, the court accepted that the claim for loss of earning power could not be awarded to the full extent claimed (Rs. 1,50,000) because the injured continued in employment and earned salary after the accident. The court also found scope for reduction in other items.
- Taking an overall view, and applying the guiding principles and evidence, the court reduced but substantially increased the award from the Tribunal's Rs. 12,000 to Rs. 4,50,000, with interest at 12% per annum from the date of the petition, and allowed the appeal in part with proportionate costs.
Holding and Implications
Core Holding: Appeal partly allowed. The appellate court held that the Tribunal erred in finding that the claimant alone was negligent and instead held that the bus crew (driver/conductor) alone was negligent. The court awarded compensation of Rs. 4,50,000 to the injured claimant with interest at 12% per annum from the date of the petition and allowed the appeal in part with proportionate costs.
Implications:
- The direct effect is that the respondent (bus corporation/owner) is liable to pay the increased compensation of Rs. 4,50,000 plus interest and costs as ordered; the Tribunal's finding of sole negligence by the claimant was reversed.
- The judgment applies existing principles (as cited) about the duties of bus drivers and conductors towards passengers alighting when a bus stops in traffic and about the proper inference of culpability where circumstances reasonably support it.
- The opinion does not announce a novel legal precedent; it applies and distinguishes established authority to the facts and reverses the Tribunal's conclusion on negligence and increases the quantum on the facts of this case.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
Abdul Hadi, J.:— The claimant, who is the injured in the motor accident that took place on 21.6.1990 is the appellant in this civil miscellaneous appeal against the compensation of Rs. 12,000 granted by the Tribunal only on the basis of no fault liability. The claim was for Rs. 6,00,000.
2. The injury sustained by the appellant has resulted in the amputation of his left leg above the knee. The injury was sustained when he was getting down from the respondent's bus from the front entrance of the bus and at a place, which was not a bus stop for the said bus. The bus was proceeding from the Flower Bazaar Police Station towards Parrys Corner in George Town, Madras. According to the claimant, there was a traffic jam due to some procession at the abovesaid place and the bus stopped as a consequence at the abovesaid place and the conductor himself asked the passengers, who wanted to get down at the next bus stop, viz., Parrys Corner to get down at the said place itself. Further, according to the claimant, pursuant to the said suggestion of the conductor, just like certain other passengers including PW 2, he also got down towards the end, but, even before he could get down completely, the driver moved the bus and that is why he (injured) fell down and the left front wheel of the bus ran over him and, therefore, when he was subsequently taken to the hospital, his leg had to be amputated.
3. On the other hand, the case of the respondent is that the bus did not stop at the above said place, but was only moving slowly and the conductor did not ask the passengers to get down at that place and yet the injured got down from the moving bus at that place, which was not a bus stop with reference to the said bus. So, the contention of the respondent Corporation is that the claimant alone was negligent and not the bus driver.
4. On the above negligence aspect, the Tribunal below has found that the claimant alone was negligent and not the driver of the bus. In this regard, the relevant observations of the Tribunal below are as follows:
(Omitted as in vernacular)
5. While holding so, the court below did not go into the question of quantum of compensation as claimed by the claimant, but only granted the no fault liability compensation of Rs. 12,000.
6. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that though the place at which the injured got down was not a bus stop for the abovesaid bus in question, the said appellant and certain other passengers including PW 2 got down from the bus at that place only because the bus stopped there due to traffic jam and the conductor asked the passengers, who wanted to get down at the next bus stop, to get down at the said place itself. In this connection, to contend that in such a situation, there was no negligence on the part of the injured and that the negligence was only on the part of the driver of the bus, learned counsel for the appellant relies on the decision in Managing Director, Thanthai Periyar Trans. Corpn. Ltd. v. N. Hussain Mohideen, 1993 ACJ 1259 (Madras); Southern Motors v. C. Sivajothiammal, 1982 ACJ (Supp) 85 (Madras); N.K.V Bros. (P) Ltd. v. M. Karumai Ammal, 1980 ACJ 435 (SC); Venkataswami Motor Service v. C.K. Chinnaswamy, 1989 ACJ 371 (Madras); Gujarat State Road Transport Corpn. v. Keshavlal Somnath Panchal, 1982 ACJ (Supp) 377 (Gujarat); and Sydney Victor v. Janab S. Kadar Sheriff, 1974 ACJ 318 (Madras). He also pointed out that in the first information report, Exh. P-5 which was recorded within ten minutes of the accident on the same day (21.6.1990), the complaint given is that the bus stopped at the abovesaid place and then only the passengers including the injured got down. Learned counsel for the appellant also submits that there could be no contributory negligence also on the part of the injured. In this regard, he relies on two of the above referred decisions, viz., Gujarat State Road Trans. Corpn. v. Keshavlal Somnath Panchal (supra) and Sydney Victor v. Janab S. Kadar Sheriff (supra).
7. Then, coming to the quantum of compensation, he drew our attention to the various heads of compensation, under which the entire compensation totalling Rs. 6,00,000 has been computed, as shown in the claim petition. He also points out that initially the injured was in the General Hospital between 21.6.1990 and 25.6.1990 and was subsequently in the Railway Hospital for about 4½ months between 25.6.1990 and 10.11.1990 (as the injured was a railway employee) and was able to join the duty only on 20.2.1991 He also submits that even though he was getting the original salary even after the accident, on that account he lost the medical leave, which could have been encashed at the time of the retirement. He also points out that the injured was admittedly aged 45 on the date of the accident and his basic salary was Rs. 1,400 in the Railways as a technician.
8. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent reiterated the reasoning of the Tribunal though he could not seriously canvass the correctness of the above referred two decisions cited by learned counsel for the appellant. No doubt, he also submits that at worst, the court could only hold contributory negligence on the part of the injured. On the question of quantum of compensation, he points out that the sum of Rs. 75,000 claimed for mental agony, torture and humiliation of the claimant because of the amputation, is very high. Likewise, he also points out that Rs. 53,000 claimed for labour, pain and suffering put up by the members of the family in attending to the claimant is also high. He also points out that since the injured's earning capacity has not lessened even after the accident, there cannot be any compensation for the loss of earning power, which was claimed at Rs. 1,50,000.
9. In this connection, learned counsel for the appellant points out that it must be noted that the future earning capacity of the injured has been very much affected because of the amputation of the left leg.
10. We have considered the rival submissions. Though the passengers of the bus are not expected to get down from the bus at any place other than a bus stop and in that sense the injured and the alleged other passengers who got down from the bus, as stated above, may be said to be negligent in getting down from the bus at the abovesaid place, which is not a bus stop for the abovesaid bus, it cannot be denied that when the bus stops particularly due to traffic jam in view of procession, etc., the tendency of many of the passengers, who have to alight at the next bus stop, is to get down even at the preceding nearby place, where the bus stops due to the traffic jam. In such or similar circumstances it has been held in several decisions that the conductor and the driver must be careful and they have a duty towards the passengers in not allowing them to be injured in any way. No doubt, in the present case, evidence also has been let in on the side of the claimant that the conductor of the abovesaid bus himself asked the passengers including the injured to get down at the abovesaid place even though it is not a bus stop. No doubt, this version has not been accepted by the conductor, who gave evidence as RW 1.
11. Anyway, in the abovesaid light, we shall now see the relevant decisions. In Sushma Mitra v. M.P State Road Trans. Corpn., 1974 ACJ 87 (MP), a Division Bench of the Madhya Pradesh High Court has observed as follows:
“It cannot be disputed that the driver of a bus which carries passengers owes a duty of care for the safety of the passengers. While driving he must have the passengers in contemplation and he must avoid acts or omissions which can reasonably be foreseen to injure them and in deciding what acts or omissions he should avoid, he must bear in mind the normal habits of passengers. It is a matter of common experience that passengers who sit adjoining a window very often rest their arm on the windowsill by which act the elbow projects outside the window. The driver of the bus must have these passengers also in contemplation and, therefore, while overtaking or crossing another vehicle on the road he must not come too close to the vehicle that is overtaken or crossed and he must leave sufficient gap between the vehicles to avoid injury to these passengers.”
12. A Division Bench of Gujarat High Court in Gujarat State Road Trans. Corpn. v. Keshavlal Somnath Panchal, 1982 ACJ (Supp) 377 (Gujarat), dealt with a case, where a passenger of a bus rested his elbow on the window-sill of the bus and the elbow protruded from the window to the extent of about 6 inches only, though the driver and conductor repeatedly warned the said passenger not to rest the elbow in such a fashion. When the truck coming from the opposite direction injured the passenger's elbow it was held that the bus driver alone was negligent because it was his duty to take precaution to ensure that a passenger sitting with his body protruding reasonably from the window did not receive injury when it crosses an oncoming vehicle and his duty was more than just administering a mere warning. In this context, the relevant observation made is as follows:
“The question which was to be considered in such a case is whether the protrusion of the arm from the window was to an unreasonable extent and whether the act was so obviously fraught with danger that no reasonable or prudent man would consider it safe to act accordingly on the facts and in the circumstances of the case. Besides, the driver of a public vehicle must have such passengers in contemplation and he owes a duty of safety to such passengers which consists of driving the vehicle slowly with care and caution, at least when another vehicle is seen approaching from the opposite direction and while crossing such vehicle, it is his duty to so manoeuvre his own vehicle that not only any contact with the body of the approaching vehicle is avoided but any contact between the oncoming vehicle and any part of the body of any passenger that might be resting on the window of the bus or projecting therefrom to a reasonable extent is also avoided.”
13. In the above Gujarat decision, it was held that there was no contributory negligence on the part of the abovesaid injured passenger. The relevant observation in this regard is as follows:
“There is no question here of attributing any negligence to the claimant, having regard to the limb or part of the body involved and the extent of projection thereof outside the window.”
14. A Division Bench of this court also held in Sydney Victor v. Janab S. Kadar Sheriff, 1974 ACJ 318 (Madras), that there was not even contributory negligence on the part of the injured claimant in a similar case. The said case related to collision between bus and lorry and the injured passenger of the bus was gripping the window cross-bar. In such a position her right thumb was outside the cross-bar. The reasoning of the court for holding that there was no contributory negligence is that by merely gripping the window crossbar, the injured did not show lack of reasonable care for her own safety and the fact that the injured had gripped the crossbar had nothing to do with the actual collision. The relevant observation of the Bench is as follows:
“It is true that putting out the hand or any other part of the body outside a fast moving vehicle would be a negligent act, particularly if the vehicle is moving in a crowded place. In a busy city where there is heavy traffic, it would certainly be highly dangerous to put out the hand or arm or other part of the body so as to be projecting outside the moving vehicle. Even such putting out a part of the body outside the moving vehicle may not be an act which endangers the safety of the person concerned, if the vehicle was not moving in a crowded place but it was moving only on a broad highway, for in such a highway there is no reasonable possibility of any other vehicle coming very close to the vehicle in which the person is travelling. In any event, we are not in a position to hold that mere gripping of the window crossbar in a position in which the right thumb was gripping the bar on its outer side would be a negligent act on the part of the injured, especially when the vehicle was on a broad highway and not moving in any crowded place. It cannot be said that PW 1, the injured had acted negligently or without due care, merely by gripping the cross-bar of the window when the bus was going on a highroad.”
15. Further in Venkataswami Motor Service v. C.K. Chinnaswamy, 1989 ACJ 371 (Madras), a learned Judge of this court was dealing with a case where a lady passenger was alighting from the front exit of the bus and her one foot was on the footboard and other on the road when the conductor gave whistle and the driver moved the bus and she was knocked down and dragged along by the body of the bus and sustained fatal injuries. There was no bus stop at the place of accident therein and the abovesaid passenger jumped from the running bus. However, the further evidence is that eyewitnesses who were passengers of the bus shouted to the driver to stop the bus. In the above circumstances, it was held that the crew of the bus was negligent for the accident which occurred at a place where the bus had stopped, though it was not a bus stop. The relevant observation therein is as follows.
“But the fundamental duty of both the driver as well as the conductor is to verify specifically whether any passenger is getting into the bus or getting down from the bus before actually the bus is moved from the bus stop where it is stopped, irrespective of the fact whether that place, of stopping is a bus stop or not.”
16. We may however point out here that this observation would be more appropriate, particularly in the case of conductor, since the driver as such may not be able, by himself, to verify every time whether any passenger is getting into the bus or getting down from the bus before actually the bus is moving from the place where it has stopped, particularly when the abovesaid ingress or egress is at the rear entrance of the bus. Anyway, point to be emphasized is that even though in the abovesaid case the deceased got down from the bus at a place, which is not a bus stop, the court held on the facts of the said case, that there was negligence on the part of the driver of the vehicle in question.
17. In N.K.V Bros. (P) Ltd. v. M. Karumai Ammal, 1980 ACJ 435 (SC), also we find the following observation, though it is not a case of the deceased or injured in any way violating any laws:
“Accidents Claims Tribunals must take special care to see that innocent victims do not suffer and drivers and owners do not escape liability merely because of some doubt here or some obscurity there. Save in plain cases, culpability must be inferred from the circumstances where it is fairly reasonable.”
18. A learned Judge of this court dealt with a case more or less similar to the present facts in Managing Director, Thanthai Periyar Trans. Corpn. v. N. Hussain Mohicleen, 1993 ACJ 1259 (Madras). The relevant observations made therein are as follows:
“When once it is accepted by RWs 1 and 2 that there was a traffic obstruction and the bus could not enter the bus stand, it is difficult to accept that the bus was moving slowly, as claimed by RWs 1 and 2. It is common knowledge that even before the bus could enter the Broadway Bus Stand, it is stopped outside to enable passengers to get down from the bus and in this case, from the evidence, it is clear that the bus had to stop outside the bus terminus, owing to traffic obstruction in the access road. Thus, on a due consideration of the manner in which the accident took place, the version given by PW 3 is more probable and acceptable and the Tribunal cannot, therefore, be stated to have committed any error in holding that the rash and negligent driving of the bus belonging to the appellant, by its driver who had caused the accident, in which the respondent sustained injuries.”
19. Taking all these decisions into consideration, we are of the view that the Tribunal below erred-in holding that the injured claimant alone was negligent. On the other hand, it should be held that the above bus crew alone was negligent.
20. On perusing the entire evidence it is clear that though the place at which the abovesaid bus stopped, was not a bus stop for the said bus, the bus actually stopped at the abovesaid place due to the traffic jam. PW 1, the injured gave evidence in chief-examination thus:
(Omitted as in vernacular)
21. Further even in cross-examination he said thus:
(Omitted as in vernacular)
22. Thus, it appears that even the suggestion to PW 1 in cross-examination was that before the abovesaid auto also there was another stationary vehicle, and the suggestion was not that the road was clear before the bus in question and the bus was actually moving, though slowly.
23. Then, regarding the other aspect that the conductor, after the bus stopped at the abovesaid place, asked the passengers going to Parrys Corner to get down at the abovesaid place itself, the relevant evidence in chief-examination by PW 1 is as follows:
(Omitted as in vernacular)
24. No doubt, in this context it must be stated that PW 1 in cross-examination deposed that after he thus fell down, the bus did not move even a foot. But, RW 1, the conductor in this regard deposed that after the injured fell down, the bus moved for about 15 feet and then stopped. In this regard, the version of RW 1 should receive greater weight since at the moment of falling down and getting injured, the injured passenger could not have correctly watched how far the bus moved after he fell down and got injured.
25. Further, even though the conductor of the bus as RW 1 deposed in chief-examination that at the abovesaid place he asked the passengers not to get down, he deposed in cross-examination thus:
(Omitted as in vernacular)
26. Taking into account the entire evidence also, we have only to hold that the crew of the bus alone was negligent.
27. Coming to the quantum of compensation, it has to be noted first of all that almost the entire left leg of the claimant has been amputated pursuant to the injury suffered in the accident. In this connection, PW 3, the doctor's evidence in chief-examination is as follows:
(Omitted as in vernacular)
28. In cross-examination he deposed thus:
(Omitted as in vernacular)
29. The injured was initially treated in the General Hospital between 21.6.1990 and 25.6.1990 and, thereafter, in the Railway Hospital between 25.6.1990 and 10.11.1990 Further, PW 1's evidence is that he was on medical leave for 772 months and if the said medical leave had not been taken, he could have encashed the said medical leave after retirement. He also deposed thus:
(Omitted as in vernacular)
30. In the claim petition, the abovesaid claim of Rs. 6,00,000 is computed as follows:
“PART-I
(a) Loss of earning from 21.6.1990 to 20.12.1990 (anticipated) (b) Partial loss of earning from … to … (c) at the net rate of Rs. 2,000 p.m … Rs. 12,000 (d) Transport to hospital a day/week … Rs. 1,000 (e) Extra nourishment … Rs. 5,000 (f) Damage to clothing and articles: dress materials damaged … Rs. 250 (g) Others (i) Cost of medicines purchased for treatment … Rs. 3,750
(ii) Labour, pain and suffering put on by the members of the family in attending to the petitioner. … Rs. 53,000 (iii) Mental agony, torture and humiliation to the petitioner because of amputation … Rs. 75,000
PART-II
(h) Compensation for pain and suffering … Rs. 1,00,000 (i) Compensation for continuing or permanent disability, if any … Rs. 2,00,000 (j) Compensation for the loss of earning power … Rs. 1,50,000 Total … Rs. 6,00,000
31. Learned counsel for the respondent, no doubt, submits that the abovesaid claim of Rs. 75,000 for mental agony, etc., is too high and likewise, Rs. 53,000 for labour, pain and sufferings put on by the members of the family is also high. He also argues that since the injured has been given job in the Railways even after the accident and the injured is getting pay as usual, he could not claim compensation for the loss of earning power to the extent of Rs. 1,50,000. We are unable to accept the said counsel's contention with reference to the abovesaid Rs. 75,000 and Rs. 53,000. However, we feel that compensation for the loss of earning power in the above circumstances could not be given to the extent of Rs. 1,50,000. Further on other items also, there is scope for some reduction. Taking an overall view, we feel that ends of justice would be met as against the claim of Rs. 6,00,000 a sum of Rs. 4,50,000 is awarded to the injured claimant. In the result, we award a compensation of Rs. 4,50,000 with interest at 12 per cent per annum from the date of petition. Accordingly the appeal is allowed in part with proportionate costs.
32. Appeal partly allowed.
Alert