Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Kuzminayaka Mothilal v. Mohd. Jahiruddin & Ors.

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Dec 31, 1996
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is the landlord of premises located in a business locality at Parvatipuram. Before the petitioner purchased the property, the respondent (tenant) had taken it on a monthly rent of Rs. 140 in 1978 under Exhibit A-2. The terms of the lease permitted the tenant to run a photo studio business and also to reside in the premises.

In 1985 the landlord filed an eviction petition alleging that he required the premises for business purposes and that he had no other owned building in the town. In his counter the tenant alleged that the landlord's requirement was not bona fide and that the eviction petition was filed to extract higher rent.

The Rent Controller dismissed the eviction petition on the ground that, because the lease was composite (both residential and non-residential), the eviction petition was not maintainable, relying on the decision in Dr. Madhusudan Mahuli v. Lambu Indira Bai, and did not decide the question of bona fide requirement. On appeal the appellate court found the petitioner's requirement for business bona fide but nevertheless held the eviction petition not maintainable due to the composite nature of the lease. The petitioner filed this revision (C.R.P.).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an eviction petition is maintainable where the lease is composite (both residential and non-residential) and the landlord seeks eviction for business purposes.
  2. Whether a landlord can seek eviction in respect of both the residential and non-residential portions together for business use, or whether seeking eviction of only one portion would impermissibly split the contract.
  3. Whether the procedural point about maintainability (composite lease objection) could be raised when it was not pleaded in the tenant's counter but was argued before the lower courts.
  4. Whether the word "occupation" (in Sec. 10(3)(a)(i) of the A.P. Act as discussed) should be construed to include non-residential occupation if the structure of the premises admits such use without structural alteration.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's (Landlord's) Arguments

  • Counsel (Mr. C. Subba Rao) contended that the question of maintainability (composite lease) was not raised by the tenant in the counter, and hence the courts below erred in considering it; he relied on the single Judge decision in Ananta v. P. Govinda Swamy (1992) 1 ALT 46 for the proposition that a tenant cannot raise such a plea for the first time in revision.
  • The petitioner argued that the decision in Dr. Madhusudan Mahudi (Madhusudan Mahuli) did not preclude his eviction petition.

Respondent's (Tenant's) Arguments

  • The tenant's primary plea in the counter was that the landlord's claimed requirement was not bona fide and that the eviction petition was a device to extract higher rent.
  • The tenant also urged that because the lease was composite (residential and non-residential), the eviction petition was not maintainable.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dr. Madhusudan Mahuli v. Lambu Indira Bai (1987) 2 ALT 504 Held that where premises are let for mixed (composite) residential and non-residential purposes, there is no provision under the Rent Control Act for eviction based on bona fide personal requirement; the contract cannot be split to permit eviction limited to the residential portion. The court considered this decision distinguishable because in that case the landlord sought eviction for residential purpose from composite premises; here the landlord seeks eviction for business purpose for both portions together, so that decision does not preclude maintainability in the present facts.
Ananta v. P. Govinda Swamy (1992) 1 ALT 46 Principle that a plea not raised before lower courts cannot ordinarily be raised for the first time in revision. The petitioner relied on this case; the court held it was distinguishable because, in the instant matter, the maintainability issue was argued before both lower courts, so Ananta did not assist the petitioner.
Miss S. Samyal v. Gian Chand AIR 1968 S.C. 438 Held that a single, indivisible lease for composite use cannot be split into separate contracts (residential and non-residential) in the absence of statutory provision; the court cannot grant eviction limited to the residential portion alone. This Supreme Court principle was applied by a single Judge in Dr. Madhusudan Mahuli and was discussed as background. The present court treated Samyal as authority for the rule against splitting a composite lease.
Firm Panjumal Daulatram v. Sakhi Gopal (1977) 3 SCC 284 : AIR 1977 S.C. 2077 Explained that where a landlord advances a dual requirement (both residential and non-residential) under provisions analogous to the A.P. Act, the eviction petition is maintainable; there is no splitting if landlord seeks eviction for both purposes. The court relied on this Supreme Court decision (and its analogy to Sec.10(3)(i) and (iii) of A.P. Act) to distinguish Samyal and to support the proposition that dual requirements entitle the landlord to seek eviction.
Yashpal Roy v. Gessulal Dinesh Kumar & Another (1993) 2 APLJ 249 Applied Firm Panjumal to hold that when the lease is for composite purpose, a landlord may seek eviction for additional residential accommodation as well as for non-residential purpose, but cannot be permitted to seek eviction only for one requirement in a way that splits the contract. The court cited this decision as precedent in favour of maintainability where the landlord seeks eviction of both portions together for permitted grounds; used to support the present petitioner's claim.
Amtual Hafeez v. D. Mohammed Ibrahim (1996) 3 ALD 582 Held that the word "occupation" in Sec. 10(3)(a)(i) cannot be restricted to purely residential occupation; it must be interpreted to include such occupation as the structure admits of (i.e., a residential building may accommodate certain non-residential uses without structural alteration). The court relied on this interpretation to conclude that residential premises which can be used for business without alteration may be the subject of eviction for business requirement.
Pendyala Venkatakrishnarao v. Dr. B. Seetharam (1989) 2 APLJ 261 Supported the proposition that a residential building need not be let out only for residential purposes if its structure permits non-residential use; clarified interplay between structure, use and classification for eviction grounds. The court followed this decision (as cited in Amtual Hafeez) to interpret "own occupation" as including the type of occupation the structure admits, supporting the landlord's entitlement to seek eviction for business use of residential portions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in a multi-step analysis driven by precedent and the facts before it:

  1. Procedural point: The court first addressed the petitioner's contention that maintainability (composite lease objection) was not pleaded by the tenant and therefore should not have been considered. The court noted that, unlike in Ananta v. P. Govinda Swamy, the maintainability objection was in fact argued by both parties before the two courts below; consequently Ananta was distinguishable and did not assist the petitioner.
  2. Distinguishing Dr. Madhusudan Mahuli / applying Samyal: The court examined the decision in Dr. Madhusudan Mahuli which applied Miss S. Samyal to hold that composite leases could not be split to grant eviction limited to the residential portion. The court observed that in Madhusudan Mahuli the landlord sought eviction of composite premises for residential purpose, and hence that decision was not on all fours with the present facts.
  3. Applying Firm Panjumal and related decisions: The court relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Firm Panjumal Daulatram v. Sakhi Gopal, which allowed eviction where the landlord advances a dual requirement under statutory provisions analogous to the A.P. Act. The court also relied on the single Judge decision in Yashpal Roy, which applied Firm Panjumal and held that a landlord may seek eviction of composite-purpose premises when he seeks eviction for both residential and non-residential purposes together.
  4. Rule against splitting the contract but allowance for dual requirement: The court distilled the principle that while a composite lease cannot be split to evict only one portion (which would amount to splitting the contract), a landlord who legitimately requires both portions for permissible grounds under the Act can seek eviction of both portions together.
  5. Interpretation of "occupation" and applicability to residential portion: Relying on Amtual Hafeez and Pendyala Venkatakrishnarao, the court reasoned that the term "occupation" in Sec. 10(3)(a)(i) is not limited strictly to residential occupation but must be understood according to the type of occupation the structure admits of. Thus, where a residential building can be used for a non-residential business without structural alteration and has not been converted under Sec. 18, eviction for business requirement is permissible.
  6. Application to the facts: The court found that the petitioner sought eviction of both portions together and satisfied the eviction ingredients with respect to each portion. The lower appellate court had found that the landlord's requirement for business purposes was bona fide. Given that the petitioner sought eviction for business use of both the business portion and the residential portion (which the court found could lawfully accommodate business use without conversion), the eviction petition was held maintainable and the petitioner entitled to relief.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Civil Revision Petition (C.R.P.) is allowed; the petitioner (landlord) is entitled to an order of eviction.

Implications and immediate consequences:

  • The court affirmed that where a lease is composite, a landlord may seek eviction for both residential and non-residential portions together if he satisfies the statutory ingredients in respect of each portion; however, the landlord cannot seek eviction of only one portion in a manner that splits the indivisible contract.
  • Specifically, where a residential portion can be used for business without structural alteration and has not been converted under Sec. 18, the landlord may claim eviction of that portion for business requirement (interpreting "occupation" to include such use as the structure admits).
  • Practical relief granted: The tenant is given four months to vacate the premises, subject to payment of rents in time. No costs were awarded.
  • On broader precedent: The decision distinguishes an earlier single Judge decision (Madhusudan Mahuli) and applies Supreme Court authority (Firm Panjumal) and later High Court decisions to clarify that a dual bona fide requirement supports maintainability; the opinion does not purport to create a novel principle beyond these applications.

Note: This summary reflects only the matters explicitly set out in the provided opinion. No external facts or inferences beyond the opinion have been included.

Show all summary ...

1. The petitioner is the landlord of the premises situated in a business locality at Parvatipuram. Prior to his purchase, the respondent tenant took it on a monthly rent of Rs. 140/- from the vendor in the year 1978 under Ex. A-2. As per the terms of the lease, the tenant can run the photo studio business and also reside in the premises. The landlord filed eviction petition in the year 1985 on the ground that he requires the premises for business purposes and that he has no other own building in the town. The main plea of the tenant in his counter is that the requirement is not bonafide and the eviction petition was filed to extract higher rent. The learned Rent Controller held that as the lease is composite for both residential and non-residential the eviction petition is not maintainable in view of the decision of this court in Dr. Dr. Madhusudan Mahuli… v. Lambu Indira Bai…. (1) (1987) 2 ALT 504 and dismissed the eviction petition without going into the question of bonafide requirement. On appeal, the appellate court held that the petitioner's requirement for business purposes is bonafide. However, it held that the eviction petition is not maintainable as the lease is composite. Aggrieved by this the petitioner has come up with this revision.

2. Mr. C. Subba Rao, learned counsel for the petitioner contended at the out set that the maintainability of the eviction petition having not been raised by the tenant in the counter, the courts below erred in going into this question and relied on a decision of the single Judge of this Court in Ananta v. P. Govinda Swamy (2) (1992) 1 ALT 46. This case is distinguishable since the plea of composite lease was not raised before the two courts below and in those circumstances it was held that the tenant had no right to raise the same for the first time in revision in this court.

3. But in the instant case, though this objection about maintainability was not taken in the counter, both the parties argued on this ground in both the courts and hence this decision does not help the petitioner.

4. Now coming to the maintainability of the petition, the learned counsel Sri Subba Rao, contended that the decision in Dr. Madhusudan Mahudi case (1 supra) does not come in the way of the petitioner. In that case, there were two portions of the premises let out one exclusively for clinic and the other for residence of compounder. The landlord filed petition for eviction of the tenant from the portion used for clinic on the ground that he requires it for residential purpose. Holding that the petition is not maintainable and applying the decision of the Supreme Court in Miss S. Samyal v. Gian Chand (3) AIR 1968 S.C 438, the learned single Judge held:

“There is no provision under the Rent Control Act for eviction based upon bona fide personal requirement in respect of premises let out for mixed purpose of residential and non residential. The Rent Control Act bearing a slant towards the protection of the tenants against unreasonable evictions provided sufficient safeguards to the landlords for eviction and otherwise. The bonafide personal requirement is founded upon the legitimate necessity of the landlord and in the event of composite lease the landlord is deprived of the remedy under the Rent Control Act.”

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

The Rent Control Act having profusely provided for eviction in the case of residential or non-residential premises appears to have overlooked the provisions for eviction in respect of premises let out for mixed purpose. The ingredients for eviction for residential and non-residential are distinct and separate though there are certain similar features and in the absence of any provision for eviction in respect of premises bearing composite lease it is not possible to lead Section 10(3)(a) with a provision for eviction in respect of premises having composite lease and such interpretation is blessed by Supreme Court while considering the analogous provisions under the Ajmer Rent Control Act.”

5. In Miss S. Samyal case (3 supra), which decision was applied by the learned single Judge, the tenant was occupying the premises part of which was used for Girls' School and rest of which for residenti purposes. Eviction Petition was filed by the landlord on the ground of requirement of the house for his residence. The High Court of Punjab, splitting the composite lease, granted eviction in respect of portion used by the tenant for residential purpose. The Supreme Court reversed the decision of High Court and held that the contract being single and indivisible, in the absence of a statutory provision to that effect, it is not open to the court to divide it into two contracts one of letting for residential purpose and the other for non-residential purposes and to grant relief limited to the portion of the premises which is being used for residential purpose. This decision has been subsequently explained by the Supreme Court in Firm Panjumal Daulatram v. Sakhi Gopal. (4) ((1977) 3 SCC 284 : AIR 1977 S.C 2077) arising under Madhya Pradesh Rent Control Act. Sec. 12(1)(e) and (f) of Madhya Pradesh Act is analogous to Sec. 10(3)(i) and (iii) of the A.P Buildings (Lease, Rent and Eviction Control) Act (for short the Act) except that of the word ‘building’ is used in the A.P Act, while the word ‘purpose’ is used in the M.P Act. In that case, the landlord leased out the premises for running cloth shop and also for residential purpose. The landlord filed eviction petition on the ground that he wanted to run medical store on the ground floor and to stay on the first floor with his wife. The tenant, relying on Samyal case (3 supra) contended that the eviction petition is not maintainable and the contract cannot be split into two. Rejecting this contention, the Supreme Court held that there is no question of splitting up the contract and as the landlord has put forward dual requirement, under Sec. 12(1)(e) and (f) the eviction petition is maintainable. Applying this decision, learned single Judge of this Court in Yashpal Roy… v. Gessulal Dinesh Kumar & Another… (5) (1993) 2 APLJ 249 held that when the lease is for composite purpose, it is always open to the landlord to seek eviction for the purpose additional residential accommodation as well as for non-residential purpose and that he will be prevented from seeking to evict the tenant only on one requirement. In that case, the land lord was staying in a portion of the 1st floor of the double storeyed building and let out two rooms in the residential portion and one mulgi, in the ground floor. The landlord sought eviction of the tenant in the ground floor who was in occupation of two rooms and one mulgi, on the ground that he requires the portion occupied by the tenant for additional accommodation as he wants to shift to the ground floor and occupy residential rooms for his residential purpose and non-residential mulgi for the purpose of business in consultancy as geologist. Distinguishing the decision of Madhusudan Mahuli case (1 supra) and applying the decision of the Supreme Court in Firm Panjuma Daulatram (4 supra), the learned single Judge held that the eviction petition is maintainable.

6. Thus, in case of composite lease, the landlord can seek eviction from the residential portion and non-residential portions on the grounds permitted under the Act in respect of each portion. But he cannot seek eviction of any one of the portions only as it will amount to splitting of contract into two. Applying this to the facts of this case, the petitioner is seeking eviction of tenant on the ground that he requires both the portions for his business purposes. As far as the portion occupied by the tenant for business purpose is concerned, there is no difficulty in holding that the petitioner can ask for eviction on the ground that he requires it for business. Now the question remains whether the petitioner can seek eviction from residential portion for his business purpose. In Amtual Hafeez v. D. Mohammed Ibrahim (6) (1996) 3 ALD 582, I have held that the word ‘occupation’ used in Sec. 10(3)(a)(i) cannot be restricted to residential occupation but must be interpreted as such occupation as the structure admits of. In that decision I have held following the decision of the Division Bench in Pendyala Venkatakrishnarao… v. Dr. B. Seetharam…. (7) (1989) 2 APLJ 261:

“To sum up, residential building need not be let out for residential purpose only but can be let out for non-residential purpose if the structure of building permits of such use and continues to be residential building as long as it is not converted into non-residential building under Sec. 18 of the Act. The words ‘own occupation’ occurring in Sec. 10(3)(a)(i) have to be interpreted as including the type of occupation as the structure of residential premises admits of and cannot be restricted to residential occupation only. On the other hand, non-residential premises can be let out only for non-residential purpose and will always remain as non-residential premises and can never be treated as residential premises unless its structure is altered. Eviction from such premises can be sought only on the ground of requirement for business.

Applying the above principle to the instant case since the premises though residential can be used for business of sale of carpets without necessity of structural alterations and is not converted under Sec. 18 of the Act as non-residential building, the landlord is entitled to claim eviction on the ground that he requires it for his own business. He is also entitled to eviction for the reason that his son wants to reside in the premises besides doing business.”

7. As the petitioner is claiming eviction of the two portions together and as the petitioner satisfies the ingredients in respect of each portion, the eviction petition is maintainable. The decision in Madhusudan Mahuli case (1 supra) is distinguishable since it is a case where landlord sought eviction of composite premises for residential purpose (emphasis supplied). It is well settled that eviction of non-residential building cannot be sought on the ground of residential occupation. As the lower appellate court found that the landlord requires the premises bonafide for business purposes, the petitioner is entitled to order of eviction.

8. The C.R.P is accordingly allowed. No costs. However, four months time is granted to the tenant to vacate the premises subject to payment of rents in time.