THOMPSON v. LIVINGSTON, MAYOR

Messrs. Raysor, Moss Lide, for appellant, cite: Amendment of Constitution regulated: Art. XVI Const. 1895. Senate Journal must be looked to: 100 S.C. 173 Failure of journal to show negative votes is fatal: 131 N.C. 657, 43 S.E. 3; Modified in 143 N.C. 110, 55 S.E. 442; also see: 200 S.W. 997, (Ark.); 33 Ark. 17. Messrs. John S. Bowman, Nathans Sinkler, for respondents, cite: Case at 131 N.C. 657 was overruled in 143 N.C. 110. There was substantial compliance by the Legislature: 12 S.C. 289; 145 Fed. Rep. 765; 93 N.E. 244; 43 S.E. 3