- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
JSC BTA Bank v Ablyazov & Anor
Factual and Procedural Background
Since 2009, extensive litigation has taken place in this court involving Company A (a bank) and its former chairman, Defendant. The litigation primarily concerns Company A's efforts to enforce a worldwide freezing order (WFO) granted against Defendant in 2009. Defendant was found to have breached the WFO, with certain individuals assisting him. Company A now alleges that Defendant's son-in-law, Appellant, also conspired to breach the WFO since 2009 by creating false documents and taking actions to impede Company A's recovery of judgment debts exceeding US$4.6 billion. Company A commenced an action against Appellant in 2015, obtained a WFO against him, and alleges that Appellant has failed to disclose asset information as required. Appellant denies the claim, arguing the cause of action is unsustainable and that the court lacks jurisdiction under the Lugano Convention.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Company A has a legally recognized cause of action against Appellant for conspiracy to injure by unlawful means based on breaches of the WFO and related conduct.
- Whether this court has jurisdiction under the Lugano Convention to hear and determine the claim against Appellant, who is domiciled in Switzerland.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The cause of action for conspiracy to injure by unlawful means is "wholly unsustainable," "bad in law," and must fail.
- Breaches of court orders, including the WFO, cannot constitute unlawful means for the tort of conspiracy to injure by unlawful means.
- The court lacks jurisdiction under the Lugano Convention because Appellant is domiciled in Switzerland, and Company A cannot establish special jurisdiction.
- There is no right to damages for contempt, and allowing damages for conspiracy based on breaches of the WFO would circumvent this "positive rule."
- Allowing damages would be an unprincipled and excessive extension of the law.
Company A's Arguments
- There is a good arguable case that breaches of the WFO and related conduct constitute unlawful means for the tort of conspiracy to injure by unlawful means.
- Contempt can be sufficiently reprehensible to justify civil liability for damages, analogous to criminal conduct recognized as unlawful means.
- Precedent supports that abuse of court process and creation of false documents can constitute unlawful means.
- There is no positive common law rule excluding damages for contempt; some authorities support damages in contempt-related cases.
- The court has jurisdiction under Articles 5(3) and 6 of the Lugano Convention because Defendant is domiciled in England and the claims against Appellant and Defendant are closely connected.
- The harmful event giving rise to damage occurred partly in England, where the conspiracy was hatched and instructions issued, at least until February 2012.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue and Customs Commissioners v Total Network [2008] 1 AC 1174 | Definition and scope of conspiracy to injure by unlawful means; criminal conduct can constitute unlawful means. | Supported the proposition that breaches of WFO (contempt) can amount to unlawful means; court relied on reasoning of Lords regarding unlawful means including crimes and torts. |
| Surzur Overseas Limited v Koros [1999] 2 Lloyd's Rep 611 | Conspiracy to injure by unlawful means involving false documents and abuse of court process. | Provided authority that conspiracy to abuse court process is actionable; suggested (but did not decide) breaches of freezing orders could be unlawful means. |
| Digicel (St. Lucia) Limited v Cable & Wireless [2010] EWHC 774 (Ch) | Non-actionable breaches of non-criminal statutes do not constitute unlawful means. | Court held it was not applicable to breaches of court orders; did not assist in deciding whether contempt can be unlawful means. |
| Customs and Excise Commissioners v Barclays Bank [2007] 1 AC 181 | No duty of care owed by third party bank informed of freezing order; court orders enforceable only by contempt sanctions. | Cited to support that damages are not available for contempt; court followed House of Lords' view that contempt jurisdiction is punitive, not compensatory. |
| Chapman v Honig [1963] 2 QB 502 | Contempt jurisdiction protects administration of justice, not individuals; damages generally not available for contempt. | Outlined arguments for and against damages for contempt; court did not decide definitively; supported the principle that contempt is not for private compensation. |
| Couling v Coxe (1848) 6 CB 703 | Damages can be awarded for breach of witness summons. | Recognized as an exception; court noted this authority but considered it inconsistent with more recent principles. |
| Fairclough v The Manchester Ship Canal (1897) 41 Sol. Journal 225 | Obiter suggestion that damages could be awarded for contempt. | Supported argument that damages may be available in some contempt cases; not binding but considered persuasive. |
| In re Mileage Conference Group of the Tyre Manufacturers' Conference Ltd.'s Agreement [1966] 1 WLR 1137 | Obiter recognition that damages could be awarded for contempt. | Used to support possibility of damages in contempt cases; not decisive. |
| The Messiniaki Tolmi [1983] 1 Lloyd's Rep. 666 | Arguable civil cause of action for damages for aiding and abetting contempt. | Supported Company's argument that damages may be recoverable for contempt-related conspiracy. |
| Midland Marts v Hobday [1989] 1 WLR 1143 | Damages can be awarded where breach of court undertaking also breaches contract; contempt alone does not give rise to damages. | Court found that damages for contempt alone are not established; distinguished cases where contractual breach exists. |
| Nunes v Agrawal (unreported, 1999) | Contempt does not itself give cause of action; obiter comments on contempt and damages. | Court found obiter comments not authoritative; did not preclude damages for contempt in other contexts. |
| Parker v Rasalingham (unreported, 2000) | Some authority for court jurisdiction to award damages for breach of injunction. | Supported Company's position that damages may be available for breach of court orders in certain circumstances. |
| Jeningon v Assaubayev [2010] EWHC 2351 (Ch) | Procedure for ordering cross-examination on compliance with freezing orders. | Referenced for procedural guidance on cross-examination related to WFO compliance. |
| Canada Trust v Stolzenberg (No.2) [1998] 1 WLR 547 | Standard for establishing "much the better argument" under Lugano Convention jurisdiction provisions. | Applied to evaluate jurisdictional arguments under Articles 5 and 6 of Lugano Convention. |
| Lady Brownlie v Four Seasons [2015] EWCA Civ 665 | Clarification of jurisdictional tests under Lugano Convention. | Supported analysis of jurisdiction under Articles 5 and 6; court applied its principles. |
| Petrotrade Inc. v Smith [1999] 1 WLR 457 | Relevant date for domicile assessment under Lugano Convention is date of proceedings commencement. | Applied to determine domicile date for Defendant in jurisdiction analysis. |
| Bank of Dubai v Fouad Haji Abbas [1997] ILPr 308 | Definition of residence and domicile for jurisdictional purposes. | Used to assess Defendant's domicile status in England. |
| R v Barnet LBC ex p. Shah [1983] 2 AC 309 | Residence must be voluntarily adopted with a settled purpose. | Guided court's assessment of Defendant's domicile given his flight and custody status. |
| Handelskwekerij GJ Bier v Mines de Potasse d'Alsace SA [1978] 1 QB 708 | Interpretation of "place where harmful event occurred" in tort jurisdiction. | Court applied principles to determine jurisdiction under Lugano Convention Article 5(3). |
| AMT Futures Ltd. v Marzillier [2015] QB 699 | Clarified meaning of "place where damage occurred" for jurisdictional purposes. | Guided court's evaluation of where damage was sustained for jurisdictional analysis. |
| Domicrest v Swiss Bank Corpn. [1999] QB 548 | Place of event giving rise to damage in negligent misstatement cases. | Considered but distinguished; court held conspiracy damage occurs on implementation, not hatching. |
| ABC1 v BFT [2003] EWCA Civ 205 | Application of place of event giving rise to damage in conspiracy cases. | Not directly helpful as conspiracy and damage occurred in same jurisdiction. |
| Sunderland Marine Mutual Insurance v Wiseman [2007] 1 CLC 989 | Conspiracy to defraud and place of event giving rise to damage. | Distinguished; did not resolve dispute on jurisdiction in present case. |
| Shevill v Presse Alliance [1995] 2 AC 18 | Defamation jurisdiction principles. | Rejected as analogy for conspiracy to injure by unlawful means. |
| Z Bank v D1 [1994] 1 Lloyd's Rep. 656 | Freezing order breach and order for sequestration with possibility of compensation. | Referenced in discussion on contempt sanctions and possible compensation. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court first addressed whether Company A had a good arguable cause of action for conspiracy to injure by unlawful means based on breaches of the WFO. It relied on precedent establishing that conspiracy requires an agreement to use unlawful means causing damage, focusing on whether contempt (breach of court orders) can constitute unlawful means. The court found strong support in authorities such as Total Network and Surzur v Koros that contempt can amount to unlawful means, rejecting submissions that breaches of court orders are non-actionable in this context. The court distinguished between contempt alone (which does not give rise to damages) and conspiracy involving contempt, where damages may be recoverable because liability arises from the conspiracy.
Regarding the court's power to award damages for contempt, the court reviewed extensive authorities and concluded that the contempt jurisdiction is primarily punitive and protective of the administration of justice, not compensatory for individuals. It found no positive common law rule allowing damages for contempt and followed recent House of Lords authority confirming this. However, the court held that this does not preclude contempt from constituting unlawful means within a tortious conspiracy claim.
On jurisdiction, the court considered the Lugano Convention. It found that Defendant was unlikely domiciled in England as of July 2015 due to his flight and incarceration abroad, undermining jurisdiction under Article 6. However, the court held that jurisdiction under Article 5(3) was established because the harmful event's effects connected to assets were sufficiently linked to England, where the conspiracy was hatched and partly implemented before February 2012. The court distinguished between the place where the conspiracy was hatched (England) and where damage was sustained (foreign jurisdictions where assets were located), concluding the court had jurisdiction for damage caused before February 2012.
The court also noted that Appellant had not responded to substantive allegations, bolstering the finding of a good arguable case and jurisdiction. The court dismissed the application to set aside the claim form and WFO against Appellant, subject to possible amendments to conform with jurisdictional findings. It deferred consideration of certain disclosure and cross-examination applications until the scope of injunctions and obligations was clarified.
Holding and Implications
The court DISMISSED the application to set aside the claim form and the worldwide freezing order issued against Appellant. It held that Company A has a good arguable case that Appellant committed the tort of conspiracy to injure by unlawful means, with contempt constituting unlawful means for this purpose. The court found that it has jurisdiction under Article 5(3) of the Lugano Convention over claims relating to conduct before 16 February 2012.
The decision means that Appellant remains subject to the claim and associated freezing order, though certain aspects of the injunction and disclosure obligations may require amendment. The ruling clarifies that while damages are not recoverable for contempt alone, contempt can constitute unlawful means within a conspiracy tort claim, representing an incremental development of the law. The court did not establish new precedent on damages for contempt but reaffirmed the distinct roles of contempt sanctions and tortious liability for conspiracy.
Alert