- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
SHRI CHUBAMONGBA JAMIR v. DEFENCE
2
3
4
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
GUWAHATI BENCH, GUWAHATI
****
5
Shri Chubamongba Jamir, Designation: Asstt. IFA (Sr. AO), Office of the Jt. IFA Hq. 3 Corps, R/O. Naga Gaon, House No. 22, Dimapur, Nagaland. chubamongbajamir@gmail.com
7980449614.
By Advocate: Mr. Bendangwabang/ Original Application No. 32 of 2025 This the 13h Day of February, 2025. OA No. 32 of 2025
Hon'ble Mr. Rajnish Kumar Rai, Member (J) Hon'ble Mr. M.L. Srivastava, Member (A) Mr. Sashi Mongba Jamir.
Versus
..Applicant
The Union of India, through the Secretary Ministry of Defence, Govt. of India, Raisina Hill, South Block, New Delhi-110001.
The Controller General of Defence Accounts, Ulan Batar Marg, Palam, Delhi Contt-110010. The Deputy Controller General of Defence Accounts, office of the Controller General of Defence Accounts, Ulan Batar Marg, Palam, Delhi Contt-l10010. Sr. Accounts Officer, AN-II, office of the Controller General of Defence Accounts, Ulan Batar Marg, Palam, Delhi Contt-110010.
By Advocate: Mr. R. Hazarika.
The Dy. IFA (AN), IFA (EC) FW, Kolkata, Integrated Financial Adviser (Eastern Command), Fort William, Kolkata-700021.
...Respondents.
Page 1 of 10
By Hon'ble Mr. Rajnish Kumar Rai, Member () heard.
Mr. Bendangwabang, counsel for the applicant and Mr. R. Hazarika, counsel for the respondents are present and 2.. The applicant has filed this O.A. under Section 19 of the relief(s):
ORDER
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, seeking the following
3.
"(a) OA No. 32 of 2025 (b)
(c)
Order No. AN/IIV2153/Trf- Posting/Vol.XII/2024/TR-21 Dated 14h Jan, 2025 issued by the Respondent Nos.2 & 3 in respect of the applicant mentioned at ANNEXURE-I Serial No, 1.
And also to set aside and quashed:
Impugned Order No. AN/N10083/Lmplementation/2025 Dated 24/01/2025.
Impugned Order No. AN/II/2053/Trf-Posting/Vol-XIII/ 2024 dated 31.0l.2025. "
The brief fact of the case is that the applicant, after selection and appointment, was posted at PAO (ORS) EME, CDA Secunderabad, Andhra Pradesh, from November 3. 2003, to 2008, and subsequently at M0, CDA Secunderabad from 2008 to 2011. Further postings included IFA, HÌ 3 CORPS, CDA, Guwahati (2011-2015), PCDA (FYS), Kolkata (2015-2019), AO (P), Sewak, PCDA (BR) (2019-2023), and IFA, HÌ 3 CORPSs, CDA, Guwahati (2023-2025). During the applicant's tenure at PCDA (FYS), Kolkata, they were diagnosed with Carcinoma Nasopharynx and underwent
Page 2 of 10
treatment at TATA Memorial Center & Hospital, Mumbai, OA No. 32 of 2025
from 07.01.2016, including radiation therapy and chemotherapy. The applicant also received treatment at Rabindranath Tagore International Institute of Cardiac Sciences, Kolkata (2017-2019), and District Hospital, Dimapur (2022-2025). Given their critical medical condition, the applicant submitted representation on 10.12.2024, requesting retention at Dimapur on health grounds, which was forvwarded to Respondent No. 2. However, before the request was processed, a transfer order dated 14.01.2025, was issued. Despite further appeals, Respondent No. 3 issued a directive on January 24, 2025, enforcing the transfer and warning of salary withholding from February 2025 for non compliance. On 31.01.2025, a final communication denied consideration of the applicant's request despite enclosed medical records. The applicant asserts that Respondent No. 3 failed to reassess the situation, disregarding the serious medical concerns and hardship caused by the transfer.
4. Counsel for the applicant submitted that since 2016, the applicant has been under constant medical attention and treatment at various hospitals within and outside the state. As such, the applicant's case is exceptional, and the competent authority under whom the applicant was serving had
Page 3 of 10
considered the matter and forwarded it to the higher authority. However, the respondent authorities failed to accede to the applicant's request, which is highly illegal and arbitrary. He further submits that the applicant had submitted a representation in advance, before the issuance of Order No. AN/II/2153/Trf-Posting/Vol.XII/2024/TR-21 dated 14h Jan 2025 by Respondent Nos. 2 & 3. However, delays in transmiting the applicant's representation/file through different levels of hierarchy and protocol resulted in the finalization and inclusion of the applicant's name in the transter order. despite his serious medical condition. Respondent No. 3, while handling the applicant's case, acted regularly and injudiciously. applying erroneous judicial reasonurng and fail1ng to consider the representation and Tequest The respondent authorities ought to have appreciated the applicant's case, however, without verifying the health cond1tion and actual status of the appl1cant, they faled to assess the matter properly and proceeded to issue subsequent
OA No. 32 of 2025
orders: Order No
I\ J0083 Implementation/2025 dated 24/01/2025 and Order No AN IW2053/Trf-Posting/Vol-XIII/2024 dated 3101 2023 for implementation and withholding of salary. These actions are illegal, arbitrary, and perverse. The
Page 4 of 10
OA No. 32 of 2025 respondent authorities' failure to analyze the applicant's case is wholly erroneous and unlawful. Since the date of appointment, the applicant has performed duties diligently and has an outstanding service record. At no point has any prejudicial or adverse remark been made against the applicant, which would justify a punitive transfer. Although the service conditions are transferable, the present transter, considering the exceptional medical circumstances,1s
5
case unjustified. He further submits that the applicant's squarely falls within the ambit of Section 8, sub-clause (i),as formulated and adopted by the Office of the CGDA (No. 0600/AN-X/Vol.XXI, dated 28/03/2014) and circulated to all concerned authorities. Aggrieved by the inaction of the respondents, the applicant has filed the present original application.
Counsel for the applicant has relied on the transfer policy, as outlined in the enclosed Ännexure, which isto be
followed by the CGDA's office and implementedby PCsDA/CsDA while carrying out the transfer of Department members, excluding IDAS officers, from one station to another. He has also prayed for interim relief, seeking a stay on the impugned order dated 24.01.2025 and the impugned Page 5 of11
5
movement respondents.
6 Counsel for the respondents submitted that the transfer order has been passed in administrative exigency and the gnevance raised in the representation has also been considered and decided by the respondents vide impugned speaking order dated 31.01.2025. Hence. there is no merit in the O.A. and same may be dismissed.
7.
OA No, 32 of 2025 order dated 31.01.2025 issued by the After perusal of the pleadings, it is apparent thatthe respondent department, vide order dated 10.12.2024, proceeded with the repatriation of the applicant along with one other individual, Shri Bappi Das. Subsequently, on transfer order was issued for several 14.01.2025, On the
individuals, including the applicant, based recommendation of the placement board (D The applicant submitted a request for exemption on 14.01.2025, which was forwarded from the Guwahati office to the Kolkata
office on 15.01.2025. Thereafter, the recommendation was further forwarded from the Kolkata office to the Delhi office
via letter dated 21.01.2025. However, the board did not
accept the request, and vide order dated
21.01.2025,
directed the relief of all concerned by 31.01.2025.
Page 6 of 11
Accordingly, the applicant was relieved etfective 31,01.202, and
OA No, 2 f 2025
the rejection ofl the exemption request
communicated through the impugned
31.01.2025.
order dated
8 More so there is a catena of judgment citations ol he Hon'ble Apex Court which deserve mention in the contezt of the submissions made by the applicant's counsel.
9. "Thus, at the outset, it has to be understood any transfer policy is an executive instruction ab intio ipso facto and is not a statutory subordinate leqislation. Therefore, a transfer policy guideline can, therefore, not acquire the authority of the statutory rules because the rules cannot be amended by executive orders and a transfer policy can be amnended and is amended from time to time by the executive authority. This is fortified in the matter of K.A. Nagamani v. Indian Airlines, 2009 (5) SCC 550 in which it has been held that '...mere administrative rules are not leqislation of any kind. They are in the nature of statements of policy and the practice of government departments, statutory authorities, whether published or otherwise. Statutory rules, which are made under the provisions of any enactment and regulations, subject to Parliamentary approval stand on entirely different footing. The administrative rules are always considered and have repeatedly been held to be rules of administrative practice merely, not rules of law and not deleqated leqislation and they have no statutory force. Mere description of such rules of administrative practice as "rules" does not make them to be statutory rules. Such administrative rules can be modified, amended or consolidated by the authorities without following any particular procedure (emphasis supplied). There are no legal restrictions to do so as long as Page 7 of 1|
7
OA No 32 of 2025 they do not offend the provisions of the Constitution or statutes or statutory rules as the case may be
10. In fact, it has also been held guite clearly in the matter of Ajaya Kumar Das v. State of Orissa, 2011 (11) SCC 136 that whatever may be the efficacy of the executive orders or CiTCulars or instructions, statutory rules cannot be altered or amended by executive orders or circulars or instructions nor Such being the
can they replace the statutory rules.
distinction between rules and executive instructions, it is quite clear that the impugned transfer orders are at best by way of executive instructions, which canbe
amended from
time to time by competent executive authoritywho need not
to refer the legislature for framing Transfer Policy or any such authority which concerns Rule making power required under the Constitution such as w.r.t. Conditions of the service of the applicant. Thus, the plea that the impugned transfer orders are statutory rules and regqulations to be followed at the pain of disregard to the Constitution or the Legislatureor such Rule making body is not tenable. In fact, the transfer orders are executive instructions and source of quidance only in view of the several Apex court rulings as we analyse herein below.
Page 8 of 11
11. Even otherwise, the Transfer Policy madeby the
respondents is merely an Instruction/Guidelineand the same
1S without any statutorv
force. The said issue felltor
consideration before the Allahabad High Court in case of Dr.
0A No. 32 of 2025
Krishna Chandra Dubey Vs. Union
of India in Civil
(Misc.) Writ Petition No.
52249/2000. wherein it has been
observed that 'Government
Instructions on transfer are mere
guidelines without any statutory force.
12. Further, in case of Union of India Vs. S.L. Abbas, reported in AIR 1993 SC 2444, the Apex Court has observed
that the Government instructions on transfer are mere
guidelines withoutany statutory force and the Courtor
Tribunal cannot interfere with the order of transfer unlessthe
said order is alleged to have been passedby
maliceor
where it is made in violation of the statutory provisions.
13. It would be well to begin this interesting task by
appreciating that the whole business of transfer, based on the universe of rulings on the matter, can be looked at from some key view-points namely (i) nature of Transfer (ii) competent authority issuing the order (iii) rightsof the concerned public
servant or employee against a said transfer (iv) transfer as
being exigencies of service,(v) transfer on grounds of
malafide / by way of punishment/ victimization/ with malice Page 9 of 1|
9
etc., (vi) representations challenging transfers (vii) issues of natural justice (vii) protection under Article 14 and 16 of the
(ix) natureand force of transfer Constitution OA No. 32 of 2025
with transfer order and (xi) interferemces of the Courts in the matter of transfers.
14. VVith respect to the nature of transfer, it is laid down
again and again that the transfer is always understoodand Construed as incident of service (B.Varadha Rao v. Stateof Karnataka, 1986 (4) SCC 624. That, transfer is not a change
in the conditions of service and it is to be well understood
that the transfer ofa government servant who is appointed at
a particular cadre of transferable posts from one place to
other place is an
ordinary incident of service and therefore,
does not result in any alternation of any of the conditionof
service to government servant's disadvantage.
15. The comprehensive analysis heretofore guathe rulings
of the Hon'ble Apex Court and various courts weigh heavily
in, in the favour of non-interference in transfer matters except in very exceptional
circumstances. In the instant matter,we do not find any merit in the applicant's claim, as the request
for exemption was duly considered by the respondent
Page 10 of 11
Guidelines/Instructions (x) Consequences of non-complance
10
authority and subsequently rejected on 24.01.2025, witha
directive to relicve the applicant on 31.01.2025.Tne
mpugned order was communicated
acCordingly, with the
observation that the DAPB did not
accede to the applicant's
request. Given this situation,
where the applicant's
grievanCe
has been considered
and the applicant stand
relieved W.e.t.
31.01.2025, we find it difficultto interfere with the impugned
transfer order.
16. In conclusion therefore on the basis of the reasoning
OA No. 32 of 2025
and the discussionsin the foregoing
paragraphs, the plea of the applicantfor quashing the impugned orders lacks merit and is not
sustainable. Consequently, the OA is
dismissed.
No order as to Costs. (M.L. Srivastava)
Member (A)
/Shakuntala/
(Rajnish Kumar Rai) Member )
11
Alert