- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
HORIZON BIOCEUTICALS PVT. LTD. v. STATE OF HP
Factual and Procedural Background
Horizon Bioceuticals Private Limited filed a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution before the High Court of Himachal Pradesh. [1]
The petitioner had purchased Plot Nos. 15, 16 and 17, Industrial Area, Johron, Kala Amb, in auction proceedings and had received a sale certificate. It complained that the authorities had not taken steps to register the supplementary deed despite repeated representations. [2]
The petitioner challenged the communication dated 17.01.2023 and sought registration or attestation of the mutation without stamp duty and registration charges, relying upon Section 17(2)(xii) of the Registration Act, 1908. [3][4][5]
The respondents stated that no sum of Rs.35,60,650 had been demanded for registration of the sale certificate. The Court subsequently directed the learned Additional Advocate General to obtain instructions regarding the apparent demand in the impugned communication. [6][7]
The Court was informed that the petitioner had deposited Rs.35,60,650 with the Member Secretary, Single Window Clearance Agency. The record also showed that permission for transfer of the leasehold rights had been granted and that the petitioner had deposited the unearned premium, processing fee and GST, but the supplementary lease deed had not been executed. [8][9][10]
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the respondents could demand stamp duty and registration charges in connection with the petitioner’s auction-purchased property and proposed supplementary deed. [11][12]
- Whether the respondents should be directed to execute the supplementary sale deed in favour of the petitioner without requiring stamp duty. [13][14]
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner argued that, although it had purchased the plots in auction and had received a sale certificate, the authorities had failed to take steps for registration of the supplementary deed. [15][2]
- It contended that it was not required to pay the amount demanded in the communication dated 17.01.2023, but was nevertheless being compelled to deposit that amount before execution of the supplementary deed. [16]
- The petitioner sought execution of the supplementary deed without stamp duty and registration charges. [3][4][5]
Respondents' Arguments
- The respondents submitted that no amount of Rs.35,60,650 had been demanded for registration of the sale certificate. [6]
- They relied on Section 17(2)(xii) of the Registration Act, 1908, asserting that a sale certificate issued in an auction sale was not required to be registered and therefore stamp duty and registration fee were not chargeable. [12]
- The respondents also stated that no deed had been presented for registration before the competent authority. [8][17]
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Mohan Singh Guleria Vs. State of H.P. and Others | No stamp duty could be demanded for registration of a sale certificate concerning property purchased in auction. [18] | The Court relied on the stated principle while examining the respondents’ demand for stamp duty. [18][13] |
| State of Punjab & Another Vs. M/s Ferrous Alloy Forgings Pvt. Ltd. & Others | Summarised the law concerning registration and stamp duty applicable to auction sale certificates. [19] | The Court reproduced and relied on the relevant principles from this decision. [19][20][21] |
| Smt. Shanti Devi L. Singh v. Tax Recovery Officer and Others | A sale certificate is not compulsorily registrable under Section 17(2)(xii), and non-registration does not invalidate transfer of title to the auction purchaser. [22] | The principle supported the conclusion that the auction purchaser’s title was not dependent on registration of the sale certificate. [22][23] |
| B. Arvind Kumar v. Govt. Of India and Others | Upon confirmation of a public auction sale, title vests in the purchaser; the sale certificate is evidence of title and does not require registration. [24][23] | The Court used this principle to explain that no further transfer deed from the court is required after confirmation of the auction sale. [23] |
| M/s Esjaypee Impex Private Limited v. The Asst. General Manager and Authorized Officer Canara Bank | Under Sections 17(2)(xii) and 89(4) of the Registration Act, the original sale certificate is delivered to the auction purchaser and a copy is forwarded to the Sub-Registrar for filing in Book 1. [25][26] | The principle reinforced that filing of a copy, rather than compulsory registration, is the statutory mechanism for an auction sale certificate. [26][20] |
| Inspector General of Registration and Another v. G. Madhurambal and Another | A sale certificate is not a conveyance subject to stamp duty, and filing it under Section 89 has the effect of registration without further action. [27] | The Court relied on this rule in assessing whether additional stamp duty could be demanded for the auction transaction. [27][20] |
| Radha Krishan Industries v. State of H.P. | An alternate remedy does not by itself remove the High Court’s jurisdiction under Article 226; exhaustion of statutory remedies is a rule of policy, convenience and discretion. [28] | The precedent was cited in the reproduced Supreme Court reasoning concerning the exercise of writ jurisdiction. [28] |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court first noted that the amount of Rs.35,60,650 had already been deposited by the petitioner. Consequently, there was no occasion to quash the demand solely on that basis; the petitioner’s remaining grievance was the failure to register or execute the relevant deed. [11]
The Court observed that the respondents’ own position was that a sale certificate issued under Section 17(2)(xii) of the Registration Act was not required to be registered. Nevertheless, the communications on record showed that stamp duty was still being demanded. [12]
Because the property had been purchased in auction and the petitioner had cleared the outstanding amount, the Court held that the respondents had no authority to demand stamp duty in the circumstances presented. [17]
The Court further noted that permission for transfer of the leasehold rights had been granted, the required premium and fees had been paid, and the supplementary lease deed remained unexecuted. The petitioner had approached the Court because additional stamp duty was being sought for that execution. [10]
Relying on the cited authorities, the Court held that an auction sale certificate is evidence of title, is not compulsorily registrable, and does not attract a requirement of further registration merely because it evidences an auction sale. [23][29][20]
The Court also recorded that stamp duty may arise when an auction purchaser presents the original sale certificate for another purpose, but the certificate itself remains non-compulsorily registrable. [21]
The Court found that the respondents’ delay was continuing while clarification regarding the stamp-duty issue remained pending, causing prejudice to the petitioner. [18][13][19]
Holding and Implications
PETITION ALLOWED AND DISPOSED OF. The respondents were directed to execute the supplementary sale deed in favour of the petitioner concerning Plot Nos. 15, 16 and 17, Industrial Area, Kala Amb, without requiring stamp duty, and to complete the process preferably within three weeks. [14][30]
The pending applications, if any, were also disposed of. The direct consequence was an order requiring the respondents to proceed with execution of the supplementary deed; the opinion does not state that any new precedent was created. [30]
2024:HHC:12990
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
Civil Writ Petition No.8488 of 2024 Date of Decision: 28.11.2024
_____________________________________________________________________ Horizon Bioceuticals Private Limited ……...Petitioner Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh and Others …....Respondents Coram
Hon'ble Mr. Justice Sandeep Sharma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting? Yes.
For the Petitioner: Mr. Tara Singh Chauhan, Senior Advocate, with Mr. Surya Chauhan and Mr.
Abhimanyu Sharma, Advocates.
For the Respondents: Mr. Anup Ratan, Advocate General, with Mr. Rajan Kahol, Mr. Vishal Panwar and Mr. B.C.
Verma, Additional Advocates General, with Mr.
Ravi Chauhan, Deputy Advocate General.
___________________________________________________________________________
Sandeep Sharma, J. (Oral) By way of instant petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, petitioner has prayed for following reliefs:
"a. That the order dated Annexure P-7, dated 17.01.2023 may be quashed and set aside.
b. That the respondents may be directed to register attest the mutation in pursuance to the Annexure P-4, without asking for stamp duty and registration charges.
c. That the respondent No.3 may be directed to perform his statutory duties in pursuance to Section 17(2)(xii) of the Registration Act, 1908. And record of the case may be called for."
2. Precisely, the grouse of the petitioner, as as has been highlighted in the petition and further canvassed by Mr. Tara Singh Chauhan, learned Senior Counsel, duly assisted by Mr. Surya
1
2
Chauhan, learned counsel representing the petitioner is that though petitioner herein has purchased plot Nos.15, 16 & 17, Industrial Area, Johron, Kala Amb, Tehsil Nahan, District Sirmaur, Himachal Pradesh, in auction proceedings and in that regard, sale certificate already stands issued, but yet, despite there being repeated representations, no steps are being taken by District Collector-cum-Deputy Commissioner, Sirmaur at Nahan, District Sirmaur, Himachal Pradesh, for registration of supplementary deed.
3. During proceedings of the case, learned Senior Counsel representing the petitioner invited attention of this Court to communication dated 17.01.2023 (Annexure P-7), issued under the signatures of Member Secretary, Single Window Clearance Agency, Kala Amb, District Sirmaur, Himachal Pradesh, to state that though petitioner on account of his having purchased property in question under auction is not required to pay the amount, as has been demanded vide aforesaid communication, but yet, he is being compelled to deposit the aforesaid amount before registration of supplementary deed.
4. Pursuant to notices issued in the instant proceedings, respondents No.1, 2 and 4 have filed reply, wherein it came to be submitted that no amount to the tune of Rs.35,60,650/- ever came to be demanded by the department for registration of sale certificate and
3
as such, this Court vide order dated 21.11.2024, passed following order:
"Though, careful perusal of the reply filed on behalf of respondent Nos. 1, 2 and 4, which has been filed under the signatures of Deputy Commission, District Sirmour at Nahan, reveals that no amount to the tune of Rs.35,60,650/- ever came to be demanded by the Department for registration of sale deed, but perusal of impugned order dated 17.01.2023, issued by Member Secretary, SWCA, Kala Amb, District Sirmour, Himachal Pradesh clearly reveals that for registration of sale deed afore authority besides demanding sum of Rs.35,60,650/- has also raised demand of Rs.5,43,150/- on account of service tax. Learned Additional Advocate General prays for and is granted four days' time to have instructions on or before the next date of hearing. List on 28.11.2024."
5. Pursuant to afore directions passed by this Court, learned Additional Advocate General placed on record communication dated 27.11.2024, issued under the signatures of District Collector-cum- Deputy Commissioner, Sirmaur, Himachal Pradesh, wherein it came to be reiterated that amount, as claimed in impugned order dated 17.01.2023, issued by Member Secretary, Single Window Clearance Agency, Kala Amb, District Sirmaur, Himachal Pradesh, has no concern with the stamp duty, rather at no point of time, deed, if any, has been presented before competent authority for registration. Perusal of aforesaid communication as well as documents annexed therewith, which are taken on record, clearly reveals that sum of Rs.35,60,650/- in terms of order dated 17.01.2023 already stands deposited by the petitioner with Member Secretary, Single Window
4
Clearance Agency, Kala Amb, District Sirmaur, Himachal Pradesh, who thereafter vide communication dated 26.11.2024, addressed to Additional District Magistrate, District Sirmaur at Nahan, Himachal Pradesh, while apprising factum of deposit of aforesaid amount, apprised aforesaid authority that petitioner-unit vide letter dated 02.11.2023 requested for rebate in stamp duty and subsequently matter was taken with the worthy Director of Industries, Himachal Pradesh vide letter dated 09.11.2023, who has further taken-up the matter with Principle Secretary, Industries, Government of Himachal Pradesh, vide letter dated 03.01.2024.
6. Having perused aforesaid communication dated 26.11.2024, this Court finds that sum of Rs.35,60,650/-, as demanded vide impugned notice dated 17.01.2023, already stands deposited by the petitioner and as such, there is otherwise no occasion, if any, for this Court to accept the prayer made on behalf of the petitioner to quash such order, rather, precisely the grouse of the petitioner at this stage is that sale certificate issued in its favour is not being registered. Though, on account of deposit of Rs.35,60,650/- in terms of order dated 17.01.2023, there is no impediment in accepting the prayer made on behalf of the petitioner for transfer of release of rights of plot Nos.15, 16 & 17 admittedly purchased by the petitioner in auction, rather, his precise grouse at this stage is that sale
5
certificate is not being registered. Though, reply filed by Deputy Commissioner, Sirmaur at Nahan, Himachal Pradesh, suggests that as per provision of Section 17(2)(xii) of the Registration Act, 1908, sale certificate is not required to be registered and as such, there is no question of charging of stamp duty and registration fee, but fact remains that stamp duty is being demanded by the respondents, as is evident from the communication dated 26.11.2024 issued by Member Secretary, Single Window Clearance Agency, Kala Amb, District Sirmaur, Himachal Pradesh.
7. Since it is not in dispute that property in question has been purchased by the petitioner in auction and he has already cleared entire outstanding amount to the tune of Rs.35,60,650/-, there is otherwise no authority, if any, with the respondents to demand stamp duty. Though on one hand, respondents by way of filing reply have submitted that as per provision of Section 17(2)(xii) of the Registration Act, 1908, sale certificate is not required to be registered, but on the other hand, while placing on record communication dated 27.11.2024, as taken note hereinabove, it has been submitted that since no deed for registration has ever been presented before the respondent No.4, there is no question of demanding the stamp duty and registration fee, however, having perused communication dated 03.01.2024 addressed to Principal
6
Secretary, Industries to Government of Himachal Pradesh, by Director of Industries, Himachal Pradesh, this Court finds that permission for transfer of leasehold rights of plot Nos.15, 16 & 17, Industrial Area, Kala Amb, Tehsil Nahan, District Sirmaur, Himachal Pradesh from M/s Lloyd Electric and Engg. Ltd. (Unit-III) to M/s Horizon Bioceuticals Pvt. Ltd. i.e. petitioner herein was accorded on 29.12.2024 pursuant to sale certificate dated 25.12.2022 by the Director, Industries, Himachal Pradesh, under Rule 6.11(b) of Rules regarding Grant of Incentives, Concessions and Facilities for Investment in Himachal Pradesh, 2019 and petitioner-unit has already deposited the unearned premium/processing fee along with due amount of GST, but yet supplementary lease deed in favour of M/s Horizon Bioceuticals Pvt. Ltd. i.e. petitioner-unit has not been executed till date. Since on account of execution of supplementary lease deed, additional stamp duty is being asked by the department, petitioner has approached this Court.
8. Careful perusal of aforesaid communication itself suggests that pursuant to judgment dated 28.03.2023 passed by this Court in CWP No.221 of 2019, titled Mohan Singh Guleria Vs. State of H.P. and Others, no stamp duty can be asked for registration of sale certificate, especially when such property is purchased in auction, but since aforesaid judgment has been laid challenge by
7
respondents/State in Hon'ble Apex Court, prayer made on behalf of the petitioner herein for registration of supplementary deed without there being any stamp duty is being delayed for more than ten months.
9. Clarification as sought by Director, Industries vide communication dated 03.01.2024 is awaited from the office of Principal Secretary, Industries, to the Government of Himachal Pradesh, as a result thereof, great prejudice is being caused to the petitioner. Needless to say, apart from judgment passed by this Court in Mohan Singh Guleria's case (surpa), number of judgments have been passed by this Court as well as Hon'ble Apex Court, specifically clarifying that no stamp duty can be claimed for execution of supplementary deed qua the property purchased/sold in auction proceedings. Reference in this regard is made to recent judgment passed by Hon'ble Apex Court in State of Punjab & Another Vs. M/s Ferrous Alloy Forgings Pvt. Ltd. & Others, Civil Appeal No.12527 of 2024, arising out of SLP(C) No.23347 of 2014. Relevant Paras of afore judgment reads as under:
"15. In Smt. Shanti Devi L. Singh v. Tax Recovery Officer and Others reported in AIR 1991 SC 1880, this Court observed that since the certificate of sale is not a compulsorily registrable document in lieu of Section 17(2)(xii) of the Registration Act, the transfer of title in favour of the auction purchaser would not be vitiated on account of non- registration of the sale certificate.
16. In B. Arvind Kumar v. Govt. Of India and Others reported in (2007) 5 SCC 745, this Court observed that when a property is sold by public auction in pursuance of an order of the court and the bid is
8
accepted and the sale is confirmed by the court in favour of the purchaser, the sale becomes absolute and the title vests in the purchaser. A sale certificate is issued to the purchaser only when the sale becomes absolute. The sale certificate is merely the evidence of such title. It is well settled that when an auction-purchaser derives title on confirmation of sale in his favour, and a sale certificate is issued evidencing such sale and title, no further deed of transfer from the court is contemplated or required. Although in the said case, the sale certificate was registered yet this Court proceeded to observe that a sale certificate issued by a court or an officer authorized by the court, does not require registration. Section 17(2)(xii) of the Registration Act, 1908 specifically provides that a certificate of sale granted to any purchaser of any property sold by a public auction by a civil or revenue officer does not fall under the category of non-testamentary documents which require registration under sub-section (b) and (c) of Section 17(1) of the said Act.
17. The position of law is thus settled that a sale certificate issued to the purchaser in pursuance of the confirmation of an auction sale is merely evidence of such title and does not require registration under Section 17(1) of the Registration Act. It is not the issuance of the sale certificate which transfers the title in favour of the auction purchaser. The title is transferred upon successful completion of the sale and its confirmation by the competent authority after all the objections against the sale have been disposed of.
18. Recently, a three-Judge Bench of this Court in M/s Esjaypee Impex Private Limited v. The Asst. General Manager and Authorized Officer Canara Bank reported in (2021) 11 SCC 537 observed that the mandate of law that flows from a combined reading of Sections 17(2)
(xii) and 89(4) of the Registration Act respectively is that the auction purchaser is entitled to receive the original sale certificate and a copy of the same is required to be forwarded to the Sub- Registrar for the purpose of filing in Book 1 as per the Registration Act.
19. In Inspector General of Registration and Another v. G. Madhurambal and Another reported in 2022 SCC Online SC 2079, a two-Judge Bench of this Court observed that the consistent position of law is that a certificate of sale cannot be regarded as a conveyance subject to stamp duty. The Court further observed that once a direction is issued for the duly validated certificate to be issued to the auction purchaser with a copy forwarded to the registering authorities to be filed in Book I as per Section 89 of the Registration Act, it has the same effect as registration and requirement of any further action is obviated.
20. The position of law discussed above makes it clear that sale certificate issued by the authorised officer is not compulsorily registrable. Mere filing under Section 89(4) of the Registration Act itself is sufficient when a copy of the sale certificate is forwarded by the authorised officer to the registering authority. However, a perusal of Articles 18 and 23 respectively of the first schedule to the Stamp Act
9
respectively makes it clear that when the auction purchaser presents the original sale certificate for registration, it would attract stamp duty in accordance with the said Articles. As long as the sale certificate remains as it is, it is not compulsorily registrable. It is only when the auction purchaser uses the certificate for some other purpose that the requirement of payment of stamp duty, etc. would arise.
21. We also do not find any force in the contention of the appellant that the High Court should not have exercised its writ jurisdiction under Article 226 as Respondent no. 1 had an alternate efficacious remedy of filing an appeal against the order of the Company Judge in pursuance of which directions came to be passed by the Registrar. This Court in Radha Krishan Industries v. State of H.P. reported in (2021) 6 SCC 771 observed that an alternate remedy by itself does not divest the High Court of its powers under Article 226 of the Constitution in an appropriate case though ordinarily, a writ petition should not be entertained when an efficacious alternate remedy is provided by law. It was held that when a right is created by a statute, which itself prescribes the remedy or procedure for enforcing the right or liability, resort must be had to that particular statutory remedy before invoking the discretionary remedy under Article 226 of the Constitution. However, this Court clarified that this rule of exhaustion of statutory remedies is a rule of policy, convenience and discretion and if the High Court is objectively of the view that the nature of the controversy requires the exercise of its writ jurisdiction, such a view would not readily be interfered with.
10. Consequently, in view of the above, present petition is allowed and respondents herein are directed to execute the supplementary sale deed in favour of the petitioner qua plot Nos.15, 16 & 17, situate in Industrial Area, Kala Amb, Himachal Pradesh, lease hold rights whereof already stand transferred in favour of petitioner vide order dated 29.12.2022 passed by Director, Industries, Government of Himachal Pradesh, under Rule 6.11(b) of Rules regarding Grant of Incentives, Concessions and Facilities for Investment in Himachal Pradesh, 2019. Since request with regard to execution of supplementary sale deed without there being stamp duty
10
is pending consideration before respondents for quite long, this Court hopes and trust that needful shall be done by the respondents expeditiously, preferably within a period of three weeks. Petition stands disposed of, along with pending applications, if any. November 28, 2024. (Sandeep Sharma),
Rajeev Raturi Judge
Alert