- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS v. LATE SHRI ASHOK KUMAR SINGH
High Court of Delhi — W.P.(C) 4835/2017: Govt. of NCT of Delhi & Ors. v. Late Shri Ashok Kumar Singh (Judgment delivered 12.10.2022)
Factual and Procedural Background
This judgment concerns a challenge by the State of Delhi to an order of the Central Administrative Tribunal (Principal Bench) in O.A. No. 2929/2015 directing grant of Compassionate Allowance with retrospective effect to Late Ashok Kumar Singh (the respondent).
Key facts and procedural history (as stated in the opinion):
- Late Ashok Kumar Singh joined the Delhi Police as a Constable in 1970 and was dismissed from service by an order dated 10.07.1992 following a departmental enquiry into misconduct (assaulting a senior officer).
- He challenged the dismissal — O.A. No. 98/1993 before the Tribunal was dismissed; a subsequent writ petition in this Court was dismissed; his Special Leave Petition (SLP (C) 14260/2012) was dismissed by the Supreme Court on merits on 31.08.2012 but the Supreme Court granted liberty to approach authorities to seek Compassionate Allowance in accordance with the rules.
- Pursuant to that liberty, the respondent filed a representation dated 12.09.2012 to the Competent Authority. That representation was rejected by the Deputy Commissioner of Police (order dated 27.11.2012) and an appeal was dismissed on 02.01.2013.
- The respondent challenged those rejections in O.A. No. 603/2013 before the Tribunal; the Tribunal directed fresh consideration on 21.10.2013.
- On reconsideration, the Competent Authority granted Compassionate Allowance by order dated 05.09.2014, effective from 05.09.2014.
- The respondent sought arrears from 10.07.1992 to 04.09.2014 by representation dated 05.01.2015; this was rejected on 12.06.2015.
- O.A. No. 2929/2015 challenged that rejection; the Tribunal allowed the O.A. by order dated 17.01.2017 directing grant of Compassionate Allowance with effect from the date of dismissal (10.07.1992).
- The respondent, Late Ashok Kumar Singh, died on 01.12.2015; his wife (Ms. Malti Devi) passed away on 29.09.2017. The litigation was continued by their legal representatives (three married daughters).
- The petitioners (Government of NCT of Delhi & Ors.) challenged the Tribunal's order in W.P.(C) 4835/2017. The High Court delivered the impugned judgment on 12.10.2022.
- Advocates recorded in the opinion: For petitioners — Mr. Anuj Aggarwal, ASC, GNCTD; For the respondent — Mr. S. Maini, Advocate. Coram: Hon'ble Mr. Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva and Hon'ble Mr. Justice Tushar Rao Gedela.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Tribunal was correct in directing grant of Compassionate Allowance with retrospective effect from the date of dismissal (10.07.1992).
- Whether Rule 41 of the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972 prescribes any particular date (such as date of dismissal) from which Compassionate Allowance must be given, or whether the date of grant is within the discretion of the Competent Authority.
- Whether Compassionate Allowance is a vested right or whether an individual (or family) can claim retrospective payment / parity in date of grant as a matter of right.
- How the provisions governing family pension (Rule 54(6) of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, as amended) affect entitlement to Compassionate Allowance arrears for family members (in particular married daughters and the widow) in the factual matrix of this case.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments (Government of NCT of Delhi & Ors.)
- Rule 41 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 does not mandate that Compassionate Allowance be given from the date of dismissal or any particular date; the matter of grant (and the date from which it is given) lies in the discretion of the Competent Authority and depends on its subjective satisfaction in each case.
- There is no vested right in the individual to claim Compassionate Allowance or parity as to the date of grant; the allowance is discretionary and cannot be claimed as of right.
- Compassionate Allowance is intended to enable the family to tide over an immediate or sudden financial crisis; a long delay (here, 22 years between dismissal and grant) and the subsequent death of the employee and his wife, combined with the daughters being married, militates against awarding retrospective arrears to date of dismissal.
- Relied upon administrative guidance (G.I., F.D., Office Memo. No. 3(2)-R-II/40 dated 22.04.1940) to emphasise that poverty is not an essential condition precedent and to support the view that grant is discretionary.
- Relied on the Kerala High Court decision in V. Kesavan Nair v. Union of India & Ors. (WA No. 2210 of 2019, dated 18.05.2021) to submit that grant of Compassionate Allowance is a matter of absolute discretion and cannot be claimed from the date of dismissal as a matter of right.
- Argued that the Supreme Court's decision in Mahinder Dutt Sharma did not prescribe that Compassionate Allowance must be given from any particular date; Rule 41 leaves such matters to the Competent Authority.
Respondent's Arguments (Legal Representatives of Late Ashok Kumar Singh)
- Supported the impugned judgment of the Tribunal directing retrospective grant from 10.07.1992.
- Relied on the Supreme Court judgment in Mahinder Dutt Sharma and on Ex. ASI Shadi Ram v. Government of NCT of Delhi & Ors. (W.P.(C) 5544/2007, order dated 22.02.2008) in support of grant of Compassionate Allowance.
- Argued that although Rule 41 confers discretion on the Competent Authority, the proviso to sub-rule (1) is an exception to the ordinary rule that dismissal or removal forfeits pension and gratuity; Compassionate Allowance is calculated with reference to pension/gratuity and, being akin to pension, may properly be granted from the date of dismissal or removal in appropriate cases.
- Emphasised the respondent's service record: prior 6 years in the Indian Army and about 21 years 7 months in Delhi Police (cumulatively approximately 28 years), absence of charges of bribery/corruption or moral turpitude, promotions up to ASI, and participation in the 1965 Indo-Pak War — factors relied on to show deserving special consideration.
- Highlighted family circumstances (ill-health of respondent and wife and the lack of a carer) as relevant considerations for compassionate relief.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court in this Opinion |
|---|---|---|
| Mahinder Dutt Sharma v. Union of India & Ors., (2014) 11 SCC 684 | Guidelines (notably para 14) for evaluating claims for Compassionate Allowance; concept of a "window for hope" and "deserving of special consideration" — illustrative (non-exhaustive) categories and guidance on what may disentitle an employee. | The Court treated the guidelines as authoritative "guiding principles" to be considered when examining requests for Compassionate Allowance but stressed they are not exhaustive; applied the guidance to the limited issue before it (the date from which allowance should be paid) and observed that the discretion under Rule 41 is subject to judicial review in light of these principles. |
| Ex. ASI Shadi Ram v. Government of NCT of Delhi & Ors., W.P.(C) 5544/2007 (order dated 22.02.2008) | The opinion records that the respondent relied on this judgment; the specific principle relied upon from this judgment is not set out in detail in the provided opinion. | The Court noted reliance on this judgment by the respondent's counsel; the opinion does not elaborate the judgment's content or further apply specific principles from it in its reasoning. |
| V. Kesavan Nair v. Union of India & Ors., WA No. 2210 of 2019 (Kerala High Court, 18.05.2021) | Held that grant of Compassionate Allowance is an exercise of discretion and that a government employee is precluded from claiming Compassionate Allowance from the date of dismissal or removal as a matter of right. | The Court held the petitioners' reliance on this decision to be misplaced insofar as it was urged to deny any possibility of awarding compassionate allowance from the date of dismissal. The Court accepted the proposition that Compassionate Allowance is not a matter of right, but explained that, because Compassionate Allowance is akin to pension, it may, depending on facts, be awarded from the date of dismissal. |
| State of H.P. & Ors. v. Naresh Lal, LPA No. 333/2010 (High Court of Himachal Pradesh, 01.12.2015) | The Division Bench referred to Government of India's Decision No. 2 dated 23.04.1977 under Rule 41 and concluded that Compassionate Allowance is "one of the various kinds of pension" enumerated in the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972. | The Court relied on this decision to support the view that Compassionate Allowance is akin to pension. However, the Court in the present case also emphasised that, unlike pension (which is a matter of right), Compassionate Allowance remains discretionary and the exercise of that discretion as to the date of grant is open to judicial review. |
| Government of India, M.F., O.M. No. F.14(3)-E.V(A) 176 dated 23.04.1977 (Decision No. 2) | Clarifies that Compassionate Allowance under Rule 41 is one of the kinds of pension and that CCS (Commutation of Pension) Rules, 1981, would apply to Compassionate Allowance in the same manner as other kinds of pension. | The Court relied on this O.M. to reinforce the conclusion that Compassionate Allowance is akin to pension and to explain why sub-rule (6) of Rule 41 (which relates to minimum pension) supports that view. |
| G.I., F.D., Office Memo. No. 3(2)-R-II/40 dated 22.04.1940 | Administrative guiding principles for grant of Compassionate Allowance; cited by petitioners to show that poverty is not an essential prerequisite for grant. | The Court recorded that the petitioners relied on this Office Memo to buttress their arguments; the opinion notes the reliance but does not adopt it as the sole basis of its decision. |
| Shiksha v. Union of India & Ors., W.P.(C) 7067/2019 (coordinate bench order dated 04.07.2022) | Coordinate bench granted Compassionate Allowance from the date of filing of the writ petition in that case. | The Court considered this coordinate-bench order and, by analogy, deemed it appropriate in the present facts to award Compassionate Allowance from the date of submission of the respondent's representation (12.09.2012) rather than from the date of dismissal (10.07.1992). |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court's analytical approach tracked these steps and legal principles (as set out in the opinion):
- Examination of Rule 41. The Court reproduced Rule 41 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 and noted its key features: it confers discretion on the Competent Authority to sanction Compassionate Allowance in deserving cases; the authority must examine each case on its merits; factors to be considered include the nature of misconduct, the service rendered, and in exceptional circumstances family dependency and other relevant factors; sub-rule (2) contemplates an outer time-frame for decision; sub-rule (6) requires that Compassionate Allowance shall not be less than the minimum pension under Rule 44.
- Nature of Compassionate Allowance — akin to pension but discretionary. From a plain reading of Rule 41 and sub-rule (6), and by reference to the Government of India decision dated 23.04.1977 (Decision No. 2), the Court concluded that Compassionate Allowance is calculated with reference to pension/gratuity and is therefore akin to pension. At the same time, the Court emphasised that Compassionate Allowance is granted by discretion of the Competent Authority and is not an absolute right like ordinary pension; therefore the Competent Authority's discretion (including on the date from which allowance may be effective) remains, but is amenable to judicial review.
- Application of Supreme Court guidance (Mahinder Dutt Sharma). The Court quoted para 14 of the Supreme Court's judgment in Mahinder Dutt Sharma and treated the illustrations in that decision as guiding principles to be considered when deciding claims under Rule 41; those principles are not exhaustive but inform judicial review of discretion under Rule 41.
- Scope of the question before the Court. The Court limited the present question to whether the Tribunal was correct in granting Compassionate Allowance retrospectively from the date of dismissal (10.07.1992). It noted that the Competent Authority had in fact reconsidered the matter and had granted Compassionate Allowance effective from 05.09.2014.
- Consideration of relevant authorities and distinctions. The Court observed that the petitioners' reliance on the Kerala High Court judgment in V. Kesavan Nair (which emphasised that Compassionate Allowance is a matter of discretion and cannot be claimed as of right) was misplaced to the extent it was urged to deny any possible retrospective grant: the Court explained that, because Compassionate Allowance is akin to pension, it may, in certain cases and on the facts, be granted from the date of dismissal, though the grant remains discretionary and subject to judicial review.
- Choice of effective date for grant in the present facts. The respondent had filed a representation on 12.09.2012 following the Supreme Court's liberty granted in its order dated 31.08.2012. The Court noted a coordinate-bench decision in Shiksha (W.P.(C) 7067/2019) which granted Compassionate Allowance from the date of filing; having regard to that decision and to the chronology in the instant case, the Court deemed it appropriate to grant Compassionate Allowance to the deceased respondent with effect from 12.09.2012 (the date of the representation), rather than from the date of dismissal (10.07.1992).
- Application of family-pension rules (Rule 54(6)). Treating Compassionate Allowance as akin to pension, the Court applied the pre-amended and amended formulations of Rule 54(6) (which govern the period for which family pension is payable) to the facts: because the three daughters were married at the time the O.A. was filed (August 2015) they would not be entitled to continuation of the Compassionate Allowance beyond the death of their mother (Ms. Malti Devi) on 29.09.2017. The Court therefore limited entitlement to the period up to 29.09.2017.
- Practical relief ordered. The Court modified the Tribunal's order and directed the petitioners to calculate Compassionate Allowance from 12.09.2012 up to 29.09.2017 at the rate specified in the Competent Authority's order dated 05.09.2014, to pay the arrears jointly to the three daughters (named in the judgment), and to pay interest on the arrears in accordance with the Pension Rules. The exercise was directed to be completed within six weeks. The petition was disposed of in these terms with no orders as to costs.
Holding and Implications
Core Holding:
The writ petition was disposed of with modification of the Tribunal's order: Compassionate Allowance shall be calculated and paid with effect from 12.09.2012 (the date of the respondent's representation) up to 29.09.2017 (date of death of the widow), at the rate specified in the Competent Authority's order dated 05.09.2014, and the arrears (with interest in accordance with the Pension Rules) shall be released jointly to the respondent's three daughters. The calculation and release shall be completed within six weeks. No orders as to costs.
Direct consequences for the parties (as stated in the opinion):
- The petitioners (Government of NCT of Delhi & Ors.) are directed to compute and pay Compassionate Allowance arrears for the period 12.09.2012 to 29.09.2017 at the rate specified in the 05.09.2014 Competent Authority order, together with interest as per the Pension Rules, to the three daughters (Ms. Vandana, Ms. Archana Gupta and Ms. Aarti Arora).
- The calculation and disbursement must be completed within six weeks from the date of the judgment (12.10.2022).
- No costs were awarded.
Broader legal implications (as articulated by the Court in this opinion):
- The exercise under Rule 41 is discretionary and based on the subjective satisfaction of the Competent Authority; it is open to judicial review guided by the principles in Mahinder Dutt Sharma.
- Compassionate Allowance is akin to pension (supported by the Government O.M. dated 23.04.1977 and the reasoning in State of H.P. v. Naresh Lal), which informs how it may be quantified and treated for purposes such as minimum pension and commutation rules.
- Although Rule 41 does not specify any particular date from which Compassionate Allowance must be made effective, in appropriate cases (depending on the facts and the reasoned exercise of discretion) it may be granted from the date of dismissal/removal; such decisions remain subject to judicial review.
- The illustrative factors mentioned in Mahinder Dutt Sharma are guiding considerations but not exhaustive; each case requires fact-sensitive application of Rule 41's discretion.
Final disposition (as reported in the opinion): Petition disposed of in the terms set out above (judgment dated 12.10.2022).
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
% Judgment reserved on : 01.09.2022 Judgment delivered on : 12.10.2022 + W.P.(C) 4835/2017 & CM APPL. 20858/2017 GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS. ..... Petitioners
versus
LATE SHRI ASHOK KUMAR SINGH ..... Respondent
Advocates who appeared in this case:
For the Petitioners : Mr. Anuj Aggarwal, ASC, GNCTD. For the Respondent : Mr. S. Maini, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV SACHDEVA HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TUSHAR RAO GEDELA
JUDGMENT
TUSHAR RAO GEDELA, J.
1. In the present case, the State of Delhi, as the petitioners assails the order dated 17.01.2017 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench (hereinafter referred to as 'Tribunal') in O.A. No. 2929/2015, whereby the Tribunal had allowed compassionate allowance with retrospective effect, that is, from the date of dismissal i.e., 10.07.1992 to the deceased respondent Late Ashok Kumar Singh (hereinafter referred to as 'respondent' which also includes his LRs.) Ex-ASI (Ministerial) who unfortunately
1
expired on 01.12.2015 and is now being represented by his Legal Representatives.
2. The present case is one of the many rounds of litigation that the respondent faced.
3. Shorn of all the unnecessary details, the facts germane to decide the present lis are being referred to hereunder.
4. The respondent, Late Ashok Kumar Singh had joined the Delhi Police as a Constable in the year 1970. In the year 1992, due to the acts of misconduct, premised on the basis of assaulting senior officer, an enquiry was held and consequent thereto, the respondent was dismissed from service vide order dated 10.07.1992.
5. The said dismissal was challenged by him before the Tribunal, which too dismissed the said O.A. No. 98/1993 filed by him. Subsequent thereto, the writ petition filed by him before this Court also had been dismissed and the Special Leave Petition, which he preferred, bearing SLP (C) 14260/2012, too was dismissed by the Supreme Court on merits vide order dated 31.08.2012. However, while dismissing the said SLP, the Supreme Court granted liberty to the respondent to approach the authorities and seek Compassionate Allowance in accordance with the rules.
6. Consequent to the liberty so granted by the Supreme Court vide order 31.08.2012, the respondent filed a representation dated 12.09.2012 with the Competent Authority of the petitioner.
2
7. The aforesaid representation was rejected by the Competent Authority i.e., the Deputy Commissioner of Police, 1stBn., DAP, Delhi vide the order dated 27.11.2012. On an appeal thereto, the Appellate Authority, vide the order dated 02.01.2013 upheld the rejection order and dismissed the appeal.
8. The respondent preferred an O.A. No. 603/2013 before the Tribunal challenging the orders dated 27.11.2012 and 02.01.2013 rejecting his representation seeking Compassionate Allowance. The Tribunal vide the order dated 21.10.2013, directed the petitioner herein to consider the representation dated 12.09.2012 afresh.
9. In compliance of the order dated 21.10.2013 of the Tribunal, the Competent Authority after re-considering the said representation, granted Compassionate Allowance to the respondent vide its order dated 05.09.2014 which, was made effective from the date of the order itself i.e., 05.09.2014.
10. Not being satisfied with the grant of Compassionate Allowance w.e.f., 05.09.2014, the respondent submitted a representation on 05.01.2015 to the Competent Authority seeking arrears w.e.f., 10.07.1992 to 04.09.2014. However, this representation was rejected vide order dated 12.06.2015 by the Competent Authority.
11. Consequent upon the said rejection of the representation requesting for Compassionate Allowance w.e.f., 10.07.1992, the respondent preferred O.A. No. 2929/2015 before the Tribunal.
3
Finding favour with the contentions put forth by the respondent, and considering the judgments on Compassionate Allowance, the Tribunal, vide order dated 17.01.2017, directed the petitioners herein to grant Compassionate Allowance from the date of dismissal i.e.,
10.07.1992.
12. It is pertinent to note that during the pendency of O.A. No. 2929/2015, the respondent Ashok Kumar Singh had left for his heavenly abode on 01.12.2015. Subsequently, the O.A. was pursued by the wife of the respondent, namely, Ms. Malti Devi. Unfortunately, Ms. Malti Devi, wife of respondent also left for her heavenly abode on 29.09.2017 leaving behind her, three married daughters.
13. The order dated 17.01.2017 in O.A. 2929/2015 passed by the Tribunal was challenged by the petitioners before this Court in the present writ petition, primarily on the ground that Rule 41 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 does not mandate that Compassionate Allowance must be given with effect from the date of the dismissal of the government employee or from any particular date, and it is entirely the discretion of the Competent Authority to allow or disallow such request based on subjective satisfaction while considering the facts and circumstances of each individual case.
14. Another ground raised by the petitioners herein is that there is no vested right nor can an individual seek parity in respect of, firstly, the grant of Compassionate Allowance, secondly, the date from which such Allowance may be granted. Further, it was also urged that
4
Compassionate Allowance is granted in order to enable the family of the Retired/ deceased employee to tide over an immediate or sudden financial crisis.
15. The petitioners also rely upon the Guiding Principles for grant of Compassionate Allowance issued by the Government of India vide G.I., F.D., Office Memo. No. 3(2)-R-II/40 dated 22.04.1940, to buttress the issue that poverty is not an essential condition precedent to the grant of Compassionate Allowance. The petitioners also rely upon judgment dated 18.05.2021 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Kerala in the matter titled 'V. Kesavan Nair v. Union of India & Ors.', bearing WA No. 2210 of 2019 to submit that the grant of Compassionate Allowance is an absolute discretion and the government employee is precluded from claiming such allowance from the date of dismissal or removal, as a matter of right.
16. Mr. Anuj Aggarwal, learned counsel for the petitioners submitted arguments on the basis of the afore-stated grounds and while referring to the judgment of the Supreme Court in 'Ct. Mahinder Dutt Sharma v. Union of India & Ors.' [(2014) 11 SCC
684] urged that the said judgment did not specify that the Compassionate Allowance ought to be given from a particular date. He further submitted that Rule 41 also does not mandate that Compassionate Allowance ought to be given from the date of dismissal or any particular date and this is left entirely to the discretion of the Sanctioning/ Competent Authority.
5
17. Learned counsel for the petitioner also submitted that Compassionate Allowance is granted in order to enable the family of the Retired/ deceased employee to tide over the sudden financial crisis. Referring to the facts in the present case, learned counsel submits that the dismissal of respondent took place 22 years before the order of grant of Compassionate Allowance in the year 2014 coupled with the fact that the respondent and his wife had passed away during the pendency of the present matter and having regard to the admission of the respondent that all the three daughters were married by the time the said O.A. was filed and thus, this exercise may be in futility.
18. Per contra, Mr. S. Maini, learned counsel for the respondent, who is also appearing for the LRs of Late Ashok Kumar Singh and Ms. Malti Devi, reiterated the stand taken before the Tribunal and supported the impugned judgment of the Tribunal.
19. Learned counsel for the respondent relied upon the judgments of Mahinder Dutt Sharma (supra) rendered by the Supreme Court and
Ex. ASI Shadi Ram v. Government of NCT of Delhi & Ors., rendered on 22.02.2008 by a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in W.P.(C) 5544/2007.
20. Learned counsel for respondent also submits that Rule 41 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, though is a discretion of the Competent Authority, based on subjective satisfaction, contemplates Compassionate Allowance which ought to be granted from the date of
6
dismissal or removal of the government employee in view of the fact that it is in the nature of an exception from the Ordinary Rule that a government employee, who is dismissed or removed from service, forfeits his pension and gratuity and thus, Compassionate Allowance should be granted from the date of dismissal/ removal from service.
21. He further submitted that the respondent had served in the Indian Army for 6 years before rendering service in the Delhi Police for about 21 years and 7 months, totaling to approximately 28 years in all. He further submits that there are no charges of bribery, corruption or moral turpitude against the respondent and that he joined as a Constable and earned promotions to the rank of ASI before his dismissal. It was further urged that the respondent while in the service of Indian Army had also participated in the Indo-Pak War of the year 1965 at the border areas. Lastly, he submits that the respondent was blessed with three daughters, who are married and there was no one to look after the respondent and his wife who were suffering from various health issues.
22. We have heard both the counsel and considered the facts arising in the present case, the grounds urged as well as the judgments relied upon by the parties and are of the considered opinion that the Order of the Tribunal granting Compassionate Allowance with retrospective effect from the date of the dismissal i.e., 10.07.1992 needs modification.
7
23. Before adverting to the reasons, it would be relevant to consider the provisions of Rule 41 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, which is extracted hereunder :
"RULE 41 - CCS PENSION RULES, 1972
41. Compassionate Allowance - (1) A Government servant who is dismissed or removed from service shall forfeit his pension and gratuity:
Provided that the authority competent to dismiss or remove him from service may, if the case is deserving of special consideration, sanction a compassionate allowance not exceeding two - thirds of pension or gratuity or both which would have been admissible to him if he had retired on superannuation pension.
(2) The competent authority shall, either on its own or after taking into consideration the representation of the Government servant, if any, examine whether any compassionate allowance is to be granted and take a decision in this regard in accordance with the proviso to sub-rule (1) not later than three months after the date of issue of the order imposing the penalty of dismissal or removal from service.
(3) The competent authority shall consider,-
(a) each case of dismissal and removal from service on its merit to decide whether the case deserves of special consideration for sanction of a compassionate allowance and, if so, the quantum thereof.
(b) the actual misconduct which occasioned the penalty of dismissal or removal from service and the kind of service rendered by the Government servant.
(c) in exceptional circumstances, factors like family members dependent on the Government servant along with other relevant factors.
(4) Where an order imposing the penalty of dismissal or removal from service was issued before the date of commencement of these rules and the competent authority, at that time, did not examine or decide whether or not any compassionate allowance was to be granted in that case, that authority shall take a decision in this regard not later than six months from the date of commencement of
8
these rules.
(5) No compassionate allowance shall be sanctioned after the expiry of the aforesaid period of six months, to a Government servant on whom a penalty of dismissal or removal from service was imposed before the date of commencement of these rules.
(6) A compassionate allowance sanctioned under the proviso to sub- rule (1) shall not be less than the amount of minimum pension under rule 44."
A plain reading of the provisions of Rule 41 bring to fore the manifold intentions of the executive while enacting Rule 41, which are, that it is a discretion of the Competent Authority; that the consideration is on the subjective satisfaction of the Competent Authority; that the competent Authority is required to consider whether the case deserves of special consideration, if so, the quantum thereof; the misconduct of the government employee and in exceptional circumstances the family members dependent on such government employee and other relevant factors.
24. From a reading of Rule 41, it is manifest that the proviso to sub Rule 1 of Rule 41 is an exception carved out from the ordinary rule that a government servant, who is dismissed or removed from service, shall forfeit his pension and gratuity. It is also clear that Compassionate Allowance is itself calculated on the basis of pension or gratuity or both, which aspect leads us to conclude that Compassionate Allowance is akin to pension which a government servant ordinarily would have been entitled to had the circumstances of dismissal or removal from service not intervened. The aforesaid
9
view becomes more clearer by looking at Sub Rule 6 of Rule 41 whereby it is stipulated that the Compassionate Allowance shall not be less than the amount of minimum pension under Rule 44. Thus, we have no doubt that Compassionate Allowance under Rule 41 is akin to pension that a Government employee is entitled to.
25. We are fortified in our above view, by the judgment rendered by a Division Bench of the High Court of Himachal Pradesh at Shimla in LPA No. 333/2010 decided on 01.12.2015 titled 'State of H.P. and Ors. v. Naresh Lal.' In that case too, facts as obtaining in the present case were involved. The learned Division Bench in para 7 of its judgment while referring to the Government of India's decision No. 2, dated 23.04.1977 under Rule 41 of the Rules regarding Compassionate Allowance concluded that it is, "one of the various kinds of pension enumerated in the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972". For convenience, para 7 of the aforesaid judgment rendered by the High Court of Himachal Pradesh is extracted hereunder :
"7. We may also refer to Government of India's Decision No. 2, dated 23rd April, 1977, under Rule 41 of the Rules, that the Compassionate Allowance is a pension. It is apt to reproduce Decision No. 2 hereunder:
"2) Commutation of Compassionate Allowance permissible. - A question has been raised whether Government servants drawing Compassionate Allowance under Rule 41 of the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972, are entitled to commute a part of such Compassionate Allowance as in the case of other kinds of pension or not. The matter has been considered and it is clarified that the Compassionate Allowance is one of the various kinds of pensions enumerated in the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, and as such
10
the CCS (Commutation of Pension) Rules, 1981, would apply to the Compassionate Allowance in the same manner as in respect of any other class of pension. [G.I., M.F., O.M. No.F.14(3)-E.V(A) 176, dated the 23rd April, 1977.]"
26. On the basis of the above O.M., the learned Division Bench concluded that since pension is always payable from the date employee ceases to be in the employment and not from any other date, Compassionate Allowance may also be granted from date of dismissal or removal. Though, we are in agreement with the conclusion that the Compassionate Allowance is akin to pension that a Government Employee may be entitled to, but, we are of the view that unlike pension, receipt of which is a matter of right, Compassionate Allowance is not a right and it is at the discretion of the Competent Authority accordingly the discretion as to the date from which it may be granted, would necessarily vest with the Competent Authority granting the same, on a case to case basis. However, it is further clarified that such discretion would obviously be open to judicial review.
27. Insofar as the ratio laid down by the Supreme Court in Mahinder Dutt Sharma (supra) is concerned, it would be pertinent to bear in mind the guidelines laid down by the Supreme Court in para 14 of its judgment while considering case of grant of Compassionate Allowance, which is quoted hereunder:
11
"While evaluating the claim of a dismissed (or removed from service) employee, for the grant of compassionate allowance, the rule postulates a window for hope, "...if the case is deserving of special consideration...". Where the delinquency leading to punishment, falls in one of the five classifications delineated in the foregoing paragraph, it would ordinarily disentitle an employee from such compassionate consideration. An employee who falls in any of the above five categories, would therefore ordinarily not be a deserving employee, for the grant of compassionate allowance. In a situation like this, the deserving special consideration, will have to be momentous. It is not possible to effectively define the term "deserving special consideration" used in Rule 41 of the Pension Rules, 1972. We shall therefore not endeavour any attempt in the said direction. Circumstances deserving special consideration, would ordinarily be unlimited, keeping in mind unlimited variability of human environment. But surely where the delinquency leveled and proved against the punished employee, does not fall in the realm of misdemeanour illustratively categorized in the foregoing paragraph, it would be easier than otherwise, to extend such benefit to the punished employee, of course, subject to availability of factors of compassionate consideration."
In the present case, we are not to examine the various considerations which are illustratively expressed by the Supreme Court in para 13 of its judgment, primarily for the reason that in the case of the respondent, the Competent Authority had in fact, itself taken into consideration all the relevant aspects and had granted Compassionate Allowance, though from the date of the order allowing such allowance.
28. Thus, in the present case, we are only to consider whether the Tribunal was correct in granting Compassionate Allowance to the respondent w.e.f., the date of his dismissal i.e., 10.07.1992.
12
29. The reliance of the petitioner upon the judgment rendered by the Kerala High Court in V. Kesavan Nair (supra) is misplaced for the reason that in that case the learned Division Bench came to the conclusion that the government employee cannot, as a matter of right, claim Compassionate Allowance or that it should be so much or it should be paid w.e.f., the date of dismissal. There is no quarrel with the proposition that the government employee may not claim it as a matter of right, however, keeping in view the fact that we have considered the same as akin to pension, it may be possible to grant the Compassionate Allowance from the date of dismissal/ removal of the government employee as per the facts obtaining in a particular case.
30. In the present case, late Ashok Kumar Singh had applied for Compassionate Allowance on 12.09.2012, in pursuance of the liberty granted by the Supreme Court vide its Order dated 31.08.2012. A coordinate bench of this Court in W.P.(C) 7067/2019 titled as Shiksha vs. Union of India & Ors., vide its order dated 04.07.2022, granted Compassionate Allowance to the Petitioner in that case, from the date of the filing of the aforesaid writ petition. In view of the above, we deem it appropriate that the deceased Respondent would be entitled to Compassionate Allowance w.e.f. 12.09.2012, i.e., the date of the submission of the representation pursuant to the liberty granted by the Supreme Court.
31. From a total consideration of all the facts, circumstances and the various judgments rendered by the Supreme Court as well the
13
High Court of Himachal Pradesh and the Kerala High Court, the following aspects are clear :
(a) The exercise under Rule 41 is discretionary.
(b) Compassionate Allowance is akin to pension. [vide G.I., M.F., O.M. No.F.14(3)-E.V(A) 176, dated the 23rdApril, 1977].
(c) Though no date is mentioned in Rule 41, such allowance may be granted from the date of dismissal, considered on a case to case basis, subject to judicial review.
(d) Illustrations in para 13 of Mahinder Dutt Sharma's case (supra) are guiding principles to be considered at the time of examining request for Compassionate Allowance, but not limited to such illustrations as explained in para 14 of the said judgment.
32. In the present case, a peculiar situation has arisen due to the fact that during the pendency of the O.A. before the Tribunal, the original respondent to the present petition had expired and subsequent to the impugned judgment of the Tribunal, his wife, Ms. Malti Devi also expired on 29.09.2017. It is an admitted case of the respondent that his three daughters were already married by the time the O.A. was filed in the month of August 2015 as averred in para 5.4 of O.A. No. 2929/2015.
33. Having regard to the aforesaid conclusion that Compassionate Allowance is akin to pension, the effect thereof, on the facts obtaining in the present case, has to be considered in terms of Rule 54(6) of the
14
CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, the pre-amended rule 54(6) reads as under :
"Rule 54……
(6) The period from which the family pension is payable shall be as under :
i) in the case of a widow or widower, up to the date of death or re- marriage, whichever is earlier;
ii) in the case of a son, until he attains the age of 25 years; and
iii) in the case of unmarried daughter until she attains the age of 25 years or until she gets married whichever is earlier." Subsequently amended as per the notification dated 08.06.2011:
"(6) The period for which family pension is payable shall be as follows:-
(i) subject to first proviso, in the case of a widow or widower, up to the date of death or re-marriage, whichever is earlier;
(ii) subject to second proviso, in the case of an unmarried son, until he attains the age of twenty-five years or until he gets married or until he starts earning his livelihood, whichever is the earliest;
(iii) subject to second and third provisos, in the case of an unmarried or widowed or divorced daughter, until she gets married or remarried or until she starts earning her livelihood, whichever is earlier (iv)………"
On the plain reading of the aforesaid Rule and applying it to the facts of the present case, it is clear that the daughters, who are already married as on the date of filing of the O.A. No. 2929/2015 would not be entitled to continuation of the Compassionate Allowance beyond the date of death of their mother Ms. Malti Devi, i.e., on 29.09.2017. However, they would jointly be entitled to the arrears of
15
Compassionate Allowance, as allowed vide order dated 05.09.2014 of the Competent Authority, w.e.f., 12.09.2012, the date of submission of representation/ application by the respondent late Ashok Kumar Singh, along with interest in accordance with the Pension Rules. To this extent, we modify the impugned order dated 17.01.2017 passed by the Tribunal in O.A. No. 2929/2015.
34. In view of the above, we direct the petitioners to calculate the Compassionate Allowance w.e.f., 12.09.2012 upto 29.09.2017, at the rate specified in order dated 05.09.2014 and release it to three daughters, Respondent Nos. 1 to 3, namely, Ms. Vandana, Ms. Archana Gupta and Ms. Aarti Arora. The respondent Nos. 1 to 3 would also be entitled to the interest on arrears of such Compassionate Allowance in accordance with the Pension Rules.
35. Said exercise be completed within six weeks.
36. The petition is disposed of, in above terms, with no orders as to costs.
TUSHAR RAO GEDELA, J
SANJEEV SACHDEVA, J
OCTOBER 12, 2022/nd
16
Alert