- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State Of Odisha And Others Petitioner(S) v. Sunanda Mahakuda (S).
Factual and Procedural Background
The State Government of Odisha sought to challenge two orders of the High Court of Orissa: (i) the Single-Judge judgment dated 12-03-2015 in WP(C) No. 7021 of 2004 (Sunanda Mahakuda v. State) and (ii) the Division Bench judgment dated 19-04-2019 in Writ Appeal No. 147 of 2017, which had already dismissed a delayed appeal against the same Single-Judge decision.
Key chronology:
- 12-03-2015 – Single-Judge judgment delivered.
- 27-04-2017 – Review petition dismissed by the High Court.
- Writ appeal filed after a delay of 783 days; ultimately dismissed on 19-04-2019.
- 13-05-2019 – Contempt proceedings initiated before the High Court upon dismissal of the writ appeal.
- The State then filed the present Special Leave Petitions (SLPs) before the Supreme Court with (a) a delay of 1,954 days vis-à-vis the Single-Judge order and (b) a delay of 545 days vis-à-vis the writ-appeal order.
The State simultaneously filed an application for condonation of delay, asserting in a single paragraph that the delays were “neither intentional nor wanton.”
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Supreme Court should condone a delay of 1,954 days (and 545 days, respectively) in filing the Special Leave Petitions against the High Court’s judgments.
- Whether chronic and unexplained governmental delays warrant imposition of costs and personal accountability of erring officers.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners’ (State Government) Arguments
- The delay was unintentional and occurred because successive proceedings (review petition and writ appeal) were pursued before the High Court.
- Denying condonation would cause “irreparable loss and hardship” to the State, whereas no prejudice would be caused to the respondent employees.
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondents’ legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Postmaster General v. Living Media (India) Ltd., (2012) 3 SCC 563 | Technological advances and governmental resources negate the presumption that State delay should invariably be condoned; stricter scrutiny of delay applications. | The Court relied on this precedent to reject the notion that government litigants deserve automatic leeway and to emphasise that limitation laws apply equally to the State. |
| State of M.P. v. Bherulal, (2020) 10 SCC 654 | Characterised habitual delayed filings by the State as “certificate cases” aimed at getting the Supreme Court to put a formal quietus on matters without accountability. | Invoked to label the present SLPs as another “certificate case,” underscoring the perfunctory nature of the condonation request. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court undertook a detailed scrutiny of the State’s conduct and found the delay application to be “casual” and devoid of any “sufficient and cogent” explanation:
- Lack of particulars: No specific dates or reasons were furnished to cover the large periods of inactivity.
- Pattern of governmental neglect: The Court noted a recurring trend of the very same State Government filing matters hopelessly time-barred, apparently assuming that limitation statutes do not apply to it.
- Precedential guidance: Relying on Postmaster General and Bherulal, the Court reiterated that technological advancements and prior warnings eliminate any special indulgence for governmental delay.
- “Certificate case” phenomenon: The filing appeared to be a strategy to obtain a dismissal order from the Supreme Court merely to shield negligent officers from blame.
- Deterrent measures: Given the magnitude of delay and the perfunctory application, the Court deemed it appropriate not only to dismiss the SLPs but also to impose costs and direct personal recovery from responsible officers.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Special Leave Petitions are DISMISSED AS TIME-BARRED. Costs of Rs 25,000 are imposed, payable to the Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Welfare Fund within four weeks, to be recovered from the officers responsible for the delay. A copy of the order is to be placed before the Chief Secretary for compliance; failure will invite consequential action for disobedience.
Implications: The judgment reinforces a zero-tolerance stance toward unexplained governmental delays, labels such filings as “certificate cases,” and mandates personal accountability of erring officers. While setting no new doctrinal precedent, it strengthens the practical deterrent against casual condonation requests by State authorities.
1. The present SLPs have been filed after a delay of 1954 days in respect of the impugned order dated 12-3-2015 WP (C) No. 7021 of 2004 of the learned Single Judge and delay of 545 days qua the order Writ Appeal No. 147 of 2017 in writ appeal. We may notice that the writ appeal itself was preferred after a delay of 783 days and was found not to have been properly explained. We may add that the present special leave petition is filed after contempt proceedings were initiated on 13-5-2019, on dismissal of the writ appeal. Now, it is our chance to scrutinise a little more closely the aforesaid conduct of the State Government.
2. The application for condonation of delay explains the reasons for delay in Para 2 which reads as under:
“2. There is a delay in the special leave petitions filed against the judgment and order dated 12-3-2015 in Sunanda Mahakuda v. State WP (C) No. 7021 of 2004 passed by the Hon'ble High Court of Orissa, Cuttack. Thereafter the petitioners filed review petition before the Hon'ble High Court which were dismissed by the order dated 27-4-2017. Thereafter the petitioners filed writ appeal before the Hon'ble High Court which were also dismissed by order dated 19-4-2019 Writ Appeal No. 147 of 2017. Therefore, there is a delay in the present special leave petitions filed against the orders. The delay is neither intentional nor wanton but for the reasons mentioned above. In case delay is not condoned, the petitioner would be put to irreparable loss and hardship. On the other hand no prejudice whatsoever would be caused to the respondent if delay is condoned. In the interest of justice the delay in refiling be condoned.”
3. A reading of the aforesaid shows that there is no reason much less sufficient and cogent reason assigned to explain the delay and the application has also been preferred in a very casual manner. We may notice that there are number of orders of this State Government alone which we have come across where repeatedly matters are being filed beyond the period of limitation prescribed. We have been repeatedly discouraging such endeavours where the Governments seem to think that they can walk in to the Supreme Court any time they feel without any reference to the period of limitation, as if the statutory Law of Limitation does not exist for them.
4. There is no doubt that these are cases including the present one where the Government machinery has acted in an inefficient manner or it is a deliberate endeavour. In either of the two situations, this Court ought not to come to the rescue of the petitioner. No doubt, some leeway is given for Government inefficiency but with the technological advancement now the judicial view prevalent earlier when such facilities were not available has been over taken by the elucidation of the legal principles in the judgment of this Court in Postmaster General v. Living Media (India) Ltd. (2012) 3 SCC 563 We have discussed these aspects in State of M.P. v. Bherulal (2020) 10 SCC 654 and thus, see no reason to repeat the same again.
5. In the present case, the State Government has not even taken the trouble of citing any reason or excuse nor any dates given in respect of the period for which condonation is sought. The objective of such an exercise has also been elucidated by us in the aforesaid judgment (2020) 10 SCC 654 where we have categorised such cases as “certificate cases”.
6. The object of such cases appears to be to obtain a certificate of dismissal from the Supreme Court to put a quietus to the issue and thus, say nothing could done because the highest Court has dismissed the appeal. It is mere completion of formality to give a quietus to the litigation and save the skin of the officers who may be at fault by not taking action in prescribed time. If the State Government feels that they have suffered losses, then it must fix responsibility on officers concerned for their inaction but that ironically never happens. These matters are preferred on a presumption as if this Court will condone the delay in every case, if the State Government is able to say something on merits.
7. Looking to the period of delay and the casual manner in which the application has been worded, we consider it appropriate to impose costs of Rs 25,000 to be deposited with the Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Welfare Fund. The amount be deposited in four weeks. The amount be recovered from the officers responsible for the delay in filing both the writ appeal and the special leave petition and a certificate of recovery be also filed in this Court within the same period of time.
8. The special leave petition(s) is/are dismissed as time-barred in the terms aforesaid.
9. A copy of this order be placed before the Chief Secretary for compliance making it clear that any non-compliance within time stipulated would invite the consequential action by this Court for disobedience of the directions.
Alert