- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
S. Ramesh v. State
Factual and Procedural Background
Three Criminal Original Petitions (Nos. 6231, 6322 and 6232 of 2018) were filed before the Madras High Court under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, seeking quashing of pending criminal cases (CC No. 1725 of 2013, CC No. 4228 of 2015 and CC No. 6766 of 2014) that arose from FIRs registered in Crime Case Nos. 3752 of 2012 and 1815 of 2015. On 1-3-2018, the High Court allowed these petitions on the basis of a compromise dated 20-2-2018 between the parties and disposed of the matters without examining them on merits.
Respondent 2 later filed Criminal Miscellaneous Petitions (Nos. 6611, 6612 and 6613 of 2018) to recall the orders of 1-3-2018, asserting various factual and legal grounds. By order dated 4-5-2018, the High Court (i) recalled its earlier orders and (ii) simultaneously dismissed the three Criminal Original Petitions. The petitioners appealed to the Supreme Court by way of special leave.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Madras High Court, after recalling its earlier orders allowing the quash petitions, was correct in simultaneously dismissing those petitions without assigning reasons.
- What is the legal effect of an order recalling a prior final order passed under Section 482 CrPC—does it automatically restore the original petitions for decision on merits?
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court, after hearing counsel and reviewing the record, held as follows:
- The High Court acted within its jurisdiction in recalling its earlier orders dated 1-3-2018; the recall was justified on the grounds advanced by Respondent 2, and that portion of the impugned order required no interference.
- However, the High Court erred in simultaneously dismissing the three Criminal Original Petitions. The Court reasoned that once the recall was ordered, the natural legal consequence was that the petitions stood revived and had to be decided on their merits “as if” the earlier orders had never been passed.
- Dismissal of the petitions without any reasoning violated this principle and constituted an illegality warranting correction.
Holding and Implications
Appeals allowed in part. The Supreme Court set aside the portion of the High Court’s order that dismissed Criminal Original Petitions Nos. 6231, 6322 and 6232 of 2018 and restored those petitions to their original numbers. The matters are remanded to the Madras High Court for fresh adjudication on merits in accordance with law.
Implications: The decision clarifies that recalling an order disposing of petitions under Section 482 CrPC restores those petitions for substantive adjudication; a court cannot dismiss them summarily without reason upon recall. No broader precedent was set beyond this procedural clarification.
Abhay Manohar Sapre, J.— Leave granted. These appeals are directed against a common final judgment and order dated 4-5-2018 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Madras in G. Sakthi Saravanan v. S. Arun 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8854 whereby the High Court dismissed the criminal original petitions filed by the appellants herein.
2. It is not necessary to set out the factual matrix of the controversy except to the extent it is necessary for the disposal of these appeals.
3. By separate orders on 1-3-2018 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8924 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8925 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8926 the High Court allowed three Criminal Original Petitions Nos. 6231, 6322 and 6232 of 2018, which were filed under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as “CrPC”) by the appellants herein for quashing of CC No. 1725 of 2013 arising out of FIR in Crime Case No. 3752 of 2012, CC No. 4228 of 2015 arising out of FIR in Crime Case No. 1815 of 2015 and CC No. 6766 of 2014 arising out of FIR in Crime Case No. 3752 of 2012.
4. These orders were passed by the High Court in the light of compromise dated 20-2-2018 said to have been arrived at between the parties. In other words, the High Court did not examine the merits of these three cases in the light of the alleged compromise said to have been arrived at between the parties and accordingly disposed of the same finally.
5. Respondent 2 herein, who was Respondent 2 in the disposed of criminal original petitions mentioned above, filed applications being Criminal Misc. Petitions Nos. 6611, 6612 and 6613 of 2018 praying therein to recall the orders dated 1-3-2018 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8924 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8925 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8926.
6. The recall was sought on various grounds and on several facts. By a common impugned order 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8854, the High Court in detail examined the questions and finding merit in the grounds urged, recalled the orders dated 1-3-2018 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8924 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8925 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8926. However, while doing so, the High Court also dismissed the three criminal original petitions. It is against this order, the petitioners of three criminal original petitions have filed these appeals by way of special leave in this Court.
7. Heard the learned counsel for the parties.
8. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and on perusal of the record of the case, we are inclined to allow these appeals in part and modify the impugned order to the extent indicated hereinbelow.
9. In our considered opinion, though the High Court was right in recalling its earlier orders dated 1-3-2018 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8924 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8925 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8926 passed in three criminal original petitions but committed an error by simultaneously dismissing three Criminal Original Petitions Nos. 6231, 6322 and 6232 of 2018 and that too without assigning any reason.
10. In our considered opinion, the effect of recalling the orders dated 1-3-2018 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8924 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8925 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8926 was that the three criminal original petitions stood restored to their respective numbers for their disposal on merits in accordance with law as if the orders dated 1-3-2018 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8924 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8925 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8926 had not been passed in those cases and that they remained pending for their disposal on merits.
11. The High Court, therefore, after recalling the orders passed on 1-3-2018 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8924 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8925 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8926 should have fixed the three criminal original petitions for their final hearing on merits. Instead of doing that, the High Court, on the one hand, restored the cases and, on the other hand, dismissed them also.
12. This approach of the High Court, in our view, was not legal and hence to that extent, the impugned order of the High Court deserves to be set aside.
13. Coming now to that part of the order, which relates to recalling of three orders passed on 1-3-2018 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8924 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8925 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8926, we find no good ground to interfere in the same.
14. In our opinion, keeping in view the grounds taken by Respondent 2 in the applications for recall of the orders, which found acceptance to the High Court, we find no good ground to interfere in that part of the order on the facts of the case alleged in the applications for recall. In other words, having regard to the facts alleged and grounds taken therein, the recall orders cannot be faulted with.
15. In view of the foregoing discussion, the appeals are allowed in part. The impugned order 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8854 is set aside to the extent it dismissed Criminal Original Petitions Nos. 6231, 6322 and 6232 of 2018.
16. These three cases are now restored to their original numbers. The High Court is requested to decide these three cases on merits in accordance with law.
17. Having formed an opinion to remand the case, we have not considered it necessary to set out the entire factual dispute and nor have gone into its merit. The High Court will, therefore, decide these cases on merits strictly in accordance with law uninfluenced by any observations made in the impugned order 2018 SCC OnLine Mad 8854 and in this order.
Alert