Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Bal Mukund Sharma Alias Balmukund Chaudhry And Others v. State Of Bihar .

Supreme Court Of India
Apr 16, 2019
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Parties Involved:

Facts:

The prosecution's case revolves around an incident involving the informant, Meghu Pandit (PW 2), who, along with his wife, was transporting soil from a gairmajarua land adjacent to their residence for the purpose of making earthen pots. While doing so, they were confronted by a group of approximately fifteen accused individuals. In response to the threat posed by the group, PW 2 and his wife fled towards their home, only to be pursued by the accused.

During this encounter, Brahamdeo Chaudhry allegedly discharged three gunshots into the air, threatening any villager who dared to intervene. Subsequently, PW 2 and his wife sought refuge in their home, barricading the doors. Despite their efforts, the accused attempted to break into the house and set part of it on fire.

The prosecution charged the accused under various sections of the Indian Penal Code (IPC), specifically Sections 302/149 (murder), 436/149 (mischief by fire), and 148 (rioting).

Issues:

1. Whether the remaining nine accused should be convicted under the charges leveled against them.

2. Whether Brahamdeo Chaudhry and Kapildeo can be held liable for the murder of the deceased and for the attempted murder of the injured eyewitnesses.

Evidence:

The evidence presented included testimonies from several eyewitnesses (PWs 1 to 7 and 9). Key points include:

PW 1

(cousin of the deceased) testified to witnessing the informant and his wife being accosted by a mob of 20-25 individuals.

PW 5

(Subhash Sao) claimed to have seen Brahamdeo shoot the deceased and identified Kapildeo as also firing a weapon during the incident, injuring himself and other witnesses.

  • Only PW 1 and PW 3 confirmed witnessing the setting of PW 2's baithak-khana on fire, with PW 1 specifically implicating Mahendra and Babulal in this act.
  • The trial court dismissed PW 4's claim of being shot at as an embellishment.

Findings:

The court found sufficient evidence to hold Brahamdeo Chaudhry responsible for the fatal shooting of the deceased. However, the evidence against Kapildeo was deemed insufficient to conclude his involvement in the murder. The court noted that the common object of the unlawful assembly did not include the murder of the deceased, which is crucial in determining liability under Section 149 IPC.

The court affirmed that the prosecution bears the burden of proving its case beyond a reasonable doubt and found that only Brahamdeo and Kapildeo were liable for the attempted murder of the injured eyewitnesses.

Conclusion:

The appellate court partially allowed the appeals, affirming the conviction of Brahamdeo for murder and the attempted murder of the eyewitnesses, while acquitting the remaining nine accused of all charges. The decision underscores the necessity of clear evidence linking individuals to specific criminal actions within the context of unlawful assembly.

Disposition:

  • Conviction of Brahamdeo Chaudhry for murder and attempted murder upheld.
  • Acquittal of the remaining nine accused on all charges.

Recommendation:

Further analysis of the evidence and the roles of each accused should be conducted to ensure that justice is served and to clarify the responsibilities of individuals within unlawful assemblies.

Show all summary ...

Mohan M. Shantanagoudar, J.— The common judgment dated 23-5-2013 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Patna in Bal Mukund Sharma v. State of Bihar 2013 SCC OnLine Pat 272 confirming the judgment of conviction dated 11-6-1990 and sentence dated 12-6-1990 passed by the 7th Additional Sessions Judge, Bhagalpur is questioned in these appeals.

2. The case of the prosecution in brief is that while the informant, Meghu Pandit, PW 2 was carrying soil that he had dug from a gairmajarua land lying to the north of his house for the purpose of manufacturing earthen pots along with his wife, the fifteen accused accosted them in a group; hence, PW 2 and his wife ran away towards their house out of fear, but were chased even to their house. The accused, Brahamdeo Chaudhry also fired three gunshots in the air, and threatened to kill any villager who came forward. The informant, PW 2 and his wife hid in their house and closed the doors, whereafter the aforesaid members of the unlawful assembly unsuccessfully tried to enter PW 2's house by breaking the doors and also set part of it on fire.

3. It is further alleged that all the accused caught hold of PW 2's nephew, Ambika Pandit, who was working in his own field nearby, and dragged him away to another field, where the accused Brahamdeo Chaudhry shot Ambika Pandit with a gun, who died on the spot. According to the informant, he had seen the occurrence after coming out of his house. After the deceased was shot, the villagers raised a hue and cry and rushed to his field, upon which the accused Brahamdeo Chaudhry and Kapildeo Chaudhry opened fire, on account of which Shanti Devi, Subhash Sao, Wakil Yadav and Kokai Sao also suffered injuries.

4. The courts below convicted the accused Brahamdeo and Kapildeo Chaudhry for the offences under Sections 302 and 302/149 of the Penal Code, 1860 (in short “IPC”) respectively, and further under Sections 436/149, 148 and 307/34 IPC, and Section 27 of the Arms Act. The rest of the accused were convicted under Sections 302/149, 436/149 and 148 IPC. Additionally, the accused Anil Chaudhry, Bhavesh Chaudhry, Babulal Chaudhry and Mahendra Rai were convicted under Sections 323/34 IPC.

5. PWs 1 to 7 and 9 are the eyewitnesses to the incident in question, out of which PWs 3, 4, 5 and 6 are the injured eyewitnesses. Among them, PWs 3 and 6 sustained only simple injuries, whereas PWs 4 and 5 sustained both simple and grievous injuries. Though PW 2, the informant was chased by the unlawful assembly, leading him to hide along with his wife in his home, no injury was sustained by him or his wife.

6. Shri Arvind Verma, learned Senior Advocate taking us through the material on record, contended that the trial court and the High Court were not justified in convicting all the fifteen accused for the offences punishable under Section 302 IPC with the help of Section 149 IPC. The argument of the learned Senior Counsel for the accused was that at the most the trial court and the High Court could have convicted the accused Brahamdeo Chaudhry who shot the deceased to death, under Section 302 IPC and five of the accused, namely, Mahendra Rai, Babulal Chaudhry, Bhavesh Chaudhry, Kapildeo Chaudhry and Anil Chaudhry, for other offences that they committed, inasmuch as common object for the offence of murder was not proved against them. It was further argued that the remaining nine accused should not have been convicted for any of the charges levelled against them. This was because there was no credible evidence in this respect, no specific overt act whatsoever had been attributed to them, and it was highly likely that they had been implicated only by virtue of being close relatives of the accused Brahamdeo Chaudhry.

7. On the other hand, Shri Devashish Bharukha, learned counsel appearing for the State argued in support of the judgments of the trial court and the High Court.

8. We have carefully considered the evidence of PWs 1 to 7 and 9, who were the eyewitnesses to the incident. Rather than quote them in their entirety, we find it necessary to discuss only those aspects of their respective depositions that pertain to the roles attributed to the various accused.

9. PW 1, a cousin of the deceased, deposed to seeing the informant PW 2 and his wife get accosted by a mob of 20-25 persons. On being threatened, these two persons ran away and hid within their house. The accused unsuccessfully tried to force their way in, and the accused Mahendra and Babulal set fire to the baithak-khana of PW 2's house. The accused then dragged away the deceased from his field to that of the accused Brahamdeo Chaudhry, who shot the deceased, causing his death. Several villagers thereafter assembled in the field of the deceased, seeing which the accused Brahamdeo and Kapildeo opened fire on the villagers, injuring PW 3, Shanti Devi; PW 5, Subhash Sao and PW 6, Wakil Yadav. PW 1 also deposed that PW 4, Kokai Sao was shot at when he ran to the spot, thinking that his son Subhash had been killed, and was assaulted by the accused by lathi, bhala, sword and gun.

10. PW 2, the informant, also corroborated the above version. In particular, he affirmed that the accused Brahamdeo had shot the deceased, causing his death, and that when the accused Brahamdeo and Kapildeo opened fire on the villagers, PWs 3, 5 and 6 got injured. He also deposed that subsequently, PW 4 Kokai Sao was assaulted by gun, bat, sword, bhala and lathi.

11. PW 7, Jugli Devi, the informant's wife, also deposed to seeing the accused Brahamdeo Chaudhry shoot the deceased, causing his death.

12. PWs 3 to 6 are the injured eyewitnesses.

13. PW 3, Shanti Devi, the cousin sister-in-law of the deceased also deposed in a similar manner as the above eyewitnesses. She too deposed that the deceased was killed by the accused Brahamdeo with a gunshot, and corroborated the aspect of firing upon the villagers, in which PW 5, PW 6 and PW 3 herself got injured.

14. PW 4 is Kokai Sao, the father of PW 5, Subhash Sao. He deposed that he had reached the spot of the incident while the accused were dealing with the body of the deceased, and had accosted them thinking that the body was of his son. At this point, the accused Brahamdeo fired upon PW 4 but missed. He also deposed that the accused Anil and Bhavesh attacked PW 4 with bhalas, the accused Babulal attacked him with a sword, and the accused Mahendra Rai assaulted him with a lathi.

15. PW 5, Subhash Sao, PW 4's son, deposed that he saw the deceased being shot by the accused Brahamdeo with a gun and by the accused Kapildeo with a pistol, and that he got injured along with PW 6 and PW 3 in the subsequent firing upon the villagers. He also deposed to seeing the accused Brahamdeo fire at his father, and the other members of the mob assault his father with lathis, bhalas, and swords. However, in his cross-examination he stated that he did not remember who in particular had attacked his father, and with what weapon, though he did affirm that his father had received a bullet injury.

16. PW 6, Wakil Yadav, too lived in the same locality as the deceased. He testified to seeing the accused Brahamdeo and Kapildeo fire at the deceased, and deposed that he, along with PWs 3 and 5, was wounded in the subsequent firing by these two accused.

17. It may also be noted that out of the six eyewitnesses, only PW 1 and PW 3 actually witnessed PW 2's baithak-khana being set on fire, out of which only PW 1 specifically deposed that it was the accused Mahendra and Babulal who started the fire.

18. In addition, PW 1 deposed to the presence of the accused Brahamdeo with a gun, the accused Kapildeo with a pistol, the accused Babulal and Ashok Rai with swords, the accused Sanjay, Pankaj, Sunil, Kishore, Mahendra Rai, Sadanand and Mani with lathis, and the accused Anil, Balmukund, Manoj, and Bhavesh with bhalas. PWs 2, 4 and 9 supported the testimony of PW 1 as to which the accused were present at the time of the incident, and bore which weapon. PW 4, however, did not name the accused Sunil and Mani, and PW 9 did not name the accused Balmukund or attribute specific weapons to the accused Sunil and Sanjay. PW 3 identified only the accused Brahamdeo and Kapildeo as being present at the spot of the incident, and could not speak as to the presence of any other accused in particular.

19. PWs 5 and 7 generally spoke of the presence of several of the accused, without attributing any specific weapon to any of them, apart from attributing a gun and pistol as being carried by the accused Brahamdeo and Kapildeo respectively. PW 6, too, named several accused, and generally stated that all the accused except for Brahamdeo and Kapildeo were equipped with bhalas, lathis and swords. It may be noted that PW 10, the village watchman, deposed to seeing a mob of 30-35 persons, out of whom he identified the accused Brahamdeo as being present with a gun, Kapildeo with a pistol, and the accused Babulal, Pankaj, Sanjay, Mahendra and Anil Chaudhry only.

20. Clearly, apart from PW 4, who did not witness the incident of firing upon the deceased or the villagers, the eyewitnesses have consistently deposed that the accused Brahamdeo shot the deceased, and he along with the accused Kapildeo fired upon the villagers, injuring PWs 3 to 6. PWs 4 and 5 additionally stated that the accused Kapildeo too shot the deceased. PW 4 testified to being attacked by the accused Mahendra Rai with a lathi, by the accused Babulal with a sword, and by the accused Bhavesh and Anil with bhalas, and was fired upon but missed by the accused Brahamdeo. PWs 2 and 5 also generally deposed that PW 4 was assaulted with various weapons, without naming any accused in particular. PW 5 supported PW 4's version of being shot at by Brahamdeo. Notably, the trial court excluded PW 4's gunshot injury as a mere embellishment.

21. Having regard to the material on record, including the ocular testimony of the witnesses and the evidence of the doctors, we are of the considered opinion that the courts below were not justified in convicting any of the accused other than the accused Brahamdeo for the offence under Section 302 IPC, by taking the help of Section 149 IPC. We also find that nine of the accused, namely, Balmukund Chaudhry, Ashok Rai, Kishore Rai, Sunil Chaudhry, Mani Chaudhry, Pankaj Chaudhry, Sanjay Chaudhry, Manoj Chaudhry and Sadanand Chaudhry (hereinafter referred to as “the nine accused”) could not have been convicted for any of the offences with which they were charged, inasmuch as the evidence of the witnesses and other material on record, in our considered opinion, was not very reliable, and was insufficient to bring home guilt against them. This is in spite of the fact that such accused were stated to have been present on or near the scene of occurrence. Even in respect of the remaining accused (except for Brahamdeo), the courts below should not have convicted them for the offence under Section 302 IPC with the help of Section 149 IPC, though they are liable to be convicted for various different offences in which they had actually participated during the incident in question.

22. The evidence of the eyewitnesses pertaining to the nine accused has been adduced to prove that they were part of the mob that killed the deceased, attacked the villagers and set a portion of PW 2's house on fire. However, we find that there is nothing on record to show that these accused had actually taken part in the occurrence or that they had any common object of committing murder and rioting along with the other accused. The evidence with respect to their presence, participation and complicity in the incident in its entirety and, therefore, even in sharing a common object for the commission of any of the acts that occurred during the incident, is vague, scanty, inconsistent and unbelievable, and necessitates giving them the benefit of doubt. Thus, these nine accused are liable to be acquitted of all charges levelled against them.

23. We are, therefore, of the view that there exists cogent evidence only as to the role of the accused Brahamdeo Chaudhry, Kapildeo Chaudhry, Mahendra Rai, Babulal Chaudhry, Bhavesh Chaudhry and Anil Chaudhry (hereinafter referred to as “the six accused”) in the incident. All of these six accused participated in the rioting on the scene of the incident, in which the accused Brahamdeo Chaudhry and Kapildeo Chaudhry were the only persons having guns at the time, of whom the accused Brahamdeo suddenly shot at the deceased and the accused Brahamdeo and Kapildeo shot the injured. We agree with the finding of the courts that it was the accused Brahamdeo who gave the fatal shot to the deceased. Though there was some evidence (i.e. the deposition of PWs 5 and 6) to the effect that the accused Kapildeo shot the deceased as well, the same was not believed by the courts. We, too, find this evidence insufficient to conclude that the accused Kapildeo shot the deceased.

24. We may now address the aspect of the constructive liability of the accused Kapildeo Chaudhry, Mahendra Rai, Babulal Chaudhry, Bhavesh Chaudhry and Anil Chaudhry for the murder of the deceased. It is well settled that to determine whether an accused, being a member of an unlawful assembly, is liable for a given offence, it needs to be seen whether such act was committed in prosecution of the common object of the assembly, and alternatively whether the members of the assembly knew that the offence was likely to be committed in prosecution of such common object. This, in turn, has to be determined from the facts and circumstances of each case. (See Dharam Pal v. State of U.P. (1975) 2 SCC 596; Roy Fernandes v. State of Goa (2012) 3 SCC 221.)

25. In the instant case, it is evident that the six accused initially accosted the informant, chased him to his house, and on failing to get a hold on him, set fire to a portion of his house and caught hold of his nephew, the deceased, who was done to death by the accused Brahamdeo. It is thus evident that the murder of the deceased was itself not the common object of the unlawful assembly. Moreover, we find that the act of the accused Brahamdeo of shooting the deceased was sudden, and knowledge of the likelihood of the same could not be attributed to the rest of the accused. Though the other accused had followed the accused Brahamdeo, in our considered opinion, the evidence on record and circumstances of this case could not, conclusively and beyond reasonable doubt, show common object being shared by the other accused, in the commission of the offence of murder by the accused Brahamdeo.

26. It is no doubt true that the evidence on record may create grave suspicion in the mind of the Court about the complicity of the other accused also, with the help of Section 149 IPC, however, such grave suspicion cannot take the place of proof. It is for the prosecution to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt. Even if the evidence on record creates suspicion in the mind of the Court, though grave, the same would not be sufficient to conclude that the other accused are liable to be convicted for the offence under Section 302 along with the accused Brahamdeo, with the help of Section 149 IPC.

27. In such circumstances, we are of the opinion that the accused Kapildeo Chaudhry, Mahendra Rai, Babulal Chaudhry, Bhavesh Chaudhry and Anil Chaudhry cannot be said to have shared any common object for the murder of the deceased, and cannot be made liable for the same. Notably, the courts have rightly held only the accused Brahamdeo and Kapildeo liable for the attempt to murder the injured eyewitnesses by firing upon them. However, for the aforestated reasons, only the accused Brahamdeo can be held liable for the murder of the deceased. At the most, it can be said that the role of the accused Mahendra Rai, Babulal Chaudhry, Bhavesh Chaudhry and Anil Chaudhry has been proved only insofar as the assault on PW 4 is concerned, through cogent and reliable evidence attributing specific and overt acts to them.

28. We do not find any reason to disagree with the reasons assigned and conclusions arrived at by the courts in convicting the six accused for the offence under Sections 436/149 IPC, and other offences for which they have been held guilty, except to the extent stated supra.

29. It is worth noticing that the accused Kapildeo Chaudhry died during the pendency of the appeals.

30. Having regard to the totality of the facts and circumstances, the judgments of the trial court and the High Court are to be modified as under:

30.1. The conviction and sentence awarded to Brahamdeo Chaudhry (Accused 9) under Section 302 IPC by the trial court and the High Court is confirmed. His conviction and sentence for other offences as ordered by the trial court and the High Court is confirmed.

30.2. Since the accused Kapildeo Chaudhry has already expired, the appeal filed by him abates.

30.3. Mahendra Rai (Accused 13), Babulal Chaudhry (Accused 12), Bhavesh Chaudhry (Accused 11) and Anil Chaudhry (Accused 14) are acquitted of the charges under Section 302 read with Section 149 IPC. Their conviction for other offences as ordered by the trial court and the High Court is confirmed. However, the sentence as against them in respect of the offences for which they stand convicted is modified to the period already undergone by them in jail in this case. If they are on bail, their bail bonds stand discharged.

30.4. The other accused, namely, Bal Mukund Sharma alias Balmukund Chaudhry (Accused 8), Ashok Rai (Accused 7), Kishore Rai (Accused 6), Sunil Chaudhry (Accused 4), Mani Chaudhry (Accused 1), Pankaj Chaudhry (Accused 2), Sanjay Chaudhry (Accused 3), Manoj Chaudhry (Accused 15) and Sadanand Chaudhry (Accused 5) are acquitted of the charges levelled against them. If they are on bail, their bail bonds stand discharged.

31. The appeals are allowed in part.