- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
NARENDRA KUMAR MAHENDRA PRASAD v. M/O FINANCE
Factual and Procedural Background
The applicant, Shri Narendra Kumar, a Senior Auditor working in the office of the Director of Audit, Mumbai, sought transfer to the office of the Principal Accountant General (Audit), Ranchi (Respondent No.1) on spouse grounds because his wife is a State Government school employee in Jharkhand. He submitted a representation for transfer relying on the Government/DOPT policy to accommodate husband and wife at the same station. The respondents rejected his request by an order dated 04.07.2017 on grounds of non-availability of vacancy in the Senior Auditor cadre at Ranchi. The applicant challenged that order by filing Original Application No.180/2018 (dated 27.02.2018). On admission, the Tribunal heard the applicant's counsel, perused the record, and dismissed the OA in limine at the admission stage without issuing notice to the respondents. The registry was directed to forward certified copies of the order to the parties, and the applicant was left free to pursue transfer through his Head of Department subject to availability and administrative constraints.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a Government employee has a vested legally enforceable right to be transferred to the same station as his spouse under the DOPT Office Memorandum and related guidelines.
- Whether the impugned refusal to transfer (on grounds of non-availability of vacancy/administrative constraints) is legally susceptible to judicial interference.
Arguments of the Parties
Applicant's Arguments
- The Government policy and the DOPT Office Memorandum to accommodate husband and wife at the same station confer a right to be transferred to Ranchi on spouse grounds.
- There was a vacancy at Ranchi for the post of Senior Auditor, and therefore the applicant should have been accommodated.
Respondents' Position (as described in the opinion)
- The respondents considered the applicant's representation but rejected it due to non-availability of vacancy in the Senior Auditor cadre at Ranchi and administrative constraints.
- The decision not to grant transfer was an administrative decision for the department to take.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Union of India Vs. S.L. Abbas, AIR 1993 SCC 2444 | Transfers are an incident of government service; guidelines and executive instructions (such as those recommending that husband and wife be posted together) do not confer a legally enforceable right and entitle an employee only to consideration subject to administrative exigencies. | The Tribunal relied on this precedent to hold that the DOPT OM and related guidelines do not create a vested right to transfer on spouse ground; since the respondents had considered the request and declined for administrative reasons/no vacancy, the impugned order was not amenable to judicial interference. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Tribunal examined the Government policy and the DOPT Office Memorandum and applied the Supreme Court's decision in Union of India Vs. S.L. Abbas. It reasoned that executive guidelines to post husband and wife at the same station only give an employee a right to be considered, not a legally enforceable right. The respondents had considered the applicant's representation and declined transfer citing non-availability of vacancy and administrative constraints. The Tribunal further observed that even if a vacancy existed, departmental administrative considerations remain for the authority to decide and are not subject to direction by the court in this context. Finding no malafide or illegality in the decision, and no breach of statutory provisions, the Tribunal concluded the OA was not maintainable and dismissed it at the admission stage.
Holding and Implications
The Original Application is dismissed in limine.
Direct effect: The applicant's challenge to the respondents' refusal of transfer on spouse ground is rejected; no relief is granted by the Tribunal. The applicant remains free to approach his Head of Department for consideration of transfer to Ranchi, subject to availability of a post and administrative constraints. The opinion does not purport to lay down any new legal precedent beyond applying established authority that the policy does not create a vested right.
1 OA No.180/2018
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
MUMBAI BENCH, MUMBAI
ORIGINAL APPLICATION No. 180/2018 Dated:- 27.02.2018
Coram: Hon'ble Shri. Arvind J. Rohee, Member (J). Hon'ble Shri. R. Vijaykumar, Member (A).
Shri Narendra Kumar s/o. Mahendra Prasad, Senior Auditor,
O/at Senior Auditor, Working
Address: Div. General (Audit) Bandra Kurla Complex,
Mumbai 400 051.
R/at B/403, Vinayak Shree
Apartment, Nandivali Road Tekadi Dombivli (E) - 421 201. ... Applicant (By Advocate Shri R.K. Singh)
Versus
1. Union of India Through the Principal Accountant General (Audit) Ranchi, State of Jharkhand 834 002.
2. Local Audit Department Shyamalu Colony, Daronda, Ranchi, State of Jharkhand 834 002. ... Respondents
ORDER (Oral) Per : Shri A.J. Rohee, Member (J) Today when the matter is called out for admission, heard Shri R.K. Singh, learned Advocate for the Applicant. We have carefully perused the case record.
2. The Applicant is presently working as Senior Auditor in the office of Principal
1
Director of Audit, Mumbai (who is not joined as party respondent). He seeks request transfer on spouse ground to the office of the Principal Accountant General (Audit) Ranchi in Jharkhand State (Respondent No.1), since his wife is a State Government employee serving there in a School run by the State Government. He, therefore, submitted a representation to his office for his transfer to Ranchi office on the said ground based on the policy of the Government to accommodate husband and wife at same Station. However, his request was rejected for non-availability of vacancy in the cadre of Senior Auditor at Jharkhand vide impugned order dated 04.07.2017. The same has been challenged in this OA.
3. During the course of arguments, learned Advocate for the applicant submitted that since it is the policy of the Government to accommodate husband and wife at one Station and DOPT has also issued the Office Memorandum in this behalf, he has a vested right to be transferred to Ranchi.
2
However, although it is the policy of the Government to post husband and wife working in Central Government/State Government at same Station, the employee who wants to seek benefit of the said policy has only a right to be considered. In other words, it is not a vested right and the DOPT's OM also states that as far as possible the request should be considered subject to administrative constraint. Since the respondents have considered the applicant's request there is substantial compliance and it cannot be said that the impugned order is in any manner illegal, improper or incorrect which is liable to be judicially reviewed.
4. Learned Advocate for the applicant tried to contend that there is vacancy in the post of Senior Auditor at Ranchi. However even if it is so, it is for the department to take a decision and if for administrative reason it is not possible to accommodate the applicant, no relief can be granted to him. In such circumstances of the case the applicant is not at all
3
justified in insisting that his request for transfer or deputation on spouse ground must be favourably considered.
5. So far as transfer of Government employee on spouse ground is concerned, we may refer to the landmark decision rendered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Union of India Vs. S.L. Abbas, AIR 1993 SCC 2444, in which the Hon'ble Supreme Court has considered the aspect of application of the guidelines framed by the Department for effecting transfer of employees. In that case, the issue regarding transfer on spouse ground is also considered and it has been held as under:-
"An order of transfer is an incidence of Government service. Who should be transferred where is a matter for the appropriate authority to decide. Unless the order of transfer is vitiated by malafides or is made in violation of statutory
provisions, the Court cannot interfere with it. There is no doubt that, while ordering the transfer the authority must keep in mind the guidelines issued by the Government on the subject. Similarly, if a person makes any representation with respect to his transfer, the appropriate authority must consider the same
4
having regard to the exigencies of administration. The guidelines say that as far as possible, the husband and the wife must be posted at the same place. The said guideline, however, does not confer upon the government employee a legally enforceable right. Executive instructions issued by the Government are in the nature of guidelines. They do not have statutory force."
6. From the above discussion it is obvious that neither guidelines nor the DOPT OM referred above conferred any legal enforceable right on applicant to insist for his transfer on spouse ground. It is needless to say that his request can be considered subject to administrative exigency. The respondents have considered it and did not concede, hence it cannot be said that O.A. is maintainable.
7. Considering the above factual position on record, we do not find any substance in the present OA. The OA, therefore, stands
dismissed in limine at admission stage, without issuing notice to the respondents.
8. In spite of dismissal of O.A., the applicant will, however, be at liberty to
5
approach the respondents through his Head of Department for his transfer on spouse ground, subject to availability of post at Ranchi and administrative constraint and if such request is made, the same shall be considered by the respondents in accordance with law.
9. Registry is directed to forward certified copy of this order to both the parties, at the earliest.
(R. Vijaykumar) (A.J. Rohee) Member (A) Member (J)
dm/H.
6
Alert