- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Smt. Shahbaz Bano Gram Pradhan v. Smt. Sahiba Bano And Others
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Ashok Bhushan, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
An election for the office of Gram Pradhan of Gram Panchayat Sarai Deshav alias Bagi was held under the U.P. Panchayat Raj Act, 1947. Polling took place on 20 June 2000 and counting on 25 June 2000. The writ petitioner was declared elected with 357 votes; respondent No. 1 obtained 351 votes; other candidates obtained fewer votes; and 57 votes were declared invalid.
Respondent No. 1 (as election petitioner) filed Election Petition No. 29 of 2001 under section 12-C of the U.P. Panchayat Raj Act, 1947, alleging mistakes and irregularities in counting and that invalid votes were counted in favour of the declared winner. The Prescribed Authority/election tribunal dismissed the election petition by order dated 20 August 2001 and refused the relief of recounting. The husband of the election petitioner (PW-1) and another witness (PW-2) gave evidence; some documents were filed.
A revision under section 12-C(6) was filed before the Additional District Judge, who allowed the revision by order dated 22 May 2002, set aside the election tribunal's order, and directed the election tribunal to conduct a recount. The present writ petition challenges that revisional order of 22 May 2002. Counter and rejoinder affidavits were exchanged and, with consent of the parties, the writ petition was finally heard and decided.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the election tribunal was correct in refusing an order for recounting of votes in the facts of this case.
- Whether the revisional court (Additional District Judge) rightly set aside the election tribunal's order and directed a recount on the basis of the pleadings and the evidence on record.
- What legal principles and standards should govern orders for inspection/recount of ballot papers in panchayat elections under the U.P. Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 (including the role of Rules 104 and 112 and the requirement for an adequate statement of material facts)?
Arguments of the Parties
Writ Petitioner (challenging the revisional order)
- The election petition did not set out sufficient material facts to justify an order for recount; no adequate evidence was produced to substantiate the claim for recounting.
- The order of recounting by the Additional District Judge contravened principles laid down by the Apex Court for ordering recounting of votes.
- The election petitioner did not personally appear as a witness to support the allegations; reliance was placed on Rajankumar Shankarrao Teware v. Ajit Anantrao Pawar for the proposition that this is a relevant factor.
- Reliance was placed on several authorities (including Bhabhi v. Sheo Govind; Ashok Jain; Ram Adhar Singh Full Bench; Ram Pal Singh; Ramesh Chandra) for the general proposition that recounting should not be ordered on vague or speculative allegations.
Respondents (defending the revisional order)
- Submission that two conditions are required for recounting: (a) an adequate statement of material facts in the petition, and (b) prima facie satisfaction of the Court that inspection/recount is necessary. Prima facie satisfaction does not mean proof to the hilt.
- Contended there were sufficient materials on the record and that the husband of the election petitioner (PW-1) provided supportive testimony, so the revisional court did not err in directing recounting.
- Relied on authorities for the principles of recounting (Ram Sewak Yadav v. Hussain Kamil Kidwai; S. Baldev Singh v. Teja Singh Swatantra; Mahendra Pal v. Shri Ram Dass Malanger) and on Martin Burn Ltd. v. R.N. Banerjee for the concept of prima facie case.
- Argued that because the revisional court only remanded the matter for recount, the High Court should not interfere under Article 226 of the Constitution (relying on precedent such as Smt. Maya Devi).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Bhabhi v. Sheo Govind | Principles concerning when inspection/recount of ballot papers may be ordered (reiteration of established conditions emphasising secrecy of ballot and need for clear material facts). | Cited by parties and discussed as part of the settled principles the Court applied in evaluating whether the present petition contained adequate material facts. |
| Ashok Jain v. XIII Additional District Judge, Agra | Relied upon for principles on ordering recount (general authority cited by petitioner). | Noted as one of the authorities relied on by the petitioner in support of the submission that recount should not be ordered on vague allegations. |
| Ram Adhar Singh v. District Judge, Ghazipur (Full Bench) | Held that principles applicable under the Representation of the People Act regarding inspection/recount apply equally to U.P. Panchayat Raj Act election petitions; need for adequate statement of material facts in petition. | The Court relied on this Full Bench decision as establishing applicability of Representation of the People Act principles to panchayat election disputes and used it as foundational authority for the required standard of pleadings. |
| Ram Pal Singh v. Prescribed Authority | Authority cited by petitioner on principles governing recounting (listed among relied authorities). | Cited by the petitioner; the Court treated it as part of the body of authorities on the standard required for recount orders. |
| Ramesh Chandra v. Election Tribunal | Authority cited by petitioner on principles for election petitions and recounting. | Cited by the petitioner; considered among the precedents forming the legal backdrop. |
| Rajankumar Shankarrao Teware v. Ajit Anantrao Pawar | Discussed facts where defeated candidate did not testify; Court considered evidence on record to determine prima facie case. | The opinion explains that Rajankumar Teware does not lay down an absolute rule that the petitioner must personally testify; the Court relied on what the Rajankumar judgment actually did — it considered available evidence and found no prima facie case. |
| Ram Sewak Yadav v. Hussain Kamil Kidwai | Set out the two conditions for permitting inspection/recount: (i) adequate statement of material facts in petition; (ii) tribunal must be prima facie satisfied inspection is necessary; and that vague/fishing allegations are insufficient. | The Court quoted and applied the two-condition test from this precedent as a central standard for deciding whether recounting was warranted in the present case. |
| S. Baldev Singh v. Teja Singh Swatantra | Authority cited by respondents on principles related to recounting (part of authorities on the point). | Noted as one of the decisions relied upon by respondents in support of their submissions about recount standards. |
| Mahendra Pal v. Shri Ram Dass Malanger | Authority cited by respondents on principles related to recounting. | Referenced by respondents; the Court recorded this as part of the body of cases relied upon by the respondents. |
| Martin Burn Ltd. v. R.N. Banerjee | Interpretation of what constitutes a prima facie case — whether evidence permits arriving at a particular conclusion reasonably. | The Court considered Martin Burn for the definition of prima facie satisfaction but held that it did not support expanding discretion to a "prudent man" subjective standard for recounts. |
| Anuradhika v. Additional District Judge, Azamgarh | Example where specific averments (special marks on certain ballot papers) justified inspection/recount; case is fact-specific. | The Court distinguished Anuradhika on its facts — it involved specific averments sufficient to justify recount — and noted it did not aid the petitioner here. |
| Smt. Maya Devi v. Special Judge, Kanpur | Case addressing remand and procedure of recount; held in its facts that remand for recount did not call for interference under Article 227. | The Court explained that Maya Devi is fact-specific and concerned with procedure/mode of recount and remand; it was distinguished and held not to apply to the present facts where a revisional court had directed a recount without adequate findings. |
| Vadivelu v. Sundaram (Vedivelu) | Held recounts should be ordered very rarely and only on specific allegations showing improper acceptance/rejection of votes; secrecy of ballot is sacrosanct. | The Court relied on this recent Apex Court authority to reinforce that recounts are exceptional and require clear, specific pleadings and proof of improper acceptance/rejection of votes; compared the pleadings in that case with the present pleadings and found them analogous (i.e., inadequate). |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded in a structured manner:
-
Statutory and regulatory framework: The Court reviewed the U.P. Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 and the relevant rules, especially:
- Uttar Pradesh Panchayat Raj (Election of Members, Pradhan and Up Pradhan) Rules, 1994 — in particular Rule 104 (procedure at counting) and Rule 112 (production and inspection of election papers); and
- Uttar Pradesh Panchayat Raj (Settlement of Election Disputes) Rules, 1994 — in particular Rule 4 concerning hearing of election petitions under section 12 and summary procedure.
- Applicable legal test: The Court recited the settled legal principles (as articulated in the Apex Court and by the Full Bench in Ram Adhar Singh) that govern inspection/recount requests: the petition must contain an adequate statement of material facts, and the Tribunal must be prima facie satisfied that inspection/recount is necessary to do complete justice; vague or fishing allegations are insufficient. The Court quoted and adopted the two-condition test from Ram Sewak Yadav and the expanded multi-factor articulation from Bhabhi and other Apex Court authorities, noting that the secrecy of the ballot is sacrosanct.
-
Examination of the election petition and evidence: The Court analyzed paragraphs 6 and 7 of the election petition and the testimony of PW-1 (the husband of the election petitioner). It noted:
- The petition alleged bundling of ballot papers by candidate and separation of rejected votes, and that initially 51 or 57 votes were declared invalid.
- The petition alleged that in one bundle of the returned candidate one invalid vote was found, and upon recounting that bundle six invalid votes were found; the petitioner’s side then orally requested further recounting but was refused, and an application allegedly to the counting officer was torn.
- There was a general allegation that invalid votes were more than 57 and a claim of suspicion that other bundles might contain invalid votes; however, there was no specific identification of any other invalid votes or any precise particulars as to which votes or how many were wrongly counted in favour of the returned candidate.
- Pursuant to Rule 104, a candidate or agent had the right to raise specific objections at counting; the pleadings did not demonstrate that any specific objections were raised at the time of counting or that the Returning Officer violated the counting procedure set out in Rule 104.
-
Evaluation of the revisional court's order: The Court examined the Additional District Judge’s revisional judgment and found that:
- The revisional court concluded there was "some manipulation" in counting and that counting had not been done according to counting rules, but it did not identify or analyze any specific evidence or particular irregularity to support that conclusion.
- The revisional judgment did not point to the "concrete evidence on the record" it allegedly relied upon; the observations were general and conclusory.
- Under section 12-C(6) the revisional power is circumscribed — the revisional court must show that the Prescribed Authority committed an error of jurisdiction, failed to exercise jurisdiction, or acted illegally or with material irregularity. The revisional court in this case did not record such findings in the manner required and effectively acted beyond the permissible scope by substituting its own conclusion without identifying the specific error or material irregularity found in the tribunal's handling of evidence.
-
Consideration of specific arguments:
- On the contention that the election petitioner did not personally testify: the Court explained that the Rajankumar Teware case did not establish a rule that a defeated candidate must personally testify; instead, the Supreme Court considered the evidence on record and found no prima facie case. Thus non-appearance of the petitioner in the witness box is not an absolute bar to consideration of the petition where other evidence exists.
- On remand and procedural precedents (e.g., Maya Devi): the Court distinguished that authority as fact-specific involving a remand for recount procedure; the present case was not a mere remand but an order setting aside the tribunal's dismissal and directing a recount without adequate reasoning or identification of errors.
- On the "prudent man" formulation and Martin Burn: the Court accepted the meaning of prima facie from Martin Burn (whether evidence reasonably permits a conclusion) but rejected the respondents' submission that the tribunal should act simply as a "prudent man" and exercise broad subjective discretion. The Court held that adopting such a standard would open the door to excessive discretionary and subjective recount directions, contrary to the settled restrictive principles protecting ballot secrecy and preventing fishing expeditions.
- Conclusion of analysis: Applying the settled principles to the facts and evidence in the present record, the Court concluded that the election petition did not present adequate material facts or particulars to justify inspection/recount, and the revisional court erred in setting aside the tribunal's order without identifying or relying on specific evidence or recognized jurisdictional error under section 12-C(6).
Holding and Implications
Holding:
The writ petition is allowed; the judgment and order of the Additional District Judge dated 22nd May, 2002 is set aside.
Direct implications for the parties:
- The revisional court's order directing a recount is quashed. (The Court's order expressly sets aside the Additional District Judge's order dated 22 May 2002.)
- There will be no order as to costs.
Broader implications and precedent:
- The decision reiterates and applies the established principle that recounts/inspection of ballot papers in panchayat elections are exceptional and require (a) an adequate statement of material facts in the election petition and (b) prima facie satisfaction of the tribunal that recount is necessary to do complete justice. The Court reiterated that secrecy of the ballot is sacrosanct and that courts must guard against permitting fishing or roving inquiries.
- The Court emphasised the limited scope of revision under section 12-C(6) — the revisional jurisdiction is not appellate; the revisional court must identify errors as specified in the statute rather than substitute its own conclusion absent articulated jurisdictional error or material irregularity shown on the record.
- The opinion does not purport to establish a new legal principle; it applies existing authorities and rules to the facts of this matter. (No novel precedent was announced beyond applying established tests to the facts before the Court.)
Note: This summary strictly follows the information and reasoning contained in the provided opinion and does not introduce facts or inferences not explicitly present in the text.
Ashok Bhushan, J.:— Heard Sri Rajendra Prasad Mishra, counsel for the writ petitioner and Sri R.S Shukla appearing for respondent Nos. 1 to 4. Counter and rejoinder affidavits have been exchanged and both the parties have prayed that writ petition itself be finally decided. With the consent of the parties, the writ petition is being finally decided.
2. By this writ petition, the writ petitioner has prayed for quashing the order dated 22nd May, 2002 passed by Additional District Judge, Allahabad in Election Revision No. 648 of 2001. By the order dated 22nd May, 2002, the Additional District Judge has set-aside the order of election tribunal dated 20th August, 2001 and has directed the election tribunal to get the recounting held in view of the directions issued in revision order.
3. The facts giving rise to this petition, briefly stated, are; election for the officer of Gram Pradhan of Gram Panchayat Sarai Deshav alias Bagi was held in accordance with provisions of U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947. The votes were polled on 20th June, 2000. The counting for votes took place on 25th June, 2000 in which writ petitioner was declared elected as Pradhan having secured 357 votes. Respondent No. 1 secured 351 votes, respondent No. 2 secured 215 votes, respondent No. 3 secured 243 votes and respondent No. 4 secured 17 votes. 57 votes were declared invalid. After the counting of votes result was declared declaring the writ petitioner elected as Pradhan. Respondent No. 1 filed election petition being Election Petition No. 29 of 2001 under section 12-C of U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 challenging the election of the writ petitioner. In the election petition grounds were taken to the effect that there are mistakes and irregularities in the counting. It was stated that several invalid votes have been counted in favour of the writ petitioner who was respondent No. 1 in the election petition. The written statement was filed by the elected candidate and evidence was also lead in the election petition. The husband of election petitioner, namely, Abdul Latif, was examined as P.W 1 and Nooruddin alias Salim was examined as P.W -2. Certain documentary evidences were also filed by the election petitioner. The Prescribed Authority vide its judgment and order dated 20th August, 2001 dismissed the election petition. Relief of recounting as prayed in the election petitioner was denied. The election tribunal held that from the arguments raised by the election petitioner, it is clear that election petition is founded only on the ground of suspicion on the basis of which election petitioner wanted recounting to beheld. Election tribunal held that counting was held in presence of husband of election petitioner and no evidence has been brought on the record to prove that any irregularity was committed in the counting. Revision under section 12-C (6) of U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 was filed by election petitioner before the Additional District Judge. The revision has been allowed by Additional District Judge vide its judgment and order dated 22nd May, 2002. Learned Additional District Judge in his order held that for recounting sufficient evidence was on the record. The revisional Court after considering the evidence on the record came to the conclusion that there is some manipulation in counting and the counting has not been done in accordance with counting rules, hence the revision is liable to be allowed. The revisional Court directed the election tribunal to get the recounting held. The said order dated 22nd May, 2002 passed by Additional District Judge has been challenged in this writ petition.
4. The counsel for the writ petitioner, challenging the order of Additional District Judge, made following submissions in support of the writ petition:
(i) The election petitioner has not given sufficient material facts in the election petition to enable recounting order passed by the Court. The election petitioner also did not bring any evidence on the record to substantiate claim of recounting of votes. The order of recounting passed by Additional District Judge is clearly against the principles laid down by the Apex Court for ordering recounting of votes. Reliance has been placed on judgments of the Apex Court in Bhabhi v. Sheo Govind,1 Ashok Jain v. XIII Additional District Judge, Agra,2Ram Adhar Singh v. District Judge, Ghazipur,3 Ram Pal Singh v. Prescribed Authority,4 Ramesh Chandra v. Election Tribunal.5
(ii) The election petitioner did not appear as witness to support the allegation of the election petition, hence no order for recounting could have been passed. Reliance has been placed on Rajankumar Shankarrao Teware v. Ajit Anantrao Pawar.6
5. Sri R.S Shukla appearing for the respondents vehemently refuted the contentions of the counsel for the writ petitioner. Sri Shukla submitted that for recounting two conditions are required to be fulfilled i.e statement of material facts and prima facie satisfaction of the Court. Sri Shukla contended that prima facie satisfaction does not mean proving of the case to the hilt. It was submitted that there were sufficient materials in the election petition, which were also proved by the statement of husband of the election petitioner, hence the revisional Court did not commit any error in directing for recounting. On the principles of recounting reliance has been placed on Ram Sewak Yadav v. Hussain Kamil Kidwai,7 S. Baldev Singh v. Teja Singh Swatantra,8 and Mahendra Pal v. Shri Ram Dass Malanger.9 For the proposition as to what is prima facie case, reliance has been placed on the judgment of Apex Court in Martin Burn Ltd. v. R. N. Bangerjee Banerjee,10 further decision of this Court Anuradhika v. Additional District Judge, Azamgarh,11 and Smt. Mayadevi v. Special Judge Kanpur.12 The Counsel for the Respondents submitted that since the revisional Court has only remanded the case, this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India cannot interfere with the order of remand.
6. I have heard counsel for the parties and perused the record. The main question, which has arisen for consideration in the writ petition, is as to whether the order of election tribunal refusing recount in the facts of the present case and dismissing the election petition is correct or revisional court has rightly set aside the order of election tribunal and directed for recounting on the basis of pleading and the evidence brought on the record in the present case.
7. Before adverting to the facts of the present case, it is pertinent to look on the provisions of U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 and the principles which have been held to be applicable while considering the prayer for recounting of votes in the panchayat elections.
8. Rules have been framed under the U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947, namely, the Uttar Pradesh Panchayat Raj (Election of Members, Pradhan and Up Pradhan) Rules, 1994 (hereinafter referred to as 1994 Rules). 1994 Rules cover the entire field of election of the office of Pradhan right from notices of election, fixing of dates and the declaration of the result. In the present case no dispute has been raised with regard to any other procedure adopted in the election except the counting. Rule 104 of 1994 Rules provides for the procedure at the counting. Rules 104 of 1994 Rules is extracted as under:
“104. Procedure at the counting.— On the date and at the time and place appointed under Rule 101, the Nirvachan Adhikari shall proceed as follows:
(a) The Nirvachan Adhikari shall satisfy himself that all the ballot boxes used at the poll and which are to be counted at the place have been received and accounted for;
(b) The Nirvachan Adhikari shall then allow the candidate and their Nirvachan Abhikartas and Ganana Abhikartas present at the counting an opportunity to inspect the ballot boxes and their seals for satisfying themselves that they are in order;
(c) The Nirvachan Adhikari shall also satisfy himself that none of the boxes has in fact been tampered with. If any ballot box is found by him to have been tampered with or destroyed or lost, the Nirvachan Adhikari shall not proceed with the counting of votes and the provisions of Rule 100 shall apply;
(d) If the Nirvachan Adhikari is satisfied that all such ballot boxes which are to be counted at such place have been received and are in order, he shall take up the counting of ballot papers contained in the ballot boxes. All the ballot boxes used at a polling place shall be opened, and the counting of the ballot papers found in those box proceeded with, in accordance with the instructions of the State Election Commission, at the same time;
(e) An account of the ballot papers found in the boxes of the polling place shall be recorded in a statement in the form specified by the State Election Commission;
(f) The Nirvachan Adhikari shall allow the candidates, their Nirvachan Abhikaratas and Ganana Abhikartas, who may be present, reasonable opportunity to inspect all ballot papers which in the opinion of the Nirvachan Adhikari are liable to be rejected, but shall not allow them to handle those or any other ballot papers. The Nirvachan Adhikari shall on every ballot paper which is rejected endorse rejection thereon in Hindi. If any candidate of his Nirvachan Abhikarta questions, the correctness of the rejection of any ballot paper, the Nirvachan Adhikari shall also record briefly on such ballot paper the grounds for his rejection.
(g) After the counting of all ballot papers contained in the ballot boxes of the polling place has been completed the Nirvachan Adhikari shall cause all such ballot papers to be kept in a separate packet on which shall be indicated such particulars as will identify the name of the Gram Panchayat to which the ballot papers relate.”
9. The ground for rejection of ballots have been provided in Rule 105. After declaration of the result and after submitting report of the result to the State Election Commission, Rule 111 provides that ballot papers and other papers relating to the election will be forwarded to the District Panchayat Raj Officer for safe custody. Rule 112 provides for production and inspection of the election papers. Rule 112 (1) contains a prohibition that the packets of ballot papers whether valid, rejected tendered, and of the marked copy of the electoral roll shall not be inspected by or produced before any person or authority except under the order of a competent court or of an authority hearing an election petition. Rule 112 is extracted as under:
“112. Production and inspection of election papers.— (1) While in the custody of the District Panchayat Raj Officer, the packets of ballot papers whether valid, rejected or tendered, and of the marked copy of the electoral roll shall not be inspected by or produced before any person or authority except under the order of a competent court or of an authority hearing an election petition.
(2) Copies of the election return forwarded by the Nirvachan Adhikari under sub-rule (1) of Rule 111 shall be furnished by the District Panchayat Raj Officer on payment of a fee of rupees twelve for each copy.
(3) All other papers relating to the election shall be opened to public inspection subject to the payment of such fees as may be specified by the State Election Commission.”
10. Another set of rules have been framed, namely, the Uttar Pradesh Panchayat Raj (Settlement of Election Disputes) Rules, 1994. Rule 4 of the aforesaid Rules provides procedure for hearing of the petition under section 12 of the U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947. Rule 4 provides that every election petition shall be tried by the Sub-Divisional Officer, as nearly as may be, in accordance with the procedure applicable under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, for the trial of the suits. Rule 4 (1) of the Uttar Pradesh Panchayat Raj (Settlement of Election Disputes) Rules, 1994 is extracted as under:
“4. Hearing of the petition.— (1) Subject to the provisions of the Act and these rules, every election petition shall be tried by the Sub-Divisional Officer, as nearly as may be, in accordance with the procedure applicable under the Code of Civil of Procedure, 1908, for the trial of suits:
(i) the Sub-Divisional Officer may hear the petitioner or his counsel and if he finds that the petition has no substance rejected the same without the issue of any notice to the opposite parties;
(ii) it shall not be necessary for Sub-Divisional Officer to record the evidence in full and he may maintain only a memorandum of evidence produced by the parties before him;
(iii) if there is a sole petitioner and he dies, or these is a sole respondent and he dies, the petition shall abate;
(iv) the Sub-Divisional Officer may allow only such evidence to the produced as he deems relevant for the purpose of deciding the petition;
(v) the District Magistrate may at any stage on sufficient cause being shown transfer an application made under sub-section (1) of section 12-C for hearing to another Sub-Divisional Officer;
(vi) an application not presented within time or unaccompanied by a treasury challan as required under sub-rule (1) of Rule 3 may at any time be dismissed by the Sub-Divisional Officer, and
(vii) the Sub-Divisional Officer may, on an application of either party made within five days after the date of his decision, review his order.”
11. The power of directing for inspection of ballot papers flows from Rule 4 of the aforesaid Uttar Pradesh Panchayat Raj (Settlement of Election Disputes) Rules, 1994 and Rule 112 of 1994 Rules.
12. The question as to what principle should be held applicable for directing recounting in an election petition under U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 has been considered and answered by the Full Bench in Ram Adhar Singh's case (supra). The Full Bench of this Court considered the decisions of the Apex Court in which principles for directing recounting were laid down while considering the election petition under the Representation of People Act, 1951. The Full Bench applied the principle with regard to inspection of ballot papers enunciated by the Supreme Court in cases arising under the Representation of People Act to an election petition dealt with under the provisions of U.P Panchayat Raj Act. In paragraph 18 of the judgment, the full Bench laid down as under;
“18. We are unable to accept the submission made by the learned counsel. As already explained the Supreme Court has, in cases arising under the representation of the People Act, spelt out the condition that all the courts dealing with an election petition should not exercise its discretion to permit inspection of ballot papers unless the petition contains an adequate statement of material facts on which the petitioner relies in support of his case (viz, that the petition meets the requirements of section 83 (1) of the Representation of the People Act regarding contents of an election petition) for the reason that under the Act, it is a matter of utmost importance to maintain the secrecy of ballot which is sacrosanct and which should not be lightly allowed to be violated on vague and indefinite allegations. This reason applies equally to an election held under the U.P Panchayat Raj Act which too cherishes secrecy of ballot to the same extent. Viewed from this angle, it becomes evident that the amplitude and purpose of the requirement of section 83(1)(a) of the Representation of the People Act that the election petition must contain a concise statement of material facts on which the petitioner relies and that of Rule 24 of the Rules framed under the U.P Panchayat Raj Act to the effect that an application under section 12-C (1) of the Act must specify the grounds on which the election of the respondent is being questioned as also a summary of circumstances alleged to justify the election being questioned on such grounds, is the same, viz, that the Court or the authority dealing with an election petition under the respective enactments, should not countenance or proceed to investigate into any ground taken in the election petition unless the ground as well as the material in support of such ground have been adequately disposed in the petition. Neither of the two enactments countenances the Court or the authority to permit the election petitioner to make or indulge into making of a proving enquiry with a view to fish out material for declaring an election void; and it is this weighty: factor which impeals the Court or the authority not to look into or permit inspection of ballot papers unless the foundation for the purpose has been properly laid in the petition by specifying the ground and the material or the circumstances in support of such ground. Viewed in this light, the provisions contained in the U.P Panchayat Raj Rules permitting the summary hearing of an application under section 12-C (1) of the Act and authorising the Sub-Divisional Officer to, instead of recording evidence in full, merely maintain a memorandum thereof, has no bearing on the question regarding circumstances in which the ballot papers can either be looked into or permitted to be inspected in proceeding under section 12-C of the U.P Panchayat Raj Act.”
13. The principles for directing recounting of votes under the Representation of Peoples Act and Conduct of Election Rules, 1961 are well settled. The Apex Court in Ram Sewak Yadav's case (supra) after considering the earlier cases laid down in paragraph 7 the principles for granting an order of recount. Paragraph 7 of the said judgment as quoted as under:
“(7) An order for inspection may not be granted as a matter of course, having regard to the insistence upon the secrecy of the ballot papers, the Court would be justified in granting an order for inspection provided two conditions are fulfilled:
(i) that the petition for setting aside an election contains as adequate statement of the material facts on which the petitioner relies in support of his cases; and
(ii) the Tribunal is prima facie satisfied that in order to decide the dispute and to do complete justice between the parties inspection of the ballot papers is necessary.
But an order for inspection of ballot papers cannot be granted to support vague pleas made in the petition not supported by material facts or to fish out evidence to support such pleas. The case of the petitioner must be set out with precision supported by averments of material facts. To establish a case so pleaded an order for inspection may undoubtedly, if the interests of justice require, be granted. But a mere allegation that the petitioner suspects or believes that there has been an improper reception, refusal or rejection of votes will not be sufficient to support an order for inspection.”
14. The Apex Court also held in paragraph 9 of the judgment that at every stage in the process of scrutiny and counting of votes the candidate or his agents have an opportunity of remaining present at the counting of votes, watching the proceedings of the returning officer, inspecting any rejected votes and to demand a re-count. Due to this a candidate who seeks to challenge election has to give concise statement of materials. Paragraph 9 of the said judgment in Ram Sewak Yadav's case (supra) is quoted below:
“(9) There can therefore be no doubt that at every stage in the process of scrutiny and counting of votes the candidate or his agents have an opportunity of remaining present at the counting of votes, watching the proceedings of the returning officer, inspecting any rejected votes, and to demand a re-count. Therefore, a candidate who seeks to challenge an election on the ground that there has been improper reception, refusal or rejection of votes at the time of counting, has ample opportunity of acquainting himself with the manner in which the ballot boxes were scrutinized and opened, and the votes were counted. He has also opportunity of inspecting rejected ballot papers, and of demanding a re-count. It is in the light of the provisions of section 83 (1) which require a concise statement of material facts on which the petitioner relies and to the opportunity which a defeated candidate had at the time of counting, of watching and of claiming a re-count that the application for inspection must be considered.”
15. The Apex Court again in 1975 after considering earlier cases in the case of Bhabhi (supra) reiterated the principles in paragraph 15 of the judgment. Paragraph 15 of the judgment is quoted below:
“15. Thus on a close and careful consideration of the various authorities of this Court from time to time it is manifest that the following conditions are imperative before a Court can grant inspection, or for that matter sample inspection, of the ballot papers;
(1) That it is important to maintain the secrecy of the ballot which is sacrosanct and should not be allowed to be violated on frivolous, vague and indefinite allegation;
(2) That before inspection is allowed, the allegations made against the elected candidate must be clear and specific and must be supported by adequate statements of material facts;
(3) The Court must be prima facie satisfied on the materials produced before the Court regarding the truth of the allegations made for a recount;
(4) That the Court must come to the conclusion that in order to grant prayer for inspection it is necessary and imperative to do full justice between the parties;
(5) That the discretion conferred on the Court should not be exercised in such a way for as to enable the applicant to indulge in a roving inquiry with a view to fish materials for declaring the election to be void; and
(6) That on the special facts of a given case sample inspection may be ordered to lend further assurance to the prima facie satisfaction of the Court regarding the truth of the allegations made for a recount, and not for the purpose of fishing out materials.
If all these circumstances enter into the mind of the Judge and he is satisfied that these conditions are fulfilled in a given case, the exercise of the discretion would undoubtedly be proper.”
16. Recently the Apex Court had occasion to consider the question of recounting in reference to the provisions of R.N Panchayats (Elections) Rules, 1995 in Vadivelu v. Sundaram.13 The Apex Court in the aforesaid judgment relied the principles laid down for directing the recount under the Representation of People Act. After considering earlier cases of recount, it was held by Apex Court in Paragraph 16 of the said judgment:
“16. The result of the analysis of the above cases would show that this Court has consistently taken the view that recount of votes could be ordered very rarely and on specific allegation in the pleadings in the election petition that illegality or irregularity was committed while counting. The petitioner who seeks re-count should allege and prove that there was improper acceptance of invalid votes or improper rejection of valid votes. If only the Court is satisfied about the truthfulness of the above allegation, it can order re-count of votes. Secrecy of ballot has always been considered sacrosanct in a democratic process of election and it cannot be disturbed lightly by bare allegations of illegality or irregularity in counting. But if it is proved that purity of elections has been tarnished and it has materially affected the result of the election whereby the defeated candidate is seriously prejudiced, the Court can resort to re-count of votes under such circumstances to do justice between the parties.”
17. From the decisions as noted above, it is clear that principles for directing inspection of ballot papers laid down with regard to election petition under the Representation of People Act have been applied while considering the same question as panchayat election. Our Full Bench in Ram Adhar Singh's case (supra) has already laid down that said principles are fully applicable. The recent judgment of the Apex Court in Vedivelu's case (supra) which was considering the T.N Panchayat (Election) Rules has also applied the same principles and has considered the prayer for recount in that light.
18. Applying the above principles laid down by the Apex Court, now it has to be considered as to whether the pleading and the evidence brought in the present case before the election tribunal were sufficient for directing recount of votes. Copy of the election petition has been filed as Annexure-1 to the writ petition. As noted above, Rule 104 of 1994 Rules provides the detail procedure of counting. At the time of counting the candidates, his or her election agent and one counting agent can be present. From the contents of paragraphs 6 and 7 of the election petition, it is clear that bundling was made of the ballot papers according to different candidates and rejected votes were separated. From the averments made in paragraphs 6 and 7 of election petition, it is clear that no objection was raised at the time of bundling, counting of votes, regarding invalidity of votes or regarding inclusion of any invalid votes in any other candidates bundles. Only allegation, which has been made in paragraph 7, is that after counting of votes of all candidates separately and declaring 51 votes as invalid, it was pointed out that in one of the bundles of Smt. Shahbaz Bano one invalid vote is there and on the said objection the said bundle was again counted and it was found that in the said bundle six invalid votes were there. The allegation thereafter is that counting officials were orally asked to get other bundles counted which was refused by the authorities with the observation that all other bundles are correct. It was further stated that one application was also given by the husband of the election petitioner to Counting Officer which application was torn. It is claimed that thereafter the application was sent to District Magistrate and Chief Development Officer at 9 A.M and information was sent on telephone regarding irregularity in the counting. It was claimed that invalid votes are more than 57. In view of the aforesaid allegation the prayer for recounting of votes was made. The husband of election petitioner appeared in the witness box and has repeated the allegations made in the election petition. Form the averments made in the election petition as well as in the statement of P.W 1, it is clear that it is not even mentioned that at the time of counting of votes or declaring votes invalid any objection was made. According to Rule 104 of 1994 Rules a candidate or agent of the candidate has right to raise objection regarding any votes which is claimed to be invalid and if objection is raised the returning officer is obliged to record reasons for rejection. The averment did not even suggest that any objection was raised when the votes were counted. The basis of election petition is that in one of the bundles six invalid votes were found and if other bundles of returned candidate were counted more invalid votes would come out. There is no detail of any of invalid vote, which is claimed to be included in the bundles of return candidate. Election tribunal in its judgment has clearly held that from the submissions of counsel of election petitioner it appears that election petition is founded on the basis of suspicion that if votes are counted again there may be different result. Election tribunal also held that there is no evidence that in one bundle of return candidate six invalid votes were found. However, he proceeded on the assumption that even if it is accepted that in one bundle six invalid votes were found there is no guarantee that in all bundles there will be invalid votes. The case as set-up by the election petitioner in the election petition is very clear from the statement of her husband who was agent of the election petitioner as deposed in the statement. The Election petitioner's husband in his statement has made following statement:
19. The statement clearly shows that the case of the election petitioner was that if the other bundles are recounted then many invalid votes would have been found. The witness stated that he has full confidence that in other bundles several invalid votes will be there. The statement made by the witness makes out the case of the election petitioner that it is his confidence that in other bundles there will be many invalid votes on which he is claiming recount. Further incident of one bundle has been cited.
20. At this stage, it will be pertinent to refer the decision of the Apex Court in Vedivalu's case (supra). The aforesaid case was also considering the question of recount of panchayat election. It is to be noted that in the aforesaid case there was difference of only one vote and in the recount the election petitioner was declared elected. The order of the tribunal directing for recounting was challenged before the High Court. The High Court set aside the order of Tribunal and held that there were no ground to direct for recount. In paragraph 17 of the judgment of the Apex Court, the averments made in the election petition were quoted. The averments in the aforesaid case were also to the effect that several invalid votes have been counted in the return candidate. Paragraphs 17 and 18 of the judgment in Vedivalu's case (supra) is quoted below:
“17. In the instant case, the appellant in his election petition alleged in paras 5 and 6 as under:
“…………. The wrong electoral roll was utilized by the Presiding Officer. The appellant and his agents strongly protested against the wrong electoral roll. The dead persons' names were deleted from the electoral roll, and other Panchayat Villagers' names were in the electoral roll. The 1st respondent utilized the same. The appellant and his agent strongly objected but the Presiding Officer, has not taken any care about the electoral roll and impersonation. The said votes polled in favour of the Ist respondent are void and therefore have to be excluded.
While counting of votes, the appellants and his agents represented these facts and requested the Counting Officers and the Returning Officer both orally and in writing to reject these votes polled by these persons. But they refused to consider the said objections. Their such acts are illegal… The Counting Officers want only put the appellant's valid votes to invalid vote box. The appellant's valid votes were added in the invalid votes. The appellant and his agents strongly objected but the Counting Officers and Returning Officers did not care about the objections. The Counting Officers counted the votes in favour of the 1st Respondent. Furthermore, the Counting Officer did not know which is valid vote and which is invalid vote. During the polling votes, the Booth Officers received the thumb impression from some voters and gave the ballot papers. The thumb impression ink marks were available in the ballot papers. The same votes were rejected and put into the invalid votes. The Counting Officers were newly appointed. They were not properly counting the votes. The Counting Officers were counting the votes very fast and they had not shown the ballots to the agents, even when they raised objection. The Counting Officers threatened the appellant's agent and told him that they are Supreme Authority for counting votes…. Finally, the Returning Officer announced that the 1st respondent had secured 1011 votes. The appellant secured 1010 votes. The difference is only one vote. More than 100 votes were added in the invalid votes by the Counting Officers. Some invalid votes were included to the 1st respondent which were void and which ought to have been rejected. The Counting Officers and the Returning Officers had not seen the intention of the voters in the ballot.”
“18. From the above pleadings, it is evident that the appellant has not set forth material facts or particulars required for recount of votes. To justify his contention that there was irregularity or illegality in the counting, except making some general and bald allegations, no other details are given. Though an allegation is made that the electoral roll contained the names of dead persons, that the 1st respondent took advantage of the same, and that some persons had impersonated and cast votes in his favour, no details are given as to who committed such irregularity. The appellant has also not mentioned as to how many such votes had been cast in favour of the 1st respondent. So also, the appellant has not alleged the nature of the illegality or irregularity said to have been committed by the Counting Officers. How and in what manner there was improper acceptance of invalid votes and improper rejection of valid votes also is not explained by the appellant. In short, the election petition is benefit of all details and the appellant, while examined as PW 1, could not supplement anything by way of evidence.”
21. From the facts, which have been brought on the record of the writ petition, it is clear that petitioner has not come out with any specific case as to which part of Rule 104 of 1994 Rules pertaining to counting has been violated in the present case. The averments made in the present case are similar to one which was made in Vedivalu's case (supra).
22. The Prescribed Authority/election tribunal after considering the evidence on the record rightly held that no ground for recount of votes has been made out and has dismissed the election petition. The Additional District Judge exercising the revisional Court power has set-aside the order of election tribunal and directed for recount. I have gone through the order of revisional Court. The revisional court has only observed in the judgment that there were concrete evidence on the record for recount. However, the revisional Court in its judgment has neither pointed out nor adverted to as to what is the concrete evidence on the record enabling order of recount to be passed. Following findings were recorded by the revisional Court for allowing the revision:
23. Apart from the aforesaid findings, there is no other discussion in the judgment of the revisional Court or any evidence on the record nor there is any reference of any evidence considered by the revisional Court in whole of the judgment. The aforesaid observation of the revisional Court only indicate the conclusion of the revisional court to the effect that manipulation has been done in the counting somewhere and the counting has not been held according to counting rules. The revisional Court has not adverted or held that what is the irregularity in the counting and at what stage manipulation has been done in the counting. The aforesaid conclusion of the revisional court is only a general conclusion without considering the evidence. In view of the fact that election tribunal in the present case after considering the evidence has dismissed the election petition and refused the prayer for recount, it was necessary for the revisional court to point out error of jurisdiction of the election tribunal. The scope of jurisdiction of the revisional Court under section 12C (6) of U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 is not that of an appellate court. section 12-C (6) is quoted as below:
“12-C.. ………………… ………………… ………………… ………………… ………………… ………………… ………………… ………………… ………………… ………………… ………………… ………………… ………………… …………………
(7) Any party aggrieved by an order of the Prescribed Authority upon an application under sub-section (1), may, within thirty days from the date of the order, apply to the District Judge for revision of such order on any one or more of the following grounds, namely:
(a) that the prescribed authority has exercised a jurisdiction not vested in it by law;
(b) that the prescribed authority has failed to exercise a jurisdiction so vested;
(c) that the prescribed authority has acted in the exercise of its jurisdiction illegally or with material irregularity.”
24. The Additional District Judge while deciding the revision could have interfered after recording finding that election tribunal has committed any error as laid down in sub-clause (6) of section 12-C of U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947.
25. On the basis of above quoted observations made by the revisional court, the judgment of the election tribunal could not have been interfered with nor on the aforesaid observation the revisional court could have directed for recount of the votes. In view of the facts of the present case and the observations as made, the revisional court committed error in interfering with the order of election tribunal.
26. The submission raised on behalf of the writ petitioner that since election petition did not appear in the witness box, no order for recount could have been passed also need to be considered. The counsel for the petitioner has relied on the judgment of the Apex Court in Rajankumar Shankarrao Teware's case (supra). Although the Apex Court in the aforesaid judgment has noted in paragraph 9 that defeated candidate, Sri Tewari did not appear as a witness to support the allegations made in the election petition but no such proposition has been laid down that unless defeated candidate appear in the witness box, the averments of election petition and other evidence cannot be looked into. In the aforesaid case the Apex Court held in paragraph 23 that after perusing the evidence which are available on record they are of the opinion that the appellants have failed to establish a prima facie case for inspection of ballot papers. Thus the Apex Court in the aforesaid judgment itself considered all evidence available on the record. The mere fact that election petitioner did not herself appeared in the witness box cannot be fetter for the election petitioner or for the prayer for recount in the facts of the present case. Thus the submission of counsel for the writ petitioner that since the election petitioner did not appear in the witness box prayer for recount should not have been considered cannot be accepted.
27. Much emphasis was laid down by Sri R.S Shukla, counsel for the respondents, on the judgment of this Court in Smt. Maya Devi's case (supra). It was submitted that since the present case revisional court has remanded the case for recount, it does not call for any interference. The decision of this Court in Smt. Maya Devi's case (supra) was based on its own fact. From the facts of that case it appears that application for recount was allowed by Prescribed Authority against which elected candidate filed writ petition No. 2039 of 2001 which was dismissed by learned single Judge. Recounting was conducted by the Prescribed Authority and election petitioner was declared elected in recounting by order dated 23rd June, 2001 by margin of one vote. Against the order dated 23rd June, 2001 revision was filed by the respondents and the revisional court set aside the order of Prescribed Authority dated 23rd June, 2001 directing the Prescribed Authority to recount the votes of the parties again in the light of the observation made in the body of the order. In the aforesaid case, the question as to whether recount should be made or not was not an issue. The challenge in that case was the method or procedure of recount and in that view of the matter the Court directed the Prescribed Authority to again recount the vote. This Court in facts of the aforesaid case held in paragraph 12 as under:
“12. In the peculiar facts and circumstances of the present case, it is held that the order passed by revisional court dated 29.8.2001 (Annexure-7 to the writ petition) is eminently just and proper and does not require interference under Article 227 of the Constitution. The learned Revisional Court has given cogent convincing reasons in support of its order, with which I am in full agreement. The revisional court has only remanded the case for recounting in accordance with law, which does not call for interference, ordinarily no writ is maintainable against remand order.”
28. From paragraph 12 of the aforesaid judgment, as quoted above, it is clear that writ petition was dismissed by the High Court in the peculiar circumstances of that case. Further as noted above, the question in that writ petition was different which was regarding the procedure and mode of recounting. The revision was filed against declaration of result on the basis of recount. Thus the aforesaid judgment is not attracted in the facts of the present case. Further in the present case it is not a case of remand as submitted by counsel for the writ petitioner. Election petition in the present case was dismissed by the election tribunal, which order has been set-aside by the revisional court and the revisional court has also directed for recounting of votes. The recount has been finally directed by the revisional court and there is no remand of that issue. Thus, the submission of counsel for the writ petitioner that since only remand has been made, hence this Court may not interfere with the order can also not be accepted. There is no remand in the present case but direction has been issued to election tribunal to recount the votes.
29. The next case relied by counsel for the respondents in Anuradhika's case (supra) in which Additional District Judge directed for inspection of ballots. From the averments made in paragraph 6 of the aforesaid judgment, it is clear that in that case specific averments were made in election petition that four ballot papers were found with special marks by which electors of these votes can be identified but only one vote was rejected and three votes were counted in favour of the petitioner of that case. In view of the aforesaid facts, this Court held that election Tribunal did not commit any error in directing for inspection of ballot papers. Further, from the aforesaid judgment, it is clear that election tribunal in that case being satisfied has directed for recount on the averments made in the election petition. Thus the aforesaid case is also on its own fact and the Court was satisfied that there was sufficient ground for directing recount. The aforesaid judgment also does not help the election petitioner in any manner. The order of inspection of ballots has to be considered in each case on the basis of its own facts. The principles for considering an order of recount are well settled as noted above.
30. The counsel for the respondents lastly contended that election tribunal while passing order of recount has to act as prudent man. The submission of counsel for the respondents is that election tribunal for directing recount has to be acted as prudent man and further only prima facie case was required to be proved. Reliance was placed on judgment of the Apex Court in Martin Burn Ltd. case (supra). There is no dispute with regard to principle laid down for determining a prima facie case. In the aforesaid case, the question was as to whether on the evidence lead it was possible to arrive at the conclusion that prima facie case has been proved. In the aforesaid case the Apex Court held that relevant consideration is whether on the evidence lead, it was possible to arrive at the conclusion and whether that was the only conclusion which can be arrived at on that evidence. The election tribunal in the present case did not find any prima facie case to direct recount. The aforesaid case does not help the respondents in any manner. The submission of counsel for the respondents that while directing recount of ballot, the tribunal ought to function as prudent would have directed for recount, no error can be found in the order of revisional court. I am unable to persuade myself to accept this argument. The principles on which recount can be ordered are well settled as noted above by various Apex Court judgments. The theory of decision by a prudent man has never accepted while considering the question of directing for recount. The submission raised by counsel for the respondents cannot be accepted since it will give much room of discretion and subjective consideration by authority directing for recount. The scope of subjective consideration is ruled out in directing recount of votes. Thus this submission of counsel for the respondents is also not acceptable.
31. The right to seek election and right to challenge election is not a common law right. The said right has to be exercised in accordance with statutory rules. A candidate has right to challenge election in accordance with statutory rules. The courts have insisted on maintaining the secrecy of ballots in democratic election. The rules providing for counting provides for several checks and balances for counting of the votes and at every stage in counting candidate his or her counting agents have been given right to raise objection. The counting process itself give opportunity to election petitioner to lay strong foundation on materials facts to challenge the process of election when there are no material facts giving details the Court will not permit roving and fishing enquiry in the election matter to fish out the evidence or material. From the evidence which have come on the record, as noted above, it is clear that recount was being asked in the present case only on belief and suspicion. It was mere suspicion of the election petitioner and her agent that there might be more invalid voters in bundles of return candidate, hence recount be ordered. On the principles noted above, recount cannot be ordered on the basis of the aforesaid allegations.
32. For the reasons given above, the order of the revisional court cannot be sustained. The writ petition is allowed. The judgment and order of Additional District Judge dated 22nd May, 2002 is set-aside. There will be no order as to costs.
Alert