Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mahendra Prakash Srivastava v. District Judge

Allahabad High Court
Jul 15, 2013
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion delivered by Hon'ble Sudhir Agarwal, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is a retired employee whose gratuity (referred to in the opinion as retiral benefits) was withheld by the respondents for an extended period (more than two years). Learned counsel for the respondents, Sri Yashwant Verma, stated that at the time of the petitioner’s retirement no departmental enquiry was pending against the petitioner; he further informed the Court that two enquiries were initiated in 2013 but could not point to any statutory provision authorising the respondents to withhold gratuity when no enquiry was pending at the time of retirement. The petitioner filed a writ petition challenging the withholding of gratuity. The Court disposed of that writ petition by allowing it and directing the respondents to release the gratuity with interest and awarding costs to the petitioner.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether withholding of the petitioner’s gratuity by the respondents for an extended period (more than two years) was lawful and justified where no departmental enquiry was pending at the time of retirement.
  2. Whether the petitioner was entitled to interest on the delayed payment of retiral benefits and, if so, at what rate and from which date interest should be computed.
  3. Whether the Court could or should award costs (including exemplary or compensatory costs) against the respondents in view of the alleged arbitrary withholding of lawful dues.
  4. Whether, as a general proposition, a provisional payment of 90% of gratuity must be made even if an enquiry is pending at the time of retirement (and the application of that proposition to the present facts).

Arguments of the Parties

Respondents' Arguments

  • Learned counsel for the respondents fairly stated that at the time of the petitioner’s retirement no departmental enquiry was pending against the petitioner.
  • He submitted that in the year 2013 two enquiries were initiated (presumably post-retirement), but he could not demonstrate any statutory provision under which gratuity could be lawfully withheld where no enquiry was pending at the time of retirement or that respondents had authority to withhold gratuity for such a prolonged period.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Cassell & Co. Ltd. v. Broome, 1972 AC 1027 (Lord Hailsham) Observations concerning harassment of an ordinary citizen by powerful authorities (as referred to in Lucknow Development Authority). Referenced (through Lucknow Development Authority) to illustrate the unacceptable nature of public authority harassment of citizens.
Rooks v. Barnard, 1964 AC 1129 (Lord Devlin) Observations concerning harassment by public authorities (as referred to in Lucknow Development Authority). Referenced (through Lucknow Development Authority) to support the Court's view that harassment by public authorities is socially abhorring and legally impermissible.
Lucknow Development Authority v. M.K. Gupta, 1993 (6) SC 307 Principle that a public functionary acting maliciously or oppressively results in abuse of power and that harassment by public authorities is legally impermissible. Quoted at length (para 10) and relied upon to underline the impropriety and illegality of oppressive action by public authorities causing harassment.
Ghaziabad Development Authority v. Balbir Singh, 2004 (5) SC 17 Reiteration of principles relating to accountability of public authorities and impermissibility of harassment. Cited as a reaffirmation of the principles set out in Lucknow Development Authority.
Registered Society v. Union of India, (1996) 6 SCC 530 Public servants cannot claim immunity from personal liability where their actions are mala fide or arbitrary. Quoted to support the proposition that no public servant can arrogate to himself arbitrary powers or act in an arbitrary manner without accountability.
Shivsagar Tiwari v. Union of India, (1996) 6 SCC 558 Statement that an arbitrary system is corrupt and self-serving. Quoted to reinforce the Court’s condemnation of arbitrary administrative action.
Delhi Development Authority v. Skipper Construction, AIR 1996 SC 715 Observations that democratic government is not lax; rules and natural justice prevent guilty persons from using procedure to delay justice. Applied to emphasise the duty to ensure that administrative processes do not become instruments of delay and injustice.
State of Kerala v. M. Padmanabhan Nair, 1985 (1) SLR-750 Necessity for prompt payment of retirement dues and justification for commencement of penal interest (suggested to commence after two months from retirement). Used as foundational authority to support the award of interest on delayed payment of retiral benefits.
Shamal Chand Tiwari v. State of U.P. (Writ Petition No. 34804 of 2004), decided 6.12.2005 (High Court) Application of principle that inaction/inordinate delay in payment of retiral benefits warrants liability for interest. Cited as a local precedent in which the Court sustained a claim for interest on delayed retiral benefits, following Padmanabhan Nair.
O.P. Gupta v. Union of India, (1987) 4 SCC 328 One of a series of Supreme Court decisions upholding entitlement to interest on delayed payment of retiral dues. Listed among authorities relied upon for the proposition that interest on delayed retiral dues is appropriate.
R. Kapur v. Director of Inspection, (1994) 6 SCC 589 Authority supporting award of interest on delayed payment of retiral benefits. Cited as part of the chain of decisions upholding interest awards on delayed retiral payments.
S.R. Bhanrate v. Union of India, AIR 1997 SC 27 Authority in the series of cases supporting interest on delayed retiral payments. Referred to as part of the catena of decisions upholding interest awards.
Uma Agarwal v. State of U.P., (1999) 3 SCC 438 Authority supporting award of interest on delayed payment of retiral dues. Cited as part of the line of authority on interest entitlement for delayed retiral dues.
S.K. Dua v. State of Haryana, (2008) 3 SCC 44 Another Supreme Court authority in the chain that supports interest on delayed payments. Included among precedents relied upon to justify an interest award on delayed gratuity/pension payments.
Rajeshwar Swarup Gupta v. State of U.P., 2011 (2) ADJ 608 Division Bench decision awarding interest (12% in that case) on delayed payment of retiral benefits, following Padmanabhan Nair and subsequent cases. Cited to illustrate recent High Court practice and to support the Court's power to award interest (and the quantum used in other matters).
Smt. Kavita Kumar v. State of U.P., (2008) 119 FLR 787 Earlier Division Bench judgment of the High Court relevant to interest awards on delayed retiral benefits. Referenced as part of the High Court’s precedential practice supporting interest awards.
Gurpal Singh v. State of Punjab, AIR 2005 SC 2755 Authority permitting the Court to award exemplary or compensatory costs to prevent crafty invasion of law and to promote good faith. Relied upon to justify the Court's power to award costs in cases where authorities have caused grievous hardship by negligent or arbitrary action.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeds from established factual findings to the legal conclusions set out below:

  1. Factual finding: The respondents' counsel conceded that at the time of the petitioner’s retirement there was no departmental enquiry pending; the respondents later initiated two enquiries in 2013 but could not point to any provision permitting withholding of gratuity where no enquiry existed at retirement.
  2. Legal and constitutional framework: The respondents are treated as "State" for the purposes of Article 12 of the Constitution, and their officers are public functionaries who must act in a people-oriented manner and cannot oppressively exercise power. The Court emphasises constitutional values — social and economic justice — and the obligation of public authorities not to harass citizens, particularly their former employees.
  3. Condemnation of arbitrary withholding: The Court characterises the prolonged withholding of retiral benefits as illegal, arbitrary, morally and socially obnoxious, and contrary to constitutional principles. It relies on a line of authority (including Lucknow Development Authority v. M.K. Gupta and related decisions) to underscore that malicious or oppressive exercise of public power is abuse and legally impermissible.
  4. Entitlement to interest: The Court reasons that where retiral benefits are paid with extraordinary delay, it is appropriate to award compensatory interest to provide some solace to the aggrieved retiree. The Court notes that the entitlement to interest on delayed retiral dues has been repeatedly upheld in a catena of cases, including State of Kerala v. M. Padmanabhan Nair (which suggests commencement of penal interest after two months from retirement) and other Supreme Court and High Court decisions.
  5. Provisional payment principle: The Court records the legal position (as stated in the opinion) that 90% of gratuity is to be treated as a provisional payment even if an enquiry is pending at the time of retirement; however, in the present case even that provisional-payment scenario does not arise because no enquiry was pending at retirement.
  6. Remedial measures and costs: The Court notes its power, in appropriate cases where grievous hardship is suffered by an individual due to negligent or arbitrary conduct of state authorities, to award exemplary or compensatory costs to deter recurrence. It cites Gurpal Singh v. State of Punjab in support of this remedial approach.
  7. Application to present facts: Applying these principles, the Court finds the respondents’ conduct in withholding the petitioner’s gratuity for over two years to be "patently illegal, erroneous, unjust, improper and unwarranted" and accordingly grants relief to the petitioner.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition was allowed. The Court directed Respondent No. 1 to forthwith release the petitioner’s gratuity along with interest at the rate of 10% per annum, to be computed from one month after the date of the petitioner’s retirement until actual payment. The petitioner was also awarded costs quantified at Rs. 5,000/-.

Direct consequences for the parties: the respondents must immediately pay the withheld gratuity, pay interest at 10% p.a. from one month after retirement until payment, and pay the quantified costs to the petitioner.

Broader implications: The opinion reiterates and applies established principles condemning arbitrary and oppressive conduct by public authorities and affirms the practice of awarding interest and, where appropriate, costs to a retired employee whose lawful dues have been unreasonably withheld. The opinion does not purport to announce a new legal principle beyond those precedents cited; it applies established authorities to the facts before the Court.

Show all summary ...

Hon'ble Sudhir Agarwal, J.

1. After receiving instructions, Sri Yashwant Verma, learned Counsel appearing for respondents fairly stated that at the time of retirement, no departmental enquiry was pending against petitioner. He, however, submitted that in the year 2013, two enquiries have been initiated but could not show any provision under which if any enquiry was not pending against an employee at the time of retirement, still his gratuity would not have been paid or respondents were authorized by some other provision to withhold gratuity of petitioner for such a long time.

2. Withholding of retiral benefits of retired employees for years together is not only illegal and arbitrary but a sin if not an offence since no law has declared so. The officials, who are still in service and are instrumental in such delay causing harassment to the retired employee must however feel afraid of committing such a sin. It is morally and socially obnoxious. It is also against the concept of social and economic justice which is one of the founding pillar of our constitution.

3. The respondents being “State” under Article 12 of the Constitution of India, its officers are public functionaries. As observed above, under our Constitution, sovereignty vest in the people. Every limb of constitutional machinery therefore is obliged to be people oriented. Public authorities acting in violation of constitutional or statutory provisions oppressively are accountable for their behaviour. It is high time that this Court should remind respondents that they are expected to perform in a more responsible and reasonable manner so as not to cause undue and avoidable harassment to the public at large and in particular their ex-employees and their legal heirs like the petitioner. The respondents have the support of entire machinery and various powers of statute. An ordinary citizen or a common man is hardly equipped to match such might of State or its instrumentalities. Harassment of a common man by public authorities is socially abhorring and legally impressible. This may harm the common man personally but the injury to society is far more grievous. Crime and corruption, thrive and prosper in society due to lack of public resistance. An ordinary citizen instead of complaining and fighting mostly succumbs to the pressure of undesirable functioning in offices instead of standing against it. It is on account of, sometimes, lack of resources or unmatched status which give the feeling of helplessness. Nothing is more damaging than the feeling of helplessness. Even in ordinary matters a common man who has neither the political backing nor the financial strength to match inaction in public oriented departments gets frustrated and it erodes the credibility in the system. This is unfortunate that matters which require immediate attention are being allowed to linger on and remain unattended. No authority can allow itself to act in a manner which is arbitrary. Public administration no doubt involves a vast amount of administrative discretion which shields action of administrative authority but where it is found that the exercise of power is capricious or other than bona fide, it is the duty of the Court to take effective steps and rise to occasion otherwise the confidence of the common man would shake. It is the responsibility of Court in such matters to immediately rescue such common man so that he may have the confidence that he is not helpless but a bigger authority is there to take care of him and to restrain arbitrary and arrogant, unlawful inaction or illegal exercise of power on the part of the public functionaries.

4. In our system, the Constitution is supreme, but the real power vest in the people of India. The Constitution has been enacted “for the people, by the people and of the people”. A public functionary cannot be permitted to act like a dictator causing harassment to a common man and in particular when the person subject to harassment is his own employee.

5. Regarding harassment of a common man, referring to observations of Lord Hailsham in Cassell & Co. Ltd. v. Broome, 1972 AC 1027 and Lord Devlin in Rooks v. Barnard1964 AC 1129, the Apex Court in Lucknow Development Authority v. M.K Gupta. 1993 (6) SC 307 held as under:

“An Ordinary citizen or a common man is hardly equipped to match the might of the State or its instrumentalities. That is provided by the rule of law……. A public functionary if he acts maliciously or oppressively and the exercise of power results in harassment and agony then it is not an exercise of power but its abuse. No law provides protection against it. He who is responsible for it must suffer it………..Harassment of a common man by public authorities is socially abhorring and legally impermissible. It may harm him personally but the injury to society is far more grievous.” (para 10)

6. The above observations as such have been reiterated in Ghaziabad Development Authority v. Balbir Singh 2004 (5) SC 17.

7. In a democratic system governed by rule of law, the Government does not mean a lax Government. The public servants hold their offices in trust and are expected to perform with due diligence particularly so that their action or inaction may not cause any undue hardship and harassment to a common man. Whenever it comes to the notice of this Court that the Government or its officials have acted with gross negligence and unmindful action causing harassment of a common and helpless man, this Court has never been a silent spectator but always reacted to bring the authorities to law.

8. In Registered Society v. Union of India(1996) 6 SCC 530 the Apex court said:

“No public servant can say “you may set aside an order on the ground of mala fide but you can not hold me personally liable” No public servant can arrogate in himself the power to act in a manner which is arbitrary”.

9. In Shivsagar Tiwari v. Union of India(1996) 6 SCC 558 the Apex Court has held:

“An arbitrary system indeed must always be a corrupt one. There never was a man who thought he had no law but his own will who did not soon find that he had no end but his own profit.”

10. In Delhi Development Authority v. Skipper ConstructionAIR 1996 SC 715 has held as follows:

“A democratic Government does not mean a lax Government. The rules of procedure and/or principles of natural justice are not mean to enable the guilty to delay and defeat the just retribution. The wheel of justice may appear to grind slowly but it is duty of all of us to ensure that they do grind steadily and grind well and truly. The justice system cannot be allowed to become soft, supine and spineless.”

11. Now, coming to another aspect of the matter, if retiral benefits are paid with extra ordinary delay, the Court should award suitable interest which is compensatory in nature so as to cause some solace to the harassed employee. No Government official should have the liberty of harassing a hopeless employee or his heirs by withholding his/her lawful dues for a long time and thereafter to escape from any liability so as to boast that nobody can touch him even if he commits an ex facie illegal, unjust or arbitrary act. Every authority howsoever high must always keep in mind that nobody is above law. The hands of justice are meant not only to catch out such person but it is also the constitutional duty of Court of law to pass suitable orders in such matters so that such illegal acts may not be repeated, not only by him/her but others also. This should be a lesson to everyone committing such unjust act.

12. Interest on delayed payment on retiral dues has been upheld time and against in a catena of decision. This Court in Shamal Chand Tiwari v. State of U.P (Writ Petition No. 34804 of 2004) decided on 6.12.2005 held:

“Now the question comes about entitlement of the petitioner for interest on delayed payment of retiral benefits. Since the date of retirement is known to the respondents well in advance, there is no reason for them not to make arrangement for payment of retiral benefits to the petitioner well in advance so that as soon as the employee retires, his retiral benefits are paid on the date of retirement or within reasonable time thereafter. Inaction and inordinate delay in payment of retiral benefits is nothing but culpable delay warranting liability of interest on such dues. In the case of State of Kerala v. M. Padmnanaban Nair, 1985 (1) SLR-750, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held as follows:

“Since the date of retirement of every Government servant is very much known in advance we fail to appreciate why the process of collecting the requisite information and issuance of these two documents should not be completed at least a week before the date of retirement so that the payment of gratuity amount could be made to the Government servant on the date he retires or on the following day and pension at the expiry of the following months. The necessity for prompt payment of the retirement dues to a Government servant immediately after his retirement cannot be overemphasized and it would not be unreasonable to direct that the liability to pay panel interest on these dues at the current market rate should commence at the expiry of two months from the date of retirement.” In this view of the matter, this Court is of the view that the claim of the petitioner for interest on the delayed payment of retiral benefits has to be sustained.”

13. It has been followed and reiterated in O.P Gupta v. Union of India(1987) 4 SCC 328, R. Kapur v. Director of Inspection(1994) 6 SCC 589, S.R Bhanrate v. Union of IndiaAIR 1997 SC 27, Dr. Uma Agarwal v. State of U.P(1999) 3 SCC 438 and S.K Dua v. State of Haryana(2008) 3 SCC 44.

14. A Division Bench of this Court has also considered the question of award of interest on delayed payment of retiral benefits recently in Rajeshwar Swarup Gupta v. State of U.P2011 (2) ADJ 608 and, relying on the Apex Court decision in M. Padmnanaban Nair (supra) and its several follow up as also an earlier Division Bench judgement of this Court in Smt. Kavita Kumar v. State of U.P(2008) 119 FLR 787, has awarded 12% interest in the said case.

15. In view of the above, I have no hesitation in holding that non payment of gratuity to petitioner is wholly arbitrary and unreasonable. There was no justification at all for respondents to delay payment thereof.

16. In a case where the person who has invoked extraordinary equitable jurisdiction satisfying the Court that in the hands of authorities of state instrumentality, individual has suffered grievously, the Court, while deciding the matter, can also pass an order of exemplary cost compensatory in nature so that such authorities may not recur the similar negligence in future. In Gurpal Singh v. State of Punjab, AIR 2005 SC 2755 it was held that the Court must do justice by promotion of good faith and prevent law from crafty invasion.

17. Be that as it may, in any case, 90% of gratuity being provisional payment has to be made even if an enquiry would have been pending at the time of retirement but in the present case even that is not the state of affairs. In these facts and circumstances it is evident that withholding of gratuity for more than two years on the part of the respondents is patently illegal, erroneous, unjust, improper and unwarranted.

18. The writ petition is accordingly allowed. Respondent no. 1 is directed to forthwith release gratuity to the petitioner alongwith interest @ 10% p.a To be computed after a month from the date of retirement, till the payment is actually made.

19. The petitioner shall also be entitled to cost which is quantified to Rs. 5,000/-.