Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Thimmappa Shambhu Bhatta And Another v. Ramachandra Krishna Bhatta And Another

Karnataka High Court
Nov 16, 1978
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an appeal by the plaintiffs against the judgment and decree dated 26 March 1973 of the Civil Judge, North Kanara at Karwar (R.A. No. 7/66), which confirmed a Munsiff's decree dated 27 October 1965 dismissing the plaintiffs' suit for partition of two properties.

Earlier, the plaintiffs had instituted O.S. No. 19/53, a partition suit that included the two disputed properties as part of the family properties. In that earlier suit the defendants asserted in their written statement that those two properties were trust properties requiring permission from the Charity Commissioner for partition. On that representation, the plaintiffs submitted Exhibit 36, restricting their suit in that earlier proceeding by withdrawing the two items from that suit; the earlier suit was thereafter decreed in relation to the remaining properties, awarding two-thirds share to the plaintiffs.

The plaintiffs later applied to the Charity Commissioner for permission to partition the two properties; their petition was dismissed, and upon appeal to the Revenue Appellate Tribunal the Tribunal held that permission was not necessary for a suit for partition. Subsequently, the plaintiffs instituted the present suit for partition of the two properties.

The defendants in the present suit raised multiple defenses, including (a) perfection of title by adverse possession, (b) that the suit was barred by Order 2 Rule 2 and Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), and (c) that the suit was not maintainable under the Bombay Prevention of Fragmentation and Consolidation of Holdings Act. The Munsiff dismissed the plaintiffs' suit on the evidence. The Civil Judge agreed with the Munsiff on the bars under Order 2 Rule 2 and Order 23 Rule 1 and dismissed the appeal, though he disagreed with the Munsiff's findings on adverse possession and the Fragmentation Act. The plaintiffs appealed to this Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the courts below were justified in dismissing the plaintiffs' partition suit as barred by Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure?
  2. Whether the courts below were justified in dismissing the plaintiffs' partition suit as barred by Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellants (plaintiffs) contended that, on the facts of the case, neither Order 2 Rule 2 nor Order 23 Rule 1 of the CPC applied so as to bar the present suit.
  • They relied on the fact that Exhibit 36 had restricted the earlier suit only for the purposes of that suit, and that they had acted bona fide in withdrawing the two properties after defendants' representation that Charity Commissioner permission was necessary; they also pursued administrative and appellate remedies (Charity Commissioner and Revenue Appellate Tribunal) before instituting the present suit.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondents supported the Civil Judge's decision and maintained that the suit was barred under Order 2 Rule 2 and Order 23 Rule 1 of the CPC (and had also pleaded adverse possession and non-maintainability under the Bombay Prevention of Fragmentation and Consolidation of Holdings Act).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Savitri Bai v. Devendra Balappa Patil, 1964 My. L.J. Supplement, p. 474 The Division Bench ruled that Order 2 Rule 2 of the CPC does not apply to partition suits in certain circumstances; the governing principle is that an acceptable explanation for the incompleteness of the first suit sustains a subsequent suit for partition. The Court relied on this decision to hold that the plaintiffs' explanation (Exhibit 36 and their subsequent proceedings before the Charity Commissioner and the Revenue Appellate Tribunal) was an acceptable explanation, and therefore the present suit was not barred by Order 2 Rule 2.
Keesari Santamma v. Hanumantha Reddi Venkatarama Reddi, A.I.R. 1935 Madras 909 The Madras High Court stated that the cause of action for a partition suit is a recurring one. The Court invoked this principle to support the proposition that a party who withdraws or postpones a claim for partition may bring a fresh suit later (subject to an acceptable explanation), and to hold that the present suit could proceed despite the earlier restriction.
A.I.R. 1960 Pat. 76 Cited in the opinion as authority for the recurring nature of the cause of action in partition suits (supporting the rule that a party may maintain a second suit if an acceptable explanation for the first suit's incompleteness is offered). The Court referred to this authority to reinforce the conclusion that the plaintiffs could maintain the present suit without having obtained court permission to withdraw the earlier claim, provided they offered an acceptable explanation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in two analytical stages, addressing (A) Order 2 Rule 2 and (B) Order 23 Rule 1 of the CPC.

A. Order 2 Rule 2

  • The Court recounted that in the earlier suit (O.S. No. 19/53) the defendants had represented that the two disputed properties were trust properties requiring Charity Commissioner permission; relying on that representation, the plaintiffs executed Exhibit 36, which restricted their earlier suit by excluding the two properties for the purposes of that suit.
  • The Court examined Exhibit 36, which states that the plaintiffs "restrict their suit for partitioning all the suit properties except serials 1 and 2 in schedule 'A' of the plaint for the purposes of this suit only." The Court treated this as evidence that the plaintiffs did not abandon their rights to those properties permanently but postponed inclusion of those items in that particular suit.
  • The Court noted the plaintiffs' subsequent conduct: applying to the Charity Commissioner, litigating to the Revenue Appellate Tribunal (which held permission unnecessary), and thereafter instituting the present suit. That sequence indicated a bona fide belief at the time of the earlier suit that partition of those properties was not then possible.
  • Relying on the Division Bench decision in Savitri Bai and related reasoning, the Court adopted the principle that a second suit for partition is permissible where there is an acceptable explanation for why the first suit was incomplete. Applying that principle to the facts (the defendants' representation, Exhibit 36, and subsequent administrative and appellate steps), the Court found the plaintiffs' explanation acceptable and legal, and therefore held that Order 2 Rule 2 did not bar the present suit.

B. Order 23 Rule 1

  • The Court reproduced the language of Order 23 Rule 1, which permits a plaintiff to abandon his suit or part of his claim after instituting a suit.
  • The Court interpreted Exhibit 36 as showing that the plaintiffs had restricted their claim "for the purposes of that suit only" and had not intended to abandon their claim to the two properties altogether.
  • Given the recurring character of the cause of action in partition suits (as supported by Keesari Santamma and cited authorities), the Court concluded that it was not necessary for the plaintiffs to obtain the court's permission to withdraw the claim regarding those properties in order to maintain a subsequent suit, provided an acceptable explanation for the earlier restriction was offered.
  • Applying these propositions to the facts, the Court was satisfied that Order 23 Rule 1 did not bar the present suit.

On these grounds the Court concluded that the Civil Judge had committed an error of law in holding the suit barred under Order 2 Rule 2 and Order 23 Rule 1. (The Court noted that the Civil Judge had disagreed with some of the Munsiff's other findings, but the appeal was decided on the basis of these legal bars.)

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED.

Direct consequences and directions issued by the Court:

  • The judgments and decrees of the courts below are set aside.
  • The suit is remitted to the trial court for disposal on merits: the trial court is directed to proceed to dispose of the suit on merits, fix the shares of the plaintiffs and pass a preliminary decree in accordance with law, having due regard to the observations made in the opinion.
  • There shall be no order as to costs in the appeal.
  • The parties are directed to be present before the trial court on 9 January 1979 to take further instructions from the trial court.
  • Refund of admissible court-fees and immediate return of the records to the trial court were ordered.

The opinion resolves the two procedural bars (Order 2 Rule 2 and Order 23 Rule 1) in favour of the plaintiffs on the specific facts and explanation offered; it remits the matter for a merits determination. The opinion applies and cites existing authorities on recurring causes of action and the circumstances in which a second partition suit is permissible; it does not purport to lay down a novel general rule beyond the authorities it cites.

Show all summary ...

Sabhahit, J.:— This is a plaintiffs' appeal against the judgment and decree dated 26th March 1973 passed by the Civil Judge, North Kanara at Karwar, in R.A No. 7/66 dismissing the appeal and confirming the judgment and decree dated 27th October 1965 passed by the Munsiff, Haliyal, dismissing the suit of the plaintiffs for partition of the suit properties with costs.

2. The plaintiffs brought a suit for partition of two serials being the family properties. The plaintiffs instituted a suit O.S No. 19/53 against present defendants for partition in which these two suit properties were also included as family properties. At that time the defendants in the written statement contended that these two properties were trust properties and it was necessary to obtain permission from the Charity Commissioner for partition of those properties. On that representation made by the defendants, the plaintiffs in that suit submitted Ex. 36 whereby they stated that they would withdraw these suit properties from that suit as it would be necessary to obtain the permission of the Charity Commissioner as represented by the defendants and that suit came to be decreed awarding ⅔rd share to the plaintiffs in the remaining suit properties. The defendants did not take up any contention that the suit for Page: 1182partial partition was not maintainable. Subsequently, however, the plaintiffs applied to the Charity Commissioner for permission to partition their properties. The petition was dismissed. Thereafter, they took up the matter in appeal before the Revenue Appellate Tribunal which also held that permission was not necessary for a suit for partition. Thereafter, the plaintiffs have instituted the present suit for partition of the said two properties. The suit was resisted by the defendants on several grounds. They contended that they had perfected their title by adverse possession. They further contended that the suit was barred under Order 2 Rule 2 and also under Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure and that the suit brought for partition was not maintainable in view of the provisions of the Bombay Prevention of Fragmentation and Consolidation of Holdings Act.

3. The learned Munsiff after appreciating the evidence adduced before him dismissed the suit of the plaintiffs. Aggrieved by the said judgment and decree, the plaintiff went up in appeal before the learned Civil Judge, who, no doubt, disagreed with the findings of the trial court that partition was not maintainable in view of the provisions of the Bombay Prevention of Fragmentation and Consolidation of Holdings Act and further that the defendants had perfected their title by adverse possession. He, however, confirmed the findings of the learned Munsiff on the points that the suit was barred by Order 2 Rule 2 as also under Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. In that view he dismissed the appeal. Aggrieved by the said judgment and decree the plaintiffs have come up in appeal before this Court.

4. The learned Advocate for the appellants vehemently contended that on the facts of this case neither Order 2 Rule 2 nor Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure could be attracted and that the courts-below were obviously in error in dismissing the suit holding that the suit was barred by Order 2 Rule 2 as also under Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. As against that, the learned Advocate appearing for the respondents argued supporting the judgment and decree of the learned Civil Judge.

5. The points, therefore, that arise for my consideration in this appeal are: (1) Whether the courts-below were justified in dismissing the suit of the, plaintiff for partition as barred by Order 2 Rule 2 of Page: 1183the Code of Civil Procedure? and (2) Whether the courts-below were justified in dismissing the suit as hit by Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure?. It is not disputed that an earlier suit O.S No. 19/53 was filed by the plaintiffs for partition of the suit properties. As stated above, the present suit properties were also included in that suit, but, the defendants in their written statement specifically contended that these properties were trust properties which required the permission of the Charity Commissioner for partitioning them. The plaintiffs bonafide believed in their representation and gave a memo as per Ex. 36 stating that they will withdraw those two items of the suit properties in that suit obviously with a view to bring the suit later for partition of the two items of the suit properties after obtaining permission from the Charity Commissioner. Ex. 36 reads thus:

“Without prejudice to any of the contentions of these plaintiffs and without admitting anything regarding the nature of the suit properties at serials 1 and 2 these plaintiffs restrict their suit for partitioning all the suit properties except serials 1 and 2 in schedule ‘A’ of the plaint for the purposes of this suit only”.

Thereafter the defendants never took up the contention that suit for partial partition was not maintainable. Accordingly, the suit was decreed awarding ⅔rd share to the plaintiffs. It is in this background that we have to consider whether the present suit is barred by Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure. A Division Bench of this Court in Savitri Bai v. Devendra Balappa Patil 1964 My. L.J Supplement, Page 474 has ruled that Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure does not apply in the case of partition suits in certain circumstances. This is what is laid down by this Court after reviewing the decisions on that point:

“It will be seen that no one can make an exhaustive list of cases in which a second suit for partition could be brought. But the true principle is that an acceptable explanation for the imcompleteness of the first suit is what sustains the next”.

Their Lordships have generally stated that if a property is not immediately available for partition and cannot be divided it would be meaningless for the plaintiff to include that property in the suit Page: 1184for the plaintiff to explain why the suit was brought for partition there was a pending litigation with a third party in Aspect of an item of land and therefore it was excluded from the suit, that would be a reason which would sustain a second suit for partition. They have further pointed out that if the defendant did not object that the first suit was bad, as being one for partial partition, it is not necessary of only some of the properties. The real occasion on which an explanation would be due is when he brings the second suit. They have also explained that if on the date of the institution of the first suit there were circumstances which justified the postponement of the institution of a suit for partition of the suit site, the subsequent event by which the inclusion of a claim for its partition became possible cannot have relevance to the maintainability of the second suit. Thus, the gist of the decision is that an acceptable explanation should be given in the second suit about the incompleteness of the first suit and, if the explanation is satisfactory, the second suit is not barred under Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

6. It may also be stated in this context that the Madras High Court in Keesari Santamma v. Hanumantha Reddi Venkatarama Reddi A.I.R 1935 Madras 909, has laid down that the cause of action for the partition suit is a recurring one. It is in this perspective that we have to examine whether the present suit of the plaintiff is hit by Order 2 Rule 2 or Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The plaintiffs have explained that they had to withdraw from the suit these two properties on the representation of the defendants that the permission of the Charity Commissioner was necessary for bringing the suit for partition with regard to these properties. Subsequently, their conduct shows that they did apply to the Charity Commissioner and contested the matter up to the Revenue Appellate Tribunal and after final orders were obtained, they have presented this suit. Thus, it becomes clear that on the notion entertained bonafide by the plaintiffs at the representation of the defendants they thought that these two suit properties were not available for partition when they instituted the earlier suit O.S 19/53. That being so, I have no hesitation to hold that the explanation offered by them is acceptable being reasonable and legal. I accept the same and hold that the present suit is not barred by Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

7. Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure states thus:

“1. Withdrawal of suit or abandonment of part of claim:

(1) At any time after the institution of a suit, the plainiff may as against all or any of the defendants abandon his suit or abandon a part of his claim”.

Ex. 36 by which the plaintiffs in the earlier suit restricted their suit properties clearly shows that they never intended to abandon their claim regarding these suit properties. They have made it amply clear that they have restricted their claim to the suit properties for the purpose of that suit only, meaning thereby that they never intended to abandon the claim over these properties. I have already shown that the cause of action is a recurring one. That being so, it was not necessary for the plaintiffs to obtain peimission of the court to withdraw the claim regarding these properties. They can maintain the present suit provided they have an acceptable explanation to offer as ruled by the Division Bench of this Court as the cause of action is a recurring one (vide A.I.R 1960 Pat. 76). That being so, I am satisfied that the suit is not barred under Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure also. The learned Civil Judge has obviously committed an error of law in coming to the conclusion that the suit is barred by Order 2 Rule 2 as also by Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. His findings are liable to be set aside.

8. In the result, the appeal is entitled to succeed. But, all the same, since the suit was not tried on merits and the shares were not fixed, it would be necessary to remit the suit back to the trial court with a direction to dispose of the suit on merits. The appeal is allowed and the judgments and decrees of the courts below are set aside. The suit is remitted back to the trial court with a direction to proceed to dispose of the suit on merits fixing the shares of the plaintiffs and passing a preliminary decree in the matter in accordance with law having due advertance to the observations made above. There shall be no order as to costs in this appeal. The parties are directed to be present before the trial on 9th January 1979 to take further instructions from the trial court. Refund admissible court-fees. Send back the records immediately.