Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

RUHIT DEBBARMA v. THE STATE OF TRIPURA & ORS

Tripura High Court
Sep 15, 2016
Smart Summary (Beta)

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion — WP(C) Nos. 957, 959, 960, 961, 963, 964, 966–968, 971–983, 996–1016, 1032–1034 of 2016

Factual and Procedural Background

A large number of writ petitions filed in 2016 were clustered for common disposal because they raised identical issues concerning students registered with schools outside Agartala Municipal Corporation who wished to appear in the Madhyamik Examination, 2017 conducted by the Tripura Board of Secondary Education (TBSE). The petitioners were continuing students (many from ST communities and from interior areas) who had previously appeared in Madhyamik examinations but were unsuccessful, had been attending coaching in Agartala, and sought permission to appear at any examination centre in Agartala as per the discretion of the TBSE.

The petitions contested the Board's published schedule (notice dated 19.05.2016) and procedures for collection and submission of application forms and allocation of examination centres. An earlier interim/order dated 01.09.2016 was made by the Court as a special exception permitting most petitioners (as continuing candidates) to approach their last-appeared schools to collect and submit forms within specified, short timelines so as to avoid losing a year. The present judgment disposes of the clustered petitions after hearing counsel for the petitioners, counsel for the State respondents, and counsel for respondent No.3 (TBSE). The opinion is an oral judgment delivered by Judge A. Ghosh.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioners (continuing students registered with schools outside Agartala but undertaking coaching in Agartala) could be allowed to appear at any examination centre situated in Agartala for the Madhyamik Examination, 2017.
  2. Whether this Court had jurisdiction to direct the Tripura Board of Secondary Education to allocate a particular examination centre to any candidate or to require the Board to issue admit cards or accept forms directly from candidates outside the Board's established procedure.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (as presented through Mr. A. Bhowmik)

  • Most petitioners belong to ST communities from interior areas, had previously been unsuccessful in Madhyamik examinations, and are presently undertaking coaching in Agartala.
  • They seek a limited relief: permission to appear from any examination centre in Agartala (as per TBSE discretion) because they receive study materials and guidance there and will continue coaching until the examination.
  • They had issued a legal notice dated 25.07.2016 and requested the Court to allow them to collect application forms from their respective schools and submit the forms after complying with formalities because the Board's schedule (forms collection/submission) had already been published and the submission period had not yet lapsed.
  • They contended that the word "centre" is defined in the Admission and Examination Regulations, 2008 and that Regulation 16 (Board's authority over centres and power to ask candidates to appear at a particular centre) and related provisions could accommodate discretion in allotting centres.

Respondents' Arguments (as presented through Mr. P. Dutta for TBSE and Mr. S. Chakraborty for the State)

  • The TBSE published its public notice and calendar on 19.05.2016 prescribing dates for collection and submission of forms; deviation from that schedule would disrupt the examination process.
  • The examination centre cannot be changed at the whim of any candidate; a prescribed procedure and regulations govern allocation of centres and issuance of admit cards.
  • The Board will not issue admit cards or accept forms directly from candidates; candidates (regular or external) must appear through a particular school as per regulation.
  • The legal notice issued by petitioners contained unlawful requests, and therefore the Board did not respond to it.
  • Allocation of an examinee to a particular centre is essential for orderly, fair, and smooth conduct of the examinations, to ensure correct serialisation/arrangement of answer scripts and avoid errors in result publication.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by acknowledging that the petitions raised common issues and were therefore clustered for a common judgment. It recorded the factual position that many petitioners were registered with schools in remote areas but attended coaching in Agartala and risked losing a year if not permitted to submit forms within the Board's timelines.

The Court analyzed the applicable regulatory framework as set out in the TBSE Admission and Examination Regulations, 2008, notably Regulation 16 which provides:

  • That the Board fixes dates and selects centres for the examinations.
  • That the Board has authority to ask any candidate to appear at a particular centre and at the candidate's cost.

The Court also noted the regulation permitting an Officer-in-charge to allow a candidate who reports to an incorrect centre (by mistake) to take the examination at that centre for one session/day and report the matter to the Secretary of the Board. The Court treated these regulatory provisions as evidence that the Board exercises discretion and flexibility in allotting centres.

Applying these principles to the facts, the Court concluded as follows:

  1. As a one-time, exceptional measure earlier (order dated 01.09.2016), the Court permitted the petitioners to approach their last-appeared schools to collect and submit forms as continuing candidates within a narrowly prescribed timeline, so they would not lose an academic year. That order was explicitly made as an exception and not to create a precedent for future cases.
  2. The Court recognized that it did not have jurisdiction to direct the TBSE to allocate a specific examination centre to any candidate; allocation of centres lies within the domain and regulations of the Board. Accordingly, the Court declined to direct the Board to allocate particular centres as a matter of right for the petitioners.
  3. Balancing the petitioners' interests and the Board's regulatory domain, the Court provided a remedial pathway short of directing allocation: petitioners were given leave (opportunity) to file representations through their respective registered schools to the Secretary of the TBSE, seeking consideration for allocation of centres in Agartala. The Court set a filing deadline for such representations and directed the Board to consider them in light of the greater public interest and the need to conduct examinations smoothly and fairly.
  4. The Court emphasized that any decision reached by the Board on such representations would be binding on the petitioners and that the Board must weigh its discretion with attention to fairness and the integrity of the examination process.

Holding and Implications

Final Disposition: The writ petitions were disposed of by the Court. There was no order as to costs.

Direct Effect on the Parties (core ruling): Writ petitions disposed of. Practically, the Court (i) allowed, as a one-time exception earlier by order dated 01.09.2016, most petitioners to approach their last-appeared schools to collect and submit continuation forms within specified short timelines (that exceptional order was not to be treated as a precedent); and (ii) granted the petitioners an opportunity to file representations through their respective schools to the Secretary of the TBSE by 31.10.2016 seeking allocation of examination centres in Agartala. The TBSE was directed to consider such representations in light of the greater public interest and to ensure smooth and fair conduct of examinations. Petitioners who appear will be bound by the Board's decision.

The Court expressly declined to direct the Board to allocate particular centres to any candidate, holding that such allocation is within the TBSE's regulatory domain and discretion; thus the decision did not establish a general precedent compelling the Board to assign centres on petitioners' demand.

Judge: A. Ghosh

Show all summary ...

and order : 15.09.2016 Whether fit for reporting : NO Judgment and Order(Oral) All these petitions being WP(C). No. 957 of 2016 [ Abhijit Kalai v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 959 of 2016 [ Khumber Debbarma v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 960 of 2016 [ Biswajit Murasingh v. State of Tripura & Ors.],WP(C). No. 961 of 2016 [ Prabin Rupini v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 963 of 2016 [ Sangita Reang v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 964 of 2016 [ Sumal Debbarma v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 966 of 2016 [ Sabita Debbarma v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 967 of 2016 [ Sanjoy Debbarma v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 968 of 2016 WP(C)Nos.957/959/960/961/963/964/966/967/968/971/972/974/975/977/978/979/980/981/982/983/996/997/ 998/999/1000/1001/1002/1003/1004/1005/1006/1007/1008/1009/1010/1011/1 012/1013/1014/1015/1016/1032/1033/1034 of 2016 Page 24 of 32 [ Mintu Debbarma v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 971 of 2016 [ Miltan Debbarma v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No.

972 of 2016 [ Sambho Kaina Debbarma v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 974 of 2016 [ Tamanna Debbarma v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 975 of 2016 [ Rabita Debbarma v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 977 of 2016 [ Kamal Murasingh v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 978 of 2016 [ Samar Debbarma v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 979 of 2016 [ Surendra Reang v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 980 of 2016 [ Dibangi Jamatia v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 981 of 2016 [ Saranbati Reang v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No.

982 of 2016 [ Suraj Kalai v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No.

983 of 2016 [ Mitali Debbarma v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 996 of 2016 [ Shiva Rupini v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 997 of 2016 [ Kothar Kalai v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 998 of 2016 [ Fulban Kalai v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 999 of 2016 [ Kalam Debbarma v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 1000 of 2016 [ Samarat Jamatia v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 1001 of 2016 [ Chandan Debbarma v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 1002 of 2016 [ Binode Kr. Reang v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 1003 of 2016 [ Pramijoy Reang v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 1004 of 2016 [Damantari Reang v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 1005 of 2016 [ Anamika Debbarma v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. WP(C)Nos.957/959/960/961/963/964/966/967/968/971/972/974/975/977/978/979/980/981/982/983/996/997/ 998/999/1000/1001/1002/1003/1004/1005/1006/1007/1008/1009/1010/1011/1 012/1013/1014/1015/1016/1032/1033/1034 of 2016 Page 25 of 32 1006 of 2016 [ Nabin Ch. Reang v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 1007 of 2016 [ Talirung Reang v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 1008 of 2016 [ Chandra Kr. Debbarma v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 1009 of 2016 [ Ruhit Debbarma v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 1010 of 2016 [ Ajay Debbarma v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 1011 of 2016 [ Bappi Debbarma v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 1012 of 2016 [ Maniram Reang v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 1013 of 2016 [ Jakhan Kr. Reang v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 1014 of 2016 [ Saidai Rung Reang v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 1015 of 2016 [ Chodaram Reang v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 1016 of 2016 [Bedorung Reang v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 1032 of 2016 [ Bishal Debbarma v. State of Tripura & Ors.], WP(C). No. 1033 of 2016 [ Braja Kishore Tripura v. State of Tripura & Ors.] and WP(C). No. 1034 of 2016 [ Pijesh Debbarma v. State of Tripura & Ors., are clustered for disposal by a common judgment inasmuch as issues are common and setup in an identical conspectus of fact.

[2] Heard Mr. A. Bhowmik, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners. Mr S. Chakraborty, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for the State respondents and Mr. P. Dutta, learned counsel appearing for the respondent No. 3., Tripura Board of Secondary Education. WP(C)Nos.957/959/960/961/963/964/966/967/968/971/972/974/975/977/978/979/980/981/982/983/996/997/ 998/999/1000/1001/1002/1003/1004/1005/1006/1007/1008/1009/1010/1011/1 012/1013/1014/1015/1016/1032/1033/1034 of 2016 Page 26 of 32

[3] By means of these writ petitions, the writ petitioners who are the continuing students, desiring to appear in the Madhayamik Examination, 2017, to be conducted by the Tripura Board of Secondary Education [TBSE, in short]. The petitioners have made a limited prayer in these writ petitions that they shall be allowed to appear in any examination centre situated at Agartala as per discretion of the respondent No. 3, TBSE.

[4] There is no dispute that most of the students are appearing from various schools situated in the far flung area beyond the area of Agartala Municipal Corporation and they are registered with their own schools which they had mentioned in their petitions. They have already approached the TBSE by making a representation through one of the learned counsel of this Court and demanded that such decision as contemplated shall be taken by the TBSE.

[5] Since they did not get any response as yet and since the examination schedule has already been published by the TBSE on 19.05.2016, as available in the Annexure-P/4 to the writ petitions, they have approached this Court. Before the matter was taken up for disposal on merit, this Court passed an order on 01.09.2016 and the relevant part of which is as under:

Mr. Bhowmik, learned counsel of the petitioners submitted that all the petitioners belong to ST Community from the interior areas of the State and they are all dropout students, appeared in the Madhyamik examination conducted by the Tripura Board of Secondary Education (TBSE) but came out unsuccessful and thereafter they have been undertaking their coaching at Agartala and they want to appear from any school at Agartala as an external candidate. He has also WP(C) Nos.957/959/960/961/963/964/966/967/968/971/972/974/975/977/978/979/980/981/982/983/996/997/ 998/999/1000/1001/1002/1003/1004/1005/1006/1007/1008/1009/1010/1011/1 012/1013/1014/1015/1016/1032/1033/1034 of 2016 Page 27 of 32 submitted that all the writ petitions were filed on 22.08.2016 and three writ petitions were filed day before yesterday and that they may be allowed to collect the forms from their respective schools and submit the forms after complying the formalities and that regarding examination centre the matter may be heard at an early date. Learned counsel, Mr. Dutta appearing for the respondent No.3 candidly submitted that respondent No.3, the Tripura Board of Secondary Education (TBSE) published the public notice on 19.05.2016 fixing the calendar for the coming Madhyamik and Secondary Examination in respect of collection of form, submission of form, etc., and that any deviation from it will disturb the entire process of examination. He has also submitted that examination centre cannot be changed at the whims of any candidate and that some definite procedure is prescribed in the regulations of the Board regarding the examination centre and other procedure to hold the examination. At the desire of any candidate there cannot be any change in the regulations. Mr. Bhowmik, learned counsel for the petitioners also submitted that the petitioners issued a legal notice on 25.07.2016 but that was not replied by the Board. Mr. Dutta, learned counsel for the Board submitted that the legal notice was containing all illegal prayers and submissions and therefore the Board did not feel it necessary to give response to the notice. He has also submitted that by issuing the legal notice the petitioners sought for issuing them admit card to appear in the examination and according to Mr. Dutta, admit card cannot be issued by the Board to any person as desired since it has to be issued in a proper process according to the provisions prescribed in the regulations through the particular school. It is an admitted position that a candidate whether regular or external has to appear in the board examinations through a particular school. The Board declares the examination centers throughout the State. The Board cannot be directed to issue admit card or to issue form to any particular candidate directly. The regulation prescribes that a candidate whether regular or external has to approach for appearing in the examination through a particular school only. As per the notified programme of the Board dated 19.05.2016, the printed form 7M for continuing candidates should be collected by the concerned school from the Board during the period from 22.08.2016 to 27.08.2016. Rightly or wrongly, the petitioners issued a notice on 25.07.2016. This batch of writ petitions, excepting three, were filed on 22.08.2016 but it has been placed before the Court only today since to process it, it took a few days time in the Registry. If the petitioners are not allowed to approach the school to collect the forms and submit the forms for appearing in the coming Madhyamik examinations they will lose a year. The application form as per schedule should be submitted by the School to the Board during the period from 13.09.2016 to 17.09.2016. Since the date of submission of form has not yet been elapsed, this Court considering the fact that these tribal young boys will be losing a year, as a special case, allowing the writ petitioners a privilege to approach the concerned school, through WP(C) Nos.957/959/960/961/963/964/966/967/968/971/972/974/975/977/978/979/980/981/982/983/996/997/ 998/999/1000/1001/1002/1003/1004/1005/1006/1007/1008/1009/1010/1011/1 012/1013/1014/1015/1016/1032/1033/1034 of 2016 Page 28 of 32 which they last appeared in the Madhyamik examination, to collect forms as a continuing candidate from the Board and to fill up the forms observing the necessary formalities as prescribed by the Board within 07.09.2016 from their respective schools. The respective schools are directed to collect the forms from the Board, if they are approached within 5th of this month by the particular petitioners and then if the candidate is found eligible for his appearing in the examination as a continuing candidate otherwise according to the rules, the concerned school will submit the form to the Board and the entire process should be complied within 7th September, 2016 so that no inconvenience is caused to the Board to process it. The respective candidates with copy of this order may approach the concerned school through which they appeared in the last Madhyamik examination.

[6] The said order was passed as exception, but not to form precedent to be followed in future. Mr. Bhowmik, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners has submitted that all the petitioners have attended their coaching classes at Agartala for having the study materials and guidance etc., and they intend to continue with such guidance till the time they appear in the examination. In this context, they have prayed for allowing them to appear in any examination centre at Agartala, as per discretion of the TBSE.

[7] Mr. Bhowmik, learned counsel for the petitioners has further submitted that the centre is a well defined word in the Admission and Examination Regulations, 2008 which is scrupulously followed by the Tripura Board of Secondary Education [the TBSE, in short]. He has also pointed out that Regulation 16 provides as under:

(i) The Secondary and Higher Secondary Examinations will be conducted by the Board on dates to be fixed by it and at such centres as may be selected by the Board. WP(C)Nos.957/959/960/961/963/964/966/967/968/971/972/974/975/977/978/979/980/981/982/983/996/997/ 998/999/1000/1001/1002/1003/1004/1005/1006/1007/1008/1009/1010/1011/1 012/1013/1014/1015/1016/1032/1033/1034 of 2016 Page 29 of 32

(ii) The Board shall have the authority to ask any candidate for any examination to appear at an examination at a particular centre and at his/her own cost.

[8] That apart, there is a provision that if a candidate reports to an examination Centre not assigned to him/her through mistake and if it is not possible for his/her to go to his/her Centre in time, the Officer-in-charge may allow him/her to take his/her examination at the Centre for one session/day only and send a report in this regard to the Secretary of the Board.

[9] For purpose of showing this provision to this Court is obvious that the Court may exercise the discretion and flexibility in allotting the centre to the examinees. Thus, the petitioners may be accommodated in any of the examination centres at Agartala for their appearance in the Madhyamik Examination, 2017 as the contiuning students from those schools where they are registered as the student. [10] Mr. P. Dutta, learned counsel appearing for the TBSE, has submitted that the students cannot as a matter of right demand that a particular examination centre shall be allocated for his appearance in the examination. The Board has its own procedure and regulations in respect of conducting the public examinations. The usual rule is that the candidate who desires to appear through a school where he is registered as the continuing student, he has to appear where the examination centre for that particular school would WP(C)Nos.957/959/960/961/963/964/966/967/968/971/972/974/975/977/978/979/980/981/982/983/996/997/ 998/999/1000/1001/1002/1003/1004/1005/1006/1007/1008/1009/1010/1011/1 012/1013/1014/1015/1016/1032/1033/1034 of 2016 Page 30 of 32 be allocated. This is done so for conducting the examinations fairly and smoothly without any sort of disruption. [11] Thata part, the answer scripts are also serialised/arranged in such a manner no error at the time of publication of the result can take place. Be that as it may, this Court is of the considered opinion that this Court does not have any jurisdiction to direct the TBSE to allocate a particular examination centre to any candidate. It is in the domain of the TBSE to conduct their examinations according to the regulations or the decisions of the board. [12] However, the Board, as from the Provisions of the Regulations it appears that the TBSE exercises wider discretion to look in the interest of the candidates who are appearing in the examination [13] Having regard to that aspect of the matter the petitioners are given an opportunity to file an application to the Secretary to the Board of Secondary Education for consideration of the matter relating to examinations centre. Such representation shall be filed by 31.10.2016 through their respective schools where they are registered as students for appearing in the examination of the Board. [14] The TBSE when they would receive such application through the respective school of the petitioners, shall consider WP(C)Nos.957/959/960/961/963/964/966/967/968/971/972/974/975/977/978/979/980/981/982/983/996/997/ 998/999/1000/1001/1002/1003/1004/1005/1006/1007/1008/1009/1010/1011/1 012/1013/1014/1015/1016/1032/1033/1034 of 2016 Page 31 of 32 whether the petitioners could be provided the examination centre as requested by the candidates or not. But it is made clear that the Board shall take decision having regard to the greater public interest and of conducting the examination in smooth and fair manner. [15] It is further made clear that, if the petitioners are appearing in the examinations conducted by the TBSE, they shall bound by the decision of the TBSE. Having observed thus, these writ petitions are disposed of. There shall be no order as to costs. JUDGE A.Ghosh WP(C)Nos.957/959/960/961/963/964/966/967/968/971/972/974/975/977/978/979/980/981/982/983/996/997/ 998/999/1000/1001/1002/1003/1004/1005/1006/1007/1008/1009/1010/1011/1 012/1013/1014/1015/1016/1032/1033/1034 of 2016 Page 32 of 32