- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
T.N Godavarman Thirumulpad v. Union Of India And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
This order is part of the long-running proceedings in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 202 of 1995. The matter is monitored by the Supreme Court through numerous Interlocutory Applications (IAs) and periodic reports from the Central Empowered Committee (CEC). The present directions concern penalties and operational permissions for saw-mills and plywood units in Uttarakhand, reconstitution of the Forest Advisory Committee, and clearance of assorted mining, prospecting, wind-energy and irrigation projects. The opinion is almost entirely procedural, allocating time for further reports, granting or refusing interim reliefs, and disposing of specific IAs.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether and on what conditions 27 plywood units and 27 saw-mills in Uttarakhand may resume operations, including payment of penalties as proposed by the CEC.
- Whether the Forest Advisory Committee should be reconstituted and, pending such reconstitution, how project clearances are to be handled.
- Whether six applications for Temporary Work Permits (TWP) and ten applications for prospecting licences, including the application by Tata Steel Ltd., require permission under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980.
- Whether four irrigation projects in Maharashtra, various mining lease extensions, and a wind-power project should be cleared in light of environmental impact and CEC observations.
- Whether pending IAs that lack valid licences as on 4-3-1997 should be dismissed as infructuous.
Arguments of the Parties
Solicitor General (Union of India)
- Stated that the existing Forest Advisory Committee would be reconstituted, proposing the inclusion of Prof. Madhav Gadgil, Dr Ullas Karanth and Mr Mahesh Rangarajan as non-official members, and that this would be communicated to the CEC.
Tata Steel Ltd.
- Argued that its application for a prospecting licence does not involve diversion of forest land for non-forest purposes and that drilling up to the statutory limit should not attract the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980.
State of Uttaranchal
- Sought six weeks’ time to file objections to a CEC report concerning IA No. 1692.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Order dated 27-04-2007 (2011) 15 SCC 662 |
Required that all fresh project clearances by the Forest Advisory Committee be placed before the Court for approval, with CEC response, pending a larger decision. | The Court notes that clause (a) of this earlier order will be deleted for future projects after reconstitution of the Committee. |
| Order dated 25-04-2008 (2011) 15 SCC 658 |
Laid down six conditions under which MoEF could decide four TWP proposals. | Applied the same framework to allow MoEF to decide the remaining two TWP proposals, subject to identical conditions. |
| Order dated 04-01-2008 (2011) 15 SCC 681 |
Imposed conditions (including payment of Net Present Value) for continuation of the Timblo mine in Goa. | Court directs compliance with those conditions in disposing IA No. 2126 regarding transfer of the mining lease. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court relied heavily on the factual assessments and recommendations contained in successive CEC reports, treating them as the primary basis for interim directions.
- Sawmills and Plywood Units (Uttarakhand): Accepting CEC’s supplementary report, the Court required payment of specified penalties within six weeks as a pre-condition for resuming operations. It differentiated between units ready to pay and six saw-mills whose relocation issues remain unresolved, listing the latter for future consideration.
- Forest Advisory Committee: In view of the Solicitor General’s statement, the Court recorded that clause (a) of the 27-04-2007 order will cease to apply once the Committee is reconstituted, signalling a future shift in the approval mechanism.
- Temporary Work Permits and Prospecting Licences: By referencing the 25-04-2008 order and Clause (v) of Chapter I of the Forest (Conservation) Act guidelines, the Court clarified that limited bore-hole drilling (up to 10 holes of 4″ diameter per 100 sq km without tree felling) does not attract the Act, thereby permitting MoEF to process such applications without further Court leave.
- Irrigation Projects (Maharashtra): Balancing environmental impact, the Court withheld clearance for the Human River Project but allowed Rajiv Sagar (Bawanthadi) Project and directed MoEF to decide on Lower Penganga and Jigaon projects.
- Mining and Wind-Energy Projects: For pending mining projects, the Court awaited Forest Advisory Committee input; for the Timblo mine, it affirmed CEC approval subject to compliance with prior conditions and any decisions of the Ministry of Mines; for the Suzlon wind project, MoEF was instructed to reconsider in light of CEC observations.
- Moot IAs: Several IAs were dismissed as infructuous where no valid licences existed as of 4-3-1997 or where earlier directions had rendered the reliefs academic.
Holding and Implications
ORDER PARTLY ALLOWING, PARTLY DISMISSING AND ADJOURNING MULTIPLE IAs.
Immediate implications include: (i) 27 plywood units and 21 saw-mills in Uttarakhand may operate upon payment of penalties; (ii) six saw-mills with relocation issues remain in limbo; (iii) MoEF can proceed on specified TWP, prospecting, irrigation, mining and wind-energy proposals under the clarified parameters; (iv) several IAs are dismissed as infructuous. No new legal precedent is set; the order primarily advances case management and enforces earlier principles.
Order
IA No. 2224
1. Four weeks' time is granted to CEC to file report.
IAs Nos. 2228-29
2. Adjourned.
IA No. 2234
3. IAs Nos. 112, 115, 167, 171, 285, 287, 133, 134, 387 and 388 are dismissed as having become infructuous.
IA No. 2236
4. Application is rejected.
IAs Nos. 208-09, 1710-12, 1704-06, 2024-53 and 2055-56
5. In the State of Uttarakhand there are twenty-seven sawmills and two plywood units. The Central Empowered Committee has suggested that these twenty-seven plywood units have to pay penalty as given in para 5 of the supplementary report submitted. The owners of these plywood units accept CEC Report and they are allowed to start the units subject to fulfilling the conditions. These units are given six weeks' time to pay penalty. These units can function only after depositing these penalties. IAs are allowed as regards these ply-wood units.
6. As regard twenty-seven sawmills, four are relocated in Jaspur and two in Rishikesh. There are problems regarding relocation of these six mills. Except these six sawmills rest of the twenty-one sawmills have agreed to pay penalty as indicated in para 9 of the supplementary report. These sawmills have agreed to pay the penalty as stated in the report. On payment of these penalties as stated in this report these units may be allowed to function. As regards sawmills at Jaspur and Rishikesh relocation, matter shall be listed later. IAs are allowed as regards the twenty-one units. IAs as regards remaining six units may be posted later.
IAs Nos. 241-42, 245, 268-69 and 288-90
7. CEC has filed the Report. The sawmills in question had no valid licence as on 4-3-1997, so they are not allowed to function. The applicants are not present. All these IAs are dismissed accordingly.
IA No. 1692
8. CEC has filed its Report. Learned counsel for the State of Uttaranchal seeks and is granted six weeks' time to file objection to the Report.
IAs Nos. 2219-20
9. Adjourned.
IAs Nos. 2164 and 2167-70 in IAs Nos. 1413-14, 1426, 1428, 1454, 1459-60, 1662-63, 1675, 1778, 2005-06, 2121-25, 2127-33, 2216-18, 2222 and 2232-33, in 1413 in WP (C) No. 202 of 1995
10. Learned Solicitor General made a statement that the existing Forest Advisory Committee would be re-constituted and Prof. Madhav Gadgil, Dr Ullas Karanth and Mr Mahesh Rangarajan would be included in Forest Advisory Committee in place of existing non-official members and further steps would be taken in that direction and it would be brought to the notice of CEC.
11. Pending finalisation of the new Forest Advisory Committee, this Court had passed an order dated 27-4-2007 (2011) 15 SCC 662 on the larger question indicated hereinbelow:
(a) The Forest Advisory Committee as it stands today will give priority to the project which need immediate clearance. In this regard, it may be stated that fresh cases may be cleared projectwise by Forest Advisory Committee and thereafter such clearance shall be placed before this Court for approval. We make it clear that pending the decision of the larger question, all clearances by Forest Advisory Committee of fresh cases shall be subject to approval by this Court. Before giving approval, we would like to have responses from CEC in respect of each clearance. In order to avoid delay, we direct the Ministry concerned to give a copy of the clearance to CEC so that CEC would give its response expeditiously. We will examine each clearance and decide whether to grant or not to grant the approval thereto. Once the approval is granted by this Court, the matter may be placed before the Central Government for disposal in accordance with law.
The above clause (a) would be deleted for future projects after reconstitution.
Fourth Report
(i) Six proposals for grant of TWP (Section IV of the Report)
12. There are six proposals for grant of temporary work permits (TWP). This Court by order dated 25-4-2008 (2011) 15 SCC 658 in IAs Nos. 2177-84 had directed MoEF to take a decision in respect of four TWP proposals subject to compliance of six conditions. The four proposals have been cleared. Subject to fulfilment of the conditions, the balance two TWP proposals may also be permitted to be decided by the MoEF in terms of the said order. IAs are disposed of as regards six proposals for grant of TWP.
(ii) Ten proposals for grant of the prospecting licence (Section III of the Report)
13. This is an application submitted by TATA Steel Ltd. for prospecting licence. Learned counsel appearing for TATA Steel Ltd. has submitted that there is no diversion of forest land for non-forest purpose as contemplated in the Forest Act. It is submitted that for prospecting licence, drilling of bore holes and clarification in (iii) of 1.3 of Chapter 1 Application of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 have been misconstrued.
14. In Clause (v) of Chapter 1-Application of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980, it is stated that prospecting of any mineral done under prospecting licence granted under the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 which requires collection/removal of samples from the forest land, would be a stage between survey and investigation and grant of mining lease and as such permission under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 would be required. However, test drilling up to 10 bore holes of maximum 4″ diameter per 100 sq km for prospecting, exploration or reconnaissance operations, without felling of trees, shall not attract the provisions of the Act. In all other cases involving more than 10 ha of bore holes, prior permission of the Central Government under the Act would be required.
15. Subject to the above, these applications are allowed. MoEF may pass appropriate orders as it is not diversion of forest land for non-forest purpose, except for the limited purpose noted above. It is clarified accordingly. In view of nine other applications pending for prospecting licences, MoEF may consider these applications. The DGFA will re-consider these problems personally in the light of the observations made by CEC and pass appropriate orders within a period of six weeks. IAs are allowed as regards.
(iii) Four Irrigation Projects of Maharashtra (Sections V and VII of the Report)
16. Four irrigation projects were pending for clearance. As regards Human River Project, it is noticed that it involved felling of very large number of trees and have serious environmental repercussions therefore for the time being this project as proposed is not cleared. One of these projects, Rajiv Sagar (Bawanthadi) Project may be cleared and implemented. In regard to two projects i.e Lower Penganga Major Irrigation Project and Jigaon Major Irrigation Project. MoEF may consider and pass appropriate orders. State may go ahead of these three projects after getting approval from MoEF. IA in regard to three projects is allowed.
(iv) The proposal for extension of mining lease in favour of Mpsmcl
17. The State has already withdrawn the project. No orders are required. IA is disposed of accordingly.
18. (v) Already cleared.
(vi) Eleven proposals (Sections IX, X, XII to XIX and XXII of the Report)
19. The MoEF may take decision in the light of the observations made by CEC in Sections IX, X, XII to XIX and XXII of the fourth Report.
(vii) Sections XI and XXI of the Report
20. Adjourned. Await report of Lok Ayukt, Karnataka.
(viii) Prospecting licence to M/s Jindal Power
21. List on 9-5-2008.
(ix) Remaining six proposals (Sections VI, XXII and XXIV of the Report)
22. CEC has already filed the Report. The MoEF is requested to give its response. Therefore, it is adjourned.
Fifth Report
(i) Wind power project in favour of M/S Suzlong Energy Ltd.
23. The MoEF to take fresh decision in the wind power project in the light of the observations made by CEC.
(ii) Four proposals of mining projects
24. CEC has given its Report and the matter is now pending with the Forest Advisory Committee. As soon as the Forest Advisory Committee gives response, the MoEF will consider and take appropriate decision and give response.
IA No. 2126 (Re: Timblo mine, Goa — Sixth and Seventh Report)
25. CEC has already approved the proposal for mining activities. It is pointed out that there is a transfer of mining lease and MoEF may take appropriate decision having regard to the transfer effected by the leaseholder. We are told that the NPV has already been paid. All other conditions imposed by this Court's order dated 4-1-2008 (2011) 15 SCC 681 should be complied with. The Ministry of Mines have to take appropriate decision relating to the right to continue with the mining activities. IA is disposed of accordingly.
IA No. 2143
26. Adjourned.
IAs Nos. 1516, 1541-56 in WP (C) No. 202 of 1995
27. Adjourned.
IAs Nos. 2194-96
28. Issue notice to State of Karnataka and also to CEC. Response may be filed within a period of eight weeks.
IA No. 2212
29. List on 9-5-2008.
IAs Nos. 2237-38
30. List on 9-5-2008.
31. Rest of the IAs are adjourned.
Court Masters
Alert