Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Punjab State v. Brij Lal

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Dec 8, 1983

J.V Gupta, J.:— This is defendant's second appeal against whom the suit for declaration has been decreed by both the Courts below.

2. Brij Lal, plaintiff, was appointed as a Kanungo on July 1, 1944 and was confirmed as such on January 9, 1958. He was promoted as a Naib-Tehsildar on April 9, 1959, though formerly from the year 1953, he had held that office only temporarily. He was involved in three criminal cases in the year 1963, during his tenure as a Naib-Tehsildar, leading to his reversion to his substantive post of Kanungo and at the same time, he was placed under suspension with effect from March 1, 1964, before he took over the charge of the post to which he was reverted. He was acquitted in one of the two criminal cases in which regular challans were submitted in Court while the third one was withdrawn at the initial stage by the police itself. The criminal case relating to first information report No. 122 of July 22, 1963, was still pending when the show cause notice dated June 17, 1972, Exhibit P. 2, was communicated to him by the Collector, Gurdaspur. This took place when he was reinstated on January 27, 1972, by reason of his acquittal in one of the criminal cases and another criminal case having been withdrawn by the Police. The plaintiff, through the show cause notice, Exhibit P. 2, retiring him at the age of 55 years, was specifically informed that the same was without prejudice to the result of the criminal case pending against him in the Criminal Court. A reply to this show cause notice was given by him on August 2, 1972, Exhibit P. 3 However, the same was found to be unsatisfactory as it so appears from the impugned order passed on October 16, 1972, Exhibit p. 4. Through this order, he was ordered to be retired from service at the age of 55 years after the expiry of the requisite notice period of three months. The plaintiff called in question the said order of the compulsory retirement, Exhibit P. 4, and the show cause notice dated June 17, 1972, by filing the present suit. It was alleged that those orders were illegal, void and ineffective in view of the regular enquiry proceedings having been not held either under the Punjab Civil Services Rules or uuder Article 311 of the Constitution. The suit was contested inter alia on the ground thar the impugned order dated October 16, 1972, retiring him at the age of 55 years was quite in order, valid and legal and was not passed by way of punishment. The trial Court found that the impugned order was illegal and in operative in view of the same casting a stigma on the plaintiff. It was further found that the considerations which weighed with the authorities in retiring him compulso-rily from service at the age of 55 years were not justified and were ill-conceived. In view of these findings, the plaintiff's suit was decreed. In appeal, the learned Additional District Judge affirmed the said findings of the trial Court and, thus, maintained the decree passed in his favour. Dissatisfied with the same, the State of Punjab has come up in second appeal to this Court.

3. The learned counsel for the appellant contended that the impugned order, Exhibit P. 4, was never passed by way of punishment and, thus, there was no question of any stigma attaching to the plaintiff. Thus, argued the learned counsel, the provisions of Article 311 (2) of the Constitution were not at all attracted to the facts and circumstances of this case. In support of this contention, the learned counsel relied upon Gian Singh v. The High Court of Punjab and Haryana, (1980) 4 SCC 266 : A.I.R 1980 Supreme Court 1894 and Kartar Singh v. The Punjab State, 1982 (1) Services Law Reporter 307. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent submitted that the impugned order to compulsory retire the plaintiff, in this case, was passed by way of punishment and since no opportunity was afforded to him before passing the impugned order, the same was bad in law. In support of this contention, the learned counsel relied upon the State of Bihar v. Shiva Bhikshuk Mishra, (1970) 2 SCC 871 : A.I.R 1971 Supreme Court 1011; Devinder Singh v. State of Punjab, 1971 (1) Services Law Reporter 708; State Of Utter Pradesh v. Madan Mohan Nagar, A.I.R 1967 Supreme Court 1260 and Purshotam Samp Johari v. State of U.P, 1976 (1) Services Law Reporter 506.

4. The notice dated June 17, 1972, Exhibit P. 2, if translated into English reads that,—

“You are hereby informed through this notice that you will be retired after three months from the receipt of that notice This order will not affect the decision of the criminal case against you and the Government will reserve the right to take action on the decision of the Court. Reply in regard to the above be sent within 15 days.”

5. Reply to the said notice was sent by the plaintiff vide, Exhibit P. 3 dated August 2, 1972. After considering the said reply, the Collector, Gurdaspur passed the impugned order dated October 16, 1972. Exhibit P. 4 the operative part of which reads,…

“Your representation has been considered and is found to be unsatisfactory. Your service record does not justify your continuance beyond the age of 55 years. You are, therefore ordered to be retired from service after the expiry of 3 months period.”

6. In Gian Singh's case (supra), it was held by the Supreme Court that no stigma or implication of misbehaviour is intended, and punishment is not the objective when a Government servant is retired compulsorily in public interest. Similarly, in Kartar Singh's case (supra), this Court held that adverse confidential remarks were sufficient to order compulsory retirement of a government servant and that the same was no punishment. It could not be successfully argued on behalf of the plaintiff that in the facts and circumstances of this case, any stimage was attached to him in retiring hin from service after the age of 55 years. As a matter of fact, since in tthe representation filed by the plaintiff, he had mentioned certain facts claiming his right to continue in service after his attaining the age of 55 years, it had become necessary to say in the order that his service record did not justify his continuance in service beyond the age of 55 years. Under the circumstances, it could not be held that that the ordering his compulsory retirement after his attaining the age of 55 years was by way of punishment. It could not be disputed that the Government has the right to retire an employee after his attaining the age of 55 years. Thus, the view taken by both the Courts below in this behalf is not warranted from the impugned order, Exhibit P. 4. The authorities relied upon by the learned counsel for the respondent have no applicability to the facts of the present case In all those cases, disciplinary action was proceeded against the delinquent officers and in certain cases, regular departmental enquiries were also held which were subsequently dropped. Such is not the position in the present case. In any case, it will be a question of fact in each case as to whether the impugned order amounts to punishment or not. From the facts and circumstances of the present case, it could be held that the impugned order was passed by way of punishment. Once it so held, then the question of issuing any notice before passing the impugned order does not arise.

7. As a result of the above discussion, this appeal succeeds and is allowed. The judgments and decrees of the Courts below are set aside and the plaintiff's suit is dismissed with no order as to costs throughout.

8. Appeal allowed.