Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Gomti Bai Tamrakar And Others v. State Of M.P And Others

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Aug 28, 2008
Smart Summary (Beta)

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This writ petition was filed challenging two notifications issued under the Land Acquisition Act: a notification dated 28 March 2008 issued under section 4(1) (Annexure-P/1) and a declaration dated 15 May 2008 under section 6 (Annexure-P/2). The petitioners state that petitioner No.1 is owner of a house on Hiraganj Tiraha and petitioner No.2 is owner of a house on Garg Chowk, Malviya Ganj, Katni. The section 4 notification was published in the M.P. State Gazette on 25 April 2008, and the declaration under section 6 was published on 15 May 2008.

The petitioners challenged the section 4(1) notification as vague for failing to contain full details of the land proposed to be acquired and for not specifying the public purpose with sufficient particularity; they asserted that the notification deprived them of rights under section 5-A and that the land described (Patwari Halka No. 43 and number Bandobast 493) comprised a very large area of which only approximately 4,763.229 sq. meters was targeted for acquisition. They also attacked the invocation of the urgency clause under section 17.

The respondent (State) defended the notification, asserting it contained sufficient details and that acquisition proceedings were taken in accordance with law. The record shows that an award was passed on 14 July 2008. The petition was filed in July 2008 — roughly three months after the section 4 notification — and the Court was informed that substantial progress in acquisition proceedings had already taken place prior to the filing.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the impugned section 4(1) notification contains sufficient details of the land proposed to be acquired and specifies the public purpose with sufficient clarity so as to avoid being vitiated for vagueness.
  2. Whether invocation of the urgency clause under section 17 was valid (this ground was raised by petitioners in oral argument).
  3. Whether a writ challenge to sections 4 and 6 notifications remains entertainable after an award has been passed in the acquisition proceedings.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The section 4(1) notification is vague because it does not contain full details of the land proposed to be acquired (the scheduled Patwari Halka No. 43 and Bandobast No. 493 cover a very large area, of which only about 4,763.229 sq. mt. was sought to be acquired).
  • Because of vagueness, the petitioners were deprived of rights under section 5-A of the Act.
  • The public purpose was not specified with sufficient particularity in the section 4 notification.
  • The invocation of the urgency clause under section 17 is bad and unsustainable (raised at final hearing).

Respondent's Arguments

  • The section 4 notification contains sufficient particulars of the land (it discloses Patwari Halka number and Bandobast number) and is not vague.
  • Acquisition proceedings were conducted strictly according to law and there is no legal flaw.
  • An award has already been passed (14 July 2008), and in view of precedent, a challenge to sections 4 and 6 notifications cannot be entertained after the award.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Executive Engineer, M.P. Housing Board v. Shri Kant Mishra (Division Bench order dated 8-8-2008, W.A. No.1145/2007) Explains that a section 4(1) notification is exploratory: it must specify the locality where land is likely to be needed; detailed identity of particular plots may not be available until survey under s.4(2) is done. The Court relied on this decision to emphasize that section 4 initiates preliminary proceedings and that the notification can be tentative; the Court used it to assess whether the present notification met the requirement of specifying locality with sufficient detail.
Narendrajit Singh v. State of U.P., (1970) 1 SCC 125 Holds that section 4(1) does not require overly detailed identity of proposed land but does require specification of the locality in which land is needed. Adopted by the Court to support the principle that exact identity of each plot is not necessary at s.4 stage but locality must be specified; used to evaluate the sufficiency of the impugned notification.
Madhya Pradesh Housing Board v. Mohd. Shafi, (1992) 2 SCC 168 Affirms that s.4 notification must be strictly construed; it must give sufficient clarity on public purpose and locality so that interested persons can identify whether their land is affected and take steps (e.g., objections). The Court invoked this precedent to state the settled law that the notification must disclose the public purpose and locality with as full a description as possible consistent with the exploratory nature of s.4.
Abdul Jabbar v. State of West Bengal, ILR (1967) 1 Calcutta 157 Holds that s.4 notification is preliminary and exact area need not be particularized at that stage. Used by the Court among other High Court authorities to support the view that plot-level particulars are not essential at the s.4 stage.
Rajkumar v. The Union of India, ILR (1974) II Delhi 81 States that at the s.4(1) stage it is not necessary for the Government to particularize the land completely. Relied on as support for the settled principle limiting the required specificity at the stage of s.4 notification.
Bahadur Singh v. Union of India, ILR (1976) 1 Delhi 375 Holds that it is not necessary to mention survey numbers in the s.4 notification; each item of land need not be specified. Cited to support the proposition that survey or plot numbers need not be insisted upon at s.4 stage.
Chandan Singh Gosain v. State of U.P., AIR 1980 Allahabad 106 Following Narendrajit Singh, it held plot numbers and details need not be mentioned in s.4 notification; locality is what must be mentioned. Used to buttress the Court's interpretation that locality is the essential requirement for s.4.
Jogendra Nath Chatterjee v. State of West Bengal, AIR 1971 Calcutta 458 Held that neither plots nor their boundary must be specified in s.4 notification but the locality must be stated. Supported the Court's view about the sufficiency of locality description at the s.4 stage.
Nagar Mahapalika, Varanasi v. Durga Shankar, AIR 1975 Allahabad 9 Found that a s.4 notification lacking plot details or boundary particulars need not be vague if other sufficient particulars are mentioned. Referred to by the Court to show that absence of plot-level detail does not automatically render a notification vague if locality and other particulars suffice.
Rambharose v. State of M.P., (2002) 3 MPLJ 378 Holds that once an award in acquisition proceedings is passed, challenges to sections 4 and 6 notifications cannot be entertained. Invoked by respondents and considered by the Court as a ground weighing against entertaining the petition in view of the award passed on 14 July 2008.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by positing the central question explicitly: whether the impugned section 4 notification contains sufficient details of the land proposed to be acquired and the public purpose so as to withstand a vagueness challenge. The Court analyzed the scope and purpose of section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, noting that section 4(1) requires publication when land in any locality is needed for public purpose and that section 4(2) authorises survey and other exploratory acts to ascertain which land in the locality is suited for the purpose.

The Court relied on a line of authority (both Supreme Court and High Court decisions) establishing that:

  • Section 4 notifications are preliminary/exploratory in character and need not identify the precise plot(s) at the stage of initial notification;
  • Nevertheless, the notification must specify the locality where land is needed with as full a description as possible consistent with its exploratory nature;
  • The notification must also disclose the public purpose with sufficient clarity so that interested persons can know whether they are affected and can take available steps under the Act.

Applying these principles to the present case, the Court observed that the impugned section 4 notification disclosed Patwari Halka number and Bandobast number and expressly stated the public purpose as construction of the "Khirhani Railway over-bridge." The Court found that these particulars, taken together, rendered the location and locality of the land sufficiently explicit for the purposes of section 4(1).

The Court rejected the petitioners' contention that disclosing Halka No. 43 and Bandobast No. 493 (which in aggregate may cover a large area) rendered the notification vague because only a small portion (4,763.229 sq. mt.) was proposed to be acquired. The Court reasoned that the indication of the specific public project (the over-bridge) made the locality and the intended acquisition explicit in a manner consistent with established authority.

On the issue of public purpose, the Court found the notification explicitly stated the purpose ("Khirhani Railway over-bridge") and observed that such a purpose falls within the statutory meaning of "public purpose" (reference made to section 3(f) of the Act). Accordingly, the Court held that the public purpose was disclosed with sufficient clarity.

Regarding the urgency clause (section 17) argument, the Court noted that petitioners raised this contention at the final hearing but had not pleaded or raised it in the writ petition itself; consequently the State had no opportunity to respond, and the Court declined to consider that ground at the late stage.

The Court also considered the procedural posture: an award had been passed on 14 July 2008, and the petition had been filed about three months after the section 4 notification. The Court observed precedent (Rambharose) holding that once an award is passed, challenges to the section 4 and 6 notifications generally cannot be entertained. Coupled with the petitioners' delay in approaching the Court and the public nature of the project (to relieve traffic congestion and safety risks at Khirhani Railway crossing), the Court concluded there was no basis to interfere with the acquisition proceedings.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Writ petition dismissed.

Implications and consequences as set out in the opinion:

  • The Court found the impugned section 4(1) notification to be legally adequate — it disclosed Patwari Halka number and Bandobast number and the public purpose (Khirhani Railway over-bridge) with sufficient clarity, and therefore the vagueness challenge to the section 4 notification failed.
  • The Court declined to entertain the petitioners' late-raised challenge to the invocation of the urgency clause because that ground had not been pleaded in the writ petition and the State had no opportunity to meet it.
  • The existence of a passed award (14 July 2008) and the petitioners' delayed litigation conduct were treated as additional reasons to refuse relief; the Court noted precedent that ordinarily a challenge to sections 4 and 6 cannot be entertained after an award.
  • The immediate effect is that the acquisition proceedings remain undisturbed and the petitioners obtain no relief; the Court made no order as to costs.
  • The opinion applies and reinforces settled law about the nature and required content of section 4(1) notifications rather than announcing a new legal principle; it relies on established precedents to reach its decision.
Petition dismissed.

No information beyond the text of the provided opinion has been added. Sections and statements in this summary are drawn exclusively from the opinion supplied.

Show all summary ...

1. This writ petition has been filed challenging the notification dated 28th March, 2008 issued under section 4 (Annexure-P/1) and the notification dated 15th May, 2008 (Annexure-P/2) issued under section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act.

2. The case of the petitioners is that the petitioner No. 1 is owner of the house situated on Hiraganj Tiraha and the petitioner No. 2 is the owner of the house situated on Garg Chowk, Malviya Ganj, Katni. The notification dated 28th March, 2008 issued under section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act was published in the M.P State Gazette dated 25-4-2008. Thereafter the declaration under section 6 was published on 15-5-2008. In the present petition, the notifications under section 4(1) of the Act as well as declaration under section 6 are under challenge.

3. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners submitted that the notification under section 4(1) of the Act is vague inasmuch as it does not contain the full details of the land proposed to be acquired and also the public purpose is not specific. The notification is so vague that the petitioners have been deprived of their right under section 5-A of the Act. He further submitted that by the impugned notification approximately 4763.229 sq. mt. of land of Patwari Halka No. 43 and number Bandobast 493 was proposed to be acquired which is part of larger piece of land. He further submitted that invocation of urgency clause under section 17 of the Act is bad and unsustainable.

4. Learned counsel for the respondent submitted that section 4 notification contains sufficient details of the land as required by law and the notification is not vague in any manner. He further submitted that the acquisition proceedings have been taken up strictly in accordance with law and there is no flaw in the proceedings.

5. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.

6. The question, which arises for consideration, is whether the impugned section 4 notification contains the sufficient details of land proposed to be acquired and the public purpose to save it from the challenge on the ground of vagueness?

7. Section 4 requires the appropriate Government to publish the notification when land in any locality is needed or likely to be needed for any public purpose. On the issuance of section 4(1) notification, under section 4(2) it becomes lawful for any officer authorised by Government to enter upon and survey any land in such locality and ascertain if the land is adapted for such purpose and also set out the boundaries of the land proposed to be taken. Division Bench of this Court in the order dated 8-8-2008 passed in W.A No. 1145/2007 in the matter of Executive Engineer, M.P Housing Board v. Shri Kant Mishra and connected writ appeals, while considering the object of notification under section 4, has held that:—

“It is apparent from sub-section (1) of section 4 of the Act that only locality in which the land was likely to be needed for any public purpose, is required to be mentioned. Sub-section (2) of section 4 provides that thereupon after issuance of notification under sub-section (1) of section 4, it shall be lawful for any officer to enter upon and survey and take Page: 538levels of any land in such locality; to dig or bore into the sub-soil; to do all other acts necessary to ascertain whether the land is adapted for such purpose; to set out the boundaries of the land proposed to be taken and the intended line of the work (if any) proposed to be made thereon; to mark such levels, boundaries and line, by placing marks and cutting trenches; and where otherwise the survey cannot be completed and the levels taken and the boundaries and line marked, to cut down and clear away any part of any standing crops, fence or jungle. Thus, section 4 provides a first step towards acquisition of land. The main purpose of the notification is to take the preliminary proceedings. The notification is of exploratory character and discloses tentative intention. After discharging the functions under section 4, the authorised officer is required to make report under sub-section (4) of section 4. At the stage of section 4 Government may not in fact possessing all the necessary details which are dependent upon the survey on which it can decide which land in the locality would be suitable for the public purpose. Investigation into necessary data provided under section 4(2) empowered the entry to carry out various operations mentioned therein on any land in such locality. Only after such survey is made, Government can decide, which particular land in the locality is adapted or suitable for the public purpose.”

8. The issue about the particulars of the land which are required to be disclosed in section 4 notification to save it from vagueness came before the Supreme Court on earlier occasion. In the matter of Narendrajit Singh v. State of U.P, reported in (1970) 1 SCC 125, the Supreme Court opined that section 4(1) does not require the identity of the proposed land to be specified with too many details but it requires to “specify the locality in which the land is needed”. It is held that:—

8. section 4(1) does not required that the identity of the lands which may ultimately be acquired should be specified but it enjoins upon the Government the duty to specify the locality in which the land is needed. In the instant cases the notifications suffer from a very serious defect in that the locality where the lands were needed was not specified. The notification merely showed that lands mentioned in the schedule were needed. The schedule in its turn though it contained the headings District, Pargana, Mauza and approximate area, gave no particulars of the same and all that was mentioned by way of a note was that the plan of the land might be inspected in the office of the Collector of Rampur. As no details were given, the only indication about the locality of the lands was possibly the District of Rampur inasmuch as the plan of the land was to be found in the office of the Collector of the same district. Certainly the Act did not intend that all the persons owning land in a district should rush to the Collector's office to find out whether his lands were covered by the notification.

9. The Supreme Court in the matter of Madhya Pradesh Housing Board v. Mohd. Shafi, reported in (1992) 2 SCC 168 while considering section 4(1) notification which only contained the name of the District and approximate area proposed to be acquired without any other further details such as Khasra number Patwari Halka number or locality etc. held that:—

8. It is settled law that the process of acquisition has to start with a notification issued under section 4 of the Act, which is mandatory, and even in cases of urgency, the issuance of notification under section 4 is a condition precedent to the exercise of any further powers under the Act. Any notification which is aimed at depriving a man of his property, issued under section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act has to be strictly construed and any serious lapse on the part of the acquiring authority would vitiate the proceedings and cannot be ignored by the Courts. The object of issuing a notification under section 4 of the Act is twofold. First, it is a public announcement by the Government and a public notice by the Collector to the effect that the land, as specified therein, is needed or is likely to be needed by the government for the “public purpose” mentioned therein; and secondly, it authorises the departmental officers or officers of the local authority, as the case may be to do all such acts as are mentioned in section 4(2) of the Act. The notification has to be published in the locality and particularly persons likely to be affected by the proposal have to be put on notice that such an activity is afoot. The notification is thus, required to give with sufficient clarity not only the “public purpose” for which the acquisition proceedings are being commenced but also the “locality” where the land is situate with as full a description as possible of the land proposed to be acquired to enable the “interested” persons to know as to which land is being acquired and for what purpose and to take further steps under the Act by filing objections etc., since it is open to such persons to canvass the non-suitability of the land for the alleged “public purpose” also. If a notification under section 4(1) of the Act is defective and does not comply with the requirements of the Act, it not only vitiates the notification, but also renders all subsequent proceedings connected with the acquisition, bad.

Thus, in view of the aforesaid judgment, by section 4(1) notification the locality where land is situated is required to be disclosed with as full possible description of the land proposed to be acquired to enable the interested persons to know as to which land is being acquired and for what purpose.

10. Division Bench of this Court also in the matter of Executive Engineer, M.P Housing Board (supra) has considered the same issue and held as follows:—

14. Thus the ratio of the decision of the Apex Court consistently is that locality should be mentioned with precision not the precise identity of the locality at the stage of notification under section 4 of the Act. Similar is the view expressed by several High Courts. In Abdul Jabbar v. State of West Bengal, ILR (1967) 1 Calcutta 157, it was laid down that the notification under section 4 is merely exploratory or preliminary in nature and the exact area to be acquired need not be particularized at that stage, but it is otherwise with the declaration under section 6 which is issued after the Government has applied its mind to the exact area and location of the lands which are needed for the purpose of and are, therefore, acquired. Delhi High Court in Rajkumar v. The Union of India, ILR (1974) II Delhi 81 has laid down that at the stage of notification under section 4(1) it is not absolutely necessary that Page: 540Government should have particularized the land. In Bahadur Singh Etc.…Petitioner v. Union Of India…, ILR (1976) 1 Delhi 375, it was laid down in para 68 that it is not necessary that each and every items of the land should be mentioned in the notification under section 4 which means that survey numbers are not required to be mentioned. A Division Bench of Allahabad High Court in Chandan Singh Gosain v. State of U.P, AIR 1980 Allahabad 106 following the decision of Narendrajit Singh's case held that plot numbers and other details are not necessary to be mentioned in the notification issued under section 4 of the Act. Only the locality is to be mentioned which by very purpose of section 4 can be mentioned. A Division Bench of Calcutta High Court in Jogendra Nath Chatterjee v. State of West Bengal, AIR 1971 Calcutta 458 held that neither the plots nor their boundary has to be specified in notification under section 4(1), but, the locality must be stated. In Nagar Mahapalika, Varanasi v. Durga Shankar, AIR 1975 Allahabad 9, Allahabad High Court held that when the notification under section 4(1) did not mention the details about the purpose of the plots or their boundaries, the notification could not be held to be vague as other sufficient particulars were mentioned.

11. Thus, the law is settled that section 4(1) does not require the identity of the land with too many details to be disclosed in the notification but the notification must specify the locality in which the land is needed.

12. The impugned section 4 notification in the present case needs to be considered in the light of the aforesaid settled legal position. The section 4 notification dated 28th March, 2008 (Annexure-P/1) which is under challenge was issued containing the following details of the land proposed to be acquired.

A perusal of the aforesaid details indicates that in the notification Patwari Halka number and number Bandobast of the land, which was proposed to be acquired, has been disclosed.

13. Learned counsel for the petitioners has argued that Patwari Halka No. 43 and number Bandobast 493 which is mentioned in section 4 notification admeasures thousands of hectares out of which only 4763.229 sq. mt. is proposed to be acquired, therefore, the locality is not specified. Such an argument is devoid of merit since along with Patwari Halka number and number Bandobast, the notification also discloses that the land is proposed to be acquired for constructing Khirhani Railway over-bridge which makes the location and the locality of the land proposed to be acquired explicit. Thus, petitioners' challenge to the impugned notification on the ground of vagueness for want of requisite particulars of land is meritless and is hereby rejected.

14. The petitioners have also raised the challenge on the ground that the notification is vague since it does not specify the public purpose. Such a challenge is also meritless since the notification in clear terms provides the public purpose as “acquired for Khirhani Railway over bridge”. Such a purpose is covered within the meaning of expression “public purpose” contained in section 3(f) of the Act. Thus, public purpose has been disclosed in section 4(1) notification with sufficient clarity, therefore, it is found that the challenge of the petitioner to the notification under section 4(1) is without any substance.

15. The learned counsel for the petitioners has also argued that the order for invoking the urgency clause was passed subsequent to section 6 declaration dated 15-5-2008. A perusal of the writ petition indicates that no such ground has been raised by the petitioners in the writ petition questioning the legality and correctness of the invocation of the urgency clause. Therefore, such an argument raised at the time of final hearing cannot be considered since State had no opportunity to respond to the same.

16. It has also been pointed out by the respondents that the award has already been passed in the matter on 14-7-2008, therefore, writ petition is liable to be dismissed in view of the judgment of this Court in the matter of Rambharose v. State of M.P, reported in (2002) 3 MPLJ 378 holding that once the award is passed challenge to sections 4 and 6 notification cannot be entertained.

17. Even otherwise, it is found that the petitioner has challenged the notification dated 28th March, 2008 (Annexure-P/1) after elapse of almost 3 months by filing the writ petition sometime in July, 2008 whereas Annexure-P/3 indicates that the petitioner was aware of the acquisition proceedings and before filing of the writ petition substantial progress had taken place in the acquisition proceedings. Therefore, no interference can be made also for the reason that the petitioner was not prompt in approaching the Court. It is also worth noting that no other person has approached this Court challenging the acquisition proceedings except for the petitioners and also that the land is being acquired for constructing a Railway over-bridge to case the traffic problem at Kami Railway crossing as the Railway line going towards Allahabad and Calcutta is busy Railway line, which results into traffic jam at Khirhani Railway crossing and causes suffering to the public at large and also loss of lives due to the accidents Page: 542while crossing the Railway line. Considering the eminent public purpose and considering the fact that section 4 notification is not vague as alleged by the petitioners and that land is being acquired after following the due procedure prescribed under the Land Acquisition Act no interference is required in this writ petition and the writ petition is, accordingly, dismissed. No orders as to costs.

Petition dismissed.