Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mohammad Usman v. Dr. Satyawan .

Allahabad High Court
Feb 25, 2011
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — Anil Kumar, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The applicant initially filed Suit No. 482 of 1992 (Mohd. Usman v. Dr. Satyavan) in the Court of IIIrd Additional Civil Judge, Barabanki, for a permanent injunction in respect of Plot No. 1145. An application for temporary injunction under Order XXXIX Rule 1 C.P.C. was granted on 12.9.1993 but vacated on 30.11.1998. The applicant obtained an interim injunction from the appellate authority on 23.12.1998, but that appeal was later dismissed on 21.8.2009.

The applicant filed Writ Petition No. 3157 (MS) of 1999 and obtained an interim order on 24.11.1999 directing the opposite parties to maintain status quo. The original suit was dismissed and a Regular Civil Misc. Appeal No. 35 of 2001 (Mohd. Usman v. Dr. Satyavan) was dismissed by judgment and decree dated 11.8.2003.

The applicant filed a second appeal under section 100 C.P.C., Second Appeal No. 246 of 2003, and on 8.9.2003 an interim injunction was ordered directing maintenance of status quo. A Civil Misc. Application No. 3017 of 2005 resulted in an injunction/interim order on 8.3.2006 directing that "The possession of the appellant from over the property in question shall not be disturbed."

The applicant alleges that the respondent violated the interim/injunction order dated 8.3.2006 on 25.6.2009 by disturbing the applicant's possession. The applicant filed the present contempt petition under section 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 alleging violation of the 8.3.2006 order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the contempt petition filed under section 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 is maintainable for alleged violation of the interim/injunction order dated 8.3.2006 passed by this Court in the pending second appeal.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • The applicant contends that the interim/injunction order dated 8.3.2006 passed by this Court in the pending second appeal was violated by the respondent on 25.6.2009 and that the respondent wilfully and deliberately disturbed the applicant's possession.
  • On that basis the applicant filed the present contempt petition under section 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 seeking punishment of the respondent for violation of the injunction/interim order.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent contended that it is incorrect to say the order was disobeyed and that the contempt petition is not maintainable because a specific remedy is available under Order XXXIX Rule 2-A of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • The respondent relied on the law as laid down by the Supreme Court in Food Corporation Of India v. Sukh Deo Prasad (2009 (5) SCC 665), arguing that Order XXXIX Rule 2-A is punitive in nature and akin to the power to punish for civil contempt under the Contempt of Courts Act; therefore the alternative remedy under Rule 2-A should be invoked instead of a contempt petition under section 12.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Food Corporation Of India v. Sukh Deo Prasad, 2009 (5) SCC 665 Held that Order XXXIX Rule 2-A is punitive in nature, akin to powers under the Contempt of Courts Act; emphasises that the applicant must clearly establish existence of an injunction/order and disobedience; Rule 2-A must be exercised with caution. The Court relied on this authority to conclude that a contempt petition under section 12 is not maintainable where an alternative remedy is available under Order XXXIX Rule 2-A and thus dismissed the contempt petition.
Dr. Bimal Chandra Sent v. Mrs. Kamla Mathur, 1983 Crl. L.J. 494 Noted that the High Court can initiate contempt proceedings even for disobedience of injunctions granted by Civil Courts but that exercise of such power is discretionary and generally unnecessary where special power is conferred on the Civil Court. The Court referenced this principle to explain that although the High Court may have contempt jurisdiction, the special procedure under Order XXXIX Rule 2-A is generally the appropriate remedy.
S.G. Pagaree v. Zonal Manager, Food Corporation of India, New Delhi, 1987 AWC 506 Where an alternative remedy under Order XXXIX Rule 2-A is available, proceedings under the Contempt of Courts Act should not be taken. The Court cited this case to support the proposition that a proceeding under the Contempt Act is inappropriate when Rule 2-A remedy exists, and applied that principle to dismiss the contempt petition.
Pratap Narain v. Smt. Nomita Roy, 1984 AWC 567 Remedy under Order XXXIX Rule 2-A is adequate and satisfactory for disobedience of an injunction order of the Court below. The Court relied on this authority to reinforce that Rule 2-A provides an adequate remedy and thus a contempt proceeding is not the appropriate course.
Savitri Devi (Smt.) v. Civil Judge (J.D.), Gorakhpur, 2003 (51) ALR 369, 2003 (1) ARC 545 Proceedings under Order XXXIX Rule 2-A are quasi-criminal in nature and meant to maintain the dignity of the Court and deter disobedience of injunctions. The Court used this reasoning to characterize Rule 2-A proceedings and to justify preference for Rule 2-A as the appropriate remedy over a contempt petition under section 12.
Mohd. Usman v. Dr. Satyavan (suit proceedings referenced) Referenced as the underlying civil litigation and procedural history where multiple injunctions and orders were passed and contested. Used in the factual and procedural narrative to show the sequence of orders, appeals, and interim directions relevant to the alleged breach and the present contempt petition.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court framed the primary question as whether the contempt petition under section 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 was maintainable for alleged violation of the interim/injunction order dated 8.3.2006 passed by the Court in a pending second appeal.

The Court reviewed the statutory provisions relevant to the issue: Order XXXIX Rule 2-A (which prescribes consequences for disobedience of injunctions and permits attachment of property and detention in civil prison for up to three months) and Section 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 (which prescribes punishment for contempt up to six months' simple imprisonment or a fine).

The Court observed that proceedings under Order XXXIX Rule 2-A are analogous to proceedings under the Contempt of Courts Act and, being a specific provision, would prevail over the general provisions of the Contempt of Courts Act. It noted that although the High Court may initiate contempt proceedings even for disobedience of injunctions granted by Civil Courts, that power is discretionary and generally need not be exercised where a special power exists under Rule 2-A.

The Court examined precedent from its own and higher courts which consistently held that where an alternative remedy under Order XXXIX Rule 2-A is available, proceedings under the Contempt of Courts Act should not be taken. The Court cited authorities (including S.G. Pagaree, Pratap Narain, Savitri Devi) to show Rule 2-A is quasi-criminal/punitive and the appropriate mechanism to address disobedience of injunctions.

The Court relied in particular on the Supreme Court's decision in Food Corporation Of India v. Sukh Deo Prasad which emphasized that Rule 2-A is punitive and akin to contempt powers, and that courts must require clear proof of the injunction and its disobedience before invoking Rule 2-A. Applying that reasoning, the Court concluded that the applicant had an alternative statutory remedy under Order XXXIX Rule 2-A and therefore a contempt petition under section 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act was not the appropriate remedy.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The contempt petition filed under section 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 for alleged non-compliance of the interim/injunction order dated 8.3.2006 is DISMISSED on the ground that an alternative remedy is available under Order XXXIX Rule 2-A of the Code of Civil Procedure.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The applicant's contempt petition is dismissed and no order as to costs was made.
  • Practical consequence: The Court treated Order XXXIX Rule 2-A as the appropriate and specific statutory remedy for alleged disobedience of injunction orders and therefore declined to entertain a contempt proceeding under section 12.
  • Broader implications: The opinion does not elaborate broader legal consequences beyond applying existing authorities; accordingly the direct effect on the parties is dismissal of the petition. This opinion does not state that it sets any new precedent beyond applying cited authorities.

No other orders were made (the judgment records "No order as to costs").

Show all summary ...

Anil Kumar, J.:— Heard Sri S.M Nasir, learned Counsel for the applicant and Sri Sunil Kumar Singh and Sri G.C Verma, learned Counsel for the respondent.

2. Facts in brief in the present case axe that initially applicant-plaintiff filed a Suit for permanent injunction in respect to Plot No. 1145 area 12 Vishwa 30 Viswansi situated Page: 70in the District Barabanki, Fatehpur registered as Suit No. 482 of 1992 (Mohd. Usman v. Dr. Satyavan) in the Court of IIIrd Additional Civil Judge, Barabanki. In the said Suit, an application for grant of temporary injunction under Order XXXIX Rule 1 C.P.C has been moved by the applicant-plaintiff, granted on 12.9.1993 but vacated on 30.11.1998

3. Aggrieved by the said order, the applicant filed, interim injunction granted on 23.12.1998 by appellate authority. Subsequently, appeal dismissed by order dated 21.8.2009 Thereafter, the applicant approached this Court by filing the Writ Petition No. 3157 (MS) of 1999 and on 24.11.1999, an interim order was passed in favour of the petitioner-applicant, till the suit is decided, the opposite parties are directed to maintain status quo as exists today.

4. Further, the Suit No. 482 of 1992 filed by the applicant for permanent injunction was dismissed. He Med a Regular Civil Misc. Appeal No. 35 of 2001 (Mohd. Usman v. Dr. Satyavan), dismissed vide judgment and decree dated 11.8.2003 passed by Additional District Judge, Court No. 10, Barabanki.

5. Applicant for redressal of his grievances approached this Court by filing second appeal under section 100 C.P.C registered as Second Appeal No. 246 of 2003 in which initially on 8.9.2003 an interim injunction order has been passed, the operative portion of the same is as under:—

“During the pendency of the appeal the parties shall maintain stautus quo as of today with regard to the disputed land.”

6. Again, a Civil Misc. Application No. 3017 of 2005 was moved on 8.3.2006, an injunction/interim order has been granted, the relevant portion is as under:—

“In the circumstances, the order dated 27.5.2004, is hereby recalled. The possession of the appellant from over the property in question shall not be disturbed.”

7. As per the version of the learned Counsel for the applicant, the injunction/interim order dated 8.3.2006 passed by this Court in pending second appeal has been violated by the respondent on 25.6.2009 inspite of the order to maintain status quo and wilfully and deliberately disturbed the possession of the applicant, so the present contempt petition has been filed under section 12 of the Contempt Court Act, 1971 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’) for punish the respondent for violation of the injunction/interim order dated 8.3.2006 passed by this Court in second appeal.

8. Sri G.C Verma, appearing on behalf of respondent No. 2 submits that it is totally incorrect on the part of the applicant to submit that his client has disobeyed the order passed by the Writ Court rattier present contempt petition is not maintainable on the other ground that as a specific remedy is available under Order XXXIX Rule 2-A of the Code of Civil procedure, so the present contempt petition is liable to be dismissed in view of the law as laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Food Corporation Of India v. Sukh Deo Prasad, 2009 (77) AIC 13 (SC) (Sum.) , 2009 (75) ALR 38 (Sum.) , 2009 (5) SCC 665 (para 38) in which it has been held that Order XXXIX Rule 2-A of the Code of Civil procedure is punitive in nature, akin to the power to punish for civil contempt under the contempt Courts Act, 1971.

9. I have heard learned Counsel for the parties and gone through the record.

10. First and foremost question which is to be decided in the instant case is whether the present contempt petition filed by the applicant is maintainable for violation of the interim/injunction order dated 8.3.2006 passed by this Court in pending second appeal under the provisions of Order XXXIX Rule 1 C.P.C

11. In order to resolve the controversy which is involved in the present case, it is necessary to have a glance over the relevant portion of the provisions of law which governs the field.

Order XXXIX Rule 2-A.

“Consequences of disobedience of breach of injunction (1) In the case of disobedience of any injunction granted or other order dame under Rule 1 or Rule 2 or breach of any of Page: 71the terms on which the injunction was granted or the order made, the Court granting the injunction or making the order, or any Court to which the suit or proceeding is transferred, may order the property of the person guilty of such disobedience or breach to be attached, and may also order such person to be detained in the civil prison for a term not exceeding three month, unless in the meantime the Court directs his release.”

Section 12 of the Contempt Court Act, 1971:—

Section 12. Punishment for contempt of Court:— (1) Save as otherwise expressly provided in this Act or in any other law, a contempt of Court may be punished with simple imprisonment for a term which may extend to six months, or with find which may extend to two thousand rupees, or with both:

Provided that the accused may be discharged or the punishment awarded may be remitted on apology being made to the satisfaction of the Court.

(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for five time being in force, no Court shall impose a sentence in excess of that specified in sub-section (1) for any contempt either in respect of itself or of a Court subordinate to it.

(3) Notwithstanding anything contained in this section, where a person is found guilty of a civil contempt, the Court, if it considers that a fine will not meet the ends of justice and that a sentence of imprisonment is necessary shall, instead of sentencing him to simple imprisonment, direct that he be detained in a civil prison for such period not exceeding six months as it may think fit.

(4) Where the person found guilty of contempt of Court in respect of any undertaking given to a Court is a company, every person who at the time the contempt was committed, was in charge of, and was responsible to, the company for the conduct of business of the company, as well as the company, shall be deemed to be guilty of the contempt and the punishment may be enforced, with the leave of the Court, by the detention in civil prison of each such person.

Provided that nothing contained in this sub-section shall render any such person liable to such punishment if he proves that ht contempt was committed without his knowledge or that he exercised all due diligence to prevent its commission.

(5) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (4), where the contempt of Court referred to therein has been committed by a company and it is proved that the contempt has been committed with the consent or connivance of, or is attributable to any neglect on the part of, any director, manager, secretary or other officer of the company, such director, manager, secretary or other officer shall also be deemed to be guilty of the contempt and the punishment may be enforced, with the leave of the Court, by the detention in civil prison of such director, manager, secretary or other officer.”

12. From the perusal of the above said provision, it is clear that the proceedings under Order XXXIX Rule 2-A C.P.C are analogous to the proceedings under the Act, 1972. The only distinction is that as the Legislature, in its wisdom, has enacted a special provision enacting the provisions of Order XXXIX, Rule 2-A, it would prevail over the provisions of the Contempt of Courts Act. Though the High Court, by virtue of the provisions of section 10 of the Act, 1972 can initiated the contempt proceeding even for disobedience of the injunction order granted by the Civil Court, but the exercise of such power is discretionary and generally does not require to be exercised in view of the special power conferred upon the Civil Court itself. (See: Page: 72Dr. Bimal Chandra Sent v. Mrs. Kamla Mathur, 1983 Crl. L.J 494

13. In the case of S.G Pagaree v. Zonal Manager, Food Corporation of India, New Delhi, 1987 AWC 506 it is held by this Court that where alternative remedy under Order XXXIX Rule 2-A C.P.C is available, proceeding under the contempt Courts Act should not be taken.

14. In the case of Pratap Narain v. Smt. Nomita Roy, 1984 AWC 567 the similar view was also expressed and it was held that remedy under Order XXXIX Rule 2-A C.P.C is far more adequate and satisfactory remedy as disobedience of an injunction order of the Court below is involved.

15. In the case of Savitri Devi (Smt.) v. Civil Judge (J.D), Gorakhpur, 2003 (51) ALR 369 , 2003 (1) ARC 545 it is held that in view of the above discussion, once reaches the inescapable conclusion that proceedings under Order XXXIX Rule 2-A are quashi-criminal in nature and are meant to maintain the dignity of the Court in the eyes of the people so that the supremacy of law may prevail and to deter the people for mustering the courage to disobey the interim injunction passed by the Court.

16. In the case of Food Corporation Of India v. Sukh Deo Prasad, 2009 (5) SCC 665 (para 38) , 2009 (75) ALR 38 (SC) (Sum.) the Hon'ble Supreme Court held as under:—

“The power exercised by a Court under Order XXXIX Rule 2-A of the Code is punitive in nature, akin to the power to punish for civil contempt under the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971. The person who complains of disobedience or breach has to clearly make out beyond any doubt that there was an injunction or order directing the person again whom the application is made, to do or desist from doing some specific thing or act and that there was disobedience or breach of such order. While considering an application under Order XXXIX Rule 2-A, the Court cannot construe the order in regard to which disobedience/breach is alleged, as creating an obligation to do something which is not mentioned in the “order” on surmises, suspicions and inferences. The power under Rule 2-A should be exercised with great caution and responsibility”. For the foregoing reasons, the present contempt petition filed by the applicants under section 12 of the Contempt Court's Act for alleged non-compliance of the interim order/injunction order granted by this Court in pending second appeal is not maintainable in view of alternative remedy available under Order XXXIX Rule 2-A of the Code of Civil procedure to applicant, accordingly same is dismissed.

17. No order as to costs.