- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kanai Lal Ghosh v. Basanta Behari Sen
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
In 1309 the plaintiff and his co-sharer obtained a darpatni settlement of a 4-annas share in three villages from predecessors of defendant No. 1 and executed a kabuliyat hypothecating that 4-annas share and seven other mouzahs as security for darpatni rent and related obligations. In 1312 they sold the darpatni to defendant No. 2; defendant No. 1 recognized the transfer and accepted rent from defendant No. 2. The kobala of sale contained a stipulation that defendant No. 2 would furnish security to defendant No. 1 or to the plaintiff and his co-sharer to replace the original security. Defendant No. 2 failed to furnish that security.
The plaintiff (to whom the seven mouzahs were subsequently allotted on partition with his co-sharer) first sued defendant No. 2 for specific performance (making defendant No. 1 a pro forma defendant) and obtained a deposit of security in cash, which defendant No. 1 did not accept. The plaintiff then instituted the present suit seeking a declaration that the seven mouzahs were no longer subject to any charge.
The Munsif dismissed the suit. On appeal the Subordinate Judge reversed and granted the plaintiff a decree declaring the charge no longer subsisted. The present appeal was preferred by the heirs of defendant No. 1 against that decree.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the plaintiff's liability to pay darpatni rent ceased on transfer of the darpatni to defendant No. 2 (i.e., whether liability based on privity of estate ends on transfer).
- Whether the security (charge) created by the kabuliyat over the seven mouzahs continued in force after the transfer, even if the lessee's liability for rent ceased.
- Whether allowing the security to continue indefinitely would offend the rule against perpetuities (i.e., whether such a charge is repugnant to that rule).
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' (defence) Arguments
- The lessee's liability to the lessor continued notwithstanding transfer because of privity of contract between the parties; the original lessee remains in the position of a surety and cannot rid himself of liability merely by transfer.
- The lessor had a remedy against the transferee for rent and covenants running with the land (privity of estate), so transferee was primarily liable, but the original lessee remained secondarily liable.
- Even if liability to pay rent ceased due to transfer, the security (charge) created by the kabuliyat remained in force and was not extinguished by the transfer.
Respondent's Arguments
- The lessee ceases to be liable for rent as soon as the transfer is complete; in any event liability ceases if the lessor has accepted the transferee, whether expressly or impliedly (for example, by acceptance of rent).
- There was acceptance of rent in the present case, so the original lessee's liability for rent had ceased.
- To hold that the security remains in force after such circumstances would offend the rule against perpetuities because it would allow a lessor to tie up property indefinitely by maintaining a continuing security.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Mahomed Abbas Mondul v. Brojo Sundari Debia, 18 C. 360 : 9 Ind. Dec. (N.S.) 240 | Stated that darpatni is a permanent tenure governed by the provisions of the Bengal Tenancy Act. | Used to establish that the darpatni in question is a permanent tenure and thus governed by the Bengal Tenancy Act framework (relevant to transfer rules). |
| Kristo Bulluv Ghose v. Kristo Lal Singh, 16 C. 642 : 8 Ind. Dec. (N.S.) 424 | Principle that when the vendor ceases to have any estate, liability consequent on privity of estate ceases. | Applied to conclude that after the transfer the plaintiff was no longer liable for the rent where liability was consequential on privity of estate. |
| Girish Chandra Guho v. Khagendra Nath Chattopadhyaya, 9 Ind. Cas. 1001 : 16 C.W.N. 64 : 13 C.L.J. 613 | Same principle as Kristo Bulluv Ghose: liability consequent on privity of estate ceases on transfer. | Reinforced the conclusion that the vendor's privity-of-estate liability ended on transfer, so defendant No. 1 must look to defendant No. 2 for rent. |
| Hamendra Nath Mukerji v. Kumar Nath Bay, 12 C.W.N. 478 | Held that the same principle (liability consequent on privity of estate ceases) applies in the case of transfer by the original lessee. | Supported the proposition that, on transfer by the lessee, the lessee's liability to pay rent (as arising from privity of estate) ceases. |
| Rupchand Ghose v. Narendra Krishna Ghose, 28 Ind. Cas. 683 : 19 C.W.N. 112 | Indicated that transfer causing a person to cease to be tenant does not necessarily absolve him from liability under personal covenant; a person may cease to be tenant and yet continue liable under his personal covenant. | Cited as authority for the possibility that contractual (personal) liabilities can survive transfer; court considered this point when assessing whether the kabuliyat created continuing obligations binding on transferor and on successors. |
| Dinobundhu Roy v. W.C. Banerjee, 19 C. 774 : 9 Ind. Dec. (N.S.) 958 | Held that a transfer in terms of the Bengal Tenancy Act is not binding on the landlord if there is a contract that transfer shall not be valid until security satisfactory to landlord is furnished; in such case original tenant remains liable for rent. | Used to support the proposition that a lessor can insist on a contractual stipulation that transfer will not be binding until security is furnished and that, if security is not furnished, the original tenant may remain liable. |
| Keshab Lal Nag Majumdar v. Madhu Sudan Pal Kundu, 6 Ind. Cas. 685 : 12 C.L.J. 126 | Holds that provisions of Section 10 of the Transfer of Property Act (saving conditions restraining alienation in leases where conditions benefit the lessor) are not inconsistent with Section 11 of the Bengal Tenancy Act; the two provisions can stand together. | Applied to show that a provision in a lease restricting transfer for the lessor's benefit is not inconsistent with tenant-transfer provisions of the Bengal Tenancy Act, supporting a landlord's competency to insist on security conditions. |
| Bijoy Chand Mohatab Bahadur v. Sarat Chandra Adhiya, 51 Ind. Cas. 909 : 29 C.L.J. 476 | The decision in that case turned on the specific terms of the kabuliyat there, which provided that so long as lessees were not released from liability to pay rent they could not transfer the property mortgaged as security; on transfer being completed lessees' liability ceased and security ended. | The court distinguished that authority, noting it rested on the particular kabuliyat terms and did not establish the general proposition that a charge is automatically extinguished upon cessation of rent liability. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded in distinct analytical steps, applying statutory and contractual principles as follows:
-
Characterization of tenure and effect of statutory transfer rules:
The court treated the darpatni as a permanent tenure governed by the Bengal Tenancy Act (citing Mahomed Abbas Mondul). It noted that under Section 11 a permanent tenure is transferable and Section 12 prescribes the mode and a condition precedent to registration. Once the transfer document is registered, the transfer is complete.
-
Effect of transfer on liability dependent on privity of estate:
Relying on Kristo Bulluv Ghose, Girish Chandra Guho, and Hamendra Nath Mukerji, the court held that where liability springs from privity of estate, that liability ceases when the vendor/lessee no longer has an estate. Thus, after the transfer the plaintiff ceased to be liable for rent and defendant No. 1 was to look to defendant No. 2.
-
Whether the contractual security (charge) survived the transfer:
The court examined whether, separate from rent liability, the kabuliyat created a continuing charge on the seven mouzahs. It acknowledged cases (e.g., Rupchand Ghose) indicating personal covenants may survive transfer; and it accepted the proposition that a lessor may, by contract, require that transfer be conditioned on satisfactory security (citing Dinobundhu Roy).
The court therefore resolved the question by examining the terms of the kabuliyat itself to determine the parties' intention: if the kabuliyat manifested an intention that the security continue, then transfer would not extinguish the charge.
-
Textual analysis of the kabuliyat:
The court quoted and analyzed the kabuliyat's language, which (among other things) permitted recovery of arrears or damages "from the said darpatni mehal and from the properties hypothecated as specified in Schedule (kha) or from our other moveable and immoveable properties"; it bound the lessees and their heirs and representatives and stated the properties in Schedule (kha) were given as security "in order to secure the said damages and for the performance of all the stipulations of this kabuliyat".
From this language the court concluded the parties intended a charge on the seven mouzahs "for all times to come" to secure payment of rent and performance of obligations arising under the kabuliyat, and there was nothing in the kabuliyat indicating the security would be extinguished merely because lessees' liability to pay rent ceased on transfer.
-
Response to rule against perpetuities objection:
The court rejected the contention that a perpetual charge offended the rule against perpetuities. It reasoned that the rule affects creation of future interests and restrictions on alienation, whereas a charge is a present interest created to secure payment of money; the property is made security but no future interest is being created by tying up transfer in the sense contemplated by the perpetuity rule. The creation of the charge formed part of the consideration for the darpatni lease; the court saw no reason it should be extinguished simply because the lessee transferred his leasehold interest.
-
Synthesis and conclusion from analysis:
The court concluded that while the lessee's liability to pay rent (arising from privity of estate) ceased on transfer, contractual obligations and the security created by the kabuliyat did not automatically end. On the facts and the terms of the kabuliyat, the plaintiff could not absolve himself of the charge by transferring the darpatni; moreover, the mere acceptance of rent by defendant No. 1 from defendant No. 2 did not extinguish the charge.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The court set aside the Subordinate Judge's decree and restored the Munsif's decision dismissing the plaintiff's suit; the plaintiff's declaration that the seven mouzahs were no longer subject to any charge was refused and the plaintiff's suit was dismissed with costs in all the Courts.
Implications:
- The direct effect on the parties is that the charge created by the kabuliyat on the seven mouzahs continues in force notwithstanding the transfer of the darpatni and notwithstanding acceptance of rent by the lessor from the transferee; the plaintiff (transferor) could not extinguish that charge by transfer.
- The court applied established principles (statutory transfer rules under the Bengal Tenancy Act; the effect of privity of estate on liability; contractual freedom to condition transfers and retain security) to the facts rather than announcing a novel principle. The opinion does not purport to announce a new general rule beyond applying these principles to the kabuliyat's specific terms.
Judges: Walmsley, J. (delivered the opinion); another judge recorded agreement ("I agree").
1. The facts necessary to be stated for the purposes of this appeal are these: In 1309, the plaintiff and his co-sharer obtained a darpatni settlement of 4-annas share of three villages from the predecessors of defendant No. 1 and executed a kabuliyat in their favour hypothecating the said 4-annas share of the three villages as well as seven other mouzahs as security for the payment of the darpatni rent and for the performance of obligations and discharge of liabilities incidental to the darpatni. In 1312 they sold the said darpatni to the defendant No. 2; and the defendant No. 1 recognized the transfer and accepted rent from the defendant No. 2. In the kobala by which the darpatni was sold there was a stipulation that the defendant No. 2 would furnish security to the defendant No. 1 or to the plaintiff and his co-sharer in order to re-place the security given by the plaintiff and his co-sharer. On the defendant No. 2 failing to furnish the said security the plaintiff, to whom the seven mouzahs in suit were subsequently allotted on partition between him and his co-sharer, instituted a suit against the defendant No. 2 making the defendant No. 1 pro forma defendant, for specific performance, and obtained a deposit of security in cash; but the defendant No. 1 did not accept the said security.
2. The plaintiff then instituted the present suit praying for a declaration that the said seven mouzahs were no longer subject to any charge.
3. The Munsif dismissed the suit, but the Subordinate Judge on appeal reversed that decision and granted the plaintiff a decree declaring that the charge no longer subsisted. From that decree the present appeal has been preferred by the heirs of the defendant No. 1.
4. The appellants' contention, which was the defence to the action, is that the liability of the lessee to the lessor continued notwithstanding the transfer, as based on the privity of contract between the parties; that the lessor had also a remedy against the transferee for rent and on the covenants running with the land, the transferee was under a liability based on privity of estate; that although the lessor has his remedy as against the transferee who is to be treated as primarily liable, the original lessee remains in the position of a surety and he cannot get rid of his liability merely by transfer. It is contended further that even if the liability to pay the rent be held to cease in consequence of the transfer the security remains in force and the charge is not extinguished.
5. The respondent urges that the lessee ceases to be liable for the rent as soon as the transfer is complete, and in any event if the lessor has accepted the transferee, whether expressly or impliedly, e.g., by acceptance of rent; that there having been acceptance of rent in the present case the original lessee's liability for rent has altogether ceased; and that to hold under such circumstances that the security still remains in force would be to offend against the rule against perpetuities.
6. Now, there is no dispute that the darpatni is a permanent tenure governed by the provisions of the Bengal Tenancy Act, Mahomed Abbas Mondul v. Brojo Sundari Debia 18 C. 360 : 9 Ind. Dec. (N.S.) 240. Under Section 11 of the Bengal Tenancy Act, it is capable of being transferred in the same manner and to the same extent as other immoveable property. Section 12 provides a limit as to the mode in which the transfer is to be made. As soon as the document by which the transfer is made is registered--and the registration is not to take place until a condition precedent mentioned in Section 12 is fulfilled--the transfer is complete. When the estate is transferred and the vendor ceases to have any estate, then if the vendor's liability is a liability consequent on privity of estate, that liability ceases: Kristo Bulluv Ghose v. Kristo Lal Singh 16 C. 642 : 8 Ind. Dec. (N.S.) 424 and Girish Chandra Guho v. Khagendra Nath Chattopadhyaya 9 Ind. Cas. 1001 : 16 C.W.N. 64 : 13 C.L.J. 613. The same principle has been held to apply in the case of transfer by the original lessee, Hamendra Nath Mukerji v. Kumar Nath Bay 12 C.W.N. 478. It is clear therefore that after the transfer the plaintiff was no longer liable for the rent, and the defendant No. 1 was thenceforward to look to the defendant No. 2 for the same.
7. The next question is as to whether, when the liability for payment of the rent ceased, the security continued and the charge remained in force. The appellants' contention is that it did, and that though as a consequence of the transfer the transferee became by operation of law the tenant of the tenure and the transferror ceased to be a tenant, the transferror was not necessarily absolved from the liability which was created by the contract. In support of this contention reliance has been placed upon a passage in the judgment of the Court in the case of Rupchand Ghose v. Narendra Krishna Ghose 28 Ind. Cas. 683 : 19 C.W.N. 112 at p. 114. The passage indicates that the fact that by transfer" the transferror ceases to be a tenant does not imply that he is absolved from liability tinder the terms of the contract between him and the lessor, and that it is conceivable that a person may cease to be a tenant and yet continue liable to the landlord under his personal covenant.
8. The respondent urges that if it is held that the security remains in force inspite of the transfer, it would mean that the lessor would be competent to impose a restriction on transfer of a permanent tenure which is transferable by law and that in that case the security might continue for ever and thus offend against the rule against perpetuities.
9. As regards the first of these objections, in my opinion, it is not well-founded on principle. In the case of Dinobundhu Roy v. W.C. Banerjee 19 C. 774 : 9 Ind. Dec. (N.S.) 958, it was held by this Court that a transfer of a tenure made in terms of the provisions of the Bengal Tenancy Act is not binding on the landlord, if there is a contract between the landlord and the tenant that the transfer shall not be valid and binding until security to the satisfaction of the landlord has been furnished, and if such security has not been given; and that in such a case the original tenant is still liable for the rent. Permanent leases no doubt are transferable under Section 11 of the Bengal Tenancy Act; but a provision in a lease of a permanent tenure for forfeiture or re-entry in case of assignment in violation of its terms would not be invalid in Keshab Lal Nag Majumdar v. Madhu Sudan Pal Kundu 6 Ind. Cas. 685 : 12 C.L.J. 126, it was held by this Court that the provisions of Section 10 of the Transfer of Property Act saving conditions restraining alienation in leases where the conditions are for the benefit of the lessor, are not inconsistent with the provisions of Section 11 of the Bengal Tenancy Act, and that the two provisions of the two Acts are not inconsistent or repugnant to each other but are capable of standing together. It follows, therefore, that the lessor is competent to insist on a stipulation that he would not be bound by the transfer unless the transferee keeps the security in force. The whole question then resolves itself into one as to whether such an intention or its contrary may be gathered from the kabuliyat. The learned Subordinate Judge has proceeded upon the decision in the case of Bijoy Chand Mohatab Bahadur v. Sarat Chandra Adhiya 51 Ind. Cas. 909 : 29 C.L.J. 476 which he treats as an authority for the proposition that the liability to pay the rent having ceased, the charge created for payment of rent is automatically extinguished. The decision in that case, however, rested upon the terms of the kabuliyat on which the case was based and not upon any such general principle. The kabuliyat in that case provided that so long as the lessees were not released from the liability to pay the rent, the lessees shall not be able to, transfer in any manner the property mortgaged as security for the rent. It was held in the case that on the transfer being completed the lessees' liability to pay the rent ceased and, therefore, the security was at an end.
10. The relevant passages in the kabuliyat in the present case are the following--
".... We shall without objection provide She rent instalment by instalment. If we fail therein you will be entitled to recover the arrears, according to the law which is in force, or which will be in force, from the said darpatni mehal and from the properties hypothecated as specified in Schedule (kha) or from our other moveable and immoveable properties which stand in our names or benami. To that neither we nor our heirs or representatives shall have any objection at any time whatsoever.... If you suffer any damage by our acts... then you will be entitled to recover the same from whatever moveable or immoveable properties we or our heirs or representatives shall have in our own name or benami and from the properties hypothecated and specified in Schedule (kha) and to that neither we nor they shall be entitled to raise any objection.... If this darpatni mehal be sold for arrears of rent due by us or in execution or is transferred in any other way, our representatives shall be bound by all the terms of this kabuliyat.... Being in possession as darpatni talukdar and maintaining intact the boundaries and regularly paying the rent, with our sons, grandsons, heirs and representatives shall in great felicity enjoy and possess the darpatni interest with powers of gift and sale.... In case we do anything injurious to you we and our heirs and representatives shall be bound to compensate you therefore, and in order to secure the said damages and for the performance of all the stipulations of this kabuliyat we give as security the properties in Schedule (kha) below owned and possessed by us...."
11. These conditions created a charge on the seven mouzahs for all times to come for the due payment of the darpatni rent and the performance of the other obligations arising under the kabuliyat, and there is nothing in the kabuliyat which may go to indicate that the security would be extinguished on the lessees' liability to pay the rent ceasing with the transfer. That this was the intention of the parties is also suggested by the term in the kobala by which the plaintiff and his co-sharer transferred the darpatni to the defendant No. 2 by which the latter was required to furnish security to the plaintiff and his co-sharer or to the defendant No. 1 in order to re-place the original security. This intention is also evidenced by the fact of the institution of the suit for specific performance, the result of which, however, is not binding on the defendant No. 1.
12. As regards the contention that a security of this description which is to last for all times to come is repugnant to the rule against perpetuities, I am not prepared to regard the contention as well-founded. This rule affects only the creation of a future interest in property and the restricting of transfer of property by tying it up. The rule has no application to the case of a charge where a present interest is created and there is no transfer of an interest in property, but the property is merely made security for the payment of money. The creation of this charge was a part of the consideration for the darpatni lease, and. I am unable to see how it could be extinguished merely because the lessee chose to transfer his interest under the lease. The position, therefore, is this: The liability to pay the rent subsists so long as the relationship of landlord and tenant exists. This relationship as between a landlord and his lessee, the permanent tenure-holder, ceases on the latter transferring the whole of his tenure. The lease may create further rights and liabilities as between the parties thereto and where it does, they do not cease automatically on the termination of the relationship.
13. For these reasons I am of opinion that plaintiff by merely transferring the darpatni to the defendant No. 2 could not get rid of the charge created by him under the kabuliyat, and that the mere acceptance of rent by the defendant No. 1 from the defendant No. 2 has not extinguished the same. The plaintiff, in my opinion, is not entitled to the declaration sought for by him.
14. The decree of the learned Subordinate Judge should be set aside and that of the learned Munsif restored and the plaintiff's suit dismissed with costs in all the Courts.
Walmsley, J.
15. I agree.
Alert