- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
A.L.S.P.P.L Subraman... v. Annamalai Chettiar B...
Case Summary: Right to Rateable Distribution under Section 73 — Decision and Analysis
Factual and Procedural Background
The petition concerns the right to rateable distribution under Section 73 of the Code of Civil Procedure. In 1931 the petitioner obtained a money decree against a grandfather, his son and his son's son (the grandson). The respondent had earlier obtained a money decree against the grandfather and the son but not against the grandson. In 1931 the grandfather and the son were adjudicated insolvent.
In 1937 the petitioner filed for execution of his decree and sought attachment of the grandson's interest in the family property; attachment was ordered and the grandson's interest was sold on 31st August 1937. Before the sale the respondent filed his own execution application seeking attachment and sale of the grandson's share and claimed a right to rateable distribution of the funds (specifically seeking to share in Rs. 800 realised). The District Munsif of Dharapuram overruled the petitioner's objection to the respondent's claim, relying on the decision in Palaniappa Chettiar v. Palani Goundan (1936) 71 M.L.J. 541. The petitioner sought to set aside the District Munsif's order by invoking the revisional powers of the High Court.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, in the facts before the Court, the respondent was entitled to rateable distribution of the proceeds under Section 73 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
- Whether a decree obtained against the father (or other joint-manager of a joint family) is to be treated as a decree "against the same judgment-debtor" so as to attract the doctrine of rateable distribution — i.e., whether a decree against the father can be treated as a decree against the sons to the extent of their interests in the family property.
- Whether the decision of Horwill, J., in Arunachalam Chettiar v. Kalayappa Chettiar (1937) 1 M.L.J. 180 should be followed or overruled in the context of rateable distribution and execution against joint family property where insolvency has intervened.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner contended that Section 73 did not apply because the respondent's decree was not obtained against "the same judgment-debtor" as the petitioner's decree; specifically, it was argued that the respondent's decree had not been obtained against the grandson and thus rateable distribution should not be available to the respondent.
Respondent's Contentions
- The respondent applied for execution of his decree and claimed entitlement to rateable distribution in the sum realised by the petitioner's execution proceedings (Rs. 800), having filed his execution application before the proceeds of the sale were brought into Court. The opinion records this claim but does not set out an extended argument in his favor beyond the factual basis for claiming rateable distribution.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Palaniappa Chettiar v. Palani Goundan (1936) 71 M.L.J. 541 | Applied to support the proposition that a decree-holder who files for execution and obtains attachment of a member's share in joint family property may be entitled to rateable distribution when similar facts obtain (including insolvency considerations). | The District Munsif relied on this decision to reject the petitioner's objection; the High Court considered that reliance to be correct and affirmed the result in the present case. |
| Sat Narain v. Behari Lal (1924) 47 M.L.J. 857; L.R. 52 I.A. 22; I.L.R. 6 Lah. 1 (P.C.) | Established the rule that when a father who is joint with his son becomes insolvent the right to realize the son's share in the family estate (under the pious obligation rule) devolves on the Official Assignee/Official Receiver; but if a judgment-creditor attaches the son's interest before the Official Assignee acts, the Official Assignee loses the power to sell that share. | The Court used this principle to hold that because the petitioner attached the grandson's share before the Insolvency Court acted, the Insolvency Court's interest was lost and the share became available to executing creditors (and thus to rateable distribution under Section 73). |
| Seetharama Chettiar v. Official Receiver, Tanjore (1926) 51 M.L.J. 269; I.L.R. 49 Mad. 849 (F.B.) | One of the cases cited to illustrate the insolvency/OA principle described above. | Referenced as supporting authority for the insolvency/OA principle and incorporated into the Court's conclusion about the effect of the petitioner's prior attachment. |
| Sat Narain v. Sri Kishen Das; Same v. The Bank of Upper India (1936) 71 M.L.J. 812; L.R. 63 I.A. 384; I.L.R. 17 Lah. 644 (P.C.) | Cited among authorities establishing how insolvency and prior attachment affect the Official Assignee's rights. | Used in conjunction with other authorities to support the Court's insolvency-related conclusion. |
| Gopalakrishnayya v. Gopalan (1928) 54 M.L.J. 674; I.L.R. 51 Mad. 342 | Cited as authority in the line of cases on insolvency and attachment affecting rights in joint family shares. | Relied on as part of the body of authority showing that prior execution/attachment by a creditor defeats the Insolvency Court's power to sell the share. |
| Arunachalam v. Sabaratnam (1939) 1 M.L.J. 889; I.L.R. (1939) Mad. 585 | Cited among cases dealing with insolvency and related principles (grouped with other insolvency decisions). | Included in the group of authorities supporting the insolvency/attachment rule adopted by the Court. |
| Ramanathan Chettiar v. Subramania Sastrial (1902) 12 M.L.J. 276; I.L.R. 26 Mad. 179 | Held that where one decree is against the father and another against the father and son, but the properties are ancestral/joint family properties, the decrees are to be treated as "against the same judgment-debtor" for the corresponding provision in the earlier Code (Section 295 of the Code of 1882). | The Court relied on this authority to reject the petitioner's argument that Section 73 did not apply because the respondent's decree was not nominally against the same person; it supported a liberal construction of "the same judgment-debtor". |
| Ramakrishna Chettiar v. Viswanatha(n) Chettiar (1935) (Full Bench) 69 M.L.J. 711; I.L.R. 59 Mad. 93 (F.B.) | Full Bench holding that a legal representative (or, in context, persons liable to the debt by virtue of joint family liability) should be treated as the "same judgment-debtor" for the purpose of the corresponding provision (here Section 73), and that a liberal construction of that phrase is appropriate. | The Court treated the Full Bench decision as authoritative support for treating decrees as against the same judgment-debtor even where the names differ eo nomine; it cited this decision approvingly in rejecting the petitioner's narrow construction. |
| Swaminatha Aiyar v. Saivu Rowthan (1935) 43 L.W. 624 | Holds that when a decree has been passed against the manager of a joint Hindu family, other members of the family must be deemed judgment-debtors as well; consequently, another decree-holder who has a decree against the manager and other members is entitled to rateable distribution. | The Court cited this decision as reinforcing the view that a decree against one joint-manager can be treated as a decree against the other members for rateable distribution purposes. |
| Ramayya v. Rangaraju (1938) 1 M.L.J. 325 | Decision following Palaniappa Chettiar and holding in similar circumstances that a decree-holder was entitled to rateable distribution. | Referenced as a supporting authority for the proposition that rateable distribution is appropriate in the factual circumstances of the present case. |
| Arunachalam Chettiar v. Kalayappa Chettiar (1937) 1 M.L.J. 180 | Decision (by Horwill, J.) holding that a petitioner in the stated facts was not entitled to rateable distribution; stressed lack of making the son a party and doubtful application of the Full Bench decision. | The Court regarded Horwill, J.'s judgment as erroneous and in direct conflict with other authorities (including the Full Bench decisions and decisions of Venkataramana Rao, J.). The present Court overruled the reasoning in that case. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded by identifying and applying two interrelated lines of authority present in the text: (1) authorities concerning insolvency and the Official Assignee's rights to realize the share of a joint family member, and (2) authorities concerning the meaning of the phrase "the same judgment-debtor" for the purposes of rateable distribution (Section 73).
On the insolvency point the Court relied on established precedents to explain the operative rule: when the father (who is a joint member) is adjudicated insolvent, the right to realize the son's share normally vests in the Official Assignee/Official Receiver. However, if a judgment-creditor attaches the son's interest before the Official Assignee takes steps to enforce that right, the Official Assignee's power to sell that share is lost. The Court applied that rule to the facts: because the petitioner attached and procured the sale of the grandson's interest before the Insolvency Court acted, the Insolvency Court's interest in the share was extinguished and the share (and proceeds) became available to executing creditors and those entitled to rateable distribution.
On the question whether the respondent's decree was "against the same judgment-debtor," the Court rejected the petitioner's narrow literalist argument. The Court cited the Ramanathan Chettiar decision and the Full Bench decision in Ramakrishna Chettiar as authority for a liberal construction: a money decree against a grandfather who is joint with his son and grandson is to be treated as a decree against the son and grandson to the extent of their interests in the joint family property, because they are liable for the father's lawful debts to that extent. The Court also relied on Swaminatha Aiyar (and other cases) to reinforce the approach of treating managers or heads of joint families and the other members as effectively judgment-debtors for these purposes. Because the respondent filed his execution application before the proceeds were brought into Court, he became entitled to rateable distribution under Section 73.
The Court considered the contrary authority of Horwill, J., in Arunachalam Chettiar v. Kalayappa Chettiar (1937) but found that decision to be in direct conflict with the Full Bench and other authorities. The Court agreed with the observations of Venkataramana Rao, J., that a strict literal construction of "the same judgment-debtor" is inappropriate; so long as a decree stands and the property sold is joint family property, the question whether the debt is binding on the sons does not arise at the stage of deciding whether the judgment-debtors are the same for rateable distribution purposes. Consequently the Court regarded Horwill, J.'s judgment as erroneous and overruled it in effect.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The petition is DISMISSED. The Court held that the District Munsif's order (which allowed the respondent to share rateably in the proceeds realised from the grandson's share) was correct.
Implications and direct effects:
- The Court affirmed that, where a judgment-creditor attaches the interest of a joint family member before the Official Assignee/Official Receiver acts, the Insolvency Court loses its power to sell that share and the share/proceeds become available to executing creditors and those entitled to rateable distribution under Section 73.
- The Court endorsed a liberal construction of "the same judgment-debtor" for the purposes of Section 73: a decree against a father or manager of a joint family may be treated as a decree against other members to the extent of their interests, making rateable distribution available in appropriate circumstances.
- The Court expressly considered and rejected the contrary reasoning in Arunachalam Chettiar v. Kalayappa Chettiar (Horwill, J.), describing it as erroneous and inconsistent with Full Bench authority and other decisions.
- On relief between the parties: the petition is dismissed and, because the respondent did not appear, there is no order as to costs.
- The Court's decision upholds the District Munsif's order in the particular factual matrix; the opinion treats the decision as consistent with existing precedent rather than as the announcement of a novel legal principle.
Judge Krishnaswami Aiyangar, J. delivered the principal opinion; another judge (name not separately appended beyond "I agree.") concurred in the result.
1. This petition raises a question with regard to the right to rateable distribution given by Section 73 of the Code of Civil Procedure, but when the authorities are examined it is clear that they negative the petitioner's contention. In 1931 the petitioner obtained a money decree against a grandfather, his son and his son's son. The respondent had previously obtained a money decree against the grandfather and the son, but not against the grandson. In 1931, in separate proceedings, the grandfather and the son were adjudicated insolvents. In 1937 the petitioner filed an application for execution of his decree and asked for the attachment of the grandson's interest in the family property. Attachment was ordered and the grandson's interest was sold on 31st August, 1937. Before the sale took place the respondent filed an application for the execution of his decree, and he also asked for the attachment and sale of the grandson's share in the family property. On the strength of this application the respondent claimed to be entitled to share rateably in the sum of Rs. 800, which was the amount realised in the execution proceedings instituted by the petitioner. The petitioner objected to the respondent's claim to rateable distribution, but his objection was overruled by the District Munsif of Dharapuram in whose Court the execution petitions were filed and the assets realised. The District Munsif, in rejecting the petitioner's contention, relied on the decision in Palaniappa Chettiar v. Palani Goundan (1936) 71 M.L.J. 541. The petitioner asks this Court to set aside the District Munsif's order under its revisional powers.
2. It is now well settled law that where a father who is joint with his son becomes insolvent, the right of realising the son's share in the family estate under the pious obligation rule devolves upon the Official Assignee or the Official Receiver as the case may be. But, if before the Official Assignee or the Official Receiver takes steps to en force that right, a judgment-creditor of the father attaches the son's interest in the estate, the power of the Official Assignee or Official Receiver to sell the son's share is lost. See Sat Narain v. Behari Lal (1924) 47 M.L.J. 857 : L.R. 52 I.A. 22 : I.L.R. 6 Lah. 1 (P.C.), Seetharama Chettiar v. Official Receiver, Tanjore (1926) 51 M.L.J. 269 : I.L.R. 49 Mad. 849 (F.B.), Sat Narain v. Sri Kishen Das : Same v. The Bank of Upper India (1936) 71 M.L.J. 812 : L.R. 63 I.A. 384 : I.L.R. 17 Lah. 644 (P.C.), Gopalakrishnayya v. Gopalan (1928) 54 M.L.J. 674 : I.L.R. 51 Mad. 342 and Arunachalam v. Sabaratnam (1939) 1 M.L.J. 889 : I.L.R. (1939) Mad. 585 Therefore, as the result of the petitioner's attachment of the grandson's share the Insolvency Court lost all its interest in that share, which then became available to the petitioner as the executing creditor and to all persons who became entitled to rateable distribution under Section 73 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Before the proceeds of the grandson's property were brought into Court, the respondent field his application for execution and thereupon became entitled to rateable distribution.
3. On behalf of the petitioner the argument has been advanced, that the respondent's decree was not obtained against the same judgment-debtor and therefore Section 73 does not apply, but this argument cannot be accepted. There is ample authority for holding that where a money decree is passed against a grandfather who is joint with his son and grandson it must be taken to be a decree passed against the son and the grandson to the extent of their interests in the family property as they are liable to that extent for his lawful debts. In Ramanathan Chettiar v. Subramania Sastrial (1902) 12 M.L.J. 276 : I.L.R. 26 Mad. 179, where the decree of one of two judgment-creditors was against the father while the decree of the other judgment creditor was against the father and his son, but the properties from which the assets had been realized by sale were the ancestral properties of the family of which the father and son were undivided members, White, C.J., held that the decrees were "against the same judgment-debtor" for the purpose of Section 295 of the Code of 1882, to which Section 73 of the present Code corresponds. In Ramakrishna Chettiar v. Viswanathan Chettiar (1935) 69 M.L.J. 276 : I.L.R. 26 Mad. 179, a Full Bench of this Court (Beasley, C.J., Cornish and Pandrang Row, JJ.) held that the legal representative of a deceased person against whom a decree was passed in his life time but which was sought to be executed against his property in the hands of his legal representative-was the same judgment-debtor within the meaning of Section 73. Pandrang Row, J., in whose judgment Beasley, C.J., concurred, observed that it was obvious that a strict literal construction of the expression, "the same judgment-debtor" could not be adopted in the sense that the decrees must be against the same persons eo nomine, and the weight of authority appeared to favour a liberal construction of the expression "the same judgment-debtor". The decision of White, C.J., in Ramanathan Chettiar v. Subramania Sastrial (1902) 12 M.L.J. 276 : I.L.R. 26 Mad. 179, was referred to with obvious approval.
4. In Swaminatha Aiyar v. Saivu Rowthan (1935) 43 L.W. 624, Venkataramana Rao, J., held that when a decree has been passed against a manager of a joint Hindu family, the other members of the family must be deemed to be judgment-debtors as well, and where another decree-holder has obtained a decree against the manager and the other members of the family, they are entitled to rateable distribution. The learned Judge considered that the Full Bench decision in Ramakrishna Chettiar v. Viswanatha Chettiar (1935) 69 M.L.J. 711 : I.L.R. 59 I.L.R. 59 Mad. 93 (F.B.), applied. There was no insolvency in this cafe, but in a later decision, Palaniappa Chettiar v. Palani Goundan (1936) 71 M.L.J. 541 Venkataramana Rao, J., had to consider the same question in connection with insolvency proceedings. In that case the respondent filed a suit against the father and attached before judgment the family property. He eventually obtained a decree, and five months later the judgment-debtor was adjudicated an insolvent. Subsequent to the adjudication, the petitioner, with the leave of the Insolvency Court, filed a suit against the father and his sons. The petitioner also applied for attachment before judgment of the son's share in the joint family property. A decree was in due course passed in his favour and the son's shares were realized in execution proceedings. Before the sale took place the respondent applied for the execution of his decree by the sale of the family estate and claimed rateable distribution. The learned Judge held that he was entitled to rateable distribution as the decree obtained against the father and the father and the sons were decrees passed against the same judgment-debtor. A similar decision was given by the learned Judge in Ramayya v. Rangaraju (1938) 1 M.L.J. 325.
5. The only case which lends support to the petitioner's argument is Arunachalam Chettiar v. Kalayappa Chettiar (1937) 1 M.L.J. 180, which was decided by Horwill, J. There the respondents attached before judgment the estate of a joint family consisting of the father and a son. A decree was obtained and the property was subsequently brought to sale, the purchase money being deposited into Court. The father then became an insolvent, and the father's share of the proceeds was handed over to the Official Receiver. The petitioner had obtained a decree against the father on a promissory note and applied for a rateable distribution. His application was filed before the proceeds had been deposited into Court. Horwill, J., considered that the petitioner was not entitled to rateable distribution. It would appear from his judgment that he considered that the Full Bench decision in Ramakrishna Chettiar v. Viswanatha Chettiar (1935) 69 M.L.J. 711 : I.L.R. 59 Mad. 93 (F.B.), had no application and he laid stress on the fact that the petitioner did not make the son a party to the execution proceedings on the ground that he was liable for his father's debts and that the Court did not know that the decree was obtained against the father for a debt binding on the son. In these circumstances he rejected the petitioner's claim to rateable distribution. This decision js in direct conflict with the judgments of Venkataramana Rao, J., in Palaniappa Chettiar v. Palani Goundan (1936) 71 M.L.J. 541, and Ramayya v. Rangaraju (1938) 1 M.L.J. 325, and it also runs contrary to the decision of the Ful 1 Bench in Ramakrishna Chettiar v. Viswanatha Chettiar (1935) 69 M.L.J. 711 : I.L.R. 59 Mad. 93 (F.B.). The judgment of Horwill, J., was considered by Venkataramana Rao, J., in Ramayya v. Rangaraju (1938) 1 M.L.J. 325, and I am in entire agreement with the observations of Venkataramana Rao, J., which are these:
The learned Judge seems to be of the opinion that where there is a decree against the father alone it cannot be said that the decree was obtained against the father for a debt binding on the son. It may be so. But once there is a decree against the father the creditor is entitled to enforce the said decree against all the joint family property including the shares of the sons until the sons choose to take exception to it either in execution or by way of a suit that the said debt is one which they are not liable to pay under the Hindu Law. So long as the decree stands and the property sold is joint family property, no question as to the binding nature of the debt arises in the consideration of the question whether the judgment-debtors are the same.
6. It follows that I consider the judgment of Horwill, J., to be erroneous and should be overruled. It also follows that I consider that the decision of the District Munsif in the present case was right. The petition will be dismissed but as the respondent has not appeared there will be no order as to costs.
7. I wish to express the appreciation of the Court for the great assistance which it has received from Mr. K.V. Ramachandra Ayyar who has appeared on behalf of the petitioner. He has placed all the relevant authorities before the Court.
Krishnaswami Aiyangar, J.
8. I agree.
Alert