- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Balwant Singh, , v. Sant Ram Sharma, .
Factual and Procedural Background
The tenant filed an application for fixation of standard rent concerning a portion of House No. 5969 in Karol Bagh, Delhi. The landlord contested the application, arguing that the parties' relationship was that of licensee and licensor rather than landlord and tenant. The Rent Controller, by an order dated 7th December 1959, held that the relationship as asserted by the tenant existed and directed evidence to be produced for fixation of standard rent. The landlord appealed, and the Rent Control Tribunal ruled that the Rent Controller's order was not final and therefore not appealable under section 38 of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the order made by the Rent Controller deciding the preliminary issue of whether the relationship of landlord and tenant exists between the parties is appealable under section 38 of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The order deciding the preliminary question of the landlord-tenant relationship is an order made under the Act and thus appealable under section 38.
- The Rent Controller's decision must be based on definitions in section 2 of the Act, and since the Controller has jurisdiction to make such an order, it should be deemed final and appealable.
- Reliance on precedents such as South Asia, Industries Private Limited v. S.B Sarup Singh and others and a decision by Mahajan J. in Pokar Mal v. Prem Nath and others which held certain orders by Rent Controllers as appealable under the Act.
Respondent's Arguments
- The order deciding the preliminary issue is interlocutory and not made under any specific provision of the Act, hence not appealable.
- Preliminary questions such as the existence of landlord-tenant relationship determine jurisdiction but do not constitute orders under the Act.
- Reliance on precedents like Messrs Lachhman Das Moti Ram v. Shori Lal and Niadre v. Nanneh which held that certain preliminary or interlocutory orders are not appealable.
- The Rent Control Tribunal's view that only final orders of the Controller are appealable, supported by analogous decisions under other statutes such as the Indian Companies Act and the Provincial Insolvency Act.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| South Asia, Industries Private Limited v. S.B Sarup Singh and others (1962 P.L.R 65) | Interpretation of "orders made under this Act" in section 38(1) - distinction between interim and final orders and their appealability. | Supported the principle that only orders expressly made under the Act are appealable; interim orders may not be appealable if not final. |
| Messrs Lachhman Das Moti Ram v. Shori Lal (1960 P.L.R 254) | Preliminary issue on limitation in proceedings before Rent Controller is not an order under the Act and not appealable. | Reinforced the view that preliminary or interlocutory orders, not made under the Act, are not appealable. |
| Niadre v. Nanneh (I.L.R 1960 (2) Punj. 76) | Order allowing substitution of legal representatives is not appealable under the Act. | Supported the principle that only orders made under the Act qualify for appeal. |
| Pokar Mal v. Prem Nath and others (1963 P.L.R 1056) | Order refusing to set aside an ex parte order is an order under the Act and appealable. | Distinguished from the present case on the basis that the order there was final, not interlocutory. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court analyzed whether the Rent Controller's order deciding the preliminary question of landlord-tenant relationship is an order "made under the Act" and hence appealable under section 38(1) of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958. The court observed that while the Rent Controller must consider definitions in section 2 of the Act to decide this question, such a determination is preliminary and jurisdictional rather than a substantive order under the Act. The court referred to several precedents holding that interlocutory or preliminary orders not explicitly made under the Act are not appealable. The court distinguished the present case from decisions where final orders were held appealable. It also noted the Rent Control Tribunal's reliance on analogous statutory interpretations that interlocutory orders are generally not appealable. Ultimately, the court concluded that the preliminary order in question does not fall within the appealable orders under section 38(1) and thus dismissed the appeal.
Holding and Implications
The appeal is dismissed with costs.
The court held that the preliminary order of the Rent Controller deciding the existence of a landlord-tenant relationship is not an appealable order under section 38(1) of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958. The decision confines appealability to final orders made under the Act, excluding interlocutory or preliminary determinations on jurisdictional questions. This ruling directly affects the parties by upholding the Rent Control Tribunal's decision and clarifies that such preliminary orders do not attract appeals, but it does not establish a broader precedent beyond the facts of this case.
Grover, J. — The sole point in this appeal is whether the order made by the Rent Controller deciding a preliminary issue whether the relationship of landlord and tenant exists between the parties was appealable.
The tenant had filed an application for fixation of standard rent regarding a portion of House No. 5969 in Karol Bagh, Delhi. The landlord contested the application on the ground that the relationship between the parties was one of licensee and licensor and not of tenant and landlord. The Rent Controller by an order dated 7th December, 1959, held that the relationship of the nature asserted by the tenant existed between the parties and therefore, it was directed that evidence be produced in the matter of fixation of standard rent. The landlord filed an appeal and in a fairly lengthy order the Rent Control Tribunal held that the order made by the Rent Controller was not final and was not appealable under section 38 of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958 (to be hereinafter referred to as the Act).
The main contention of Mr. P.S Safeer, who appears for the appellant, is that the order deciding the preliminary question whether the relationship of landlord and tenant exists between the parties—is an order made under the Act and, therefore, an appeal would lie under section 38 of the Act to the Rent Control Tribunal. The aforesaid section provides that:—
“(1) An appeal shall lie from every order of Controller made under this Act to the Rent Control Tribunal (hereinafter referred to as the Tribunal) consisting of one person only to be appointed by the Central Government by notification in the official Gazette.
Section 36 deals with the powers of the Controller and section 37 with the procedure to be followed by him. According to sub-section (2) of section 37, the Controller while holding an enquiry must follow as far as may be the practice and procedure of a Court of Small Causes. Section 43 makes the order of the Controller or the order passed on appeal final. The expressions “landlord” and “tenant” are defined by clauses (e) and (1) of section 2 of the Act. The contention of Mr. Safeer is that the decision given by the Rent Controller with regard to relationship between the parties has to be given with reference to the definition contained in section 2 and since the Controller has the jurisdiction to make such an order it must be deemed to be an order made under the Act and as it finally and conclusively determines the question of relationship, the order must be deemed to be final with the result that it would be appealable under section 38 (1). In South Asia, Industries Private Limited v. S.B Sarup Singh and others () 1962 P.L.R 65. Gosain J. had an occasion to interpret the meaning of words made under this Act is section 38 (1). It was pointed out by him that the orders which are made by the Rent Controller may be in the nature of interim orders or final orders. All those orders when made must be deemed to have been made under the Act and must therefore be appealable. But these words refer to the express provisions of the Act and not to the provisions contained in the Civil Procedure Code. In the case which was decided by him, an order by which the name of the tenant had been struck off the records was held not to be covered by section 38(1) at it was not an order made under the Act. In Messrs Lachhman Das Moti Ram v. Shori Lal . () 1960 P.L.R 254, in the proceedings before the Rent Controller for fixation of standard rent a preliminary issue had been framed and decided on the question of limitation. It was held that such an order could not be regarded as an order under the Act and was not appealable as such. In Niadre v. Nanneh () I.L.R 1960 (2) Punj. 76 , I held that an order allowing substitution of legal representatives was not an appealable order. The basis of all these decisions is that in order to be appealable the order must have been made under the provisions of the Act.
When a question arises in proceedings before the Rent Controller whether relationship of landlord and tenant exists between the parties, the order disposing of that issue is not one which is made under any of the provisions of the Act. That question has to be decided for settling whether the Rent Controller would have jurisdiction to entertain and proceed with the application for fixation of standard rent or for eviction, as the case may be, which has been filed before him. But while deciding that matter the Rent Controller is not making any order under the Act although he may have to consider the definitions given in section 2 of the expressions “landlord” and “tenant”. It is difficult to hold that every order made by the Rent Controller in the exercise of his jurisdiction as such would be an order made under the Act.
Mr. Safeer relies on a decision of Mahajan J. in Pokar Mal v. Prem Nath and others () 1963 P.L.R 1056, in which it was held that an order of the Rent Controller refusing to set aside an ex parte order is an order under the Act. The learned Judge referred to section 37 and relied on the provisions therein that the procedure which the Rent Controller has to follow is the procedure prescribed for the Courts of Small Causes. He was of the view that if the Judge, Small Cause Court, had the power by virtue of section 37 of the Ad, the Rent Controller had also the power and that being so the order refusing to set aside on ex parte order must be held to be an order under section 37. I cannot see how that decision can be of an assistance in deciding whether an order deciding one issue in proceedings relating to standard rent of the nature that was decided in the present case would become appealable under Section 38. It is noteworthy that in the case decided by Mahajan J. the order which was sought to be appealed against was final and was not of an interlocutory nature as it is in the present case. It may be that certain interlocutory orders which are made under the Act would be appealable but I cannot accede to the contention that the Legislature could have ever intended that an order of a preliminary nature deciding the question of relationship of landlord and tenant was to be appealable.
The Rent Control Tribunal referred to decisions under the Indian Companies Act, the Provincial Insolvency Act etc., where similar language is employed and in which it had been held that an interlocutory order is not appealable. He was of the opinion that only a final order of the Controller was appealable. There is a good deal of force in the view expressed by the Rent Control Tribunal but no final opinion need be expressed on the nature of the orders which will be appealable, be they interlocutory or final under the Act. Suffice it to say that so far as the order sought to be appealed against is concerned, it could not possibly be regarded as falling within the provisions of section 38(1) on the Act. I would, therefore, dismiss this appeal with costs.
B.R.T
Alert