Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Dharam Singh v. Ram Dial Singh Fuller

Allahabad High Court
Jul 18, 1914
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The dispute concerns co-sharers of the village Bhankra and events that followed a partition in 1898 which divided the village into several mahals. One mahal was assigned to Thakur Dharam Singh (the plaintiff-appellant) and included a plot of land described as old No. 337 (area: 2 bighas 7 biswas). Another mahal, Mahal Kalan Ghairkhwahindgar, contained plots including Nos. 335, 336 and 417; at least No. 336 is identified as the defendant's property.

In the 1900 settlement the village numbers were re-assigned: old No. 337 was given a corresponding number 981 (if correctly stated) and Nos. 336 and 417 were given the corresponding number 797 (if correctly stated). The village map correctly located the mahals, but the khasra prepared at settlement contained reciprocal mistakes: the khasra showed 337 linked to 797 (instead of 981), and 336/417 linked to 981 (instead of 797). The mistake remained undetected in the revenue records while the physical possession continued with the same occupants: the plaintiff in the field of old No. 337, the defendants in their respective plots.

The plaintiff later acquired an interest in Mahal Kalan Ghairkhwahindgar (by mortgage and subsequently by sale or foreclosure) and therefore became a co-sharer there. In 1907 a co-sharer in Mahal Kalan, Ram Piari, applied for partition of her share; the plaintiff was impleaded as a necessary party in those partition proceedings. Because of the earlier khasra mistake, the plot corresponding to No. 981 (i.e., old No. 337, belonging to Mahal Dharam Singh) was treated in the partition as part of Mahal Kalan and was assigned to the defendant. The mistake only became apparent later when the defendant initiated proceedings against the tenant in possession of old No. 337.

The plaintiff instituted this suit seeking a declaration that old No. 337 (corresponding number 981) is part of his mahal (Thakur Dharam Singh) and that the 1907 partition proceedings which treated No. 981 as part of Mahal Kalan Ghairkhwahindgar did not affect his rights. The facts relating to the ownership of No. 337 are undisputed in the record.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the erroneous treatment and allotment of old No. 337 (shown as corresponding No. 981) in the 1907 partition of Mahal Kalan Ghairkhwahindgar precludes the plaintiff from asserting his proprietary right in that land.
  2. Whether Section 233(k) of the Land Revenue Act bars the plaintiff's suit to correct the record or to obtain a declaration respecting old No. 337.
  3. Whether the plaintiff is estopped from asserting his title by reason of not pointing out the khasra/numbering mistake during the 1907 partition proceedings.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Plaintiff)'s Position

  • The plaintiff sought a declaration that old No. 337 (corresponding number 981) is part of Mahal Thakur Dharam Singh and was never part of Mahal Kalan Ghairkhwahindgar.
  • The plaintiff maintained that the 1907 partition of Mahal Kalan could not, and did not, affect his proprietary right in land that never belonged to that mahal.
  • The plaintiff relied on the undisputed factual position that physical possession and the correct map showed No. 337 in Mahal Dharam Singh.

Respondent (Defendant)'s Position — as presented by Mr. Dar

  • Argued that the suit is barred by Section 233(k) of the Land Revenue Act, relying on the precedent of Lachman Das v. Hanuman Prasad.
  • Argued that the plaintiff was estopped from claiming the land because he did not disclose the mistake in the course of the 1907 partition proceedings.
  • Relied on other cited cases (Tirbeni Sahai v. Gokal Prasad and Kishan Prasad v. Kadher Mal) to support the contention that partition proceedings should preclude subsequent suits in certain circumstances.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Lachman Das…(Defendant); v. Hanuman Prasad…(Plaintiff) The duty of a co-sharer in the mahal being partitioned to claim lands during the partition (failure to claim under Section 112 may preclude reopening the matter by suit). The Court explained that this case involved land admittedly part of the mahal whose partition was in issue; it was distinguished from the present case because the land here was never part of the mahal being partitioned (so the same rationale did not apply).
Tirbeni Sahai v. Gokal Prasad A partition related to a mahal of which the land in dispute was claimed as part; illustrates partition cases where the land in question formed part of the mahal being partitioned. The Court noted this case similarly concerned land that belonged to the mahal under partition and therefore is distinguishable from the present situation where the disputed land did not belong to the mahal being partitioned.
Kishan Prasad v. Kadher Mal Relevant to the situation where a party was impleaded in partition only as a co-sharer of the mahal being partitioned and the obligation (or expectation) to raise claims in those proceedings. The Court treated this case as more in point than the others but observed that in the present matter neither party discovered the khasra mistake at the time; thus the plaintiff could not be blamed for failing to point out a mistake unknown to him, and the defendant likewise had an opportunity to object.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by stressing the statutory scheme under the Land Revenue Act: revenue Courts have exclusive jurisdiction to partition a mahal, and partition proceedings are confined to the mahal in respect of which the application is made. The Court reviewed the procedural safeguards that apply to partition applications: Section 107 (application must be accompanied by a certified copy of the annual register of proprietors of the mahal), Section 110 (Collector must notify recorded co-sharers who have not joined), Section 111 (such co-sharers may raise objections within the time fixed by proclamation), and Section 112 (where an objection involves a question of proprietary title it may be disposed of in the manner provided).

Applying those principles, the Court observed that the 1907 partition proceedings were proceedings for Mahal Kalan Ghairkhwahindgar only and that the revenue Court had no jurisdiction to partition lands not belonging to that mahal. Because the khasra mistake was not discovered before the date fixed for objections, it could not be raised under Sections 111 and 112 in those partition proceedings.

The Court then considered whether Section 233(k) or estoppel precluded the plaintiff's suit. It accepted the trial Court's conclusion that Section 233(k) did not bar the suit, distinguishing the cited authorities where plaintiffs failed to claim land that was indisputably part of the mahal being partitioned. Here, the land in dispute (old No. 337 / corresponding 981) was never part of Mahal Kalan Ghairkhwahindgar and therefore the revenue Court lacked jurisdiction in 1907 to deal with it; the plaintiff's position was analogous to that of a stranger asserting title to land wrongly treated as part of a mahal.

On the estoppel argument, the Court found no basis to hold the plaintiff estopped. The record did not show that the plaintiff made any representation that old No. 337 was part of Mahal Kalan; if any misleading representation occurred it was likely due to the clerk who prepared the erroneous khasra. The Court rejected the appellate Court's reasoning that failure to disclose the mistake amounted to an estoppel, noting that both parties were equally misled by the clerical error and that the defendant should have raised an objection when the number 981 was allotted to him.

The Court also noted that the plaintiff's claim lay within limitation and that his proprietary rights were subsisting at the date of the 1907 partition. On these grounds the Court agreed with the trial Court, set aside the lower appellate Court's decree, and restored the trial Court's decree (with costs and higher-scale counsel fee).

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: APPEAL ALLOWED; the decree of the lower appellate Court is set aside and the decree of the Court of first instance is restored.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The plaintiff is entitled to the relief sought in the suit: a declaration that old No. 337 (corresponding number 981) is part of Mahal Thakur Dharam Singh and that the 1907 partition allotment (which treated No. 981 as part of Mahal Kalan Ghairkhwahindgar) did not divest him of his rights.
  • The plaintiff's suit was not barred by Section 233(k) of the Land Revenue Act and the claim was not defeated by estoppel on the facts before the Court.
  • The trial Court's decree is restored with costs, including counsel's fee on the higher scale in this Court.

Broader precedent: The opinion distinguishes prior authorities on the facts and bases its decision on the limited statutory jurisdiction of revenue Courts in partition and on the factual finding that the land in dispute never belonged to the mahal that was partitioned. The opinion does not purport to establish a broad new legal principle beyond its factual context.

Disposition noted in the opinion: "Appeal allowed."


End of summary — prepared strictly from the provided opinion text. No information beyond that text has been added.

Show all summary ...

1. This appeal arises under the following circumstances: The parties to this suit were co-sharers of a village named Bhankra. In 1898 the village was partitioned and divided into several mahals. One of these mahals was assigned to Thakur Dharam Singh, the plaintiff-appellant, and was named after him. Another mahal known as mahal Kalan Ghairkhwahindgar was formed of the property owned by persons who had not applied for partition. In this mahal the defendant was a co-sharer. In mahal Dharam Singh a plot of land No. 337, with an area of 2 bighas 7 biswas was assigned to the plaintiff and he held that land as part of his mahal. In the other mahal there were two plots of land, Nos. 335 and 417, the area of which was also 2 bighas 7 biswas, which formed part of a road, and one of them at least, No. 336, was shown as the property of the defendant. In 1900 a settlement of the village book place. Plot 337 in mahal Dharam Singh was given a new number which, if correctly stated was 981, and Nos. 336 and 417 in mahal Kalan Ghairkhwahindgar reoeived another number which if correctly stated was 797. The map of the village showing the mahals was correctly prepared and in that map old No. 337 was shown as in mahal Dharam Singh and Nos. 336 and 417 as being in Mahal Kalan Ghairkhwahindgar. But by some mistake in the khasra which had been prepared at the settlement, as against No. 337 the corresponding number shown was 797 instead of 981. A similar mistake occurred in the khasra with reference to No. 336 and 417. Instead of the corresponding number being shown as 797 it was shown as 981. No one seems to have detected this mistake and it continued to linger on the record of the revenue settlement till it led to events which have given rise to this suit. The plaintiff continued to be in actual possession of the old No. 337 and the defendants of the numbers assigned to them in spite of the mistake on the record.

2. It appears that the plaintiff obtained a mortgage of the interest of some of the co-sharers in Mahal Kalan Ghairkhwahindgar and either by sale or foreclosure (the Court below is not clear by which procedure) he later on became full owner of the share mortgaged to him. The plaintiff thus became a co-sharer in Mahal Kalan Ghairkhwahindgar also. In 1907 Mt. Ram Piari, a co-sharer in Mahal Kalan Ghairkhwahindgar, applied for partition of her share in the said mahal. To this proceeding the plaintiff as a co-sharer of that mahal was a necessary party and was impleaded as such. On the said application for partition the revenue Court proceeded to sub-divide this mahal. Ram Piari got her own mahal divided out and the non-applicants had a mahal assigned to themselves. In these partition proceedings, by reason of the mistake of the entry which I have mentioned above, the plot shown as No. 981, i.e the old No. 337 which belonged to Mahal Thakur Dharam Singh, was by mistake treated as belonging to the old Mahal Kalan Ghairkhwabindgar. It was in that partition assigned to the lot of the defendant. No one seems to have been aware of the mistake nor did the revenue officers discover it. It was only recently, when the defendant took proceedings against the tenant in possession of old No. 337, that the mistake was discovered.

3. The plaintiff has now instituted this suit to obtain a declaration that old No. 337, the corresponding number of which is 981, is part and parcel of his mahal Thakur Dharam Singh and that the proceedings in the partition, in which No. 981 had been deemed to be a part of Mahal Kalan Ghairkhwabindgar, did not affect the plaintiff's right to the said land. The facts themselves are undisputed. There is no doubt that No. 337, the present number of which is 981, is part and parcel of Mahal Dharam Singh and that it never was part of the other mahal. The question however is whether by reason of its being erroneously treated as part of the other mahal and allotted in partition to the defendant the plaintiff is now precluded from asserting his right thereto. Under the Land Revenue Act in force in these provinces the revenue Courts are given exclusive jurisdiction to partition a mahal.

4. In respect of each mahal separate proceedings for partition have to be instituted. If parties are co-shares in more mahals than one it is not necessary for them to bring all the mahals into Court for partition. The proceedings for partition, therefore initiated by Ram Piari were proceedings for the partition of Mahal Kalan Ghairkhwahindgar. On that application the revenue Court had no jurisdiction to partition any other mahal or to touch the land which did not form part of the mahal in respect of which the application was made. Under S. 107 of the said Act an application for partition must be accompanied by a certified copy of the annual register of proprietors of the mahal sought to be partitioned. That copy would only show the shares in the said mahal owned by each proprietor. It would not show in detail the various numbers of the fields which go to make up the shares. Under S. 110 the Collector is required to issue notices to all recored co-sharers of the mahal who have not joined in the application, and under S. 111 any such recorded co-sharer of the mahal may raise any objection that he may have to the partition of the mahal. Such objection must be filed on or before the date fixed in the proclamation for filing such objections. If in the objection so filed a question of proprietary title arises, the question may be disposed of in the manner provided by S. 112.

5. It will thus be clear that the entire proceedings in partition are confined to the mahal of the applicant. Under this Act it is not possible to deal in the same application with lands appertaining to another mahal. Now in this case it was perhaps not possible to raise any question as to the mistake in the numbers which has led to the present difficulty, as neither party seems to have been aware of it. In the application for partition this number was presumably not shown as part of Ram Piari's mahal and it is only later on, when the details of the partition were settled, that any question could possibly arise. If the mistake was not discovered before the date fixed in the proclamation it could not be subject of inquiry under Sections 111 and 112 of the Land Revenue Act. The question then is: Is the plaintiff now precluded either by the provisions of S. 233(k) or for any other reason from getting the numbers corrected?

6. The Courts below have held that S. 233(k) does not apply to this case. But the lower appellate Court has held that by reason of the plaintiff not coming forward to disclose this mistake in the course of the partition proceedings he is now estopped from showing it and from retaining what he is entitled to. Mr. Dar on behalf of the respondent has supported the decree of the Court below on two grounds. In the first place he has urged that the suit is barred by Section 233(k) of the Land Revenue Act, and has relied upon the case of Lachman Das…(Defendant); v. Hanuman Prasad…(Plaintiff).* (1). In that case the plaintiff was a co-sharer in the mahal which was being partitioned. He did not put in a claim in the partition case within the time fixed by Section 112 of the Land Revenue Act, to Khata No. 34 of which he claimed to be the proprietor. The proceedings in that case were proceedings for the partition of the mahal in which this man was a co-sharer and of the lands which were admittedly in that mahal.

7. The Court, in that case, held that being a co-sharer in the mahal it was his duty to bring forward his claim to the lauds at the partition of that mahal in the course of those proceedings and as he had not done so, he was not competent to re-open the partition by a suit in the revenue Court. The Court carrying on the partition had full jurisdiction to partition Khata No. 34 as it was admittedly part and parcel of that mahal. The other case relied upon is the case of Tirbeni Sahai v. Gokal Prasad (2). There again the partition related to a mahal of which one of the pattis was claimed by the plaintiff. The land which was the subject of the partition appertained to the mahal. In this case it is common ground that the land in suit was not part and parcel of Mahal Kalan Ghairkhwahindgar. The revenue Court therefore had no jurisdiction to deal with it in the partition of that mahal. The case more in point is the case of Kishan Prasad v. Kadher Mal (3). It has been urged that the plain, tiff was a party to the partition proceedings in this case. He was, no doubt a party in his position as a co-sharer of Mahal Kalan Ghairkhwahindgar. It was in that character alone that he was impleaded in those proceedings. It is urged that he ought to have pointed out the mistake by showing the corresponding numbers. The answer to the objection is that neither party had discovered the mistake at that time. It is hard indeed to blame the plaintiff for not pointing out a mistake which it was equally the duty of the defendant to point out himself. He ought to have come forward when No. 981 was being allotted to him and to have told the revenue officer that land was no part of that mahal and to have got in exchange therefore some other land in that mahal. I do not see on what principle by reason of a mistake like this the plaintiff can be precluded from retaining what admittedly belongs to him. The Court of first instance rightly held that S. 233(k) did not bar the suit. The plaintiff is not seeking to re-open the partition of Mahal Ghairkhwahindgar. He only seeks to point out that this land is not part of that mahal, but is part of Mahal Dharam Singh of which he is the owner, and for that purpose his position did not differ from that of an utter stranger who has no share in Mahal Kalan Ghairkhwahindgar.

8. The second ground relied upon by Mr. Dar is that the plaintiff is estopped. I do not see on what principle the plaintiff can be estopped. He made do representation that his old No. 337 was part of mahal Kalan Ghairkhwahindgar. If anybody did make any representation it was probably the clerk who prepared the khasra. He misled both parties and I do not see how the plaintiff can be held responsible for his acts. The reason assigned by the Court below for refusing the plaintiff the decree asked for by him is that in the proceedings in 1907 he did not disclose this mistake. His claim is within limitation and his rights were subsisting rights on the date of the partition of 1907. Agreeing therefore with the Court of first instance I set aside the decree of the lower appellate Court and restore that of the Court of first instance with costs including in this Court counsel's fee on the higher scale.

V.B/R.K

9. Appeal allowed.