- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Municipal Chairman v. Saravana Pillai
It seems to me clear that the District Munsiff was wrong in holding that Sect. 262 of the District Municipalities Act IV of 884 was not a bar to this suit. Cl. (2) of that section expressly prohibits a suit in any Court to recover money collected under the authority of the Act provided that the provisions of the Act have been in substance and effect complied with. There is no case made here that in assessing plaintiff, any of the relevant provisions of the Act were not complied with; nor is this a suit falling within the proviso to Sect. 262.
Sect. 54 gives the power to the Chairman to decide the class in which a person has to be placed for professional tax and in doing so, he has to satisfy himself as to the man's income. The action of the chairman is subject only to an appeal to the Council under Sect. 97 and Sect. 101 provides that his assessment is final when there is no appeal to the Council, as was the case here. It would thus not be open to the Civil Court to find that his assessment was erroneous on facts or go into the question of the amount of a person's income, as that is not a ground on which the application of the prohibition against suits in Sects. 262 can be a ‘voided. In the case cited by the Municipal Council Of Chidambaram…(Defendant) v. Venkatanarayana Pillai…(Plaintiff) .*(1), no question based on Sect. 262 was argued or considered and the case is therefore of no authority on the point before me. On the other hand, it was ruled in Municipal Council, Nellore v. Rangayya(2) that even when tax was wrongly levied on a house which was not completed and occupied, Sect. 262 barred the suit to recover the tax paid, from the Municipality and that the aggrieved party's remedy was only by an appeal under Sect. 97 of the Act.
As I hold this suit was barred by Sect. 262 it must be dismissed. The Civil Revision Petition is allowed and the decree of the Lower Court is set aside and the plaintiff's suit is dismissed with costs here and in the Court below.
K.V.SPetition allowed.
Alert