Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Delhi State Industri... v. M/S. K.G Electronics...

Delhi High Court
Nov 7, 2014
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Rajiv Sahai Endlaw, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an intra-court appeal challenging the Single Judge's judgment dated 10 December 2013 in W.P.(C) No. 2324/2013. The Single Judge had allowed the writ petition filed by respondent no. 1 and directed the appellant to execute the perpetual lease of plot no. A-102 at Narela Industrial Complex in favour of respondent no. 1 (the writ petitioner) within six weeks, subject to the petitioner completing all formalities.

Procedural posture: The appellant filed this appeal accompanied by an application to condone 110 days' delay. The bench, prima facie of the view that the appeal did not deserve to be entertained, nevertheless heard the appellant's counsel on merits and reserved judgment on admission. The counsel for respondent no. 2 (Commissioner of Industries, GNCTD) appeared on advance notice as a non-contesting respondent.

Material factual chronology (as stated in the opinion): - In or about 1987 respondent no. 1 (through its two directors) applied for allotment of an industrial plot at Narela. The appellant allotted plot A-102. - Around 1995 possession of the plot was handed over to respondent no. 1 on a perpetual lease basis, with execution of the lease deed to follow later. - In 2007 respondent no. 2 initiated the work of executing the lease deed and asked the company to furnish details of changes in shareholding and directorship to determine if unearned increase charges were applicable. It was found that shares had been transferred to persons other than family members and there were changes in directorship; execution of the lease was held up. - In or about 2009–10 respondent no. 2 transferred the Narela Industrial Area to the appellant. The appellant then demanded unearned increase charges of Rs. 15,08,436 from respondent no. 1 for executing the perpetual lease deed. The writ petition challenged that demand, leading to the Single Judge's order impugned in this appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant (or its predecessor) was entitled to claim unearned increase from respondent no. 1 on account of transfers of shares and changes in directorship in the allottee company.
  2. Whether transfer of shares or change in directorship of the allottee company amounts to a "sale" or to "selling, transferring, assigning or otherwise parting with possession" of the leased land so as to attract unearned increase or to be prohibited by the terms of allotment/lease.
  3. Whether the Land Management Guidelines (or a policy decision reflected in minutes of a meeting dated 11 June 2009) entitled the appellant to claim proportionate unearned increase where shares/directorship changed in a private limited company, particularly when transfers were to non-family members as defined in those Guidelines.
  4. Whether the allotment under the Relocation Scheme imposed any additional restriction on transfer of shares or directorship of the allottee company that would make such transfers impermissible or render the company liable for unearned increase.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant sought condonation of delay in filing the appeal (110 days) and pursued the appeal on merits.
  • The appellant relied on a decision recorded in the minutes of a meeting held on 11 June 2009 which, it contended, permitted change of directors in a private limited company only on payment of proportionate unearned increase and restricted change of directors in relocation cases to family members.
  • The appellant argued that because the allotment was under a Relocation Scheme, the respondent company should be deemed not entitled to transfer shares or change directorship (i.e., the allottee should be restricted from such changes under the scheme).
  • The appellant's counsel asked the court to dispose of the appeal by observing that the Single Judge's judgment was on peculiar facts and should not constitute a precedent.

Respondent(s)' Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments advanced by respondents in the appeal proceedings. (The writ petition challenged the demand for unearned increase; the Single Judge's findings favouring the writ petitioner are recorded in the opinion, but the respondents' articulations in the appeal are not detailed.)

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Human Care Medical Charitable Trust v. Delhi Development Authority, 186 (2012) DLT 395 Where perpetual lease is executed in favour of a society, prohibition on selling/transferring/assigning/parting with possession applies to the society; change in governing body/membership does not amount to parting with possession. The court relied on this principle to treat the corporate allottee as a separate legal entity and to conclude that changes in membership/shareholding do not amount to parting with possession of the land held by the entity.
Indudyog Co. Ltd. v. GNCTD and J.C. Khosla v. Khosla Medical Institute & Research Society Earlier judgments supporting the proposition that the privity under a perpetual lease is with the legal entity to which lease is granted, not with individual members. These cases were cited in support of the position that change in the proprietorship/membership of the allottee entity does not translate into a prohibited transfer of the leased property.
Delhi Development Authority v. Mahabir Prasad and Sons (Division Bench) Unearned increase as a jural concept requires a sale; without sale there is no measure to determine increase in price of land. The court invoked this authority to support the view that transfer of shares (absent a sale of the land or an identifiable sale event) does not automatically give rise to a claim for unearned increase.
Rama Association (P) Ltd. v. Delhi Development Authority, 45 (1991) DLT 630 A company is a legal entity separate and distinct from its shareholders and directors; embargo in a lease on subletting/assigning applies to the company itself. The court applied this principle to hold that the company as the lessee remained the owner/possessor of the land despite interim changes in shareholding/directorship.
Salomon v. Salomon and Co. Ltd. [1897] A.C. 22 (HL); State Trading Corporation v. C.T.O AIR 1963 SC 1811; Ram Chand and Sons Sugar Mills v. Kanhaya Lal Bhargava AIR 1966 SC 1899; Electronics Corporation of India Ltd. v. Secretary, Revenue Department (1999) 4 SCC 458; Bacha F. Guzdar v. Commissioner of Income Tax, AIR 1955 SC 74 General corporate law principle: transfer of shares does not change the separate legal identity of the company; share transfers do not equate to changing the company's legal entity. The court cited these authorities to reinforce that sale/transfer of shares cannot be treated as sale/transfer of the company's land or as altering the company's legal identity for purposes of enforcing lease restrictions or claiming unearned increase.
Scindia Potteries and Services Ltd. v. Deputy Land and Development Officer, Government of India, 41 (1990) DLT 261 Shareholders are distinct from the company; sale of shares cannot be construed as sale of land held by the company. The court relied on this precedent to affirm that transfers of shareholding do not amount to transfers of the land owned/possessed by the corporate allottee.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded from the undisputed facts and from settled legal principles as reflected in prior decisions:

  1. The factual matrix was accepted as not in dispute: allotment in circa 1987, possession in 1995 on perpetual lease basis (execution to follow), later interim transfers of shares and changes in directorship, inquiry in 2007, and demand by appellant for unearned increase after transfer of administrative control in 2009–10.
  2. The Single Judge's findings (set out in the opinion) were recited and included that: at allotment the two brothers were sole shareholders and directors; at an intermediate date non-family members held shares; by 29 September 2007 the two brothers were again the only shareholders; the Guidelines did not provide for charging unearned increase where shares in a private limited company were transferred to a person who is not a family member; the appellant relied on minutes of 11 June 2009 asserting a decision to charge proportionate unearned increase for change of directors; and the proposed perpetual lease terms restricted transfer of possession but such restriction in any event applied to the legal entity (company) and not to its individual shareholders.
  3. The court examined precedent law emphasising the separate legal personality of companies and authorities holding that sale/transfer of shares does not equate to sale/transfer of the land held by the company and that the privity of the lease is with the entity to whom the lease is granted. Those authorities were used to question the legal basis for treating share transfers as triggering unearned increase or as violating prohibitions on transfer of the leased land.
  4. The court inspected the allotment letter dated 7 July 1990 and found no condition therein prohibiting change of shareholding or directorship or stipulating payment of unearned increase on account of such changes. The opinion notes that such provisions do exist in some other allotment/lease documents, but not in this case.
  5. The court rejected the appellant's contention that the allotment being under a Relocation Scheme should preclude transfer of shares or directorship. The court held that the allotment/transfer would be governed by the terms of the allotment/transfer itself, and since those terms did not provide the claimed prohibition or charge, the contention failed.
  6. The court also considered but did not accept the appellant's submission to curtail the precedential effect of the Single Judge's decision; the bench concluded the Single Judge's reasoning rested on settled legal principle and thus could not be so limited by a mere observation.
  7. No substantive rejoinder was recorded from the appellant's counsel to the precedents and reasoning pointed out by the bench ("No reply has been forthcoming").

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal was dismissed, thereby leaving the Single Judge's order (directing execution of the perpetual lease in favour of respondent no. 1 subject to completion of formalities) intact. The court expressly refused to impose costs.

DISPOSITION: The appeal is dismissed.

Implications: - Direct effect: The Single Judge's order permitting execution of the perpetual lease in favour of respondent no. 1 stands; the appellant's demand for unearned increase (Rs. 15,08,436) was not upheld in the writ proceedings and the appellate challenge has failed. - Precedential effect: The court held that the Single Judge's judgment was based on settled principles of law and therefore an observation that it should not constitute a precedent could not be made. The court noted, however, that in other cases the appellant would be free to attempt to distinguish the Single Judge's reasoning or the authorities cited.

Note: This summary strictly reflects the information contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond that text.

Show all summary ...

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW, J.

1. This intra-court appeal impugns the judgment dated 10th December, 2013 of the learned Single Judge of this Court, allowing W.P(C) No. 2324/2013 preferred by the respondent no. 1 by directing the appellant to execute the perpetual lease of plot of land bearing no. A-102 at Narela Industrial Complex in favour of the respondent no. 1.writ petitioner within six weeks thereof subject to the respondent no. 1.writ petitioner completing all the formalities.

2. Though this appeal was accompanied with an application for condonation of 110 days delay in filing thereof, however being prima facie of the opinion that the appeal does not deserve to be entertained, we, without entertaining the controversy whether the appellant discloses sufficient cause for condonation of delay in filing the appeal, heard the counsel for the appellant on merits and reserved judgment on the aspect of admission. We may notice that the counsel for the respondent no. 2 Commissioner of Industries, Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi (GNCTD), a non-contesting respondent, appeared on advance notice.

3. The facts are not in dispute. The respondent no. 1.writ petitioner through its two Directors Sh. Devender Kumar Gupta and Sh. Dinesh Kumar Gupta, in or about the year 1987, applied to the appellant for allotment of an industrial plot in Narela area and the appellant allotted plot no. A-102 at Narela Industrial Area to the respondent no. 1.writ petitioner and in or about the year 1995 handed over the possession of the said plot of land to the respondent no. 1.writ petitioner on perpetual lease basis. The said perpetual lease was to be executed subsequently. The work of execution of the lease deed by the respondent no. 2 in favour of the respondent no. 1.writ petitioner was taken up in the year 2007 when the respondent no. 2 asked the respondent no. 1.writ petitioner to furnish details of changes in the shareholding and directorship of the respondent no. 1.writ petitioner company so as to calculate the unearned increase charges if applicable. Finding that shares of the respondent no. 1.writ petitioner, subsequent to allotment and being put in the possession of the plot of land aforesaid, had been transferred to persons other than family members and further finding that there had also been change in directorship of the respondent no. 1.writ petitioner, the work of execution of the perpetual lease was held up. The respondent no. 2 in or about the year 2009-10 transferred the Narela Industrial Area to the appellant. The appellant finally demanded unearned increase charges of Rs. 15,08,436/- from the respondent no. 1.writ petitioner for executing the perpetual lease deed and impugning which demand, the writ petition from which this appeal arises was filed.

4. The learned Single Judge has allowed the writ petition as aforesaid finding/observing/holding:

(i) that at the time of allotment of the land to the respondent no. 1.writ petitioner company, the brothers Sh. Devender Kumar Gupta and Sh. Dinesh Kumar Gupta were its only shareholders and Directors; however as on 30 September, 2004, the said Sh. Devender Kumar Gupta and Sh. Dinesh Kumar Gupta held only 28.814% share each and Smt. Anju Gupta, wife of Sh. Devender Kumar Gupta held 14.124% shares, Smt. Rekha Gupta, sister-inlaw of Sh. Devender Kumar Gupta and Sh. Dinesh Kumar Gupta held 14.124% shares and one Sh. Tarun Gupta held the remaining 14.124% shares;

(ii) that Smt. Rekha Gupta and Mr. Tarun Gupta who together held 28.248% in the respondent no. 1.writ petitioner company were not family members as defined in the Guidelines for Management of Industrial Land managed by the Delhi Government; however as on 29 September, 2007, Sh. Devender Kumar Gupta and Sh. Dinesh Kumar Gupta were again the only shareholders of the respondent no. 1.writ petitioner company;

(iii) that in the aforesaid Guidelines for Management of Industrial Land in Delhi, there is No. provision for charging unearned increase wherever the shares in a private limited company are transferred to a person who is not a family member in terms of the definition given in the said Guidelines;

(iv) that the appellant relied on the Minutes of the Meeting held on 11 June, 2009 in the Chamber of the respondent no. 2 where a decision was taken that change of Directors in a private limited company is permissible on payment of proportionate unearned increase wherever required as per Land Management Guidelines and that change of Directors in relocation cases is allowed only amongst family members;

(v) that the aforesaid decision also applied to the case where Land Management Guidelines provide for payment of unearned increase; however as aforesaid the said Guidelines do not provide for payment of unearned increase in case there is a transfer of shares in a company to a person who is not a member of the family; thus the said policy decision also did not entitle the appellant to claim unearned increase from the respondent no. 1.writ petitioner;

(vi) in the light of the above, the question whether the said Guidelines apply to the respondent no. 1.writ petitioner was not relevant;

(vii) that even the terms and conditions of the perpetual lease deed proposed to be executed in favour of the respondent no. 1.writ petitioner prohibit only selling, transferring, assigning or otherwise parting with the possession of the leased land without permission and which could be granted on payment of 50% of the unearned increase; however the respondent no. 1.writ petitioner to whom the land was allotted, is a company, a legal entity and notwithstanding the interim change in shareholding and directorship of the respondent no. 1.writ petitioner, the respondent no. 1.writ petitioner company remained the owner/in possession of the said land;

(viii) it was also not a case of transfer/change of majority shareholding in a company and in which case the unearned increase could possibly be claimed; as aforesaid the shareholders at the time of allotment of land had continued to hold 71% share even when the shares were transferred.

5. We have invited the attention of the counsel for the appellant to:

(a) Human Care Medical Charitable Trust v. Delhi Development Authority 186 (2012) DLT 395 where one of us (Rajiv Sahai Endlaw, J.) held that when perpetual lease is executed, in that case by the DDA, in favour of a Society, it is the Society which is prohibited from selling, transferring, assigning the land/building constructed thereon and a change in the proprietorship or the Governing Body of the Society cannot fall within the meaning of ‘otherwise part with the possession of the property’; that a change in proprietorship of the Society would thus not amount to subletting, assigning or parting with possession of the leased property as the privity under the perpetual lease deed is with the Society and not with the members, at the time of allotment of land of the Society; reliance was placed on the earlier judgments of this Court in Indudyog Co. Ltd. v. GNCTD and J.C Khosla v. Khosla Medical Institute & Research Society;

(b) Delhi Development Authority v. Mahabir Prasad and Sons where a Division Bench of this Court held that unearned increase as a jural concept requires a sale, for the reason that without a sale, what would be the measure to determine the increase in the price of land;

(c) Rama Association (P) Ltd.… v. Delhi Development Authority…. 45 (1991) DLT 630 where another Single Judge of this Court held that a company is a legal entity separate and distinct from its shareholders and Directors; if the lease is executed in favour of a company, the embargo therein on subletting, assigning or parting with possession is on the company;

(d) Salomon v. Salomon and Co. Ltd. [1897] A.C 22 (HL), State Trading Corporation v. C.T.O AIR 1963 SC 1811, Ram Chand and Sons Sugar Mills v. Kanhaya Lal Bhargava AIR 1966 SC 1899, Electronics Corporation of India Ltd. v. Secretary, Revenue Department (1999) 4 SCC 458 and Bacha F. Guzdar v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Bombay AIR 1955 SC 74 inter alia to the effect that if the shares of a company are transferred, it does not mean that the legal entity of the company is changed; and

(f) Scindia Potteries and Services Ltd. v. Deputy Land and Development Officer, Government of India 41 (1990) DLT 261 where also a Single Judge of this Court held that shareholders of the company are distinct from the company of which they hold shares and sale of shares cannot be construed as sale of land held by the company.

and enquired from the counsel for the appellant that in view of the said settled position of law aforesaid followed by the learned Single Judge, how can the impugned judgment be faulted.

6. No. reply has been forthcoming.

7. We have also examined the letter dated 7 July, 1990 of allotment of the said land in favour of the respondent no. 1.writ petitioner and the same is also not found to contain any condition to the effect that the change of shareholding and Directorship was prohibited or any unearned increase would be payable therefor. We may in this regard notice that such a provision exists in some of the documents of allotment and lease/perpetual lease of land executed by governmental agencies.

8. The counsel for the appellant has sought to argue that the allotment of land in favour of the respondent no. 1.writ petitioner being under a Relocation Scheme, the respondent no. 1.writ petitioner should be deemed to be not entitled to indulge in transfer of shares and directorship.

9. The said contention is to be noted to be rejected. The allotment/transfer would be governed by the terms of such allotment/transfer thereof and which as aforesaid do not provide so.

10. The counsel for the appellant has lastly contended that we may dispose of this appeal by observing that the judgment of the learned Single Judge is on the peculiar facts and would not constitute a precedent.

11. The judgment of the learned Single Judge being on settled principle of law as above, such an observation cannot be made. However, if the appellant in any other case is entitled to distinguish the said judgment or the judgments cited by us, it would of course be entitled to. The appeal is accordingly dismissed. We refrain from imposing any costs.