Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mohd. Sohrab Khan An... v. The Deputy Director ...

Allahabad High Court
Dec 2, 1969
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition under Article 226 of the Constitution arises from proceedings under the U.P. Consolidation of Holdings Act. The dispute concerns plot no. 29 in village Mustafabad, Ghazipur district, originally owned by two brothers, Sita Ram and Sri Krishna Rai, as a joint Hindu family. Sita Ram died in 1351 (Bikram Samvat), leaving behind his widow and four sons. After zamindari abolition, Sri Krishna Rai and Sita Ram’s sons deposited ten times the land revenue in respect of the occupancy portion of the plot and became bhumidhars of the entire plot.

On June 19, 1958, the plot was sold to Mohammad Sohrab Khan and Wahab Khan for Rs. 5,400. At that time, only one son, Achhutanand, was major; the others were minors. The sale deed was executed by Sri Krishna Rai and Achhutanand, who acted as de facto guardian for his minor brothers. The vendees’ names were entered in revenue records, and after Wahab Khan’s death, his sons were substituted as bhumidhars. During consolidation proceedings, objections were filed by the minor sons alleging the sale deed was a sham ("farzi") and void as Achhutanand lacked authority to sell on their behalf. The Consolidation Officer initially rejected the objection, but the Assistant Settlement Officer upheld it on appeal. Revision applications by the vendees were dismissed by the Deputy Director of Consolidation, who held that Achhutanand had no right to transfer the minors’ shares under Section 11 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956. The petition challenges these orders.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Achhutanand was competent to execute the sale deed on behalf of his minor brothers acting as their de facto guardian.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956 (a Central Act) does not apply to agricultural land transactions, which fall under the exclusive legislative competence of the State under Article 246(3) and Entry 18 of List II of Schedule VII of the Constitution.
  • Therefore, Section 11 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act could not invalidate the sale deed concerning agricultural land.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Reliance on Entry V of the Concurrent List in Schedule VII to assert applicability of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956.
  • The prohibition in Section 11 of the Act is absolute and forbids a de facto guardian from transferring a Hindu minor’s property.
  • The mother, as the natural guardian, was the only competent person to execute the sale on behalf of the minors.
  • Notions of joint family property and coparcenary do not apply to bhumidhari land, which is governed by the U.P. Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ram Awalamb v. Jata Shanker (1968 A.L.J 1108) Held that members of a joint Hindu family holding bhumidhari rights hold as tenants in common, not joint tenants; Hindu law notions of joint family property do not apply. Supported the court’s conclusion that joint family property and coparcenary concepts are inapplicable to bhumidhari land, which is governed by state land reform laws.
Mahendra Singh v. Attar Singh (1967 A.L.J 8) Similar view as Ram Awalamb regarding application of joint family property concepts to bhumidhari land. Reinforced the court’s position on the inapplicability of Hindu joint family property principles to the land in question.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined Section 11 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956, which prohibits a de facto guardian from disposing of a Hindu minor’s property. The provision is absolute and imperative, allowing only the natural guardian, with court permission, to deal with a minor’s property. Since the minors’ mother was alive and the natural guardian, Achhutanand’s execution of the sale deed as de facto guardian was invalid and void. The court rejected the petitioners’ contention that the Central Act did not apply to agricultural land, noting that although agricultural land legislation is within the exclusive domain of the State Legislature, no State law provision authorized transfer of a minor’s share by a guardian. The court relied on precedents establishing that bhumidhari land is not joint family property governed by Hindu law but by the U.P. Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act. In absence of any conflicting State law provisions, the Central Act’s prohibition prevailed. Therefore, the consolidation authorities correctly refused to recognize the sale deed as to the minors’ shares.

Holding and Implications

The court DISMISSED the petition with costs.

The direct effect of this decision is that the sale deed executed by Achhutanand on behalf of his minor brothers, acting as their de facto guardian, is declared void with respect to the minors’ shares in the agricultural land. The consolidation authorities’ orders upholding this position stand affirmed. No new legal precedent beyond the application of existing statutory provisions and prior case law was established.

Show all summary ...

Gulati, J.:— This petition under Art. 226 of the Constitution arises out of certain proceedings under the U.P Consolidation of Holdings Act (hereinafter referred to as the Act).

2. The facts giving rise to this petition are these. Sita Ram and Sri Krishna Rai alias Hari Kishan were two brothers and formed a joint Hindu family. They owned plot no. 29 in village Mustafabad in the district of Ghazipur. On May 13, 1351 Sita Ram died leaving behind his widow Smt. Nageshwari and four sons viz. Achhutanand, Sri Ram Rai, Hari Har Rai and Shambhu Rai. The plot in dispute was partly bhumidhari and partly occupancy land. After the abolition of zamindari, Sri Krishna Rai and the four sons of Late Sita Ram deposited on June 19, 1958 ten times the land revenue in respect of that part of the plot in dispute which was occupancy land and thus became bhumidhar of the entire plot. It appears, that on the same day the plot in dispute was sold to one Mohammad Sohrab Khan and his brother Wahab Khan for a sum of Rs. 5,400/-. At that time out of the four sons of Sita Ram only Achhutanand was major and the rest were minor. The sale deed was executed by Sri Krishna Rai and Achhutanand for himself and as the de facto guardian of his minor brothers. On the basis of the sale-deed the names of the vendees were entered in the revenue papers as bhumidhars of the plot in dispute and after the death of Wahab Khan the names of his two sons Mohd. Zakari Khan and Mohd. Shamshad Khan were substituted. Thereafter, the village in question came under the consolidation proceedings and after C.H Form V and V-B were issued to the tenure-holders, objections were filed by the three minor sons of Sita Ram contending that Achhutanand and Sri Krishna Rai had executed a farzi sale-deed which was void as against them as they were minors and Achhutanand had no right to execute the sale-deed on their behalf. This objection was rejected by the Consolidation Officer on July 9, 1966. On appeal, however, the objection was upheld by the Assistant Settlement Officer (Consolidation) by his order dated December 16, 1966. Against this order, Mohd. Sohrab Khan and the two sons of Wahab Khan went up in revision under Sec. 48 of the Act. Their revision application, however, was dismissed by the Deputy Director of Consolidation, Ghazipur by his order dated September 4, 1967 on the ground that Achhutanand acting as a de facto guardian of the three minor sons of Sita Ram had no right to transfer the share of the minors by reason of Sec. 11 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956. He, however, upheld the sale on behalf of Har Krishna Rai and Achhutanand, major son of Sita Ram and thus held that out of the plot in dispute 518th belonged to the vendees and the remaining 3/8th belonged to three minor sons of Sita Ram. This petition is directed against the order of the Deputy Director of Consolidation as also against the order of the Assistant Settlement Officer (Consolidation).

3. Mohd. Sohrab Khan and the two sons of Wahab Khan, viz. Mohd. Zakari Khan and Mohd. Shamshad Khan are the petitioners while the three minor sons of Sita Ram are respondents second set and Achhutanand, major son of Sita Ram and Hari Krishna Rai are the respondents third set.

4. The only question that falls for consideration is as to whether Achhutanand was competent to execute the sale on behalf of his minor brothers acting as their de facto guardian.

5. The Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act of 1956 (Act No. 32 of 1956) came into force with effect from August 25, 1956. Sec. 11 of that Act provides:

“11. After the commencement of this Act, no person shall be entitled to dispose of, or deal with, the property of a Hindu minor merely on the ground of his or her being the de facto guardian of the minor.”

6. This provision is in imperative terms and contains an absolute prohibition against the transfer of a Hindu minor's property by his de facto guardian. Sec. 8 of the Act permits only the natural guardian to deal with the property of a minor and that to with the permission of the court. In the present case the mother of the minors was alive and she being the natural guardian was alone competent to execute the sale deed on their behalf. As it is, the property has been transferred by the brother of the minors who purports to have acted as their de facto guardian. Sec. 11 of the Act makes such a transfer absolutely void. It cannot, therefore, be said that the consolidation authorities committed any error of law in refusing to give effect to the sale deed so far as it related to the shares of the minors.

7. Sri D.S Sinha, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, however, submits that Act No. 32 of 1956 had no application because the property which was the subject matter of the sale was agricultural land and by virtue of Art. 246(3) read with Entry No. 18 of List II of Schedule VII of the Constitution the State Legislature alone was competent to make laws in respect of agricultural land. Learned counsel argued that Act No. 32 of 1956 was a Central Act and as such could not govern the transaction in dispute. Sri G.P Bhargava, learned counsel for the respondents, on the other hand, places reliance on Entry V of the Concurrent List in the VII Schedule to support his contention that Act No. 52 of 1956 was applicable.

8. It appears that the contention which Mr. Sinha seeks to raise was not raised in that form before the consolidation authorities. There it was contended that Sri Krishna Rai having already separated Achhutanand was the Karta of the family and as the land was the joint family property it could be alienated by the Karta for legal necessity. The learned counsel has not put forth this contention before this Court and in my opinion very rightly because now it is a settled law, so far as this Court is concerned, that the notions of a joint family property and the coparcenary have no application with regard to the bhumidhari land, the alienation and succession whereof is now governed by the provisions of the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act. A Division Bench of this Court in Ram Awalamb v. Jata Shanker . 1968 A.L.J 1108. has held that where members of a joint Hindu family hold bhumidhari night in any holding, they hold the same as tenants in common and not as joint tenants and that the notions of Hindu law cannot be invoked. Similar view was taken in Mahendra Singh v. Attar Singh . 1967 A.L.J 8..

9. I am of the opinion that the contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner has no force. There is no doubt that framing of laws with regard to agricultural land is within the exclusive power of the State Legislature and any such law would abrogate the personal law of the parties so far as the latter is inconsistent with the former as illustrated by the two decisions of this Court referred to above. But the parties would still be governed by their personal law in matters which are not covered by the State laws.

10. Learned counsel for the petitioner has not been able to point out to me any provision in the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act or any other State laws relating to agricultural land which provides for the transfer of the share of a minor in agricultural land by a guardian. Had there been such a provision and had that provision been inconsistent with the provisions of Act No. 32 of 1956, a question might have arisen as to which one would prevail. But as it is, there is no provision in the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act dealing with the subject with which Sec. 11 of Act 32 of 1956 deals. That provision would, therefore, prevail. Under that provision a de facto guardian of a Hindu minor is prohibited from disposing of the property of a minor for any reason whatsoever. The petition is accordingly dismissed with costs.

11. Petition dismissed.