- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bechu Lal Kayastha v. Emperor
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner was a driver employed by the Calcutta Tramways Company Ltd. He was convicted by the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate under Section 279 of the Indian Penal Code for rash and negligent driving and sentenced to a fine of Rs. 100, half of which was ordered to be paid to a person injured as a result of the alleged negligence.
A Rule (judicial review application) was issued on the sole ground that Section 342 of the Criminal Procedure Code had not been complied with in the proceedings before the Magistrate. The Magistrate's explanation was that Section 342 was not complied with because the matter was a summons case; he relied on Full Bench decisions of the Madras High Court (Ponnusamy Odayar v. Ramasamy Thathan and Dharma Singh v. King-Emperor) for the proposition that Section 342 does not apply to summons cases.
The present Court noted that in its own jurisdiction convictions in summons cases have previously been set aside for failure to comply with Section 342 (Gulzari Lal v. Emperor; Surendra v. Isamaddi), and also recorded that the Bombay High Court has held Section 342 to apply to summons cases (Emperor v. G.S. Fernandez; Emperor v. Gulabjan), a view described as prevailing outside Madras. The Rule in the present case was ultimately made absolute, a retrial ordered, and the fine to be refunded if paid.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Section 342 of the Criminal Procedure Code applies to summons cases (including the application of the concluding words of sub-section (1): "after the witnesses for the prosecution have been examined and before he is called on for his defence").
- If Section 342 applies to summons cases, whether failure to comply with it in a summons case requires that a conviction be set aside (as raised by the Rule in the present matter).
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Ponnusamy Odayar v. Ramasamy Thathan, A.I.R. 1924 Mad. 15 | Held (Full Bench, Madras) that Section 342 CrPC does not apply to summons cases (or at least that the concluding words of sub-section (1) are inapplicable to summons cases). | The Magistrate relied on this decision to justify non‑compliance with Section 342. The present Court criticized the decision's test for exclusion as inadequate and rejected the conclusion that Section 342 has no reference to summons cases. |
| Dharma Singh v. King-Emperor, A.I.R. 1924 Mad. 30 | Cited alongside Ponnusamy as authority for the view that Section 342 does not apply to summons cases. | Referenced by the Magistrate; used by the Court as part of the Madras Full Bench position which the Court found unpersuasive. |
| Gulzari Lal v. Emperor, A.I.R. 1923 Cal. 164 | Example of this Court (Calcutta) setting aside convictions in summons cases for failure to comply with Section 342. | Noted by the Court as prior practice in its own jurisdiction where convictions were set aside for non‑compliance with Section 342. |
| Surendra v. Isamaddi | Another instance (in this Court) of convictions in summons cases set aside for failure to comply with Section 342 (no formal citation provided in the opinion). | Referred to as supporting local practice; the Court noted that no case was cited where the applicability to summons cases had been fully argued and the Madras decisions canvassed. |
| Emperor v. G.S. Fernandez, [1920] 45 Bom. 672 | Bombay High Court authority holding that Section 342 applies to summons cases. | Adduced by the Court as persuasive authority and as representative of the prevailing view in provinces other than Madras; cited to support the proposition that Section 342 is not confined to warrant or Sessions trials. |
| Emperor v. Gulabjan, A.I.R. 1922 Bom. 290 | Bombay High Court decision aligned with Fernandez that Section 342 applies to summons cases (Macleod, C.J., took the same view). | Used to show that the Bombay High Court adopted an interpretation contrary to the Madras Full Bench; relied on as persuasive support for general applicability. |
| Raghu Bhumij v. The King-Emperor, [1920] 5 Pat.L.J. 430 | Historical reference for the origin/evolution of the provision: Section 342 (or its antecedent) given by Jwala Prasad, J.; Mullick, J.'s observation that an accused in a summons case is called on for his defence after prosecution is closed. | Quoted and relied upon to show legislative history and judicial interpretation which supports construing Section 342 as an enabling, generally framed provision applicable across trial types. |
| Kesri v. Muhammad Bukhsh, [1896] 18 All. 221 | Interpreted by some authorities to mean in summons cases a man cannot be acquitted until after he has been heard and produced his evidence. | Referred to critically by the Court as an example of an interpretation the present Court finds questionable; used to discuss procedural consequences in summons cases and to critique a strict reading that would render Section 342 inapplicable. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court undertook a textual, contextual and historical analysis of Chapter 24 of the Criminal Procedure Code, within which Section 342 appears. It noted that Chapter 24 is headed "General Provisions as to Inquiries and Trials" and contains many provisions expressed with deliberate generality (examples given in the opinion include Sections 340, 341, 343, 344, 351, 352). The Court observed that Section 342 likewise possesses the hallmarks of a general provision: its language permits the Court to examine an accused "at any stage of any inquiry or trial."
Turning to legislative history, the Court traced antecedent provisions (Section 373 of Act 25 of 1861; Act 8 of 1869; Section 250 of Act 10 of 1872 and its later placement in the Code of 1882 as Section 312). The Court used this history to show the consolidation of provisions relating to examination of the accused into a general chapter, reinforcing the view that the present Section 342 is the enabling provision for court examination of an accused.
The Court examined the procedural stages in the various types of cases: Section 244 governing summons cases (Magistrate shall hear the complainant and "also to hear the accused and take all such evidence as he produces in his defence"), Section 258 for warrant cases ("The accused shall then be called upon to enter upon his defence and produce his evidence"), and Section 289 for Sessions trials (accused asked whether he means to adduce evidence). It compared these provisions with the language of Section 342: "and shall question him - generally on the case after the witnesses for the prosecution have been examined and before he is called on for his defence."
The Court rejected the argument (attributed to the Madras Full Bench decisions) that the concluding words of sub‑section (1) of Section 342 are incompatible with summons cases. The Court found no difficulty in identifying the stage of trial referred to ("after the witnesses for the prosecution have been examined") in summons cases and regarded the phrase "before he is called on for his defence" as an ordinary English expression suitably used in a general provision.
Relying on prior judicial observations (including Mullick, J. in Raghu Bhumij and dicta from the Bombay decisions), the Court held that Section 342 is the enabling provision envisaged throughout the chapters dealing with various kinds of trials and in particular that it has reference to summons cases. The Court described the Madras test (that the provision applies unless special sections indicate otherwise) as inadequate for excluding Section 342 from summons cases and concluded that the concluding words of sub‑section (1) have effect in summons cases unless there is an express or clearly implied inconsistency.
The Court expressly declined to decide certain collateral questions: whether, if Section 342 applies, failure to comply with it can be condoned under Section 537, and whether in warrant or Sessions cases the examination of the accused is purely discretionary — noting these issues were concluded by authority binding on the bench and therefore not further examined in the opinion.
On this basis of analysis and interpretation, the Court found that the Magistrate's failure to comply with Section 342 in the summons proceedings was not justified by the Madras authorities and warranted interference with the conviction.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court held that Section 342 of the Criminal Procedure Code applies to summons cases (including the concluding words of sub‑section (1) referring to the stage "after the witnesses for the prosecution have been examined and before he is called on for his defence"). The Court found that the Magistrate's non‑compliance with Section 342 in the present summons case was not justified and directed a fresh trial.
Direct consequences for the parties:
- The Rule was made absolute; the conviction was set aside and the case ordered to be re‑tried by a Magistrate to be nominated by the Chief Presidency Magistrate.
- If the fine had been paid, it was ordered to be refunded.
Broader implications: The opinion rejects the Madras Full Bench view that Section 342 does not apply to summons cases and endorses the interpretation (as taken in Bombay and elsewhere) that Section 342 is an enabling, generally framed provision applicable to all trials unless a clear inconsistency or express exception appears. The Court characterized the Madras test for exclusion as inadequate, thereby clarifying the applicability of Section 342 to summons proceedings in this Court's view.
1. The petitioner is a driver in the employ of the Calcutta Tramways Coy. Ltd. He has been convicted by the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate tinder Section 279 of the Indian Penal Code for rash and negligent driving and has been sentenced to pay a fine of Rs. 100. Half of the fine has been ordered to be paid to a person injured by the negligence of the petitioner.
2. The present Rule was issued on the sole ground that Section 342 of the Criminal Procedure Code was not complied with. The Magistrate in his explanation states that Section 342 was not complied with because the case was a summons case and cites the decisions of a Full Bench of the Madras High Court Ponnusamy Odayar v. Ramasamy Thathan A.I.R. 1924 Mad. 15 and Dharma Singh v. King-Emperor A.I.R. 1924 Mad. 30 for the view that Section 342 does not apply to a summons case whether it be tried summarily or in the ordinary way.
3. In this Court convictions have in summons cases been set aside for failure to comply with Section 342 : Gulzari Lal v. Emperor A.I.R. 1923 Cal. 164; Surendra v. Isamaddi but we have not been referred to any case in which the applicability of the section to summons cases has been argued or the Madras decisions canvassed.
4. The Bombay High Court has in two cases held that the section applies to summons cases : Emperor v. G.S. Fernandez [1920] 45 Bom. 672; Emperor v. Gulabjan A.I.R. 1922 Bom. 290, and this appears to be the prevailing view in provinces other than Madras.
4. Section 342 occurs in Chapter 24 which is headed "General Provisions as to Inquiries and Trials." Some of the sections in this chapter are not in accordance with a strict interpretation of the heading in respect that they do not deaf with matters which either must or may arise in the course of any enquiry or trial (cf. Sections 349, 350, 350A). Others deal with questions which are in nature general (e.g. tender of pardon to accomplice, compounding of offences) but permit of the specified procedure in particular cases only (cf. Sections 337-339A, 345). Others however appear to be quite general and to be so expressed (exemptions or exceptions being made as necessary). The right to be defended by a pleader (Section 340), the rights of an accused who cannot be made to understand the proceedings (Section 341), the right to be free of undue influence by threat or promise (Section 343), the power of remand (Section 344), detention of offenders attending Court (Section 351), Courts to be held in public (Section 352) - these are all "General provisions as to enquiries and trials" in the fullest sense of the phrase. The language in several of these sections is of studied generality (e.g. any person accused of an offence before a criminal Court) (Section 340, cf. Sections 351, 352) and it is appropriate to the subject-matter. They are intended as general provisions - not merely as miscellaneous provisions.
5. Taking Chapter 24 for the moment by itself it must I think be conceded that Section 342 has all the notes of generality. The language is "the Court may, at any stage of any inquiry or trial." The subject-matter of the opening phrase - "Power to examine the accused" is undoubtedly general : it asserts a principle which is in marked contrast with a fundamental principle of the common law of England under which no Court could examine an accused. It is here and here only that we find it stated that no oath shall be administered to the accused, that he cannot be punished for not answering, that a charge of perjury cannot be brought upon his answers.
6. The history of the section - if this be relevant - detracts in no way from the force of these considerations. It was given by Jwala Prasad, J., in the case of Raghu Bhumij v. The King Emperor [1920] 5 Pat.L.J. 430.
In the earlier Acts, the examination of the accused person was discretionary with the Court : vide Section 373 of Act 25 of 1861 and Act 8 of 1869. In Act 10 of 1872 while the discretionary nature of the examination was retained so far as enquiries and trials of cases other than Sessions cases were concerned, it was made compulsory for Sessions trials. section 250 of that act occurred in the chapter relating to Sessions trials and ran as follows:
The Court may from time to time at any stage of the trial examine the accused person and shall question him generally on the case after the witnesses for the prosecution have been examined and before he is called on for his defence.
In 1882 the provisions relating to the examination of an accused parson which were scattered in different chapters in the previous Acts, were removed from those chapters and brought under one chapter headed "General Provisions Relating to Enquiries and Trials." Section 250 of Act 10 of 1872 was therefore removed from the chapter relating to Sessions trials but its provisions were embodied in their entirety in Section 312 of the Code of 1882 as well as in 1898.
7. What then is the contention to be? Is it that no part of Section 342 applies to summons cases or merely that the last clause of sub-section (1) does not apply. I am not quite sure which doctrine is affirmed by the Madras decisions but I think it is the former; though the reason given for it is the inapplicability of the closing words of the sub-section.
8. In either case it appears to me that there is really one argument upon which everything turns, and the other arguments collapse without it. Of a contested summons case, Section 244 says that the Magistrate shall proceed to hear the complainant (if any), and tike all such evidence as may be produced in support of the prosecution, and also to hear the accused and take all such evidence as he produces in his defence.
9. In a warrant case after charge framed and after the last prosecution witness has been cross-examined and re-examined, Section 258 says : "The accused shall then be called upon to enter upon his defence and produce his evidence." Of Sessions cases Section 289 says:
When the examination of the witnesses for the prosecution and the examination (if any) of the accused are concluded the accused shall be asked whether he means to adduce evidence.
10. In Sub-section 4 the Code says that "the Court shall call on the accused to enter on his defence" and the context shows what this means. It means that if he calls no witnesses the accused (or his pleader) is to make his final address to the Jury : if he is calling witnesses he may open his case and proceed to call them.
11. It is to these sections that Section 342 has to be applied. Its words are:
and shall question him - generally on the case after the witnesses for the prosecution have been examined and before he is called on for his defence.
12. I do not collect that any shadow of difficulty is imposed to surround the phrase "after the witnesses for the prosecution have been examined." These exact words do not occur in Section 244, Section 256 or Section 289 but they refer without any ambiguity whatever to a definite stage in any kind of trial, and their equivalent in the sections mentioned leaps to the eye. In these circumstances there seems little room for any further difficulty but it is said - if I follow the argument - -that there is a significant precision of language-in the words "before he is called on for his defence." This it is said has a definite meaning both in Section 289 and Section 256 but in Chapter 20 the expression is not used. "The prisoner in these cases does-not enter on his defence" but the Magistrate is bound to "hear the accused" (per Schwabe, C.J.) : in Ponnusamy v. Ramasamy A.I.R. 1924 Mad. 15.
13. The argument appears to me to be unsubstantial. There is no such exact identity of phrase as could make Section 342 short circuit with Sections 289 and 256 to the exclusion of Section 244. The phrase is "called on for his defence." The words of Section 256 are "called upon to enter upon his defence"; in Section 289 "call on the accused to enter on, his defence." The similarity of phrase is apparent and there is no such similarity in Section 244 but that is all; and there can be no question of significant precision. The Legislature has not hit upon a general expression equidistant from all three sections in point of variation of language. But as Mullick, J., observed in Raghu Bhumij v. The King-Emperor [1920] 5 Pat.L.J. 430, a case already cited:
if it is argued that in a summons case the accused is never 'called on for his defence' the reply seems to be that there is no virtue in these particular words and the accused in a summons case is called on for his defence after the prosecution is closed just as much as an accused in any other case.
To call upon an accused person to enter upon his defence is a necessary incident of every trial.
14. Per Crump, J., in Emperor v. S.S. Fernandez [1920] 45 Bom. 672. Macleod, C.J., has taken the same view : Emperor v. Gulabjan A.I.R. 1922 Bom. 290. There is every reason to suppose that the words are used as ordinary English and there is independent reason to presume that the provision is a general provision. The function of the concluding words of Sub-section 1 of Section 342 is to point to a definite stage of every trial. For this purpose it is natural enough to use rather more informal language than seems to be called or when describing the procedure in summon case. Thus, although in summons cases there is no formal charge and Chapter 20 says nothing about "plea" or "pleading guilty," the legislature when in Section 263 (cf. Section 262) it has occasion to refer to this stage when dealing with summary trial both of summons cases and of warrant cases, vises the words "the plea of the accused," In the same way Section 342 uses the phrase "called on for his defence" - not only without any special or limited intention but in a chapter which is expressly devoted to general provisions and in a section which refers to "any stage of any inquiry or trial."
15. I do not here discuss whether if Section 342 applies to any case a failure to comply with it can be condoned under Section 537. Nor do I discuss whether if in Warrant cases, or in Sessions cases it is purely discretionary for the Court to examine or not to examine. These questions are concluded by authority binding upon me.
16. Confining myself to summons cases, I would observe that the argument from the repealed Section 451 has been answered by Oldfield, J., in Ponnusamy v. Ramasamy A.I.R. 1924 Mad. 15 that Section 242 applies to a stage and a purpose different from Section 342; and that the words "if he thinks fit" in Section 215 do not necessarily mean more than that an accused can be acquitted without being examined. Section 245 is very similar in language to Section 209 and Section 253 but it has not quite the same purpose. The governing idea, is that in summons cases the matter should be finally decided (save in cases under Section 249). It should proceed to a conviction or acquittal - not merely end in a discharge. Apparently Section 245 has been held to mean that a man cannot be acquitted until after he has been heard and after he has produced all his evidence Kesri v. Muhammad Bukhsh [1896] 18 All. 221 which seems a little marvellous. If this be right, (which I take leave to doubt) then when the case against the accused breaks hopelessly down - I presume the really correct procedure must be to tell the accused that if he holds his tongue he will be acquitted but that if ho will insist on defending the case further he may be convicted on any charge triable as a Summons case that may turn up before the case is over.
17. If "the evidence referred to in Section 244" is not a phrase used by mistake for the complainant if any and all such evidence as may be produced in support of the prosecution, and if it really means that the accused must be asked to call his evidence even though there is no case to answer, then the words "if he thinks fit" do raise a difficulty. But on the common sense of the matter and even on the strict construction of the section it seems reasonably clear that the words "if he thinks fit" have reference in this section to cases in which the Magistrate is prepared to acquit without examining the accused, That he can convict without examining the accused is an inference from the dubious proposition that he cannot acquit without hearing all such evidence as the accused requires him to hear. Sections 109 and 253 may I think be looked at to explain what is meant by the words "if he thinks fit" in Section 245. They all refer to cases where it is unnecessary to give an opportunity to an accused to explain any circumstances appearing in the evidence against him because the case against him is going to be stopped then and there. (The effect of the words "if any" in Section 289 is a different question).
18. My main criticism of the decision in Ponnusamy Odayar v. Ramasamy A.I.R.1924 Mad. 15 is that it fails to appreciate that on the face of the Criminal Procedure Code every reference to any examination or possibility of an examination of an accused person by the Court is a reference to Section 342. Before 1882 the Code was different. But now Section 342 is the enabling section - it is the section which explains the purpose for which and the terms on which any accused can be examined by the Court at all. It confers a power which may be exercised at any stage. It is presupposed in. Chapter 20 as in Chapter 18, Chapter 21, Chapter 22 and Chapter 23, and these are the only chapters to which its direct reference can be primarily intended. With all respect I think it impossible to maintain that p. 342 has no reference whatever to Summons cases. If the question be as to the applicability of the concluding words of Sub-section (1), then I think the Madras High Court applied a test which is inadequate when it said:
It must be applied to all oases unless the special sections dealing with particular cases indicate that it is not intended to apply to them or unless the words of the section itself give such indication.
19. Ponnusamy v. Ramasamy A.I.R. 1924 Mad. 15. The concluding words of the sub-section must have effect like the other words in the absence of an express exception or of an exception to be implied from a specific provision clearly inconsistent therewith unless indeed the words as applied to Summons cases are insensible or at least markedly inapt.
20. In the present case the Rule must be made absolute and the case must be re-tried by a Magistrate to be nominated by the Chief Presidency Magistrate.
21. The fine, if paid, will be refunded.
Duval, J.
22. I agree.
Alert