Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Maqbool Ahmed v. State Of Rajasthan

Rajasthan High Court
Oct 28, 1983
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Case Summary — Writ Petition (Dwarka Prasad, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, initially appointed Mechanic Grade II on December 22, 1954, was promoted to Mechanic Grade I on March 1, 1956 and temporarily promoted to Foreman Grade I on March 7, 1975 for four months or until a person selected by the Departmental Promotion Committee was available. The petitioner alleged that although the Rajasthan Medical and Health Subordinate Service Rules, 1955 (referred to as "the Rules") were promulgated in 1965, the appointing authority failed to determine the number of vacancies in the cadre of Foreman Grade I under Rule 9 and consequently substantive appointments were not made. The petitioner also complained that two juniors (respondent Nos. 3 and 4) were earlier promoted to Foreman Grade I and continued to hold those posts in an ad hoc or temporary capacity, which the petitioner alleged was illegal.

The court recorded that respondent No. 3 (Prem Singh) had been a temporary Foreman Grade I since May 25, 1961 and respondent No. 4 (Gheesalal) since May 3, 1966; the court held the petitioner could not now challenge their appointments by way of a writ petition filed in 1975 because of the long period they had held those posts. Respondent No. 5 had been appointed Foreman Grade II on August 19, 1972 and had not been promoted; he was declared surplus and surrendered for absorption elsewhere, and therefore was not a member of the subordinate service or working as Foreman Grade I.

The petition principally sought enforcement of the procedural obligations in Rule 9 (determination of vacancies each year) and consequent substantive promotions under Rule 24. The respondents replied that vacancies could not be determined due to "administrative difficulties" and that "steps" were being taken to make substantive appointments.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appointing authority's failure to determine annually the number of vacancies under Rule 9 of the Rules and its consequent failure to make substantive appointments violated the legal rights of eligible employees, including the petitioner.
  2. Whether long-standing temporary or ad hoc appointments to Foreman Grade I (specifically those of respondent Nos. 3 and 4) could be challenged by the petitioner by way of a writ petition filed in 1975.
  3. What remedies and directions the court should issue to remedy failure to comply with Rule 9 and to ensure promotions are made in accordance with the eligibility conditions applicable in the year in which vacancies arose.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The appointing authority has failed, since the Rules were promulgated in 1965, to determine the number of vacancies in the cadre of Foreman Grade I under Rule 9 and therefore substantive appointments have not been made.
  • Ad hoc or temporary promotions have continued for years; persons junior to the petitioner (respondent Nos. 3 and 4) were promoted earlier and continued to hold the post although their appointments were, according to the petitioner, illegal; this prejudiced the petitioner's right to promotion and seniority.

Respondents' Arguments / Reply

  • The respondents stated in their reply dated November 19, 1975 that vacancies could not be determined due to "administrative difficulties."
  • The respondents also stated that steps were being taken to make substantive appointments to Foreman Grade II and that at that time all eligible persons would be considered for substantive appointments.
  • Regarding respondent No. 5, respondents explained he had not been promoted to Foreman Grade I and had been declared surplus and surrendered for absorption in another department.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Rajasthan Public Service Commission, Ajmer v. Dr. (Miss) Damyanti Dadich Rule 9 is a statutory instruction to and for the guidance of the appointing authority; failure to comply may create administrative difficulties and render the appointing authority answerable to superiors. The court relied on this decision to characterize Rule 9 as imposing a statutory duty on the appointing authority to determine vacancies annually and to show that noncompliance adversely affects legal rights of employees.
O.P. Agarwal v. The State Of Rajasthan Sub-Rule (1) of Rule 9 imposes a mandatory obligation to determine at the commencement of each year the number of vacancies anticipated and the number of persons likely to be recruited by each method; appointments made later must be treated with reference to eligibility conditions existing in the year the vacancies arose for seniority purposes. The court cited this reasoning to explain that clubbing vacancies over several years prejudices persons eligible in earlier years and to support the requirement that promotions must consider eligibility as of the year the vacancy arose.
N.K. Hingorani v. The State of Rajasthan The underlying purpose of Rule 9 is to ensure vacancies are determined and filled yearly according to the then-existing eligibility conditions; failure to so determine may enable abuse and defeat just claims by clubbing vacancies. The court used this authority to reinforce that non-determination of vacancies and clubbing years' vacancies together would cause grave prejudice and that later determinations must consider earlier eligibility conditions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in a stepwise analysis strictly grounded in the factual record and the Rules:

  1. Identification of the core statutory duty: The court emphasized Rule 9's textual obligation that "the Appointing Authority shall determine each year the number of vacancies anticipated during the following twelve months" and explained how that duty had been modified by an amendment of October 16, 1973 (to focus on the following 12 months) but retained the annual determination requirement.
  2. Factual application: The court accepted the petitioner's uncontested contention (not denied by respondents) that since the Rules' promulgation in 1965 the appointing authority had not determined vacancies year-by-year in the Foreman Grade I cadre, thus preventing the initiation of the substantive appointment process under Rule 24.
  3. Procedural consequence: The court explained that Rule 24 requires a correct and complete list (not exceeding five times the number of vacancies) of eligible senior-most persons, and the constitution of a Departmental Promotion Committee to select suitable candidates up to twice the number of posts vacant for promotion. Without yearly determination under Rule 9, Rule 24 could not be lawfully operationalized.
  4. Rejection of respondents' justification: The respondents' reply attributed non-determination to vague "administrative difficulties." The court found this explanation inadequate, noting the Deputy Government Advocate could not specify the difficulties and characterizing the plea as "absolutely vague" and unacceptable without particulars.
  5. Reliance on precedent: The court relied on earlier decisions (Rajasthan Public Service Commission v. Damyanti Dadich; O.P. Agarwal v. State of Rajasthan; N.K. Hingorani v. State of Rajasthan) to derive legal principles (Rule 9 as a statutory direction, mandatory nature of annual determination, and the prohibition on prejudicial clubbing of vacancies). The court explained how clubbing vacancies skews eligibility and seniority: eligibility conditions applicable in an earlier year may be lost if selections are deferred and conducted later by reference to later eligibility standards.
  6. Recognition of statutory response: The court noted that the State Government later amended Rule 9 and Rule 24 (introducing sub-rule 11-A) to provide that when vacancies relating to earlier years are determined subsequently, the Departmental Promotion Committee must consider persons who would have been eligible in the year the vacancy related to and apply the eligibility criteria applicable to that earlier year (though no arrears of pay are allowed). The court used these developments to underscore the recognized principle that later determinations must recreate earlier eligibility conditions for promotion and seniority purposes.
  7. Remedies and directions: Considering the prolonged failure (over ten years and more in practical effect), the court concluded that the petitioner's rights were likely prejudiced and that an appropriate remedial direction was required. The court ordered respondents No. 1 and 2 to determine vacancies under Rule 9 within six months and then forthwith make substantive appointments to Foreman Grade I considering all eligible candidates (including the petitioner) according to the eligibility, criteria and procedure for promotion applicable in the relevant year(s).
  8. Limitation on challenge to long-standing temporary appointments: The court observed that appointments of respondent Nos. 3 and 4 dated 1961 and 1966 respectively had been held in temporary capacity for a very long period and could not be challenged by the 1975 writ petition; consequently the petitioner could not displace them via this petition.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition was allowed. The court directed respondents No. 1 and 2 to determine the number of vacancies in accordance with the provisions of Rule 9 within six months and thereafter to make substantive appointments to the posts of Foreman Grade I, considering all eligible candidates (including the petitioner) according to the eligibility conditions, criteria and procedure for promotion as was applicable in the particular year to which the vacancies relate.

Implications:

  • The immediate and binding effect is a mandatory administrative action: respondents must perform the statutory duty of annual vacancy determination (or determine outstanding vacancies within the six-month period ordered) and proceed with substantive promotions in conformity with the Rules and the eligibility conditions of the year in which each vacancy arose.
  • The petitioner is to be considered among all eligible candidates for substantive promotion to Foreman Grade I in accordance with the applicable historical eligibility criteria for the year(s) of the vacancies.
  • The court rejected the petitioner's attempt to challenge the long-standing temporary appointments of respondent Nos. 3 and 4 by this writ petition given the passage of time; thus those appointments, by virtue of long continuance, were not set aside here.
  • No indication in the opinion that a novel legal principle or new precedent was created; the court applied existing authorities and statutory interpretation to direct compliance with the Rules. The decision remedies administrative non-compliance in the specific departmental context and orders concrete compliance rather than announcing new law of general application beyond the principles already articulated in cited cases.

Costs: Each party was directed to bear their own costs.

Show all summary ...

Dwarka Prasad, J.:— This writ petition discloses the deplorable conditions in which low paid employees of the Medical and Health Department of the State Government are placed, inspite of the promulgation of the Rajasthan Medical and Health Subordinate Service Rules, 1955 (hereinafter referred as to ‘the Rules’).

2. The petitioner was initially appointed as a Mechanic Grade II on December 22, 1954. He was there after promoted as Mechanic Grade I on March 1, 1956. On March 7, 1975 the petitioner was further promoted as a Foreman Grade I, purely on the temporary basis for a period of 4 months or until a person selected by the Departmental Promotion Committee was available, whichever was earlier. The petitioner's grievance is that inspite of the promulgation of the Rules in the year 1965, the number of vacancies in the cadre of Foreman Grade I have not so far been determined nor any substantive appointments have been made but ever since the promulgation of the Rules in 1965, persons have been continuing to hold the posts of Foreman Grade 1 in an ad hoc or temporary capacity. The petitioner's further grievance is that persons junior to him namely, respondent Nos. 3 and 4 were promoted earlier to him to the post of Foreman Grade I and they are still continuing as such although their appointment on the post of Foreman Grade I was illegal and they should be ousted from such posts.

3. However, as regards the appointment of respondents No. 3 and 4 is concerned, the petitioner's case cannot be considered now as the said respondents have been holding the posts of Foreman Grade I, although in a temporary capacity, but for a very long period. Respondent No. 3 Prem Singh was appointed as a Foreman Grade I on May 25, 1961 in a temporary capacity, while respondent No. 4 Gheesalal was appointed as a Foreman Grade I in a temporary capacity on May 3, 1966. Thus, respondent Nos. 3 and 4 have been holding the posts of Foreman Grade I since 1961 and 1966 respectively and the petitioner cannot challenge the validity of their appointment on the post of Foreman Grade I, in an ad hoc or temporary capacity, by means of a writ petition filed in the year 1975.

4. As regards respondent No. 5 the petitioner has no case inasmuch as the respondent No. 5 was appointed as Foreman Grade II on August 19, 1972 and he has not been promoted as Foreman Grade I. Moreover, according to the reply filed by the respondents, respondent No. 5 has already been declared surplus and services have been surrendered to the General Administration Department for absorption in another department. Thus, the said respondent no longer remains even as a member of the Rajasthan Medical and Page: 410Health Subordinate Service and he is not working on the post of Foreman Grade I.

5. As regards the main grievance of the petitioner that the vacancies in the cadre of Foreman Grade I have not been determined according to the provisions of rule 9 and substantive appointments have not been made since 1965, it must be observed that the State Government has paid scant regards to the provisions of rule 9, since it has failed to determine the number of vacancies as envisaged in the said provision. It is surprising to note that any promotions or appointments have not been made in the category of Foreman Grade I in a substantive capacity ever since the Rules were promulgated in the year 1965 although several years have passed since then. Rule 9(1), as it stood at the time when the writ petition was filed in the year 1975, read as under:—

“9. Determination of vacancies.-(1) Subject to the provisions of these rules, the Appointing Authority shall determine each year the number of vacancies anticipated during the following twelve months and the number of persons likely to be recruited by each method. Such vacancies shall be determined again before the expiry of twelve months of the last determination of such vacancies.”

It was incumbent upon the State Government, in accordance with the aforesaid provisions, to determine each year the number of vacancies anticipated during the following twelve months. Prior to October 16, 1973 the number of vacancies anticipated during each calender year were required to be determined by the appointing authority at the commencement of each year, but after the amendment made by the notification dated October 16, 1973, the appointing authority is called upon to determine each year the number of vacancies anticipated during the following 12 months. Such determination of vacancies has to be repeated before the expiry of 12 months of the last determination of such vacancies. However, the petitioner contends and which fact has not been denied by the respondents that ever since the Rules were promulgated in the year 1965, the number of vacancies anticipated either during the calender year or during the next 12 months have not been determined at all. Rule 24 provides that as soon as the number of vacancies is determined and it is decided that a number of posts shall be filled in by promotion, a correct and complete list should be prepared containing the names, not exceeding five times of the number of vacancies, out of the senior most persons qualified for promotion to the class of posts concerned. Thereafter a Departmental Promotion Committee should be constituted, consisting of the Director, the Deputy Secretary to the Government in the Department of Personnel and the Deputy Secretary to the Government in the Medical and Health Department, for the posts falling within the purview of the Appointing Authority and the Committee should consider the cases of all eligible persons and select suitable candidates upto twice the number of posts vacant to be filled in by promotion. According to the Schedule annexed to the Rules, the post of Foreman Grade I is required to be filled in 100% by promotion from amomgst Mechanic Grade I/Foreman Grade II/Fitter Grade I, with five years experience.

6. The reply filed by the respondents in this respect provides an indication about the casual manner in which the mind of the respondents has been working in respect of the rightful claims of the poor and low paid employees of the Medical and Health Department of the State. The respondents have stated as under in their reply dated November 19, 1975:—

“In reply to the contents of para 9-A (ii) of the amemded writ petition, it is submitted that the vacancies could not be determined due to administrative difficulties. It is however, submitted that steps are being taken for making the substantive appointments on the post of Foreman Grade II. At Page: 411that time all the eligible persons will be considered for making substantive appointments.”

7. The learned Deputy Govt. Advocate was unable to submit before this Court as to what administrative difficulties were experienced by the respondent, the Director, Medical and Health Services, who is the appointing authority, in determining the number of vacancies, in accordance with the provisions of rule 9. It may be pointed out that the provisions of rule 9 embodies a direction requiring the appointing authority to determine each year the number of vacancies anticipated during the following twelve months. In the case of Rajasthan Public Service Commission, Ajmer v. Dr. (Miss) Damyanti Dadich (1), a Division Bench of this Court, while dealing with a similar rule contained in the Educational Service (Collegiate Branch) Rules, 1971 observed that Rule 9 is in the nature of a statutory instruction to and for the guidance of the appointing authority and further that if the appointing authority fails to comply with it, his failure in that behalf may create administrative difficulties and he would certainly be answerable to his superiors for his failure in that behalf thus, a statutory duty has been cast upon the appointing authority under Rule 9 to determine the number of vacancies every year and as the appointing authority has failed to discharge its statutory duty for over 10 years, such failure on his part is likely to adversely affect the legal rights of the petitioner. Unless the number of vacancies are determined under Rue 9, the further process of making substantive appointments under Rule 24 cannot be undertaken and thus the entire process of making substantive appointments in the department on the junior posts of Foreman Grade I are at a stand-still because of the noncompliance of the provisions of rule 9 by the appointing authority.

8. In the face of the axistance of Rule 9, it is not permissible to the appointing authority to club together the vacancies occurring during a long period of time and thereafter to make selections for promotions on all these vacancies together, on the basis of eligibility of all candidates on the date of making such selections. The provisions of rule 9 have been specifically inserted in the Rules so that the vacancies which had occurred in the previous years may not be clubbed together over a number of years, as it is likely to prejudicially affect the rights of the persons who are entitled to be considered for promotion in the earlier years, according to the eligibility clause. As a matter of illustration, I may refer to the question of promotion to the post of Foreman Grade I. According to the Rules, five years experience on the post of Mechanic Grade I/Fitter Grade I/Foreman Grade II is required to make a person, working, on any one of the aforesaid posts eligible for promotion to the post of Foreman Grade I. If the vacancies are determined year after year, persons who do not possess the requisite five years, experience would not be eligible for promotion to the post of Foreman Grade I. But if for a number of years the vacancies are not determined, as they occurred from year to year, but ad hoc or temporary promotions are given to a large number of employees without any consideration of seniority and after a number of years the total number of vacancies existing at that time are determined and persons eligible at the time of selection are considered for promotion, then persons who became eligible for promotion in the earlier years are likely to be prejudiced in the matter of selection and seniority. In O.P Agarwal v. The State Of Rajasthan (2), Agrawal, J., while dealing with a similar provision contained in Rule 9 of the Rajasthan Medical and Health Service Rules, 1963 observed as under:—

“If the Government has the discretion not to fill the vacancies occurring in a particular year in that year the result would be that a vacancy which arises in a particular year against the merit quota and is not filled in that year would be lumped up with a vacancy of senioritycum-merit quota which arises in a subsequent year and both the appointments will to treated Page: 412to be made at the same time and thereby the person selected by merit will be deprived of his seniority which he would have got if the selection to the post in the merit quota had been made in the year in which the post fell vacant. Such a consequence would be avoided if Sub-Rule (1) of Rule 9 is construed as imposing a mandatory obligation on the Government to determine, at the commencement of each year the number of vacancies anticipated during the calender year and the number of persons likely to be recruited by each method of recruitment as laid down in Rule 6 and make appointments on that basis only. This does not mean that the Government cannot fill the vacancies occurring in a particular year in a subsequent year. It would be open to the Government to make appointment on a vacancy which occurred in a particular year in a subsequent year also but the said appointments will have to be treated as appointments of the year in which the appointment is made, had accured. This necessarily implies that while making appointments on vacancies which arose in an earlier year, the Government will take into consideration the qualifications and other conditions of eligibility as were present in the year in which the vacancies arose and treat the said appointments as appertaining to the year or years in which the vacancies arose for the purpose of seniority.”

9. The same view was taken by Jain, J. in N.K Hingorani v. The State of Rajasthan (3) and it was observed in that case that the underlying purpose of the provisions of rule 9 is that after the determination of vacancies, they should be filled up yearly on the then existing eligibility conditions. It was also observed that if the rules are not construed in this manner, they may be open to abuse and just claims may be defeated by clubbing of vacancies of earlier years. If the vacancies are not determined as contemplated by Rule 9 and the vacancies occurring for a number of years are clubbed together, then the selection for such a large number of vacancies would be open to a large number of employees, according to the eligibility conditions existing at the time of selection and it would result in grave prejudice being caused to those employees who could have been selected earlier for promotion if the vacancies would have been determined year after year, as provided in rule 9 and their case for promotion would have been considered according to the eligibility conditions then existing. It appears that the rationals of these decisions has also been recognised by the State Government, inasmuch as rule 9 has been further amended by the notification dated October 6, 1979 published in the Rajasthan Gazette of the same date and was also amended by the notification dated December 21, 1981 published in the Rajasthan Gazette dated July 1, 1982. A new sub-rule 11-A was introduced in rule 24 by the notification dated October 6, 1979, which was substituted by the notification dated October 18, 1982 published in the Rajasthan Gazette dated October 21, 1982. The existing sub-rule 11-A of the rule 24-A runs as under:—

“If in any subsequent year after promulgation of these rules, vacancies relating to any earlier year are determined under sub-rule (2) of rule relating to determination of vacancies, which were required to be filled by promotion, the Departmental Promotion Committee shall consider the cases of all such persons who would have been eligible in the year to which the vacancies relate irrespective of the year in which the meeting of the Departmental Promotion Committee is held and such promotions shall be governed by the criteria and procedure for promotion as was applicable in the particular year to which the vacancies relate, and the service/experience of an incumbent who has been so promoted, for promotion to higher post for any period during which he has not actually performed the duties of the post to which he would have been promoted, shall be counted. The pay of a person who has been so promoted shall be refixed at the pay which he would have derived Page: 413at the time of his promotion but no arrears of pay shall be allowed to him.”

10. Thus, the State Government now recognised the principal that vacancies ought to be determined every year under Rule 9, if they are determined subsequently, the cases of all those persons who would have been eligible for promotion in the earlier years, would be considered with respect to the year in which the vacancies had occurred, irrespective of the year in which the vacancies were actually filled in and such promotion shall be governed by the eligibility conditions, criteria and procedure for promotion as was applicable in the particular year to which the vacancies relate.

11. As I have already observed above, no explanation worthiness has been offered on behalf of the appointing authority as to why the vacancies could not be determined in respect of the posts of Foreman Grade I from year to year since 1965 and as to why the provisions of rule 9 were consistently ignored by the appointing authority. The mere submission that vacancies could not be determined due to ‘administrative difficulties’ is an absolutely vague plea and without disclosure of the alleged difficulties it is difficult to accept the bald and vague contention of the respondents that there was any lawful reason for not determining the number of vacancies, year after year, as provided in rule 9. It would be no solace to the petitioner that substantive appointments would be made after the number of vacancies is determined and that all eligible persons would be considered at the time of making substantive appointments. The rights of the petitioner are likely to be prejudicially affected by the abnormal delay in determination the number of vacancies occurring year after year. The petitioner was promoted as Mechanic Grade I with effect from March 1, 1956 and he could have been promoted as Foreman Grade I either at time when the respondent No. 3 was so promoted or when respondent No. 4 was promoted as Foreman Grade I, because the petitioner claims to be senior to both respondents No. 3 and 4. Thus, the delay in making substantive appointments to the cadre of Foreman Grade I for the last several years, without any valid reason for the same, may unduly prejudice the rights of the petitioner in the reply filed by the respondents, it was submitted on their behalf that ‘steps’ were being taken for making substantive promotions to the posts of Foreman Grade I. The above reply was filed on November 19, 1975 and although a period of almost 8 years has elapsed since then, yet the learned Deputy Government Advocate is not in a position to say even today as to what ‘steps’ have been taken during this long period or 8 years and how far the matter relating to making of substantive appointments to the posts of Foreman Grade I has proceeded uptil now. The attitude of the appointing authority with regard to its low paid employees, without caring to make substantive appointments by way of promotion in accordance with the provisions of the Rules, for a period of more than 15 years, deserves to be depricated. The attention of the State Government is invited to the state of affairs prevailing in the Medical and Health Department of the State in respect of low paid employees working on the posts in the subordinate service.

12. With these observations, the writ petition is allowed. The respondents No. 1 and 2 are directed to determine the number of vacancies, in accordance with the provisions of rule 9 within a period of 6 months and then proceed forthwith to make substantive appointments to the posts of Foreman Grade I, considering all eligible candidates, including the petitioner, according to the eligibility conditions, criteria and procedure for promotion as was applicable in the particular year to which the vacancies relate.

13. The parties are left to bear their own costs.