Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Land Acquisition Collector And Ors. v. Roshan Lal

Himachal Pradesh High Court
Jun 20, 2015
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — Dharam Chand Chaudhary, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This judgment disposes of the present appeal together with eight other appeals raising identical questions of law and fact arising out of the same award. Land Reference Petition No. 42 of 2009 was preferred by Roshan Lal (appellant in this appeal) against supplementary award No. 1 of 2007 dated 12.1.2007 (Ex. PA) concerning Phati Dashad, Tehsil Sainj District Kullu. Similar reference petitions were preferred in eight other matters; all nine references were consolidated by the trial Court with Reference Petition No. 42 of 2009 for a common trial and evidence for all references was recorded in Reference Petition No. 42 of 2009.

By a common award dated 31.5.2010 the learned trial Court held the petitioners (respondents before this Court) entitled to the market value of their acquired houses as assessed by RW-1 Shri G.C. Gupta (an officer of the Public Works Department), without any deduction for depreciation, and with an increase of 40% on the market value so assessed. The trial Court also granted other statutory benefits under Section 23(1)(a) and 23(2) and interest under Section 28 of the Land Acquisition Act.

The State (appellant before this Court) challenged the legality and validity of the award in these consolidated appeals.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the award under challenge is legally and factually sustainable.
  2. Whether any deduction on account of depreciation is permissible from the market value of houses assessed for compensation.
  3. Whether it was permissible for the trial Court to grant an increase (40%) over the market value assessed by the departmental valuation (RW-1).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant-State's Arguments (as stated in the opinion)

  • The Court below failed to appreciate and correctly apply the evidence on record and, as a result, reached a wrong conclusion.
  • Statutory benefits granted by the Court below were allegedly not admissible.
  • The trial Court erred in awarding compensation for the acquired houses without deduction for depreciation and by granting a 40% increase over the assessment made by the Land Acquisition Collector or by the departmental assessment.
  • Learned Additional Advocate General emphasized that the compensation for houses was rightly assessed and awarded by the Land Acquisition Collector and there was no occasion for the trial Court to award compensation based on RW-1 Shri G.C. Gupta's assessment without deduction and with enhancement.

Respondents' Arguments (as stated in the opinion)

  • Counsel for the respondents (Mr. Sunil Mohan Goel) submitted that the award passed by the trial Court requires no interference because it is based on the evidence on record and applicable law.
  • Counsel also produced an award dated 31.8.2010 in Reference Petition No. 28 of 2009 (Shiv Ram and others v. Collector Land Acquisition and another) showing that in identical matters enhanced compensation with 40% increase had been implemented by the State.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Union of India v. Savjiram and another, (2004) 9 SCC 312 The Supreme Court held that no deduction on account of depreciation can be made from the market value of the house assessed; compensation for house is to be calculated by taking into consideration the cost of construction at rates prevalent at the time of assessment and there is no scope for any further deduction within the value of the house/building so assessed. The trial Court's refusal to deduct depreciation from the valuation made by RW-1 Shri G.C. Gupta was held to be in accordance with this precedent; accordingly the High Court found no illegality in awarding compensation based on RW-1's assessment without deduction for depreciation.
National Hydro Electric Power Corporation v. Smt. Sumundari and others, 2007 (3) S.L.J. (H.P.) 2021 Approved an increase (50% in that case) over the older schedule of rates when structures were valued on an older schedule (1987) and the acquisition notification related to 1992; recognized that land and structures can be separately valued in appropriate factual situations and noted the general trend of increase in cost of construction. The Court applied the ratio of Sumundari to uphold the trial Court's grant of a 40% increase over the market value assessed by RW-1 (who used H.P. Schedule of Rates 1999) in view of the Section 4 notification published on 16.4.2005 and comparable decisions in connected matters; thus the 40% enhancement was treated as justified and not arbitrary.
Kirtan Tandon v. Allahabad Development Authority and another, (2004) 10 SCC 745 There is no absolute rule that land and building must be valued as one unit; where a large portion of land is vacant and the structure covers a small area, land and structure can be assessed separately. The building value may be estimated on prime cost or replacement cost less depreciation and the rate of depreciation depends on factors including maintenance. Quoted within the Sumundari discussion and used to support the principle that structures standing on acquired land can be separately valued; this reasoning underpins the Court's acceptance of separate assessment and enhancement of structure values in the present consolidated matters.
Administrator General of W.B. v. Collector, Varanasi (referred within Kirtan Tandon) Explains circumstances in which land and building might be valued separately and describes methods of building valuation including consideration of depreciation and factors affecting it. Referenced in the Kirtan Tandon passage that the Court relied upon; contributes to the legal backdrop permitting separate valuation of structures and method of assessing building value.
Shiv Ram and others v. Collector Land Acquisition and another, Reference Petition No. 28 of 2009 (award dated 31.8.2010) This connected award (produced by respondents' counsel) was relied upon as an example of an identical matter in which enhanced compensation with 40% increase was implemented by the State. The High Court noted that in identical matters the appellant-State had implemented awards providing 40% enhancement; this fact was used in the Court's reasoning to indicate inconsistency in the State's challenge and to underscore that the present appeals lacked substance.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court summarized the controversy as narrow: whether the impugned award was legally and factually sustainable. The Court set out and applied the following reasoning based exclusively on evidence and cited authorities contained in the opinion:

  1. Consolidation and Evidence: The nine reference petitions were consolidated for trial and evidence for all references was recorded in Reference Petition No. 42 of 2009. Engineer G.C. Gupta (RW-1), an officer of the Public Works Department, made assessments of the superstructures/houses and stepped into the witness box to prove multiple reports (Ex. PW-8/B, Ex. PW-8/D, Ex. PW-8/F, Ex. PW-8/H, Ex. PW-8/J, Ex. PW-8/L and Ex. PW-8/N).
  2. Depreciation Issue: Although RW-1 Gupta made deductions for depreciation in his assessments, the Court held that such deductions are impermissible in light of Union of India v. Savjiram (2004) 9 SCC 312, which categorically held that no deduction on account of depreciation can be made from the market value of the house as assessed; compensation for house should be calculated by taking into account cost of construction at prevailing rates without any further deduction.
  3. Increase over Assessed Value: The State challenged the trial Court's grant of a 40% increase over the departmental assessment. The High Court observed that the law is no longer res integra on this point and relied on a co-ordinate bench decision in National Hydro Electric Power Corporation v. Smt. Sumundari (2007 (3) S.L.J. (H.P.) 2021) where a 50% increase was approved in comparable factual circumstances. The Sumundari judgment explains that structures may be separately valued (citing Kirtan Tandon) and recognizes a general trend of increase in construction costs; prior decisions relating to acquisitions for the Chamera Project approved 50% increases where assessments were on older schedule rates.
  4. Application to Present Case: In the present matter, the Section 4 notification was issued on 5.4.2005 and published in the official gazette on 16.4.2005; RW-1 G.C. Gupta had assessed market value of the houses on the basis of H.P. Schedule of Rates 1999. Applying the ratio of Sumundari, the trial Court's grant of a 40% increase over RW-1's assessed market value was treated as justified. The Court further noted that in identical matters the State had implemented awards providing a similar 40% enhancement (as evidenced by the award in Reference Petition No. 28 of 2009), suggesting inconsistency and undermining the State's challenge.
  5. Conclusion of Analysis: For these reasons — reliance on RW-1's assessment, the binding (or persuasive) authority of Union of India v. Savjiram on the depreciation point, and the application of Sumundari on the permissible enhancement — the High Court concluded that the trial Court had not committed illegality or irregularity in awarding compensation without deduction for depreciation and with a 40% increase.

Holding and Implications

Final Holding: The appeals are dismissed and the impugned award is upheld.

Implications and immediate consequences:

  • The award dated 31.5.2010 passed by the trial Court in the consolidated reference petitions (including Reference Petition No. 42 of 2009) stands affirmed. That award granted compensation for the acquired houses based on RW-1 Shri G.C. Gupta's assessments without deduction for depreciation and with a 40% increase; it also granted statutory benefits under Section 23(1)(a) and 23(2) and interest under Section 28 of the Act.
  • The Court directed that an authenticated copy of this judgment be placed on the record of each of the connected appeals.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel principle or overrule existing authorities; it applies existing precedent (as discussed above) to the facts of these consolidated references. No broader new precedent was declared beyond applying the cited authorities to these facts.

This summary is prepared strictly from the contents of the provided opinion and does not add information not present in the text.

Show all summary ...

Dharam Chand Chaudhary, J.:--

1. This judgment shall dispose of the present appeal and also eight other appeals detailed hereinabove involving identical questions of law and facts and having arisen out of the same award. As a matter of fact, Land Reference Petition No. 42 of 2009 was preferred by Roshan Lal appellant in this appeal against the supplementary award No. 1 of 2007, dated 12.1.2007 (Ex. PA) of Phati Dashad, Tehsil Sainj District Kullu. Similar references were preferred by the appellants in other eight appeals referred to hereinabove. All the nine references were consolidated by the Court below with reference petition No. 42 of 2009 for common trial. Evidence for the purpose of all the references was recorded in reference petition No. 42 of 2009. Consequently, all the petitions came to be decided by a common award passed on 31.5.2010 whereby learned trial Court has held the petitioners, respondents herein, entitled to the market value of their acquired houses as assessed by RW-1 Shri G.C. Gupta, of course, without deduction of any amount on account of depreciation and with increase at the rate of 40% on the market value of the houses so assessed by Mr. Gupta. Other statutory benefits payable under section 23(1)(a) and 23(2) and also the interest payable under Section 28 of the Act were also granted in favour of the respondents-petitioners.

2. The respondent-State, appellant herein, aggrieved by the impugned award has challenged the legality and validity thereof in these appeals on the common grounds that the Court below has failed to appreciate the facts and evidence available on record in its right perspective and the same rather has been misread and misconstrued and as a result thereof, a wrong conclusion has been drawn. The statutory benefits, allegedly not admissible, have erroneously been granted in favour of the petitioners-respondents. The Court below allegedly erred in law and facts while awarding the compensation in respect of the acquired houses without deduction on account of depreciation and with 40% increase.

3. Learned Additional Advocate General during the course of arguments has mainly emphasized that the compensation in respect of the house in existence over the acquired land was rightly assessed and awarded by Land Acquisition Collector. It has, therefore, been urged that there was no occasion to the Court below to have awarded the compensation in respect of the houses as per the assessment made by RW-1 Shri G.C. Gupta, without deduction on account of depreciation from the assessment so made by him with 40% increase. As a matter of fact, this is the only grievance brought to this Court by the appellant-State, in these appeals.

4. On the other hand Mr. Sunil Mohan Goel, Advocate has very ably argued that the award passed by Court below calls for no interference in these appeals being based on the evidence available on record and also the law applicable to the given facts and circumstances of this case.

5. The controversy is not much and rather lies in a narrow compass. The only question, which needs determination in these appeals, is as to whether the award under challenge is legally and factually sustainable or not. The answer to this poser in all fairness and also in the ends of justice would be in affirmative for the reasons that the assessment of the value of the houses belonging to the respondents-petitioners, in existence over the acquired land has been made by Engineer G.C. Gupta, none-else, but an officer of the Public Works Department. Mr. G.C. Gupta has stepped into the witness box as RW-1 and proved the reports Ex. PW-8/B, Ex. PW-8/D, Ex. PW-8/F, Ex. PW-8/H, Ex. PW-8/J, Ex. PW-8/L and Ex. PW-8/N, he submitted. No doubt, Mr. Gupta has made deduction on account of depreciation out of the assessment of the valuation of the houses, he made, however, no such deduction is permissible.

6. The apex Court in Union of Indian v. Savjiram and another, (2004) 9 SCC 312, relied upon by learned trial Court also, has held that no deduction on account of depreciation can be made from the market value of the house assessed and that the compensation payable in respect of the house has to be calculated by taking into consideration the cost of construction at the rates prevalent at the time of assessment of the compensation by working out the current value of the materials and that there is no scope for any further deduction within the value of the house/building so assessed. Therefore, the apex Court in the judgment supra has categorically held that any deduction towards depreciation is not permissible. The trial Court has, therefore, not committed any illegality or irregularity in awarding the compensation in respect of the houses as per the assessment made by RW-1 Shri R.C. Gupta without any deduction on account of depreciation and with 40% increase thereon.

7. If coming to the grouse of the appellant-State that 40% increase in the amount so assessed was impermissible, the law on the point is no more res integra because a co-ordinate Bench of this Court in National Hydro Electric Power Corporation v. Smt. Sumundari and others, 2007 (3) S.L.J. (H.P.) 2021, taking into consideration the value of the houses so assessed on the basis of 1987 schedule of rates whereas the property acquired vide notification dated 13.6.1992, under Section 4 of the Act, approved the increase to the extent of 50% on the market value of the houses so assessed by the District Judge. This judgment reads as follows:

15. The value of the superstructures was done by the project authorities on the basis of 1987 schedule of rates and no premium was given on 1987 schedule of rates even though the property was acquired vide notification dated 13.6.1992 under Section 4 of the Act. A feeble attempt was made by the learned Counsel for the Corporation that claimants/petitioners are not entitled to compensation for the structures built on the acquired land, his submission is that market value of the structures built on acquired land is included in the market value of the land. This argument of the learned Counsel has no force. The structures on the acquired land are on very small area. The valuation of the structures has been done separately by the project authorities themselves. There is no absolute bar that no valuation of the structures standing on the acquired land can be done separately, it depends upon the facts of the case, where acquired area is large and structure on such acquired area is on small area then land and structure can be assessed separately. In Kirtan Tandon v. Allahabad Development Authority and another, [ (2004) 10 SCC 745], the Supreme Court has held as follows:--

......But there is no hard and fast rule that land and building must be valued as one unit. They can be separately assessed if the large portion of the land is lying vacant and is capable of better use as stated by Venkatachaliah, J. (as His Lordship then was) in Administrator General of W.B. v. Collector, Varanasi, and it will be useful to extract the relevant part of AIR para-8 of the Report: (SCC pp. 159-60, para 17)

Usually, land and building thereon constitute one unit. Land is one kind of property; land and building together constitute and altogether different kind of property. They must be valued as one unit. But where, however, the property comprises extensive land and the structures thereon do not indicate a realization of the full developmental potential of the land, it might not be impermissible to value the property estimating separately the market value of the land with reference to the date of the preliminary notification and to add to it the value of the structures as at that time. In this method, building value is estimated on the basis of the prime cost or replacement cost less depreciation. The rate of depreciation is, generally, arrived at by dividing the cost of construction (less the salvage value at the end of the period of utility) by the number of years of utility of the building. The factors that prolong the life and utility of the building, such as good maintenance, necessary influence and bring down the rate of depreciation.

In the present case, structures are on very small area in comparison to whole of the acquired land, therefore, land and structures can be assessed as different units.

16. It is common knowledge that there is general trend of increase in cost of construction. The State has acquired land and structures under different notifications for construction of reservoir of Chamera Dam. In RFA No. 72 of 1998, along with RFAs No. 75, 56 and 63 of 1998 decided on 30.5.2007 and RFA No. 127 of 1998 decided on 1st June, 2007, this Court has approved 50% increase in market value of the structures over and above the 1987 schedule of rates. The land and structures in those cases were also acquired for construction of reservoir of Chamera Project on the basis of notifications under Section 4 of the Act dated 6.6.1992 and 16.6.1992. In the present case, the notification under Section 4 is of 13.6.1992, therefore, 50% increase given by the District Judge for assessing the market value of the structures over and above the 1987 schedule of rates is just, reasonable, and not arbitrary. The claimants/petitioners have not otherwise independently proved that at the time of notification under Section 4 of the Act what was the value of their superstructure standing on the acquired land.

8. If coming to the case in hand, notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act though issued on 5.4.2005, has been published in the official gazette on 16.4.2005. RW-1 Shri G.C. Gupta, has made the assessment of the market value of the acquired houses on the basis of H.P. Schedule of Rates 1999. Therefore, applying the ratio of the judgment of this Court in Sumundari s case supra, learned trial Court has not committed any illegality and irregularity by giving 40% increase, over and above the market value of the houses belonging to the respondents-petitioners assessed by RW-1 G.C. Gupta. Mr. Sunil Mohan Goel, Advocate while stating at the bar that in identical matters, the enhanced compensation, in respect of the houses with 40% increase has allegedly been paid to the claimants by the appellant-State in compliance with the award has produced the copy of such award dated 31.8.2010 in Reference Petition No. 28 of 2009 titled Shiv Ram and others v. Collector Land Acquisition and another, and its connected matter ten in number for perusal of this Court. When in identical matters, the appellant-State has implemented the award same and similar in nature, these appeals being without any substance seems to have been filed merely for rejection.

9. In view of what has been stated hereinabove, I find no force in the present appeal and its tagged matters as aforesaid and the same are hereby dismissed. Consequently, the award under challenge is upheld. Authenticated copy of this judgment be placed on the record of each of the connected appeals.