Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ghaziabad Development Authority v. Kashi Ram And Others

Allahabad High Court
Nov 13, 2014
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The State of Uttar Pradesh, through the Ghaziabad Development Authority (GDA), acquired land belonging to the claimants in village Makanpur, Pargana Loni, Tehsil Dadri, District Ghaziabad for planned development. A notification under Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act was issued on 12.9.1986 (published in the Gazette on 28.2.1987) and a notification under Section 6(1) was issued on 24.2.1988. Possession was taken on 14.6.1988 and 29.6.1988. The Special Land Acquisition Officer (SLAO) awarded compensation at `50/ per sq. yard on 30.12.1989, relying on an exemplar sale (plot No. 582). Objections were filed and, under Section 18 of the Act, the matter was referred to the District Judge. The Reference Court (IV and VI Additional District Judges, Ghaziabad) passed awards dated 19.4.1999 and 31.5.2000 enhancing compensation to `90/ per sq. yard and awarding solatium and interest. The GDA filed a batch of First Appeals (Sl. Nos. 1–60) challenging the Reference Court awards; tenure-holders/claimants filed appeals (Sl. Nos. 61–96) seeking further enhancement and reduction in deductions. During the proceedings some original claimants died and substitution applications for their legal heirs were allowed after condonation of any delay.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the compensation awarded by the Special Land Acquisition Officer (SLAO) was inadequate and, if so, to what amount of compensation the petitioners (claimants) were entitled? (Issue No.1)
  2. Whether the reference (to the District Judge under Section 18) was time-barred? (Issue No.2)
  3. Whether the reference was barred by Section 9 of the Land Acquisition Act? (Issue No.3)
  4. Whether the reference was barred by principles of estoppel? (Issue No.4)
  5. To what amount of compensation, if any, are the petitioners entitled? (Issue No.5)

Arguments of the Parties

Ghaziabad Development Authority (GDA) — Primary Contentions

  • The claimants accepted the original compensation without protest, and therefore they could not maintain a Reference under Section 18; some protest entries showed an interpolation (a different handwriting inserted the word "protest" without signature), suggesting acceptance.
  • The Reference Court wrongly rejected certified copies of sale exemplars produced by the Collector on the ground that witnesses were not examined; reliance was placed on the Apex Court's decision in P. Rama Reddy that certified copies of registered documents may be accepted as evidence.
  • The Reference Court wrongly relied on sale deeds executed by builders (Tripati Builders) to determine value; because those deeds were by builders rather than farmers, the court should set them aside as they inflated value.
  • There was inconsistency between the two impugned Reference Court orders: one award fixed compensation at `90/ after deducting 33% from `135/; another fixed `90/ without deduction — this variance warrants interference.
  • The Reference Court erred in allowing only 33% deduction for development costs; given the large chunk of land and requirements for internal development (roads, sewerage, water tank, parks, etc.), a deduction of at least 70% should have been applied; reliance was placed on Chandrashekar (AIR 2012 SC 446) and the authorities discussed therein.
  • The GDA had not shown before the Reference Court the specific amenities and civic facilities they would provide, and therefore the plea for enhanced deduction was not made at the appropriate stage and could not be raised belatedly before this Court.

Claimants / Tenure Holders — Primary Contentions

  • Compensation must reflect the situation and potentiality of the land; reliance was placed on the replication (Trilok Chand and others, paras 3–6) and on the oral evidence of PW 1 (Krishna Tyagi) who stated that in 1987 the land could have been sold in the open market at `500/ per sq. yard.
  • The Reference Court's fixation of `90/ per sq. yard (derived as `135/ less 33%) is inadequate; the market value should lie between `135/ and `500/ per sq. yard based on PW 1's statement.
  • The Reference Court failed to consider Exhibit Paper No. 37-Ga — an earlier Reference Court judgment (Satish Takural v. State) that fixed value (after 20% deduction) at `138/ per sq. yard for land acquired in 1982; since the present acquisition occurred in 1987, claimants are entitled to enhancement.
  • Reliance was placed on Mohinder Singh v. State of Haryana (2014) where the Apex Court held that a deduction of 1/4th of market value (rather than 40%) was appropriate — supporting the claimants' challenge to high deductions.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
P. Rama Reddy v. Special Land Acquisition Officer, 1995 (2) SCC 305 Certified copies of documents registered under the Registration Act may be accepted as evidence in proceedings under the Land Acquisition Act. The GDA relied on this to contend that the Reference Court erred in rejecting certified sale exemplars; the Court recorded the GDA's submission but did not set aside the Reference Court's evidentiary rulings on that point.
Chandrashekar (D) by LRs and others v. Land Acquisition Officer and another, AIR 2012 SC 446 Discusses quantum of deductions to be applied to market value assessed from exemplar sale transactions; explains two components of deduction (land for amenities and costs to raise infrastructure) and surveys prior precedents. The GDA invoked this case to argue for a large deduction (up to 70%); the Court examined Chandrashekar and the cases it surveys but found 33% deduction acceptable here given the facts.
Brigadier Sahib Singh Kalha and Ors. v. Amritsar Improvement Trust and Ors., (1982) 1 SCC 419 Where large area of undeveloped land is acquired, allowance must be made for land to be left for infrastructure (20%) and costs for raising infrastructure (20–33%); cumulative deductions may range between 40% and 53%. Referred to in Chandrashekar's survey of authorities; used to illustrate that large deductions can be appropriate in some cases.
Administrator General of West Bengal v. Collector, Varanasi, (1988) 2 SCC 150 Upheld a deduction of 40% as applied by the High Court. Included in the precedential matrix on permissible deductions; considered when assessing appropriate deduction in instant matter.
Chimanlal Hargovinddas v. Special Land Acquisition Officer, Poona and Anr., (1988) 3 SCC 751 Factors for determining market value and that deductions (20–50%) may account for disadvantages of developing large blocks of land versus smaller plots. Referred to as authority supporting the range of permissible deductions; considered by the Court in analysing deduction quantum.
Land Acquisition Officer Revenue Divisional Officer, Chottor v. L. Kamalamma (Smt.) Dead by LRs and Ors., (1998) 2 SCC 385 Arrived at a deduction of 40% as just and proper for developmental cost. Included among authorities illustrating possible deduction levels; weighed in the Court's determination of an appropriate deduction here.
Kasturi and others v. State of Haryana, (2003) 1 SCC 354 In respect of agricultural/undeveloped land with potential for housing, a normal deduction of 1/3rd (approx. 33%) may be made depending on facts; deduction may be more or less in particular cases. The Court relied on this authority to support the proposition that a 1/3rd deduction is a recognized norm and that deductions must be determined case-by-case.
Land Acquisition Officer, Kammarapally Village, Nizamabad District, A.P. v. Nookala Rajamallu and Ors., (2003) 12 SCC 334 Applied a deduction of 53% in that case. Mentioned to demonstrate the upper range of possible deductions; used in the precedential survey.
V. Hanutnantha Reddy (Dead) by LRs. v. Land Acquisition Officer and Mandal R. Officer, (2003) 12 SCC 642 Examined compensation; endorsed a deduction (approx. 37% in that case) as within acceptable limits in context. Cited among examples showing different courts have approved varying deduction percentages depending on facts.
Viluben Jhalejar Contractor (Dead) By Lrs. v. State Of Gujarat, (2005) 4 SCC 789 Held that deductions for development could range between 20% and 50% of the total market price of the exemplar land. Used in the Court's review of authorities on permissible deduction ranges.
Attna Singh (Dead) through LRs and Ors. v. State of Haryana and Anr., (2008) 2 SCC 568 After reviewing authorities, concluded that deductions starting from 20% onwards could be made depending on facts. Included in the precedential context relied upon by parties and considered by this Court.
Lal Chand v. Union of India and Anr., (2009) 15 SCC 769 To determine market value of large tracts with potential, deductions varying between 20% and 75% of the price of small developed plots could be made. Referenced in the survey of authorities to show the wide possible range of deductions.
Subh Ram and Ors. v. State of Haryana and Anr., (2010) 1 SCC 444 Where valuation of large agricultural area is based on sale price of small developed plot, standard deductions of 1/3rd for infrastructure space and 1/3rd for developmental costs (total 2/3rds or ~67%) were indicated. Referred to by Chandrashekar and considered by this Court in assessing the GDA's argument for a high deduction.
Andhra Pradesh Housing Board v. K. Manohar Reddy and Ors., (2010) 12 SCC 707 Examined case law and concluded deductions could vary between 20% and 75%; in that case a deduction of 1/3rd was applied. Included as part of the authorities showing flexibility in deductions; used in the Court's reasoning.
Special Land Acquisition Officer and Anr. v. M.K. Rafiq Sahib, (2011) 7 SCC 714 In that case deduction made by High Court (50%) was increased to 60% by the Apex Court given the land's characteristics. Referred to illustrate that higher deductions have been applied depending on land's non-agricultural nature.
Special Land Acquisition Officer, Bangalore v. T. Adhinarayan Setty, AIR 1959 SC 429 Court must ascertain market value of land on the date of notification under Section 4(1); various methods of valuation exist including expert opinion and bona fide transactions in adjacent lands. Referred to by this Court as foundational authority on the correct date and methods for valuation.
M/s. Printer House Private Limited v. Saiyadan, AIR 94 SC 1160; P. Ram Reddy and others v. Land Acquisition Officer, Hyderabad UDA (1995) Discussed principles for determining market value and admissibility of registered documents. Referenced alongside other authorities to explain valuation principles to be applied on the date of Section 4 notification.
Atma Singh v. State of Haryana, (2008) 2 SCC 568 Discussed principles for valuation of market value including building potentiality on date of Section 4 notification. Used to support the settled law that building potentiality as of Section 4 notification is critical for valuation.
State of Haryana v. Gurbax Singh (Dead) by LRs and Anr., 2008 (11) SCC 65 Commercial potentiality of land is an important factor in deciding compensation. Referred to support the view that commercial potential and location matter for enhanced compensation.
Mummidi Apparao (Dead) through LRs. v. Nagarjuna Fertilizers and Chemicals Limited and another, 2009 (4) SCC 402 Emphasized location, development around, and potential for conversion into housing sites as factors in valuation. Relied upon in the Court's survey establishing factors that support an enhanced valuation for land in developed/fast-developing areas.
General Manager, Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited v. Rameshbhai Jivanbhai Patel and another, 2008 (14) SCC 745 Increase in land prices depends on situation, surrounding development, availability of land, and demand; urban/semi-urban areas show faster escalation. Used to support the finding that proximity to development and demand justify higher compensation in appropriate cases.
National Thermal Power Corporation Limited and others v. Om Prakash and others (Faridabad Gas Power Project), 2009 (4) SCC 719 Close vicinity of planned development area is a factor in fixation of higher compensation. Referred to as supporting authority for granting higher compensation where land is near planned development.
Baburam and others v. State of U.P., AIR 1980 All 324 Observed that determination of compensation is not an exact science and involves elements of judgment and "guess work". Quoted by the Reference Court (and noted by this Court) to underscore the discretionary and fact-specific nature of valuation.
Khazan and others v. State of U.P. and others (First Appeal No. 564 of 1997); Raghuraj Singh and others v. State of U.P. and others (First Appeal No. 1056 of 1999) High Court decisions (Division Benches) granting compensation at `297/ per sq. yard for adjoining villages in Tehsil Dadri. This Court referred to and followed those Division Bench decisions and comparable subsequent decisions to award `297/ per sq. yard to the present claimants by parity.
Amor Singh and another v. State of U.P. and others (First Appeal No. 644 of 2012) Applied earlier High Court Division Bench precedents and enhanced compensation to `297/ per sq. yard for adjacent areas. Referred to as part of a line of decisions that supported awarding `297/ per sq. yard to similarly placed landowners.
Harbhajan Kumar and others v. Collector, Land Acquisition and another (Civil Appeal No. 6775 of 2013) Apex Court extended benefit of enhanced compensation granted in a previous similar Civil Appeal. Noted to show that enhanced awards in earlier similar matters were extended in appeal, supporting parity in the present batch.
First Appeal No. 336 of 1998 (judgment dated 23.5.2014) and First Appeal No. 34 of 2007, Ganeshi Singh and others v. State of U.P. (judgment dated 9.5.2008) Hold that landowners in subsequent notifications are entitled to at least the same rate of compensation as similarly placed landowners in earlier notifications when brought to the Court's notice. The Court applied the parity principle drawn from these Division Bench decisions to justify awarding `297/ per sq. yard to the present claimants.
Satish Takural v. State (L.A.R. No. 495 of 1990) — Exhibit Paper No. 37-Ga Reference Court judgment fixing value (after 20% deduction) at `138/ per sq. yard for land acquired in 1982. Claimants urged that this prior Reference Court determination supported enhancement; the opinion notes this exhibit but the Court's final resolution relied primarily on parity with other Division Bench awards to reach `297/.
Mohinder Singh and others v. State of Haryana, (2014) 8 SCC 897 Held that a deduction of 40% by the High Court was unjustified and that a deduction of 1/4th of market value by the Reference Court was appropriate. Claimants relied on this to oppose large deductions; the Court noted the authority as supportive of the position that large uniform deductions are not always justified.
Charan Dass v. H.P. Housing and Urban Development Authority, (2010) 13 SCC 398 Observed that deductions should be based on situation of the land and need for development; where land is amid developed area with amenities, a 40% deduction may not be justified. Referred to by this Court to support the proposition that deduction quantum depends on surrounding development and facts of each case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded through the following analytical steps, drawing strictly on the materials and findings recorded in the opinion:

  1. Procedural matters and substitution: The Court allowed substitution applications for deceased appellants/claimants (their legal heirs) after condoning any delay and directed substitution to take place during the day.
  2. Recitation of facts: The Court set out the acquisition timeline (Section 4(1) notification, Section 6(1) notification, dates of possession), the SLAO award (`50/ per sq. yd) and the Reference Court awards (enhancement to `90/ per sq. yd and grants of solatium and interest), and identified that all claimants were affected by the same Notification.
  3. Reference Court's issues and findings: The Reference Court had framed five issues. It found SLAO's award inadequate, enhanced compensation to `90/ per sq. yd, decided issues 2 and 3 in claimant's favour (not pressed by appellants), and awarded solatium (30%) and additional and continuing interest at stated rates.
  4. Consideration of GDA's primary objections: The Court recorded GDA's contentions (acceptance without protest, interpolation in protest entries, rejection of certified exemplars, improper reliance on builders' sale deeds, inconsistency in Reference Court orders, and the argument that a much larger deduction—up to 70%—should be applied). The Court evaluated these contentions against the record and law presented.
  5. Examination of evidentiary and valuation issues: The Court noted the claimants' reliance on oral evidence (PW 1's statement of `500/ per sq. yd potential in 1987), replication material, and an earlier Reference Court judgment (Satish Takural). The Court reviewed settled principles on valuation: market value is to be ascertained on the date of Section 4(1) notification, and building potentiality and surrounding development are relevant factors.
  6. Survey of authorities on permissible deductions: The Court extensively cited and summarized Supreme Court and High Court authorities (including Chandrashekar and numerous cases discussed therein) demonstrating that deductions for development costs are highly fact-specific and can range widely (examples in the opinion ranged from about 20% up to 75% depending on circumstances).
  7. Application of precedents and parity: Rather than adopt the GDA's request for a large deduction, the Court placed emphasis on a line of Division Bench decisions in this Court relating to adjoining or similarly situated areas (multiple First Appeal decisions that awarded `297/ per sq. yd). The Court considered location and surrounding development: proximity to Delhi (about 2 km from Delhi border), adjacency to Mohan Nagar-Delhi Link Road and National Highway, industrial areas and residential schemes, and municipal limits having already been extended over the acquired Khasra plots.
  8. Conclusion on deduction quantum: Considering the factual matrix (including municipal limits and surrounding development), the Court found no merit in GDA's contention for increasing the deduction to 70% (or 75%) and held the Reference Court's 33% deduction to be fully justified in the present case.
  9. Remedial outcome: Applying parity with earlier Division Bench orders and weighing the valuation factors and precedents, the Court enhanced the compensation payable to the claimants to `297/ per sq. yd and directed payment of enhanced compensation with statutory dues (solatium, interest, etc.) within three months of receipt of certified copy of the order. The GDA appeals were dismissed; the claimants' appeals for enhancement were allowed.
  10. Ancillary directions: Defective appeals with court-fee deficiencies were to have any deficiency recovered/adjusted according to rules while preparing the final decree; all pending applications were disposed of; parties were directed to bear their own costs.

Holding and Implications

Holding (core ruling):

The appeals filed by the Ghaziabad Development Authority are dismissed; the appeals filed by the claimants/land losers for enhancement are allowed.

Immediate consequences for the parties:

  • The claimants are awarded compensation at the rate of `297 per square yard for the land acquired by the relevant notification.
  • The claimants are to be paid the enhanced compensation together with other statutory dues (including solatium and interest as directed by the Reference Court) within three months from receipt of a certified copy of the order.
  • Deficiencies in court-fees for defective appeals are to be recovered/adjusted in accordance with rules when preparing the final decree.
  • All pending applications are disposed of and parties shall bear their own costs.

Broader legal implications: The Court's decision applies and synthesizes existing precedent (as summarized in the opinion) and applies the principle of parity with earlier Division Bench awards in adjoining/similarly situated areas to fix compensation at `297/ per sq. yd. The opinion does not state that it creates a new legal precedent; it applies existing authorities and fact-specific valuation principles to the present batch of appeals.

Show all summary ...

Rajiv Sharma and Dinesh Gupta, JJ.

1. Heard Mr. Mahendra Pratap, learned Counsel for Ghaziabad Development Authority and Mr. D.P. Singh and Mr. Shiv Sagar Singh, learned Counsel for the claimants. At the outset, it is relevant to mention here that in some of the First Appeals, the appellants/claimants left for heavenly abode and as such, substitution applications were filed on their behalf for bringing on record their legal heirs. There is no objection to these applications. Accordingly, all the substitution applications are allowed, after condoning the delay, if any, in preferring the substitution applications.

2. Let them be substituted in place of claimants during the course of the day.

3. In short, the facts of the case are that the land of the claimants pertaining to the village Makanpur, Pargana Loni, Tehsil Dadri, District Ghaziabad was acquired by the State of U.P. for planned development by the Ghaziabad Development Authority [in short referred to as 'GDA']. The notification under Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act was issued on 12.9.1986, which was published, in the Gazette on 28.2.1987, whereas notification under Section 6(1) of the Act was issued on 24.2.1988. The possession of the land in question was taken by the State Government on 14.6.1988 and 29.6.1988. The Special Land Acquisition Officer (SLAO) pronounced the award on 30.12.1989 and granted compensation at the rate of ` 50/- per square yard relying on the exemplar of plot No. 582, area 5 Bigha executed on 28.9.1987 by one Smt. Amarjeet Kaur in favour of GDA @ ` 50/- per square yard. The respondents and other persons whose land was acquired had filed objections to the said determination of compensation by the SLAO and the matter was referred to the District Judge under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act. The IV Additional District Judge, Ghaziabad and VI Additional District Judge, Ghaziabad [hereinafter referred to as the "Reference Court"] passed separate awards dated 19.4.1999 and 31.5.2000, whereby the Reference Court enhanced the amount of compensation from ` 50/- per Square Yard to ` 90/- per square yard.

4. Feeling aggrieved, the GDA has filed the above-captioned first appeals description of which is given from Sl. Nos. 1 to 60. In contrast, Appeals mentioned at Sl. Nos. 61 to 96 have been filed by the tenure holders-claimants for enhancement of compensation and lowering the deductions from 33% made towards development cost.

5. Since the land of all claimants was acquired by the same Notification, facts pertaining to the said Notification apply to all these respondents. The only difference is in the area of land which was owned by these respondents and has been taken away by the State in acquisition. Therefore, taking general note of the particulars of acquisition and the nature of land, would serve the purpose.

6. From perusal of the impugned award dated 19.4.1999, it reflects that the Reference Court, on the basis of pleadings, had framed five issues, which are as under:

"(1) Whether the compensation awarded by S.L.A.O. is inadequate? If so to what amount of compensation are the petitioners entitled?

(2) Whether the reference is time barred?

(3) Whether the reference is barred by Section 9 of Land Acquisition Act?

(4) Whether the reference is barred by principles of estoppel?

(5) To what amount of compensation, if any, are the petitioners entitled?"

7. While deciding issue No. 1, the Reference Court had recorded specific findings of fact that the present claimants seem to be very unfortunate because the land of the same village was acquired for 'Avas Vikas Parishad' and NOIDA and those farmers got higher rates, while the land of present claimants acquired for GDA got less compensation. Some land of village Makanpur was acquired for NOIDA and partly acquired for Avas Vikas Parishad and the remaining part was acquired for GDA. Therefore, the Reference Court was of the view that the compensation awarded by the SLAO was inadequate and enhanced the compensation from ` 50/- to ` 90/- per square yard.

8. As the appellants have not pressed the issue Nos. 2 and 3, the Reference Court decided the said issues in favour of the claimants.

9. As regard issue No. 5, the Reference Court, after taking into consideration the totality of the circumstances, came to the conclusion that the claimants are entitled to get solatium @ 30% on the market rate and 12% per annum additional amount together with interest @ 9% per annum on the enhanced amount of compensation for the first year from the date of taking the possession and thereafter 15% per annum till the date of payment.

10. The main contention of the GDA is that the claimants accepted the compensation without protest and as such, it was not open for the tenure holders to file Reference under Section 18 of the Act. In this regard, he submits that on some applications, the word 'protest' was written by one different handwriting without signature appended thereto. Since there is an interpolation, it has to be considered that the claimants have accepted the compensation without protest.

11. Further, he submits that certified copies of sale exemplars, relied by the Collector, were produced before the Reference Court, but the Court concerned rejected the same for want of examination of witness. According to him, it is contrary to law as has been held by the Apex Court in P. Rama Reddy v. Special Land Acquisition Officer, 1995 (2) SCC 305. In this judgment, the Apex Court held that in any proceeding under this Act, a certified copy of a document registered under the Registration Act, 1908 (16 of 1908), including a copy given under section 57 of that act, may be accepted as evidence of the transaction recorded in such document.

12. While determining the compensation, the Reference Court relied on the sale deeds executed by the Tripati Builders in favour of Subhash Chand and Chandra Mohan. As the sale deeds were executed by the builders instead of the farmers, naturally the value of the land is on higher side and as such the same is liable to be set aside.

13. Next, he contended that in the impugned order dated 19.4.1999, the Reference Court determined the compensation as ` 90/- per sq. yard, after deducting 33% from ` 135/-, whereas in the impugned order dated 31.5.2000, the Reference Court fixed the compensation as ` 90/- per square yard without any deduction. Since there is variance in determination of compensation, this Court's interference is required in setting aside the impugned order.

14. Lastly, it has been vehemently contended by the Counsel for the GDA that the Reference Court erred in deducting 33% towards development cost overlooking the fact that the large chunk of land was acquired and sufficient land was to be left for internal developments, like road, sewerage, overhead water tank, water lines, parks, etc. According to him, deduction of at least 70% should have been allowed. To substantiate the aforesaid assertion, reliance has been placed upon Chandrashekar (D) by LRs and others v. Land Acquisition Officer and another, AIR 2012 SC 446. In para 15 of the report, it has been observed by the Apex Court as under:-

"15. The present controversy calls for our determination on the quantum of the deductions to be applied, to the market value assessed on the basis of the exemplar sale transaction, so as to ascertain the fair compensation payable to the land loser. The only factual parameters to be kept in mind are, the factual inferences drawn in the foregoing paragraph. On the issue in hand, we shall endeavor to draw our conclusions from past precedent. In the process of consideration hereinafter, we have referred to all the judgments relied upon by the learned Counsel for the appellants, as well as, some recent judgments on the issue concerned:

(i) In Brigadier Sahib Singh Kalha and Ors. v. Amritsar Improvement Trust and Ors., (1982) 1 SCC 419, this Court opined, that where a large area of undeveloped land is acquired, provision has to be made for providing minimum amenities of town-life. Accordingly it was held, that a deduction of 20 percent of the total acquired land should be made for land over which infrastructure has to be raised (space for roads etc.). Apart from the aforesaid, it was also held, that the cost of raising infrastructure itself (like roads, electricity, water, underground drainage, etc.) need also to be taken into consideration. To cover the cost component, for raising infrastructure, the Court held, that the deduction to be applied would range between 20 percent to 33 percent. Commutatively viewed, it was held, that deductions would range between 40 and 53 percent.

(ii) Noticing the determination rendered by this Court in Brigadier Sahib Singh Kalha's case (supra), this Court in Administrator General of West Bengal v. Collector, Varanasi, (1988) 2 SCC 150, upheld deduction of 40 percent (from the acquired land) as had been applied by the High Court.

(iii) In Chimanlal Hargovinddas v. Special Land Acquisition Officer, Poona and Anr., (1988) 3 SCC 751, while referring to the factors which ought to be taken into consideration while determining the market value of acquired land, it was observed, that a smaller plot was within the reach of many, whereas for a larger block of land there was implicit disadvantages. As a matter of illustration it was mentioned, that a large block of land would first have to be developed by preparing its lay out plan. Thereafter, it would require carving out roads, leaving open spaces, plotting out smaller plots, waiting for purchasers (during which the invested money would remain blocked). Likewise, it was pointed out, that there would be other known hazards of an entrepreneur. Based on the aforesaid likely disadvantages it was held, that these factors could be discounted by making deductions by way of allowance at an appropriate rate, ranging from 20 percent to 50 percent. These deductions, according to the Court, would account for land required to be set apart for developmental activities. It was also sought to be clarified, that the applied deduction would depend on, whether the acquired land was rural or urban, whether building activity was picking up or was stagnant, whether the waiting period during which the capital would remain locked would be short or long; and other like entrepreneurial hazards.

(iv) In Land Acquisition Officer Revenue Divisional Officer, Chottor v. L. Kamalamma (Smt.) Dead by LRs and Ors., (1998) 2 SCC 385, this Court arrived at the conclusion, that a deduction of 40 percent as developmental cost from the market value determined by the Reference Court would be just and proper for ascertaining the compensation payable to the landowner.

(v) In Kasturi and others v. State of Haryana, (2003) 1 SCC 354, this Court opined, that in respect of agricultural land or undeveloped land which has potential value for housing or commercial purposes, normally 1/3rd amount of compensation should be deducted, depending upon the location, extent of expenditure involved for development, the area required for roads and other civic amenities etc. It was also opined, that appropriate deductions could be made for making plots for residential and commercial purposes. It was sought to be explained, that the acquired land may be plain or uneven, the soil of the acquired land may be soft and hard, the acquired land may have a hillock or may be low lying or may have deep ditches. Accordingly, it was pointed out, that expenses involved for development would vary keeping in mind the facts and circumstances of each case. In Kasturi's case (supra) it was held, that normal deductions on account of development would be 1/3rd of the amount of compensation. It was however clarified that in some cases the deduction could be more than 1/3rd and in other cases even less than 1/3rd.

(vi) Following the decision rendered by this Court in Brigadier Sahib Singh Kalha's case, this Court in Land Acquisition Officer, Kammarapally Village, Nizamabad District, A.P. v. Nookala Rajamallu and Ors., (2003) 12 SCC 334, applied a deduction of 53 percent, to determine the compensation payable to the landowners.

(vii) In V. Hanutnantha Reddy (Dead) by LRs. v. Land Acquisition Officer and Mandal R. Officer, (2003) 12 SCC 642, this Court examined the propriety of compensation determined as payable to the land loser by the High Court. The Reference Court had determined the market value of developed land at ` 78 per sq. yard. The Reference Court then applied a deduction of 1/4th to arrive at ` 58 per sq. yard as the compensation payable. The High Court however concluded, that compensation at ` 30 per sq. yard would be appropriate (this would mean a deduction of approximately 37 percent, as against market value of developed land at ` 78 per sq. yard). This Court having made a reference to Kasturi's case (supra) did not find any infirmity in the order passed by the High Court. In other words, deduction of 37 percent was approved by this Court.

(viii) In para 21 of the judgment in Viluben Jhalejar Contractor (Dead) By Lrs. v. State Of Gujarat., (2005) 4 SCC 789, it was held that for development, i.e., preparation of lay out plans, carving out roads, leaving open spaces, plotting out smaller plots, waiting for purchasers, and on account of other hazards of an entrepreneur, the deduction could range between 20 percent and 50 percent of the total market price of the exemplar land.

(ix) In Attna Singh (Dead) through LRs and Ors. v. State of Haryana and Anr., (2008) 2 SCC 568, this Court after making a reference to a number of decisions on the point, and after taking into consideration the fact that the exemplar sale transaction was of a smaller piece of land concluded, that deductions of 20 percent onwards, depending on the facts and circumstances of each case could be made.

(x) In Lal Chand v. Union of India and Anr., (2009) 15 SCC 769, it was held that to determine the market value of a large tract of undeveloped agricultural land (with potential for development), with reference to sale price of small developed plot(s), deductions varying between 20 percent to 75 percent of the price of such developed plot(s) could be made.

(xi) In Subh Ram and Ors. v. State of Haryana and Anr., (2010) 1 SCC 444, this Court opined, that in cases where the valuation of a large area of agricultural or undeveloped land was to be determined on the basis of the sale price of a small 12 developed plot, standard deductions ought to be 1/3rd towards infrastructure space (areas to be left out for roads etc.) and 1/3rd towards infrastructure developmental costs (costs for raising infrastructure), i.e., in all 2/3rd (or 67 percent).

(xii) In Andhra Pradesh Housing Board v. K. Manohar Reddy and Ors., (2010) 12 SCC 707, having examined the existing case law on the point it was concluded, that deductions on account of development could vary between 20 percent to 75 percent. In the peculiar facts of the case a deduction of 1/3rd towards development charges was made from the awarded amount to determine the compensation payable.

(xiii) In Special Land Acquisition Officer and Anr. v. M.K. Rafiq Sahib, (2011) 7 SCC 714, this Court after having concluded, that the land which was subject matter of acquisition was not agricultural land for all practical purposes and no agricultural activities could be carried out on it, concluded that in order to determine fair compensation, based on a sale transaction of a small piece of developed land (though the acquired land was a large chunk), the deduction made by the High Court at 50 percent, ought to be increased to 60 percent."

15. According to the GDA, if the aforesaid case laws are applied to the instant case, deduction of 70% would serve the purpose.

16. In contrast, learned Counsel for the claimants submits that the compensation is totally based on situation of the land and he has drawn our attention towards the replication filed by Trilok Chand and others [paras 3 to 6 of the replication]. Further, he has relied upon the oral statement of Sri Krishna Tyagi (PW 1), who has stated that if the land was not acquired, he could have easily sold the land in the year 1987 at the rate of ` 500/- per square yard in open market. By no stretch of imagination, the valuation of the land acquired can be said to be ` 135/- per square yard less 33% equivalent to ` 90/- per square yard, as held by the Reference Court. Suffice to say that the valuation of the land should have been fixed by the Reference Court something between ` 135/- per square yard to ` 500/- per square yard in view of the statement of PW 1 Krishna Tyagi.

17. Next, he contended that the Reference Court has not considered the Exhibit Paper No. 37-Ga, the judgment of the Reference Court dated 27.5.1993 passed in L.A.R. No. 495 of 1990 in the case of Satish Takural v. State, wherein the Reference Court had determined the value of the land after 20% deduction at the rate of ` 138/- per square yard for the land which was acquired on 26.6.1982, whereas in the instant case the land in question was acquired in the year 1987 and the Reference Court determined the value of the land as ` 90/- per square yard. Therefore, the claimants are entitled for enhancement of compensation.

18. Before concluding his submissions, he has relied upon the case of Mohinder Singh and others v. State of Haryana, (2014) 8 SCC 897, wherein the Apex Court held that the deduction of 40% towards development cost as determined by the High Court was unjustified and the deduction of 1/4th of market value made by the Reference Court was appropriate.

19. Next he has drawn our attention towards the findings of Reference Court, wherein it has been stated that the Hon'ble Court in the case of Baburam and others v. State of U.P., reported in AIR 1980 All 324, has observed that determining compensation is not an exact science. The question of fair compensation is not algebraic problem which could be solved by abstract formula. There is an element of guess work inherent in most cases involving determination of market value of the acquired land.

20. As regard the assertion of the GDA's Counsel that the claimants had accepted compensation without protest and as such, the Reference was not maintainable, we would like to mention that while deciding issue No. 4, the Court below recorded a finding of fact that if the claimants have received the amount of compensation under protest then it cannot be said that they are estopped and cannot raise the plea for enhancement of compensation. In other words, if some of the claimants have received their amount without protest, then they cannot be estopped because mere filing of reference amounts to protest.

21. Before dealing with the controversy involved in the present batch of appeals, it would be apt to refer some of the relevant cases of the Apex Court and this Court on the subject, for proper adjudication of the matter.

22. In Special Land Acquisition Officer, Bangalore v. T. Adhinarayan Setty, AIR 1959 SC 429, it was held that in awarding compensation under the Act, the Court has to ascertain market-value of the land on the date of notification under Section 4(1) of the Act. It was also observed that there are several methods of valuation, such as (1) opinion of experts, (2) the price paid within a reasonable time in bona fide transactions of purchase of the land acquired or the lands adjacent to the lands acquired and possessing similar advantages, and (3) a number of years purchase of the actual or immediately prospective profits of the land acquired.

23. Hon'ble Supreme Court in the cases of M/s. Printer House Private Limited v. Saiyadan, reported in AIR 94 SC 1160, and P. Ram Reddy and others v. Land Acquisition Officer, Hyderabad Urban Development Authority, reported in 1995 All India Acquisition and Compensation Cases 184 and Atma Singh v. State of Haryana, (2008) 2 SCC 568, has discussed the principles on the basis of which the market value has to be determined. It is now settled law that the building potentiality of the acquired land existing on the date of notification under Sub-section (1) of Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, is the correct market value of the acquired property, which has to be judged on consideration of various factors and material which are brought on the record and such building potentiality is not only to be judged merely on the basis of its existing value but also after taking into consideration the future advantages.

24. In 2008 (11) SCC 65 : 2008 (4) Supreme 174 State of Haryana v. Gurbax Singh (Dead) by LRs. and Anr. etc. it has been considered by the Supreme Court that commercial potentiality of the land is important factor for deciding compensation.

25. Again in 2009 (4) SCC 402 Mummidi Apparao (Dead) through LRs. v. Nagarjuna Fertilizers and Chemicals Limited and another, the Supreme Court has given an emphasis over the location and development all around and its full potential value of developing into housing sites and fast taking up the character. In 2008 (14) SCC 745 General Manager, Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited v. Rameshbhai Jivanbhai Patel and another, the Supreme Court held that primarily, the increase in land prices depends on four factors: situation of the land, nature of development in surrounding area, availability of land for development in the area, and the demand for land in the area. In rural areas, unless there is any prospect of development in the vicinity, increase in prices would be slow, steady and gradual, without any sudden spurts or jumps. On the other hand, in urban or semi-urban areas, where the development is faster, where the demand for land is high and where there is construction activity all around, the escalation in market price is at a much higher rate as compared to rural areas. In 2009 (4) SCC 719 (Faridabad Gas Power Project, National Thermal Power Corporation Limited and others v. Om Prakash and others) close vicinity of the planned development area was determined as one of the factor for fixation of higher compensation. Thus, these judgments are supporting the contention of the land losers/tenure holders.

26. Thus, the relevant factors for determination of the amount of compensation are the nature and quality of land, whether irrigated or unirrigated, facilities for irrigation, presence of fruit bearing trees, location of the land, closeness to any road or highway, evenness of the land, existence of any building or structure and a host of other factors bearing on the valuation of the land. The learned Court below while determining the rate of compensation of the acquired land in his impugned order has considered all these relevant factors and also took into consideration the evidence adduced by the parties.

27. It may be noted that in bunch of First Appeals led by First Appeal No. 564 of 1997, Khazan and others v. State of U.P. and others, pertaining to adjoining villages of Bhangel Begumpur, Nagla and Geha Tilpatabad of Dadri Tehsil relating to land acquisition was decided by this Court granting compensation at the rate of ` 297/- per square yard, in terms of decision of this Court rendered in First Appeal No. 1056 of 1999, Raghuraj Singh and others v. State of U.P. and others.

28. Again this Court while dealing with a First Appeal No. 644 of 2012, Amor Singh and another v. State of U.P. and others, pertaining to adjacent Village Gejha Tilpatabad, followed the several judgments, passed by this Court including the judgment rendered in the bunch of First Appeals, led by First Appeal No. 564 of 1997, Khazan and others v. State of U.P. and others and this Court enhanced the compensation to ` 297/- per square yard.

29. Similarly, by means of a detailed and well-considered judgment dated 19.5.2010 passed in First Appeal No. 1056 of 1999, a Division Bench held that the claimants are entitled to compensation @ ` 297/- per square yard alongwith other statutory dues. In this case, the acquired land situates in Tehsil Dadri, District Ghaziabad. The enhancement of compensation to ` 297/- per square yard in respect of the land situates in village Bhangel Begumpur has been followed by another Division Bench in its judgment and order dated 11.10.2012 passed in First Appeal No. 564 of 1997.

30. The Apex Court in Civil Appeal No. 6775 of 2013 Harbhajan Kumar and others v. Collector, Land Acquisition and another while deciding similar Civil Appeal, extended the benefit of enhanced compensation made in previous Civil Appeal of similar nature.

31. Recently, a Coordinate Bench of this Court, following the aforesaid judgment, allowed the compensation to the tune of ` 297/- per square yard vide its judgment and order dated 23.5.2014 passed in First Appeal No. 336 of 1998.

32. We would like to point out that in First Appeal No. 34 of 2007, Ganeshi Singh and others v. State of U.P. and others decided on 9.5.2008, a Division Bench of this Court has held that the land owners of a particular land in a subsequent notification are entitled to at least the same rate of compensation as awarded to similarly placed land owners in an earlier notification when the same has been brought to the notice of the Court.

33. There is no dispute to the fact that the land in question falls within the territory of Tahsil Dadri and situates near Delhi, close to Hindan River on Mohan Nagar-Delhi Link Road surrounded by industrial area declared by U.P. government - Bharat Electricals, CEL, Dover and other well known units and Delhi-Lucknow National Highway and just 2 kms. away from Delhi border. On one side Vasundhara Residential Scheme developed by Avas Evam Vikas Parishad situates near to the developed Kaushambi Residential Colony. On the other side of the National Highway, the area known as NOIDA situates with all civic amenities on the acquired land.

34. As regards the potentiality of the land, the Reference Court has observed as under:-

"In the present case, at my hand, it is established by the evidence and may be noticed by the Court that the land situated at very important point from where Delhi boarder is about 2 kms. It is adjacent to link road, which leads from Mohan Nagar to Delhi and other side National High Way leads from Delhi to Lucknow. At some distance there is an Industrial Area having all the facilities. There are the surrounding circumstances on the basis of which it can be guessed that land in question has much potential value for the abadi purpose and it can also be noticed that subsequently the land was being sold at very high rates. The State acquired the land for G.D.A. to facilitate the people, but G.D.A. is not supposed to act in the manner like Property Dealer."

35. In the backdrop of the aforesaid facts, it would be highly prejudicial to the interest of the claimants/land losers to be deprived of such a rate when they are placed in similar circumstances. In our view, such an action would certainly be the arbitrariness and violative of constitutional mandate. Therefore, the claimants are entitled to ` 297/- per square yard in respect of the land acquired by the aforesaid notification.

36. As regard the deduction, it has been argued by the Counsel for GDA that 33% deduction is very low and in view of the decision rendered in Chandrasekhar's case (supra) it should be atleast 70%. On the contrary, claimants have argued that deduction @ 33% is highly excessive and wholly unjustified looking to the overall situation of the land and other evidence on record.

37. In Chandrashekhar's case ((supra)) which has been relied upon by the Counsel for the GDA the Court took into consideration the two components for deduction. The first component relates to area to be left out for providing basic amenities, like, roads, sewerage, water lines, adjoining pavements, street light, electric sub-stations etc. Besides the aforesaid, land has also to be kept apart for parks, gardens and playgrounds. Additional development includes provision of civic amenities, like educational institutions, dispensaries and hospitals, police stations, petrol pumps etc. The second component is deduction towards expenditure/expenses which is likely to be incurred in providing and raising the infrastructure and civic amenities referred to above.

38. At this juncture, we would like to point out that a Division Bench of this Court in Ganeshi Singh's case (supra) has held that there is no legal provision for the deduction from the amount of compensation under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. Various Courts normally pass such order of deduction on the subjective satisfaction of each case. Therefore, there is no hard and fast rule for making deductions.

39. It may be noted that learned Counsel for the GDA has failed to point out that before the Reference Court it has brought on record the indispensable amenities and civic amenities which they would provide on the acquired land. Further, when confronted with the question that whether they have demanded excess deduction, as claimed here, before the Reference Court, the answer was in negative and they failed to point out any material in this regard. Since no such plea has been raised at the initial stage, it is not open for them to raise such a plea before this Court at a belated stage.

40. The Apex Court in the case of Kasturi and others v. State of Haryana, (2003) 1 SCC 354, held that a cut of 20% to the development charges which was lower than the normal 1/3rd was understandable and could be justified. Subsequently, in Charan Dass v. H.P. Housing and Urban Development Authority, (2010) 13 SCC 398, the Apex Court observed that any deduction made should be made on the situation of the land and the need for development and where the acquired land is in the midst of already developed land with amenities of roads, drainage, electricity, etc. then deduction of 40% would not be justified.

41. Recently, in Mohinder Singh's case (supra), the Apex Court held that the deduction of 40% towards development cost as determined by the High Court was unjustified and the deduction of 1/4th of market value made by the Reference Court was appropriate.

42. It may be added that Counsel appearing in First Appeal No. 700 of 2002 has filed an application bringing on record the notification dated 7.11.1977 issued by the District Magistrate, Ghaziabad whereby the Khasra Plot acquired has been brought under municipal limits of Ghaziabad. Therefore, there is no doubt that the land in question of the claimants acquired for the Vaishali Scheme of Village Makanpur has already been brought under the limit of Nagar Palika before issuance of notification under the Land Acquisition Act.

43. In view of the location of land in municipal limits, nature of soil and other factors, referred to above, we find no force in the submissions made by the Counsel for the GDA for enhancing the deduction to the tune of 75% and held that 33% deduction made by the Reference Court is fully justified.

44. In view of the aforesaid detailed discussions, the appeals filed by the GDA are hereby dismissed and the appeals filed by the claimants/land losers for enhancement of the compensation are allowed. The claimants-private respondents shall be entitled for compensation @ ` 297/- per square yard, as held by us above and they shall be paid the enhanced compensation together with other statutory dues [like solatium, interest etc.], as directed by the Reference Court, within three months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.

45. So far defective appeals are concerned, any defect/s was/were deficiency of Court fees, it is directed that same will be recovered/adjusted in accordance with rules, while preparing final decree by the department.

46. All the pending applications shall also stand disposed of accordingly. Parties shall bear their own costs.

_____________