- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Manzoor Ahmed v. Jaggi Bai And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
A writ petition was filed challenging the order dated 5-03-2009 passed by the trial Court, which rejected an application filed by the defendants under Order 7, Rule 11 of the Civil Procedure Code. The defendants sought to reject the plaint on the grounds that the trial Court lacked pecuniary jurisdiction and that adequate Court fees had not been paid. The plaintiff had filed a suit for declaration of title and confirmation of possession, seeking to declare a sale deed dated 20th September 2007 as null and void, along with a prayer for permanent prohibitory injunction.
The plaintiff averred that she was the rightful owner (Bhumiswami) of the land, was 100 years old and disabled, and that the sale deed was fraudulently executed without her knowledge or consent under the pretext of processing a loan under the Kisan Credit Scheme. The plaintiff denied executing the sale deed or receiving any consideration. The defendants contended that the suit was not properly valued and that ad valorem Court fees were payable based on the sale deed's consideration of ₹2,29,000. The trial Court rejected the defendants' application, leading to the present writ petition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether ad valorem Court fees is required to be paid when the suit challenges a sale deed alleged to be void due to fraud.
- Whether a suit seeking a declaration that a sale deed is null and void requires consequential relief of cancellation of the deed for payment of ad valorem Court fees.
- The distinction between void and voidable documents in the context of Court fees liability.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The plaintiff is a party to the sale deed and therefore bound to pay ad valorem Court fees for consequential relief of cancellation of the deed.
- Relied on certain precedents to support the necessity of seeking cancellation relief and paying ad valorem Court fees.
Respondent's Arguments
- Supported the impugned order rejecting the application to dismiss the plaint for non-payment of ad valorem Court fees.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Pratap and another vs. Punia Bai and others, 1976 MPLJ 627 / 1976 JLJ 703 | Distinction between void and voidable documents for payment of ad valorem Court fees; relief of cancellation necessary only for voidable documents. | The Court relied on this precedent to hold that the sale deed was alleged to be void, thus no ad valorem Court fees was payable for cancellation relief. |
| Santoshchandra and others vs. Gyansunder Bai, 1970 JLJ 290 / 1970 MPLJ 363 (FB) | A party seeking to avoid an agreement must seek relief of setting aside the instrument; declaration alone is insufficient for voidable documents. | Referenced to distinguish the necessity of cancellation relief in voidable cases as opposed to void cases. |
| Sunderbai vs. Manohar Singh Yadav, 1974 JLJ Short Note 75 | Affirmed liability to pay ad valorem Court fees when seeking cancellation of a sale deed obtained by fraud. | Used to demonstrate that cancellation relief attracts ad valorem Court fees only if the document is voidable. |
| Manohar Singh Nathasingh vs. Parmeshwari and others, AIR 1949 Nag 211 | Determination of nature of suit (declaration vs. cancellation) depends on plaintiff's pleadings. | Applied to assess the nature of the present suit as seeking declaration of non-execution, not cancellation. |
| Secretary of State vs. Dadoo Ghanshyamsingh Gupta and others, AIR 1937 Nagpur 14 | Where declaratory relief is the substantial relief, the suit falls under section 7(iv)(c) of the Court Fees Act, exempting ad valorem fees. | Supported the conclusion that no ad valorem Court fees was payable as the suit was primarily declaratory. |
| Ashok Kumar Gehani and another vs. Ramhet Agrawal and another, 2008 (1) MPLJ 116 | Reiterated distinction between void and voidable documents for Court fees. | Relied upon to affirm the trial Court's order. |
| Smt. Sabina alias Farida vs. Mohd. Abdul Wasit, 1997 (1) MPLJ 554 / AIR 1997 MP 25 | Relief of injunction not consequential relief requiring ad valorem Court fees when based on possession. | Applied to note that injunction relief claimed was not a basis for ad valorem Court fees. |
| Johan Ram vs. Dasmat Bai, 1982 MPWN 464; Vibhuti Narain Singh vs. Municipal Board, AIR 1958 Allahabad 41; Bhupat Singha and others vs. Jnanendra Kumar Chowdhury and others, AIR 1955 Calcutta 341; Jatindra Nath Nandi and others vs. Krishnadhan Nandi and another, AIR 1953 Calcutta 34; Balram Mandal vs. Sahebjan and others, AIR 1950 Calcutta 85; Burjor Pestonji Sethna vs. Nariman Minoo Todiwala and others, AIR 1953 Bombay 382; Kalla Surayya and Sons represented by Kalla Venkataraju vs. Province of Madras, AIR 1949 Madras 778 | Various principles relating to Court fees and declaratory relief suits. | Cited to support the legal framework for Court fees in declaratory suits. |
| Shyamacharan Paul and another vs. Roopali Promoter and Construction (M/s) and others, 2009 (3) MPLJ 691 / 2009 (3) MPHT 113 | Where consequential relief of cancellation is necessary, declaration alone is insufficient; ad valorem Court fees payable. | Distinguished on facts; held not applicable to the instant case where document is void. |
| Mohammad Jameel Khan and others vs. Miththulal Khushal Singh Gujar, 1999 (1) MPLJ 37 | Ad valorem Court fees liability in suits involving cancellation of sale deeds. | Rejected by the Court as not applicable to void documents. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the nature of the plaintiff's suit and the allegations made in the plaint. The plaintiff claimed that the sale deed was obtained by fraud without her knowledge or consent and that no consideration was paid, effectively asserting that the document was void rather than voidable. The Court distinguished between void and voidable documents: a voidable document remains valid until set aside and thus requires consequential relief of cancellation, attracting ad valorem Court fees; whereas a void document is treated as never having existed, and a mere declaration suffices without the need for cancellation relief or ad valorem Court fees.
The Court relied on established precedents to reinforce that in cases where the document is alleged to be void ab initio, seeking cancellation is unnecessary and the suit falls within the ambit of declaratory relief attracting only nominal Court fees. The Court found that the plaintiff's pleadings indicated a void document, not a voidable one, and thus the requirement to pay ad valorem Court fees did not arise. The Court also distinguished the facts of the petitioner’s cited precedents, holding them inapplicable to the instant case.
Accordingly, the Court upheld the trial Court’s order rejecting the defendants’ application to dismiss the plaint on the ground of non-payment of ad valorem Court fees and lack of pecuniary jurisdiction.
Holding and Implications
The writ petition is dismissed.
The direct effect of this decision is the affirmation of the trial Court’s order rejecting the defendants’ application under Order 7, Rule 11 CPC. The plaintiff’s suit challenging the sale deed as void does not require payment of ad valorem Court fees for cancellation relief. No broader precedent beyond the facts of this case is established, and no costs were imposed.
Arun Mishra, J. :-
Writ petition has been filed as against order dated 5-03-2009 passed by the trial Court rejecting an application filed by the defendants under Order 7, Rule 11 of Civil Procedure Code to reject the plaint on the ground that trial Court was not having pecuniary jurisdiction; well as adequate Court fees was not paid.
2. The plaintiff respondent has filed the suit for declaration of title and confirmation of possession. Prayer has also been made to declare the sale deed dated 20th September, 2007 as null and void. Prayer for permanent prohibitory injunction has also been made.
3. Plaintiff has averred that plaintiff is the Bhumiswami of the land in question. Her age is 100 years, she is disabled also. Plaintiff No. 2 is residing with her and looking after agricultural operation. Plaintiff wanted to obtain the loan under the Kisan Credit Scheme for improving fertility of the land. She was assured by the defendants that for performing formalities, she would have to sign certain documents. Under the guise of processing the papers of Kisan Credit Scheme, a sale deed was got executed which she had never executed. She has lodged objection on coming to know of the execution of sale deed and also lodged report at PS, Majhgawan. She has never sold the land and fraud was played. There was no question of receipt of consideration.
4. In the application filed under Order 7, Rule 11, Civil Procedure Code, it was submitted that suit has not been properly valued, ad valorem Court fees was required to be paid on consideration mentioned in the sale deed of 2,29,000. Trial Court has rejected the application, hence the petition.
5. Shri B.P. Sharma, learned counsel appearing for petitioner has submitted that it is necessary to seek consequential relief of cancellation of sale deed as the plaintiff is a party to the document, thus, she was bound to make the payment of ad valorem Court fees. He has referred to certai decisions to be referred later.
6. Shri Pushpraj Agrawal, learned counsel appearing for responded has supported the impugned order.
7. The main question for consideration is whether ad valorem Co fees is required to be paid. Document is shown to be void not avoidable Plaintiff has averred that she was never told about the sale deed which 1 been obtained by playing fraud. She never intended to execute the sale de she wanted to obtain the loan and taking the advantage of her advanced and disability, sale deed was obtained. No consideration was paid, averments made in the plaint indicate that document is shown to be void avoidable. There is difference in incident of payment of Court fees in i document is voidable at the instance of executant ad valorem Court fees is required to be paid, not in the case of void document in such cases injunction which has been prayed flows from the relief of declaration. In case of void document, it is not necessary to seek the relief of cancellation of document itself, it is only in the cases of voidable documents, it is necessary to claim I such a relief. This question was considered by this Court in Pratap and another i vs. Punia Bai and others, 1976 MPLJ 627 = 1976 JLJ 703 thus:-
"5. Learned counsel for the applicant relied mainly on the Full Bench decision of this Court in Santoshchandra and others vs. Gyansunder Bai, 1970 JLJ 290 = 1970 MPLJ 363 (FB). It was held in that case that where it is necessary for a plaintiff to avoid an agreement or a decree or a liability imposed, he must seek the relief of having that decree, agreement"instrument or liability set aside and he is not entitled to a declaration simpliciter in such cases. This decision was followed in Sunderbai vs. Manohar Singh Yadav, 1974 JLJ Short Note 75. In that case plaintiff had filed a suit for a declaration and for permanent injunction alleging that the sale deed in question was got executed by her by playing fraud. The plaintiff was held liable to pay an ad valorem Court fees under section 7 (c) of the Court Fees Act. From the aforesaid decisions it is clear that where a person who is party to an agreement or transaction and his allegation is that it is not binding on him because it was obtained by misrepresentation or fraud, it is necessary for him to seek the consequential relief of setting aside such agreement or transaction and as such the suit falls within the purview of section 7 (c) of the Court Fees Act. But the question of avoiding an agreement or an instrument arises only where it is voidable. If it is wholly void a mere declaration that it is so, is sufficient and it is not necessary for the plaintiff to seek the relief of setting aside something which has no existence in law. It is not necessary to ask for relief of setting aside an agreement or an instrument which is wholly void. 6. The question whether the suit is really one for a declaration with the consequential reliefer not has to be determined by looking to the pleadings of the plaintiff only, vide Manohar Singh Nathasingh vs. Parmeshwari and others, AIR 1949 Nag 211. If we carefully examine the allegations in the plaint it would appear that the case of the plaintiff is that she did not execute the sale deed in question, that she did not receive any consideration of the sale and that she was not a party to any document of sale. From these allegations it would appear that there was no sale at all and the plaintiff is merely seeking a declaration that she did not execute the sale deed in question and thus did not transfer any property to the defendants. As such it is not necessary for her to seek relief of setting aside the sale deed in question, because, as pointed out above, the question of seeking the relief of setting aside something which has no existence in law, does not arise. In such a case bare declaration would suffice.
7. Voidable transfer remains valid until avoided and therefore, it is necessary to avoid it by seeking the relief of setting it aside. But a transaction, which is avoidable initio, must be deemed to have never taken place. It is not to be regarded as an alienation which is perfect till it is set aside. There is a clear distinction between a fraudulent misrepresentation as to the character of a document and as to its contents. Where the misrepresentation is both as to contents as well as character of the document, the transaction is wholly void."
8. It depends upon the averments made in each case in the plaint whether ad valorem Court fees is payable or not. Court has to find out whether a transaction is alleged to be "void" or "voidable". In case of void document, it is not necessary to seek the relief of cancellation of document. Similar view was taken by Nagpur High Court in Secretary of State vs. Dadoo Ghanshyamsingh Gupta and others, AIR 1937 Nagpur 14. it has been laid down that if on averments made in the plaint, the substantial relief could not be other than one for a declaratory decree and it is coupled with another relief, which follows naturally in the wake of the declaration, then the case must be regarded as falling within the ambit of section 7 (iv) (c). This Court in Ashok Kumar Gehani and another vs. Ramhet Agrawal and another, 2008 (1) MPLJ116 has relied upon Pratap and another vs. Punia Bai and others (supra) and came to the similar conclusion. In Smt. Sabina alias Farida vs. Mohd. Abdul Wasit, 1997 (1) MPLJ 554 = AIR 1997 MP 25 relief of injunction was not consequential relief, it was claimed because of settled possession of plaintiff, thus, ad valorem Court fees was not required to be paid. In the instant case also plaintiff is claimed to be in possession, she is not claiming relief for possession, thus, it could not be said that ad valorem Court fees is required to be paid. When declaratory relief is the main relief has also been considered in Johan Ram vs. Dasmat Bai, 1982 MPWN 464, Vibhuti Narain Singh vs. Municipal Board, Allahabad, AIR 1958 Allahabad 41, Bhupat Singha and others vs. Jnanendra Kumar Chowdhury and others, AIR 1955 Calcutta 341, Jatindra Nath Nandi and others vs. Krishnadhan Nandi and another, AIR 1953 Calcutta 34, Balram Mandal vs. Sahebjan and others, AIR 1950 Calcutta 85, Burjor Pestonji Sethna vs. Nariman Minoo Todiwala and others, AIR 1953 Bombay 382 and in Kalla Surayya and Sons represented by Kalla Venkataraju vs. Province of Madras, represented by the Collector of East Godavari at Kakinada and another, AIR 1949 Madras 778.
9. Petitioner's counsel has relied upon Division Bench decision of this Court in Shyamacharan Paul and another vs. Roopali Promoter and Construction (M/s) and others, 2009 (3) MPLJ 691 = 2009 (3) MPHT113 in which on the averments made, it was held by Division Bench of this Court that consequential relief of cancellation of sale deed was necessary, declaration would not suffice. The ratio has no application on the facts of the instant case. Petitioner's counsel has also relied upon decision is Mohammad Jameel Khan and others vs. Miththulal Khushal Singh Gujar, 1999 (1) MPLJ 37. We are unable to subscribe to the aforesaid view as it is trite law that in the case of void document it is not necessary to seek the relief of cancellation of document. In our opinion, the order passed by the trial Court is proper in the facts of the instant case.
10. Resultantly, writ petition being devoid of merits deserves dismissal, same is hereby dismissed. No costs.
Petition dismissed.
Alert