Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Vadiga Amose v. Vadiga Anjaneyulu And Ors.

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Dec 12, 2013
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner filed a writ petition under Article 226 seeking a writ of mandamus to declare the Lok Adalat Award dated 20.8.2005 (passed by the fifth respondent in LAC No. 1049 of 2005 under Section 21 of the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987) illegal and void as being opposed to Articles 14, 19, 21 and 300A of the Constitution. The petitioner alleges that respondents 1 to 4 committed fraud on the court by suppressing joint family members and a partition settlement deed dated 13.4.2005.

Relevant factual averments in the petition: the petitioner claims to be the son of Emelamma and late Veeraswamy; petitioner and respondents 1–4 allegedly shared ancestral property and executed a partition deed dated 13.4.2005 in the presence of village elders; the petitioner says he leased his share to his brothers who paid rent until 2011 but stopped payments in May 2012. The petitioner learned of a suit and settlement in Lok Adalat and obtained the impugned award dated 20.8.2005, which he alleges was procured by fraud and suppression of the partition deed.

The third respondent filed a counter-affidavit denying the petitioner’s relationship to the family, alleging that the petitioner produced a fabricated partition deed and asserting the petitioner should approach a civil court rather than seek relief under Article 226. The writ petition was heard by the Court, arguments were heard from counsel for both sides, and the Court reserved and delivered a judgment dismissing the writ petition without expressing any opinion on the validity of the award and leaving open the petitioner’s option to approach a civil court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner, as an alleged third party to the proceedings before the Lok Adalat, can challenge the Lok Adalat Award by filing a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution.
  2. Whether the impugned Lok Adalat Award dated 20.8.2005 is vitiated by fraud or misrepresentation such that it can be set aside in extraordinary proceedings before this Court.
  3. Whether the petitioner is entitled to any share in the ancestral property by establishing his parentage (i.e., that he is the son of late Veeraswamy and Emelamma) and thereby obtain declaratory relief affecting the impugned award.
  4. What is the appropriate remedy for a third party who claims that an award/decree obtained by fraud affects his rights — extraordinary writ jurisdiction under Article 226 or a civil suit for declaration (including relief under Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963)?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner sought a writ of mandamus to declare the Lok Adalat Award of 20.8.2005 illegal, void and opposed to Articles 14, 19, 21 and 300A on the ground that respondents 1–4 colluded and obtained the award by suppressing the partition deed dated 13.4.2005 and other joint family members.
  • The petitioner asserted that he is the son of Emelamma and late Veeraswamy, that he and respondents 1–4 were joint Hindu family members with equal shares in ancestral property, and that the partition deed of 13.4.2005 confirms this.
  • Relying on authorities (including Kataru Anjamma; Union of India v. Ch. Gopalakrishna Murthy; Chilukuri Umadevi v. Kalidindi Vijaya Lakshmi), the petitioner argued that a Lok Adalat Award can be challenged where fraud is pleaded and that a third party can challenge such an award in appropriate cases.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents, through the third respondent's counter-affidavit, denied the petitioner’s parentage and relation to the family, asserting the petitioner is not the son of Veeraswamy and Emelamma and that he is not their brother.
  • The respondents alleged that the partition deed produced by the petitioner is fabricated and forged, and that the petitioner’s claims amount to perjury and fraud on the Court.
  • They contended that the petitioner has no right in the property and that, if aggrieved, he should approach the jurisdictional civil court rather than invoke writ jurisdiction under Article 226 to challenge the Lok Adalat Award.
  • Respondents relied on authorities (including Sri Durga Malleswara Educational Society v. D.L.S.A.) to argue that only parties to the settlement ordinarily can challenge an award by writ and that third parties are generally required to seek relief in civil courts except in limited circumstances.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kataru Anjamma v. Chairman, Lok Adalat Bench-cum-I Additional Senior Civil Judge, Guntur, 2011 (2) ALD 135 (DB) Held that challenge of a Lok Adalat award is impermissible when the petitioner’s conscious acceptance of the terms is not in doubt and there is no egregious fraud vitiating the award. The petitioner relied on this decision to support limiting interference with Lok Adalat awards where no clear fraud is shown. The Court considered this authority among others in assessing appropriateness of writ jurisdiction.
Union of India v. Ch. Gopalakrishna Murthy, 2011 (6) ALD 447 (DB) Recognises that a Lok Adalat award can be challenged on the ground of fraud played by one of the parties to the proceedings. The petitioner relied on this authority to support the proposition that fraud may permit challenge; the Court noted the principle but required prima facie evidence and factual enquiry before entertaining writ relief.
Chilukuri Umadevi v. Kalidindi Vijaya Lakshmi, 2010 (5) ALD 617 (DB) Holds that a third party to the suit can challenge a Lok Adalat award by filing a writ petition; in that case the Division Bench set aside the award and directed impleadment of the petitioners in the trial court. The petitioner invoked this case as directly supportive. The Court acknowledged the authority but treated it as a precedent that may be applied only in appropriate factual scenarios; it concluded that the present case requires detailed inquiry and is not fit for writ determination.
Sri Durga Malleswara Educational Society (Regd), Vijayawada v. D.L.S.A. (Lok Adalat), 2012 (4) ALD 27 (DB) : 2012 (3) ALT 211 (DB) Explains that a Lok Adalat award can be challenged by way of writ under Article 226 or 227 only by parties to the settlement and not by anyone else, except on very limited grounds such as absence of settlement or where compromise is vitiated by fraud or misrepresentation. Respondents relied on this decision. The Court treated it as authority limiting writ challenges by third parties and used the principle to support the conclusion that third parties should ordinarily seek relief in civil courts unless there is prima facie, cogent evidence of fraud.
Batchu Subba Lakshmi v. Sannidhi Srinivasulu, 2010 (1) ALD 277 (DB) : 2010 (1) ALT 483 (DB) Holds that ordinarily a third party cannot challenge a Lok Adalat award by writ; such third parties should institute a suit for declaration (including under Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963). It adds that extraordinary cases involving prima facie fraud or collusion may permit a writ petition, but factual complexity often makes a civil suit the preferable remedy. The Court relied on this authority to frame the standard for third-party challenges: absent prima facie evidence of fraud or in cases involving complex factual disputes, the appropriate forum is a civil court. This reasoning informed the Court's dismissal of the writ petition and direction to approach the civil court.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by addressing two interlinked questions: (a) whether the petitioner has locus to challenge the Lok Adalat Award in this writ petition, and (b) whether the petitioner has established prima facie entitlement (by proving parentage and relationship) to seek declaratory relief that would affect the award.

Key steps in the Court’s analysis:

  1. The Court observed that to claim a share in the property covered by the impugned award, the petitioner must establish that he is the son of Veeraswamy and Emelamma and the natural brother of the third respondent. The respondents' counter-affidavit specifically and unequivocally denied that relationship.
  2. The Court found that the issues raised (parentage, validity of the partition deed dated 13.4.2005, existence of fraud in obtaining the award) involve complicated, disputed questions of fact and are declaratory in nature. Those issues require detailed enquiry and a reasonable opportunity to both sides.
  3. The Court noted the legal character of a Lok Adalat award under Section 21 of the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987 — an award is deemed a decree of a civil court — and reiterated the established principle that a decree obtained by playing fraud on the court can be challenged by a third party by filing a suit for declaration.
  4. The Court reviewed precedents which collectively reflect a balance: while awards can be challenged for fraud, and in exceptional cases a third party may invoke writ jurisdiction, ordinarily a third party should seek relief by instituting a civil suit (including under Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act) unless there is prima facie evidence of fraud or collusion justifying extraordinary writ relief.
  5. Applying these principles to the present facts, the Court concluded that there was no basis to decide the complex factual and declaratory dispute in a writ petition; instead, the petitioner should approach the civil court for appropriate relief. The Court emphasized the need to avoid multiplicity of proceedings and to permit full factual enquiry.

Because a detailed factual enquiry was necessary to determine parentage, the validity of the partition deed and the allegations of fraud, the Court held that the writ forum was not the appropriate forum for resolving the lis raised by the petitioner.

Holding and Implications

WRIT PETITION DISMISSED.

Consequences and implications explicitly stated in the opinion:

  • The writ petition was dismissed without the Court expressing any opinion on the validity or otherwise of the impugned Lok Adalat award dated 20.8.2005.
  • The petitioner was advised that, if so advised, he may approach the civil court for appropriate relief as per law (including relief under Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963), so that the issues can be determined after appropriate factual enquiry.
  • There shall be no order as to costs.
  • Any miscellaneous petitions pending in the writ petition were ordered to stand closed.

The Court did not record or establish any finding on the merits of the fraud allegations or on the validity of the partition deed; it confined its decision to the procedural question of the appropriate forum and dismissed the writ petition on that basis.

Show all summary ...

1. This writ petition is filed seeking a writ of mandamus to declare the impugned Award dated 20.8.2005 passed by the fifth respondent in LAC No. 1049 of 2005 under Section 21 of the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987, as illegal, void and opposed to Articles 14, 19,21 and 300A of the Constitution of India, on the ground that respondents 1 to 4 played fraud on the Judiciary by suppressing the joint family members of late Veeraswamy and partition settlement deed dated 31.4.2005. The facts leading to filing of this writ petition, in brief, are as follows. The petitioner's mother by name Emelamma is the legally wedded wife of late Veeraswamy. The petitioner and third respondent are the sons of Emelamma and Veeraswamy. His mother went to her parents' house for second delivery in the year 1976. Taking advantage of the same, Veeraswamy high-handedly married his sister's daughter by name Rama Lakshmi, who is the second respondent herein. Respondents 1 and 4 are the sons of Veeraswamy and Rama Lakshmi. The petitioner and respondents have been residing jointly by enjoying the ancestral property admeasuring Acs.26.17 guntas in Survey No. 425, Acs. 12.27 guntas in Survey No. 427/A, and Acs.13.30 guntas including house bearing No. 3-9-8 with a vacant site of Ac. 1.00 situated at Guddimalla Village (Venkatagiri), Khammam Rural Mandal and District. All the properties are ancestral properties and the parties have equal shares. Venkataswamy died in the year 1999. Respondents 1, 2 and 4 are residing in the village. The petitioner, who is working in Police Department, is being transferred from one place to another place, as part of his job. At the time of filing the writ petition, he is working as Sub-Inspector of Police, Kushaiguda Police Station. The third respondent, who is his natural elder brother, is a Doctor in Kothagudem Town. The petitioner and respondents I to 4 have partitioned their joint family properties in the presence of village elders, as per partition deed dated 13.4.2005. The said document is signed by him and respondents 1 to 4. The petitioner leased out his share to his brothers and they used to pay Rs. 20,000/- per month towards rent till 2011. In the month of May, 2012, his brothers refused to pay the rents on the ground that he has no right in the property.

2. The petitioner came to know about filing of a suit and settlement of the same in Lok Adalat. He obtained certified copy of the impugned award dated 20.8.2005 passed by the fifth respondent. The respondents 1 to 4 together colluded and initiated the civil suit by playing fraud against the Court and obtained the impugned award behind his back by suppressing partition deed dated 13.4.2005. The impugned award passed by the fifth respondent is non est in the eye of law and it is liable to be set aside.

3. The third respondent filed counter-affidavit on behalf of all the respondents inter alia contending that the petitioner, by suppressing the factum of his birth, pleaded that he is the son of late Veeraswamy as if he was born through him. The petitioner has produced a fabricated and forged deed dated 13.4.2005 for getting an order in this writ petition. The said action is nothing but perjury and plying fraud on this Court and petitioner deserves to be punished for the said offence. The petitioner has no right to claim the property in question, as he has nothing to do with their family. It is absolutely false to state that the petitioner is the son of late Veeraswamy. If the petitioner has any grievance, he has to approach jurisdictional civil Court and he cannot invoke the jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The contention that the respondents 1 to 4 have obtained the impugned award by playing fraud on Court is false.

4. Heard Sri Mummaneni Sreenivasa Rao, learned Counsel for petitioner and Sri K. Chidambaram, learned Counsel for respondents 1 to 4.

5. The contention of learned Counsel for petitioner is that the only remedy available to him is to challenge Lok Adalat Award by invoking jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution. Per contra, learned Counsel for respondents 1 to 4 contended that the petitioner is no way related to respondents 1 to 4, and therefore, the writ petition is liable to be dismissed.

6. To substantiate the argument, learned Counsel for the petitioner relied upon three decisions of this Court. In Kataru Anjamma v. Chairman, Lok Adalat Bench-cum-I Additional Senior Civil Judge, Guntur, 2011 (2) ALD 135 (DB), it was held that challenge of the award passed in Lok Adalat is impermissible when consciousness of the petitioner in accepting the terms cannot be doubted and there is no egregious fraud vitiating the award. In Union of India v. Ch. Gopalakrishna Murthy, 2011 (6) ALD 447 (DB), the principle enunciated is that the award passed in Lok Adalat can be challenged on the ground of fraud played by one of the parties to the proceedings. In Chilukuri Umadevi v, Kalidindi Vijaya Lakshmi, 2010 (5) ALD 617 (DB), a Division Bench of this Court held that a third party to the suit can challenge the Lok Adalat Award by filing a writ petition. While holding so, the Division Bench set aside the Lok Adalat Award dated 14.2.2008 and directed the petitioners to move an application before the trial Court seeking their impleadment as party defendants in O.S. No. 1359 of 2006. The principle in the above case is applicable to the facts of the present case.

7. Learned Counsel for the respondent has drawn our attention to the following Division Bench decisions of this Court. In Sri Durga Malleswara Educational Society (Regd), Vijayawada v. D.L.S.A. (Lok Adalat), at Vijayawada, Krishna District, rep. by its Secretary, 2012 (4) ALD 27 (DB) : 2012 (3) ALT 211 (DB), the principle enunciated is that the award passed in a Lok Adalat can be challenged by way of writ petition under Article 226 or Article 227 of the Constitution of India only by parties to the settlement and not by any one else, on a very limited ground such as passing of award without settlement or that settlement or compromise itself is vitiated by fraud or misrepresentation.

8. In Batchu Subba Lakshmi v. Sannidhi Srinivasulu, 2010 (1) ALD 277 (DB) : 2010 (1) ALT 483 (DB), a Division Bench of this Court resolving the question, who can file writ petition challenging the Lok Adalat Award, in Paragraph 8, it was held as follows:

8. The parties to the compromise or settlement, which is the basis for award of Lok Adalat, no doubt entitled to challenge the award on any of the grounds referred to herein above grounds. Ordinarily, a third party cannot challenge the award in a writ petition even if such award causes prejudice. The remedy of such party would be to institute a separate suit or proceeding for necessary redressal and seek appropriate decree of declaration by filing a suit within the period of limitation prescribed under law. Under Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963, any person entitled to legal character or any right as to any property, may file a suit for declaration. Under this provision, any person can even institute a suit for declaration that the decree passed by civil Court in an earlier suit is not binding on him. When a civil Court can even declare that an earlier decree of the Court is not binding on the party before it, we do not see any objection for a third party to institute a suit in a civil Court seeking a declaration that the award of Lok Adalat is not binding on him/her subject to the law of limitation. We however hasten to add that there may be extraordinary cases where a third party is meted with injustice at the behest of two or more conniving and colluding parties, who may have obtained an award of Lok Adalat by fraud or misrepresentation only to defeat the rights of such third party. In such cases within a reasonable period such third party may maintain a writ petition. But in such cases, there should be prima facie evidence of fraud or misrepresentation or collusion in obtaining the award of Lok Adalat. Even if such allegations are made and the question involves complicated questions of fact requiring voluminous evidence, third party should be left to seek remedy in a civil Court rather than preferring extraordinary remedy under Article 226 of the Constitution.

9. The case of the petitioner is that himself and respondents 1 to 4 constitute joint Hindu family and therefore, he is entitled to the share in the ancestral property. His further contention is that respondents 1 to 4 obtained the Award, by playing fraud, in order to deprive his right over the property under the Award.

10. In order to claim a share in the property covered under the impugned award, petitioner has to establish that he is the son of Veeraswamy and Emelamma and natural brother of the third respondent. On behalf of the respondents, third respondent filed counter-affidavit specifically denying that the petitioner is not son of Veeraswamy and Emelamma. The third respondent, in unequivocal terms, denied that he is own brother of the petitioner. As per the averments in the counter-affidavit, the petitioner is no way related to the respondents 1 to 4. Various contentions raised, in this writ petition, require a detailed enquiry by affording a reasonable opportunity to both parties. The legality or otherwise of partition deed dated 13.4.2005 cannot be decided, without establishing relationship between the parties. The lis involved in this writ petition is declaratory in nature apart from complexity of disputed facts.

11. An award passed under Section 21 of the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987, is deemed to be a decree of civil Court. A decree obtained by playing fraud on the Court can be challenged by a third party to the suit by filing a suit for declaration. In order to avoid multiplicity of proceedings and to put an end to the litigation once for all, the best course open to the petitioner is to approach jurisdictional civil Court for redressal.

12. Having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case and the principle enunciated in the cases cited supra, we are of the considered view that the lis involved cannot be decided in a writ petition. However, the petitioner, if so advised, may approach the civil Court for appropriate relief as per law.

13. Without expressing any opinion with regard to validity or otherwise of the impugned award, the writ petition is dismissed There shall be no order as to costs. Consequently, miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in this writ petition shall stand closed.

________________