Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ashrafi And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Apr 11, 2013
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The judgment consolidates numerous special leave petitions and civil appeals from the States of Punjab, Haryana, Madhya Pradesh, Andhra Pradesh and the Union Territory of Chandigarh. All matters concern claims for enhancement of compensation for lands acquired under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. Most petitions arise from the State of Haryana, covering acquisitions in districts such as Faridabad, Ambala, Hisar, Sonepat, Kurukshetra and Fatehabad, made under different Section 4 notifications between 1981 and 1993.

Separate representative matters were selected (e.g., Ashrafi, Sailak Ram, Surinder Kumar, Manohar Lal Khurana, Atam Singh, Sucha Singh, Mukesh Kumar, and Manohar Singh) so that the rulings would govern hundreds of tagged petitions listed in the judgment. The High Court had generally fixed compensation at a flat rate of Rs 235 per square yard irrespective of land type. Both landowners and State authorities challenged these awards, leading to the present batch decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. What is the just and proper market value to be awarded for the acquired lands in the different districts, having regard to comparable sales, potentiality, and escalation in land prices?
  2. Whether annual escalation should be calculated at 12% on a flat basis or on a cumulative (compounded) basis when determining market value.
  3. What percentage deduction towards development charges is appropriate—particularly whether the uniform deductions of 40% or 60% applied by the High Court should be reduced to one-third.
  4. Whether the “belting system” adopted by the High Court for certain parcels was justified.

Arguments of the Parties

Landowners / Appellants

  • High Court awards (Rs 220–235 per sq yd) were far below comparable awards in closely situated villages (e.g., Rs 435, Rs 392.50, Rs 337.20 per sq yd).
  • Sale deeds and municipal auctions showed much higher prevailing rates; when adjusted by 12% per annum, proper compensation should reflect those figures (e.g., Sucha Singh asserted Rs 7,82,746 per acre).
  • Annual increase ought to be calculated cumulatively as recognised in ONGC v. Rameshbhai Jivanbhai Patel.
  • Deductions of 40%–60% toward development were excessive because many acquired lands were already within developed municipal limits; one-third would be appropriate.
  • The belting system was arbitrary where the entire acquisition shared similar potential and location advantages.

State of Haryana / HUDA

  • Large-scale acquisitions involved mostly undeveloped agricultural land; small sale instances (≈60 sq yd) near main roads could not represent bulk market value.
  • Deductions of up to 40% (or 60% in some cases) were justified to convert raw land into buildable plots.
  • Escalation at a flat 12% was reasonable; cumulative compounding overstated values.
  • Purpose of acquisition cannot inflate compensation; Section 24 bars consideration of increased value from the proposed use (citing Subh Ram).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Haryana v. Gurbax Singh (2008) 11 SCC 65 Accepted enhancement by adding 12% per annum for two years. Used to justify upward revision of compensation in parity with other awards.
Union of India v. Harinder Pal Singh (2005) 12 SCC 564 Same 12% annual enhancement principle. Cited within Gurbax Singh to support applying annual escalation.
ONGC Ltd. v. Rameshbhai Jivanbhai Patel (2008) 14 SCC 745 Escalation in urban/semi-urban land prices may require cumulative calculation; annual increases can be 30–50% in developed pockets. Court adopted cumulative 12% increase and rejected flat calculation for certain cases (e.g., Mukesh Kumar).
Udho Dass v. State of Haryana (2010) 12 SCC 51 12% increase often inadequate given astronomical rise; noted potential 100% yearly rise. Relied on to reconsider adequacy of 12% and magnitude of deductions.
Charan Dass v. H.P. Housing & Urban Dev. Authority (2010) 13 SCC 398) Deduction must depend on existing development; one-third cut not justified where amenities already exist. Supported reducing deduction from 40%/60% to 33-1/3% for lands within municipal limits.
Haridwar Dev. Authority v. Raghubir Singh (2010) 11 SCC 581 Deduction towards development may vary 20%–75% based on circumstances. Cited to calibrate appropriate deduction to one-third.
Kasturi v. State of Haryana (2003) 1 SCC 354 Confirmed normal one-third deduction; allowed 20% in peculiar facts. Bench compared and preferred one-third deduction over higher cuts.
Subh Ram v. State of Haryana (2010) 1 SCC 444 Percentage of deduction unrelated to purpose of acquisition; Section 24 bars considering future use value. Relied on by State; Court acknowledged but still moderated deduction to 33-1/3%.
Kanta Devi v. State of Haryana (2008) 15 SCC 201 Where land abuts developed area, 70% deduction excessive; 60% reasonable. Used as illustration that very high deductions may be unwarranted.
Saibanna v. Commr. & LAO (2009) 9 SCC 409 Deduction should ordinarily not exceed one-third; 53% held excessive. Bench applied same rationale to lower 60% deduction to one-third.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court undertook a district-wise examination, selecting illustrative appeals whose outcomes would bind the rest. Key steps in its analysis include:

  • Comparable Sales & Awards: The Court compared earlier judicial awards and registered sale deeds in the same villages to identify prevailing market rates. Where earlier awards (e.g., Rs 435 or Rs 392.50 per sq yd) existed for contiguous land, the bench found the High Court’s Rs 220–235 figure understated.
  • Annual Escalation: Relying on Rameshbhai Jivanbhai Patel, the Court held that escalation should be computed at 12% on a cumulative basis from the base year (date of Section 4 notification) rather than a simple flat addition, reflecting real-world compounding increases.
  • Uniform Rates with Limited Belting: The belting system was discarded where the entire block enjoyed similar location advantages. Instead, uniform rates (e.g., Rs 325 per sq yd) were fixed for those parcels.
  • Deductions for Development: High Court deductions of 40% and 60% were deemed excessive for lands already within or adjoining developed municipal areas. Applying precedents, the Court standardised deduction at 33-1/3% except where specifically varied.
  • Specific Valuations:
    • Ashrafi, Kamlesh Kumari, Sailak Ram: compensation raised to Rs 325 per sq yd.
    • Surinder Kumar (Ambala): fixed at Rs 180 per sq yd uniformly.
    • Atam Singh: Rs 100 per sq yd accepted.
    • Sucha Singh: after one-third deduction, Rs 7,25,000 per acre.
    • Mukesh Kumar & connected: cumulative 12% applied; reassessed at Rs 325 per sq yd.
    • Manohar Singh (Hansi): 60% cut reduced to one-third; value to be re-worked accordingly.
    • Fatehabad Sector 3 lands: belting rejected; one-third deduction; compensation set at ~Rs 350 per sq yd.

Holding and Implications

APPEALS ALLOWED IN PART / DISPOSED OF WITH REVISED COMPENSATION

The Supreme Court recalculated compensation for each cluster of cases, generally increasing market value, substituting cumulative 12% escalation, and reducing deductions to one-third where higher cuts had been applied. It declared that each lead decision “will govern” extensive lists of tagged matters, thereby standardising compensation principles across hundreds of appeals. No costs were awarded to any party.

Implications are largely confined to the parties: higher monetary awards and clarity that (i) cumulative escalation may be appropriate, and (ii) deductions must reflect existing development. The decision reiterates but does not materially expand Land Acquisition jurisprudence on these points.

Show all summary ...

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

Altamas Kabir, C.J— All these matters involve a common question relating to claims for enhancement of compensation in respect of lands acquired under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (hereinafter referred to as “the 1894 Act”) in several States, such as, Punjab, Haryana, Madhya Pradesh, Andhra Pradesh and the Union Territory of Chandigarh. In some of the special leave petitions, leave has already been granted and they have been listed as civil appeals. Leave is also granted in all other special leave petitions which are being heard together in this batch of matters.

2. For the sake of convenience, we have taken up the batch matters Statewise. The major number of cases are from the States of Punjab and Haryana and, accordingly, it was decided to take up the said matters first. We have, therefore, heard the matters relating to the State of Haryana before the other matters and for the said purpose, we have also selected some specific matters, the decision wherein would also govern the rest.

3. Since in the State of Haryana, the lands acquired were from different districts, such as Faridabad, Ambala, Fatehabad, Hisar, Sonepat and Kurukshetra and under different notifications published under Section 4 of the 1894 Act, we took up the individual cases of Ashrafi v. State of Haryana, being SLPs (C) Nos. 24704-712 of 2007, relating to the Notification dated 2-8-1989 and Sailak Ram v. State of Haryana, being SLP (C) No. 28686 of 2010, relating to the Notification dated 7-9-1992, in respect of the lands situated in Faridabad. In addition, we also took up SLP (C) No. 18588 of 2006 filed by the State of Haryana against Surinder Kumar and others, in respect of the Notification dated 26-5-1981, relating to the lands situated within the District of Ambala. Another matter relating to the District of Ambala, namely, State of Haryana v. Manohar Lal Khurana, being SLP (C) No. 11527 of 2007, relating to the Notification dated 2-2-1989, was also taken up separately. As far as the lands relating to the District of Hisar are concerned, the special leave petition filed by the State of Haryana against Partap Singh and another, being SLP (C) No. 21597 of 2006, relating to the Notification dated 21-3-1991, was taken up for separate hearing as also some of the cases involving lands in Sonepat, Kurukshetra Districts, in respect of the Notifications published under Section 4 of the 1894 Act, dated 20-4-1982 and 17-9-1993, respectively.

4. Some of the special leave petitions (now appeals) have been filed by the State of Haryana, which is equally aggrieved by the enhancement of the compensation assessed in reference under Section 18 of the 1894 Act. As would be evident shortly, the High Court almost on a uniform basis awarded compensation at the rate of Rs 235 per square yard notwithstanding the type of land involved. Although a distinction had been made between “chahi” lands, “pahar gair mumkin” lands and “gair mumkin” lands while assessing compensation, ultimately, a uniform rate was awarded in respect of the different types of lands which had been acquired. Different reasons have been given by the High Court in arriving at the uniform figure of Rs 235 per square yard, but what is important is that ultimately by applying different methods, the compensation worked out to be same.

5. In the case of Smt Ashrafi, arising out of RFA No. 99 of 1997 decided by the Punjab and Haryana High Court on 21-5-2007 RFA No. 99 of 1997, along with several other similar appeals, lands measuring 184.66 acres in Village Mewla, Maharajpur, District Faridabad, were acquired for the development of Sector 45 in Faridabad. The Notification was published under Section 4 of the 1894 Act on 2-8-1989. The Land Acquisition Collector awarded compensation at the rate of Rs 3,50,000 per acre for chahi lands and Rs 1,50,000 per acre for other lands. On a reference made by the landowners to the learned District Judge, Faridabad, under Section 18 of the 1894 Act, the Reference Court fixed the compensation at Rs 45 per square yard against which the parties moved the High Court in the first appeal.

6. One of the other cases which was taken up separately was that of Kamlesh Kumari v. State of Haryana, being SLPs (C) Nos. 28613-42 of 2010, wherein 486.61 acres of land in Village Mewla, Maharajpur, were also acquired.

7. Coming back to the decision in Ashrafi case RFA No. 99 of 1997, the High Court fixed the compensation at Rs 220 per square yard in respect of the lands situated in Village Mewla, Maharajpur, acquired for the purpose of establishing Sector 45, Faridabad.

8. It was sought to be urged that the compensation assessed was extremely low in comparison to the compensation awarded in respect of the lands acquired in the same area and under the same Notification under Section 4 of the 1894 Act. It was urged that the learned Single Judge in the High Court had wrongly assessed compensation at Rs 220 per square yard, when in respect of the lands acquired under the same Notification dated 28-8-1989, the learned District Judge had fixed the market value at Rs 328.50 per square yard and also at Rs 337 per square yard, in respect of the lands acquired under a Notification issued in July 1987.

9. In Smt Kamlesh Kumari case, it was urged by Mr J.L Gupta, learned Senior Advocate, that while the Collector had awarded Rs 1,96,000 per acre in respect of the acquired lands, the Reference Court enhanced the same to Rs 325 per square yard, which would be equivalent to Rs 15,73,000 per acre. The High Court, however, reduced the rate from Rs 325 per square yard to Rs 90 per square yard, which would be equivalent to approximately Rs 4,35,000 per acre. The letters patent appeals filed against the said decision of the learned Single Judge were dismissed LPA No. 794 of 2000 and the matter ultimately came up to this Court in Civil Appeal No. 9808 of 2003, and the case was remanded (2013) 5 SCC 622 to the Reference Court for a fresh determination. After remand, the Reference Court, by its order dated 12-1-2008, assessed the compensation at Rs 238 per square yard. In appeal, after considering the decision of a learned Single Judge of the same Court in Sailak Ram case, referred to hereinabove, the learned Judge determined the compensation at Rs 280 per square yard. In fact, it was pointed out by Mr Gupta that in Sailak Ram case, different amounts were awarded as compensation in respect of lands comprised in Village Mewla, Maharajpur, acquired under the Notification dated 2-8-1989. It was finally held that the market rate for the acquired properties would be Rs 280 per square yard, along with all statutory benefits, as per the provisions of the 1894 Act.

10. Mr Gupta urged that even the enhancement made by the High Court was not adequate in view of the compensation awarded in other cases, in respect of the lands comprised in the same village. It was highlighted that in Pritam Singh case, compensation had been awarded at the rate of Rs 435 per square yard. Even in the case of lands situated in Village Ajronda acquired under the Notification dated 5-6-1992, for the development of Sector 20-B, Faridabad, compensation had been awarded at Rs 392.50 per square yard. Mr Gupta submitted that, in such circumstances, the compensation should have been assessed, if not at the said rate, at least at a figure nearabout the said rate. Mr Gupta submitted that in yet another case regarding lands acquired from the same village by the Notification dated 30-7-1987, for constructing a link road from Delhi-Mathura road to Sector 46, Faridabad, compensation awarded was at the rate of Rs 337.20 per square yard.

11. Mr Gupta lastly referred to the decision of this Court in State of Haryana v. Gurbax Singh (2008) 11 SCC 65, in which the decision of this Court in another case viz. Union of India v. Harinder Pal Singh (2005) 12 SCC 564 was referred to and quoted. In para 15 thereof, it was indicated that the entire area was in a stage of development and the different villages were capable of being developed in the same manner, as lands situated elsewhere. Mr Gupta submitted that in the said decision, an enhancement of compensation by adding 12% per annum for a period of two years, was duly accepted by this Court. It was, therefore, submitted that the compensation awarded by the High Court was required to be revised in parity with the compensation awarded in respect of the other lands comprised in the same village, in line with the observations made by the Court in Sailak Ram case and also in Smt Kamlesh Kumari case.

12. One of the other sets of cases viz. Sucha Singh v. Collector (LA), being SLPs (C) Nos. 1678-97 of 2010, were taken up separately, at the instance of Mr R.K Kapoor, learned Advocate, appearing for the appellant claimants. According to Mr Kapoor, the submissions made on behalf of the appellant, Sucha Singh, would also cover SLPs (C) Nos. 13529-49 of 2011, Surjit Kaur v. Collector (LA and Colonisation), SLPs (C) Nos. 15508-511 of 2011, Joginder Singh v. Collector (LA) and SLP (C) No. … (CC No. 2620 of 2011), Mehar Singh v. Collector (LA and Colonisation Deptt.).

13. Mr Kapoor contended that the Notification under Section 4 was issued on 10-2-1984, for acquisition of 79 acres and 5 kanals of land in Village Talwandi Bhai, District Ferozepur, for the purpose of construction of a new grain market. In respect of such acquisition, the Land Acquisition Collector awarded compensation to the landowners at the rate of Rs 40,000 per acre, which was enhanced by the Reference Court to Rs 4,60,000 up to one killa and to Rs 4,00,000 beyond one killa. On appeal to the High Court, the amounts were reduced. The special leave petitions were, thereafter, filed against the said order in this Court. While issuing notice on 5-1-2010 SLP (C) CC No. 19038 of 2009, confined to the question of deduction, this Court directed stay of recovery of the amounts already paid by way of compensation to the petitioners therein.

14. Mr Kapoor contended that having regard to certain plots which were auctioned by the Municipal Committee before acquiring the lands in question, the average rate in respect of various plots was Rs 30,000 per marla and Rs 6,00,000 per kanal, which would mean that the value of the land would be Rs 48,00,000 per acre. Mr Kapoor submitted that, since apart from the above, sale deeds are also a reliable indicator of the land value in a particular area, if the market value is not taken at Rs 48,00,000 per acre, the value of sale transactions during the same period could also be taken into consideration in determining the compensation. According to Mr Kapoor, the High Court took the average value of such transactions for the period 19-9-1980 up to 3-6-1983. The average sale price was found to be Rs 6,23,997 per acre, which would, therefore, be the market value of the land during the period in question. An added increase of 12% per annum would give a figure of Rs 7,82,746 per acre. Accordingly, on the date of the Notification under Section 4 of the 1894 Act i.e 10-2-1984, the market value of the land would be Rs 7,82,746 per acre, even if the auction price of Rs 48,00,000 per acre is not taken into consideration. Mr Kapoor submitted that the lands in question fell within the municipal limits of Talwandi Bhai and no development would be required since the lands had been acquired for constructing a new grain market only. Hence, a deduction of 40% was unjustified in the circumstances. Mr Kapoor, therefore, prayed that even if the final figure of the market value, as determined by the High Court i.e Rs 6,23,997, is taken into consideration, then also by adding 12% per annum to the said figure, the compensation would amount to Rs 7,82,746 per acre.

15. In one of the other matters, Surinder Kumar v. State of Haryana, being SLPs (C) Nos. 16372-404 of 2008, 250.51 acres of land situated in Villages Patti Mehar, Saunda and Jandli in Ambala District, covered by the Notification dated 26-5-1981, were intended to be acquired for development and utilisation of residential areas for an urban estate in Ambala. Three awards were made by the Land Acquisition Collector. When Award No. 4 was pronounced on 27-6-1984, the market value of the acquired lands was assessed at Rs 52,000 per acre, thereafter, two further awards were pronounced wherein some other chahi lands were assessed at Rs 34,500 per acre, barani land was assessed at Rs 27,520 per acre and banjar and gair mumkin land was assessed at Rs 13,760 per acre. On reference, the Reference Court enhanced the market value of the acquired lands to Rs 57,000 per acre. Subsequently, however, another Reference Court assessed the market value of the acquired lands at Rs 3,38,800 per acre. Being dissatisfied with the orders of the Reference Courts, the parties approached the High Court. The State of Haryana also filed appeals relating to the judgment of 6-5-1992. In the appeals filed by the claimants, they claimed that the acquired land was liable to be assessed at Rs 300 per square yard. The Division Bench of the Punjab and Haryana High Court accepted the contention of the landowners and directed that they would be entitled to the market rate at Rs 110 per square yard for the acquired land, together with all statutory benefits, as per the amended provisions of the Act. The appeals filed by the State of Haryana were dismissed.

16. Appearing for the appellants, Ms Indu Malhotra, learned Senior Advocate, submitted that though the compensation was enhanced by the Division Bench from Rs 70 per square yard to Rs 110 per square yard, there was no basis for fixing the value at the said rate. Ms Malhotra urged that the said rate was fixed despite the fact that a conveyance of the year 1973 i.e earlier than the date of acquisition (26-5-1981), had been produced by the appellants. Apart from the above, sale deeds of 1981 were also produced which showed the value of the lands to be Rs 209-Rs 213 per square yard. Ms Malhotra urged that it would be evident from the above that the High Court has erred in fixing the rate of compensation at Rs 110 per square yard, without any basis whatsoever, when sale deeds of even previous years and years contemporaneous to the acquisition, indicated a much higher valuation in respect of the acquired lands. Ms Malhotra submitted that the valuation of the acquired lands was liable to be enhanced in a manner which was commensurate with the value of the lands, as would be evident from the various sale deeds produced on behalf of the appellants.

17. Mr Manoj Swarup, learned Advocate, appeared in several of the matters relating to acquisition of the lands in Hisar, covered by various notifications issued under Section 4 of the 1894 Act. Mr Swarup, firstly, referred to Atam Singh v. State of Haryana, being SLPs (C) Nos. 33337-40 of 2010, involving lands measuring 112 kanals and 12 marlas situated in Village Basti Bhiwan, Tehsil Fatehabad, District Hisar, notified for acquisition for establishing new fruit, vegetable and fodder market, under Section 4 of the aforesaid Act. Mr Swarup also referred to Sarwan Singh v. State of Haryana, being SLPs (C) Nos. 20144-50 of 2007, involving lands measuring 429.75 acres of land, which is the subject-matter of a Notification dated 21-3-1991, under Section 4 of the above Act for the development of a part of Sectors 11, 13, 15, 16 and 17, Hisar, Haryana. Reference was also made to Mukesh Kumar v. State of Haryana, being SLP (C) No. 19668 of 2006, involving lands measuring 227.44 acres in Hisar, which was the subject-matter of the Notification dated 20-8-1992, under Section 4 of the above Act for use as a residential sector by the Haryana Urban Development Authority (HUDA). Mr Swarup, lastly, referred to Mukesh v. State of Haryana, being Civil Appeals Nos. 319-52 of 2011, involving lands measuring 157.20 acres situated in Fatehabad, District Hisar, under the Notification dated 21-7-1993, also for residential and commercial purposes in Sector 3, Fatehabad.

18. In Atam Singh case, Mr Swarup, pointed out that the lands had been notified on 15-10-1987 for establishing a new fruit, vegetable and fodder market and that initially compensation was awarded at the rate of Rs 54.75 per square yard. Mr Swarup pointed out that the land acquired in 1987 is adjacent to the land acquired subsequently in 1993. It was urged that the Reference Court had in its judgment found the potentiality of the suit land to be high having regard to the various developments, which had occurred in the said area and also for future development relating to a proposal for a truck union and auto market. Certain contemporaneous private sales, for the purpose of comparison, had been filed, which were accepted by the High Court, which had been held to be genuine, from which it would appear that there has been a steady increase in the valuation of the lands and the chart indicates that the price of land in the year 1989 was about Rs 200 per square yard. The chart also demonstrates that two years later, the prices had doubled to about Rs 400 per square yard. Taking the same to be a yardstick, Mr Swarup submitted that the value of the land acquired in 1987 should be taken as the comparative unit and that the value of the land acquired in 1987 should, therefore, be assessed at Rs 100 per square yard.

19. Mr Swarup pointed out that the decision in Atam Singh case was thereafter followed by the High Court in Sarwan Singh, being SLPs (C) Nos. 20144-50 of 2007. As indicated hereinbefore, the said matter involved acquisition of 429.75 acres of lands similar to the lands acquired in Atam Singh case. However, for the purpose of assessing the value of the land, the methodology followed was to add 12% annually towards the value of the lands for a period of six years, which is also one of the methods for arriving at a valuation taking a base year and, thereafter, computing the annual increase of the value at the accepted rate of 12% per annum.

20. The question which was raised was whether the same should be on the basis of a flat rate annually or by adding to the value at the rate of 12% per annum at a flat rate from the date of notification till the award. In these matters, a connected question arose as to whether instead of flat rate the interest should be added cumulatively, which, according to Mr Swarup, had been considered and decided in the affirmative by this Court in ONGC Ltd. v. Rameshbhai Jivanbhai Patel (2008) 14 SCC 745. Mr Swarup, therefore, urged that the compensation assessed at Rs 235 per square yard on the basis of an annual increase of 12% was inadequate and the yearly escalation is required to be calculated on a cumulative basis.

21. In the case filed by Mukesh Kumar, being SLP (C) No. 19668 of 2007, relating to acquisition of 227.44 acres under the Notification dated 20-8-1992, Mr Swarup pointed out that the decision had been arrived at on the reasoning in Sarwan Singh case and Atam Singh case, referred to hereinabove. Mr Swarup urged that in Sarwan Singh case, the High Court considered the location of the acquired lands and upon observing that they were situated next to prominent localities to the north of the acquired lands, it had no hesitation in arriving at the conclusion that the entire acquired land fell within the municipal limits of the District of Hisar with substantial potential for its development for residential and commercial purposes. Even the Division Bench in appeal, while rejecting the submissions made on behalf of the State, observed that having regard to the nature of the development of the surrounding areas, it would be improper to resort to the belting system and to award one set of compensation for the entire land.

22. Mr Swarup then urged that in Udho Dass v. State of Haryana (2010) 12 SCC 51, this Court had the occasion to observe that although, in the 1894 Act provision has been made for the payment of solatium, interest and an additional amount, the same had not kept pace with the astronomical rise in land prices in many parts of India, and most certainly in North India, and the compensation awarded could not fully compensate for the acquisition of the land. This Court further observed that the 12% per annum increase which had often been found to be adequate in matters relating to compensation, hardly did justice to those landowners whose lands had been taken away and the increase was even at times up to 100% a year for land which had the potential of being urbanised and commercialised, such as in the present case.

23. Mr Swarup pointed out that similar observations had been made by this Court in ONGC Ltd. v. Rameshbhai Jivanbhai Patel (2008) 14 SCC 745, wherein similar views were expressed in a similar vein as in the earlier case that primarily the increase in land prices depends on four factors: (i) situation of the land, (ii) nature of development in surrounding area, (iii) availability of land for development in the area, and (iv) the demand for land in the area. It was observed that in rural areas, unless there was any prospect of development in the vicinity, increase in prices would be slow, steady and gradual. On the other hand, in urban or semi-urban areas, where the development is faster and the demand for land is high and where there is construction activity all around, the escalation in market price is at a much higher rate, as compared to rural areas and in some pockets in big cities, due to rapid development and high demand for land, the escalation in prices have touched even 30% to 50% or more per year during the nineties.

24. In the light of his aforesaid submissions, Mr Swarup submitted that although, the High Court had allowed yearly increase of 12%, taking 1983 as the base year, such increase was not commensurate with the yearly escalation of prices and the same was required to be calculated on a cumulative basis, as indicated in Rameshbhai Jivanbhai Patel case (2008) 14 SCC 745.

25. In regard to 157.20 acres of land situated in Fatehabad, District Hisar, Haryana, acquired for utilisation and development of residential and commercial purposes in Sector 3, Fatehabad, by the Haryana Urban Development Authority (HUDA), the Collector had awarded compensation at a uniform rate of Rs 1,81,200 per acre along with statutory benefits. As against the claim of the landowners that the market value was Rs 1000 per square yard, the Reference Court determined the compensation at the uniform rate of Rs 206 per square yard. The High Court modified the said award and awarded compensation at the rate of Rs 260 per square yard for the land acquired up to the depth of 100 metres abutting National Highway No. 10. The value of the rest of the acquired land was maintained at Rs 206 per square yard. Mr Swarup submitted that having regard to the sale instances for the years 1989 and 1991, wherein the prices had doubled, by the same equation the price of the land in 1993 should have been Rs 800 per square yard. Urging that the High Court had erred in imposing a cut of 50% on the value, it was submitted that no cut was required to be imposed since the lands forming the subject-matter of the sale instances formed part of the acquired land and was comprised in identically situated lands to the rest of the acquired land. Mr Swarup submitted that at best the standard cut of one-third would have been sufficient to balance the smallness of the exhibits and, in any event, the belting system resorted to by the High Court was erroneous in the light of the observations made by the High Court itself in Udho Dass (2010) 12 SCC 51 and Rameshbhai Jivanbhai Patel (2008) 14 SCC 745.

26. In regard to the lands forming the subject-matter of CAs Nos. 3381-89 of 2011 and other connected matters (Jamna Bai v. State of Haryana), Mr Anoop G. Chaudhari, learned Senior Advocate, appearing for the appellants, submitted that the price of the plots to be sold by auction by the municipality required an average of four sale transactions to be taken as a sale index price of the lands in question. Mr Chaudhari urged that out of the four sale transactions taken into consideration the High Court erroneously chose the value of Rs 200 per square yard, which ought not to have been taken for the purpose of determining the value of the lands acquired.

27. Mr S.B Upadhyay, learned Senior Advocate, who appeared for the petitioners in four of the matters relating to the lands in question, submitted that if all the valuation available were taken together and an average was drawn, the valuation of the land would come to Rs 4572 per square yard. Furthermore, deduction of 40% from the market value towards development charges was excessive and where the acquired land falls in the midst of already developed land, the reasonable deduction would be not more than one-third of the assessed value of the land.

28. In this regard, reference was firstly made to the decision of this Court in Charan Dass v. H.P Housing and Urban Development Authority (2010) 13 SCC 398, wherein quoting from the decision of this Court in Tribeni Devi case (1972) 1 SCC 480, this Court had observed that it had to be noted that in the Building Regulations, setting apart lands for development of roads, drainage and other amenities like electricity, etc. are condition precedent for approval of a layout for building colonies. Therefore, any deduction made should be based upon the situation of the land and the need for development. Where acquired land is in the midst of already developed land with amenities of roads, drainage, electricity, etc. then deduction of one-third would not be justified. Reference was also made to the decision of this Court in Haridwar Development Authority v. Raghubir Singh (2010) 11 SCC 581, wherein also, taking into consideration the various stages of development, this Court observed that appropriate deduction towards development costs could vary between 20% to 75% depending upon various factors, but that in the said case the deduction of 25% towards development cost was appropriate. Mr Upadhyay also referred to the decision of this Court in Kasturi v. State of Haryana (2003) 1 SCC 354, wherein also, as against the normal cut of one-third from the amount of compensation, it was held that a cut of 20% towards development charges was justified.

29. Appearing for the State of Haryana in SLPs (C) Nos. 32764-65 of 2011, Ms Anubha Agarwal, learned Advocate, submitted that the disparity in the sale price of the different sale transactions was mainly on account of the different areas where the said lands were located. Furthermore, the sale transactions relied upon by the appellant-petitioners related to only plots measuring about 60 square yards or so. On account of the above, the sale price of such transactions could not be taken to be an accurate assessment of the valuation of the lands which were acquired in bulk. What was also important was the level of development of the lands acquired. According to Ms Agarwal, most of the lands forming the subject-matter of the acquisition proceedings under different notifications published under Section 4 of the 1894 Act, at different points of time, were agricultural in nature and comprised the interior portion of lands acquired which were not developed at all. The valuation of the said lands could not, in any way, be compared with the lands which were closer to the main roads and the developed zones and as such the High Court had wrongly relied upon the same in assessing the value of the extent of compensation for the lands forming the subject-matter of the present proceedings.

30. Referring to the decision of the Reference Court, Ms Agarwal pointed out that development work and/or construction had taken place alongside the roads, such as the national highway, Tosham Road and Bhiwani Road and it was more or less established that the development in the acquired land was along the roads only and the entire acquired land was not a developed block. Even alongside the roads the development was not symmetrical or systematic, but at the same time, it also had to be recognised that the acquired land had potential for being developed for residential, commercial and/or industrial purposes as on the date of the notification.

31. Referring to the decision of this Court in Subh Ram v. State of Haryana (2010) 1 SCC 444, Ms Agarwal pointed out that the factors determining percentage of deduction had nothing to do with the purpose for which the land was acquired, nor could the purpose of acquisition be used to increase the compensation awardable with reference to expected profits from future user. In the said judgment it was pointed out that Section 24 of the 1984 Act prohibits courts from taking into consideration any increase in value of land acquired, or likely to accrue from use to which it is put when required. Ms Agarwal submitted that it had also been indicated in the judgment that deduction of “development cost” is a concept used to derive the “wholesale price” of a large undeveloped plot. The difference between the value of a small developed plot and the value of a large undeveloped land is the “development cost”. Reference was also made to the decision in Kanta Devi v. State of Haryana (2008) 15 SCC 201, where it had been held that to determine the market value for purposes of compensation, deduction of development charges was normally one-third of the market value which also required the nature of land to be acquired to be taken into consideration. In the said case, relying upon the sale price of a small plot, the High Court had fixed the market value of the acquired land, but deducted 70% therefrom towards development charges to make the land suitable for the purpose for which the land had been acquired. This Court held that since the land was adjacent to the village abadi which was already developed, the deduction at the rate of 70% was on the high side and a deduction of 60% of the market value would be reasonable. Various other decisions were also cited on the same lines and referring to the same would only amount to repetition.

32. Ms Agarwal submitted that the deduction towards development cost depended mainly on the area in which the land was located and their potentiality for development and in the instant case, the deduction of 40%, as suggested, was quite apposite and did not require any interference.

33. Mr R.S Badharan, learned Advocate for HUDA, in Civil Appeals Nos. 3388-89 of 2011, urged that the lands in question could not be compared with the lands under consideration in a review. While referring to other decisions, Mr Badharan also referred to the decision of this Court in Kasturi v. State of Haryana (2003) 1 SCC 354, wherein a question had arisen as to whether the deduction of development charges at the rate of 20% in regard to the acquired lands was justified or not. Ultimately, after taking the various factors into consideration, the said Court agreed that a cut of 20% towards the development charges, which was lower than the normal one-third, was understandable and could be justified. However, the same principle as has been relied upon in all the abovementioned decisions, has also been dealt with in Kasturi case (2003) 1 SCC 354 and the Courts have relied basically on the normal deduction of one-third of the value.

34. Responding to the submissions made on behalf of the respective parties, the learned Additional Solicitor General, Mr A.S Chandhiok, referred to the decision of this Court in Saibanna v. Commr. and Land Acquisition Officer (2009) 9 SCC 409, wherein the same question, as was considered earlier, once again fell for examination. Relying on the earlier judgments of this Court, the learned Judges reiterated the factors which led to the higher rates of deduction in respect of lands within the municipal limits of a city. Their Lordships held that the deduction of 53% as imposed was on the higher side and should not have been more than one-third. Their Lordships observed that though no hard-and-fast or rigid rule can be laid down, and each case had to be decided on its individual facts, in the case before Their Lordships the deduction of 33-1/3% towards development charges, was justifiable. Mr Chandhiok urged that the quantum of compensation, as decided by the High Court in the various cases under consideration, was based on the abovementioned principles and did not warrant the interference of this Court.

35. As indicated hereinbefore, a common question is involved in all these matters in respect of the lands acquired in the States of Punjab, Haryana, Madhya Pradesh, Andhra Pradesh and the Union Territory of Chandigarh. Since the acquired lands are situated in different areas even within the different States, different quantums of compensation have been awarded for the lands so acquired. The general principles which have been followed in assessing the compensation payable in all these matters are the location of the lands sought to be acquired, their potential for development, their proximity to areas which are already developed and the exorbitant rise in the value of the lands over the years. In some of the cases, the authorities have taken recourse to the comparison method in regard to the sale transactions effected in respect of similar plots of land in the area under the notifications close to the date of notification by which the lands of the appellants were acquired. The courts have also taken recourse to assessing the value of the lands for the purposes of compensation on a uniform rate in respect of the lands acquired, making a special concession in respect of the lands which are close to the roads and national highways where a certain amount of development had already taken place.

36. Having resorted to the aforesaid methods, the Collectors of the different areas arrived at different valuations in respect of the lands situated within their respective jurisdictions. In most of the cases, the High Court almost on a uniform basis awarded compensation at the rate of Rs 235 per square yard on a flat rate notwithstanding the type of land involved. In Smt Ashrafi case arising out of RFA No. 99 of 1997 decided by the Punjab and Haryana High Court on 21-5-2007 RFA No. 99 of 1997, along with several other similar appeals, the Land Acquisition Collector awarded compensation at the rate of Rs 3,50,000 per acre for “chahi” lands and Rs 1,50,000 per acre for other lands. The Reference Court fixed the compensation at Rs 45 per square yard as against the rate of compensation awarded by the Land Acquisition Collector. In respect of similar lands, the High Court fixed the compensation at Rs 220 per square yard in respect of the lands situated in Village Mewla and Maharajpur for establishing Sector 34, Faridabad. It has been agitated on behalf of the appellants that the said assessment of compensation fixed by the High Court was on the lower side in view of the fact that in respect of lands acquired under the same Notification dated 20-8-1989, the District Court had fixed the market value at Rs 328.50 per square yard and also at Rs 337 per square yard, in respect of the lands acquired under a Notification issued in July 1987. In Smt Kamlesh Kumari case, in which the facts were the same, as that in Smt Ashrafi case, the Collector had awarded Rs 1,96,000 per acre in respect of the acquired lands which figure had been enhanced by the Reference Court to Rs 325 per square yard, which would be equivalent to Rs 15,73,000 per acre. The High Court reduced the rate from Rs 325 per square yard to Rs 90 per square yard, but ultimately the compensation was assessed at Rs 238 per square yard. In appeal, the said amount was increased to Rs 280 per square yard.

37. Even the aforesaid enhancement does not appear to have reflected the proper valuation of the lands acquired since soon, thereafter, in Pritam Singh case, compensation was awarded at Rs 435 per square yard and also at the rate of Rs 392.50 per square yard in respect of the lands acquired under the Notification dated 5-6-1992, in Village Ajronda.

38. In our view, the enhancement of the compensation from Rs 280 per square yard to Rs 435 per square yard and Rs 392.50 per square yard was probably occasioned by the fact that while the lands were acquired under the Notification issued in July 1987, the comparative rate relating to the same property was Rs 392.50 per square yard. In view of the passage of time between the different acquisitions, in our view, a just compensation would be at the rate of Rs 325 per square yard instead of Rs 280 per square yard. Similar is the case of Smt Kamlesh Kumari, where the facts were similar to those in Ashrafi's case. In Smt Kamlesh Kumari's case, initially the amount of compensation assessed by the Reference Court at the rate of Rs 325 per square yard was reduced to Rs 90 per square yard by the High Court and, ultimately, the amount of compensation was increased to Rs 280 per square yard, in appeal. In our view, the just compensation in the lands in Smt Kamlesh Kumari's case also deserves to be increased to Rs 325 per square yard, which had been the amount awarded by the Reference Court.

39. In Sailak Ram's case, different amounts were assessed as compensation in respect of the lands comprised in Village Mewla, Maharajpur, acquired under the Notification dated 2-8-1989. There too the market rate was assessed at Rs 280 per square yard along with all statutory benefits under the 1894 Act. In our view, the compensation in respect of the lands involved has also to be assessed at Rs 325 per square yard.

40. In Sucha Singh's case, Mr Kapoor had submitted that the Land Acquisition Collector had awarded the compensation at the rate of Rs 40,000 per acre, which was enhanced by the Reference Court to Rs 4,60,000 up to one killa and to Rs 4,00,000 beyond one killa. On appeal to the High Court, the amounts were reduced to Rs 3,74,400 per acre up to one acre and Rs 2,24,640 per acre beyond one acre. According to Mr Kapoor, while the average sale price had been found to be Rs 6,23,997 per acre, together with increase of 12% per annum, the figure would amount to Rs 7,82,746 per acre. However, although the land belonging to Mr Kapoor's clients fell within the municipal limits of Talwandi Bhai, a deduction of 40% was unjustified. On the other hand, a cut of 33-1/3% would be more realistic. Accordingly, the compensation for the said lands, after taking into consideration the deduction of 33-1/3% is assessed at Rs 7,25,000 per acre.

41. As far as the lands within the District of Ambala are concerned, in respect of one set of lands, the Reference Court assessed the market value of the acquired lands to be Rs 57,000 per acre. However, another Reference Court assessed the market value of the acquired lands at Rs 3,38,800 per acre. In our view, the claim of the landowners, assessed at Rs 300 per square yard is on the high side but Rs 110 per square yard, as had been held by the Division Bench of the Punjab and Haryana High Court, is on the low side. On a comparison of the price of lands sold during 1981, or by adding 12% per annum on Rs 70 per square yard on annual compounded basis, the value of the lands is assessed at Rs 180 per square yard on a uniform basis for all lands, as also submitted by Ms Malhotra.

42. In the lands covered in Atam Singh's case, the Collector had initially assessed the compensation at the rate of Rs 54.75 per square yard. Having regard to Mr Manoj Swarup's submissions that the lands acquired in 1987 were adjacent to the lands acquired subsequently in 1993, the value of the lands in 1989 would be about Rs 200 per square yard, the prices had, in fact, doubled to about Rs 400 per square yard within the next two years. Mr Swarup's submission that by such standards, the value of the lands acquired in 1987 should be Rs 100 per square yard, is, in our view, justifiable.

43. In Mukesh Kumar's case, Mr Manoj Swarup had pointed out that having regard to the potentiality of the acquired lands, the belting system should not have been resorted to. We are inclined to accept Mr Swarup's contention on this score. We are also inclined to accept Mr Swarup's other submissions that, although, the High Court had allowed a yearly increase of 12%, taking 1983 as a base year, such increase was not commensurate with the yearly escalation of prices and that was required to be calculated on a cumulative basis, as was held in Rameshbhai Jivanbhai Patel case (2008) 14 SCC 745.

44. Accordingly, in Mukesh Kumar's case and the other cases heard along with the said case, we are of the view that while adding 12% annual increase to the value of the lands acquired, the same should be done on a cumulative basis. In Mukesh Kumar's case, the compensation awarded was at the rate of Rs 235 per square yard along with all statutory benefits, as provided under Sections 23(1-A), 23(2) and 28 of the Land Acquisition Act. Having discarded the belting system which has been resorted to, we are of the view that the compensation as awarded at the rate of Rs 235 per square yard, has to be reassessed by applying the cumulative rate of increase at the rate of 12% per annum with the base year being the date of the notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, together with the statutory benefits, as indicated hereinabove. The stand taken on behalf of the State of Haryana, regarding the amount of escalation fixed at 12% being improper, does not appeal to us having regard to the potentiality of the lands acquired and the sharp increase in the value of the lands in recent times. The valuation of the compensation of the acquired land at the rate of Rs 235 per square yard by the High Court, appears to have been influenced by the compensation already assessed in Atam Prakash's case, where the market value of the land acquired in Sectors 9 and 11 was assessed at Rs 235 per square yard. According to Mr Swarup, the said lands were far away from the lands involved in the present set of cases and, accordingly, the rate of compensation for the lands under consideration should be definitely higher than awarded in respect of the lands covered in Atam Prakash's case. Accordingly, we reassess the compensation assessed in respect of the lands covered by these cases by applying the cumulative rate of interest, taking the date of notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act as the base year for such calculation at Rs 325 per square yard. The said valuation will also be applicable in Mahabir v. State of Haryana [SLP (C) No. 1512 of 2007], Sarwan Singh v. State of Haryana [SLPs (C) Nos. 20144-50 of 2007] and State of Haryana v. Partap Singh [SLP (C) No. 21597 of 2006]. As far as the lands in Village Patti Mehar, Saunda and Jandli in Ambala District and forming the subject-matter in Surinder Kumar case [SLPs (C) Nos. 16372-404 of 2008], in Manohar Lal Khurana case and in other cases falling in the same category are concerned, the compensation will be at the above rate on a uniform basis.

45. There is yet another set of lands forming the subject-matter of the appeals arising out of Special Leave Petitions (C) Nos. 33637-38 of 2011, filed by Manohar Singh and others, which are situated in Hansi, District Hisar. The said lands also form the subject-matter of several other special leave petitions, which will be covered by the decision in the abovementioned special leave petitions (now appeals). In the said cases, the High Court had assessed the compensation payable for the acquired lands at the rate of Rs 805 per square yard along with the statutory sums available under Section 23(1-A) of the Land Acquisition Act and solatium on the market value under Section 23(2) thereof. It was also indicated that the landowners would also be entitled to interest as provided under Section 28 of the Act.

46. While deciding the valuation of the lands, the High Court applied a cut of 60% and also took into consideration that the lands in question were small plots, the value whereof was definitely higher than the lands which had been acquired which were much larger in area.

47. In our view, the High Court was justified in taking into consideration the size of the plots, which were exhibited for the purposes of comparison with the size of the plots acquired, but we are unable to uphold the cut of 60%, which has been imposed by the High Court, since the acquired lands are already within developed municipal limits. In these cases also, a cut of one-third the value would be appropriate as in the other cases. Accordingly, we modify the valuation arrived at by the High Court upon imposing a cut of 60% and direct that the amount of compensation be reassessed upon imposing a cut of 33-1/3% while reassessing the value of the land.

48. This brings us to the last part of the submissions made with regard to the amount of deduction effected in respect of the various properties. The general cut imposed is at a flat rate of 40%, which, in our view, is not warranted on account of the fact that the lands in question have lost their character and potentiality as agricultural lands and have more or less been converted into lands which were ready for use for the purpose of construction. Taking Ms Agarwal's submissions regarding the factors which determine deduction towards development cost, such as location and potentiality, into account, we are of the view that a deduction of 33-1/3% would be reasonable on account of the passage of time and the all-round development in the area which has made it impossible for the lands to retain their original character.

49. Accordingly, we direct that except where we have provided otherwise, wherever a deduction of 40% had been made, the same should be altered to 33-1/3% and the compensation awarded is to be modified accordingly.

50. In regard to the 157.20 acres of land situated in Fatehabad, District Hisar, Haryana, acquired for utilisation and development of residential and commercial purposes in Sector 3, Fatehabad, the compensation in respect thereof has been questioned in Civil Appeals Nos. 319-52 of 2011 by one Mukesh and a number of appeals have been tagged with the said matter, including the one filed by the Haryana Urban Development Authority, being SLPs (C) Nos. 26772-79 of 2009 (now appeals). As indicated hereinbefore, in para 25, the Collector had awarded compensation at a uniform rate of Rs 1,81,200 per acre along with statutory benefits. The Reference Court determined the compensation at the uniform rate of Rs 206 per square yard. The High Court modified the said award and awarded compensation at the rate of Rs 260 per square yard for the land acquired up to the depth of 100 metres abutting National Highway No. 10. The value of the rest of the acquired land was maintained at Rs 206 per square yard. The area in question being already developed to some extent, a cut of 50% on the value is, in our view, excessive. We agree with Mr Swarup that resorting to the belting system by the High Court was improper and that at best a standard cut of one-third would have been sufficient to balance the smallness of the exhibits produced. It has been pointed out by Mr Swarup that on a comparative basis, the price of lands in the area in 1991 was on an average of about Rs 420 per square yard. Given the sharp rise in land prices, the value, according to Mr Swarup, would have doubled to about Rs 800 per square yard by 1993. Even if we have to apply the formula of 12% increase, the valuation of the lands in question in 1993 would be approximately Rs 527 per square yard. Imposing a deduction of one-third, valuation comes to about Rs 350 per square yard, which, in our view, would be the proper compensation for the lands covered in the case of Mukesh and other connected matters.

51. This disposes of all the various matters which were heard along with lead matters, a table of which has been supplied by Mr Swarup.

52. The decision rendered in the appeals arising out of SLPs (C) Nos. 24704-712 of 2007, Ashrafi v. State of Haryana, will govern SLPs (C) Nos. 13415-26, SLPs (C) Nos. 12263-82, SLP (C) No. 15648, SLPs (C) Nos. 5392-94 of 2008, SLPs (C) Nos. 15485-86, SLPs (C) Nos. 8592-96 of 2009, SLPs (C) Nos. 34118-20, SLPs (C) Nos. 4176-79 of 2010, SLPs (C) Nos. 11156-58 of 2009, SLP (C) No. 28895 of 2008, SLP (C) No. … (CCs Nos. 863-65 of 2011), SLP (C) No. 33257 of 2010, SLPs (C) Nos. 11171-72 of 2009, SLPs (C) Nos. 3125-26 of 2011, SLPs (C) Nos. 29721-22, SLP (C) No. 31281 of 2009, CA No. 8719 of 2010, SLPs (C) Nos. 18744-824, SLPs (C) Nos. 1089-105, SLPs (C) Nos. 27923-24 of 2008, SLP (C) No. 246 of 2009, SLPs (C) Nos. 3367-68 of 2010 and SLPs (C) Nos. 9268-70 of 2011.

53. The decision rendered in appeals arising out of SLPs (C) Nos. 28613-42 of 2010, Kamlesh Kumari v. State of Haryana, and SLP (C) No. 28686 of 2010, Sailak Ram v. State of Haryana, will govern the appeals arising out of SLPs (C) Nos. 7233-39 of 2011, SLPs (C) Nos. 35673-93 of 2010, SLPs (C) Nos. 12083-087, SLPs (C) Nos. 14389-90, SLP (C) No. 13613, SLPs (C) Nos. 674-81 of 2011, SLP (C) No. 33749 of 2010, SLP (C) No. 3647 of 2011, SLPs (C) Nos. 28644-85, SLP (C) No. 31832, SLPs (C) Nos. 27706-723 of 2010, SLP (C) No. 14425 and SLPs (C) Nos. 31772-76 of 2011.

54. The decision rendered in the appeal arising out of SLP (C) No. 19668 of 2007, Mukesh Kumar v. State of Haryana, will govern the appeals arising out of SLP (C) No. 16005, SLP (C) No. 16262, SLP (C) No. 16271, SLPs (C) Nos. 16302-04, SLPs (C) Nos. 16378-79, SLP (C) No. 16407, SLPs (C) Nos. 16536-38, SLP (C) No. 19384, SLP (C) No. 16793, SLP (C) No. 16794, SLP (C) No. 18564, SLP (C) No. 19381, SLP (C) No. 19379, SLP (C) No. 19382, SLP (C) No. 19380, SLP (C) No. 19419, SLP (C) No. 19489, SLP (C) No. 19603, SLP (C) No. 21851, SLP (C) No. 21850, SLP (C) No. 20188 of 2006, SLP (C) No. 5509, SLP (C) No. 6175, SLP (C) No. 8129, SLP (C) No. 7001, SLP (C) No. 5571, SLP (C) No. 5895, SLP (C) No. 5572, SLP (C) No. 6167, SLP (C) No. 7002, SLP (C) No. 11527 of 2007, SLP (C) No. 29447 of 2008, SLP (C) No. 18448, SLPs (C) Nos. 18876-77, SLP (C) No. 19133, SLP (C) No. 19231 of 2006, SLP (C) No. 5487 of 2007, SLP (C) No. 18588 of 2006, SLP (C) No. 7601 of 2007, SLP (C) No. 21848, SLP (C) No. 21846 of 2006, SLP (C) No. 3416, SLP (C) No. 3468, SLP (C) No. 2420 of 2007, SLPs (C) Nos. 6866-80 of 2008, SLP (C) No. 3356, SLP (C) No. 3415, SLP (C) No. 3411 of 2007, SLP (C) No. 17564, SLP (C) No. 14642, SLP (C) No. 14536, SLP (C) No. 17361, SLP (C) No. 6326, SLP (C) No. 7165, SLP (C) No. 7106, SLP (C) No. 14161, SLP (C) No. 9990, SLP (C) No. 18583, SLP (C) No. 16272, SLP (C) No. 17268, SLP (C) No. 12661, SLP (C) No. 16273 of 2006, SLP (C) No. 3646 of 2011, SLP (C) No. 3350 of 2007, SLP (C) No. 6899, SLP (C) No. 7036, SLP (C) No. 7247 of 2006, SLP (C) No. 19676, SLPs (C) Nos. 19539-42, SLP (C) No. 20667 of 2007, SLPs (C) Nos. 16372-404 of 2008, SLP (C) No. … (CC No. 2754 of 2007), SLP (C) No. … (CC No. 9752 of 2007), SLP (C) No. 6332 and SLP (C) No. 6335 of 2007.

55. The decision rendered in the appeals arising out of SLPs (C) Nos. 1678-97 of 2010, Sucha Singh v. Collector, will govern the appeals arising out of SLPs (C) Nos. 13529-49, SLPs (C) Nos. 15508-11 and SLP (C) No. … (CC No. 2620 of 2011).

56. The decision rendered in CAs Nos. 319-52 of 2011, Mukesh v. State of Haryana, will govern CAs Nos. 8654-61, CAs Nos. 8642-45 of 2010, CAs Nos. 423-24, CAs Nos. 418-19 of 2011, CAs Nos. 8637-38, CAs Nos. 8646-53 of 2010, CAs Nos. 354-411, CAs Nos. 412-17 of 2011, SLPs (C) Nos. 26772-79 and SLPs (C) Nos. 31842-45 of 2009.

57. The decision rendered in the appeals arising out of SLPs (C) Nos. 33637-38 of 2011, Manohar Singh v. State of Haryana, will govern Civil Appeals Nos. 3388-89, CA No. 5206, CAs Nos. 5208-14, CA No. 5207, CAs Nos. 5215-16, CAs Nos. 7179-82 of 2011, SLPs (C) Nos. … (CCs Nos. 14220-21 of 2011), SLP (C) No. … (CC No. 14164 of 2011), SLPs (C) Nos. 21344-51, SLPs (C) Nos. 32764-65, SLPs (C) Nos. 32766-67, SLPs (C) Nos. 32770-71, SLPs (C) Nos. 32772-73, SLPs (C) Nos. 32790-91, SLPs (C) Nos. 32792-93, SLPs (C) Nos. 32796-97, SLPs (C) Nos. 32798-99, SLPs (C) Nos. 32801-802 and SLPs (C) Nos. 32806-807 of 2011.

58. Having regard to the facts of the various cases disposed of by this judgment, the parties will bear their own costs.