Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Zafar v. State Of U.P .

Supreme Court Of India
Jan 15, 2003
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, the sole accused in Sessions Trial No. 583 of 1980 before the Additional District and Sessions Judge, Gorakhpur, was convicted under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code for the murder of his relation, Hidayat Hussain, who was shot at approximately 8 a.m. on 28 June 1980. The trial court sentenced the accused to life imprisonment, and the Allahabad High Court affirmed both conviction and sentence on appeal. The present decision arises from the accused’s further appeal to the Supreme Court by special leave.

According to the prosecution, the deceased was walking with his seven-year-old son, Aizaz @ Guddu (PW 2), towards a meat shop when the accused fired a shot with a country-made pistol. The deceased collapsed and died at the spot. PW 1, father of the deceased, reached the scene shortly thereafter and lodged a First Information Report at 9:15 a.m. The investigating officers (PW 6 and PW 7) collected evidence, conducted an inquest, and filed a charge-sheet. Motive was attributed to the accused’s suspicion that the deceased had illicit relations with his wife. The principal eyewitness was PW 2; another purported eyewitness (PW 3) turned hostile.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the conviction could safely rest on the testimony of the child witness (PW 2) in light of alleged inconsistencies and investigative irregularities.
  2. Whether the concurrent findings of the courts below warranted interference under Article 136 of the Constitution because of overlooked infirmities in the prosecution evidence.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • The testimony of PW 2 was unreliable due to material discrepancies regarding the exact place of occurrence.
  • There was an unexplained delay of four to five days in the police examining PW 2, contrary to the investigating officer’s claim of same-day examination.
  • PW 2’s version that police were already present when PW 1 arrived conflicted with both PW 1 and the investigating officer.
  • PW 1’s FIR omitted any statement from PW 2 identifying the accused, undermining the claimed immediacy of PW 2’s eyewitness account.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent State’s legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Leela Ram v. State of Haryana
(1999) 9 SCC 525; JT (1999) 8 SC 274
Minor discrepancies (e.g., whether one or two shots were fired) do not necessarily vitiate otherwise credible prosecution evidence. The High Court relied on this case to hold that uncertainty about the number of shots was not fatal to the prosecution; the Supreme Court noted this reliance but ultimately found other infirmities decisive.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court undertook a fresh appraisal of PW 2’s evidence against the backdrop of the rule that child testimony must be scrutinised with special caution.

  • Discrepancy in the Scene of Crime: PW 2 stated that the shooting occurred inside the meat shop, whereas the site plan (Ext. K-9) and the investigating officer (PW 7) located the firing spot in front of Sidhu’s house, 5-6 paces away. This divergence created reasonable doubt about PW 2’s direct perception of the event.
  • Delay in Examination of PW 2: PW 2 testified that police questioned him only after four or five days, contradicting PW 7’s assertion of same-day examination. Case-diary entries lacked dates, and PW 2’s statement was absent from the earliest pages, undercutting the prosecution narrative and raising suspicion about subsequent fabrication.
  • Presence of Police at the Scene: PW 2 alleged that police were already on the spot before PW 1 arrived and had placed the body on a cot, conflicting with PW 1 and PW 6, both of whom said police arrived only after the FIR. This inconsistency further eroded PW 2’s credibility.
  • Omission in FIR: Although PW 1 mentioned PW 2’s presence in the FIR, he did not note that PW 2 identified the assailant. While not decisive by itself, when read with the above discrepancies it heightened doubts.
  • Cumulative Effect: The Court held that these “telling factors” were overlooked by both courts below, which had concentrated on trivial contradictions. Given the cumulative infirmities, reliance on PW 2 without corroboration was unsafe.

Having found it unnecessary to re-examine alleged inconsistencies between ocular and medical evidence, the Court concluded that the prosecution had failed to prove the charge beyond reasonable doubt.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed – Conviction and sentence set aside. The Court directed immediate release of the appellant.

Implications: The decision provides relief only to the appellant on benefit-of-doubt grounds and does not establish new legal precedent; it reiterates the necessity for rigorous scrutiny of child-witness testimony and careful attention to investigative lapses.

Show all summary ...

P. Venkatarama Reddi, J.— This appeal by special leave is preferred by the sole accused in Sessions Trial No. 583 of 1980 on the file of the Additional District and Sessions Judge, Gorakhpur. The accused was convicted under Section 302 IPC on the charge of murdering his relation by the name of Hidayat Hussain at about 8 a.m on 28-6-1980 on a public street. The accused was sentenced to life imprisonment. On appeal, the High Court confirmed the conviction and sentence.

2. The prosecution case is that on the crucial day at about 8 a.m the deceased was going to a meat shop with his son Aizaz @ Guddu (PW 2). As they came close to the meat shop, the accused fired a shot from his country-made pistol in front of the house of one Sidhu. The victim collapsed before the meat shop of Achhan (PW 3) and succumbed to the injuries then and there. Though some people tried to overpower the accused, he reloaded his pistol and threatened them not to risk their lives. Thereafter, he fled away from the scene. PW 1, the father of the deceased, on coming to know of the incident came to the spot immediately. He saw the son of the deceased (PW 2) weeping by the side of the dead body. His clothes were bloodstained. After some time he got a complaint drafted by one Yusuf and handed over the same in the police station at 9.15 a.m The head constable registered the FIR. PW 6, the Sub-Inspector of Police immediately went to the scene of offence, took custody of the dead body after having it photographed and prepared a panchnama. Thereafter, PW 7, the Senior Sub-Inspector, took over the investigation and seized the bloodstained earth, empty cartridge and bloodstained kurta of PW 2. On search at the house of the accused, he found nothing incriminating.

3. Post-mortem examination was conducted by PW 5 who was the Medical Officer attached to District Hospital, Gorakhpur, on the evening of the same day. The following ante-mortem injuries were found on the body of the deceased:

“1. Gunshot wound 1 ½″ × 1/2″ cavity-deep on the right back 9″ below the root of the back and adjacent to the midline. Margins black, contused and inverted wound of entry.
2. Gunshot wound 1/2″ × 4/10″ × cavity-deep on the chest 2″ inner to right nipple, margins black, everted, contused wound of exit. Six pellets recovered underneath this injury.”

4. The doctor further noted that the injuries were caused by a firearm. On internal examination, he found 8 ounces of clotted blood in the thoracic cavity and laceration of right lung at several places. He found one pound of blood in the stomach. According to the doctor, the deceased died due to shock and haemorrhage caused by the firearm injuries and the death would have occurred instantaneously. PW 7 conducted the inquest and recorded the statements of witnesses. He filed the charge-sheet.

5. The motive for the crime as disclosed by PW 1 is that the accused was under the impression that the deceased was having illicit relations with the wife of the accused as the deceased was often protesting against the cruel treatment being meted out to her and trying to help her. PW 1 also stated that there was some altercation a week earlier, whereupon the accused threatened the deceased with consequences. The accused and the deceased are related.

6. The two eyewitnesses examined by the prosecution are PWs 2 and 3. The eyewitness PW 2 Aizaz Hussain was aged 7 years at the time of the incident and 8 years at the time of giving evidence. He was studying in Class I in the local school. He gave an account of the incident and the circumstances in which his father was killed. He clearly implicated the accused as the assailant. PW 3, the meat shop owner turned hostile. However, he supported the prosecution case partly.

7. Therefore, much turns on the evidence of the child witness, PW 2. The trial court as well as the High Court were of the view that the testimony of PW 2 was clear and trustworthy and reliance could be safely placed on his evidence. The learned trial Judge noted that he had put several questions to satisfy himself if he could give rational answers to the questions. The learned Judge then noted that the witness was intelligent. However, a rider was added to the effect that he could not fully understand the sanctity of oath. However, that does not by itself vitiate his evidence.

8. The learned Judges of the High Court having noted the proposition that cautious approach has to be adopted in appreciating the evidence of a child witness, proceeded to discuss the evidence. The High Court has pointed out that the presence of this witness, PW 2 in the company of his father at the time of the incident cannot be doubted in view of the evidence of PW 3 (who was declared as hostile witness) and PW 1, the informant. The High Court then discussed the two alleged contradictions i.e about the dress he was wearing and the deceased not having any money in his pocket. The High Court rightly explained away these contradictions by giving cogent reasons. The High Court then discussed at length the medical evidence and came to the conclusion that there was really no inconsistency between the ocular testimony and the medical evidence. In any case, the High Court relying on the decision of this Court in Leela Ram v. State of Haryana (1999) 9 SCC 525, JT (1999) 8 SC 274 observed that the prosecution case cannot be rejected outright, even if there was some doubt on the question whether one shot was fired or two shots were fired. The fact that the FIR was lodged promptly naming the accused as the assailant on the basis of the first-hand information which PW 1 got was also considered to be an important factor in support of the prosecution.

9. However, we find on a perusal of the evidence on record that the trial court as well as the High Court failed to focus their attention to certain crucial aspects which have undoubted bearing on the reliability of the evidence of the child witness, PW 2. The first and foremost aspect which deserves attention is about the version of PW 2 as regards the actual scene of offence. According to the prosecution case, the deceased was shot at in front of the house of one Sidhu and he fell down in front of the meat shop of PW 3 after walking for a little distance. In the site plan (Ext. K-9) the place of occurrence is marked as ‘A’, as spoken to by PW 7, the IO. That spot is just in front of the house of Sidhu. The distance between the place of shooting i.e Sidhu's house and the meat shop of PW 3 is about 5 to 6 “paces” according to PW 7. PW 7 stated more than once that the spot of shooting was pointed out to him by PW 2. PW 7 further stated that PW 2 informed him that his father after having been hit by the bullet walked some distance and fell down near the meat shop. The fact that the site plan was drawn up after PW 2 pointed out the place of occurrence was stated by the IO (PW 7), even in the chief examination. The version of PW 2, the child witness is materially different. According to him, the incident took place at the meat shop itself. This is what PW 2 categorically stated:

“The meat shop is at Baxipur. It is the shop of Achhan (PW 3). I and my father reached the meat shop. Before my father could purchase meat, the accused Budhu came there and fired a shot. After receiving the bullet injury, my father fell before the shop of Achhan.”

This statement in chief examination was further reinforced and clarified in the following words:

“At the meat shop my father asked Achhan to weigh meat. At that time, beside my father other customers were also present in the shop. Achhan was weighing meat for the customers who were standing ahead of my father. There were many customers present at the shop of Achhan for buying meat. While my father was standing there were many persons standing before and after him for buying meat. I was standing ahead of my father. My father was fired at the place where he was standing. It is true that he fell flat.”

10. Thus the witness was categorical about the spot of occurrence being at the meat shop itself. He further stated in the questions put to him by the court that the bullet hit his father on his back. To a question as to what his father was doing when he was shot at, the witness stated that his father was buying meat. As already noted, according to PW 7, the earliest version of PW 2 was that the accused shot him at a spot close to the meat shop but before he reached the shop. PW 7 drew the site plan as pointed out by PW 2. If what is stated by PW 7 is correct, we have two different versions from PW 2 as regards the scene of offence. In any case, the evidence of PW 2 does not fit into the prosecution case about the place of occurrence. In the face of this discrepancy on a very important aspect, a reasonable doubt arises as to the reliability of the evidence of this child witness.

11. Another circumstance which deserves notice is that as per the version of PW 2, the police came to him four or five days after the occurrence and enquired of him about the details of the murder and had also taken him to the place of murder. PW 7, the IO, has a different story to tell. According to him, after sending the dead body for post-mortem, he recorded the statements of witnesses, Achhan (PW 3) and Aizaz Hussain (PW 2) and got the bloodstained kurta removed from the body of PW 2 and collected samples of bloodstained soil etc. and thereafter inspected the place of occurrence on being pointed out by PW 2 and prepared the site plan accordingly. That means PW 7 claims to have examined PW 2 on the day of the incident itself. But this version is belied by the categorical statement of PW 2 that the police came to him only after four or five days and made enquiries about the murder. PW 7 admitted that he did not record the dates when he took the statement of each witness in the case diary — which is very strange. Amongst the statements found in the first running pages of the case diary, the statement of PW 2 does not figure at all, as seen from the cross-examination of PW 7. All this supports PW 2's version that he was contacted and examined by the police only after four or five days. The question then arises as to why there was such an inordinate delay in examining him. No explanation was forthcoming from the investigating officer in this regard. However, the learned counsel for the respondent State has endeavoured to give a plausible explanation for this. According to him, the IO would not have felt it necessary to adduce the evidence of the child witness on account of the fact that there was another eyewitness, namely, PW 3, who was examined on the same day and who unfortunately became hostile later on. This explanation remains in the area of surmise. The best person to throw light on this aspect is PW 7 but he did not say a word about it. Moreover, PW 7 came forward apparently with an untrue version that he examined PW 2 on the day of the incident itself and drew up the site plan as per the information given by him. The fact that PW 2 was examined and taken to the spot only four or five days after the incident while making it appear on record that he was examined on the same day of the incident casts another doubt on the prosecution case. If PW 2 was in the know of things, why should the police postpone the event of examining him for so many days? Were they trying to project PW 2 as an eyewitness, having failed in their attempts to get direct evidence of others? These are the imponderables in this case. On account of this, a doubt has to be necessarily entertained as to whether PW 2 claimed to be an eyewitness on the day of the incident itself and he in fact witnessed the occurrence.

12. One more point of doubt which makes the version of PW 2 vulnerable to criticism is this: PW 2 stated that the police personnel were already there at the spot by the time his grandfather (PW 1) reached and that the policemen brought a cot and placed the dead body on it. However, this version is inconsistent with that of PW 1 as well as the IO. According to them, the police reached the scene of offence only after the complaint was lodged by PW 1. PW 6 found the dead body lying flat on the ground. All this gives rise to a doubt as to when exactly PW 2 was at the scene of offence.

13. Lastly, it is urged by the learned counsel for the appellant that although in the FIR, PW 2's presence was mentioned by the informant, he did not mention in the FIR that PW 2 told him that the accused killed his father. In the cross-examination, PW 1 stated that he forgot to mention this fact. One way of looking at it is that having regard to the tenor of the FIR in which he made a general statement that many persons tried to catch the accused, the omission to mention what he had been told by PW 2 need not be viewed seriously. Though, by itself, it may not be a significant omission, but, coupled with other doubtful features emerging from the evidence of PW 2 and the IO, this aspect cannot be brushed aside.

14. In view of the doubtful features and other infirmities in the prosecution evidence as discussed above, we are of the view that it is not safe to rely on the evidence of PW 2 whose evidence needs to be scrutinized with due care and caution. It is, however, unnecessary to probe into the other question whether the ocular evidence is inconsistent with the medical evidence. Though it is a case of concurrent finding by both the courts resting on the appreciation of evidence, we are of the view that the trial court and the High Court overlooked certain important aspects in the practical application of the rule of prudence and caution which the High Court itself proceeded to apply in appreciating the evidence of the child witness. The High Court failed to take note of certain telling factors emerging from the evidence on record. There was no critical appraisal of the evidence of PW 2 except focusing attention on two alleged contradictions of no significance and repelling the arguments based on them. Even if the finding that the medical evidence does not go counter to the prosecution case is allowed to remain, there are other fatal infirmities in the evidence relied upon by the prosecution which were not adverted to by the High Court. In these circumstances, we are of the view that it is a fit case for interference under Article 136. Accordingly, we hold that the accused is entitled to benefit of doubt and his conviction ought to be set aside. We, therefore, allow the appeal and direct the authorities concerned to release the accused from the prison forthwith.