Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

S. Rajendran v. Union Of India And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Feb 11, 1998
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, Rajendran, and the third respondent are members of the Jail Department in the Union Territory of Pondicherry. Rajendran was promoted to Assistant Superintendent of Jails on 8 February 1980, while the third respondent, a Scheduled Caste candidate, was directly recruited as a probationary Assistant Superintendent on 4 November 1988. In the seniority list of Assistant Superintendents, Rajendran ranked first and the third respondent fourth.

A single vacancy in the promotional post of Deputy Superintendent of Jails (a Grade C post) arose on 23 July 1990. That vacancy corresponded to a roster point reserved for a Scheduled Caste candidate. Because the third respondent had not yet completed probation or passed the requisite departmental examinations, he was ineligible for promotion at that time. The department’s request to de-reserve the post was denied, and Rajendran was promoted only on an ad hoc basis.

On 6 February 1993 the third respondent became eligible after completing probation, passing the Jail Test and Executive Officers' Test, and gaining three years of regular service. The department sought to appoint him to the reserved vacancy. Rajendran then filed an application before the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) for regularisation of his ad hoc promotion. The CAT initially allowed the application but, on review, set aside its earlier order for error apparent on the face of the record. Rajendran appealed that review decision to the Supreme Court, giving rise to the present judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an ad hoc promotion given to a general category employee could be regularised when the underlying vacancy was reserved for a Scheduled Caste candidate and subject to the carry-forward rules.
  2. How the “single vacancy” carry-forward scheme, as outlined in the Government of India’s reservation brochure and related office memoranda, applied to the 1990 vacancy in the Pondicherry Jail Department.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Arati Ray Choudhury v. Union of India (1974) 1 SCC 87 Clarified treatment of a single reserved roster point that arises in a year with only one vacancy and the mechanism for carrying forward such reservation. Referenced as the basis for the 1975 Office Memorandum that governs carry-forward of single-vacancy reservations; served as the foundational rule applied to the 1990 vacancy.
Jogendra Sethi v. Rabindranath Behura, 1995 Supp (3) SCC 693; (1995) 31 ATC 772 Defined "recruitment year" and affirmed that reserved vacancies must be carried forward for three consecutive calendar years. Used to compute the carry-forward period (1991–1993) for the 1990 reserved vacancy and to justify limiting regularisation of the appellant's promotion.
Malkhan Singh v. Union of India (1997) 2 SCC 33 Reiterated principles on carry-forward of reserved vacancies and the meaning of “recruitment year.” Cited to reinforce the interpretation adopted from Jogendra Sethi regarding the three-year carry-forward rule.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. Statutory framework. The Court examined the 1981 Recruitment Rules for the Pondicherry Jail Department alongside the Government of India’s brochure and Office Memoranda governing reservation and carry-forward of single vacancies.

2. Chronology of the vacancy. A reserved roster point first arose in 1978, became unreserved that year for want of a Scheduled Caste candidate, and was carried forward. In 1983 the vacancy again arose; it was de-reserved with permission and filled by a general candidate, resetting the cycle. The next vacancy occurred on 23 July 1990 and was again reserved.

3. Application of carry-forward rules to 1990 vacancy. Because the 1990 vacancy was reserved and no Scheduled Caste candidate was then eligible, the rules mandated carrying the reservation forward for three recruitment years—1991, 1992, and 1993—after which it would lapse in 1994.

4. Ad hoc promotion justified. Given the mandatory carry-forward period, Respondents 1 and 2 could only grant Rajendran an ad hoc promotion. Any regular appointment from the general category before the lapse of the reservation would contravene the scheme.

5. Eligibility of Respondent 3 in 1993. In 1993 the third respondent became fully qualified, satisfying the probation and examination requirements as well as the three-year service condition. Therefore, the reserved vacancy could and should be filled by him within the carry-forward window.

6. Tribunal's review correct. The CAT’s initial order regularising Rajendran’s promotion conflicted with the reservation policy. Its subsequent review order correcting that error was therefore proper. The Supreme Court agreed, relying on Jogendra Sethi and Malkhan Singh to affirm the computation of the carry-forward period.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed. The Supreme Court upheld the Tribunal’s review order, denying regularisation of the appellant’s ad hoc promotion and allowing the reserved vacancy to be filled by the qualified Scheduled Caste candidate.

Implications: The decision reinforces strict adherence to the single-vacancy carry-forward scheme for Scheduled Caste reservations, confirming that ad hoc promotions granted during the carry-forward period do not create a right to regularisation. The ruling applies the existing reservation framework without setting a new legal precedent.

Show all summary ...

Sujata V. Manohar, J.— The appellant and Respondent 3 belong to the service of the Jail Department of the Government of Pondicherry. The appellant Rajendran was promoted as Assistant Superintendent of Jails on 8-2-1980. The 3rd respondent was directly recruited as a probationer to the post of Assistant Superintendent of Jails on 4-11-1988. The 3rd respondent belongs to a Scheduled Caste. At the material time, in the seniority list of Assistant Superintendents, the appellant was at Serial No. 1 and the 3rd respondent was at Serial No. 4. The next promotional post for Assistant Superintendent of Jails is the post of Deputy Superintendent which is a Grade C post with the pay scale of Rs 1400-2300. Under the Government of Pondicherry, Jail Department, Group C and Group D Posts (Non-Ministerial) Recruitment Rules, 1981, the post of Deputy Superintendent of Jails is to be filled by promotion failing which, by direct recruitment. In the case of recruitment by promotion, the Rules as amended provide that it will be by promotion from regular Assistant Superintendents who have put in not less than three years' continuous service in that grade.

2. On 23-7-1990 a single vacancy arose in the post of Deputy Superintendent of Jails. This vacancy was a reserved vacancy for a Scheduled Caste candidate. Respondent 3 was the only available Scheduled Caste candidate. However, he was not eligible for promotion on that date since he had not completed his period of probation and had not qualified for promotion by passing the departmental tests being Jail Test and Executive Officers' Test. Since no suitable Scheduled Caste candidate was available for promotion, the department applied for dereservation of the post so that a general category candidate could be appointed to that post. This request, however, was turned down and the department was advised by the Government to fill up the post on an ad hoc basis until a suitable Scheduled Caste candidate became available. Accordingly, the appellant was appointed Deputy Superintendent by promotion on an ad hoc basis. On 6-2-1993 Respondent 3 became eligible for promotion since he was declared to have satisfactorily completed his period of probation and since he had also qualified by passing the two departmental tests. By then he had also completed three years of regular service. The department accordingly moved the Government for appointing the 3rd respondent in the reserved post. Thereupon the appellant filed an application before the Central Administrative Tribunal at Pondicherry for regularisation of his appointment as a Deputy Superintendent. His application was allowed. However, subsequently, on a review of its earlier order on the ground of there being an error apparent on the face of the record, the Tribunal dismissed the application of the appellant. Hence, the appellant has come by way of present appeal against the order of the Tribunal in review.

3. The brochure on “Reservation For Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in Services” issued by the Government of India, in para 11.3 in Chapter 11 deals with reservations and carry-forward of a single vacancy arising in a year. It provides as follows:

“In cases where only one vacancy occurs in the initial recruitment year and the corresponding roster point happens to be for a Scheduled Caste or a Scheduled Tribe, it should be treated as unreserved and filled accordingly and the reservation carried forward to subsequent three recruitment years, but in the subsequent recruitment year(s), even if there is only one vacancy, it should be treated as “Reserved” against the carried forward reservation from the initial recruitment year, and a Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribe candidate, if available, should be appointed in that vacancy, although it may happen to be the only vacancy in that recruitment year(s).”

In this connection OM No. 1/9/74-Estt.(SCT) dated 29-4-1975 further provides that the matter has been considered in the light of the judgment of the Supreme Court dated 11-10-1973 in the case of Arati Ray Choudhury v. Union of India (1974) 1 SCC 87 and it has now been decided that in partial modification of OM dated 4-12-1963 and 2-9-1964, while in cases where only one vacancy occurs in the initial recruitment year and the corresponding roster point happens to be for a Scheduled Caste or a Scheduled Tribe, it should be treated as unreserved and filled accordingly and the reservation carried forward to subsequent three recruitment years as hitherto. In the subsequent years, even if there is only one vacancy, it should be treated as “Reserved” against the carried forward reservation from the initial recruitment year and a Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribe candidate, if available, should be appointed in that vacancy, although it may happen to be the only vacancy in that recruitment year. For instance, if a single vacancy arises in the initial recruitment year 1975, and it falls at a reserved point in the roster, it will be treated as “unreserved” and filled accordingly in that year but the reservation would be carried forward to subsequent recruitment years. In the first subsequent year i.e 1976, if again, a single vacancy occurs, then it should be treated as “reserved” against the reservation carried forward from 1975 and a Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribe candidate, should be appointed against that vacancy. In the event of Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribe candidate not being available to fill the reserved vacancy in 1976, the reservation would be further carried forward to 1977 and 1978, when also a single vacancy, if any, arising in those years should be treated as “reserved” against the carried forward reservation, whereafter, the reservation will lapse.

4. In the present case, a single vacancy for the post of Deputy Superintendent against a roster point which was reserved for a Scheduled Caste candidate arose in the year 1978. This was the initial recruitment year. In that year since no Scheduled Caste candidate was available it was treated as “unreserved” and the reservation was carried forward to the next recruitment year which was 1983 when a single vacancy arose. This vacancy was treated as a “reserved” vacancy. However, since a Scheduled Caste candidate was not available for this vacancy an application was made for dereserving this vacancy which was granted. It was thereupon filled by a general category candidate and the reservation was carried forward or transferred to the next recruitment year which would now be the initial recruitment year for the reserved vacancy since the earlier point was dereserved. The next recruitment year was 1990 when the next vacancy arose. This is how the vacancy which arose on 23-7-1990 was reserved for a Scheduled Caste candidate. Since no Scheduled Caste candidate was available in 1990 and since the application of the department for dereservation was rejected, this vacancy as per the rules set out above, was required to be carried forward for three recruitment years. The vacancy was accordingly carried forward for the next three recruitment years being the years 1991, 1992 and 1993. In 1994 the reservation would have lapsed if no suitable Scheduled Caste candidate was available. However, in 1993 the 3rd respondent was available for filling up the reserved vacancy in the Scheduled Caste category. That is why, to prevent the appointment of Respondent 3, the appellant filed the application before the Central Administrative Tribunal in July 1993.

5. In the background of this factual position, the action of Respondents 1 and 2 in giving only an ad hoc promotion to the appellant appears to be justified. Because they were required to carry forward the reserved vacancy for three subsequent years, the reservation would lapse only in the year 1994. The occasion, however, for making an appointment from the general category in 1994 did not arise.

6. In the case of Jogendra Sethi v. Rabindranath Behura 1995 Supp (3) SCC 693, (1995) 31 ATC 772 this Court considered the provisions with regard to reservation of posts for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in Orissa made in the Orissa Reservation of Vacancies in Posts and Services (For Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes) Act, 1971. It considered the provision for carry-forward of vacancy for three years of recruitment and held that the first recruitment year would be the year in which the vacancy arose and it was required to be carried forward for three subsequent calendar years looking to the definition of “recruitment year” in the said Act. Under the brochure on “Reservation for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in Services” also, in Chapter 11, para 11.1, Note (1) defines “recruitment year” to mean “a calendar year and for purposes of the three years' limit for carry-forward of reserved vacancies it shall mean the year in which recruitment is actually made”. The vacancy, therefore, was required to be carried forward for three calendar years starting with 1991. (See also in this connection Malkhan Singh v. Union of India (1997) 2 SCC 33.)

7. In the premises the Tribunal had correctly reviewed its earlier order and dismissed the application of the appellant. The present appeals are, therefore, dismissed. There will, however, be no order as to costs.