- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Amir Mohammad v. Gafoor Ahmed Khan & Ors.(10)
Factual and Procedural Background
This is a Civil Misc. Appeal under O. 43 R. 1(a) C.P.C. against the order of the Additional District Judge, Baran dated 10.11.1975 in Civil Suit No. 10/75, which held that the suit was triable by the revenue court and ordered the plaint returned to the plaintiff-appellant for presentation in the proper court. The plaintiff-appellant had filed a suit in the Additional District Judge's court for cancellation of a sale deed dated 22.4.1974 (registered 24.4.1974) executed by defendant-respondent No. 3 Mst. Samiran in favour of respondents Nos. 1 & 2, relating to agricultural land Khasra No. 279 (10 bighas 15 biswas), which the plaintiff alleged belonged to him and was in his possession. Respondents raised a preliminary objection that the suit related to agricultural land and was triable by the revenue court. Prior facts on record include an asserted earlier sale by Mst. Samiran to the plaintiff on 6.12.1961 (allegedly unregistered) and revenue proceedings in which the plaintiff asserted khatedari/possession, including a decree or decision in his favour and subsequent appellate/revision rejections up to the Board of Revenue.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a suit for cancellation of a sale deed affecting agricultural land is triable by a civil court or is exclusively triable by the revenue court.
- Whether a prayer for cancellation of a subsequent sale deed, without a prayer for declaration of khatedari rights, nevertheless amounts to seeking a declaration of khatedari that would render the suit within exclusive revenue jurisdiction.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- Counsel Shri J.K. Singhi submitted that the only relief claimed was cancellation of the sale deed dated 22.4.1974, and that such relief is exclusively cognizable by a civil court because a revenue court could not grant cancellation of a sale deed.
- It was contended that the lower court erred in treating a prayer for cancellation as tantamount to a claim for declaration of khatedari rights, thereby ousting civil jurisdiction.
- Factually, the appellant relied on an earlier sale to him on 6.12.1961, his possession antecedent to the later sale, and an asserted favourable result in revenue proceedings (including admissions by Mst. Samiran) to show the dispute on cancellation did not require exclusive revenue adjudication in the civil forum.
Respondents' Arguments
- Counsel Shri S.P. Tyagi supported the impugned judgment, arguing correctly that the suit was not triable by a civil court and that returning the plaint for presentation before the appropriate revenue court was proper.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Chandanmal v. Dawa (1954 R.L.W 184) | The court must look to the substance of the plaint and not merely its outlook when determining forum. | The trial court relied on this principle; the present court acknowledged and agreed with the principle but distinguished the present facts. |
| Ashata v. Narain (1963 RLW 323) | Such questions should be decided on the allegations in the plaint taken in their essence to determine the true nature and object of the suit. | The court accepted the principle but noted each case depends on its facts and applied it to examine that only cancellation was prayed here. |
| Shankerlal v. Dhulilal (1963 RLW 313) | It should not be lightly inferred that the jurisdiction of a civil court is barred unless such inference arises by express provision or necessary implication. | The court cited the principle and treated it as a cautionary rule while distinguishing the present case from those where revenue jurisdiction was exclusive. |
| Mohanlal… v. Ratna…. (AIR 1971 Raj. 164) | Where cancellation of a document is sought but the real controversy is seeking a declaration of khatedari rights, the suit is triable exclusively by the revenue court. | The court referred to this authority as showing circumstances where revenue jurisdiction is exclusive but distinguished the present suit on its facts (no declaration prayed). |
| Gurcharan v. Mst. Gurdayal Kaur (AIR 1982 Raj 91) | A suit dealing with composite matters including reliefs not referable to revenue court is cognizable by the civil court; cancellation/reliefs not grantable by revenue court render civil forum appropriate. | The court treated this decision as directly applicable and supportive: since cancellation cannot be granted by a revenue court and the present suit only seeks cancellation, civil court jurisdiction is appropriate. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Bench heard counsel and examined the record. It applied the established principles that the substance of the plaint and the true nature of the suit (as shown by the allegations) determine forum. The court observed that (a) the plaint sought only cancellation of the sale deed dated 22.4.1974 and did not seek a declaration of khatedari rights; (b) there was on record a certified plaint and reply from earlier revenue proceedings indicating the appellant's claim of prior purchase and possession and an admission by Mst. Samiran; and (c) prior revenue adjudications had addressed tenancy/possession disputes up to the Board of Revenue. The court further noted the legal position that cancellation of a sale deed is not a relief grantable by a revenue court and relied on Gurcharan v. Mst. Gurdayal Kaur to hold that where cancellation is the sole relief, the civil forum is competent. Distinguishing earlier authorities where cancellation was merely a guise to obtain declaratory khatedari relief triable exclusively by revenue courts, the court concluded the lower court erred in returning the plaint for presentation to the revenue court.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL ALLOWED.
The order of the Additional District Judge, Baran dated 10-11-1975 is set aside. The Additional District Judge, Baran is directed to proceed with the suit and decide it in accordance with law on a priority basis. The direct effect on the parties is that the suit for cancellation will be adjudicated by the civil court. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new precedent beyond the application of cited authorities to the facts of this case.
I.S Israni, J.:— This is a Civil Misc. Appeal under O. 43 R. 1(a) C.P.C against the order of learned Additional District Judge, Baran dated 10.11.1975 in civil suit No. 10/75, by which it was held that the suit is triable by the revenue court and the plaint was ordered to be returned to the plaintiff appellant for presenting the same in proper court.
2. The plaintiff appellant filed a suit for cancellation of sale deed in the court of Additional District Judge, Baran regarding the agricultural land bearing Khasra No. 279, measuring 10 bighas and 15 biswas, which, belonged to him and was in his possession. It was further asserted that the defendant-respondent No. 3 Samiran had no right to sale the disputed land in favour of defendant-respondents No. 1 and 2 by executing a sale deed in their favour on 22.4.1974, which was got registered on 24.4.1974 It was prayed that a decree for cancellation of the above mentioned sale deed be passed in favour of the appellant A preliminary objection was raised by the respondents that suit was with regard to agricultural land, it was triable by the revenue court. After hearing arguments of both sides, learned Additional District Judge vide his order dated 10.11.1975 held that the suit is not triable by the civil court and the plaint should be returned to the appellant for presentation in proper revenue court.
3. It may be mentioned that before respondent No. 3 executed sale deed in favour of respondents No. 1 and 2 on 22.4.1974 she had sold out this land to the plaintiff for consideration of Rs. 1300/- on 6.12.1961 even though according to the appellant he had been in possession of the land since about 4-5 years before the above sale deed. This sale deed was executed on a stamp paper of Rs. 39/- and it appears that it was not got registered. The appellant, therefore, filed a suit in the court of Assistant Collector, Baran for declaring him to be khatedar tenant of the above land. It has been asserted by the appellant that the above suit was decreed in his favour on an admission made by Mst. Samiran in the said court. Subsequently, she again sold the same land for consideration of Rs. 8,000/- to respondents No. 1 and 2 as mentioned above. Learned counsel for the appellant Shri J.K Singhi has contended that only relief claimed in the plaint was cancellation of sale deed in favour of respondents No. 1 and 2, therefore, this suit was exclusively triable by a civil court as this relief could not have been granted by a revenue court. He has therefore, urged that the lower court has seriously erred in holding that even though the relief claimed in the suit is couched in the manner that it looks like making only a prayer for cancellation of sale deed executed in favour of respondents No. 1 & 2 but the relief, if awarded, would actually’ amount to grant of declaration that the plaintiff is a khatedar tenant of the suit land and, therefore, the 3rd defendant had no right to sale the said land in dispute.
4. Shri S.P Tyagi, learned counsel for the respondents on the other hand has supported the impugned judgment and contended that it has been rightly held that the suit was not triable by a civil court and it has been properly returned to the plaintiff for presentation to a revenue court of competent jurisdiction.
5. I have heard learned counsel for both the parties and gone through the record of the case. The trial court has relied upon the case of (1) Chandanmal v. Dawa (1954 R.L.W 184) in which this court has held that while deciding such nutters the court must look to the substance of the plaint and not merely its outlook. In the case of (2) Ashata v. Narain, (1963 RLW 323) it has been laid down in to such questions should be decided on the allegations made in the plaint taken in their essence and it should be seen what is the true nature of the suit and the object as disclosed by the allegations contained in the plaint. In the case of (3) Shankerlal v. Dhulilal (1963 RLW 313) it has been lain down that it should not be lightly inferred that the jurisdiction of a civil court is barred, unless such on inference could be raised by express provisions of law or by necessary implication. In the case of (4) Mohanlal… v. Ratna…. (AIR 1971 Raj. 164), it was held by this court that where the plaintiff had claimed a relief of cancellation of a document on the ground that the plaintiff has by fraud made to admit in a document executed by him that he was only a sharer in ⅓rd of the agricultural land, which was in dispute, while in fact he was sharer of 1 ½ it was clearly a case where real controversy was the desire of the plaintiff to seek declaration that he was khatedar of half share in the land. It was therefore held that such a suit was triable exclusively by the revenue court and not by the civil court.
6. I am in respectful agreement with the principles laid down in the above cases, but these cases referred to above are not of much help to the respondents, as each case has to be decided on the facts of its own. In the present case the only relief claimed is cancellation of subsequent sale deed dated 22.4.1974 executed in favour of respondents No. I & 2. No declaration has been prayed regarding khatedari rights of the plaintiff. It may be further noted that certified copy of the plaint filed by the appellant against Mst. Samiran & others in the court as Assistant Collector, Baran is on record, in which it has been asserted that Mst Samiran had sold this land to the appellant for consideration. Therefore, the appellant is khatedar tenant of this land, which was in his possession. A certified copy of the reply filed by Mst. Samiran has also been placed on record of trial court, in which she has admitted all assertions made by the appellant. A suit was also filed by Abdul Saqoor and Gafoor Ahmed sons of Allanodr against Amirkhan claiming possession of the land in dispute in which their application for stay was rejected by the Deputy Collector, Baran holding that the possession of the disputed land was with appellant Amir Mohammad and appeal against this order was filed before the Revenue Appellate Authority, which was also rejected. A revision petition against the order of Revenue Appellate Authority was filed before the Board of Revenue for Rajasthan at Ajmer, which was also rejected on 17.3.73 This clearly shows that all disputes regarding tenancy or possession of the disputed land have been dealt with by appropriate revenue courts. The present case was filed, in which the only prayer made was for cancellation of sale deed dated 22.4.1974 executed by defendant No. 3 Mst. Semiran in favour of defendant-respondent Nos. 1 & 2.
7. It may also be pointed out that the relief of cancellation of sale deed cannot be granted by any revenue court. My attention has been drawn to a decision of Division Bench in the case of (5) Gurcharan v. Mst. Gurdayal Kaur, (AIR 1982 Raj 91). in which a suit was instituted by Shyam Kaur and others for cancellation of decree dated March 7, 1963 passed in Civil Suit No. 7/61 by the Assistant Collector, Hanumangarh on the ground tbat it was collusive and fraudulent and that Smt. Shyam Kaur not being a party to suit No. 7/61 was not bound by the decree. It was also prayed in the plaint that declaration may also be made with regard to the share of the plaintiff and Smt. Suchivar Kaur defendants and after partition, possession of their shares may also be delivered to them. In this case, it was held that the suit instituted by the plaintiffs deals with the composite matter and the suit was cognizable by a civil court and not by revenue court as other relief's could not be referred to the revenue court. The law laid down in this case is applicable with full force to the facts of this case also as this is a case, in which even a composite question is not involved and the only relief claimed is that of cancellation of sale deed dt. 22-4-1974 executed by respondent No. 3 in favour of respondent Nos. 1 & 2.
8. I am, therefore, of the considered opinion that the Additional District Judge, has erred in holding that the suit was triable by a revenue court. In the result, this appeal is allowed. The order of learned Additional District Judge. Baran dated 10-11-1975 is set-aside and the Additional District Judge, Baran is directed to proceed with the suit and decide the same in accordance with law on priority basis as the suit has become quite old.
9. Appeal allowed with cost.
Alert