Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Satish Chander And Others v. Rattan Chand And Others

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Aug 4, 2008
Smart Summary (Beta)

Written Summary of the Opinion (Rakesh Kumar Jain, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiffs instituted a suit for partition seeking separate possession of a half share in joint property measuring 2 kanals 9 marlas (Khasra No. 1580) in village Dohar, Tehsil Dasuya, District Hoshiarpur. The plaintiffs supplied a pedigree showing that they are descendants of Shobha Ram while the defendants are descendants of Jangi, real brothers who allegedly each owned one-half of the ancestral property. Plaintiffs alleged joint possession, claimed to have planted trees on the eastern corner and alleged that defendant Nos. 2–6 had raised construction on the western corner and threatened further constructions and forcible dispossession; plaintiffs sought partition after defendants refused.

Defendants filed a written statement raising preliminary objections (non-joinder of necessary parties, valuation for court-fee and jurisdiction, and partial partition) and on merits made various denials and factual averments, including that portions were abadi deh and that their ancestors occupied abadi sites. The plaintiffs filed replication. The trial court framed several issues (including ownership to 1/2 share, non-joinder, valuation, partial partition and relief). Both parties led oral and documentary evidence.

The trial court found (inter alia) that (i) Satish Chander was the adopted son of Bhagat Ram; (ii) on pleadings and evidence the property was joint and plaintiffs were entitled to 1/2 share; and therefore decreed a preliminary decree for partition on 12.10.1985. The defendants appealed. The lower appellate court interpreted pleadings differently, held that the land was a gairmumkin abadi and relied on Bur Singh v. Sant Singh (AIR 1934 Lahore 327) to hold that no suit for partition lay; it allowed the appeal. The plaintiffs (appellants before the present court) challenged that judgment and raised substantial questions of law. The present court heard the appeal and restored the trial court's judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether non-dealing with the admission made by Rattan Chand (DW-1) vitiates the judgment of the lower Appellate Court when the trial court considered that admission while decreeing the suit?
  2. Whether the pleadings, evidence on record and Jamabandi for 1979–1980 (Annexure P-6) were misread and misinterpreted by the lower Appellate Court while reversing the trial court?
  3. Whether the lower Appellate Court made out a new case for the defendants that the suit property is not partible, when the defendants' case was that the suit was bad for partial partition?
  4. Whether the judgment in Bur Singh v. Sant Singh (AIR 1934 Lahore 327) applies to the facts of the present case, given that defendants did not assert that the suit property is not partible?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' (Plaintiffs') Arguments

  • The first appellate court misread, did not read or misinterpreted the pleadings and evidence and erred in concluding that plaintiffs failed to prove a 1/2 share when that fact was admitted in Para 4 of the plaint and not specifically denied.
  • Para 4 of the plaint contained two categorical averments: descent from Shobha Ram and Jangi Ram (real brothers) and that those brothers were owners to 1/2 share each; the written statement did not specifically deny that Shobha Ram and Jangi Ram had 1/2 share each and thus those facts are deemed admitted under Order 8 Rule 3 and Order 8 Rule 5 CPC.
  • Counsel relied on statutory rules (Order 8 R.3 & R.5 CPC) and case law (Sukhdev Sharma v. State of Haryana; M. Venkataramana Hebbar v. M. Rajagopal Hebbar) to contend that evasive or non-specific denials are treated as admissions and need not be separately proved.
  • The trial court correctly took into account admissions by DW-1 Rattan Chand (that the land is ancestral and jointly held) and other oral evidence; the first appellate court erred in ignoring or failing to deal with that admission.
  • The first appellate court wrongly applied Bur Singh's case; that precedent is inapplicable on facts because here the disputed land is a small family site (2 kanals 9 marlas) and not shamlat/abadi land used by the community or occupied by individual houses in a manner making partition inappropriate.

Respondents' (Defendants') Arguments

  • Jamabandi (Exhibit P-6, 1979–80) shows the land as abadi deh; relying on Bur Singh v. Sant Singh, abadi portions (occupied by houses or used for public purposes) are not liable to partition.
  • Para 4 of the written statement did not amount to an admission that Shobha Ram and Jangi Ram owned 1/2 share each in the disputed plot; the pleading was not a categorical admission.
  • An evasive plea in Para 6 suggested that Shobha Ram had settled in a different abadi (Khasra No. 2241/1363), implying that Sant Ram and Bhagat Ram each had separate abadi sites and that the disputed plot belonged to defendants; accordingly, the first appellate court's conclusion was proper and should not be interfered with.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bur Singh v. Sant Singh, AIR 1934 Lahore 327 Principle that portions of abadi occupied by houses of villagers or used for public purposes may not be partitionable (limitation on partition in respect of communal/abadi areas). The lower Appellate Court relied on this case to hold that the disputed land (shown as abadi deh in Jamabandi) could not be the subject of partition and therefore allowed the appeal. The present court distinguished Bur Singh on facts, holding it inapplicable because the disputed land here is a small family site (2 kanals 9 marlas) and not shamlat/communal abadi land; therefore Bur Singh did not bar partition in this case.
Sukhdev Sharma v. State of Haryana, 1993 (1) PLR 107 Principle that a written statement must specifically deal with each allegation of fact; evasive or non-specific denials may be treated as admissions. The present court relied on this authority to support the conclusion that, where the defendants did not specifically deny the pleaded ancestral ownership and pedigree in Para 4 of the plaint, those averments were to be treated as admitted and thus did not require independent proof.
M. Venkataramana Hebbar (D) By L.Rs v. M. Rajagopal Hebbar, 2007 (2) RCR (Civil) 404 : JT 2007 (6) SC 164 Confirmed that under Order 8 Rule 3 and Order 8 Rule 5 CPC and Section 58 of the Evidence Act, non-denial of plaint averments results in deemed admission and such facts need not be separately proved. The court invoked this decision to support the legal proposition that the defendants' failure to specifically deny the plaintiffs' averments regarding ancestry and ancestral ownership rendered those averments admitted; this formed part of the basis for restoring the trial court's decree.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in discrete steps based on the text of the opinion:

  1. Admission in Pleadings: The court first identified that Para 1 of the plaint (pedigree) and Para 4 (that the parties descend from Shobha Ram and Jangi Ram, real brothers, and that those brothers owned half shares each) were not specifically denied by the defendants in their written statement. Applying Order 8 Rule 3 and Order 8 Rule 5 CPC (as interpreted in cited authorities), the court treated these pleadings as deemed admitted.
  2. Oral Admission by DW-1: The court noted that DW-1 Rattan Chand admitted in cross-examination that the entire land was ancestral and had come to Shobha Ram and Bhagat Ram from their ancestors, and that the disputed land fell in Khasra No. 1580. The court considered this an admissive oral statement corroborating the plaintiffs' pleaded pedigree and ownership contentions.
  3. Evaluation of Lower Appellate Court's Approach: The court found the first Appellate Court's view—that no admission could be presumed from the relevant paragraphs and that the land was abadi deh not partitionable—to be based on misreading/misinterpretation of pleadings and evidence. The present court held that the appellate court erred by not treating the non-specific denials as admissions and by not dealing with the oral admission of DW-1.
  4. Distinction with Bur Singh: The lower Appellate Court relied on Bur Singh v. Sant Singh to conclude partition could not be granted over abadi land. The present court examined Bur Singh's facts and reasoning and concluded it was distinguishable: Bur Singh involved circumstances where the plaintiff failed to show an empty site not used by the community and where abadi portions used for communal/public purposes were held not partible. Here, the land was described as a small family site (2 kanals 9 marlas) forming part of the parties' ancestral holding and not shamlat/communal abadi; hence Bur Singh did not apply.
  5. Legal Synthesis: Combining (i) the deemed admission in the pleadings; (ii) the specific oral admission by DW-1; and (iii) the established principle that joint property is ordinarily partitionable (the right to partition being incident to joint ownership), the court concluded the trial court's findings were correct and sustainable.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Appeal allowed. The judgment of the first Appellate Court is set aside and the judgment and decree of the trial Court (which decreed the suit and granted a preliminary decree for separate possession by way of partition) is restored.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The plaintiffs' decree in the trial court for partition and separate possession of their half share is reinstated. The first Appellate Court's contrary decision (which had allowed the defendants' appeal) is overturned.
  • On legal principles: The court reaffirmed that (a) pleadings not specifically denied are deemed admitted under Order 8 Rules (and related authorities), (b) oral admissions by a defendant witness are material, and (c) Bur Singh's restriction on partition of abadi land is fact-specific and not automatically applicable where the disputed land forms a family/ancestral holding and is not communal shamlat/abadi used by the village community. The opinion did not assert the setting of any novel precedent beyond these applications and distinctions.
Show all summary ...

Rakesh Kumar Jain, J.:— The plaintiffs/appellants have filed a suit for partition by way of separate possession of ½ share of the joint property of the parties measuring kanals 9 marlas falling in Khewat No. 90, Khatauni No. 27, khasra No. 1580 situated in village Dohar, Had bast No: 602, Tehsil Dasuya, District Hoshiarpur.

2. In order to establish the relation between the plaintiffs and the defendants the plaintiffs have given the following pedigree table:—

3. The plaintiffs are the descendants of Shobha Ram whereas the defendants are the descendants of Jangi, who were reals brothers and were owners of the suit property to the extent of ½ share each. They were the original proprietors of the village and therefore they had share in the sham-lat as well as abadi deh. It is claimed by the plaintiffs that their ancestors as well as ancestors of the defendants had settled in khasa No. 1580 measuring 2 Kanals 9 marlas and started using it as abadi. The plaintiffs have asserted that they are in joint possession of the land which is subject matter of the dispute in which they had even planted valuable trees towards the eastern corner. The allegation is that about two years back defendant Nos. 2 to 6 had raised construction on the western corner of the suit property and again threatened one week before the filing of the suit, to raise new construction in the joint land in their possession by cutting the trees and by dispossessing them forcibly. The plaintiffs had asked for partition of the suit land, but the defendants had refused, hence this suit.

4. On notice of the suit, the defendants filed their written statement in which preliminary objection was taken that the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties; the suit is not valued for the purpose of Court fee and jurisdiction and is bad for partial partition. On merits, so far Para No. 1 is concerned, pedigree table has been admitted but relation of plaintiff with Bhagat Singh was denied on the ground that he was not his adopted son. However, they have admitted that Jawala and others were proprietors of the village. They did not specifically deny that Shobha Ram and Jangi had ½ share each in the suit property. They further pleaded that actually their ancestors and now they have their houses in the site in dispute which is abadi deh and that Sant Ram had his abadi in khasra No. 2241/1363. They have further claimed that trees have been plated by them in the suit property. They denied that Sant Ram had any share in the suit property.

5. The plaintiffs filed replication controverting the stand of the defendants and reiterated the stand taken by them in the plaint.

6. From the pleadings of the parties, the following issues were struck by the trial Court:—

1. Whether the plaintiffs are the owners to the extent of 112 share out of the suit property? OPP

2. Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties? OPD

3. Whether the suit is properly valued for the purpose of Court fee and jurisdiction? OPD

4. Whether the suit is bad for partial partition? OPD

5. Relief.

7. Both plaintiffs and the defendants led oral as well as documentary evidence in support of their respective contentions.

8. The trial Court while dealing with issue No. 1, split it into two parts, namely, whether plaintiff Satish Chander is the adopted son of Bhagat Ram and secondly as to whether plaintiffs have ½ share each in the suit property?

9. On the basis of the evidence available on the file, it was found by the trial Court that Satish Chander is the adopted son of Bhagat Ram. So far as the second part is concerned with regard to the plaintiffs' ownership to the extent of ½ share in the suit property, it was held that the pedigree-table in Para No. 1 has been admitted by the defendants in the written statement and on the basis of the pleading of the parties, wherein, in Para 4 of the plaint, it is mentioned that the parties are descendants of Shobha Ram and Jangi Ram who were real brothers and in that way Shobha Ram and Jangi Ram were owners in their ancestral property to the extent of ½ share each. The paragraph in the written statement has not been denied specifically. However, it is denied the plaintiffs have no relationship with defendants. Therefore, in the absents of specific denial, it was presumed by the trial court that the defendants admitted that Shoba Ram and Jangi Ram were the owners in equal share of the suit property. The trial Court also took into consideration the arguments raised by the defendants that Exhibit P-6 which is a copy of Jambabandi for the year 1979–1980, khasra No. 1580 (2 kanals 9 marlas) has been mentioned as gairmumkin abadi and in column of possession, it is mentioned as abadi deh, therefore, the suit property belongs to all the proprietors of the village being misconceived argument as there was no such pleading rather in Para 4, pleading of the plaintiff was that Shobha Ram and Jangi Ram had ½ share in the property in question which was not specifically denied, not it was pleaded by the defendants that the suit property belongs to all the proprietors of the village and not exclusively by Shobha Ram and Jangi Ram, therefore, it was found to be an argument beyond pleadings and was not considered. It was also found by the trial court that abadi of the village Dohar cannot be only 2 kanals 9 marlas. The trail court also discussed the statement of Satish Chander who appeared as PW-1, who had categorically stated that they had ½ share in the suit property but no specific suggestion was given to him by the defendants to the effect that the plaintiffs did not have ½ share in the suit property. Onkar Singh PW-3 and Munshi Ram had also stated that ancestors of the parties had joined khata. Rattan Chand appeared as DW-1, who admitted that the property is joint with Sant Ram and Bhagat Ram and their ancestors did not purchase any property which is joint till today. In these circumstances, the trial court found that the property in dispute is joint property which is owned by the parties.

10. On the basis of pleadings on record, the trial court vide its judgment and decree dated 12.10.1985 decreed the suit and ordered for a preliminary decree holding the plaintiff to be entitled to a separate possession by way of partition. The defendants had filed an appeal in which the lower appellate court while interpreting Para No. 1 of the plaint with the corresponding paragraph of the written statement observed that no admission can be presumed in view of the averments made by the defendants in Para 4 of the written statement but it was also held that since the land in dispute is a gairmumk in abadi, therefore, no suit for partition can be filed in view of the law laid down in Bur Singh v. Sant Singh, AIR 1934 Lahore 327. It was also held that in Para No. 6 of the written statement, the defendant had taken the plea that Shobha Ram had settled in abadi deh site comprised in khasra No. 2241/1363, therefore, in all probabilities, Sant Ram and his brother Bhagat Ram owned and possessed separate abadi sites whereas, Rattan Chand and others had the suit plot for their abadi. The first appellate court thus allowed the appeal.

11. Mr. D.R Mahajan, learned counsel for the appellants has argued that the finding recorded by the first appellate court is based upon misreading, non-reading and mis-interpreting the pleading as well as the evidence on record. It has been argued that the first appellate court has erred in law in observing that the plaintiffs have failed to prove that they had ½ share in the suit plot, though this fact is admitted by the defendants in view of the averments made in Para 4 of the plaint which may be read with the corresponding paragraph 4 of the written statement which are reproduced herein below for ready reference:

Para 4 of the plaint. That the parties are descendants of Shobha Ram and Jangi Ram, who were real brothers and in this way, Shobha Ram and Jangi Ram were owners in ancestral property to the extent of ½ share each.

Paragraph 4 of the written statement. Para 4 is mis-stated. The defendants are related to each other put the plaintiff has no relationship with the defendants or their ancestors.

12. Learned counsel for the appellants has referred to the provisions of Order 8 Rule 3 and Order 8 Rule 5 of CPC which is reproduced as under:—

“3. Denial to be specific. — It shall not be sufficient for a defendant in his written statement to deny generally the grounds alleged by the plaintiff, but the defendant must deal specifically with each allegation of fact of which he does not admit the truth, except damages.

Specific denial. — [(1)] Every allegation of fact in the plaint, …………….specifically or by necessary implication, or stated to be not admitted in the pleading of the defendant, shall be taken to be admitted except as against a person under disability:

Provided that the Court may in its discretion require any fact so admitted to be proved otherwise than by such admission.

[(2) Where the defendant has not filed a pleading, it shall be lawful for the Court to pronounce judgment on the basis of the facts contained in the plaint, except as against a person under a disability, but the Court may, in its discretion, require any such fact to be proved.

(3) In exercising its discretion under the proviso to sub-rule (1) or under sub-rule (2), the Court shall have due regard to the fact whether the defendant could have or has engaged a pleader.

(4) Whenever a judgment is pronounced under this rule, a decree shall be drawn up in accordance with such judgment and such decree shall bear the date on which the judgment was pronounced.]”

13. Mr. Mahajan has vehemently argued that Para 4 of the plaint was categoric in respect of two facts: i) that the parties are descendants of Shobha Ram and Jangi Ram who were real brothers and ii) that Shobha Ram and Jangi Ram were owners in ancestral property to the extent of ½ share each. Defendants did not categorically deny the averments to the effect that Shobha Ram and Jangi Ram were not owners in ancestral property to the extent of ½ share each. Rather it was vaguely replied and mis-stated and had been wrongly denied that the plaintiff had no relationship with the defendants or their ancestors', whereas pedigree table given in Para No. 1 of the plaintiff has been admitted to be correct except for the relationship of the plaintiff-Satish Chander with Bhagat Ram who has been denied to be his adopted son, although appellate Court has held that he has been proved to be adopted son of Bhagat Ram. Therefore, learned counsel for the appellants has argued that non-denial in the written statement of the observations even in the plaint is also an admission and if there is vague denial that too is an admission which need not be proved. Learned counsel has referred to Sukhdev Sharma… v. State Of Haryana…., 1993 (2) RRR 28 : 1993 (1) PLR 107, in which it was held that written statement must deal specifically with each allegation of fact in the petition and when a respondent denies any such fact, he must not do so evasively but answers the point of substance, if his denial of fact is not specific but evasive. Such fact shall be taken to be admitted. In such an event, admission itself, being proved, no further proof is necessary Learned counsel further cited the decision of the Apex Court in the case of M. Venkataramana Hebbar (D) By L.Rs v. M. Rajagopal Hebbar, 2007 (2) RCR (Civil) 404 : 2007 (2) RAJ 403 : JT 2007 (6) SC 164 wherein it was held that in view of Order 8 Rule 3 and Orders 8 Rule 5 CPC, Section 58 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, if there is no denial of the averments of the plaint in the written statement, averments would be deemed to be admitted and the courts are entitled to draw an inference that the same has been admitted which fact is admitted and the fact of admission in terms of Section 58 need not to be proved.

14. Learned counsel further argued that the findings recorded by the first appellate court in respect of interpretation of Para 4 of the plaint and the written statement are patently erroneous where it has been observed that in the written statement, it was not admitted that Shobha Ram and Jangi Ram has. ½ share in the suit plot. Learned counsel further argued that the first appellate court has not at all referred to the statement of Rattan Chand defendant who had appeared a DW-1 and categorically admitted that his entire land is ancestral which had come to Sant Ram and Bhagat Ram. None of their elders had purchased the 1 and and the same is joint till today. It was also admitted that the land in dispute falls in khasra No. 1580 which is 2 kanals 9 marlas which has also come to them from their ancestors. It was further admitted that the land other than Lal Lakir has not been partitioned and they have no other khasra No. in Lal Lakir. So far as the khasra No. 2241/1363 is concerned, he has shown his ignorance about the source of that land as to whether it came to their ancestor Jawala. Counsel further argued that the finding recorded by the first appellate court that the land of abadi deh cannot be partitioned in view of Bur Singh's case (supra), which has no applicability to the facts of the present case.

15. Rebutting the arguments of learned counsel for the appellants, learned counsel for the defendants Mr., R.K Joshi has argued that in the document Exhibit P-6 which is a jamabandi for the year 1979–1980, the land in question has been shown as abadi deh which according to the learned counsel for the defendants could not be partitioned in view of the law laid down in Bhur-Singhs case (supra). He has further argued that the averment made in Para 4 of the written statement does not show that the defendants have admitted that Shobha Ram and Jangi Ram were the owner of ½ share each in the suit plot. It was also argued that an evasive plea has been taken in Para 6 of the written statement that Shobha Ram had settled in abadi deh comprised in revenue No. 2241/1363, therefore, in both Shobha Ram and his brother Bhagat Ram owned and possessed separate abadi deh site whereas defendant possessed separate abadi deh which is the disputed plot. It was further submitted that the finding recorded by the first appellate court is just proper and does not call for any interference.

16. It is worthwhile to mention here that during the pendency of the aforesaid appeal, the appellant has placed on record substantial question of law involved in this appeal.

1. Whether non-dealing of the admission made by Rattan Chand defendant-respondent, who appeared at the trial of the suit as DW-1, vitiates the judgment passed by the learned lower Appellate Court when the learned trial court has considered this admission while decreeing the suit of the plaintiff-appellant?

2. Whether the pleadings of the parties, the evidence on the record, jamabandi for the year 1979–1980 (Annexure P-6) have been misread and mis-interpreted by the learned lower Appellate Court while reversing the judgment of the learned trial court?

3. Whether the learned lower Appellate Court has made out a new case for the defendant respondents that the suit property is not partible whereas the case of the defendant-respondent was that the suit was bad for partial partition?

4. Whether the judgment in Bur Singh v. Sant Singh, (AIR 1934 Lahore 327) is not at all applicable to the facts of the present case as it is not the case of the defendant-respondents that the suit property is not partible?

17. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and have gone through the file with their assistances.

18. There is no dispute that the defendant has admitted Para 1 of plaint to be correct which contains pedigree table. It is also admitted thatthe parties are descendants of Shobha Ram and Jangi Ram who were real brothers and they had ½ share in the ancestral property. Since this fact is not categorically denied, therefore, it is deemed to have been admitted. Further, DW-1 Rattan Chand has admitted in the cross-examination that the entire land is ancestral which has come to Shobha Ram and Bhagat Ram from their ancestors including the land in dispute which co-relates to the averments made in Para 4 of the plaint. Therefore, the finding that has been recorded by the first appellate court that there is no specific reference in these paragraphs that the suit plot is ancestral is patently erroneous and unsustainable in view of the law laid down in the case of Sukhdev Sharma… v. State Of Haryana…., 1993 (1) PLR 107 and M. Venkataramana Hebbar (D) By L.Rs v. M. Rajagopal Hebbar, 2007 (2) RCR (Civil) 404 : 2007 (2) RAJ 403 : JT 2007 (6) SC 164. So far as the finding of the first appellate court that the portion of the abadi occupied by the houses of the villagers is not liable to partitioned is concerned, in view of Bur Singh's Case (supra), in my view that has no applicability to the facts of the present case because in that case the plaintiff had owned ⅓rd share in the village dismissed on the ground that he had failed to prove that there was an empty site in occupation by any individual and not used by the community for any public purpose. This finding was not challenged by plaintiff Bur Singh before the High Court, therefore, the appeal was dismissed. It was then observed that portion of the abadi occupied by the houses of the villagers or used for public purposes are not liable to partition. In the present case, the facts are altogether different because the land in question is only 2 kanals 9 marlas belonging to the family of the parties to the suit and is not shamlat land for which proprietors can seek partition by way of dispossessing the persons having residential houses. Even otherwise, it is well settled that the joint property is liable to partition as the right to partition is an incident of joint ownership. Therefore, in my view the judgment rendered in Bur Singh's case (supra) is not applicable to the facts of the present case.

19. In view of the above discussion, the present appeal is allowed. The judgment of the first Appellate Court is set aside and that of the trial Court restored.

Appeal allowed.