- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kamlesh Kumari v. The Punjab University .
Case Summary: Letters Patent Appeal from judgment dated 22 April 1964 (Civil Writ No. 1830 of 1963)
Factual and Procedural Background
The appeal under clause 10 of the Letters Patent arises from the judgment dated 22nd April 1964 of P. C. Pandit, J., in Civil Writ No. 1830 of 1963. The examinee, Kamlesh Kumari (Roll No. 75925), appeared in the Matriculation Examination of Punjab University held in March 1963 at the Jaitu (District Bhatinda) centre. She was disqualified by the Punjab University for employing unfair means in the English Paper 'A' and was debarred from appearing in the Matriculation Examination for two years (1963 and 1964).
Kamlesh Kumari challenged the university's order before this Court on the ground that the rules of natural justice had been violated. The return in the writ petition shows that the impugned order followed an enquiry conducted under the Standing Committee of the Punjab University. The examinee was summoned and appeared on 15th July 1963 before the Deputy Registrar (Examinations) and answered a questionnaire (annexure "R.1"). Prior to her appearance, on 24th June 1963, a report of the Head Examiner (annexure "R.6") had been obtained. Subsequently, on 26th July 1963, a report of an expert (annexure "R.7") was obtained and appended to the return.
The principal grievance of the examinee was that the expert's report (R.7) had not been made known to her and she was given no opportunity to meet that report, despite its use—along with other material—as a basis for the University's order disqualifying her. The learned Single Judge (Pandit, J.) dismissed the writ petition (along with others) principally relying on an earlier Single Judge decision and the Bench decision in Karamjit Kaur v. The Punjab University (1964 63 P.L.R. 674).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the rules of natural justice were violated when the Standing Committee relied upon an expert report (annexure "R.7") that had been obtained after the examinee had answered the questionnaire and which was not disclosed to her or made available for her to meet.
- Whether the judgment of the learned Single Judge dismissing the writ petition (relying on prior decisions such as Karamjit Kaur) was sustainable in light of the non-disclosure of the expert report and applicable precedents.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's (Kamlesh Kumari) Arguments
- The rules of natural justice were violated because the expert's report (annexure "R.7"), which was used in reaching the decision to disqualify her, was not disclosed to her.
- She was given no opportunity at any stage to meet or respond to the expert report, despite it being used as part of the material leading to the final order of disqualification.
Respondent's Position (as reflected in the record)
- The impugned order was made pursuant to an enquiry held under the Standing Committee of the Punjab University.
- The examinee was summoned, appeared on 15th July 1963 before the Deputy Registrar (Examinations), and answered the questionnaire annexed as "R.1".
- Reports were obtained in the course of the enquiry: the Head Examiner's report (annexure "R.6") on 24th June 1963 and an expert's report (annexure "R.7") on 26th July 1963, the latter being appended to the return.
- The opinion of the respondent as to culpability was based on the enquiry and the reports, including R.7 (the record does not provide a detailed justification for non-disclosure in the text of the opinion summarized here).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Karamjit Kaur v. The Punjab University (1964 63 P.L.R. 674) | Used by the Single Judge as a basis to dismiss similar writ petitions. | The Bench observed that the earlier Single Judge's decision in that case was relied upon below. The present Court found that Karamjit Kaur was distinguishable because in that case the challenge had not been raised in the same manner and the expert report did not appear to have been pressed into service; therefore the Single Judge's reliance on it did not justify dismissal here. |
| Ramesh Kapur v. The Punjab University (1965 67 P.L.R. 693) | Principle that a person to be condemned must be given adequate opportunity to meet the accusations and the evidence forming part of the charge; non-disclosure of such evidence offends natural justice. | The Court referred to this Full Bench decision to state the settled rule of natural justice—i.e., disclosure of evidence and opportunity to meet it is required—and applied that principle to conclude the failure to disclose R.7 was fatal to the impugned decision. |
| Suresh Kumar v. The Punjab University (A.I.R. 1955 Punj 120) | Directly on point: disallowing reliance on an expert report obtained after initial proceedings when that report was not communicated to the person affected; such reliance without disclosure violates natural justice. | The Court quoted Grover, J.'s observations from Suresh Kumar noting the expert's report was obtained subsequently and not communicated to the petitioner though it was relied upon. The Court treated Suresh Kumar as binding on this Bench (same facts, same order impugned, and same points) and applied it to set aside the Single Judge's dismissal and to quash the University's order. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the sequence of events and the materials placed before the Standing Committee: the examinee answered the questionnaire (annexure "R.1") on 15th July 1963; a Head Examiner's report (R.6) had been obtained on 24th June 1963; and an expert's report (R.7) was obtained subsequently on 26th July 1963 and appended to the return. The central legal principle invoked was that established by prior authority that a person who is to be condemned must be given adequate opportunity to meet the accusations and the evidence forming part of the charge; evidence intended to be used against the accused must be disclosed so that the accused can deal with it, otherwise the enquiry offends the principles of natural justice (reference made to the Full Bench decision in Ramesh Kapur).
The Court found Karamjit Kaur distinguishable because that decision did not involve the same manner of challenge nor the pressing into service of an expert report obtained after initial proceedings. By contrast, the expert report R.7 in the present case had been obtained after the questionnaire and had not been communicated to the examinee at any stage, yet it was relied upon in coming to the final conclusions.
The Court relied heavily on Suresh Kumar v. The Punjab University, where Grover, J. had observed (quoted in the present opinion) that an expert's report obtained subsequently and not brought to the notice of the petitioner but relied upon by the Standing Committee was a ground for setting aside the impugned order. Given that Suresh Kumar involved the same facts, the same order being impugned, and the same points, the Court treated that authority as binding on this Bench and applied its principle to the present matter.
On this basis the Court concluded that the learned Single Judge's dismissal of the writ petition could not be sustained. The failure to disclose the expert report and to afford the examinee an opportunity to meet it was a breach of the rules of natural justice and vitiated the University's order of disqualification.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL ALLOWED; ORDER OF THE PUNJAB UNIVERSITY QUASHED
Holding:
- The Letters Patent appeal was allowed.
- The judgment of the learned Single Judge (Pandit, J.) dismissing Civil Writ No. 1830 of 1963 was set aside.
- The impugned order of the Punjab University disqualifying Kamlesh Kumari and debarment for two years was quashed.
- There was no order as to costs.
- Justice Mehar Singh agreed with the result.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: the disciplinary order against Kamlesh Kumari was quashed, restoring the position that had been affected by that order (subject to whatever administrative or other lawful steps the University may take consistent with the Court's determination).
- Legal consequence: the decision reaffirmed the established principle—drawn from Full Bench and prior authority—that evidence (including expert reports) which is to be relied upon against a person must be disclosed and the person given an opportunity to meet it; failure to do so constitutes a breach of natural justice and invalidates the proceedings.
- The opinion did not purport to create a new legal principle; it applied existing authorities (notably Suresh Kumar and Ramesh Kapur) to the facts and treated Suresh Kumar as binding on this Bench in the circumstances described.
Khosla, J.:— This appeal under clause 10 of the Letters Patent is from judgment dated 22nd April, 1964, of P.C Pandit J., in Civil Writ No. 1830 of 1963.
2. The facts were these:—
3. Kamlesh Kumari an examinee bearing Roll No. 75925 appeared in the Matriculation Examination of the Punjab University convened in March 1963 from Jaitu (District Bhatinda) centre. For employing unfair means in the said examination relating to English Paper ‘A’ she was disqualified by the Punjab University debarring her from appearing in the Matriculation Examination for two years (1963 and 1964). Kamlesh Kumari, aggrieved as she was moved this Court questioning the said order of the Punjab University. The challenge was grounded on the contention that rules of natural justice had been violated. From the return filed in the civil writ petition it appears that the impugned order had been proposed after some sort of enquiry held under the auspices of the Standing Committee of the Punjab University. Kamlesh Kumari had been summoned and appeared on 15th July 1963 before the Deputy Registrar Examinations. She was asked to answer the questionnaire, annexure “R. 1” of return. Prior to her appearance on 24th of June 1963 report of the Head Examiner, which formed annexure “R 6” to the return, had also been obtained. Subsequent to that on 36th of July 1963 report of an expert (annexure R. 7) appended to the return had also been obtained, he grievance was that this subsequent report “R. 7” had not been made known to the petitioner and she had been given no opportunity to meet the same despite the fact that in coming to the final conclusions the said report “R. 7” had been along with other material made the basis of the respondent's order disqualifying her.
4. By the impugned judgment dated 22nd April 1964 the learned Single Judge had disposed of civil writ petition No. 1830 of 1963 and three others (Nos. 1831 to 1833 of 1963). The said writ petitions were dismissed principally on the basis of decision of the learned Single Judge in a prior civil writ petition (No. 1849 of 1963) and the Bench decision of this Court in Karamjit Kaur… v. The Punjab University…. . 1964 63 P.L.R 674., to which decision My Lord Mehar Singh, J. was also a party.
5. That case appears to be distinguishable. Reading of body of the judgment in the said case indicates that the challenge had not been raised in the manner as in the instant case. Report of the expert appears not to have been pressed into service. It is well settled that the person to be condemened ought to be given adequate opportunity to meet the accusations the evidence forming part of the charge and to be used against accused ought to be disclosed so that full opportunity is afforded to deal with the same, otherwise the proceedings in enquiry offend the principles of the rule of natural justice. Reference in this behalf is called to the decision of Full Bench of this Court in Ramesh Kapur v. The Punjab University . 1965 67 P.L.R 693.
6. Admittedly, in the instant case report of the Expert “R. 7” dated 26th July 1963 had not been made known to the examinee and at no stage was she able to meet the same. The decision in Suresh Kumar v. The Punjab University . A.I.R 1955 Punj 120, Letters Patent Appeal from this very judgment now impugned of the learned Single Judge (Pandit, J.) relating to another examinee from the same centre and examination is directly in point. Grover, J., speaking for the Court observed:—
“* *the more important question which has arisen is whether the Standing Committee was justified in relying on the report of the expert which was prejudicial to the petitioner, without giving any indication to him of the existence of such a report. No such indication could be given at the time the questionnaire was framed or was answered because it is common ground that the opinion of the expert had not been obtained till then and that it was obtained subsequently. After the expert's report had come, no further intimation was sent to the petitioner about it”.
Pronouncing upon the decision of the Standing Committee this is what the learned Judge said:
“It is apparent from it that the report of the expert was relied on ??? for giving a decision that the petitioner had been guilty of the use of unfair means. It is admitted that the petitioner at no stage was informed of the existence of such a report which was highly prejudicial to him * *.”
The impugned order in the writ petition, subject-matter of the said Letters Patent Appeal, in consequence, was set aside. The decision in Suresh Kumar's case is of a binding authority as far as this Bench is concerned, particularly because it was on the same facts, same order was impugned and points urged and disposed of were the same as in the instant case.
7. We have thus for all these reasons no hesitation in finding the judgment of the learned Single Judge challenged in the present proceedings cannot sustain. The same is accordingly set aside.
8. In the result, this appeal is allowed and the order of the Punjab University impugned in Civil Writ No. 1830 of 1963 is quashed. There will, however, be no order as to costs.
9. Mehar Singh, J.:— I agree.
Appeal allowed.
Alert