Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Jogi Sahu And Another v. Collector, Cuttack Opposite Party.

Orissa High Court
May 14, 1991
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Certain lands of the petitioners were acquired for expansion of the Central Rice Research Institute, Cuttack pursuant to a State of Orissa notification dated 2-9-1971. The Collector passed an award fixing compensation at Rs. 7,500 per acre. The award was not accepted and the matter was referred to the Subordinate Judge, Cuttack under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. On 10-4-1975 the reference Court disposed the matter for non-appearance with the order: “O.P files hazira. Petitioners take no steps. Hence the award of L.A Collector is confirmed. Misc. Case is dismissed.” The petitioners filed a series of restoration applications (some under Order 9, Rule 9 CPC and some under Section 151 CPC). By the impugned order dated 11-9-1990 the Subordinate Judge held those applications not maintainable and refused to entertain Misc. Case No. 24 of 1988. The petitioners sought relief by civil revision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the reference Court was legally justified in dismissing the land-acquisition reference for non-appearance on 10-4-1975.
  2. Whether applications for restoration filed under Order 9, Rule 9 CPC or under Section 151 CPC are maintainable in a land-acquisition reference.
  3. Whether, in the circumstances, the petitioners should be deprived of their entitlement because of alleged laches or mistaken legal advice.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The reference Court's order was contrary to law and should not deprive them of entitlement on mere technicalities.
  • Mistaken legal advice led to bona fide inappropriate steps and should not bar relief.

Respondent-State's Arguments

  • The petitioners showed laches and negligent conduct; there is no scope for interference.
  • The impugned order was appealable and petitioners failed to avail that remedy; they should not be allowed to challenge the award now.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Abdul Karim Khan…Applicant; v. State Of Madhya Pradesh…Opponent. through the Collector, Bilaspur, AIR 1964 MP 171 High Court authority supporting that dismissal for non-appearance under Order 9, Rule 8 CPC is not applicable to land-acquisition references. Cited as part of consistent High Court view that references under the Land Acquisition Act cannot be dismissed for non-appearance under O.9 R.8 CPC.
B. Munda v. D. Oraon, AIR 1970 Patna 209 Patna High Court authority consistent with the principle that O.9 R.8 CPC does not apply to land-acquisition references. Relied upon to support the proposition that dismissal for default is impermissible in such references.
S.S Sahai v. State, AIR 1974 Patna 176 Patna High Court authority supporting inapplicability of O.9 R.8 CPC to land-acquisition references. Used to demonstrate consistent judicial approach across High Courts on the point.
Gopal Charan Sahu v. Collector, Cuttack, 1976 (1) CWR 1 Held that O.9 R.8 CPC provisions were not applicable; Order 9 Rule 9 restoration applications were not maintainable but relief could be sought under Section 151 CPC (inherent powers). Followed and applied: court held O.9 R.9 applications could be rejected but petitions under Section 151 CPC are maintainable; guided restoration approach here.
Nabaratna Khamari v. State of Orissa, 60 (1985) CLT 234 Followed the rule in Gopal Charan Sahu regarding maintainability of Section 151 petitions in land-acquisition references. Cited as supporting authority for allowing inherent-power petitions instead of O.9 R.9 restoration applications.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the statutory scheme under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894: when a claimant does not accept the Collector's award and a reference is made under Section 18, the claimant is not a conventional plaintiff but the Court must, under Section 20, serve notice and thereafter make an award under Section 26(1) which is deemed a decree under Section 26(2). Given this structure, dismissal of a land-acquisition reference for default (by invoking Order 9, Rule 8 CPC) is impermissible and Section 53 of the Act cannot operate to permit such dismissal. The Court noted consistent High Court authorities adopting this view. Applying Gopal Charan Sahu, the Court held that restoration applications under Order 9, Rule 9 CPC are not maintainable in this context, but relief can be sought under the Court's inherent powers (Section 151 CPC); thus the reference Court was correct to reject O.9 R.9 applications but should have entertained petitions under Section 151 CPC. Weighing the equities and the fact that similarly situated claimants later received higher awards, the Court found compelling reasons to restore the case to its earlier stage. Because some delay was attributable to the petitioners, the Court declined to award interest for the period from 10-4-1975 to the date of decision, but preserved other statutory entitlements and interest for other periods as available in law. The Court directed that the Misc. Case be restored to the position it stood on 10-4-1975 and the reference Court proceed in accordance with law, with parties to appear on 19-6-1991.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF — The Civil Revision is disposed of.

Direct consequences and practical effects:

  • Land Acquisition Misc. Case No. 146 of 1974 is restored to the stage it stood on 10-4-1975; the reference Court is directed to proceed and dispose of the case in accordance with law.
  • The reference Court was correct to reject restoration applications under Order 9, Rule 9 CPC, but petitions invoking Section 151 CPC are maintainable for relief from the dismissal.
  • No interest shall be awarded to the petitioners for the period from 10-4-1975 until the date of the opinion; petitioners remain entitled to other statutory entitlements and interest for other periods as available in law.
  • No costs were awarded. The decision does not purport to create a new legal precedent beyond applying and following prior authorities cited.
Show all summary ...

1. Mistaken advice by lawyers have sometimes resulted in disastrous consequences, and the case at hand is one classic example.

2. Certain lands owned by the petitioners were acquired for expansion of the Central Rice Research Institute in Cuttack pursuant to a notification published in the official gazette by the State of Orissa on 2-9-1971. The Collector, Cuttack passed award quantifying the entitlement of the petitioners at the rate of Rs. 7,500/- per acre. The award made by the Collector was not accepted and on a dispute being raised the matter was referred to the learned Subordinate Judge, Cuttack. Due to non-appearance of the petitioners on 10-4-1975, the matter was disposed of by the reference Court with the following order:

“O.P files hazira. Petitioners take no steps. Hence the award of L.A Collector is confirmed. Misc. Case is dismissed.”

Therefore, a series of petitions were filed for restoration, some under Order 9, Rule 9, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (in short ‘CPC’) and some under Section 151, CPC. Finally, impugned order dated 11-9-1990 was passed holding that the applications were not maintainable. The learned Subordinate Judge referred to the chequered career of the case and hold that misc. case No. 24 of 1988 which was under the consideration was not to be entertained.

3. The primary question that has been urged for resolution is that the order passed by the reference Court was contrary to law and therefore, on mere technicalities a party should not be deprived of his entitlement. It is pleaded that due to mistaken legal advice, inappropriate steps were taken bona fide. Such a plea is countered by the learned counsel for the State on the ground that laches and negligent conduct of the petitioners is apparent and there is no scope for interference at this stage; the order passed by the reference Court was also appealable and the petitioners having not availed that remedy should not be permitted to agitate the correctness of the award in the present proceeding.

4. For resolution of the dispute the primary question is whether the order passed by the reference Court on 10-4-1975 was in accordance with law. In other words, whether the reference Court was legally justified in disposing of the matter in the manner done. When a claimant does not accept the award of the Collector, on an application under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (in short ‘the Act’), being filed the Collector makes a reference to the reference Court. On the reference being made, the claimant does not become plaintiff or petitioner before the Court. As provided under Section 20 of the Act, the Court has to serve notice on the claimant on whose application reference has been made under Section 18 of the Act. After the notice, the Court is required to make an award in terms of Section 26(1) of the Act and this award is deemed to be a decree under Section 26(2). It is, therefore, impermissible to dismiss a case for default. The dismissal for default is not in terms of Order 9, Rule 8, C.P.C since the land acquisition reference cannot be dismissed for non-appearance of the claimant under Order 9, Rule 8, C.P.C and Section 53 of the Act shall not operate to this case. This view has been consistently taken by several High Courts. (See Abdul Karim Khan…Applicant; v. State Of Madhya Pradesh…Opponent. through the Collector, Bilaspur, AIR 1964 MP 171; B. Munda v. D. Oraon, AIR 1970 Patna 209 and S.S Sahai v. State, AIR 1974 Patna 176. This Court had also occasion to consider the question and a similar view was expressed, (see Gopal Charan Sahu v. Collector, Cuttack, 1976 (1) CWR 1). In that case it was also held that the provisions of Order 9, Rule 8, C.P.C were not applicable. It was held that an application for restoration under Order 9, Rule 9, C.P.C is not maintainable; but the impugned order can be set aside by invoking the inherent powers of the Court under Section 151, C.P.C Therefore, the reference Court was justified in rejecting the applications which were filed under Order 9, Rule 9, C.P.C but the petitions under Section 151, C.P.C were maintainable. Such a petition was maintainable as held by this Court in Gopal Charan Sahu's case (supra). The view expressed in Gopal Charan Sahu's case (supra) was followed in Nabaratna Khamari v. State of Orissa, 60 (1985) CLT 234. A person whose land was being acquired is entitled to compensation therefor, and this entitlement should not be denied except on very compelling reasons. To deprive a person from his due entitlement on a technical plea would be a negation of the rule of law. Considering the fact that the claimants whose lands were acquired for the self-same purpose were awarded much higher amount than what was awarded on the basis of the original award by the Collector, Cuttack, I feel, the petitioners should not be deprived. Therefore, in the peculiar circumstances of the case I hold that the matter should go back to the stage it stood on 19-4-1975. The Land Acquisition Misc. Case No. 146 of 1974 is restored to the stage where it stood on 10-4-1975. The reference Court shall now proceed with the case and dispose of the same in accordance with law. To avoid unnecessary delay the parties are directed to appear before the reference Court on 19-6-1991.

5. It, however, appears that delay in disposal of the Land Acquisition Misc. Case is partially due to the action of the petitioners. It would, therefore, be not proper to grant any interest to them during the period from 10-4-1975 till today. While computing the compensation, the reference Court shall exclude the interest payable to the claimants-petitioners for this period. The claimants, however, shall be entitled to their other statutory entitlements, and interest for such other periods as available to them in law.

The Civil Revision is disposed of with the aforesaid direction. No costs.

Order accordingly.