Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Babaji Charan Sahu v. Netrananda Sahu And Others

Orissa High Court
Aug 17, 1978
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff filed a suit for partition on 17-12-1973 in the court of the Munsif at Anandapur, alleging the death of Abhimanyu Sahu who left behind four sons, including the plaintiff and defendant No. 2. The plaintiff claimed one-fourth share in the joint family properties, valued at Rs. 12,000/- in total with his share valued at Rs. 3,150/- (though mathematically one-fourth would be Rs. 3,000/-). Defendants challenged the valuation and the pecuniary jurisdiction of the court in their written statement, but no issue on jurisdiction was framed. Defendant No. 1 lost in the courts below and raised the question of pecuniary jurisdiction for the first time in the second appeal before a learned single Judge, who referred the matter to a Division Bench for disposal in accordance with law.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the pecuniary jurisdiction of the trial court should be determined by the value of the plaintiff's claimed share or the value of the entire joint family property in a suit for partition.
  2. Whether the objection to pecuniary jurisdiction can be raised for the first time in a second appeal when it was noted but not framed as an issue in the trial court.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The valuation for jurisdictional purposes should be the value of the entire property, not just the plaintiff's share.
  • The objection to pecuniary jurisdiction was raised in the written statement at the trial court and thus should be considered despite not being framed as an issue.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The valuation for jurisdiction should be based on the plaintiff's share claimed, not the entire property.
  • The question of pecuniary jurisdiction cannot be raised for the first time in the second appeal as barred by Section 21 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC).
  • The amending provision allowing such objection at later stages does not apply to the present case.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Chadhai Behera v. Parbati (1962) 28 Cut LT 433 Value of plaintiff's share determines jurisdiction where there is dispute over share and title adjudication is sought. Confirmed that in suits involving dispute over share and title, valuation of plaintiff's share is relevant for jurisdiction.
Bhairab Chandra Rao v. Sat Narain Sarkar, AIR 1953 Pat 342 Value of plaintiff's share determines jurisdiction in suits involving title adjudication and partition. Applied as authoritative support for the principle that valuation depends on plaintiff's share in disputed title cases.
Mst. Dura Deo v. Smt. Pirobati Dei (1976) 42 Cut LT 1247 : AIR 1977 Orissa 85 In simple partition suits with no dispute over title, valuation of entire property determines jurisdiction. Distinguished between suits involving title disputes and pure partition suits; held present suit as pure partition.
Smt. Nakhyatramali Debi v. Chandrasekhar Pattnaik, AIR 1977 Orissa 161 Where plaintiff disputes quantum of share and seeks adjudication, valuation of plaintiff's share determines jurisdiction. Reaffirmed principle regarding valuation of share in suits involving dispute over share quantum.
Rajani Kanta Bag v. Raja Bala Dasi, AIR 1925 Cal 320 In suits for partition pure and simple, valuation of entire property determines jurisdiction. Supported appellant's contention that entire property valuation is relevant in pure partition suits.
Kalander v. Kunhipakki, AIR 1947 Mad 273 Valuation for jurisdiction is based on plaintiff's interest in property, particularly where declaration of share is sought. Held that suit related to plaintiff's share and valuation must be accordingly; no conflict with Court's principle.
Sabastian Antonio Texeira v. Rodolf Minguel Texeira, AIR 1962 Bom 4 Value of plaintiff's share determines pecuniary jurisdiction in partition suits where share is disputed. Applied to confirm that valuation of plaintiff's share governs jurisdiction where share dispute exists.
Shevantibai v. Janardhan Raghunath, AIR 1944 PC 65 Valuation of the plaintiff's share is the valuation of the suit in partition suits involving title adjudication. Used to support the principle that valuation depends on plaintiff's claimed share in disputed title cases.
Ranjit Sahi v. Maulavi Quasim, AIR 1923 Pat 342 Distinction between pure partition suits and suits involving title adjudication affecting valuation for jurisdiction. Relied upon to distinguish valuation principles depending on dispute nature.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the nature of the suit and the dispute over valuation for pecuniary jurisdiction. It noted that the plaintiff's suit was a simple partition suit without a dispute over title or share quantum, thus the valuation of the entire property (Rs. 12,000/-) should determine jurisdiction. The Court reviewed divergent views from various High Courts and authoritative decisions, ultimately aligning with the principle that in pure partition suits, the entire property's value governs jurisdiction, whereas in suits involving dispute over title and share, the valuation of the plaintiff's share is relevant. Since the trial court entertained the suit based on the plaintiff's share valuation and not the entire property, it lacked pecuniary jurisdiction. The Court also addressed procedural objections regarding the timing of raising jurisdictional challenges, holding that the appellant could raise the issue at the second appeal stage because the objection was initially taken in the written statement, though not framed as an issue. The Court concluded that the trial court's jurisdictional error rendered its decision contrary to law.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is allowed. The decision of the trial court, as affirmed by the lower appellate court, is vacated. The learned Munsif is directed to return the plaint to the plaintiff for presentation in the proper court according to law. The parties are directed to bear their own costs throughout.

The decision directly affects the parties by invalidating the jurisdiction of the trial court to entertain the suit based on the valuation method applied. No broader precedent beyond the application of existing valuation principles in partition suits is established.

Show all summary ...

R.N Misra, J.:— Defendant No. 1 in a suit for partition has carried this appeal against the affirming judgement and decree of the learned Subordinate Judge.

2. Plaintiff filed the suit on 17-12-1973 in the court of the Munsif at Anandapur alleging that Abhimanyu Sahu died leaving behind him four sons, namely, Bikala, Gananath (defendant No. 2), Raghu and Netrananda (plaintiff). Bikala is dead and his son Babaji is defendant No. 1. Raghu died leaving his widow (defendant No. 3) and two daughters, namely, Hadiani and Paluni Plaintiff demanded his share in the joint family properties and as defendants have not partitioned the same in spite of demand, he instituted the suit asking for one-fourth share in the property. In the plaint he valued the entire property at Rs. 12,000/- and his one-fourth share at Rs. 3,150/- though on the total valuation of Rs. 12,000/- the one-fourth share should have been calculated at Rs. 3,000/- net (see para 8 of the plaint). Paras. 4 and 5 of the written statement of the defendants challenge the valuation and maintain that the suit was beyond the pecuniary jurisdiction of the court. No issue on the question of jurisdiction was however, framed. Defendant No. 1 lost in both the courts below. When the second appeal came for hearing before a learned single Judge the question of want of pecuniary jurisdiction of the trial court to entertain the suit was agitated. The learned single Judge observed:—

“……. Mr. Sahu contends that the valuation of this suit for the purpose of jurisdiction is Rs. 35,000/- and odd, which the valuation of the entire suit property, and not the valuation of the share claimed by the plaintiff. But Mr. Ran, the learned counsel for the respondents, submits that the valuation of the suit for the purpose of jurisdiction would be the valuation of the share claimed by the plaintiff and not the value of the entire property for which the partition is sought. On the above question divergent views have been expressed in the decisions of this Court reported in (1962) 28 Cut LT 433 (Chadhai Behera v. Parbati); (1946) 2 Cut WR 949 : (AIR 1977 Orissa 161), (Smt. Nakhyatramali Debi v. Chandrasekhar Pattnaik) and the decision reported in (1976) 42 Cut LT 1247 : (AIR 1977 Orissa 85), Smt. Durga Deo v. Smt. Pirobati Dei). There is also divergence of opinion on this point in the decisions of some other High Courts. The decision reported in AIR 1925 Cal 320 (Rajani Kanta Bag v. Raja Bala Dasi) supports the contention of Mr. Sahu for the appellant, whereas the decisions reported in AIR 1953 Pat 342 (Bhairab Chandra Rao v. Sat Narain Sarkar); AIR 1947 Mad 273, (Kalander v. Kunhipakki) and AIR 1962 Bom 4 (Sabastian Antonio Texeira v. Rodolf Minguel Texeira) support the view contended by Mr. Rao for the respondents. Certain other important questions are also involved in this case. I, therefore, deem it fit and proper to refer this second appeal to a Division Bench of this Court for its disposal in accordance with law.” That is how the Second Appeal has been placed before us.

3. Mr. Rao for the respondents maintained that the question of want of pecuniary jurisdiction could not for the first time be raised in the second appeal Section 21 of the CPC barred objection as to the place of suing being raised at a later stage in the suit of in the appellate court. Until insertion of Sub-Section (2) of Section 21 of the by the Amending Act of 1976, there was no provision regarding a similar power with reference to pecuniary limits of court's jurisdiction. There is no dispute that the amending provision would not apply to the present appeal. There is a similar provision in the Suits Valuation Act in S. 11 thereof which provides:—

“(1) Notwithstanding anything in Section 578 of the CPC 14 of 1882, an objection that by reason of the overvaluation or under-valuation of a suit or appeal a Court of first instance or Lower Appellate Court which had not jurisdiction with respect to the suit or appeal exercised jurisdiction with respect thereto shall not be entertained by an Appellate Court unless—

(a) the objection was taken in the Court of first instance at or before the hearing at which issues were first framed and recorded, or in the Lower Appellate Court in the memorandum of appeal to that Court, or

(b) the Appellate Court is satisfied, for reasons to be recorded by it in writing that the suit or appeal was overvalued or under-valued, and that the over-valuation or under-valuation thereof has prejudicially affected the disposal of the suit or appeal on its merits.”

4. In the instant case, as we have already noticed, objection was taken in the court of first instance in the written statement. An appropriate issue was, however, not framed by the court and the question does not appear to have been examined. In the circumstances, we are inclined to agree with counsel for the appellant that the appellant cannot be precluded from raising a contention at this stage, particularly when, the argument is based upon the facts disclosed by the plaint itself.

5. There are three decisions of this Court relevant to the point. The first one is the case of Chadhai Behera v. Parbati, (1962) 28 Cut LT 433, where Misra, J. as the learned Judge then was approved the dictum laid down by a Division Bench of the Patna High Court in the case of Bhairab Chandra Rai v. Sat Narain Sarkar, AIR 1953 Pat 342 and observed:—

“………Law is well settled that where there is dispute over the plaintiff's share and the plaintiff seeks adjudication of his title and for partition after such adjudication, it is the value of the plaintiff's share which will determine the jurisdiction of the Court and not the value of the entire property …….”

6. The second is the case of Mst. Dura Deo v. Smt. Pirobati Dei, (1976) 42 Cut LT 1247 : (AIR 1077 Orissa 85), where one of us (Mohanti, J.) has relied upon the aforesaid decision of this Court and observed (at p. 86 of AIR):—

“In a simple suit for partition it is the value of the whole property which determines the jurisdiction of the Court and not the value of the plaintiff's share only. In such a suit, the Court has to deal with the entire property. It may on the application of the defendants effect partition of their shares. Therefore the valuation of the suit for the purpose of the jurisdiction cannot he the value of the plaintiff's share only. I am fortified in this view by a Bench decision of the Patna High Court reported in AIR 1923 Pat 342, (Ranjit Sahi v. Maulavi Quasim). Their Lordships held that there is a distinction between suits for partition pure and simple where the plaintiff is in joint possession of his share and there is no dispute as to the title or share and suits where the plaintiff seeks for an adjudication of his title or extent of share and for partition after such adjudication. It was clearly laid down that in the latter case it is the value of the plaintiff's share which would determine the jurisdiction of the Court and not the value of the entire property. But if there is no dispute regarding the title of the plaintiff and the only question before the Court is as regards partition, the value of the whole property sought to be partitioned must be the value for the purpose of jurisdiction. In the case of Rajani Kante Beg v. Raja Bala Dasi, AIR 1925 Cal 320, it was also held by a Division Bench that a suit for partition is triable by the Court which is competent to try the suit valued at the entire value of the property and not at the value of the plaintiff's share.”

7. The third and the led decision of this Court on the point is the case of Smt. Nakhyatramali Debi v. Chandrasekhar Paitnaik, AIR 1077 Orissa 161. The learned Judge in para 6 of the judgement has observed (at p. 164):

“……… In a suit for simple partition, where the plaintiff does not allege dispossession but there is dispute as to the quantum of share, the value for the purpose of jurisdiction would be the value of the share claimed by the plaintiff and not the value of the whole property of which the partition is sought (See Dukhi Singh v. Harihar Shah, AIR 1921 Pat 78, Ranjit Shah v. Maulavi Quasim, AIR 1923 Pat 342 and Chadhai Behera v. Parbati, (1962) 28 Cut LT 433). There is no dispute in the present case that the value of the plaintiff's share is Rs. 1,250/- and, as such, the appeal to the Additional District Judge was maintainable.”

8. The learned Judge while indicating the facts had stated:

“It is clear from the averments of the plaint that the plaintiff's quantum of share was in controversy and she wanted adjudication of the same ………”

9. There is thus no divergence of opinion on the point in issue in this Court.

10. In the Patna decision (AIR 1953 Pat 342) the placitum is misleading. The facts of the case clearly indicate that the plaintiffs had asked for a declaration of their title to the share claimed and for partition and separate possession of their shares in the properties as there was dispute over their right. The aforesaid Patna decision relied upon the decision or the Privy Council in the case of Shevantibai v. Janardhan Raghunath, AIR 1944 PC 65.

11. From the report of the decision of the Judicial Committee it is clear that the assignee of the purchaser from a member of a joint family of a share in the joint family property sued for partition obviously asking for title in the purchase. The Privy Council, therefore, rightly indicated that the valuation of the share was the valuation of the suit.

12. Two other decisions have been relied upon for the contrary proposition. The first is the Bench decision of the Madras High Court in the case of Kalander v. Kunhipakki, AIR 1947 Mad 273. The learned Judges referred to the Privy council decision which we have already noticed and came to hold relying on Section 4 of the Suits Valuation Act:

“It is clear from this Section that for purposes of jurisdiction it is the plaintiff's interest in the property that must be valued. The plaintiff's suit was for partition of their half share in the suit properties. In other words, they asked that their undivided half share in the properties should be converted into a divided half share. This relief could not be valued; and court-fee had to be calculated according to the provisions of Article 17 of Sch. II, Court-fees Act. The matter in dispute in the suit was however whether the plaintiffs had a half share in the plaint schedule properties or not. According to their claim, they had an undivided half share in the suit properties, which they sought to have divided, and so it seems clear to us that the suit related only to a half share of the plaint schedule properties.”

13. From what has been said above, it is clear that the plaintiffs were also asking for declaration of their half share. If that be so, the aforesaid ratio is not divergent to the principle laid down in this Court.

14. The last case which has been placed before us for consideration is the decision of a learned single Judge of the Bombay High Court in the case of Sabastian Antonio Texeira v. Rodolf Minguel Texeira, AIR 1962 Bom 4. After referring to certain authorities, the learned Judge concluded by saying (at p. 7):

“………Thus, there is no doubt that in a suit for partition it is the value of the share which the plaintiff claims in the joint family property or the property of which partition is sought, which determines the pecuniary jurisdiction of the Court and not the value of the entire property. If, therefore, this suit is held to be a suit for partition, then this Court will have no jurisdiction to entertain it, because, as pointed out in the earlier part of the judgement, the value of the plaintiff's share does not exceed Rs. 10,000/-. In other words, it is very much less than what is necessary for this Court to have the pecuniary jurisdiction.”

15. The parties were Christians and on a reading of the facts there appears to have been disputes as to the share. In view of the settled position of law in this Court as also in the Patna and the Calcutta High Courts, we are not inclined to take a different view. All the three single Judge decisions of this Court correctly stated the legal position.

16. The present suit was one for simple partition and, therefore, the valuation of the entire property was the valuation of the suit for the purpose of jurisdiction. In the plaint, the valuation was put at Rs. 12,000/-. On the said valuation, the trial Court had no pecuniary jurisdiction. Therefore, the entertainment and disposal of the suit by the trial Court is contrary to law.

17. The appeal is allowed. The decision of the trial Court as affirmed in appeal is vacated and the learned Munsif is directed to return the plaint to the plaintiff for presentation in proper court in accordance with law. Parties are directed to bear their respective costs throughout.

18. P.K Mohanti, J.:— I agree.

19. Appeal allowed.