Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Khetra Dolai v. Mohan Bissoyi Opposite Party.

Orissa High Court
Mar 24, 1960
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This matter arises from a defendant's application under Order IX, Rule 13 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC) directed against an order of the Small Cause Court Judge, Berhampur, which rejected the defendant's application on the ground that it did not comply with the proviso to Section 17 of the Small Cause Courts Act.

Key events in chronological order (as recorded in the opinion):

  • An ex parte decree for Rs. 247 (inclusive of costs) was passed on 25-1-1957.
  • The application under O. 9, R. 13 was filed on 28-1-1957.
  • On 11-2-1957 the applicant applied for permission to file security or to treat previous security as sufficient.
  • On 13-2-1957 the Court directed fresh security and allowed time till 20-2-1957 (within the 30-day period).
  • On 20-2-1957 a draft bond for Rs. 200 executed by a third party (Krushna Moharana) was filed; the Court ordered it to be put up on 26-2-1957.
  • On 26-2-1957 the draft bond was not accepted and the petitioner was asked to file a proper security bond.
  • On 8-3-1957 a fresh bond for Rs. 250 was filed but lacked an affidavit showing properties free from encumbrances; the affidavit was then ordered and filed on 2-4-1957.
  • The draft bond was accepted as sufficient on 16-4-1957 and the properly engrossed security bond was filed into court on 7-5-1957.
  • The impugned order rejecting the application was passed on 5-11-1958.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a draft security bond filed within the 30-day period specified in the proviso to Section 17 of the Small Cause Courts Act (but not accepted as a valid security by the Court at that time) constitutes valid compliance with the proviso so as to maintain an application under O. 9, R. 13 CPC.
  2. Whether a security bond that is (a) executed by a third party and/or (b) for an amount less than the decretal sum, and which is not accepted by the Court within the 30-day period, can later be treated as valid security for compliance with the proviso to Section 17.
  3. Whether the security to be furnished under the proviso to Section 17 must be for the performance of the ex parte decree (as held in some precedents) rather than for the performance of any ultimate decree that might be passed if the ex parte decree is set aside.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant / Defendant (represented by Mr. Ramdas)

  • Contended that he had complied with the proviso to Section 17 within the period of limitation by filing a draft security bond within thirty days of the ex parte decree.
  • Argued that the draft bond filed on 20-2-1957 should be regarded as valid security upon which the Court could act, and that the applicant should not be penalised for any laches of the Court in formally accepting or completing the security.
  • Relied upon decisions of the Andhra Pradesh High Court and the Madras High Court (specifically P. Satyanarayana v. V. Ramabrahman and In re: Chinnathambi Asari) to support the contention that a draft/unregistered bond tendered in time and ultimately accepted is sufficient compliance with S.17.

Respondent / Small Cause Court (counsel Mr. Pal as noted)

  • Contended that the security filed was not a valid security in law because the security was furnished for the performance of the ultimate decree that might be passed if the ex parte decree were set aside, rather than to secure the performance of the ex parte decree itself.
  • Relied upon Pulin Chandra v. Khetra Mohan (AIR 1939 Cal 748) and the Bombay High Court decision cited there (Maganlal Pitamberdas Khatri v. Dahyabhai Chhaganlal Vyas, AIR 1938 Bom 448) for the proposition that security must secure performance of the ex parte decree and not a prospective ultimate decree.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Manu Sadangi v. Baraju Das, Civil Revision No. 255 of 1958 (Orissa Judicial Decisions p. 604) Interprets proviso to Section 17: an applicant must at the time of presenting his application either deposit the decretal amount or give such security as the Court may have directed on a previous application; if no previous application for security was made, deposit must be in full; Court cannot extend the time for deposit or security. The Court regarded this as a settled statement of the law on the proviso to Section 17 and relied on it to frame the correct legal position regarding timing and requirements for security.
P. Satyanarayana v. V. Ramabrahman, 1960-1 Andh WR 24 : AIR 1960 Andh Pra 230 (Full Bench) Holds that an unregistered security bond is sufficient if delay in registration is not due to the applicant; the relevant test is whether the security ultimately accepted by the Court was sufficient to enforce the obligation. Used by the applicant to argue that a draft bond tendered in time and ultimately accepted satisfies the proviso; the Court discussed this view but found the facts distinguishable because the draft bond tendered in time here was insufficient (third party, less amount) and was not one on which the Court could act.
In re: Chinnathambi Asari, 1958-2 Mad LJ 594 Holds that where a draft security bond and list of immovable properties are filed at the time of application and, after testing, a fair bond is executed and filed in accordance with the Court's direction within the limited time and accepted, the requirements of Section 17(1) proviso are satisfied. Cited as supporting authority for the proposition that tendering security in draft form in time and subsequently formalising it (if accepted) can constitute compliance; the Court noted this authority but distinguished the present facts because the draft bond here was not acceptable.
Pulin Chandra v. Khetra Mohan, AIR 1939 Cal 748 Holds that the security required is to ensure performance of the ex parte decree in case it is not set aside, not to secure performance of any ultimate decree that might be passed if the ex parte decree is set aside. Relied upon by respondent's counsel; the Court considered this principle when addressing whether the security in the present case was the correct species of security and noted the relevance of that principle to the second ground of rejection by the Small Cause Court Judge.
Maganlal Pitamberdas Khatri v. Dahyabhai Chhaganlal Vyas, AIR 1938 Bom 448 Earlier decision cited in Pulin Chandra; used to support the principle that security must secure performance of the ex parte decree. Cited in support of the proposition in Pulin Chandra; the Court recorded its existence as an authority forming part of the chain relied upon by Mr. Pal.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in several discrete steps, grounded in the statutory proviso to Section 17 of the Small Cause Courts Act and the factual chronology recorded above.

  1. The Court recapitulated the legal position as earlier stated in Manu Sadangi v. Baraju Das: the proviso requires either deposit of the decretal amount or furnishing of such security as the Court may have directed on a previous application and this must be done at the time of presenting the application; if no previous order for security has been obtained the plaintiff must deposit the decretal amount in full; the Court has no power to extend the time for such deposit or security.
  2. The Court examined the facts to determine whether the draft security tendered within the 30-day period could be treated as compliance with the proviso. The draft bond filed on 20-2-1957 was executed by a third party and was for Rs. 200, which was less than the decretal amount of Rs. 247; for those reasons the trial court did not accept it and asked for a proper security bond.
  3. The Court found that the only security on which the Court could act was the properly engrossed bond filed on 7-5-1957, which was well beyond the 30-day period. Consequently the petitioner had not filed a valid security within the proviso's time limit.
  4. The applicant's contention that he should not be penalised for the Court's delay when he had filed a draft bond in time was rejected. The Court held that the draft bond filed on 20-2-1957 could not be treated as a valid security on which the Court could act because it was insufficient in amount and was executed by a third party.
  5. The Court acknowledged and discussed the contrary authorities (the Andhra Full Bench in P. Satyanarayana and the Madras decision in Chinnathambi Asari) which adopt a more liberal construction — namely, that a draft/unregistered bond tendered in time and ultimately accepted suffices. The Court explained the underlying test articulated in those decisions: whether the security ultimately accepted by the Court is sufficient to enforce the obligation, and whether any delay in formal completion (e.g., registration) was attributable to the applicant.
  6. The Court expressly reserved its view on questions of registration and dating back of instruments because those issues were not necessary for decision in this case.
  7. With respect to the second ground of rejection (that the security was not a valid security in law), the Court considered the Calcutta decision in Pulin Chandra which emphasises that the security must ensure the performance of the ex parte decree (and not secure performance of any ultimate decree). That principle was noted as relevant to deciding whether the security tendered in this case met the statutory purpose.
  8. Synthesising the statutory requirement and the facts, the Court concluded that a valid security on which the Court could act was not filed within the 30-day period, and hence the proviso to Section 17 had not been complied with.

Holding and Implications

Application dismissed with costs.

Direct consequences:

  • The defendant/applicant's application under O. 9, R. 13 CPC was dismissed; the order of the Small Cause Court Judge, Berhampur (rejecting the application for non-compliance with Section 17) was upheld.
  • The Court found that the proviso to Section 17 had not been complied with because no valid security on which the Court could act was filed within thirty days of the ex parte decree.

Broader implications:

  • The opinion applies existing authorities and does not proclaim a novel legal principle. The decision rests on the application of the proviso to Section 17 to the particular facts (insufficiency and timing of the security) and the Court's assessment of the cited precedents.

End of summary.

Show all summary ...

1. This is a defendant's application directed against an order of the Small Cause Court Judge, Berhampur, rejecting his application under O. 9 R. 13 of the CPC. The learned Judge rejected the application on the ground that the application is not maintainable, since it did not comply with the provisions of Section 17 of the Small Cause Courts Act.

2. Mr. Ramdas, learned counsel on behalf of the petitioner contended that he had complied with the provisions of S. 17 within the period of limitation. In other words his contention is that he had filed a draft security bond within thirty days of the ex parte decree. The proviso to S. 17 says that an applicant for an order to set aside a decree passed ex parte or for a review of judgment shall, at the time of presenting his application, either deposit in the Court the amount due from him under the decree or in pursuance of the judgment, or give such security for the performance of the decree or compliance with the judgment as the Court may, on a previous application made by him in this behalf, have directed.

3. An identical question came up before this Court in the case of Manu Sadangi v. Baraju Das, Civil Revn. No. 255 of 1958 since reported in Orissa Judicial Decisions p. 604. In that case I look the view that the proviso to Section 17 of the Small Cause Courts Act lays down that an application for an order to set aside a decree passed ex parte or for a review of the judgment shall at the time of presenting his application either deposit in court the amount due from him under the decree or in pursuance of the judgment or give such security for the performance of the decree or compliance with the judgment as the court may, on a previous application made by him in this behalf have directed. This proviso to Sec. 17 was introduced by Act IX of 1935. The amendment adopted the view that an applicant applying for a review of judgment or for an order to set aside an ex parte decree must at the time of presenting his application do one of the two things, namely, either deposit in court the amount due under the decree or give such security for performance of the decree as the court may have directed on a previous application made by him in this behalf. If he does not make the previous application, he must put in the decretal amount in full. If he has made the previous application and succeeded in getting an order for security in cash, he can, instead of depositing the decretal amount, furnish the security directed by court. It is no longer open to the court to extend the time within which the deposit is to be made or the security furnished.

4. In order to appreciate the argument of Mr. Ramdas, certain facts have got to be stated in detail. The ex parte decree for a sum of Rs. 247/- including costs was passed on 25-1-1957. The application under O. 9, Rule 13 was filed on 28-1-57. Before expiry of the 30th day, the applicant filed an application on 11-2-57 for giving him permission to file security or to take the previous security as sufficient. On 13-2-57, the Court ordered that the previous security furnished by the petitioner having been discharged the petitioner was to furnish fresh security and allowed him time till 20-2-57 which was within the period of limitation.

5. On 20-2-57 a draft-bond for Rs. 200/- executed by a third party Krushna Moharana was filed, and the court ordered it to be put up on 26-2-57. On 26-2-57 the court did not accept the draft bond which was filed by Krushna Moharana but asked the petitioner to file a proper security bond. A fresh bond for Rs. 250/- was filed by the petitioner on 8-3-57, but no affidavit showing that the properties are free from encumbrances were filed by him. Accordingly the court ordered that the petitioner must file such an affidavit by 21-3-57. However, the affidavit was filed on 2-4-57 and the Court ordered the bond to be checked and put up on 9-4-57.

6. This draft-bond was accepted as sufficient on 16-4-57 and the fresh security bond engrossed on proper stamp paper was filed into court on 7-5-57. The impugned order was passed on 5-11-58. The learned Small Cause Court Judge rejected the application on two grounds: (1) the security bond has not been filed within thirty days of the passing of the ex parte decree; and (2) that the security bond is not a valid security bond in the eye of law. The reason for this was that the purpose for which the security had to be furnished was to ensure the performance of the ex parte decree in case that decree is not set aside, but in the security bond the security had been furnished by the petitioner for the performance of the ultimate decree that might be passed in the event of the ex parte decree being set aside.

7. As far as the position in law is concerned, it is well settled, as has been laid down by me in the case referred to above. Mr. Ramdas however sought to argue that the bond which he had filed within the period of limitation should be taken as a valid security bond for the due performance of the ex parte decree. The question is whether the draft bond which had been filed on 22-2-57 would be taken as a valid security bond upon which the court could act. To begin with this bond was executed by a third person Krushna Chandra Moharana and the bond was for a sum of Rs. 200/- whereas the decretal dues were for Rs. 247/- inclusive of the costs. Naturally the court rejected that and asked the petitioner to file a proper security bond by his order dated 2G-2-57 and the fair security bond was filed on 7-5-57 much beyond the period of limitation.

8. Mr. Ramdas wanted to argue that since the court did not pass the order within the period of limitation when he filed the draft security bond on 20-2-57, the petitioner should not be penalised for the laches of the court. I cannot acceed to this argument of Mr. Ramdas. The security bond that was filed on 20-2-57 could not be taken to be a valid security bond on which the Court could act. The only security bond that had been filed on 7-5-57 is the bond on which the court could act, but that had been filed much beyond the period of limitation. Mr. Ramdas wanted to rely upon two cases of the Andhra Pradesh High Court and the Madras High Court.

9. In the case in P. Satyanarayana v. V. Ramabrahman, 1960-1 Andh WR 24 : (AIR 1960 Andh Pra 230) a Full Bench of the Andhra High Court took the view that an unregistered security bond is sufficient compliance with the law provided the delay in getting it registered is not due to any fault of the applicant himself. The test is whether the security which the party placed in the hands of the court and which the court ultimately accepted was sufficient to enforce the obligation upon him.

10. Therefore, the filing in time of the draft bond, if accepted by the court after scrutiny would be sufficient compliance with the requirements of the proviso to Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act. Where, therefore, security is tendered within time and proves, even though tested after the time, eventually to be sufficient, the applicant must be deemed to have complied with the requirements of the proviso to S. 17. The words ‘give such, security’ in the proviso to S. 17 may be construed to mean ‘tender such security’.

11. A similar view was taken by the Madras High Court in the case of In re: Chinnathambi Asari 1958-2 Mad LJ 594. A learned Single Judge in that case held that where at the time of filing an application for setting aside an ex parte decree, the defendant files a draft security bond giving a list of immovable properties offered as security, and after the security is tested and found sufficient, the defendant executes a fair bond and files it in court in accordance with the direction of the Court within the time limited by the proviso to Section 17(1) of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act, and it is accepted by the Court, it must be held that the security has been given in time and that the requirements of Sec. 17(1) proviso, have been satisfied.

12. The circumstance that the bond is registered only subsequently, after the period of 30 days from the date of knowledge of the decree, does not affect the matter, as the bond, when registered, would take effect and date back to the date of execution. I am not here in this case concerned with the fact of registration or dating it back to the date of execution. Hence, I would reserve my opinion on that point. It has been stated at the Bar that there is divergence of opinion on this point between the opinions of the Madras High Court and the other High Courts in India. Since it is not necessary to be decided in this case, I express no opinion on it.

13. With regard to the second reason adopted by the Small Cause Court Judge that the security is not a valid security in the eye of law, Mr. Pal sought to rely upon a decision of the Calcutta High Court reported in Pulin Chandra v. Khetra Mohan, AIR 1939 Cal 748. In that a learned single Judge of the Calcutta High Court has held that the purpose for which security has to be furnished is to ensure the performance of the ex parte decree in case that decree is not set aside. The security to be furnished is not for the performance of the ultimate decree that might be passed in the event of the ex parte decree being set aside. Edgley, J. while coming to this decision had relied upon a decision of the Bombay High Court in Maganlal Pitamberdas Khatri…Applicant; v. Dahyabhai Chhaganlal Vyas…Opponent., AIR 1938 Bom 448.

14. Thus, the fact that stands out in this case is that a valid security bond on which the court could act was not filed within a period of thirty days from the date of the ex parte decree. That being the position, the subsequent filing of the security bond with the permission of the court or having it accepted by the court would not enable the petitioner to comply with the provisions of Section 17 of the Small Cause Courts Act.

15. Accordingly, I find that the provisions contained in the proviso to Sec. 17 have not been complied with and the Small Cause Court Judge has taken the right view in the matter.

16. In the result, this application is dismissed with costs.

KD/R.G.D

17. Application dismissed.