Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Laxmi Devi Dwivedi And Others v. State Of Madhya Pradesh And Others

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Jan 7, 2003
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal challenges the award passed by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Shahdol, in Claim Case No. 30/92, dated 12-12-1997. The deceased, Vinod Kumar Dwivedi, a Sub-Auditor in the Panchayat Department of the Government of Madhya Pradesh, was traveling by a Forest Department jeep driven by Sunderlal for election duty on 10-1-1991. The vehicle, driven rashly and negligently, fell into a river between Anuppur and Chachai, resulting in serious injuries to the deceased who died the following day in the District Hospital, Shahdol. At the time, he earned a monthly salary of Rs. 1,958 and was 33 years old. He left behind a wife and five daughters who depended entirely on him. The claimants sought compensation of Rs. 11,67,000/- for the loss sustained.

The respondents denied negligent driving, claimed the driver was compelled to drive under difficult conditions, and argued the claim was exaggerated. They also contended that since the claimant wife was appointed on compassionate grounds, the claim should be dismissed.

The Claims Tribunal found the accident occurred as alleged and that the claimants were entitled to maintain the petition. It awarded Rs. 65,000/- with 12% interest per annum and Rs. 500/- costs, reasoning that the wife’s pension and compassionate appointment disqualified her from full compensation.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Claims Tribunal erred in assessing the income of the deceased and consequently in awarding just compensation.
  2. Whether the family pension and compassionate appointment of the widow should reduce the compensation awarded.
  3. Whether the claimant widow, appointed on compassionate grounds, is entitled to maintain a petition for compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The Claims Tribunal committed a serious error in assessing the deceased’s income, resulting in inadequate compensation.
  • No deduction should be made from compensation on account of the widow receiving family pension or having been appointed on compassionate grounds.
  • Relied on the Division Bench decision in Smt. Dayavati Bai and Ors. v. Devendra Singh and Ors. which held that family pension payable to the widow is not to be deducted from compensation.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The driver was not negligent but compelled to drive under difficult conditions.
  • The claim is exaggerated.
  • The claimant widow’s appointment on compassionate grounds disqualifies her from compensation, or justifies deduction of salary received.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Smt. Dayavati Bai and Ors. v. Devendra Singh and Ors., 2000(1) M.P.H.T. 1 (NOC) Family pension payable to the widow of the deceased is not to be deducted from the compensation amount. The Court relied on this precedent to reject the reduction of compensation on account of family pension.
Andhra Pradesh State Road Trans. Corporation v. G. Jana Bai and Ors, 2002 ACJ 502 Recognition that the widow appointed on compassionate grounds remains entitled to maintain a petition for compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act. The Court cited this decision to reject the contention that compassionate appointment disqualifies the widow from claiming compensation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court affirmed the Claims Tribunal’s finding that the accident was caused by rash and negligent driving of the vehicle, supported by evidence. The dispute centered on the quantum of compensation. The deceased’s monthly salary at the time was Rs. 1,958, from which one-third was deducted for personal expenses, resulting in a monthly dependency of Rs. 1,306 and an annual dependency of Rs. 15,672. Applying a multiplier of 17 (appropriate for the deceased’s age of 33), the compensation was calculated at Rs. 2,66,414.

The Court rejected the respondent’s contention that compensation should be reduced due to the widow’s compassionate appointment and salary received post-accident. It distinguished compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act, which is payable to legal heirs, from compassionate appointments made by employers, governed by separate executive orders. Thus, no deduction was warranted.

Additional amounts were awarded for loss of expectancy of life (Rs. 7,000), consortium to the wife (Rs. 5,000), loss to the estate (Rs. 2,500), and funeral expenses (Rs. 2,000), bringing total compensation to Rs. 2,82,414. The Court ordered interest at 9% per annum from the date of application until payment and directed costs to be borne by the parties.

Holding and Implications

The appeal was allowed in part by enhancing the compensation awarded to Rs. 2,82,414/- plus interest and costs.

The Court’s decision clarifies that family pension and compassionate appointment do not reduce the compensation payable under the Motor Vehicles Act to legal heirs. The ruling directly affects the parties by increasing the compensation but does not establish new precedent beyond reaffirming existing principles.

Show all summary ...

1. This appeal is directed against the award passed by Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Shahdol, Claim Case No. 30/92, dated 12-12-1997.

2. Vinod Kumar- Dwivedi was Sub-Auditor, Panchayat Department, Government of Madhya Pradesh. On 10-1-1991 at about 12.30 P.M. he had gone to Anuppur and Kotma with his colleagues by Jeep No. CPZ 2951. This jeep was of Forest Department driven by Sunderlal and purpose of visit was election duty. When they reached a place between Anuppur and Chachai, it fell into the river. This happened because driver was driving it rashly and negligently. As a result, deceased suffered serious injuries and died in the District Hospital, Shahdol, on 11-1-1991. At the time of accident he was receiving salary of Rs. 1,958/- per month. He was 33 years old at that time. He left behind wife Smt. Laxmi Devi Dwivedi (30), daughters Ku. Anju (9), Ku. Neelu (7), Ku. Renuka (5), Ku. Rashmi (3) and Ku. Ruchi (5 months). On account of this death, the family has been left high and dry since it was entirely depending on the deceased. Compensation of Rs. 11,67,000/- has been claimed.

3. Respondents have denied that the driver was driving the vehicle rashly and negligently. Claim is exaggerated. The driver was compelled to drive the vehicle with three occupants during night. The claimant has been appointed on compassionate ground, therefore, claim is liable to be dismissed.

4. Claims Tribunal has held that the accident took place as alleged in which deceased died and that the claimants were entitled to maintain the petition. Ultimately, compensation of Rs. 65,000/- has been awarded with interest at the rate of 12 per cent per annum with cost Rs. 500/-. The Claims Tribunal awarded this compensation holding that wife was receiving pension and had been appointed on compassionate ground, therefore, she was not entitled to compensation.

5. Shri N.K. Tiwari, learned Counsel appearing for the appellants submits that Claims Tribunal has committed serious error in assessing the income of the deceased therefore, just compensation has not been awarded. There would be no reduction on account of pension and compassionate appointment. Reliance is placed on Division Bench decision of this Court in Smt. Dayavati Bai and Ors. v. Devendra Singh and Ors., 2000(1) M.P.H.T. 1 (NOC), which, after taking into consideration some decisions of this Court, holds that in view of consistent view of the Court, family pension payable to the widow of deceased is not to be deducted from the amount of compensation awarded.

6. The finding of the Claims Tribunal with regard to accident being result of rash and negligent driving of the vehicle is sustainable on the evidence in the case. The dispute relates to assessment of compensation. On the date of accident deceased was receiving salary of Rs. 1,958/- per month. After making deduction of l/3rd toward personal expenditure monthly dependency comes to Rs. 1,306/-, yearly Rs. 15,672/-. At the time of accident, deceased was 33 years old. By application of multiplier of 17, the compensation works out to Rs. 2,66,414/-.

7. The contention of Shri P.D. Gupta, Deputy Advocate General that since wife of deceased has been appointed on compassionate ground, compensation to the extent of salary being received by appellant should be deducted. We do not accept this contention. Compensation is awarded on account of the death of deceased who happens to be her husband. It is arrived at on the basis of certain principles, while appointment on compassionate ground is, by way of compassion, shown by the employer due to the death of its employee during employment and governed by executive orders/instructions. Under Motor Vehicles Act wife is one of the legal heirs of the deceased, therefore, entitled to maintain petition for compensation. A Division Bench of Andhra Pradesh High Court has taken similar view in Andhra Pradesh State Road Trans. Corporation v. G. Jana Bai and Ors. (2002 ACJ 502). Therefore, the contention is rejected.

8. Apart from the compensation assessed above, claimants are also entitled to Rs. 7,000/- for loss of expectancy of life, Rs. 5,000/- for consortium to the wife, Rs. 2,500/- for loss to the estate and Rs. 2,000/- for funeral expenses. Therefore, the total amount of compensation payable in this case is Rs. 2,82,414/-. Enhanced compensation will carry interest at the rate of 9 per cent per annum from the date of application till payment. Costs on parties.