- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Shri Saingura v. Shri F. Sapa And Others
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The election petitioner filed a petition alleging that the first respondent committed corrupt practice within the meaning of Section 123 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951. The first respondent appeared, but after taking several adjournments for filing his written statement an ex parte hearing was fixed. The first respondent subsequently filed a written statement together with a petition to set aside the ex parte order; the High Court set aside the ex parte hearing order and accepted the written statement.
Issues were framed and the case was listed for hearing. The first respondent raised preliminary objections on maintainability which this Court rejected by order dated 3-9-90. The first respondent appealed to the Supreme Court, which admitted the petition and stayed further proceedings; by order dated 22-8-91 the Supreme Court disposed of the appeal with a direction to rectify defects. The High Court thereafter fixed 6-1-91 for trial at Aizawl, Mizoram.
The petitioner filed successive applications: (i) on 16-11-91 for summons to produce certain original documents (explaining omissions and that copies had been filed except certain serial numbers); (ii) on 17-12-91 a similar application for production of documents; and (iii) on 20-1-92 for summons to call witnesses whose names were not in the earlier list (notably Sri Oscar Fernandes, whose evidence related to a letter dated 15-12-88 obtained only on 18-1-91 and filed on 20-1-91).
The first respondent objected to the late applications, contending that the petitioner should have produced or applied for summons for documentary evidence before the issues were settled, that procedural requirements under the Code of Civil Procedure were not complied with, and that introducing witnesses and documents at the belated stage would prejudice the respondent.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the High Court should allow summons to be issued for production of original documents and for witnesses not named in the originally filed list at a belated stage in an election petition.
- Whether procedural provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure (notably Order VII Rule 14, Order VII Rule 18, Order XIII Rule 1 and Order XVI Rule 1) apply strictly to trials of election petitions under Section 87 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951, or whether the "spirit" of those provisions governs.
- Whether the Court should refuse admission of documents (or the summoning of witnesses to produce documents) where the documents were not in the petitioner's possession at the time of filing and only copies were filed earlier.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments (as summarised in the opinion)
- The petitioner explained omissions were due to oversight/inadvertence and that original manuscripts were in the possession of third parties (listed in the Schedule), not the petitioner; copies had already been filed for most documents.
- The petitioner engaged new counsel (in Guwahati) due to difficulties of distance from his Delhi counsel; the applications were filed at the earliest opportunity after detection of omissions.
- Order XVI Rule 1 (CPC) permits the Court to allow witnesses whose names do not appear in the list if sufficient cause is shown; therefore these petitions should be entertained following the spirit of Order XVI.
- In an election petition (which involves quasi-criminal corrupt practice charges), parties should be given opportunities to prove their case and not unduly penalised on technical grounds like delay in filing the list of witnesses.
First Respondent's Arguments (as summarised in the opinion)
- The petitioner ought to have produced documents, or at least filed an application for summons to produce them before issues were framed; the failure to do so meant the documents were inadmissible at that stage.
- The petitioner delayed deliberately and was negligent in conducting the case; issuing summons at a belated stage would prejudice the respondent and frustrate justice.
- The petitioner had local counsel (from Guwahati) yet did not produce documents or make timely applications; there has been suppression of material facts and non-compliance with procedural provisions (CPC).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Tripura Modern Bank Ltd. v. Sushil Chandra Dutta, AIR 1953 Assam 40 | The opinion cited this decision as an example of cases relating to filing of documents at a later stage where courts accepted documents if good and sufficient cause was shown. | The Court treated it as authority that supports accepting belatedly produced documents when good cause is shown; used to justify lenience in accepting the petitioner's applications. |
| Dr. Jagjit Singh v. Kartar Singh, AIR 1966 SC 773 | The Supreme Court's statement that charges of corrupt practice are quasi-criminal and must be proved satisfactorily; thus election petitioners should be given opportunity to prove their case. | The Court relied on this principle to emphasise that technical procedural defaults should not defeat a party's opportunity to prove quasi-criminal election-related charges. |
| D. Athubon v. G. Choba Koboi, 1973 ALR 151 | The opinion referenced this case as relating to the filing of documents at a later stage and acceptance where sufficient cause is shown. | The Court treated it as supportive authority for accepting late-filed documents upon satisfactory explanation. |
| Shri Jai Prakash Singh … v. Shri Ram Narayan Singh …, (1987) 1 GLR 372 | Referenced as a case concerning acceptance of documents filed at a later stage when good cause is shown. | The Court cited it among authorities demonstrating judicial discretion to admit belated documents if reasons are sufficient. |
| (1990) 2 GLR 221 | The opinion listed this decision among other similar authorities related to late filing of documents. | The Court included it in the group of authorities indicating documents may be accepted on showing of sufficient cause; no separate detailed application in this opinion. |
| AIR 1952 TC 445 | The opinion cited this decision (respondent's counsel relied on it) but did not specify in the text the precise rule or principle attributed to it. | The Court noted it as one of the authorities relied upon by the respondent concerning filing/acceptance of documents; no distinct further application in the opinion. |
| AIR 1957 AP 784 | The opinion cited this decision (respondent's counsel relied on it) but did not specify the particular principle attributed to it in the text. | The Court recorded it as an authority relied upon by the respondent; the opinion does not expand on specific application beyond noting the general line of authorities. |
| Smti Sahodrabai Rai v. Ram Singh Aharwar, AIR 1968 SC 1079 | The Supreme Court observed that the trial of an election petition is to follow, as far as may be, the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure and that it is permissible to look into the CPC to see what would have been the case if it were a suit. | The High Court used this principle to justify considering CPC provisions by analogy but also to support a flexible approach (the "spirit" of the CPC) in election petition trials. |
| AIR 1973 Gau 145 | The opinion listed this decision among respondent-cited authorities; the text did not specify the exact principle attributed to it. | Noted as part of the respondent's authorities concerning document production and exclusion under Rule 18; no separate detailed application in the opinion. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court conducted a stepwise analysis focused on the procedural rules invoked and the factual circumstances of the case:
- The Court examined Section 87 of the Representation of the People Act (R.P. Act) which directs that an election petition shall be tried by the High Court as nearly as may be in accordance with the procedure applicable under the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC). The Court concluded that the CPC applies subject to the R.P. Act and that only where the R.P. Act provides otherwise would CPC provisions be inapplicable.
-
The Court reviewed the relevant CPC provisions relied upon by the parties:
- Order VII Rule 14 (requirement to file documents on which the plaintiff sues and to file list of documents relied upon), and Rule 18 (precluding receipt of such documents in evidence without leave) — described as a penal provision to prevent suspicious or doubtful documents.
- Order XIII (Rule 1) requiring production of documentary evidence in a party's power and possession at and before settlement of issues, with the Court having discretion under sub-rule (2) to accept documents later upon good cause.
- Order XVI Rule 1 requiring parties to present a list of witnesses within a prescribed time, with sub-rule (3) empowering the Court to allow witnesses not listed if sufficient cause is shown.
- Applying those provisions to the facts, the Court found key factual features: the documents sought were originals in third parties' possession (copies had already been filed); the genuineness of the documents had not been challenged by the first respondent; and the trial had not yet commenced.
- The Court concluded the petitions did not fall under the strict operation of Order VII Rule 14(1)(2) because the documents were not in the petitioner's possession and thus Order XIII's requirements did not strictly attract. Consequently, the penal provision of Rule 18 of Order VII did not automatically apply.
- As to the list of witnesses, while the petitioner ought to have filed the list within the stipulated time (15 days after settlement of issues), the petitioner's explanation for late filing (including difficulties of communication between distant counsel and the courts in Mizoram) was held to amount to sufficient cause.
- The Court emphasised a functional approach: procedural strictness should be tempered in election petitions — particularly from remote regions such as Mizoram — and the "spirit" rather than the strict letter of the CPC should guide the Court's exercise of discretion in such trials.
- Given all circumstances — unchallenged genuineness of documents, documents in third-party possession, trial not having commenced, and lack of demonstrated prejudice to the respondent — the Court exercised its discretion to permit issuance of summons to the witnesses and for production of the original documents.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court issued the following operative direction: PETITION ALLOWED. Specifically, the Court ordered that summons be issued to the witnesses for giving evidence and for production of the documents as prayed for by the petitioner. The petitioner was directed to pay costs of Rs. 200 (Rupees Two hundred).
Implications:
- Direct effect: The petitioner's requests for summons to witnesses and for production of the listed documents were granted and the witnesses may be summoned to give evidence and to produce the documents. The petitioner must pay the specified nominal costs to the respondent.
- Scope and precedent: The opinion reflects and applies existing authorities to show that courts have a wide discretion to admit belatedly produced documents or witnesses where genuineness is not disputed and sufficient cause is shown. The Court endorsed a flexible approach to procedural provisions of the CPC in election petitions (guided by Section 87 R.P. Act), particularly where geographic and practical difficulties exist. The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel legal principle beyond applying established discretion; it addresses the parties' immediate procedural applications rather than announcing a broader new precedent.
Petition allowed.
This summary is based exclusively on the content and language of the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond what the opinion contains.
1. The petitioner filed the election petition alleging that the first respondent is guilty of corrupt practice within the meaning of Section 123 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951. The first respondent appeared on receipt of notice and filed written statement. However, he took several adjournments for filing the written statement, which compelled this Court to fix the case for ex parte hearing. Ultimately, the first respondent filed the written statement with a petition for setting aside the ex parte order and to accept the written statement. After hearing the parties, this Court set aside the ex parte order of hearing and accepted the written statement.
2. Thereafter, issues were framed and the case was posted for hearing. Meanwhile, the first respondent raised some preliminary objections as to the maintainability of the election petition and this Court rejected the preliminary objections by order dated 3-9-90. Against that order, the first respondent moved the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court admitted the petition and stayed further proceedings. By order dated 22-8-91 the Supreme Court disposed of the appeal with a direction to rectify the defects. This Court, thereafter, fixed 6-1-91 for trial of the cases at Aizwal, Mizoram.
3. In the meantime on 16-11-91 the election petitioner filed an application praying for issuance of summons to produce certain documents. In this petition, he inter alia, stated that his case was conducted by a counsel practicing and residing in New Delhi. Due to long and hazardous distance between Aizawl and New Delhi and other difficulties, he could not meet his counsel. Having faced with such difficulties, the election petitioner engaged another set of counsel practicing at Guwahati to conduct the case. These newly engaged counsel appeared on 19-9-91. Thereafter, on scrutiny of the records it was found that there had been omissions to call for the original manuscript of the documents described in the Schedule to the petition due to oversight and inadvertence. The petitioner further stated that all the documents except the documents mentioned in serial Nos. 11, 12 and 13 were already annexed to the election petition and copies thereof were furnished to the respondents. Besides, these documents listed in the Scheduled were required to be produced by the persons who were cited as witnesses on behalf of the election petitioner in the list of witness already filed. The documents listed and mentioned in Schedule were in power and possession of the persons mentioned in Column (3) of the Schedule. The petitioner further stated that this application was filed at the earliest opportunity after detection of the omissions. According to the election petitioner his case mainly based on these documents and if the documents were not called for, the petitioner would be denied fair trial which would cause serious prejudice to him.
4. The election petitioner filed a similar application on 17-12-91 also praying for issuance of summons to produce documents.
5. Again on 20-1-92 the election petitioner filed yet another petition praying for issuance of summons to witnesses whose names were not mentioned in the list of witnesses already filed before this Court. In this petition, he had, inter alia, stated that a list of witnesses to be examined by the election petitioner was already filed and the same was on record. It was further stated that issues were settled on 6-12-90 and the list of witnesses was prepared by the counsel in consultation with petitioner's representatives on 7-12-90. The petitioner's representatives wanted to verify the names of the witnesses and, therefore, he intended to visit Guwahati. However, the list could not be filed as the representative of the petitioner failed to turn up for verification. Ultimately on 8-1-91, the petitioner's counsel filed additional list of witnesses. The name of one witness, viz. Sri Oscar Fernandes was not mentioned in the list of witnesses filed earlier. This witness was a material witness for the petitioner in view of the fact that he wrote a letter dated 15-12-88 to the Chief Electoral Officer, Mizoram, Aizawl and the petitioner could obtain a certified copy of the letter only on 18-1-91 and filed the same on 20-1-91. He further stated that the said letter was not available to the petitioner on the date of filing the list of witnesses on 8-1-91, and, therefore, the name of Sri Oscar Fernandes could not be included in the list of witnesses. He also stated that the letter dated 15-12-88 was an important document having a great bearing upon the merit of the petitioner's case, especially in view of the stand taken by the first respondent in his written statement. The petitioner further stated that he was not guilty of any deliberate laces or negligence for omission to mention the name of Sri Oscar Fernandes in the list of witnesses and the situation was beyond his control. The evidence in the present case was yet to be recorded, and, therefore, respondents would not suffer any-loss or prejudice, if this Court issued summons to the witness to prove the contents of the said letter and his signature. Therefore, for the ends of justice, it was necessary for this Court to summon the said witness Sri Oscar Fernandes and other witnesses mentioned in the Schedule-A to this petition.
6. The first respondent filed objection against the application praying for issuance of summons to produce documents. The respondent stated that the election petitioner ought to have produced or at least filed an application praying for issuance of summons of documentary evidence on which the election petitioner intended to rely on or before the issues were framed by this Court. But even after framing of issues on 6-12-90 neither he produced any documents nor he filed any application for issuance of summons, nor he filed any list of witnesses as required under the provisions of Code of Civil Procedure. The first respondent also stated that the case was listed for hearing at Aizwal and Sri Joginder Singh an Advocate from Guwahati appeared for the election petitioner. But he did neither produce any document nor he filed any application praying for issuance of summons to produce documents. He also stated that the petitioner having sued on the documents mentioned in the Schedule to the application, ought to have produced the documents and the same having not been produced at the time of presentation of the election petition, the documents were inadmissible at that stage. He also denied that there was any lack of communication between the counsel at Delhi and the petitioner in view of the fact that the petitioner had a local counsel practicing at Guwahati. The election petitioner deliberately delayed the production of the documents and the filing of the application for issuance of summons, to produce the documents. He stated that the election petitioner was negligent in conducting his case, and, therefore, the prayer made at the belated stage should not be allowed.
7. The first respondent also filed an objection against the prayer for issuance of summons to witnesses. The witnesses mentioned in Schedule A to the application are at variance to the list of witnesses already submitted by the election petitioner, therefore, the petitioner had tried to bring some more witnesses by filing the petition. Besides, the first respondent also stated that if the summons were issued to the witnesses mentioned in Schedule-A to the application, it would affect the case of the respondent and would frustrate the cause of justice. Therefore, the prayer of the election petitioner should be rejected.
8. I have heard both sides. Mr. Mazumdar, learned counsel on behalf of the first respondent has submitted that these petitions are not maintainable in view of fact that the petitions have been filed at a belated stage and contrary to the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure. Besides, there have been suppression of some material facts. However, so far the suppression of material facts are concerned, Mr. Mazumdar has not elaborated. According to him, even though the Code of Civil Procedure is not applicable in Mizoram, but the Representation of the Peoples Act, in short the R.P Act, is applicable. He has referred to Section 87 of the R.P Act. Section 87 of the R.P Act runs thus:—
“Subject to the provisions of this Act and of any rules made there under, every election petition shall be tried by the High Court, as nearly as may be, in accordance with the procedure applicable under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908”.
According to this, the Code of Civil Procedure is applicable subject to provisions of R.P Act and if any provisions contrary to Code of Civil Procedure are provided in the R.P Act, only then the Code of Civil Procedure would be inapplicable. Otherwise, the Code of Civil Procedure is applicable.
9. Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner has drawn my attention to the provision of Order XVI Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. According to him, the petitions should be entertained following the spirit of Order XVI, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure (C.P.C) Mr. Mazumdar, learned counsel for the first respondent on the other hand, has submitted that while disposing of the petition, provision of Order VII, Rules 14 and 18 and also Order XIII Rules 1 and 2 should be looked into. In the light of submissions made by the learned counsel, it will be apposite to look into the said provisions of the C.P.C
10. Under sub-rule (1) of Rule 14 of Order VII of C.P.C the plaintiff is required to file all the documents on which he sues along with the plaint, and he is also required to file a list of documents which he relies on (whether in his possession or power or not). From the plain reading of this sub-rule of Rule 14 indicates that there are two types of documents, i.e the documents on which the plaintiff sues; these are required to be filed along with the plaint, and the documents on which the plaintiff relies in support of his claim, he is required to give a list of such documents. The effect of non-compliance of sub-rules (1) and (2) of Rule 14 of Order VII is that such documents shall not be received in evidence without the leave of the Court under Rule 18 of the said order. Therefore, Rule 18 is a penal provision for non-compliance of Order VII, Rule 14. The object of Rule 18 is prevent suspecious and fraudulent document or document which is not genuine or doubtful about the existence at the time of filing, and, therefore, duty casts on the Court to see whether leave should be granted or not. While granting leave, it is the duty of the Court to see the document sought to be evidenced as required of Rule 14, is a genuine document or not. If the document appears to be a genuine document, the Court should always be lenient towards granting leave.
11. Under Order 13(1)(2), the parties should produce documentary evidence of any description in their power and possession at and before settlement of issues. If the documents are not filed at that time, the Court shall normally not receive such documents at a later stage unless good cause is shown. If any good cause is shown, under sub-rule (2) of Rule 1 of Order XIII empowers the Court to accept such document.
12. Under Order XVI Rule 1 requires the parties to present a list of witnesses whom they propose to call either to give evidence or produce documents. This must be done on any date appointed by the Court and not later than 15 days after the settlement of issues. It may be mentioned here that in the present case no date was fixed for filing of documents and list of witnesses after the filing of written statement or before settlement of issues. In sub-rule (3) of Rule 1 of Order XVI, however, empowers the Court to allow any witness to be summoned and examined by the parties, whose names do not appear in the list if any sufficient cause is shown.
13. Mr. Bhattacharjee states that copies of documents were already filed and the original documents and manuscript were not in his possession. Therefore, the production of documents in a manner contemplated under Order VII, Rule 14 and/or Rule 1 of Order XIII do not apply in the instant case. His case squarely covers by the spirit of Order XVI, inasmuch as, according to him, he has shown sufficient cause for not furnishing the list of witnesses within the time as envisages under Order XVI. Following the spirit of Order XVI, according to Mr. Bhattacharjee, the petitioner's prayer for issuance of summons to witness and for production of documents should be allowed.
14. Mr. Bhattacharjee relies on the following decisions: (i) AIR 1953 Assam 40; (ii) AIR 1966 SC 773; (iii) 1973 ALR 151 (iv) (1987) 1 GLR 372 and (v) (1990) 2 GLR 221.
15. In Dr. Jagjit Singh v. Kartar Singh, AIR 1966 SC 773, the Supreme Court observed thus (at page 779):—
“…..The charges of corrupt practice are in the nature of quasi criminal. The proof of the charge has a double consequence; the election of the returned candidate is set aside, and he incurs subsequent disqualification as well. Therefore, when a charge of this kind is framed against a returned candidate, it has to be proved satisfactorily…”
Relying on this decision Mr. Bhattacharjee submits that in an election petition all opportunities should be given to the parties to prove their case. On technical ground such as delay in filing, of list of witnesses, the party should not be allowed to suffer.
16. The other decisions referred to by the counsel for the petitioner, viz.; in The Tripura Modern Bank Ltd. v. Sushil Chandra Dutta, AIR 1953 Assam 40; in D. Athubon v. G. Choba Koboi, 1973 ALR 151; in Shri Jai Prakash Singh… v. Shri Ram Narayan Singh…Opposite Party., (1987) 1 GLR 372, etc., are all relating to filing of documents at a later stage. This Court in the above mentioned cases held that if good and sufficient cause is shown, documents should be accepted.
17. Mr. Mazumdar, learned counsel for the respondent has relied on the following decisions: (i) AIR 1952 TC 445; (ii) AIR 1957 AP 784; (iii) AIR 1968 SC 1079; and (iv) AIR 1973 Gau 145.
18. In Smti Sahodrabai Rai v. Ram Singh Aharwar, AIR 1968 SC 1079 : (1968 All LJ 782), the Supreme Court observed as follows (at page 1081):
“….It may be pointed out that the trial of election petition has to follow as far as may be the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure. We are therefore of opinion that it is permissible to look into the Code of Civil Procedure to see what exactly would have been the case if this was a suit and not a trial of an election petition….”
Other decisions cited by Mr. Mazumdar are related to filing of documents. As per these decisions, the policy underlying Rule 18 is to exclude document the genuineness of which may be suspected and the existence of which at the filing of the suit is doubtful. However, these decisions also indicate that a Court has wide discretion in the matter for production of documents which were not entered in the list as required by Order 7 Rule XIV. If the genuineness of the documents is not challenged, and good cause is shown, in that case the Court may accept these documents.
19. From the petitions as well as the written objections, it appears to me, that the documents sought to be called for by issuing summons are original documents which are not in the possession of the election petitioner and the copies of those documents were already filed along with the election petition. The first respondent in his objection also did not challenge the genuineness of the documents. His objection is that prayer for introduction of documents by summoning witnesses was filed at a belated stage without proper explanation, and if such documents are allowed to be introduced in evidence, the first respondent would be highly prejudiced.
20. In my opinion, the prayers of the petitioner for issuance of summons to the witnesses and for issuance of summons to produce documents do not come under the purview of Order 7, Rule 14(1)(2). Therefore, the question of application of the penal provision of Rule 18 does not arise. The documents sought to be introduced in evidence by summoning the witnesses are not in possession of the petitioner, and, therefore, the provisions of Order XIII also do not attract. The petitioner only very recently has filed these two petitions for summoning the witnesses to give evidence and to produce documents as per the Schedule annexed thereto. It is true that the list of witnesses ought to have been filed within the stipulated date after filing the written statement. As stated earlier, this Court did not fix any date for filing the list of witnesses. At any rate, the petitioner ought to have filed the list of witnesses within 15 days from the date of settlement of the issues if the Code of Civil Procedure is strictly applied. The petitioner has explained the reasons for late filing of the list of witnesses on 8-1-91. From the reasons given by the election petitioner appear to me that he failed to file the list of witnesses within time for sufficient cause. Besides, the provisions of Code of Civil Procedure should not be strictly followed in an election case, more so, in a case from Mizoram, which is situated at Eastern corner of the Country. As stated, in Mizoram, only the spirit of the Code of Civil Procedure is applicable.
21. Considering all the aspects of the matter, I think it proper to allow the petitioner to issue summons to witnesses for giving evidence and for production of documents, as prayed for. It may be mentioned here that the trial has not yet been begun and the first respondent will not be prejudiced if the witnesses are summoned and the documents are produced as prayed for by the petitioner.
22. In view of the above, it is ordered that summons shall be issued to the witnesses for giving evidence and also for production of documents as prayed for by the petitioner.
In the result the petition is allowed. However, the petitioner shall pay a cost of Rs. 200/- (Rupees Two hundred) as costs.
Petition allowed.
Alert