- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Nanak Chand v. Delhi Jal Board .
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Hima Kohli, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitions seek issuance of a writ of mandamus, or any other appropriate writ, order or direction for quashing/declaring the respondent's order dated 10 April 2006 rejecting the petitioners' claims for appointment on compassionate grounds.
For convenience, the judgment records facts of W.P.(C) No. 12609 in detail. The petitioner’s father had been employed as a "Fitter II Class" with the Delhi Jal Board and died while in service on 23 October 2001, leaving behind the petitioner and his mother. The petitioner applied for compassionate appointment on 15 February 2002. The respondent directed the petitioner to appear for an interview on 23 October 2002; after interview the petitioner was informed by letter dated 9 October 2003 that the Screening Committee had considered the application and the Competent Authority rejected it on grounds including that the petitioner owned a house, had no other liability, and had sufficient terminal dues and pension.
The petitioner filed writ petition W.P.(C) No. 10931/2005; that petition was allowed on 1 February 2006, permitting the petitioner to apply afresh including a claim for consideration as a Scheduled Caste candidate. Pursuant thereto the petitioner applied again on 23 February 2006, appeared for interview on 9 March 2006, and by order dated 10 April 2006 the respondent rejected the application on the ground that there was no post vacant against the reserved quota for compassionate appointment and that there were other deserving cases in more merciful conditions.
A related petition W.P.(C) No. 12613/2006 involves similar facts pertaining to another petitioner; both petitions were taken up together for final hearing and disposal as the issues were common.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the respondent's order dated 10 April 2006 rejecting the petitioners' claims for appointment on compassionate grounds should be quashed.
- Whether the respondent followed the applicable scheme, rules and administrative instructions in assessing the petitioners' entitlement to compassionate appointment, including consideration of family financial position (pension, terminal dues, family liabilities, etc.).
- Whether the High Court, in exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 226, may interfere with the competent authority's factual and discretionary findings on compassionate appointment (i.e., whether the decision-making process was vitiated).
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The grounds on which the applications for compassionate appointment were rejected were "totally wrong, incorrect, false and malafide."
- The respondent failed to consider that the petitioners were unemployed and had no source of income except the meagre family pension of the deceased father, which was insufficient to support their families.
- Specific family circumstances were highlighted: in W.P.(C) No. 12609 the petitioner allegedly had a large family including wife, three minor children and mother; in W.P.(C) No. 12613 the petitioner had a wife, two children and mother; the family pension of Rs. 3,500/- per month was contended to be insufficient.
Respondent's Arguments
- Compassionate appointments in the respondent board were reserved at a maximum of 5% of direct recruitment vacancies and, due to many applications, a Departmental Screening Committee was constituted to consider applications fairly.
- An eligibility criteria was applied by the Screening Committee considering factors such as: age of employee at death, number of children and their ages, family property, amount of benefits given to the family and family pension. The Screening Committee's recommendations were based on these criteria.
- The deceased employees had completed two-thirds of their service; payments (terminal dues and family pension) given to the families were found sufficient.
- There was no post lying vacant against the reserved quota for compassionate appointment, and other applicants in more merciful conditions were available; therefore the petitioners' applications were rightly rejected.
- The High Court should not determine what constitutes a reasonable income for survival or decide whether a family had been left in penury; the proper question is whether the competent authority's decision-making process is vitiated. Reliance was placed on State Bank of India v. Somvir Singh and Savitri Devi v. Union of India & Ors.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| State Bank of India & Anr. v. Somvir Singh, JT 2007 (3) SC 398 | High Court should not itself decide reasonable income/penury; it may only examine whether the competent authority's decision-making process is vitiated. | The court relied on this to support the proposition that it should not substitute its own view for the competent authority's factual evaluation and to decline interference absent vitiation. |
| Savitri Devi & Anr. v. Union of India & Ors., 2005 (85) DRJ 175 (DB) | Where dependants receive family pension and the deceased had completed majority of service, it cannot be said that the family is unable to make both ends meet. | The court noted this authority as reflecting that family pension and substantial service tenure are relevant factors against compassionate appointment. |
| State Of Manipur v. Md. Rajaodin, (2003) 7 SCC 511 | Parameters to be kept in mind: compassionate appointment is an exception to normal recruitment; must respect equality and affirmative action principles (Articles 14 and 16); object is to tide over sudden financial crisis. | The court followed these parameters as basic guiding principles when assessing compassionate appointment claims. |
| Umesh Kumar Nagpal v. State of Haryana, (1994) 4 SCC 138 | Support for regulated compassionate appointment schemes (context: limited percentage, adherence to rules). | Used as authority for the proposition that compassionate appointments must be made in accordance with scheme/regulations. |
| State of Haryana v. Rani Devi, (1996) 5 SCC 308 | Support for regulated compassionate appointment schemes and consideration under the rules. | Invoked to demonstrate settled law that compassionate appointments are governed by rules and limited quotas. |
| State of Haryana v. Ankur Gupta, (2003) 7 SCC 704 | Support for the principle that compassionate appointments are governed by the scheme and limited in application. | Referred to as part of the line of cases that define the controlled nature of compassionate appointment schemes. |
| Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd. v. A. Radhika Thirumalai (Smt), JT 1996 (9) SC 197 | Compassionate appointment can be made only if a vacancy is available for that purpose. | The court applied this principle to uphold that absence of vacancy is a valid ground for rejection; the judgment's rule was followed. |
| Jasbir Singh v. Director (INMAS) & Ors., 121 (2005) DLT 411 | Application of Hindustan Aeronautics principle in this Court (single judge) that vacancy is necessary for compassionate appointment. | The court noted that the single judge had followed Hindustan Aeronautics and treated it as precedential support. |
| General Manager (D&PB) and Ors. v. Kunti Tiwary and Anr., 2004 (7) SCC 271 | High Court cannot dilute the criterion of 'penury' to a lesser standard such as "not very well-to-do". | The court relied on this observation to reinforce that mere hardship or not being well-to-do is not sufficient; strict adherence to the scheme's criterion is required. |
| Union Bank of India & Ors. v. M.T Lateesh, 2006 (7) SCC 350 | Authorities constituted by rules are better equipped to decide; High Court should not fetter discretion of appointing/selection authorities; compassionate appointments are exceptions to general recruitment and guided by family's financial condition. | The court cited this to support non-interference with competent authority's factual findings and to hold that the High Court should not direct appointment contrary to the scheme. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court set out to determine whether the respondent's rejection of the petitioners' claims for compassionate appointment was vitiated or arbitrary, and whether interference under Article 226 was warranted.
The court first recorded and applied established parameters from the Supreme Court decisions governing compassionate appointments: (a) such appointments are an exception to the normal recruitment process and cannot be treated as a matter of right; (b) the object is to tide over a sudden financial crisis caused by the death of an employee while in service; (c) rules, regulations and administrative instructions must conform to Articles 14 and 16; and (d) compassionate appointments are subject to quantitative limits (in the respondent board's scheme, up to 5% of direct recruitment vacancies).
The court analysed the respondent's decision-making process and factual findings: the Screening Committee considered relevant factors (age at death, number and ages of children, family property, benefits paid including terminal dues and family pension). The petitioners' requests were considered twice (October 2003 and April 2006, the latter pursuant to the earlier order of this Court treating them as reserved-category candidates). On consideration, the respondent found (i) absence of any vacancy even in the reserved quota for compassionate appointment; (ii) existence of other deserving cases in more merciful conditions; and (iii) that the petitioners had received terminal dues and were receiving family pensions and, in one case, owned a house and had no other liabilities.
The court emphasised settled law that terminal benefits and other sources of income must be taken into account when deciding compassionate appointment claims. Given the absence of vacancy and the screening committee's findings that others were more deserving and that the petitioners had sufficient means, the court concluded that the respondent's grounds for rejection were neither arbitrary nor irrelevant.
Relying on Supreme Court authorities, the court reiterated that the High Court's role is limited to examining whether the competent authority's decision-making process was vitiated; it must not substitute its own view of what constitutes reasonable income or penury where the authority has applied the scheme and reached a factual conclusion. Applying these principles to the facts, the court found no vitiation in the respondent’s decision-making and therefore declined to interfere.
Holding and Implications
Writ petitions dismissed.
Direct effect on the parties: the court upheld the respondent's rejection of the petitioners' applications for compassionate appointment dated 10 April 2006; the writ petitions were dismissed as devoid of merit and there was no order as to costs.
Broader implications: the court reiterated settled principles (drawn from Supreme Court authorities) limiting judicial interference with competent authorities' factual and discretionary findings in compassionate-appointment cases. The opinion did not announce any new legal principle or change existing precedent; it applied established authority to the facts before it.
Hima Kohli, J.— With the consent of counsels for the parties, both these writ petitions are taken up for final hearing and disposal by passing a common order as the issues involved are common.
2. By way of the present petitions the petitioners have sought issuance of a writ of mandamus, or any other appropriate writ, order or direction for quashing/declaring the order dated 10th April, 2006 passed by the respondent, rejecting the claims of the petitioners for appointment on compassionate grounds.
3. For the sake of convenience, only the facts of W.P(C) No. 12609, are being stated in brief. The father of the petitioner was working as a ‘Fitter II Class’ with Delhi Jal Board and died in harness while in service on 23rd October, 2001 at Delhi, leaving behind the petitioner and the petitioner's mother. The petitioner applied for appointment on compassionate ground vide application dated 15th February, 2002. On 20th September, 2002, the respondent after considering the application of the petitioner for compassionate appointment, directed the petitioner to appear for Interview on 23rd October, 2002. The petitioner appeared for the said interview and was informed by the respondent vide its letter dated 9th October, 2003 that his application had been considered by the Screening Committee in its meeting and his application was rejected by the Competent Authority on the grounds that “he having own house, no other liability, sufficient terminal dues and pension etc.”. Thereafter the petitioner sent some reminders to the respondent but having received no reply to the same, a writ petition being W.P(C) No. 10931/2005 was filed in this court by the petitioner which was allowed vide order dated 1st February, 2006 on the ground that since the petitioner had originally not made a claim for compassionate appointment with reference to his caste, he was given the liberty to approach the respondent afresh with an application with the direction that the same shall also include his claim for consideration as a scheduled caste in quota available for compassionate appointment. Pursuant thereto, the petitioner moved another application for consideration on suitable post on compassionate ground under the Scheduled Caste category on 23rd February, 2006. Accordingly the petitioner appeared for an interview on 9th March, 2006 but by its order dated 10th April, 2006 the application of the petitioner was rejected on the ground that there was no post lying vacant against the reserve quota for compassionate appointment and also for the reason that there were other deserving cases found in more merciful conditions, than that of the petitioner.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioners stated that the grounds on which the application for compassionate appointment was rejected are totally wrong, incorrect, false and malafide. It was submitted that the respondent has not considered that the petitioners in both the cases are unemployed, having no source of income whatsoever except the meager pension of the deceased father, which is not sufficient for the whole family. While it is stated in the WP (C) No. 12609/2006, that the petitioner has a large family including his wife, three minor children and his mother, the petitioner in W.P(C) No. 12613/2006 has his wife, two children and his mother to support, which it was contended is not possible with a family pension of Rs. 3,500/- per month.
5. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent submitted that according to the directions and Rules issued by the Government of India, the direct recruitment on the basis of the compassionate grounds in the respondent board has been reserved at 5% and it was due to the large number of applications received for appointment on compassionate grounds that a Departmental Screening Committee had been constituted so that these matters could be decided fairly. For the purpose of making such appointments, an eligibility criteria had been evolved keeping in view the age of the employee at the time of the death, the number of his children and their ages, family property, amount of benefits given to the family and family pension etc., and it was only after considering the said factors, that the Screening Committee gave its recommendation. It was stated that the deceased employees in both cases had already served 2/3rd of the total periods of their employment and that the payments made to the family by way of family pension and other retrial dues was found sufficient. Further, it was stated that there was no post lying vacant against the reserved quota and therefore the applications of the petitioners were rightly rejected.
6. Counsel for the respondent also argued that once the department concerned comes to the conclusion that the financial position of the applicant does not warrant compassionate appointment, then the High Court should not undertake any exercise to decide what would be reasonable income which should be sufficient for the survival of the family and whether it had been left in penury or without any means of livelihood. Reliance in this regard was placed on the judgment rendered by the Supreme Court in the case of State Bank of India & Anr. v. Somvir Singh, JT 2007 (3) SC 398. Reliance was also placed on the judgment rendered by a Division Bench of this Court in the case of Savitri Devi & Anr. v. Union of India & Ors., 2005 (85) DRJ 175 (DB), to state that once the petitioners were receiving family pension and the deceased employees had already completed majority of their service tenure, it cannot be said that the family was not able to make both ends meet.
7. I have heard the counsels for the parties and have carefully perused the pleadings and other documents, including the records of the case of the petitioner produced by the respondent. I have also given my thoughtful consideration to the rival contentions of both the parties.
8. Before weighing the merits of the arguments advanced by the parties, it is appropriate to note certain basic parameters as laid down by the Apex Court, that are to be kept in mind while dealing with the cases of compassionate appointment. While considering the case of compassionate employment, it is to be kept in mind that it is not unduly unfair to the rights of those other persons who are eligible to seek appointment against a post which would have been available but for the provision enabling appointment being made on compassionate grounds to the dependents of the deceased employee. Reliance in this regard can be placed on the judgment rendered by the Supreme Court in the case of State Of Manipur v. Md. Rajaodin., (2003) 7 SCC 511. Appointment on compassionate ground cannot be claimed as a matter of right and such appointment cannot be made applicable to all types of posts irrespective of the nature of service rendered by the deceased employee. A claim for appointment on compassionate basis has been considered as reasonable and permissible keeping in view the sudden crisis occurring in the family of an employee who has served the state and died while in service. However the rules, regulations, administrative instructions and orders in this behalf must stand the test on the touchstone of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. Appointment on compassionate basis is hot another source of recruitment but. merely an exception to the aforesaid requirement taking into consideration the effect of the death of the employee while in service leaving his family without any means of livelihood. In such cases, the object is to enable the family to tide over the sudden financial crisis.
9. It is to be noted that compassionate appointments in the respondent board were governed by scheme, regulations and policy guidelines in this regard, according to which compassionate appointment could be made upto a maximum of 5% of vacancies falling under direct recruitment quota. Such appointments on compassionate ground have to be made only in accordance with the rules, regulations or administrative instructions and taking into consideration the family condition of the family of the deceased. Support is drawn from the following judgments:
(i) Umesh Kumar Nagpal v. State of Haryana, (1994) 4 SCC 138;
(ii) State of Haryana v. Rani Devi, (1996) 5 SCC 308; and
(iii) State of Haryana v. Ankur Gupta, (2003) 7 SCC 704.
10. It is to be noted that the Supreme Court in the case of Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd. v. A. Radhika Thirumalai (Smt), JT 1996 (9) SC 197, has held that the appointment on compassionate grounds can be made only if a vacancy is available for that purpose and the said judgment has been followed by a single judge of this court in the case of Jasbir Singh v. Director (INMAS) & Ors., 121 (2005) DLT 411
11. In the present case also, the applications of the petitioners were rejected primarily on the ground that there was no vacancy even in the reserved category for compassionate appointment and also on the ground that while in the case of petitioner in WP (C) No. 12613/2006, all his brothers were found to be major, married, were doing private work and could sustain themselves, in case of the petitioner in W.P (C) No. 12609/2006, it was noticed that the petitioner was a major, owned a house, had no other liability and had already received terminal dues worth Rs. 3.76 lakhs from the respondent and both the petitioners were also receiving family pensions. It is also revealed from the records that the request of the petitioners to be considered for appointment on compassionate grounds was considered twice, once in October 2003, and the second time in April 2006, in pursuance of the order of this Court, treating the petitioners as reserved category candidates. On such consideration, it was held by the respondent that the petitioners had no liability as such and had sufficient means to tide over the sudden financial crisis created on the demise of their father. It is now a settled law that retrial benefits and other sources of income have also to be taken into consideration while granting appointment on compassionate grounds. In view of absence of any vacancy and the fact that there were more deserving cases than those of the petitioners, the respondent rejected their claim. The aforesaid consideration and the grounds for rejection cannot be said to be arbitrary and irrelevant. The decision taken is in accordance with the provisions of the Scheme and the ratio of the decisions of the Supreme Court on the said issue. It is to be noted that the object of compassionate appointment is not to create a post that is hereditary in nature, and since such appointments are made as an exception to the regular mode of recruitment, they have to be made strictly in conformity with the rules laid down with regard to such appointment.
12. Reliance has been rightly placed by the counsel for the respondent on the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of State Bank of India (supra), wherein it was held as under:
13. In our considered opinion the High Court itself could not have undertaken any exercise to decide as to what would be the reasonable income which would be sufficient for the family for its survival and whether it had been left in penury or without any means of livelihood. The only question the High Court could have adverted itself is whether the decision making process rejecting the claim of the respondent for compassionate appointment is vitiated? Whether the order is not in conformity with the scheme framed by the appellant-Bank? It is not even urged that the order passed by the Competent Authority is not in accordance with the scheme. It is well settled that the hardship of the dependant does not entitle one to compassionate appointment de hors the scheme or the statutory provisions as the case may be. The income of the family from all sources is required to be taken into consideration according to scheme which the High Court altogether ignored while remitting the matter for fresh consideration by the appellant-Bank. It is not a case where the dependants of the deceased employee are left ‘without any means of livelihood’ and unable to make both ends meet. The High Court ought not to have disturbed the finding and the conclusion arrived at by the appellant-Bank that the respondent was not living hand to mouth. As observed by this Court in General Manager (D&PB) and Ors. v. Kunti Tiwary and Anr., 2004 (7) SCC 271 the High Court cannot dilute the criteria of ‘penury’ to one of “not very well-to-do”. The view taken by the Division Bench of the High Court may amount to varying the existing scheme framed by the appellant-Bank. Such a course is impermissible in law.
13. The following observations of the Supreme Court in the case of Union Bank of India & Ors. v. M.T Lateesh, 2006 (7) SCC 350 are also noteworthy:
36. In the present case, by declining the application submitted by the respondent after the proper consideration of the same in the light of the relevant parameters, the appellant-Bank cannot be said to have acted in an arbitrary manner regardless of the constitutional principles.
37. It is also settled law that the specially constituted authorities in the rules or regulations like the competent authority in this case are better equipped to decide the cases on facts of the case and their objective finding arrived on the appreciation of the full facts should not be disturbed. Learned Single Judge and the Division Bench by directing appointment has fettered the discretion of the appointing and selecting authorities. The Bank had considered the application of the respondent in terms of the statutory scheme framed by the Bank for such appointment. After that even though the Bank found the respondent ineligible for appointment to its service, the High Court has found him eligible and has ordered his appointment. This is against the law laid down by this Court. It is settled law that the principles regarding compassionate appointment that compassionate appointment being an exception to the general rule the appointment has to be exercised only in warranting situations and circumstances existing in granting appointment and guiding factors should be financial condition of the family. The respondent is not entitled to claim relief under the new Scheme because the financial status of the family is much above the Criterion fixed in the new scheme.
14. The mandate of the Supreme Court is very clear from the aforestated judgments that it is not for the High Court in exercise of its powers under Article 226 of the Constitution of India to interfere with the decision arrived at by the competent authority while considering the eligibility of an applicant for appointment on compassionate basis and all it can do is to see whether the decision of the competent authority is vitiated. Having scrutinized the eases in hand in the aforesaid background, this Court does not consider it appropriate to interfere with the findings of facts and the conclusion arrived at by the competent authority.
15. In the light of the above discussions, the writ petitions are dismissed being devoid of merits. There shall be no order as to costs.
Alert