Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Govt. Of Nct Of Delhi v. Ved Prakash Mehta

Delhi High Court
Sep 8, 2005
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Swatanter Kumar, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Govt. of NCT of Delhi through its competent officer invited tenders for the work described as "Increasing the capacity of NG Drain from Dhansa Regulator to Bharat Nagar Bridge, SW: Construction of Additional Regulator at Dhansa Bund." Respondent No. 1 submitted a tender which was accepted by the objector and Agreement No. EE/NDD.II/88/99.I was executed between the parties. Disputes arose in relation to the work and the contractor invoked the arbitration clause in 1994. The sole arbitrator (respondent no. 2) made and published an award dated 12 May 1999 (after commencement of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996). The objector filed objections to that award under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996; this opinion addresses those objections and the court's decision on them.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the arbitrator misconducted the arbitration proceedings by going beyond his jurisdiction and the terms of reference.
  2. Whether the award qualifies as a "speaking" or reasoned award as required by Clause 25 of the agreement and Section 31(3) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, given that the award exceeded Rs. 75,000 and the arbitrator did not give reasons for various claims.
  3. Whether Claim Nos. 8, 9 and 10 (which the objector contends were not originally referred) could properly have been considered and awarded by the arbitrator.
  4. Whether specific monetary awards (Rs. 4,50,000 and Rs. 1,50,000) were based on no evidence or on forged and fabricated documents.
  5. Whether the arbitrator was justified in awarding interest at the rate of 18% per annum.

Arguments of the Parties

Objector's Arguments

  • The arbitrator misconducted the proceedings by exceeding his jurisdiction and the terms of reference.
  • Clause 25 of the agreement requires a speaking award when the amount claimed exceeds Rs. 75,000; although the arbitrator allowed a claim of Rs. 12,51,450, he did not give reasons for awards against various claims of the contractor.
  • Claim Nos. 8, 9 and 10 were not originally referred to the arbitrator but were nonetheless considered and awarded.
  • Certain awarded amounts (Rs. 4,50,000 and Rs. 1,50,000) are either unsupported by evidence or based on forged/fabricated documents.
  • The award of interest at 18% per annum is unjustified, arbitrary and should be set aside.

Respondent / Contractor's Arguments

  • The contractor maintained that losses arose because the respondents failed to provide details and drawings despite repeated requests, resulting in machinery, manpower and material being rendered idle and causing heavy loss.
  • The contractor relied on precedent (A.T. Brij Paul Singh & Bros. v. State of Gujarat) to support the proposition that where the party entrusting the work commits breach, the contractor is entitled to damages for loss of profit.
  • Implicitly, the contractor relied on the record before the arbitrator and the arbitrator's discussion of letters and proceedings to support the awards made.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Thyssen Stahlunion Gmbh v. Steel Authority Of India Ltd., (1999) 9 SCC 334 The opinion refers to this Supreme Court judgment; no specific principle from the case is elaborated in the text of this opinion. Referenced by the court; the opinion does not elaborate a specific application beyond making reference to the judgment.
Fixopan Engineers (P) Ltd. v. UOI, CS (OS) No. 1048/1998 (Del HC), reported 2005 (Suppl.) Arb. LR 193 (Del.) Cited in the context of what constitutes a reasoned award and the sufficiency of the arbitrator's reasoning. Used by the court to support the conclusion that the arbitrator's award (about nine pages, with proceedings) qualifies as a reasoned award where contentions were considered and a nexus between pleaded facts and conclusions is apparent.
Arosan Enterprises Ltd. v. Union of India, (1999) 9 SCC 449 (AIR 1999 SC 3804) Holds that findings of fact recorded by the arbitrator based on appreciation of material on record would not be interfered with by the court; the scope of the old Act's s.30 was wider than the present Act's s.34. The court applied this principle to emphasize that the objector must show that objections fall within the specific grounds in Section 34; mere disagreement with the arbitrator's conclusions is insufficient for interference.
A.T. Brij Paul Singh and Bros. v. State of Gujarat, (1984) 4 SCC 59 (AIR 1984 SC 1703) Where the party entrusting the work commits breach of contract, the contractor is entitled to damages for loss of profit; such a claim is admissible though the measure and proof are separate issues. The court noted the contractor's reliance on this authority and observed that the arbitrator referred to relevant letters and proceedings when dealing with damages for loss of profit, supporting the admissibility of such claims.
Oil & Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. v. Saw Pipes Ltd., (2003) 5 SCC 705 Illustrates limits on interference with arbitral findings; relied upon by the objector to contend that findings lacked evidence, but the court observed that mere reference to the judgment is insufficient without pointing to record support. The court rejected the objector's reliance on this case because the objector failed to identify from the arbitrator's record which findings were contrary to law or unsupported by evidence; reinforced that the court does not act as an appellate fact-finding forum under s.34.
Executive Engineer, Irrigation, Galimala v. Abhaduta Jena, (1988) 1 SCC 418 (AIR 1988 SC 1520) Was relevant to debates about award of interest prior to enforcement of the 1996 Act (as described in the opinion). The court noted this authority as part of the historical context on interest but then relied on subsequent authority and statutory provisions to decide the matter under the 1996 Act.
T.P. George v. State of Kerala, JT 2001 (2) SC 438 Interpreted in the opinion together with Section 31(7)(a) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 to show that arbitral awards of interest are less open to challenge under the 1996 Act. The court relied on this judgment and s.31(7)(a) to hold that the arbitrator's award of interest at 18% per annum could hardly be questioned and that detailed discussion by the arbitrator of the reasons for the rate was not obligatory.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded through the following analytical steps, based directly on the opinion's text:

  1. Applicability of the 1996 Act: The court accepted that the provisions of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 apply to the proceedings and that the objections filed under Section 34 must be dealt with according to that Act's scheme.
  2. Nature of the objection grounds: The court summarized the objector's principal grounds of challenge (jurisdictional excess, lack of reasons despite Clause 25/Section 31(3), consideration of claims not originally referred, awards based on no/forged evidence, and the 18% interest award).
  3. Standard for a reasoned award: The court analyzed the arbitrator's award against Clause 25 and Section 31(3). It observed that the award spans nearly nine pages and is supported by detailed proceedings and discussions. The court stated that an arbitral forum is not required to produce a lengthy judgment, but must make clear that party contentions were considered and that there is a nexus between pleaded facts and the arbitrator's conclusions. The court found that the award met that standard, noting references in the award to letters and to daily proceedings as evidence of consideration.
  4. Deference to factual findings: Relying on Arosan Enterprises and similar principles, the court emphasized that findings of fact based on material on record are not ordinarily interfered with, and that the scope of challenge under Section 34 is limited. The objector must show that objections fall within the specific clauses of Section 34; mere disagreement with the arbitrator's conclusions is insufficient.
  5. Assessment of the specific factual complaints: The court examined the objector's own pleadings before the arbitrator and noted that the objector had admitted certain matters (e.g., some earthwork paid for and communications to "go slow") and that the contractor's statement of claim raised failure to provide drawings and resultant idling of resources. The court concluded that the arbitrator's factual findings in respect of work at the site and loss suffered were supported by the record and therefore not open to interference.
  6. On the issue of forged or fabricated documents and awards without evidence: The court found that the objector failed to demonstrate from the arbitrator's record which particular findings were contrary to law or unsupported by evidence. The court reiterated that it does not sit as an appellate forum to re-evaluate every finding of fact.
  7. Interest: The court considered prior authority (Galimala) but, having regard to T.P. George and Sections 31(7)(a) and (b) of the 1996 Act, held that awards of interest are scarcely challengeable under the Act and that it was not obligatory for the arbitrator to discuss in detail the reasons for awarding interest at 18% per annum. The court found the grant of interest at 18% to be justified in the circumstances.
  8. Conclusion from analysis: Because the objections essentially challenged factual findings and did not fall within the specific grounds of Section 34, and because the award was held to be a reasoned award with adequate consideration of contentions and record, the court found no merit in the petition challenging the award.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition challenging the arbitral award is dismissed.

Implications:

  • The arbitral award dated 12 May 1999 stands as upheld by the court on the grounds articulated in the opinion.
  • The court ordered that the parties shall bear their own costs.
  • The court emphasized the limited scope of judicial interference under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 — factual findings by an arbitrator based on record will not be routinely disturbed and an objector must show that one of the statutory grounds in Section 34 is satisfied.
  • The opinion does not announce the establishment of a new legal principle beyond its application of existing authorities and statutory provisions; its effect is to uphold the specific award and to confirm the application of the cited principles to these facts.
Show all summary ...

Swatanter Kumar, J.:— These are the objections filed by the objector under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’) to the award dated 12th May, 1999 made and published by the sole arbitrator-respondent no. 2 in furtherance to the reference of disputes made to him for adjudication.

2. The necessary facts are that the Govt. of NCT of Delhi through its competent officer had invited tenders for execution of the work of ‘Increasing the capacity of NG Drain from Dhansa Regulator to Bharat Nagar Bridge, SW: Construction of Additional Regulator at Dhansa Bund’. The respondent no. 1 has submitted his tenders which were accepted by the objector and Agreement No. EE/NDD.II/88/99.I was executed between the parties. Certain disputes arose between the parties in relation to the work and the contractor invoked the arbitration clause in the year 1994.

3. According to the objector, the disputes were false but still the matter was referred to the arbitrator according to the provisions of Arbitration Act, 1940. The arbitrator-respondent no. 2 made and published his award on 12.05.1999 after the commencement of the present Act and to the said award objections have been filed by the objector.

4. It is not in dispute between the parties that the provisions of the 1996 act would be applicable to the facts and circumstances of the present case and the objections filed by the objector under Section 34 of the Act are liable to be dealt with and disposed of by the court in terms of the provisions and scheme of the 1996 Act. The main grounds of objections are that—(1) The arbitrator has misconducted the arbitration proceedings by going beyond the jurisdiction and terms of reference. (2) As per the terms of agreement wherever the claim is allowed in excess of Rs. 75,000 the arbitrator is supposed to publish a speaking award and in the present case though the arbitrator has allowed a claim of Rs. 12,51,450 the arbitrator has not given reasons for giving award against various claims of the contractor. (3) Claim Nos. 8, 9 and 10 were not originally referred to arbitrator but still they have been taken into consideration and awarded in favour of the contractor. The claim of Rs. 4,50,000 and Rs. 1,50,000 awarded by the arbitrator to the contractor is either based on no evidence or is based upon the forged and fabricated documents and lastly that the arbitrator could not have granted 18% interest which is highly unjustified, arbitrary and liable to be set aside.

5. Parties in any case have considered that the matter in controversy has to be resolved under the provisions of the 1996 act. However, reference can be made to the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Thyssen Stahlunion Gmbh v. Steel Authority Of India Ltd., (1999) 9 SCC 334 : 1999 (3) Arb. LR 532 (SC).

6. It is again not disputed that in terms of the Clause 25 of the agreement between the parties the arbitrator shall give reasons where the amount claimed in disputes exceeds Rs. 75,000. This will be more so keeping in view the provisions of Section 31(3) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. I have perused the award subject to the discussion made hereinafter in this judgment, it cannot be said that the award of the arbitrator is not a reasoned award. It is an award running into nearly 9 pages supported by the detailed proceedings and discussion on arguments raised on behalf of the parties before the arbitrator. The arbitral forum is not required to write judgments by detailed discussion. What the arbitrator is required to do is to make it clear from the award and the proceedings annexed thereto that contentions of the parties in reference to the record were considered and there is a nexus of reasoning between the pleaded facts and the conclusion drawn by the arbitrator in favour or against the parties. It may be noticed that while passing the award the arbitrator has not only given some reasons followed by the discussion in the daily proceedings but have also referred to the extracts of the letter which according to the arbitrator were practical admission of the claim of the parties. Reference can be made to the judgment of this court in CS (OS) No. 1048/1998 titled as Fixopan Engineers (P) Ltd. v. UOI, decided on August 11, 2005 [reported as 2005 (Suppl.) Arb. LR 193 (Del.)].

7. Furthermore, reference can also be made to the judgment of the Supreme Court in Arosan Enterprises Ltd. v. Union of India, (2000) 9 SCC 449 : AIR 1999 SC 3804 : 1999 (3) Arb. LR 310 (SC), where the court clearly held that under section 30 of the old act the findings of the facts recorded by the arbitrator based on appreciation of material on record would not be interfered by the court in such proceedings. The scope of section 30 of the old act was apparently much wider than the scope of the objections under section 34 of the present act. The objector must essentially satisfy that the objections are relatable to and are covered under any of the clauses of Section 34 of the Act and a general talk of the content and conclusion of the award would not be satisfactory cause for interference by the court. The main thrust of the submissions on behalf of the objector was that the contractor had done no work at the site and as such he was not entitled to any damages for non-performance or on account of the material and machinery collected at the site. Furthermore, there was no evidence before the arbitrator to allow such claims. This argument is again without any merit. The arbitrator's finding in this regard would hardly call for any interference. In the statement of claim filed by the contractor before the arbitrator specific reference was made that in paragraphs 8-10 an issue was raised that the respondents have failed to provide details and drawings despite repeated requests by the claimants and the claimants' machinery, manpower and material were rendered ideal which subjected to heavy loss to the contractor. The drawings were not even supplied till the expiry of the date of contract. The reply filed by the respondents to the claim petition before the arbitrator have been denied but content thereof was hardly and properly questioned by the respondents before the arbitrator.

8. In the written arguments which were filed on behalf of the objector before the arbitrator under Claim 1(i) it was stated that at site only small quantity of earthwork was carried out and it was duly paid on 21st May, 1988 and thereafter no claim was raised by the contractor. In fact it is stated in the same written submission that the department has asked the contractor to go slow vide letter dated 20th January, 1988 but that has no relevancy to the claims in question. Thus, the denial that no work was carried out at the site by the contractor is demolished by the own pleadings of the objector before the arbitrator. The findings recorded by the arbitrator in this regard, thus, can hardly be questioned. The learned counsel appearing for the contractor has relied upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of A.T Brij Paul Singh and Bros. v. State of Gujarat, (1984) 4 SCC 59 : AIR 1984 SC 1703, where it was held that if the party entrusting the work commits breach of contract, the contractor will be entitled to claim damages for loss of profit which he expected to earn by undertaking the works contract. What must be the measure of profit and what proof should be tendered to sustain the claim are different matters but the claim under this head is certainly admissible. The arbitrator while dealing with the claim under these heads had referred to the letters of the respondents dated 29th April, 1988, 10th June, 1988 and 21st May, 1988 in regard to non-furnishing of drawings as well as wastage of manpower and material at site and the factum of the work being carried on at the site in question.

9. The learned counsel appearing for the objector while relying upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Oil & Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. v. Saw Pipes Ltd., (2003) 5 SCC 705 : 2003 (2) Arb. LR 5 (SC), contended that the findings are not based upon any evidence and in fact are contrary to law. Merely referring to the judgment would not suffice. The objectors have failed to administer before the court from the record of the arbitrator as to what claim is against law and is not based upon evidence. This court while entertaining objections against the award does not sit as a court of appeal which would interfere with every finding of fact or finding of the law. The provisions of section 34 of the Act are to be construed strictly and once the legislature in its wisdom has prescribed limitation for setting aside of arbitral award the objector must essentially show that he is covered by either of the grounds stated in those provisions.

10. The claims were referred to the arbitrator and every claim which has been granted by the arbitrator has been so asked for by the claimant in his statement of claim and was duly discussed by the arbitrator in the daily proceedings. The objections filed by the objector for all purposes and intent, challenges the finding of facts recorded by the arbitrator. The scope of challenge besides being limited is not covered in the case of the petitioner by any of the provisions of section 34 of the Act.

11. Lastly coming to the claim of interest granted by the arbitrator there is no substance in the submission made on behalf of the objector. Prior to the date of enforcement of this Act the question of interest could be debated in view of the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Executive Engineer, Irrigation, Galimala v. Abhaduta Jena, (1988) 1 SCC 418 : AIR 1988 SC 1520 : 1988 (2) Arb. LR 356 (SC). However, in view of the recent judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of T.P George v. State of Kerala, JT 2001 (2) SC 438 : 2001 (1) Arb. LR 490 (SC), and the provisions of Section 31(7)(a), award of interest can hardly be questioned. The grant of interest @ 18% per annum is justified in the facts and circumstances of the present case. In the face of the provisions of Sections 31(7)(a) and (b) of the Act it was not obligatory upon the arbitrator to discuss in detail the reasons for awarding interest 18% per annum. That is the expected rate of interest which a party would be entitled to unless the arbitrator otherwise directs. Thus even this objection of the objector is without any merit.

12. For the reasons aforestated, I find no merit in this petition, the same is dismissed while leaving the parties to bear their own costs.