Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. M.Mansoor

Madras High Court
Apr 30, 2010
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion delivered by M. Venugopal, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from an Award dated 28.04.2004 in M.C.O.P. No. 4973 of 2001 passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (II Small Causes Court, Chennai). The Appellant in this appeal is the Insurance Company (which was the Second Respondent before the Tribunal). The Tribunal had awarded a total compensation of Rs. 24,65,668/- with interest at 9% per annum from 07.08.2000 to 28.04.2004 in favour of the Respondents/Claimants (parents of the deceased) and directed the insurer to deposit the award within two months.

The appeal challenges the Tribunal's findings and the quantum of compensation in respect of the death of Amjath Khan Arabu, who died in a road accident on 22.07.2000 when a container lorry allegedly dashed into a Government bus. The Tribunal had recorded oral and documentary evidence including eyewitnesses (P.Ws.2, 3 and 4), Ex.P3 (First Information Report), Ex.P5 (Charge Sheet in Cr.No.630/00 under Sections 279, 337, 338 and 304A IPC), and Ex.P8 (salary certificate).

A common award had been passed by the Tribunal in several M.C.O.P.s (including Nos. 4973/2001, 4561/2000 and 4554/2000), but this Civil Miscellaneous Appeal concerns M.C.O.P. No. 4973/2001. Evidence in that common trial included witnesses P.Ws.1 to 5 and exhibits Exs.P1 to P27.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Tribunal erred in fastening negligence on the driver of the offending container lorry (i.e., the correctness of the Tribunal's finding of negligence).
  2. Whether the Tribunal was justified in accepting Ex.P8 (and Ex.A7 as relied upon) to fix the deceased's monthly salary at Rs. 18,100/- and in the Tribunal's approach to proof of salary.
  3. Whether the Tribunal erred in the approach to computation of pecuniary loss, specifically (a) the adoption of the salary figure; (b) allowance for future prospects; (c) deduction for personal expenses; and (d) adoption of the multiplier (including whether multiplier 18 or another multiplier should apply).
  4. Whether the total compensation awarded (Rs.24,65,668/-) was excessive and required revision.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Second Respondent / Insurance Company)

  • The Tribunal erred in fastening negligence on the driver of the Third Respondent / First Respondent and was wrong in its reliance on Ex.A7 (Letter of Appointment of the deceased's son), which the insurer contended was a fabricated document.
  • There was no corroborative documentary or oral evidence to substantiate Ex.A7 (the Letter of Appointment).
  • P.W.1 had allegedly admitted that the salary was increased only from June 2000, and the Tribunal did not appreciate that point adequately.
  • No documents were filed before the Tribunal to show any income tax deduction from the deceased's salary.
  • The Tribunal was not correct in assuming the deceased's monthly earning to be Rs.18,100/- in the absence of material to prove that salary.
  • The Tribunal erred in adopting multiplier 18 (or gave an unduly high multiplier), especially when the deceased was unmarried (a bachelor), and therefore the Award under "Loss of Pecuniary Benefits" was excessive and arbitrary.

Respondents / Claimants (Parents of the Deceased)

  • The Award of Rs.24,65,668/- with interest at 9% p.a. granted by the Tribunal was contended to be a fair and reasonable sum, taking into account the relevant aspects considered by the Tribunal.
  • Their counsel relied on authorities (including U.P. State Road Transport Corporation v. Trilok Chandra and an earlier Madras High Court decision) to support the multiplier approach and the court's discretion in adopting an appropriate multiplier.
  • For the grant of compensation for future prospects, the respondents relied on several Supreme Court decisions cited in the opinion (see the Table of Precedents below).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
U.P. State Road Transport Corporation v. Trilok Chandra, 1996 (4) SCC (LB) 362 Observed that courts can adopt a maximum multiplier up to 18 years. Cited by the Respondents to support use of higher multipliers; the Court noted the authority but did not apply a multiplier of 18 here, choosing a lower multiplier based on the specific facts (parents' ages).
Gnanam Santhanam & Others v. M/s Sathyalakshmi Enterprises & Others, 2004 (4) L.W. 23 (Madras DB) Holds that under relevant circumstances a court can deviate from the multiplier as shown in the Second Schedule. Cited by the Respondents; the Court recognized the principle and exercised discretion in adopting a multiplier (12) appropriate to the facts of this case.
Sarala Varma & Others v. DTC & Another, 2009 (2) TNMAC 1 SC Authority on grant of compensation for future prospects. Cited by the Respondents in support of awarding future prospects; the Court considered authorities on future prospects when reassessing compensation and awarded a specific sum for future prospects.
General Manager, Kerala SRTC v. Susamma Thomas, 1994 (2) SCC 176 Authority relevant to future prospects and computation of compensation. Relied upon by Respondents; the Court treated these authorities collectively in its approach to future prospects and adjusted the monthly figures accordingly.
National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Indhira Srivastava, 2008 (1) TNMAC 166 SCC Authority relating to future prospects in compensation awards. Cited by Respondents; Court took note of the line of authorities on future prospects in framing its revised computation.
National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Saroj & Others, 2009 (1) TNMAC 619 SC Authority on future prospects and related compensation principles. Quoted by Respondents; the Court considered such authorities when estimating and awarding sums for future prospects.
Raj Rani & Others v. Oriental Ins. Co. & Others, 2009 (1) TNMAC 638 SC Statement that it is the duty of the Court to award just compensation irrespective of whether any plea in that behalf was raised or not. Cited by Respondents; the Court acknowledged the principle and applied it in awarding an equitable compensation package despite issues in documentary proof.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in two main strands of analysis: (A) liability (negligence) and (B) quantum of compensation.

(A) Liability — Negligence

The Court examined eyewitness evidence (P.Ws.2, 3 and 4) together with documentary evidence — Ex.P3 (First Information Report) and Ex.P5 (Charge Sheet in Cr.No.630/00 framed against the container lorry driver under Sections 279, 337, 338 and 304A IPC). On the basis of these materials the Tribunal had concluded that the container lorry driver (Regn. No. TN-01-C-6248) drove the vehicle at fast speed, rashly and negligently and caused the accident. The Court expressly stated that it was in complete agreement with the Tribunal's view on this point and upheld the finding of negligence and responsibility of the offending vehicle/driver for the happening of the accident.

(B) Quantum — Reassessment of Pecuniary Loss

The Court carefully reviewed the Tribunal's computation and the evidentiary material regarding the deceased's employment and salary:

  • The Tribunal had accepted Ex.P8 (Salary Certificate dated 08.08.2000) showing gross/total monthly salary as Rs. 18,100/- and, after deducting one-third for personal expenses (Rs.6,033/-), treated Rs.12,067/- as monthly loss of income and adopted multiplier 17 to arrive at pecuniary loss of Rs.24,61,668/- (Rs.12,067 x 12 x 17).
  • The Appellant argued that Ex.A7 (letter of appointment) was fabricated and that there was no corroborative evidence from the employer; the Court noted that while Ex.P8 was on record, no witness from the deceased's employer was examined in court to corroborate the document.
  • The Court accepted that the deceased was an M.B.A. graduate aged 24 (age fixed on the basis of Ex.P1 Post Mortem Certificate dated 23.07.2000) and that future prospects should be taken into account. However, because of the evidentiary gap (no employer witness), the Court exercised its discretion in determining an equitable monthly figure rather than mechanically adopting Rs.18,100/-.
  • The Court determined monthly Loss of Income at Rs.10,600/- and separately estimated Future Prospects at Rs.4,500/- per month, combining to Rs.15,100/- per month as an equitable figure for monthly pecuniary loss.
  • From Rs.15,100/-, the Court deducted one-third (Rs.5,033/-) for the deceased's personal expenses, leaving Rs.10,067/- per month as the monthly loss of income to be used for computation.
  • Annual loss was computed as Rs.1,20,804/- (Rs.10,067 x 12).
  • Considering the ages of the claimants (father 51 years; mother about 46 years at the time of death), the Court adopted a multiplier of 12. Applying the multiplier yielded Rs.14,49,648/- as total pecuniary loss (Rs.1,20,804 x 12).
  • The Court awarded additional heads: Loss of Love and Affection Rs.50,000/-, Funeral Expenses Rs.5,000/-, Loss of Estate Rs.10,000/-, producing a total award by this Court of Rs.15,14,648/- (Rupees fifteen lakhs fourteen thousand six hundred and forty eight only).
  • The Court ordered interest at 9% p.a. from the date of the accident till date of payment; costs (pro costs) were to be paid by the Appellant/Insurance Company. The Respondents were to receive the award in equal shares.

The Court explicitly found that the Tribunal's award of Rs.24,65,668/- was "indeed an exorbitant one" and therefore revised the quantum downward to Rs.15,14,648/- after making the above adjustments and applying judicial discretion in the absence of employer testimony.

Holding and Implications

Holding (core ruling): The Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is allowed in part.

Implications and consequential orders (direct effects on the parties):

  • The Court reduced the compensation payable to the Respondents/Claimants from Rs.24,65,668/- to Rs.15,14,648/-, and directed interest at 9% p.a. from the date of the accident till payment.
  • The Respondents/Claimants are entitled to withdraw their respective shares of the awarded compensation (less any amount already withdrawn) by filing the necessary payment-out application before the trial court.
  • The Appellant/Insurance Company is entitled to receive any excess amount lying to the credit of M.C.O.P. No.4973 of 2001 (if any) by filing a payment-out application before the Tribunal; the Tribunal is directed to pass appropriate orders thereon on merits.
  • The parties were left to bear their own costs in the appeal; the connected miscellaneous petition was closed.
  • The Court fixed the lawyer's fee at Rs.22,146/-.
  • Earlier procedural note preserved in the opinion: this Court, in C.M.P. No. 3579 of 2005 (dated 09.03.2005), had passed an order of stay on condition that the Petitioner/Appellant deposits the balance compensation amount including interest and costs to the credit of M.C.O.P. No. 4973 of 2001 within eight weeks from the date of the order.

No new legal precedent was announced by this judgment; the Court relied on established authorities concerning multipliers and future prospects and exercised its fact-driven discretion to revise the quantum of compensation in the particular circumstances of this case.

Show all summary ...

M.VENUGOPAL,J.

The Appellant/Second Respondent/Insurance Company has preferred this Civil Miscellaneous Appeal as against the Award dated 28.04.2004 in M.C.O.P.No.4973 of 2001 passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal viz., II Small Causes Court, Chennai.

2. On an appreciation of oral and documentary evidence available on record, the Claims Tribunal in the original Claim Petition had passed an Award on 28.04.2004 awarding a total compensation of Rs.24,65,668/- together with interest at 9% per annum from 07.08.2000 to 28.04.2004 with costs to the Respondents/Claimants 1 and 2 and directed the Appellant/Insurance Company to deposit the same within two months from the date of passing of the order.

3. Dissatisfied with the Award passed by the Tribunal, the Appellant/Insurance Company (Second Respondent) has preferred this Civil Miscellaneous Appeal before this Court.

4. Before the Tribunal, a common Award was passed in M.C.O.P.Nos.4973/2001, 4561/2000 and 4554/2000. However, in the present Civil Miscellaneous Appeal before this Court, we concerned with M.C.O.P.No.4973/2001. A common evidence was taken and witnesses P.Ws.1 to 5 were examined and Exs.P1 to P27 were marked in the aforesaid M.C.O.P. case.

5. According to the Learned counsel for the Appellant/Insurance Company, the Tribunal had erred in fastening the negligence on the driver of the Third Respondent/First Respondent and in fact, the Tribunal was wrong in placing reliance on Ex.A7 Letter of appointment of the deceased son S.M.Amjath Khan Arabu. It is the further contention on the side of the Appellant/Insurance Company that Ex.A7 Appointment Letter as Executive Consultant in respect of the deceased son S.M.Amjath Khan Arabu was a fabricated document and there was no material either documentary or oral evidence to corroborate Ex.A7 Letter of Appointment. Also, a plea is put forward on the side of the Appellant/Insurance Company that P.W.1 in his evidence had admitted that the salary was increased only from the year June 2000 and this aspect of the matter was not appreciated by the claims Tribunal in a real perspective.

6. Moreover, it is the contention of the Appellant/Insurance Company that no documents were filed before the Tribunal to establish that any income tax was deducted from out of the salary of the deceased.

7. At this stage, the Learned counsel for the Appellant/Insurance Company submits that the Tribunal was not correct in assuming that the deceased Amjath Khan Arabu was earning a sum of Rs.18,100/- per month in the absence of any material to prove the salary of the deceased.

8. That apart, the Tribunal was wrong in adopting multiplier 18 especially, when the deceased was a Bachelor at the time of his death and in short, the Award of Rs.24,65,668/- under the caption 'Loss of Pecuniary Benefits' was an excessive and arbitrary one.

9. The Claims Tribunal after considering the evidence of eyewitnesses P.Ws.2, 3 and 4 coupled with Ex.P3 First Information Report and Ex.P5 Charge Sheet in and by which in Cr.No.630/00 a case was registered under Section 279, 337, 338 and 304 A of I.P.C. Against the container lorry driver, came to the resultant conclusion that the offending container lorry driver bearing Registration No. TN-01-C-6248 drove the vehicle in a fast speed, rashly and negligently and caused the accident and therefore, he was absolutely responsible for the happening of the occurrence and in this regard, we are in complete agreement with the view taken by the Tribunal.

10. In regard to the quantum of compensation to be awarded, the Respondents/Claimants being the parents of the deceased Amjath Khan Arabu in their Claim Petition had claimed a total compensation of Rs.28,00,000 /- and the break up figures of the same is as follows:-

i) Loss of Pecuniary Benefits - Rs. 27,95,000.00
ii) Loss of Estate - Rs. 2,500.00
iii) Funeral Expenses - Rs. 2,500.00
----------------------
" 11. It is the evidence of P.W.1/First Claimant (Father of the deceased) that his son Amjath Khan Arabu died in an accident at the age of 24 years and on 22.07.2000, his son was travelling along with his friend in the Government bus from Chennai to Chidambaram near Lotpettai and at Maduranthagam near Silavattam Village, a container lorry dashed against the bus, as a result of which, the accident took place. As per the information received by him, when he came to Mathuranthagam hospital, he saw his son dead and his deceased son was an M.B.A. Graduate and he was working in INTEL Comex Management India (P) Ltd. as Business Manager on a monthly salary of Rs.18,100/-."

12. The evidence of P.W.2 is to the effect that on 22.07.2000 at about 05.30 p.m., he was travelling in the State Transport bus and after Maduranthagam near Silavattam, the container lorry came from the opposite direction of the bus and dashed against the bus as a result of which, the passenger who was travelling next to him died on the spot and also, 5 more persons died at the spot itself and that the driver of the container lorry bearing Registration No.TN-01-C-6248 was responsible for the happening of occurrence.

13. P.W.2 has also deposed that the deceased was sitting on the side of the window while travelling in the bus and that he was seated in the back 8 seats away from the driver seat and the Registration Number of the bus was TN-01-M 6587.

14. The Tribunal by placing reliance on Ex.P8 Salary Certificate dated 08.08.2000 issued by the employer of the deceased Amjath Khan Arabu had determined the salary of the deceased Amjath Khan Arabu (who was worked as Business Manager since June 1999 in their organisation) as Rs.18,100/- p.m. In the Claim Petition, the Respondents/Claimants had mentioned the age of the deceased Amjath Khan Arabu as 24 years. The deceased was a Bachelor at the time of his death. In Ex.P1 Post Mortem Certificate of the deceased son Amjath Khan Arabu, his age was mentioned as 24 years. In the absence of any document other than Ex.P1 Post Mortem Certificate, by placing reliance on Ex.P1 Post Mortem Certificate dated 23.07.2000, this Court fixes the age of the deceased as 24 at the time of his death, arising out of the accident that took place on 22.07.2000.

15. The Tribunal by determining the salary of the deceased Amjath Khan Arabu as Rs.18,100/- p.m. had deducted one third sum of Rs.6,033/- towards the deceased personal expenses and the balance works out to Rs.12,067/- which was taken as Loss of Income per month. Considering the age of the deceased at the time of his death as 24, the Tribunal adopted a multiplier of 17 and towards pecuniary loss/Loss of Income, had arrived at a figure of Rs.24,61,668/- (Rs.12,067X 12X17). Towards Loss of Estate, it has awarded a sum of Rs.2,000/-. For Funeral Expenses, it granted a sum of Rs.2,000/-. Thus in all, the Tribunal had awarded a sum of Rs.24,65,668/- as total compensation to the Respondents/Claimants for the death of the deceased Amjath Khan Arabu together with interest at 9% p.a. from the date of filing of the petition till date of payment, etc., . The break up figure of the sum of Rs.24,65,668/- is mentioned hereunder:-

16. The Learned counsel appearing for the Respondents/Claimants contends that the Award of Rs.24,65,668/- with interest at 9% p.a. from the date of filing of the claim petition, etc., granted by the Tribunal is a fair and reasonable sum and in fact, the Tribunal had taken note of the relevant aspects into consideration while determining the compensation payable by the Appellant/second respondent/Insurance Company and the same need not be interfered by this Court at this stage of the Appeal.

17. The Learned counsel appearing for the Respondents/ Claimants 1 and 2 cites the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court U.P. STATE ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION V. TRILOK CHANDRA, 1996 (4) SCC (LB) 362, wherein it is observed that 'Courts can adopt a maximum multiplier upto 18 years'. He also relies on the decision of this Court GNANAM SANTHANAM AND OTHERS V M/S.SATHYALAKSHMI ENTERPRISES AND OTHERS, 2004 (4) L.W.23 MADRAS (DB), wherein it is held that 'under relevant circumstances court can deviate from the multiplier as shown in the 2nd Schedule.'

18. In regard to the grant of compensation for Future Prospects, the Learned counsel for the Respondents/Claimants relied on the following decisions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court:

(a) SARALA VARMA & OTHERS VS DTC & ANOTHER, 2009(2) TNMAC 1 SC.

(b) GENERAL MANAGER, KERALA SRTC VS SUSAMMA THOMAS, 1994 (2) SCC 176.

(c) NATIONAL INS.CO.LTD. VS INDHIRA SRIVASTAVA & OTHERS, 2008 (1) TNMAC 166 SCC.

(d) NATIONAL INS. CO.LTD. VS SAROJ & OTHERS, 2009 (1) TNMAC 619 SC.

19. Yet another decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court is cited on the side of the Respondents/Claimants RAJ RANI & OTHERS VS ORIENTAL INS. CO. & OTHERS., 2009 (1) TNMAC 638 SC wherein it is held that 'it is the duty of the Court to award just compensation irrespective of the fact that whether any plea in that behalf was raised or not.'

20. In the instant case on hand, even though on the side of the Respondents/Claimants, Ex.P8 Salary Certificate dated 08.08.2000 issued by the employer in respect of the deceased Amjath Khan Arabu was marked as an exhibit to show that the deceased Net Salary was Rs.18,100 p.m., it is to be pointed out that no one witness from the office where the deceased worked was examined as witness. As a matter of fact, in Ex.P8 Salary Certificate, the break up figure of the deceased Amjath Khan Arabu salary was mentioned hereunder:

Basic Salary : Rs.8,000 D.A (20%) : Rs.1,600 Commission : Rs.6,000 Conveyance : Rs.1,500 HRA : Rs.1,000

--------------

Total Rs.18,100/-

---------------

21. Since the deceased Amjath Khan Arabu was an M.B.A. Graduate and since he was aged 24 years at the time of his death and notwithstanding the fact that no witness was examined from the organisation where the deceased served as Business Manager, we deem it appropriate to take into account of the future prospects of the deceased also and accordingly, determines the monthly Loss of Income of the deceased Amjath Khan Arabu at Rs.10,600/- per month and towards Future Prospects, we estimate the loss at Rs.4,500/- p.m. and accordingly in all, we determine the Loss of monthly Income/Pecuniary Loss in respect of the deceased at Rs.15,100/- p.m. as an Equitable one and fair sum. From and out of the sum of Rs.15,100/-, we deduct one third sum of Rs.5,033/- towards personal expenses of the deceased and the balance works out to Rs.10,067/- and this sum, we aptly take into account as Loss of Income/Pecuniary Loss per month in respect of the death of the deceased son of the Respondents/Claimants. Per year, it comes to Rs.1,20,804/- (Rs.10,067X12). Since the First Respondent/First Claimant's (father) age was 51 and the Second Respondent/Second Claimant's (Mother) aged about 46 at the time of the death of the deceased son, we deem it fit and proper to adopt a just fair and reasonable multiplier of 12 and accordingly, the Loss of Income works out to Rs.14,49,648/- (Rs.1,20,804X12). Towards loss of Love and Affection, we award a sum of Rs.50,000/- to the Respondents/Claimants. Towards Funeral Expenses, we award a sum of Rs.5,000/-. Towards Loss of Estate, we grant a sum of Rs.10,000/-. Thus, we award a total compensation of Rs.15,14,648/- (Rupees fifteen lakhs fourteen thousand six hundred and forty eight only) with interest at 9% p.a. from the date of accident till date of payment with pro costs payable by the Appellant/Second Respondent Insurance Company (being the insurer of the offending container lorry bearing Registration No. TN-01-C-6248) the Respondents/Claimants as compensation for the death of their son in a road accident that took place on 22.07.2000. The Respondents 1 and 2 are entitled to receive the compensation amount awarded by this Court in equal proportions and the break up figures of the same is mentioned hereunder:

22. Per contra, the Award of the Tribunal in granting a sum of Rs.24,65,668/- to the respondents/Claimants was indeed and exorbitant one, in our considered view.

23. Earlier, this Court in C.M.P.No.3579 of 2005 on 09.03.2005 had passed an order of stay on condition that the Petitioner/Appellant deposits the balance compensation of amount including interest and costs to the credit of M.C.O.P.No.4973 of 2001 on the file of II Judge, Court of Small Causes (MACT) Chennai within a period of eight weeks from the date of the order, etc.,

24. In the result, the Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is allowed in part, leaving the parties to bear their own costs. The connected miscellaneous petition is closed.

25. The Respondents/Claimants are permitted to withdraw their respective shares amount of compensation (less the amount already withdrawn if any) by filing necessary payment out application before the trial court in the manner known to law. Likewise, the Appellant/Insurance Company is entitled to receive the excess amount if any lying to the credit of M.C.O.P.No.4973 of 2001 by filing necessary payment out application before the Tribunal in the manner known to law and the Tribunal is directed to pass appropriate orders thereto on merits. The Lawyer's fee is fixed at Rs.22,146/-.