- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mayil Vahanan v. Intelligence Officer, Narcotic Control Bureau
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, R. Mayilvahanan (arraigned as the 8th accused), moved to quash the criminal proceedings in C.C.No.102 of 2003 pending before the Principal Special Judge for NDPS Act Cases, Chennai. The petitioner was charged under Section 8(c) read with Section 29 of the NDPS Act, 1985.
On 22.9.2002, the respondent Intelligence Officer attached to the Narcotic Control Bureau is said to have recovered 15.350 kgs of heroin from the possession of accused A.2 to A.6. The first accused (Mohamed Saheed Md. Ismath) and the second accused (S. Kugadas @ Das) allegedly made confession statements under Section 67 of the NDPS Act implicating the petitioner, who at that time was lodged in Central Prison, Bangalore in connection with another NDPS case.
The respondent-Intelligence Officer obtained permission from the Special Court for NDPS Cases, Bangalore to interview the petitioner in Central Prison; the prosecution states the petitioner did not furnish information during that interview. The Intelligence Officer requested the Chennai trial court to bring the petitioner from Bangalore to face trial.
The trial court in Chennai chose to split the trial in respect of the petitioner; it proceeded with the trial of the other accused and by judgment dated 30.8.2004 acquitted all other accused. The Intelligence Officer appealed that acquittal in C.A. No.1149 of 2004 and this Court issued warrants of arrest against the other accused under Section 391 Cr.P.C.
The petition alleges that, apart from references in the confession statements of A.1 and A.5, there is no material on record to incriminate the petitioner and that charges have not been framed against him. The petitioner had, during the split-up trial, escaped from Central Prison, Bangalore and absconded, but was thereafter apprehended and remanded to custody.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the criminal proceedings in C.C.No.102 of 2003, insofar as they relate to the petitioner (8th accused), should be quashed.
- Whether the confession statements of co-accused (A.1 and A.5) can be relied upon under Section 30 of the Indian Evidence Act to incriminate the petitioner where the trial has been split and the co-accused have already been tried (and some acquitted).
- Whether the prosecution can project further evidence (including examining an acquitted co-accused) to furnish a basis for framing charges against the petitioner when charges have not yet been framed.
- Whether the presumptions under Section 35 of the NDPS Act can be applied in the absence of any material on record implicating the petitioner apart from co-accused confessions.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The prosecution's case against the petitioner rests solely on alleged confession statements made by the first accused (A.1) and the fifth accused (A.5), and there is no other material on record to implicate the petitioner.
- After the trial was split and the other accused were tried and acquitted, the petitioner cannot be chargesheeted on the basis of those confession statements under Section 30 of the Evidence Act.
- There has been a failure by the trial court to take concrete steps to secure the petitioner's presence from Central Prison, Bangalore for trial despite availability and notice.
Respondent's (Prosecution's) Arguments
- The split of the trial was not due to any fault of the prosecution, and the petitioner cannot claim immunity under Section 30 of the Evidence Act merely because the trial was split.
- The prosecution intends to examine the fifth accused (A.5) from the split-up case as a witness against the petitioner; there is no bar to examining an accused whose confession implicates another accused if that accused has already been tried (the prosecution treats such examination as permissible).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Suresh Budharmal Kalani Alias Pappu Kalani v. State of Maharashtra, 1998 SCC (Cri) 1625 | Holds that the confession of an accused who has been discharged is not admissible as against a co-accused; the trial court is not justified in taking into consideration such confession for framing charges against co-accused. | The court applied this authority to reject the prosecution's contention that it could rely on the confession of an acquitted/discharged co-accused (A.5) to frame charges or to examine that co-accused to establish guilt of the petitioner; the ratio was treated as squarely applicable and decisive. |
| D. Sathiyamoorthy v. State Rep., By Inspector of Police, Spe/CBI, Madras, 1998 (1) MWN (Cr.) 234 | Permits the High Court to entertain an application under Section 311 Cr.P.C. to summon a convicted co-accused as an additional witness where the prosecution is entitled to present the best evidence available. | The court distinguished this precedent on facts: it noted that the cited authority involved summoning a convicted co-accused (not an acquitted/discharged co-accused) and therefore did not justify using the confession of an acquitted/discharged co-accused as evidence to frame charges against the petitioner in the present situation. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded through the following analytic steps, grounded in statutory provision and precedents cited in the opinion:
- The court reviewed Section 30 of the Indian Evidence Act, which on its face requires that more than one person be tried jointly for the same offence before a confession by one affecting others can be taken into consideration as against those others. The court treated joint trial as a prerequisite for invoking Section 30.
- Applying the authority in Suresh Budharmal Kalani (1998 SCC (Cri) 1625), the court held that the confession of an accused who has been discharged or acquitted is not admissible as against a co-accused and the trial court is not justified in relying on such a confession to frame charges against a co-accused.
- The court rejected the prosecution's argument that splitting-up the trial should allow it to examine an already acquitted co-accused (A.5) to establish the petitioner's guilt. The Suresh Kalani ratio was applied to hold that examining an acquitted/discharged co-accused to use his confession against a co-accused would not be permissible in the present circumstances.
- The court distinguished D. Sathiyamoorthy, a case in which the court permitted the summons of a convicted co-accused under Section 311 Cr.P.C. to act as an additional witness. The court emphasized that the facts there involved a convicted co-accused (not an acquitted/discharged one) and therefore the principle did not support the prosecution's present attempt.
- The court noted that charges had not been framed against the petitioner and that when considering whether charges should be framed the court must confine itself to materials collected during investigation which can legally be translated into evidence. The court stressed that the prosecution cannot project further evidence at the charge-framing stage that would only be adduced after charges are framed and contested.
- On the factual record, aside from references in the confessions of A.1 and A.5, there was no material prima facie to implicate the petitioner. The mobile phone allegedly used by the petitioner was not recovered despite attempts, and the petitioner had not cooperated with recovery efforts.
- The court observed that the presumption under Section 35 of the NDPS Act applies only where there is some material to rope in the accused; absent such material, it would be impermissible and dangerous to presume culpable mental state. Thus, without any evidence apart from co-accused confessions (found not to be legal evidence in this context), charges could not be framed.
- Having accepted the submission of the petitioner's senior counsel that there was no viable material to support framing a charge, the court concluded that the split-up proceedings against the petitioner could not be allowed to continue.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The split-up case in C.C.No.102 of 2003 as against the petitioner (8th accused) is quashed and the criminal original petition is allowed.
Implications:
- Direct effect: The prosecution cannot proceed further in the split-up trial against the petitioner in C.C.No.102 of 2003 on the present record; no charge was framed and, given the absence of any material except co-accused confessions (which are not usable in the present circumstances), the proceedings as to the petitioner are quashed.
- On admissibility: The court applied settled authority to hold that confession statements of co-accused who have been discharged or acquitted cannot be used as legal evidence against a co-accused in circumstances where a joint trial prerequisite is not satisfied or where the co-accused's confession cannot be legally translated into evidence at the charge-framing stage.
- Broader precedent: The opinion applies and follows existing precedent (as discussed) and does not purport to lay down a new legal principle beyond the application and distinction of those precedents.
This summary is strictly confined to the material and findings contained in the provided opinion. No information beyond the text of the opinion has been added, and where the opinion did not address broader issues, those sections are limited to the direct effects stated therein.
1. The petition is filed seeking quashment of the criminal proceedings in C.C.No.102 of 2003 on the file of the learned Principal Special Judge for NDPS Act Cases, Chennai.
2. The petitioner, who has been arraigned as 8th accused, is charged for the offence under Section 8(c) r/w Section 29 of the NDPS Act, 1985. On receipt of vital information, the respondent Intelligence Officer attached to Narcotic Control Bureau allegedly recovered 15.350 kgs of Heroin on 22.9.2002 from the possession of A.2 to A.6 in this case.
3. The first accused Mohamed Saheed Md. Ismath and the second accused S. Kugadas @ Das, have allegedly given confession statements under section 67 of the ndps act, implicating the petitioner R. Mayilvahanan, who has been lodged in Central Prison, Bangalore in connection with another case under the NDPS Act in the State of Karnataka.
4. The respondent-Intelligence Officer, duly approached the Special Court for NDPS Act Cases, Bangalore, seeking permission for interviewing the petitioner herein in the Central Prison, Bangalore. It is the contention of the prosecution that the said Mayilvahanan, the petitioner herein, failed to furnish any information in the interview undertaken by the respondent-Intelligence Officer as per the orders of the High Court of Karnataka.
5. The respondent-Intelligence Officer pleaded with the learned Principal Special Judge for NDPS Act Cases, Chennai, to take steps to bring the petitioner herein from Central Prison, Bangalore to face the trial in C.C.No.102 of 2003.
6. The trial Judge had chosen to split up the case against the petitioner and has conducted the trial and acquitted all the other accused by judgment dated 30.8.2004. Now the fact remains that the complainant-Intelligence Officer has preferred an appeal in C.A. No. 1149 of 2004 against the order of acquittal before this Court and this Court was pleased to issue warrant of arrest as against the other accused for the offence under Section 391 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
7. The petitioner inter alia has contended that the whole case of the prosecution as regards the petitioner herein rests only on the alleged confession statement given by the first accused Mohamed Saheed Md. Ismath and the fifth accused Karan Singh. When the other accused had already faced the trial after splitting up of the case and received a verdict of acquittal, the petitioner cannot be chargesheeted based on the alleged confession statements of A.1 and A.5 under Section 30 of the Evidence Act.
8. The learned Special Public Prosecutor appearing for the respondent would submit that just because the trial was split up for no fault of the respondent as against the petitioner herein, the petitioner cannot claim immunity under Section 30 of the Evidence Act, inasmuch as the prosecution is toying with the proposal of examining the fifth accused in the split up case as against the petitioner. It is his further submission that there is no bar for the prosecution to examine one of the accused in this case as regards his confession statement implicating one of the accused, as the accused who gave confession statement has already been acquitted in this case.
9. The mobile phone which was allegedly used by the petitioner herein from Central Prison, Bangalore at the time of commission of the henious crime was not recovered in this case based on the alleged confession statements of the first and the fifth accused. Of course, the respondent-Intelligence Officer had taken some steps to examine the accused for the purpose of recovering the cellphone alleged to have been used by the petitioner for the purpose of hatching a criminal conspiracy to commit the offence, but it was of no avail as the petitioner had reportedly not co-operated with the process of investigation based on the alleged confession statements of A.1 and A.5.
10. I am at a loss to understand as to why the legal avenues available were not explored by the learned Principal Special Judge for NDPS Act Cases, Chennai, to secure the petitioner herein, who was jailed in Central Prison, Bangalore for the purpose of facing the trial of the case pending before the said Court.
11. The records would reflect that when the trial of this Case as against the other accused was going on after splitting up the case as against the petitioner herein, the petitioner had escaped from the Central Prison, Bangalore and absconded. Of course, thereafter, he had been apprehended and put behind the bars in Central Prison, Bangalore. The learned Principal Special Judge for NDPS Act Cases, Chennai, has miserably failed to take concrete steps even after the prosecution had sounded him about the availability of the petitioner in Central Prison, Bangalore.
12. As rightly pointed out by the learned senior counsel for the eighth accused, except the reference as to the complicity of the petitioner in the confession statement of A.1 and A.5, there is no material on record to incriminate the petitioner herein. The matter has now been pending as against the petitioner even without framing charge against him.
13. Section 30 of the Indian Evidence Act reads as follows:-
"Section 30. Consideration of proved confession affecting person making it and others jointly under trial for same offence.---When more persons than one are being tried jointly for the same offence, and a confession made by one of such persons affecting himself and some other of such persons is proved, the Court may take into consideration such confession as against such other person as well as against the person who makes such confession." (Explanation.---"Offence" as used in this Section, includes the abetment of, or attempt to commit, the offence.) A bare reading of the Section would reveal that joint trial is a pre-requisite to bank on Section 30 of the Indian Evidence Act to draw inspiration from the confession statement of the co-accused.
14. Straightaway, let me refer to an authority, which applies squarely to the facts and circumstances of this case, in Suresh Budharmal Kalani Alias Pappu Kalani v. State Of Maharashtra. 1998 SCC (Cri) 1625 wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court has categorically held that the confession of an accused, who has been discharged, is not at all admissible as against a co-accused. It has been further observed that the trial Court is not justified in taking into consideration such confession of the discharged accused for framing charges against the co-accused on the ground that the prosecution could examine him as a witness for establishing the facts disclosed in his confession.
15. There is no dispute to the well settled position of law that the confession statement of an accused implicating the co-accused can be used only when the trial is being conducted jointly with the co-accused. The plea of the respondent that the respondent is toying with the proposal to examine the fifth accused, who has already been acquitted in this case, has to be rejected outright in view of the above ratio laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court.
16. Of course, in the authority in D. Sathiyamoorthy v. State Rep., By Inspector of Police, Spe/Cbi, Madras 1998 (1) MWN (Cr.) 234, this Court has chosen to entertain the petition filed under Section 311 of the Code of Criminal Procedure to summon the convicted co-accused to examine as additional witness, as the prosecution is entitled to project the best possible evidence available before the Court to prove the fact.
17. That was not a case where an attempt was made by the prosecution to establish the guilt of an accused based on the confessional statement of the co-accused who was convicted or acquitted. In the said case, it appears that an accused having pleaded guilty received a verdict of conviction in a corruption case and thereafter the case as against the co-accused was split up, the prosecution filed an application under Section 311 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, to summon the convicted co-accused as an additional witness to establish the guilt of the co-accused, who is facing trial later in point of time. This Court has held in such circumstances that there is no impediment for the prosecution to bring such a witness during the course of trial to establish the guilt of the co-accused.
18. In this case, the charge has not been framed as against the petitioner herein. The Court will have to consider as to whether there is any available material on record to frame the charge as against the petitioner. In the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court referred to above, it has been categorically observed that the Court is required to confine its attention only to those materials collected during the course of investigation, which can be legally translated into evidence and not open further evidence that the prosecution may adduce in the trial which would commence only after the charges are framed and the accused denies the charges.
19. If charges had already been framed as against the petitioner based on the incriminating materials available on record, there may not be any impediment for the prosecution to examine the co-accused, who was acquitted or convicted as the case may be to establish the guilt of the petitioner, but when the charges have not been framed against the petitioner and the petitioner has questioned the propriety of the trial Court in proposing to frame a charge without any foundation or basis, the prosecution cannot be permitted to project further evidence to be let in as a basis for framing a charge as against the petitioner.
20. As there is no material on record implicating the petitioner prima facie that he had committed an offence as projected by the prosecution, no charge can be framed as against him. The presumption under section 35 of the ndps act, will come into play only in a case where there is some material to rope in the petitioner in the offence alleged. The Court cannot presume animus of the petitioner to commit an offence under NDPS Act, without any scrap of evidence available on record except the confession statements of the co-accused, which are found to be not legal evidence. The presumption of culpable mental state without any iota of material as against a person will be a very dangerous trend. The Court accepts the above submission made by the learned senior counsel for advocate on record for the petitioner/8th accused.
21. In the result, the split up case in C.C.No.102 of 2003 on the file of the learned Principal Special Judge for NDPS Act Cases, Chennai, as against the petitioner herein stands quashed and the criminal original petition stands allowed.
Alert