Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

G. Vijayaraghavan v. (1) General Manager (Personnel), Indian Bank Head Office, Chennai

Madras High Court
Jul 19, 2000
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner filed a writ of mandamus seeking a direction to the respondents (Indian Bank and its Neravy branch) to consider sympathetically and provide a suitable job on compassionate grounds to him, and to refrain from rejecting his claim on technicalities or on the ground of laches.

Relevant factual assertions from the petition and the record include:

  • The petitioner describes himself as the only son, with two sisters, of the late Govindaraj, who was employed as a peon at Indian Bank, Pondicherry (Neravy branch). The text also states that the father left behind his wife and two daughters.
  • The father died on 7 June 1981. The petitioner was about eight years old at that time.
  • After the father's death, the petitioner's mother made multiple representations to the respondent bank requesting compassionate appointment either for herself or for her brother (and seeking assurance that her son could be appointed on attainment of majority).
  • Key dates of representations in the record (as recounted by the court): 14 October 1981 (initial representation by the mother); 26 February 1982 (representation seeking appointment for herself and assurance for her son's future appointment); 9 March 1982 (second respondent's letter recommending the mother's claim to the Deputy General Manager, Madras); 8 June 1982 (further representation); 14 August 1982 (reminder); 9 April 1983 (mother gave up earlier claim and requested appointment for her brother, enclosing his undertaking); 11 April 1983 (second respondent recommended the mother's 9 April 1983 request).
  • The respondents' personnel department wrote to the petitioner's mother on 8 June 1994 stating that applications must be made within one year from the date of death and conveying inability to consider the late request.
  • The petitioner asserts educational qualifications (SSLC with good marks, higher examination in typewriting in Tamil and English, and a diploma in computer applications) and contends that despite various representations, the respondents failed to consider his claim, prompting this writ petition.
  • In reply, the respondents filed a counter-affidavit arguing, inter alia, that the petition was filed after about ten years and was barred by laches; that the bank's compassionate-appointment scheme requires application within one year (with a possible three-year extension if dependents lack requisite qualifications); that the mother had, at one stage, opted for full term service gratuity and thereby waived claim to appointment; and that accounts were settled, precluding subsequent claims.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner's claim for compassionate appointment can be rejected on the ground of laches and for being beyond the time prescribed under the bank's compassionate-appointment scheme.
  2. Whether the mother's acceptance of full term service gratuity (and alleged waiver of the right to appointment) bars the petitioner's and other dependents' claim for compassionate appointment.
  3. Whether the mother's multiple representations (including branch recommendations) constituted timely and sufficient steps to bring the claim within the scheme's time limits or otherwise prevent dismissal on technical grounds.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner sought compassionate appointment to Indian Bank and asked the court to direct respondents to consider his claim sympathetically and not reject it on technical or laches grounds.
  • The petitioner relied on the fact that his mother had made representations beginning 14 October 1981 and on multiple subsequent occasions, and that the second respondent had in writing recommended consideration of the mother's claim.
  • The petitioner asserted his own educational qualifications (SSLC, typewriting Tamil & English, diploma in computer applications) to show suitability for employment.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents contended the petition was filed after about ten years and is liable to be dismissed on the ground of laches.
  • They relied on the bank's compassionate-appointment scheme which requires applications within one year of death, with a further period of three years allowed only if none of the dependents have the requisite educational qualification; on this basis they argued the petitioner could and should have applied earlier (petitioner attained majority in 1988-89 and could have applied by 1992).
  • The respondents asserted that the petitioner's mother had opted for full term service gratuity and thereby waived the right to appointment, and that the terminal benefits being paid and accounts being settled preclude appointment under the scheme.
  • The respondents relied on certain Supreme Court decisions (including Haryana State Electricity Board v. Hakim Singh and Managing Director, MMTC Ltd. v. Pramoda Devi) to support the submissions on laches and the limited purpose of compassionate appointment.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Balbir Kaur v. Sail, 2000 (3) L.L.N. 55 Observation that compassionate employment should be viewed in light of social justice; family members availing of family-benefit schemes does not necessarily bar consideration of compassionate employment; law's adaptability and flexibility in administering justice. The court relied on this authority to hold that settlement of full term service gratuity and receipt of terminal benefits does not, by itself, preclude eligible persons from claiming appointment on compassionate grounds.
Haryana State Electricity Board v. Hakim Singh, 1997 (3) L.L.N. 783 Authority relied upon by respondents to argue that claims after a long period can be rejected as barred by laches; discussed treatment of time-limits for minor children (and post-majority period). The respondents relied on this decision to support their laches argument, but the court found this authority not helpful to respondents' stand in view of the continuous representations made by the mother within the relevant period.
Managing Director, MMTC Ltd. v. Pramoda Devi, (1997) 11 S.C.C. 390 Principle that compassionate appointment is meant to enable a penurious family to tide over sudden crisis and is not intended to provide employment as a right or as a permanent entitlement. The respondents cited this decision in support of rejecting belated claims; the court noted the principle but held that, on the facts here (continuous representations and branch recommendations), the authority did not sustain the respondents' refusal to consider the petitioner's claim.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a fact-driven analysis focused on the timeline of representations and the content of the bank's compassionate-appointment scheme:

  1. The court accepted the undisputed core facts: the father's death on 7 June 1981 and the petitioner's age of about eight years at that time.
  2. The court examined the mother's representations beginning 14 October 1981 and continuing through 1982–1983, and the second respondent's written recommendations (including a 9 March 1982 recommendation and an 11 April 1983 recommendation) to the first respondent asking for sympathetic consideration.
  3. The court noted apparent inconsistencies in the respondents' later position, specifically the Assistant General Manager's 8 June 1994 letter stating that no timely application had been made, despite the record showing multiple earlier representations and branch recommendations.
  4. The court analysed the relevant clauses of the bank's compassionate-appointment scheme as placed before it (Clause 2 defining "dependent" and Clause 4 prescribing the time limits: one year from date of death, with a possible three-year extension if none of the dependents have requisite minimum educational qualification).
  5. On the respondents' contention that the mother accepted full term service gratuity and thereby waived any right to appointment, the court rejected the absolute effect of that contention. Relying on the reasoning in Balbir Kaur v. Sail, the court held that settlement of terminal benefits does not automatically foreclose the possibility of claiming compassionate appointment where eligible persons have made representations.
  6. The court considered the respondents' reliance on authorities urging caution against entertaining belated claims and the limited purpose of compassionate appointment (Haryana State Electricity Board v. Hakim Singh and MMTC v. Pramoda Devi). Taking the facts into account — especially the timely and repeated representations by the mother and the branch recommendation — the court concluded those authorities did not justify denying consideration to the petitioner's claim on laches grounds in this case.
  7. Given the continuous representations from 14 October 1981 onward, the branch-level recommendations, and the absence of a clear record of any final adverse decision by the first respondent, the court held that the petitioner's claim ought to be considered on merits rather than being rejected summarily on time-bar or laches grounds.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition was allowed in part. The court directed the respondents to consider the petitioner's claim for a suitable job in the respondent bank on compassionate grounds and to pass orders thereon within four weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of the order. The court ordered no costs.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The respondents are required to consider the petitioner's compassionate-appointment claim and to pass a decision within four weeks. The immediate consequence is a mandatory administrative consideration of the petitioner's claim by the bank within the specified time period.
  • Broader implications: The opinion does not state or declare any new legal precedent. The court expressly relied on existing authorities (including Balbir Kaur, Hakim Singh, and Pramoda Devi) and applied them to the specific factual matrix before it. The decision emphasizes that settlement of terminal benefits does not per se bar compassionate-appointment claims and that continuous, timely representations (and branch recommendations) can be material in determining whether a claim should be dismissed as belated.

No other remedies or directions were issued in the opinion beyond those expressly stated above.

Show all summary ...

JUDGMENT

1. The petitioner has approached this Court to issue a writ of mandamus directing the respondents to consider sympathetically and provide a suitable job in Indian Bank to him on compassionate ground without rejecting his claim on technicalities and also on the ground of laches.

2. The case of the petitioner is briefly stated hereunder. According to him, he is the only son apart from two sisters to his late father Govindaraj who was working as a peon in Indian Bank, Pondicherry Union Territory. His father died in harness on 7 June 1981 leaving behind him, his wife and two daughters. At the time of his father's death, he was only 8 years old. After the death of his father, his mother requested the respondent-bank through its branch at Neravy, the second respondent herein to give her an appointment on compassionate grounds. It is further stated that he has passed SSLC with good marks apart from Higher Examination in typewriting in both Tamil and English and also obtained diploma in computer applications. In spite of various representations, the respondents failed to consider his claim, hence has filed the present writ petition.

3. On behalf of the respondents, the Assistant General Manager, Indian Bank, has filed counter-affidavit disputing various averments made by the petitioner. It is stated that the petitioner has approached this Court after a lapse of about 10 years and on the ground of laches, the writ petition is liable to be dismissed in limine. As per the scheme of the bank for appointment under compassionate grounds, the claim should be made within one year from the date of death and a further period of three years allowed if none of the dependents have requisite educational qualification. Though the petitioner was a minor at the time of the death of his father on 7 June 1981, he attained majority during 1988-89 and even if three years allowed, the petitioner could have made his representation on or before 1992. The wife of the deceased employee and the mother of the petitioner requested the bank to provide employment to her brother on compassionate grounds by her letter, dated 14 October 1981. Subsequently, the mother of the petitioner had opted for full term service gratuity and waived her right for appointment on compassionate grounds. Having received the entire terminal benefits for full term, there is no scope for appointment of the dependents of the deceased employee under the shceme. Even though she claimed appointment to her brother, subsequently withdrew her claim and opted to receive the entire terminal benefits. Again on 9 April 1983, the mother of the petitioner requested for appointment of her brother on compassionate grounds. Since the same was not provided for in the scheme and the petitioner's mother did not seek employment for herself, the terminal benefits were paid to her and the accounts were settled. Since she had settled the accounts fully and finally, it is not open to the petitioner to stake a claim for compassionate appointment that too after a lapse of 10 years. The belated request of the petitioner was rightly rejected on verification of the records available with the respondent-bank. With these averments, they prayed for dismissal of the writ petition.

4. In the light of the above pleadings, I have heard the learned counsel for the petitioner as well as respondents. There is no dispute that the father of the petitioner while working as a peon in Indian Bank, Neravy branch, Near Karaikal Commune in Pondicherry, died on 7 June 1981. It is the case of the petitioner that at the time of the death of his father, he was aged about 8 years. He belongs to Harijan community. It is also the definite case of the petitioner that though his mother had made representation even on 14 October 1981 and the second respondent had also recommended to the first respondent for considering the claim of the mother for appointment of her brother and in spite of subsequent representations/letters, the respondents failed to consider the same. It is also the grievance of the petitioner that in spite of the fact that the second respondent had recommended the claim of the mother of the petitioner to give employment to her brother, the same was not considered by the first respondent. On the other hand, the learned counsel appearing for the respondents by drawing my attention to the scheme framed by the Indian Bank regarding appointment under compassionate grounds would contend that inasmuch as the claim of the petitioner is beyond the time prescribed under the shceme, the same cannot be considered. It is also stated that in view of the fact that the mother of the petitioner withdrew her claim for appointment to her brother and received full term gratuity and other benefits, the claim to the petitioner cannot be considered at this juncture.

5. I have carefully considered the rival submissions. After the death of her husband (i.e) on 7 June 1981, the mother of the petitioner made a representation even on 14 October 1981 This has been admitted in Para. 3 of the counter-affidavit filed by the respondents. Since the petitioner's mother did not receive any information about her request for appointment, she made another representation on 26 February 1982 wherein she claimed appointment for her and also assurance mat on attainment of majority, her son (petitioner herein) may be appointed in a suitable job. On 9 March 1982, the second respondent herein had written a letter to the Deputy General Manager, Indian Bank, Madras, recommending the claim made by the mother of the petitioner. On 8 June 1982, the mother of the petitioner made another representation requesting employment for her and assurance for her son's employment after attainment of majority. Again on 14 August 1982, she made another reminder to the first respondent. On 9 April 1983, the mother of the petitioner made another representation to the respondents wherein she had given up her earlier claim and once again requested the respondents to provide employment to her brother-Ganesan. She also enclosed the assurance letter given by her brother that in the event of his appointment in the respondent-bank, he would take care of his sister namely the mother of the petitioner and other family members. On 11 April 1983, the second respondent recommended the claim made by the mother of the petitioner. In the said letter, the second respondent has requested the first respondent as follows:

“We request your goodselves to consider this application sympathetically and issue your favourable instructions for further proceedings. In this connection, we wish to add that though the approved strength for sub-staff for our branch is two at present we are having only one sub-staff in our Branch. So we request you to consider his application and to post him on our branch itself.

Kindly instruct us for further actions.”

It is not clear as to what was the ultimate decision taken by the first respondent with regard to the request of the second respondent. On 8 June 1994, the Assistant General Manager has informed the mother of the petitioner that as per their compassionate appointment shceme, the application for compassionate appointment has to be made within one year from the date of death of the employee. It is further stated that since the application was not made within the time prescribed, he conveyed his inability to consider her request for compassionate appointment to her son. I have already referred to various representations/letters made by the mother of the petitioner starting from 14 October 1981. When the mother of the petitioner had made proper representation even on 14 October 1981 followed by various representations, it is not clear how the Assistant General Manager, Personnel Department, in letter, dated 8 June 1994, had informed the petitioner's mother that the application was not made within the time as prescribed in the scheme.

6. The learned counsel for the respondents very much relied on certain clauses in the scheme for appointment under compassionate grounds. The following clauses are relevant for our consideration.

“2. Under the scheme, “dependent” in relation to the deceased employee will mean:

(a) widow (b) son (including adopted son) (c) daughter (d) any other close relative nominated by the widow on whome she will be wholly dependent and who would give in writing that he/she would look after the family of the deceased employee In the case of a married employee (e) brother In the case of an unmarried employee (f) sister

4. Under this scheme the dependant should apply to the bank for appointment within a period of one year of the date of death of the deceased employee. In case none of the dependants have the requisite minimum educational qualification for appointment under this scheme, then on application within one year of the date of death of the deceased employee, a further period of three years will be allowed to any of the dependants to acquire the minimum educational qualification and apply for appointment under this scheme.”

As per the said scheme, in the case before me, widow is eligible to apply. Though the mother of the petitioner initially applied for appointment on compassionate grounds, subsequently, she requested employment for her brother. Her brother had also filed necessary undertaking. As per Cl. 2(d) of the scheme, the said request is acceptable. As per Cl. (4), the dependent should apply to the bank for appointment within a period of one year from the date of the death of the deceased employee, I have already stated that the employee in question died on 7 June 1981 and widow of the deceased made an application even on 14 October 1981. I have also referred to subsequent representations/letters of the mother of the petitioner. All those documents find place in the typed set of papers filed by the petitioner. No doubt, in the counter-affidavit filed by the respondents, it is stated that the mother of the petitioner had opted for full term service gratuity and waived her right for appointment on compassionate grounds. It is also stated that having received the entire terminal benefits for full term mere is no scope for any appointment of the dependent of the deceased employee in the scheme. I am of the view that irrespective of settlement of full term service gratuity and other benefits, eligible persons can claim appointment on compassionate grounds. In this regard it is useful to refer the observation of Hon'ble Supreme Court in [2000 (3) L.L.N 55] Balbir Kaur v. Sail. Their Lordships have held, in Para. 19, at page 62:

“Sri Bhasme further contended that family members of a large number of the employees have already availed of the Family Benefit Scheme and as such it would be taken to be otherwise more beneficial to the concerned employee. We are not called upon to assess the situation but the fact remains that having due regard to the constitutional philosophy to decry a compassionate employment opportunity would neither be fair nor reasonable. The concept of social justice is the yardstick to the justice administration system or the legal justice and as (respondent) pointed out that the greatest virtue of law is in its adoptability and flexibility and thus it would be otherwise an obligation for law Courts also to apply the law depending upon the situation since the law is made for the society and whichever is beneficial for the society, the endeavour of the law Court would be to administer justice having due regard in that direction.”

7. The learned counsel for the respondents very much relied upon the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court reported in 1997 (3) L.L.N 783, Haryana State Electricity Board v. Hakim Singh. By relying on the said decision, the learned counsel or the respondents would contend mat the present claim of the petitioner cannot be considered after a long time and the same is liable to be rejected on the ground of laches. In that case, the High Court came to the conclusion that in case of minor child, a period of three years would be applicable from the date he becomes major. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has set aside the interpretation made by the High Court and held that if the family members of the deceased employee can manage for fourteen years after his death, one of his legal heirs cannot put forward a claim as though it is a line of succession by virtue of right of inheritance. She also very much relied upon another decision of the Supreme Court namely (1997) 11 S.C.C 390, Managing Director, MMTC, Ltd. v. Pramoda Dei, wherein the Lordships of the Supreme Court have held mat compassionate appointment is to enable the penurious family to tide over the sudden crisis and is not to provide employment. Considering the factual position in our case that the mother of the petitioner had made proper representation even on 14 October 1981, within the time prescribed in terms of the scheme and various representations thereon, highlighting her family circumstances and unable to maintain herself, I am of the view that both the decisions are not helpful to the stand taken by the respondents. On the other hand, the continuous representations from 14 October 1981 show that the mother of the petitioner was unable to maintain her family and requested employment initially to her brother and subsequently to herself. In as much as the request of the mother of the petitioner was turned down, the petitioner herein has made representation to consider his claim for appointment on compassionate grounds. I have already referred to the fact that at one stage considering the grievance expressed by the mother of the petitioner, the second respondent had recommended to the first respondent for accepting her claim. In such circumstances, I hold that the petitioner has made out a case to consider his claim for appointment on compassionate grounds in the respondent-bank. The request of the petitioner cannot be rejected on the ground of laches more particularly in view of the prolonged requests and representations made by the mother of the petitioner.

8. In the light of what is stated above, there shall be a direction to the respondents to consider the claim of the petitioner for providing a suitable job in the respondent bank on compassionate ground and pass orders within a period of four weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order The writ petition is allowed to the extent mentioned above. No costs.