Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

G. Ramadoss And Others v. (1) Management Of Tansi Die Castings Industrial Estate, Chennai

Madras High Court
Nov 17, 2000
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The opinion concerns two writ petitions that raise common questions about computation of awards and entitlement to interest and certain allowances. The workman had earlier obtained an award in I.D. No. 459 of 1987 (First Additional Labour Court, Madras) dated 30 November 1990, which reinstated him with back wages and continuity of service. The management's challenge to that award was dismissed by this Court at the admission stage, rendering that award final.

Because the management did not implement the reinstatement award, the workman filed a claim petition (C.P. No. 529 of 1991) before the First Additional Labour Court, Madras, seeking computation of monetary benefits for the period April 1982 to March 1991. The Labour Court computed some items but disallowed the claim for interest and certain allowances, awarding Rs. 1,39,347.65 out of a total claimed Rs. 2,57,614.10.

The workman challenged the disallowance by way of Writ Petition No. 13051 of 1993. The management filed Writ Petition No. 11664 of 1998 challenging an award of the Principal Labour Court, Madras in C.P. No. 875 of 1993 (dated 27 March 1997). Because both writ petitions raised common issues, they were disposed of by this common order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner/workman is entitled to interest on the award amount as claimed by him.
  2. Whether the workman is entitled to the various allowances (for example, night shift allowance, washing allowance, casting allowance, festival holiday wages, tea allowance, lunch allowance subsidy, etc.) claimed in the computation.

Arguments of the Parties

Workman's Arguments

  • The workman's counsel relied on authorities to argue that Labour Courts/Industrial Tribunals have power to award interest, including that tribunals are "courts" within the meaning of the Interest Act, 1839, and possess wider powers than civil courts in adjudicating industrial disputes. Specific cases cited in support included E.I.D. Parry (India) Ltd. v. Industrial Tribunal, Madras (1991-I L.L.J 25) and other decisions where interest on equitable grounds was recognized.
  • The workman sought interest at 16% per annum on the claimed monetary loss and also claimed various allowances as components of monetary relief for the period he was not employed.

Management's Arguments

  • The management contended that, under S. 33C(2) of the Industrial Disputes Act, when a claim petition is for computation based on an earlier award, the Labour Court acts in the nature of an executing court and cannot award interest unless interest was provided for in the original award. Reliance was placed on the judgment of Nainar Sundaram, J., in Management of Nathan's Press, Madras v. K. Krishnan (1988 (2) L.L.N 95) and similar precedents.
  • As to the period of entitlement, the management asserted the company closed on 31 January 1992. It stated the workman was entitled only to Rs. 20,926 (money value) up to the date of closure and that this amount had been paid in compliance with the Court's directions. The management produced an agreement under S. 12(3) of the Industrial Disputes Act dated 31 January 1992, a closure notice (Exhibit R3), and an acknowledgment by the workman (Exhibit R4), along with oral testimony of an officer (R.W.1) to support its position.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
E.I.D. Parry (India) Ltd. v. Industrial Tribunal, Madras [1991-I L.L.J 25] Held that Industrial Tribunals/Labour Courts are "courts" within the meaning of the Interest Act, 1839, and possess powers wider than civil courts to adjudicate industrial disputes and to award interest in appropriate cases. The Court acknowledged this authority to show tribunals can, in principle, award interest; however, the Court evaluated that principle against the specific procedural context of S.33C(2) and the absence of interest in the primary award.
Ghaziabad Development Authority v. Union of India [(2000) 6 S.C.C 113] Recognized that interest can be awarded on equitable grounds in appropriate cases and that the rate of interest in equity should not be unduly high or low. The decision arose from a breach of contract matter. The Court cited this Supreme Court authority to support the proposition that interest may be awarded on equitable grounds but noted the factual and procedural distinction from an S.33C(2) computation where the primary award contained no interest clause.
Vepar Vikas Co-operative Bank Ltd. v. Ghanshyam Lallubhai Patel [2000 (4) L.L.N 878] Illustrated an instance where a High Court directed payment of awarded amount with 9% interest in an order under S.33C(2) (as applied in that case). The Court noted this decision as an example where interest was ordered in the context of a labour dispute, but treated it as a case-specific exercise of equitable relief rather than a general rule overriding S.33C(2) limitations.
Management of Nathan's Press, Madras v. K. Krishnan [1988 (2) L.L.N 95] Held that in the absence of a provision for interest in the primary award, a Labour Court considering a petition under S.33C(2) cannot award interest; the Labour Court's role under S.33C(2) is akin to that of an executing court and is limited to computation based on the award. The Court accepted and followed this reasoning in concluding that interest could not be awarded in the present S.33C(2) computation where the original award contained no interest clause.
Krishnamurthy v. Mail [1964-II L.L.J 88] Expressed the view that interest is not a head that a Labour Court can entertain under S.33C(2) unless provided for in an award or settlement; the claim for interest cannot be incidental to computation of benefits. The Court referenced this authority in support of the conclusion that interest could not be awarded in the present computation proceedings absent an interest provision in the award.
Union of India v. Central Government Labour Court [1985 (1) L.L.N 279] Noted as following the view that a Labour Court has limited jurisdiction under S.33C(2) and cannot award interest unless it is part of the adjudicated entitlement. Used to reinforce the principle that S.33C(2) proceedings are of an executing nature and do not permit adding new heads such as interest unless previously adjudicated.
Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. Ganesh Razak [1995 (1) L.L.N 402] Held that under S.33C(2) the Labour Court cannot adjudicate new entitlement disputes (for example, parity in wages); S.33C(2) jurisdiction is to be exercised only where entitlement has earlier been adjudicated or recognized, and its jurisdiction is akin to an executing court. The Court relied on this Supreme Court authority to underscore that S.33C(2) proceedings cannot be used to create entitlement to interest or other heads not adjudicated in the main award.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in several discrete analytical steps strictly tied to the facts and authorities cited in the opinion:

  1. The Court first observed that the primary award (I.D. No. 459 of 1987) did not contain any provision for payment of interest. That factual point framed the analysis of whether interest could be granted in the subsequent computation proceeding under S.33C(2).
  2. The Court reviewed precedents supporting two competing propositions: (a) that Labour Courts/Industrial Tribunals can, in appropriate cases, award interest and are "courts" under the Interest Act (as held by the Division Bench in E.I.D. Parry), and (b) that when a matter comes before a Labour Court under S.33C(2) for computation of an award, the Labour Court's role is analogous to an executing court and it cannot award interest unless interest was provided for in the original award (as held in Nathan's Press v. K. Krishnan, Krishnamurthy, and followed in other authorities).
  3. The Court noted the Supreme Court's articulation (Ghaziabad and Municipal Corporation of Delhi) that interest may be awarded on equitable grounds in appropriate cases, but also reiterated that S.33C(2) jurisdiction is essentially executing in nature and is not a forum to adjudicate fresh entitlements that were not earlier adjudicated or recognized.
  4. Balancing these authorities, the Court concluded that although Labour Courts/Industrial Tribunals possess power to award interest in general, where a computation is made under S.33C(2) and the main award contains no clause for interest, the Labour Court cannot grant interest in that S.33C(2) proceeding. The Court therefore rejected the workman's claim for interest.
  5. On allowances (night shift allowance, washing allowance, casting allowance, festival holiday wages, tea allowance, lunch allowance subsidy, etc.), the Court adopted the reasoning of N.V. Balasubramaniam, J. in W.P. No. 9244 of 1991: allowances that form part of wages are payable only where the employee has actually worked and thereby become entitled to such allowances. Because the workman had not actually worked during the claimed period, the Court agreed that those allowances could not be treated as part of wages during the non-working period and sustained the Labour Court's disallowance of those allowances.
  6. Regarding the management's writ petition and the period of entitlement, the Court examined the evidence placed by the management: an agreement under S. 12(3) dated 31 January 1992, oral testimony of R.W.1 that the company closed on 31 January 1992, a closure notice (Exhibit R3), and an acknowledgment by the workman (Exhibit R4). The Court found that the Labour Court had failed to take these materials into account and thus erred in awarding back wages beyond the closure date. On the basis of the agreement and the closure-related materials, the Court concluded that the workman's entitlement to wages and allowable benefits ceased on 31 January 1992 and that the money value was fixed at Rs. 20,926, which had been paid.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

  • W.P. No. 13051 of 1993 (filed by the workman) is dismissed. The workman's claims for interest and the various allowances were rejected for the reasons stated in the opinion.
  • W.P. No. 11664 of 1998 (filed by the management) is allowed to the extent that the workman's entitlement to wages and other allowable benefits is limited to the period up to 31 January 1992 and that the money value fixed at Rs. 20,926 has been paid.
  • No costs were ordered, and several connected writ miscellaneous petitions were closed.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: the workman will not receive interest on the award amount nor the claimed allowances for the period he did not actually work; his entitlement is limited to wages and benefits up to the date of closure (31 January 1992) in the money value determined (Rs. 20,926), which has been paid.
  • The Court applied existing precedent to clarify the limited, executing-role nature of S.33C(2) proceedings: where the original award contains no provision for interest, a subsequent computation under S.33C(2) cannot be used to award interest or create new heads of entitlement not adjudicated in the main award.
  • The opinion does not announce a novel legal principle; it resolves the dispute by applying and reconciling prior authorities and the specific factual record before the Court. In that sense, no new precedent was set beyond the Court's application of existing case law to the facts at hand.
Show all summary ...

1. With regard to disallowed claim in the award passed by the First Additional Labour Court, Madras-104 in C.P No. 529 of 1991, dated 6 November 1992, the workman has filed W.P No. 13051 of 1993. Aggrieved by the award of the Principal Labour Court, Madras in C.P No. 875 of 1993, dated 27 March 1997, the management of Tansi Die Castings, Chennai-32, has filed W.P No. 11664 of 1998. Since common questions are involved in both the impugned orders, the above writ petitions are being disposed of by the following common order.

2. Inasmuch as we are concerned with the orders passed in the claim petitions, it is unnecessary to refer the order of dismissal passed by the management and the ultimate award passed by the First Additional Labour Court, Madras, in I.D No. 459 of 1987, dated 30 November 1990, reinstating the workman with back-wages and continuity of service. Though the management has filed a writ petition challenging the said award, it is stated that the same was dismissed by this Court even at the admission stage, hence, the award in I.D No. 459 of 1987 has become final.

3. According to the workman, since the management failed to implement the award, he was forced to file claim petition in C.P No. 529 of 1991, for computation of monetary benefits before the First Additional Labour Court, Madras. In the said claim petition, workman has claimed monetary loss of Rs. 2,57,614.10 for his non-employment from April 1982 to March 1991 under various heads such as pay, H.R.A, CCA, bonus, night ship allowance, etc., and also interest at the rate of 16 per cent per annum on the said amount. The Labour Court disallowed the claim of interest as well as allowances claimed. Out of the total claim of Rs. 2,57,614.10, the Labour Court has awarded a sum of Rs. 1,39,347.65.

4. As far as W.P No. 13051 of 1993 is concerned, the following points are to be considered:

(i) Whether the petitioner/workman is entitled interest for the award amount as claimed by him.

(ii) Whether the workman is entitled to lowances.

5. Regarding the first claim, namely, interest, admittedly, the award in I.D No. 459 of 1987 on the file of the First Additional Labour Court, Madras, does not contain any clause for interest. Likewise, there is no specific provision enabling the Labour Court/Industrial Tribunal to award interest. In this regard, Sri S. Kanniah, learned counsel for the workman has very much relied on the following decisions:

(i) E.I.D Parry (India), Ltd. v. Industrial Tribunal Madras [1991-I L.L.J 250].

(ii) Ghaziabad Development Authority v. Union of India [(2000) 6 S.C.C 113]; and

(iii) Vepar Vikas Co-operative Bank, Ltd. v. Ghanshyam Lallubhai Patel [2000 (4) L.L.N 878] (current issue).

6. In the first case, namely, 1991-I L.L.J 252 (vide supra), the Division Bench of this Court has held that Industrial Tribunal is having powers wider than a civil Court in a matter of adjudication of dispute and its jurisdiction to grant interest. Their Lordships have further held that Industrial Tribunal is a Court within the meaning of Interest Act, 1839. In the light of the said Division Bench decision, it is clear that both the Labour Courts and Industrial Tribunals are Courts within the meaning of Interest Act, 1839, and they are having powers wider than a civil Court in the matter of adjudication of an industrial dispute and can award interest in appropriate cases.

7. In the case reported in (2000) 6 S.C.C 113 (vide supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that interest on equitable grounds can be granted in appropriate cases. Their Lordships also held mat the rate of interest awarded in equity should neither be too high nor too low. Further, the said decision arose out of breach of contract and a complaint was filed before the M.R.T.P Commissioner.

8. In the case reported in 2000 (4) L.L.N 878 (current issue), the learned Single Judge of the Gujarat High Court, while dismissing the writ petition filed by the Co-operative Bank against the order of the Labour Court, passed an order in an application filed by the employee under S. 33C(2) of the Industrial Disputes Act, directing the management of the co-operative bank to pay the amount with 9 per cent interest.

9. It is clear from the above decisions that though there is no provision in the Act as observed by the Division Bench of this Court in the case reported in 1991-I L.L.J 25 (vide supra), Labour Courts/Industrial Tribunals are having wider powers than civil Courts in a matter of adjudication of industnal dispute and accordingly in appropriate cases they can award interest. Likewise, the same authorities, on equitable grounds, can grant interest in appropriate cases. Further, while confirming the award of the Labour Courts/Industrial Tribunals, this Court can also direct the management to pay reasonable interest for the unpaid amount.

10. Sri M. Vijayan, learned counsel for the management, by relying on the judgment of Nainar Sundaram, J. (as he then was) reported in 1988 (2) L.L.N 95, Management of Nathan's Press, Madras v. K. Krishnan, would contend that in the absence of provision for interest in the main award itself, the Labour Court under S. 33C(2) of the Act cannot award interest. While considering the question, namely, whether Labour Court can award interest in an application filed under S. 33C(2) of the Act, the learned Judge has held thus, in Para. 4, at page 96 of the order:

“The second grievance of the learned counsel for the petitioner is directed against the award of interest. Learned counsel would submit that the second respondent is not a civil Court on the question of interest…”

Such a view has been expressed by Verraswami, J. (as he then was) in Krishnamurthy v. Mail [1964-II L.L.J 881. The learned Judge further observed as follows:

“Interest is not one of the items that appear to be competent for the Labour Court to go into under that section unless it has been provided for in-an award or a settlement. That is not the case here. The order of the Labour Court in so far as it related to interest cannot be sustained.

It is not claimed here that the award passed in the instant case provided for payment of interest as such. In this context, one has to take note of the scope of S. 33C(2) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, under which alone the present claim petition has come to be filed. The Labour Court, while making the computation has got only role of an executing Court, and it cannot go beyond the award unless the question is incidental to working the reliefs on the basis of the award. The heads of claims could be based only on the award, and in the absence of any provision for payment of interest in the award, there could not be any claim for such interest and countenancing thereof by the second respondent in the present case. The claim for interest could not be stated to be incidental to computation of the benefits given under the award. I find the view expressed in Krishnamurthy v. Mail [1964-II L.L.J 88], has been taken note of and followed by a Single Judge of the High Court of Delhi in Union of India v. Central Government Labour Court [1985 (1) L.L.N 279]. In this view, the award of interest by the second respondent has got to be discountenanced…”

Though the decision of Nainar Sundaram, J. (as he then was) appears to be conflicting with the decision of the Division Bench of this Court in 1991-I L.L.J 250 the learned Judge has concluded that in the absence of any provision for interest in the main award itself, the same cannot be granted while considering claim petition filed under S. 33C(2) of the Act. As rightly contended, the Labour Court can determine and compute as per the award secured by the parties. In the absence of any direction for payment of interest in the award, in the claim petition filed under S. 33C(2) of the Act. the Labour Court cannot impose or award interest. In other words, the claim for interest could not be stated to be incidental to computation of benefits given in the award. I am in respectful agreement with the view expressed by Nainar Sundaram, J. (as he then was).

11. Similar view has been expressed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in 1995 (1) L.L.N 402, Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. Ganesh Razak. After considering the jurisdiction of the Labour Court under S. 33C(2) of the Industrial Disputes Act, Their Lordships have held that the Labour Court cannot adjudicate dispute relating to entitlement of workmen to parity in wages. Their Lordships further held that power under S. 33C(2) of the Act can be exercised only when entitlement has been earlier adjudicated upon or recognised by employer. Their Lordships further held that its jurisdiction is similar to that of executing Court.

12. As stated earlier, admittedly, award in I.D No. 459 of 1987, does not contain any clause for interest. In such circumstance, though the Labour Court has power to award interest in appropriate cases, in the absence of any provision in the main award itself for interest, the same cannot be granted while computing the amount in an application filed under S. 33C(2) of the Act. In the light of the above conclusion, I am unable to accept the argument of the learned counsel for the workman with regard to interest and accordingly the same is rejected.

13. Coming to allowances such as night shift allowance, encashment of shoes, washing allowance, casting allowance, etc., the same question has been elaborately considered by N.V Balasubramaniam, J., in W.P No. 9244 of 1991, dated 14 September 1999. Before the learned Judge, it was contended that inasmuch as there was no proof for the workman has offered himself to join duty after the award became operative, he is not entitled to wages for the festival holidays, tea allowance, annual leave with wage encashment thereof, lunch allowance subsidy, as he was not actually working during the period for which he has made a claim. After considering relevant provisions from the I.D Act as well as catena of decisions of various High Courts and the Apex Court, the learned Judge has held that the workman is not entitled to claim the same as part of wages, inasmuch as he had actually not worked. I am in respectful agreement with the view expressed by the learned Judge and I hold that the employee concerned would not be entitled to claim such allowance unless he has actually worked and then only it would become an allowance which forms part of the wages. In other words, where there is no actual service, the question of payment of such allowance would not arise. Accordingly, I sustain the conclusion arrived by the Labour Court and reject the contra argument made by the learned counsel for the workman.

14. Coming to the writ petition filed by the management in W.P No. 11664 of 1998, inasmuch as the Labour Court has not granted interest, it is unnecessary to consider the same. Even otherwise, the conclusion of mine, as stated above, is applicable to the issue in question. According to the learned counsel for the management, their company was closed on 31 January 1992, and the workman was entitled only Rs. 20.926 and the same had been paid to the workman as per the direction of this Court. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the workman would contend that in the absence of any documentary evidence, the workman was entitled to wages up to September 1993. In this regard, it is brought to my notice the agreement under S. 12(3) of the Industrial Disputes Act, between the management and the workmen, dated 31 January 1992. The said agreement was signed by the management as well as the representatives of the employees and the same was executed in the presence of Labour Officer No. III, Kuraiagam, Chennai-108. The said agreement finds place at page 1 of the typed set filed by the management in W.P No. 11664 of 1998. Though it is stated that the said document has not been placed before the Labour Court while considering the claim petition, the contents and the genuineness of the agreement has not been seriously disputed. Apart from this, one Basheer Ahmed, an Officer of the company, has been examined as R.W 1 in the claim petition. He would specifically state that the company has been closed on 31 January 1992, hence, according to him, the workman is not entitled to back-wages as claimed in the petition. He would further state that closure notice has been sent to the workman under Exhibit R3 and the same has been received by the workman under Exhibit 114. Though no document has been filed evidencing closure of the company, in the light of oral evidence of R.W 1, closure notice and acknowledgment by the workman, namely, Exhibits R3 and R4 and after perusing agreement under S. 12(3) of the Act between the management and workmen, dated 31 January 1992, I am unable to accept the conclusion arrived by the Labour Court. The Labour Court failed to take note of relevant materials and committed an error in passing an order in favour of the workman as claimed. At the most, the workman was entitled wages and other allowable benefits only up to 31 January 1992 and in the money value it was fixed at Rs. 20.926 which had also been paid to the workman.

15. In the light of what is stated above, Writ Petition No. 13051 of 1993, filed by the workman, is dismissed and W.P No. 11664 of 1998, filed by the management, is allowed to the extent mentioned above. No costs. Consequently, connected Writ Miscellaneous Petitions Nos. 20054 of 1993, 17758, 25512 and 25513 of 1998 are closed.